Latest / Articulated Illustration / WORDS WE NEVER QUESTION: BREAK A LEG
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine you're backstage, you're nervous, you're about to perform, and somebody walks up, looks you straight in the eye and says,"I hope you break a leg." Now, if that was Dwane, I would have a question.
- 0:14What did I do to you?
- 0:16But in theater, that strange wish means good luck.
- 0:20So how did wishing someone an injury turn into wishing them success?
- 0:25And here's the bigger mystery.
- 0:27Does anybody actually know where it started?
- 0:36Welcome to Articulated Illustrations, Words We Never Question I'm your host, Dwane Richardson Sr.
- 0:43Every phrase has a footprint, and today we're following the trail behind a phrase we all heard and use.
- 0:50Today's phrase is break a leg.
- 0:53We're going backstage for this one because in the performing arts, what sounds like a terrible thing to say can actually be a compliment.
- 1:01And if you never stopped to question that, think about how strange it really is.
- 1:18Now we wouldn't tell a football player to break a leg on the way onto the field and expect a thank you.
- 1:24So why is the performing arts different?
- 1:27Break a leg means good luck, especially when somebody is about to perform.
- 1:32A actor's opening night, A singer about to walk out under the lights, somebody's heading to an audition, and these days people use it outside the theater, too.
- 1:43Maybe you got a big presentation, or you're about to speak in front of a room of people and somebody tells you,"Break a leg." And they're not wishing for 911.
- 1:53They are telling you,"I hope you do well." But that still does not answer the question, why couldn't they just say,"Good luck"?
- 2:03Here's the first clue.
- 2:04Stage superstition.
- 2:06In theater, tradition wishing a performer good luck directly could be treated as bad luck, as though saying the words might jinx the performance.
- 2:15So the ideal is performers use a wish that's sounding like the opposite.
- 2:21Think about that.
- 2:23The good wish wears the clothes of a bad wish.
- 2:26It's like trying to outsmart bad luck by telling it the wrong thing.
- 2:31Now, that helps explain why somebody would say something negative, but it still doesn't prove why that particular negative wish involved a leg.
- 2:41And that's where the history gets very interesting Now, one thing we have to remember about expressions is this, somebody saying it in a book doesn't mean that that person invented it.
- 2:54But printed examples can tell us how far back the saying goes In 1921, a writer named Robert Lynn wrote about superstition for a London magazine.
- 3:06He said the stage was maybe the most superstitious institution in England, second only to the racetrack.
- 3:13And he explained that wishing somebody luck on the way to the race was considered unlucky.
- 3:19Instead, you were supposed to say something insulting, like,"May you break your leg." Notice something.
- 3:26His example is about the racetrack, but look what he puts right next to it, the stage.
- 3:34And that doesn't prove actors were already using that expression in 1921.
- 3:39It shows how closely Lynn connected racing superstitions and theater superstitions.
- 3:45And by 1948, an American newspaper The Charleston Gazette described,"I hope you break a leg," as something actors said instead of wishing each other good luck.
- 3:57Now, that's an unmistakable explanation of the custom.
- 4:01We have evidence for the expression.
- 4:03What we don't have is a signed birth certificate telling us exactly who invented it And here's a detail I don't want us to skip.
- 4:12In 1939, author Edna Ferber wrote about understudies sitting in the back of a theater wishing the principal performers would break a leg.
- 4:22Now, you might hear that and say,"There it is.
- 4:26They were wishing them luck." Maybe, but think about what a understudy does.
- 4:33A understudy is the person who may have to step in if the lead performer cannot go on.
- 4:40So that sentence can also sound like people privately hoping for a chance to perform.
- 4:46The passage does not settle which meaning was intended, and that is a perfect example of why we cannot grab one old quotation and announce that the entire mystery has been solved.
- 4:57Now, let's talk about some of the stories you may have heard.
- 5:01One explanation says a performer breaks the line of the leg by bending the knee to bow.
- 5:08Another points to the curtains at the sides of a stage, which can be called legs.
- 5:13There's even a story connected the saying to John Wilkes Booth, you know, the man who assassinated President Abraham Lincoln.
- 5:22Now, those are stories people tell.
- 5:25They are not established origins of this expression.
- 5:28So what's the answer?
- 5:30We know what break a leg means, and we know that it's associated with theater superstition.
- 5:35We have old written evidence, but nobody has conclusively established why that exact wording became the tradition.
- 5:44And saying we don't know for sure is better than handing you a good story dressed up as a fact Now, here's the unusual angle I want to leave you with.
- 5:54Somewhere along the way, a phrase that sounds like somebody is wishing harm became a way of saying that I am rooting and cheering for you.
- 6:04The words sound harsh, the intention is kind, and isn't that something?
- 6:10The same sentence can mean one thing if you read it literally, and something very different when you understand the community using it, and that's why context matters.
- 6:21If you only hear the words, you might think somebody wants you to fail.
- 6:26But if you understand the tradition, you hear encouragement.
- 6:30Now, I'm not telling you to start wishing injuries on people at work, and please don't tell your favorite supervisor that I told you to do that.
- 6:38You see what I did there?
- 6:40But all jokes aside, I'm saying that expressions have histories, and sometimes the meaning is hiding behind the very words that seems to contradict it So today we followed the trail behind break a leg.
- 6:53It means good luck, especially before a performance.
- 6:58The idea of avoiding a jinx helps explain why a negative wish could become a positive one.
- 7:04And the old records tell us this expression has been around for generations, but they don't settle every detail about where it came from.
- 7:13And to me, that's the interesting part.
- 7:17Sometimes the best answer isn't a story that sounds good.
- 7:21It's the truth about what we know and what we still don't.
- 7:25Have you ever said break a leg without thinking about it?
- 7:29Tell me in the comments and let me know which phrase we should investigate next.
- 7:34This is Dwane Richardson Sr, and this has been Words We Never Question because every phrase has a footprint, and now we know why we say what we say