Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Discovering Agroecological Research from an Intercultural Perspective with Dr. Arit de León
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating the Human
- 0:06Side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and will discuss their meanings
- 0:17from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:21This is an English version of the original interview.
- 0:24It may be summarized or reinterpreted. Welcome
- 0:30to Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating the
- 0:32Human Side. This time, we go into the fields
- 0:35of the Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico, to explore
- 0:37agroecological projects and look at the education
- 0:40and research from an intercultural perspective.
- 0:42Today, we welcome Dr. Ari De Leon, who from her
- 0:45position as researcher at the Intercultural Majority
- 0:48University of Quintana Roo, will tell us about
- 0:51how applied research can be carried out and in
- 0:54hand with traditional communities. Dr. Ari is
- 0:56an environmental engineer from the Polytechnic
- 0:59University of Chiapas. She has a PhD in biotechnology
- 1:02and bioengineering from the Zimbabwe staff. She
- 1:05has been involved in several microbial ecology
- 1:08projects, specializing in soils and street environments.
- 1:12She is the author of several scientific articles
- 1:15and has worked on the use of microbial ecology
- 1:17as an indicator of the conservation status of
- 1:21ecosystems. Arif, thanks for joining us today
- 1:25for this episode. To begin with, could you tell
- 1:28us... How did you come to work in an intercultural
- 1:32university? And what are the particularities
- 1:34compared to other universities or research centers?
- 1:38Hi, thank you for the invitation. I am at the
- 1:40Intercultural Mayan University of Quintana Roo
- 1:43as a part of the program called Researchers for
- 1:46Mexico. So I applied to the call and fortunately
- 1:50I was selected. It was very tricky. I had known
- 1:54the university a year before. I got to know the
- 1:56facilities. how they work and the projects that
- 1:59they were carrying out. What is different is
- 2:02precisely that intercultural universities arise
- 2:05to bring higher education to indigenous peoples
- 2:08or populations. If these institutions were not
- 2:11there here, it would be more difficult for these
- 2:13communities to study because of their location.
- 2:16In terms of the careers that they offer, they
- 2:19have more to do with the community. For example,
- 2:22there are careers such as communitary health
- 2:24or alternative tourism. That's so that the aspiration
- 2:28of young people is no longer to leave their community.
- 2:31In the case of Yucatan Peninsula, the aspiration
- 2:34was to leave and go to the tourist area, to Cancun,
- 2:38for example, or a resort. So this part of the
- 2:40migration of young people led to the loss of
- 2:43the labor force for rural communities. So these
- 2:46universities emerged in the early 2000s in different
- 2:50parts of Mexico, including the Yucatan Peninsula,
- 2:53to provide a solution. to the problem of loss
- 2:57of the labor force from young people. That sounds
- 3:00very important. Could you explain a little bit
- 3:02why it is essential for traditional communities,
- 3:06particularly in the Yucatan Peninsula, to have
- 3:08universities using this approach? I mentioned
- 3:11the issues with migration. Just because there
- 3:14is no university nearby, it is more difficult
- 3:17for young people to finish a university degree
- 3:19or a technical career. Young people from there
- 3:23would have to go to larger cities or big cities
- 3:25like Merida or Cancun, and therefore further
- 3:29away from their families and also paying more
- 3:31expensive rents, transportation, and all that
- 3:34eating plus. From a personal point of view, my
- 3:37life would have been entirely different if this
- 3:40option had existed for us. It gives them the
- 3:43opportunity not only to be with their family,
- 3:46but also to reduce costs and the opportunity
- 3:48to study. to encourage them to study and continue
- 3:51with the academic or social part and work in
- 3:55the same place where they grew up. The idea is
- 3:57also professionalizing knowledge because a lot
- 3:59of knowledge already exists or it has been there
- 4:02transmitted from generation to generation. But
- 4:05it needs to be systematized or professionalized.
- 4:08On the other hand, it is also vital that young
- 4:11people appropriate what they do, that they feel
- 4:15proud of the knowledge that they have. of this
- 4:17ancestral legacy of care, this knowledge and
- 4:20an application, and how to apply it. Of course.
- 4:23They have been doing technical work for a long
- 4:26time in their communities. However, it is essential
- 4:29for an educational institution to ensure that
- 4:31these types of skills are not lost among the
- 4:35people who live there. Of course. Also, from
- 4:38the farmer's point of view, your word is not
- 4:41worth the same. If unfortunately you don't have
- 4:44a document that supports a degree. So even if
- 4:46you are the best fee keeper in the world, if
- 4:49you never went to the university or you are not
- 4:52a technician, it is nothing. It doesn't mean
- 4:54nothing. And your work is devaluated. How the
- 4:57work is evaluated and how it is remunerated is
- 5:01also important in that sense. And I could say
- 5:04that the university responds to several of these
- 5:07problems or at least tackle these issues. So
- 5:09could you tell us a little bit about what agroecology
- 5:13is and why do you see it is important? Agroecology
- 5:17is a different approach to the exploitation of
- 5:20natural resources. It has nothing to do with
- 5:23monoculture or extensive crops. I say that the
- 5:26Mayans knew it. Oh, they knew much more than
- 5:29we do. In the Yucatan Peninsula, there is, for
- 5:32example, the Mayan Milpa, which consists of planting
- 5:35in symbiosis of different crops such as corn,
- 5:39squash, bean, and crops, and these ones are rotated.
- 5:43Many Mayan communities continue to do these activities.
- 5:46This knowledge allows the people to conserve
- 5:49the soil's fertility. Another important thing
- 5:52is that in the Yucatan Peninsula, there is quite
- 5:56poor soil, or it's like a little. layer of soil.
- 6:00So if you dig anywhere on the peninsula, there
- 6:03is only a few centimeters before you reach the
- 6:06rock. So agroecology is the modern name for something
- 6:09ancient. So it is usually the knowledge that
- 6:11the ancestors had and has to these days. My approach
- 6:15to the communities continues to be very humble
- 6:18because I consider that I have much to learn
- 6:21from them than they have to learn from me. The
- 6:23Mayan Milpa has A whole series of observations
- 6:27of the environment related to the stars, the
- 6:30weather, and what is called the cabanuelas, when
- 6:33the ants or larvae come out. So that indicates
- 6:36that it's going to rain soon. This is very ancient
- 6:38knowledge that has been mixed with technology
- 6:40and is getting understood a little bit more.
- 6:44It is important to combine these traditional
- 6:46and scientific parts. Also, in Yucatan, burning
- 6:49is mainly done to replenish the soil with carbon.
- 6:52The meal pie is not mechanized or is hardly mechanized.
- 6:55And it's all artesian work that helps to replenish
- 6:59the nutrients in the soil. That's very interesting.
- 7:02So moving forward, tell us about your projects
- 7:05at the Intercultural University. How do you see
- 7:08your knowledge of microbial systems as applications
- 7:11in the activities and missions of the traditional
- 7:14communities? You're aware that microorganisms
- 7:17exist everywhere. What excites me now is sharing
- 7:21the curiosity I have or the significance I see
- 7:24in understanding phenomena like the microbiome
- 7:26of bees. The Yucatan Peninsula is renowned for
- 7:29its beekeeping and melipony culture. The management
- 7:33of native stingless bees. These bees not only
- 7:37produce honey, but they are actually unknown.
- 7:40There's different biological aspects of these
- 7:42bees are unknown. Many in Mexico are unaware
- 7:45that the stingless bees are honey producers too.
- 7:48Honey is created as a nectar passes through the
- 7:51bee's digestive system and is then deposited
- 7:54back into the hive. Consider honey as a reflection
- 7:56of the microbiome of a specific part of the bee's
- 7:59digestive system. Thus, I found a tree link to
- 8:02explore its properties and describe each type
- 8:05of honey. The variation in honey depends on what
- 8:08bees pollinate or select. My project, and the
- 8:11reason I am at the university, revolves around
- 8:14this inquiry. It also involves studying how microbial
- 8:18or bacterial communities in the soil change,
- 8:21whether in forest, soil, milpa, or the vegetation
- 8:24that sustains these bees. And how does this microbiome
- 8:28change with different agricultural practices?
- 8:30The Mayan population has endured, but it faces
- 8:33ongoing challenges due to the relentless expansion
- 8:36of technified monoculture and extensive crops.
- 8:39Some of the tools that have helped to understand
- 8:41the importance of The different techniques that
- 8:44they use or they disknowledge is the molecular
- 8:46level evidence. Although may not always be necessary,
- 8:50it is crucial to demonstrate economically the
- 8:53importance and the relevance of the conserving
- 8:56bee habitats and pollinators. This conservation
- 8:59effort benefits not only the inhabitants of the
- 9:02peninsula, but all Mexicans and indeed all inhabitants
- 9:05of the world. The significant issue lies in our
- 9:07failure to grasp the ecosystem as a whole. Instead,
- 9:10we focus on isolated components, leading to monocultures
- 9:15that lack biodiversity and understanding of soil
- 9:18property, changes in interactions with pollinators,
- 9:21and impacts on natural predators. Furthermore,
- 9:24the social aspect adds complexity, particularly
- 9:27regarding land ownership. Many hold the belief
- 9:29that it is my land and I'll do as I please, without
- 9:33considering the broader community's interest.
- 9:36It is essential to shift this perspective towards
- 9:38recognizing that while the land may be individual
- 9:41property, it is everyone's best interest, and
- 9:44to avoid devastation and monoculture practices.
- 9:47Yes, precisely. There are very different visions
- 9:50of the territory, and in this case, new works
- 9:52amplified was not traditionally the case for
- 9:55Mayan culture or communities. The land is communal
- 9:59property for them and one day they are doing
- 10:03their cornfield or crop but tomorrow they will
- 10:06do it at a neighbor's land because the first
- 10:08place needs to be born or harvest, whatever is
- 10:11the case. And the neighbor will do the same.
- 10:14These are very different missions of conceiving
- 10:16a concept as important as territory. It is very
- 10:18important that you are working to incorporate
- 10:21this type of mission and academia. Yes, it is
- 10:24also something that I recognize and applaud from
- 10:26the Intercultural Mayan University of Quintana
- 10:29Roo, because it is something that in my scientific
- 10:32career I had not seen. That's right. So how have
- 10:36you applied or proposed this research to these
- 10:39activities that you carry out with the community?
- 10:43Well, I am also relatively new. in this university.
- 10:48Actually, I started in January of this year.
- 10:50I have been using the links that they had already
- 10:53been created in the past. I have been recognizing
- 10:56their territory and the people of the community
- 10:58involved in the project. To my surprise, there
- 11:01are many producers and many people interested.
- 11:04There's everything. There's small producers,
- 11:07medium -sized producers, large producers, and
- 11:10also large exporters. There is a lot of interest,
- 11:14but there is also a lot of... skepticism from
- 11:16the population with good reason. They need more
- 11:19certainty that this resource or what we discover
- 11:22will reach them and will translate in benefits
- 11:26or at least we will be able to communicate with
- 11:29them. And here it has been quite different. They
- 11:32know what they want and they know why we are
- 11:35contacting them and getting into their territory.
- 11:38And this is because we are going to make them
- 11:41participate in everything we do to avoid scientific
- 11:45extractivism. Because the samples and data is
- 11:48knowledge obtained from their territory. So it's
- 11:50important to give them a purpose for the community.
- 11:53Yes, communities need to be contacted about the
- 11:56findings, even if they are not tangible results.
- 11:58So we avoid starting from scratch every time.
- 12:02There is no continuity and the communication
- 12:04with the actors is key. Yeah, that's right. There's
- 12:08also the training, the formation, this appropriation
- 12:11of the systematized knowledge. Yeah, that is
- 12:14important. You have already told us a little
- 12:16bit about what your project is about and what
- 12:19the objective is. Tell us about other initiatives
- 12:21that are carried out at your university and how
- 12:24both indigenous communities and the scientists
- 12:27benefit from them. I was mentioning a part of
- 12:29the project related to the bees. Interestingly,
- 12:32in our region, the Mayan Milpa often intersects
- 12:35with beekeeping activities. This synergy between
- 12:38the Milpa and beekeeping impacts bees in various
- 12:42ways. The university promotes awareness through
- 12:45its programs and courses, emphasizing the careful
- 12:48use of agrochemicals due to the significant impact
- 12:51on pollinators and ecosystem functions. Consequently,
- 12:55producers are increasingly conscious of the quality
- 12:58of their products, understanding that it depends
- 13:00on the vegetation types and ecosystems there,
- 13:03which is going to impact the prices of the products.
- 13:06So also... Part of the project is to evaluate
- 13:09and explore the other side of the genetically
- 13:11modified organisms, especially as mechanisms
- 13:14to conserve the native corn varieties that exist
- 13:18in Mexico, because it's also part of the milk
- 13:21activities and is to conserve seeds that come
- 13:24from those native varieties. That's super important
- 13:27because it gives tools to the community precisely
- 13:30to protect and to look for policies that protect
- 13:33all their genetic potential, their traditional
- 13:36agricultural potential, and they can have data
- 13:39behind them that support this traditional way
- 13:42of managing their crops. Yes, one of the great
- 13:44advantages of agroecology is that it promotes
- 13:47food sovereignty. So I believe... It's important
- 13:51to replicate exercises in various territories
- 13:54or do the same in different locations of different
- 13:57parts of the world. We need to consider the realistic
- 14:00needs of these communities and find ways to bridge
- 14:03the gap between scientific knowledge and indigenous
- 14:06wisdom. That's right, we shouldn't dismiss their
- 14:08wisdom just because it doesn't follow the traditional
- 14:11scientific method. It's not the only path to
- 14:13knowledge. Dismissing it in such a condescending
- 14:16manner is practically racist and prevents us
- 14:19from benefiting from the valuable knowledge of
- 14:21ancestral community. Of course, because there
- 14:23is also interculturality or a peace dialogue
- 14:26between cultures. So all the parties should be
- 14:29open to listen, to listen to everyone, because
- 14:32this is the first thing. This also has been a
- 14:35very interesting exercise for me, to simply listen.
- 14:38This is listening without thinking of an answer,
- 14:42not thinking about... What is this article related
- 14:45to this process? What this person says about
- 14:48that? No, it's just, just please shut up and
- 14:51just listen. What is the need of this person?
- 14:53What is telling me? Yeah, it's important. So
- 14:56in your opinion, is there a gap between traditional
- 14:58knowledge and the scientific community? Before
- 15:00I joined the Intercultural Maya Community or
- 15:03this university, my approach was quite different.
- 15:05I recognized that I had certain biases and perspectives
- 15:09that were limited in their scope. To a certain
- 15:12extent, condescending. I'm going to come and
- 15:15explain them. I think as a scientific community,
- 15:17we need to open ourselves and see what are the
- 15:21needs that the communities have. Because we can't
- 15:24just rely on like, oh, I'm going to publish this
- 15:26paper. Yeah, very fancy paper, nice publication
- 15:29in nature or whatever. But what I'm doing with
- 15:32this? What is the solution that is provided in
- 15:35this paper? What are the problems that I'm tackling
- 15:38of the people that I'm working with? The impact
- 15:41that we can have or the incidents that we can
- 15:44have comes also precisely from the resolution
- 15:46of real problems. And that implies a lot to get
- 15:50out of the laboratories and leave outside the
- 15:53papers. I believe that this was done before.
- 15:56And from those observations came those questions
- 15:59or emerged those questions. That curiosity was
- 16:02born as they need to look for answers to something.
- 16:05But we have forgotten this. Finally, would you
- 16:08like to tell us about any personal experience
- 16:10or anecdote? There was a worship on beekeeping
- 16:13and melipony culture. So to my surprise, there
- 16:17were many people from honey producers to government
- 16:20representatives and many young people as well.
- 16:23There were also people selling their honey products.
- 16:26It was something very communitarian and it was
- 16:29one of the first experiences that I had with
- 16:32the community. I didn't participate in anything,
- 16:35I think. It just came to observe and listen.
- 16:38But for me, it was very enriching. Thanks for
- 16:41sharing your knowledge and experiences, Ari.
- 16:44What you said about the bees and that their honey
- 16:46is actually the profile of their microbiota is
- 16:49very interesting. And I think it is also for
- 16:53many people that don't know this. I had never
- 16:55stalked a bee that way. It is incredible. Yes,
- 16:58and we are just exploring all the properties
- 17:01of the honey has, like prebiotics and probiotics.
- 17:06But yeah, we will continue working on that. Thank
- 17:09you very much for the invitation and for having
- 17:11me here. What an inspiring interview. We have
- 17:16heard about a few cases where science collaborates
- 17:19closely with the local and regional community,
- 17:21including traditional inhabitants and indigenous
- 17:24peoples. This marks a significant part of the
- 17:26internship where traditional communities actively
- 17:29participate and have direct access to research
- 17:31projects. It is different from the traditional
- 17:34approach. where they were only asked for access
- 17:37to sites or places, or sacred places, and then
- 17:41the knowledge remaining documents or papers.
- 17:43Now, there's a collaborative effort to address
- 17:46both immediate and long -term needs, enhancing
- 17:50traditional methods and integrating tools to
- 17:52improve crop production or mitigate the impacts
- 17:55of agricultural activities. That's right. From
- 17:58higher education, we see how these initiatives
- 18:00can be implemented. First, by providing an educational
- 18:03service for a community historically excluded
- 18:06from these levels of training. And second, by
- 18:09validating traditional knowledge. So it is a
- 18:11win -win situation. Combine traditional knowledge
- 18:14with technology and science. Another important
- 18:16aspect of engaging in scientific endeavors with
- 18:19communities is to provide training in the use
- 18:21of technological tools while also learning about
- 18:24the traditional uses of natural resources. This
- 18:27approach is tailored to the current needs of
- 18:29the community. It is common in scientific research
- 18:32projects to lack continuity and fail to address
- 18:36local needs. However, it is essential to recognize
- 18:39that to achieve applied science, there must first
- 18:43be a solid scientific foundation to test hypotheses,
- 18:46conduct pilot studies, and develop theories.
- 18:49That's true. These synergies are wonderful because
- 18:52they empower the traditional inhabitants of these
- 18:56regions to make decisions about the development
- 18:58and future of their communities. It also empowers
- 19:01scientists because it gives them in -situ evidence,
- 19:04for example, of the state of their resources
- 19:06and the need to concept them. Moreover, potentially,
- 19:09these new rural or regional academics can be
- 19:12valuable political allies of many scientific
- 19:15or conservation interests. Exactly. Science -policy
- 19:19partnerships are critical to address the challenges
- 19:21we face in resource management effectively. When
- 19:24science is integrated into policymaking, more
- 19:28effective strategies can be designed that not
- 19:30only meet the needs of communities but also protect
- 19:34ecosystems. For example, providing communities
- 19:36with tools to protect crop genetic biodiversity
- 19:39and preserve traditional knowledge gives them
- 19:42an active voice in making decisions that directly
- 19:45affect their lives and environment. This inclusion
- 19:48not only promotes equity and fairness, but also
- 19:52enhances the long -term sustainability of our
- 19:55actions. It is a fascinating topic that gives
- 19:57a lot to discuss. And indeed, I think that this
- 20:00episode has shown that there are different ways
- 20:02to approach scientific development, leaving behind
- 20:05some of the margins that the current paradigm
- 20:07of science and the policies for its promotion
- 20:10has drawn for us. We hope you enjoyed this episode
- 20:13of Science Behind the Glass with this exciting
- 20:15topic. This episode was inspired by the article
- 20:18Rural Science Education, Valuing Local Knowledge.
- 20:21We leave reference to this material in the episode
- 20:24description. Listen to our next episodes on the
- 20:27YouTube channel and Spotify. Also remember to
- 20:30subscribe and visit our official website. Follow
- 20:32us on our social networks, Facebook and Instagram.
- 20:36Original music by our colleague and friend Bernardo.