Latest / Housecast / The Housecast Dream Team - Episode 1
Transcript
- 0:00What have you had for your tea, dude?
- 0:02Chicken Kiev, new potatoes, broccoli, sweet corn very.
- 0:06Nice. 2 veg 3 veg Sorry. For a Monday.
- 0:10Yeah. What are you?
- 0:11What is that? I've had some salmon with some.
- 0:14What's yours, Gaz? I had some anyway quarter
- 0:18chicken sort of chocolate when we start stir fried veg and rice
- 0:21that's. Why?
- 0:23We're all doing really well. We'll go to Joe Martin, see what
- 0:25we. I made some.
- 0:27We had some Mexican chicken, some pita breads and like a PETA
- 0:32tomato or salad. OK, Gavil have had McDonald's on
- 0:36it. No Gavil have had chilli I bet.
- 0:38I bet Gav's had chilli. Has chilli a lot.
- 0:40It's a solid. Fish.
- 0:41I like chilli. What would you have when you put
- 0:43cheese on it dude? Cheese no.
- 0:45No sour cream. Yeah, yeah, I've.
- 0:49Got it. You look disappointed by that
- 0:51suggestion. No, no, no, no, no.
- 0:52Is it? Is it cheese in general or?
- 0:55Oh no, biggest cheese fan on it just now.
- 1:04We're chilling. No, that really is cheese mate.
- 1:09Really is cheese. Yeah, just have to have it
- 1:12straight, don't you? It's the house cast dream team,
- 1:23the Kings of the West End. From Higgy to Blairs, their
- 1:27legacy won't end. Stan wanted more than 50 years,
- 1:31but it's not up to him. So who's in your team?
- 1:35Who is out? Who is in?
- 1:44Hello everybody and welcome to the House Cast Law House Cricket
- 1:48Clubs podcast. With Midwinter, they don't
- 1:51really matter what date we're on, but with Midwinter we're
- 1:54getting towards the end of November and the five of us have
- 1:57come up with a plan to pick who we feel is the best low house
- 2:02side none of all time going back the last 50 years.
- 2:07So they must have played in the last 50 years.
- 2:09So that's the topic for the next couple of podcasts.
- 2:13So without further ado, we'll just go around the the team who
- 2:17are going to be carrying out this task.
- 2:19First of all, Gav, welcome Gav. I'll be you're 20 minutes late.
- 2:25Sorry about that. Generally, how are we all?
- 2:26You're all right. Yeah, yeah, good.
- 2:28Thanks. We've we've just had a real
- 2:30catch up all about our tea and what we've been up to whilst
- 2:34you've been taking forever to get to to get out your paint.
- 2:37What if you have for your tea, Gav?
- 2:39Lasagna. Very sorry A.
- 2:42Sweepstake and everyone send you the back chiller.
- 2:46Half and half got whack. A good chilly, but lasagna?
- 2:49Hang on. That's good.
- 2:51Everything all right, Gav? Yeah, really good mate.
- 2:54Good. The SO that's host #2.
- 2:57Or or vote. #2 let's call it for the for the team vote #3 is Joe
- 3:04Martin. Hi, Jeremy, are you OK?
- 3:07Yeah, fine. Thanks.
- 3:08Yeah, we went off then. That's why I'm going.
- 3:14Joe, I see you're in the Joe Martin suite.
- 3:18Is it? What is it cold?
- 3:20No, it's warm. The radiator's on.
- 3:23I think it's just making sure the pipes don't freeze up.
- 3:27I don't think you need full heating on to make the pipes not
- 3:31freeze up is there no no one that cares about the energy I'm.
- 3:37Not in charge of it. It's all it's all done from the
- 3:40clubhouse. Why are you parked?
- 3:42Up there, that's where the clubhouse is.
- 3:46For the record, that's not. Convincing you, certainly
- 3:49warming the pipes just happens to be on the same night that
- 3:51you're in the club. That's coincidence.
- 3:53I've got nothing to do with it. I assume that it's due to.
- 3:58I assume that it's due to the temperature dropping before
- 4:01below a certain level it comes on automatically.
- 4:05Wasting money anyway, Joe, thanks very much.
- 4:08You're still out to doing bits of running.
- 4:10There's a little bit of snow tonight, so be careful when you
- 4:13get out. Yeah, I'll be all right.
- 4:14Yeah, still out most days. That's every day.
- 4:17That's good. So let's go to the vote #4 Joe
- 4:23Beneducci. Now you've got a significant
- 4:25role because you're still involved with the players.
- 4:27Duke James, how are you going on, first of all?
- 4:31How we decided the running order for these for these voters.
- 4:35An important. OK, fair enough.
- 4:38Reverse order what? So let's have a little chat.
- 4:46About your glasses. The bonfire.
- 4:48How did that go? Oh.
- 4:50Great, Yeah, yeah, excellent. Great team effort from from
- 4:54everybody involved. Really good.
- 4:56Good to see so many people from the club getting involved,
- 4:58particularly those that, you know, live close by.
- 5:01It's good that people can, you know, come down and give us a
- 5:03Chuck up whether it's during the week or on the night itself.
- 5:07It's it's good. Yeah, I mean, I've, I did liaise
- 5:10with Stan a few times and he said that, you know, the
- 5:13building the vampire went on, there were a lot of people then
- 5:16helping with that and then, you know, the night before and, you
- 5:20know, you're actually on the night.
- 5:21You know, it was amazed. Some people travel some distance
- 5:23as well. Didn't they do?
- 5:24Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. People put a real, a real shift
- 5:27in, make a real effort. It's good to see.
- 5:29Joe Martin, I believe you were doing all the photography that
- 5:32and and a little bit of security in a lot of building.
- 5:34That must be some time. I did.
- 5:37I took two days off work. Yeah, to to come and help.
- 5:40I'm not trying to. That's what happened.
- 5:42I'm not trying facts. No.
- 5:44Brilliant. That's so so Gavoi, have you got
- 5:46your blisters gone, Gav from really heavily you did.
- 5:49Yeah, yeah. All right.
- 5:51This year, Jess. Yeah, I think, I think the
- 5:53bodies found become attuned to building it.
- 5:55So. So yeah, I'm just a lean, mean
- 5:57bonfire building machine. Right.
- 5:59What days did you go down? So you're cracking up there,
- 6:02Jess. Sorry, can you say that again?
- 6:10Sorry, just. But I'll say it again for the
- 6:13listeners, Gav lives within 100 metres and didn't turn at once.
- 6:18And we we had a good earlier why?
- 6:20And we came to the conclusion you're a lazy bastard.
- 6:23Yeah. Oh yeah.
- 6:24How long did that take you to get to you?
- 6:27Not long enough. Jesus wept.
- 6:29For the record, Gav, I said that you're very busy, chap.
- 6:31Thank you. Thank you.
- 6:34Thanks Gav. Thanks and sorry we but you were
- 6:36late. We're all.
- 6:39No problem, Jeremy, No problem. That's why you get the stick.
- 6:42And then to the fifth and final voter, Gary Moore outside.
- 6:47Gaz looks like Gary's having a few issues.
- 6:53It looks like he's got a condom on his head.
- 7:04It's tremendous you're. Doing that on purpose.
- 7:11So I think Gary's having technical by the looks of it.
- 7:14Don't worry, we can edit this. No, don't it all.
- 7:18Looks so well. That's such a game that we call
- 7:23that the the the listeners won't.
- 7:25We have to see it. We get a video of it, you know
- 7:28the recorded video. I'm getting a clip of the
- 7:31picture as well and. Yeah.
- 7:33So Gary will probably be able to hear as not being able to to
- 7:37transmit. So let's just start on how this
- 7:40is going to work. We've all got the same brief,
- 7:44all the five individuals on here.
- 7:47We thought about having X amount of batters, X amount of bowlers
- 7:51etcetera, etcetera. But we've Pooh poohed that what
- 7:54we are going to pick by the end of these debates, which
- 7:58hopefully don't take too long but hopefully generates really
- 8:03good discussions, are 10 amateurs who've played cricket
- 8:07in the last 50 years for low, high, more than 30 games in a
- 8:12relatively sensible batting order.
- 8:15For example, we're not going to pick 10 battles, 10 bowlers.
- 8:17Obviously one of those amateurs has to be a wicket keeper and
- 8:21then we will pick a professional between us very quickly.
- 8:24We'll start off and I'm sure there will be the the odd
- 8:27individual that we hope picked that would fall into the team.
- 8:31We will then start to debate and we are aiming for a unanimous
- 8:36vote on each position. If that doesn't occur and we
- 8:40can't agree and we will have strong discussions about this
- 8:44and try and persuade each other, almost like a jury try and
- 8:48persuade each other as to why our particular selection should
- 8:52be in and not the other persons who's voting and ultimately get
- 8:56to what a team that we all agree on.
- 8:58It's worth mentioning now we've had lots and lots of teams come
- 9:03in from the supporters and the listeners and I think Joe
- 9:06Martin, you've been collecting those.
- 9:08Can you just give us an update as to how that's gone?
- 9:11Excellent. Really, what's what's that?
- 9:12How many we had in. Over 100.
- 9:15Wow. Brilliant.
- 9:17That is fantastic. That is absolutely brilliant.
- 9:20And I mean I've seen quite a few, I think some have been on
- 9:23open source, EG on on X or Twitter and some on Facebook and
- 9:29some have gone straight onto the website.
- 9:31Are you? I mean I've seen a pattern
- 9:34around it. Are you seeing much of A
- 9:36pattern, Joe? Yes, I think in in some cases
- 9:40there has been some corruption in how the teams have have been
- 9:44put forward. Wow, that's a strong alligator.
- 9:48Which is a golden, which is a whole.
- 9:50Claim, isn't it? You what?
- 9:51Sorry, John. Possibly.
- 9:53Yeah. Yeah, let's go with that.
- 9:55Yeah. Slanderous that I think in it,
- 9:58yeah. Yeah.
- 9:59We've haven't slandered anybody. So we've had.
- 10:01Not yet, anyway. So we've had the the teams come
- 10:04in from far and wide. I think it's fair to say you
- 10:08know any, any names so that we can drop in and thank them for
- 10:12submitting the teams. Yeah, we've had quite a few.
- 10:16So we've had wheel driver centre team in Francois, centre team in
- 10:20Chippy, centre team in Dave Gardner, centre team in.
- 10:24So there's been. There's been loads all four of
- 10:27those. He did send one in, but he only
- 10:30picked 10 players. For the listeners, you know,
- 10:37this is a bit of fun. We're not here to cause mass
- 10:40riots as to why he's not been picked or why he's not been
- 10:43picked. We are aware that the groundsman
- 10:46stroke cricket chair is not happy beyond 50 years.
- 10:50But you know, even I'm starting to remember much beyond 50 years
- 10:55now, Stan might be able to remember a little bit further,
- 10:58but with those are the rules, listeners, those are the rules.
- 11:00So we cannot go outside of that, that remit, Stan.
- 11:05Stan actually argued, Jess, that we should do it decade by decade
- 11:08because the cricket was so different.
- 11:10He's got too much time on his hands.
- 11:12Hello, Gary's back. Brilliant, Gaz.
- 11:17So Gaz, welcome. You're the 5th voter.
- 11:20We'll give you an opportunity now that you've got your
- 11:22technical equipment in order. Excellent.
- 11:26Are you doing all right, Sir? What's your thoughts around this
- 11:29initiative that we've got going? It's.
- 11:31Me thoughts. Yeah, I'm all right.
- 11:33Jess. Thoughts around this?
- 11:35Yes. It's been tricky trying to
- 11:37anticipate various conversations and debates.
- 11:41We might have all the things that you've just said about
- 11:44different eras, different when the league was different,
- 11:49different conditions, different rules, match match rules,
- 11:53etcetera. Nobody's going to be happy, are
- 11:55they? Everybody will have an opinion
- 11:57so. Yeah, looking forward to it.
- 11:59Yeah, it will. It will be good.
- 12:00And I think it's worth mentioning now as well, we did
- 12:04think about, you know, whether we set criteria for it's got to
- 12:08be talent based or it's got to be loyalty based or you know,
- 12:13it's just got to be who's who's my friend, I'm going to pick him
- 12:17type of thing. And we've not set anything.
- 12:19We've just left it to the individuals who are on this
- 12:22call, the five of us. So our ultimate aim, if we
- 12:26manage this, I'm not really sure, but what we're aiming to
- 12:29do is having maybe two or three episodes where we discuss the
- 12:35team and we get to a final 11. It will be fantastic.
- 12:39If we could then have the final podcast live, I'm not sure we
- 12:44could. What's the word?
- 12:48Not record. We could air it live because of
- 12:51some inappropriate language. But we'd like to do it maybe
- 12:55down at the Cricket Club if we could manage it on the Christmas
- 12:59drink or at another time and invite a few people to come and
- 13:02listen. But that's a way off yet.
- 13:04So let's let's wait and see. So let's go through and have a
- 13:08look at opening bats or batters. Who would be batting in the top
- 13:11four who could open? But maybe he's opened all the
- 13:15career, but we can't leave them actually lasted and four.
- 13:18So I'll start with a few wild cards I've got up to, you know,
- 13:23these are top four or five batters.
- 13:24I think I've got about 12 listed down here.
- 13:27A few wild cards I'll throw out there.
- 13:29So I want to encourage the the other voters to come back with
- 13:32with further ones. These are not particular people
- 13:34I'm going to vote for, but Stephen G, you know, outstanding
- 13:38player, obviously could bowl as well.
- 13:41Went on throwing elsewhere. He's one I've, you know, I've
- 13:45looked at and I'm considering. And then you've got Johnny
- 13:48Whitehead, you know, and Stan and Nicka.
- 13:51So Joe Martin, can you throw any of your considerations out as
- 13:55well? Yeah, I've I had a group of 6 to
- 13:59open the batting. You've already listed a couple
- 14:04with Stan and Johnny that were on my list and Nikki, but the
- 14:09others that I had in there were Ben Heap, current captain, you
- 14:14know, second highest run score. And now I think in the pub I had
- 14:17Vishal Tripathi because he's outstanding, fantastic batter
- 14:22and Piggy because he opened batting.
- 14:26His numbers are very good, very high and was a, you know,
- 14:32legendary figure at the cricket. They were my selections that
- 14:36were all. All fair shapes, all fair
- 14:38shapes, Dukes, any you know, obviously Joe and I have
- 14:42mentioned two or three there who were going to be right up there
- 14:46and then a few wild cards. Any you know who are you
- 14:48thinking is going to be in the mix towards the end and then any
- 14:52other wild cards that you thought of I.
- 14:54Ain't got any other wild cards but my, my list of five have
- 14:57been, you know, covered there by yours and yours and yours
- 15:00shouts. I started with five and then got
- 15:04to three fairly quickly and then struggled, struggled from 3:00
- 15:08to 2:00, but I've eventually got there.
- 15:12I have to say I didn't struggle a bit from 3:00 to 2:00, but I
- 15:14would say that Ben was one of the first names I wrote down.
- 15:18So you've, you've gone there Dutch and you're working it all
- 15:21at yourself and you are now that is going to be your your set on
- 15:25those two opening batters that you've obviously been won and
- 15:29you're set on that. Brilliant.
- 15:31No, that's I like, I like to. That's a good starting point for
- 15:34us to discuss. Gav, what about yourself around
- 15:37the opening bats? Forgive me, did anyone throw
- 15:41finching to the potential opening birth?
- 15:44Nobody mentioned Gav. Well, you see, I, I, I think, I
- 15:48think he's up there for the debate opening the batting, you
- 15:53know, but again, as, as what will probably become apparent
- 15:56throughout the couple of episodes, you know, the, the
- 15:59same names are going to crop up. But I did quite similar to what
- 16:02Benny's done. You know, I've, I've looked at
- 16:06each position in the order, whether it be batting or middle
- 16:08order or all rounders. And then, and I've actually,
- 16:11I've actually got down to my 11. So, so I've actually drilled
- 16:16down there and I've done that since over the last couple of
- 16:19weeks. So, so Ben is one of my opening,
- 16:24opening partners. Sorry, one of my opening
- 16:27batters. Really.
- 16:28I agree with Benny, I think, I think you know.
- 16:31But anyway, anyway, we'll get to that.
- 16:33But Ben is definitely in my one of my own.
- 16:36Yeah. And I think this is a really
- 16:38good place to because we can develop it from there and
- 16:40hopefully keep keep going through the individuals and
- 16:43decide on. And you look at Ben, I mean,
- 16:45Adam, Adam's pulled a spreadsheet together and it's a
- 16:49continuing updated spreadsheet, you know, game by game, year by
- 16:54year, which is really useful for us.
- 16:56And you look at Ben 8 times and 558 rooms.
- 17:00And that's just league runs. You know, it's phenomenal. 26.41
- 17:04has have any of the others? Well, let me go to Gary first.
- 17:07Gary, we opening bats give us, I know you've had a few issues
- 17:11there, but I think you're hearing us.
- 17:13What's your opening bats thoughts?
- 17:15And is there any wild cards you want to throw in?
- 17:18Gary's Gary's happy. A bit like you, Jess.
- 17:25I had a bit like you, Jess and Steve G in the mix.
- 17:31Johnny Vishal again, Stan, Ben, of course.
- 17:36So yeah, I don't think anything different to what you guys were
- 17:38already thrown in. Right.
- 17:40So that's. We mentioned standers.
- 17:43Yeah. Yeah.
- 17:44Yeah, I thought you. Did I mean the other thing on
- 17:48Ben is that yes, he scored an an incredible amount of runs, but
- 17:53he also always turns up in the big games.
- 17:56I think to Worsley Cup finals, T20 finals, title defining
- 18:02games. Ben is always there front and
- 18:05centre and usually he's he comes off and.
- 18:11We've actually spoke about that quite a lot on this podcast
- 18:14before. His record in finals and big
- 18:17games is phenomenal. And when you throw the fact that
- 18:20he's shouldering the captains here at the same time as opening
- 18:23the batted, I think his records ridiculous really.
- 18:26And I really should see how he wouldn't make his side I.
- 18:30Think as well as added to all that, but you're all right as
- 18:34well. It's the fashion in which he
- 18:35plays as well, because he's not scratching around.
- 18:37He really does dominate, goes at the bowler, so it's everything.
- 18:43It's the old package really. Yeah, I think safe picking it,
- 18:47yeah. Yeah, I'm sure it is.
- 18:49But what I want to get across now and you know, I'm only
- 18:52playing Devil have a cut. But you know, the pictures are
- 18:56better now. The bats are bigger and can hit
- 18:59it further. You know, they're not playing
- 19:01against test pros like, you know, in the Seventies, 80s and
- 19:0690s that that was going on then. You know, I don't we don't
- 19:09particularly mean Ben, you know that.
- 19:11But I it shocked me. And Dukes is for the listeners.
- 19:14Dukes is shaking his head and and and using hand signals
- 19:19towards me. But.
- 19:23Do you look at the averages? Has anyone studied the averages
- 19:26with old players and new players?
- 19:29It it really does shock me how poor some of the old averages
- 19:32are from the, you know, the players who played in the late
- 19:36seventies, 80s and 90s. Has anyone else identified that?
- 19:40I I agree with you Jess, to some extent.
- 19:43However, I think when you look at the upper echelon of amateur
- 19:48cricket, the averages amongst them are pretty consistent.
- 19:53So if the pictures are that bad back then why is everyone's
- 19:58economy rate not 1.3? Well, it is a lot like.
- 20:01Bowlers. It is quite a bit less.
- 20:04But another reason as to why it's less is because the outlook
- 20:07of the batters and the way that the game was played.
- 20:09For example, batters in years gone bad, Stan's always talked
- 20:12about it, the first, let's not get out.
- 20:15You're not telling me that the likes of Ben, Johnny Whited,
- 20:18other class batters in the league, they don't go out there
- 20:21just to survive. They go out there to take the
- 20:23game on. And I think that's where the
- 20:25game has moved on in the last sort of 15, 15 years in
- 20:28particular. I think the outlook of an
- 20:30amateur, there's always been good players of course, as
- 20:33they'd have to say otherwise. But I think the outlook of how a
- 20:36good amateur bats these days and how they approach their cricket,
- 20:40I think that is a big factor of it as well.
- 20:42Yeah. Disparity.
- 20:44The disparity in the bowling figures is nowhere near as much
- 20:48as the disparity in the batting averages.
- 20:50Nowhere near. So I can't all be down to
- 20:52pitches and conditions. No, no, I'll have it, Joe.
- 20:55I just want to throw it out there because Stan, because Stan
- 20:59asked me to. I think, I think we can all
- 21:06agree that the Ben is going to be in the team.
- 21:10Is there anyone that would disagree?
- 21:12No, no. If Gary's still struggling to
- 21:17get back in, can someone just message him on their house cast
- 21:20and say does he agree that Ben's in please?
- 21:23Yeah, I'll let him. I'll let you know what he says.
- 21:26Thank you. So let's move on to the other
- 21:29one, the other opening bat. Now bear in mind, chaps, you
- 21:32know, we can have maybe 3 or 4 who've who've opened the bat in
- 21:37all the careers, but we feel that they've got to get into the
- 21:40side to the detriment of a normal #3 or #4 So always bear
- 21:45that in mind. So my next choice, Oh no, let me
- 21:49say I would, I would unfortunately, I would kick Phil
- 21:53out of it, out of my list of eight.
- 21:55I will kick V Shall out of it. And I think Phil, because you're
- 21:59looking at the average, it's less than 15.
- 22:01I don't know back Phil, come back to three or four and we can
- 22:05look at that. And again, you know, it is we
- 22:09have to be a little bit controversial at times.
- 22:11V Shall whilst one of the best players you know, I've played
- 22:14with and watched, he hasn't played enough for us you know.
- 22:17And I would throw in, there's a loyalty card there.
- 22:20I know people will contest that, but that's just my view.
- 22:24So I would kick those two out to my 8.
- 22:26Gooch, what about? Who would you kick out of yours?
- 22:29Right, so I only have 5. OK.
- 22:33The outline there was Finchy. He wasn't one of my 5, but I'm
- 22:35going to I'm going to mention him later down.
- 22:38So my 5 was Ben, Stan, Johnny, Nicky and Michelle.
- 22:43So like you I agree with everything you said about
- 22:45Michelle. He was one of the best players
- 22:46that I played with comfortably but just on the fact that he he
- 22:51didn't perhaps play as long and he and he left us at a bad time
- 22:56and moved to a bad club. So unfortunately in my selection
- 22:59criteria he he gets ejected. The next one to miss out on this
- 23:05unfortunately is Nicky. Nicky's one of my favourite ever
- 23:08law house players. He was captain when I made my
- 23:10debut that day, got 78 not out against James Anderson at
- 23:14Burnley and that was a day I'll never forget for obvious
- 23:17reasons. But he doesn't miss out.
- 23:20So that leaves a straight shootout between Johnny and
- 23:23Stan. When we started thinking about
- 23:26this, I was picking Stan, but now I'm picking Johnny.
- 23:29And you want me to say why? Or do you want to?
- 23:32Yeah, yeah, you watch. You watch the role.
- 23:35Right. So I check what you're saying
- 23:37about wickets and eras and everything else, but to me
- 23:39that's, it's all quantifiable that you can't, you can't really
- 23:43measure how much of a difference that makes.
- 23:45When you look at what what Johnny's done this year alone,
- 23:48you know, brought the league amateur batting record, one of
- 23:54these 190 at Middleton, he got a tonne against Rochdale.
- 23:57That's two tonnes he's had this year.
- 23:59Stan didn't get a century in his career.
- 24:01Now I know we talk about different areas and everything
- 24:03else, but Stan played 470 games for our house.
- 24:07He scored 33 fifties. Johnny's got 28 and three
- 24:11hundreds already. And I don't think in the modern
- 24:15era, like Gav said about modern cricket, and now it's changed,
- 24:18Stan might have been been produced into a completely
- 24:21different player than he was. But Stan does not fit into my
- 24:26team from a batting style point of view.
- 24:29Except he was fantastic for the club and all that.
- 24:31But to me he doesn't. He doesn't make it.
- 24:33He's third or out of twos and he misses out.
- 24:36Johnny and Ben are my ultimate partnership.
- 24:37Right, so we've gone from everything going honky Dory with
- 24:41all picking Ben to to the issues that we've got now.
- 24:46Gav, your thoughts on what was said then?
- 24:48Yeah, happy to go down the the way that we're talking about it
- 24:52and you know, the people who we had in would have yet it'd be
- 24:55interesting to see what Benny's team is.
- 24:58I think we could be quite similar again.
- 25:01You know, we all had similar groups of openers dinner.
- 25:04We are through Finchy in, you know, I think, but Finchy is
- 25:08going to still be in my team or he is in my team, but not
- 25:12necessarily up top. I had Nicky in in my in my top,
- 25:17but again, you know, it doesn't quite make the 11.
- 25:20And again, as Joe said, it was a straight shoot out between Stan
- 25:26and Johnny. And I really this was this was
- 25:30one of the few difficult ones. And I was sort of looking at the
- 25:33records. And, you know, again, you're
- 25:35sort of thinking about when, you know, Stan's played at the club
- 25:38throughout and you know, Johnny has been proing and he's been
- 25:40here there and everywhere. But you just look at what
- 25:42Johnny's has done this year. Like Joe's very, very well, you
- 25:46know, just pointed out there, it's difficult to not have him
- 25:49in that team for what he's done. And so I then I thought, well,
- 25:53you know, let's look about different areas and and balance
- 25:56of the team. And and again, you know, I love
- 25:59watching, you know, this, this current team and either go about
- 26:01it and and either play the cricket and I think, well, you
- 26:04know, do we all want shot makers or, you know, would if we had
- 26:07stand up top, you know, not that he's going to anger around or
- 26:11whatever, he can't play, he can't play shots, but would he
- 26:13be the blue that all the top 6 together?
- 26:16So that, you know, I was thinking, is that a plus point
- 26:18for Stan? But the more I thought about it,
- 26:21Johnny Wharton has to be in that team.
- 26:23He just has to be because of the way, like Joe said, the way he
- 26:27plays on what is achieved. And you look back at the two
- 26:30careers together, you know, if Johnny plays, you know, a decent
- 26:35amount of time for Laura actually, like you try to think
- 26:37what what, what he could achieve and what those figures could be.
- 26:41So I think I think Joe reasoned it very well.
- 26:45And that's that one I opened in partnership, Ben and Johnny.
- 26:50OK. Well, good point from from both
- 26:53of you, Joe Martin. When you look at Stan's record,
- 26:57if he'd have played more games, I know he played over 400 games,
- 27:01but if he hadn't been in the police and missed large swathes
- 27:04of the season, he would have been easily a 10,000 runner and
- 27:08you know at that. But his record is great anyway.
- 27:11I don't think you can't I, I, you can't not pick Johnny
- 27:14Whitehead. He is probably the best batter,
- 27:18naturally gifted batter that I've played with and played with
- 27:22Blaze at a slightly different time.
- 27:25But as a clean striker of the ball, his ability to take a game
- 27:29away from any opposition, regardless of their quality, I
- 27:34think he is one of the best batters and and what a character
- 27:39as well. He's been on the podcast a few
- 27:41few times and I've and he's been one of my best friends since I
- 27:44was 10 and he's and he's not been any different.
- 27:48But on a pure batting front, his stats are incredible to look at.
- 27:52I think actually, and I and I actually think the fact that
- 27:55he's gone proing and been successful there and come back
- 27:59possibly adds weight to that. OK.
- 28:02I mean, it's really good food for thought.
- 28:04I'm, you know, mulling it all over for like as my my puts on
- 28:09it. Gary, what's your thoughts?
- 28:11I know you've possibly missed a little bit of what other people
- 28:14said, but summarising it is that we can't leave Johnny Whited out
- 28:18because of his volume of runs and, and the talents he's got.
- 28:22And it looks like Stan certainly for the other three would be the
- 28:25one that missed out. What's your view?
- 28:28Yeah, you can make arguments from all.
- 28:30Like I said, the opening spots I think will be the most
- 28:34competitive slots that we that we discussed really number of
- 28:39quality players and yeah, OK, your best batters are usually
- 28:42top of the order. It stands to reason in amateur
- 28:45cricket in the top 3 or 4. The only reason, the only reason
- 28:51I'd like put Steve G4 at the beginning was he only played 8
- 28:55odd games and he underscored 2000.
- 28:57But he brought the league batting, he broke, he broke our
- 28:59batting record in that time in an era when, you know, the
- 29:03tracks were, were uncovered, weren't, weren't taking a
- 29:08majorly strong side. So, you know, we, we, we were
- 29:12often chasing lot, chasing plenty or, or wickets falling
- 29:15around and sort sort of thing. I just think it's that age-old
- 29:19question. What would a player from a
- 29:21different area be like in now you have that displaying
- 29:24football and everything else and I and I just think from from
- 29:27that point of view sets brick controversial, slightly
- 29:29controversial. Yeah.
- 29:31Could you leave Johnny out? In reality, you probably
- 29:34wouldn't, but I'm just thinking like for right balance to the
- 29:37side. The guy also bowled tightly.
- 29:39He he in those 80 odd games, he played nearly 50 wickets.
- 29:44So, you know, he was no mug with the ball and and it just gives
- 29:47that that other bit of balance there as well.
- 29:51So I can't say don't pick Johnny, but I just didn't have
- 29:54him in the final knockings in my in my side.
- 29:58OK, gals, thanks. Thanks very much.
- 30:01And you're looking again at, you know, Adam's done a great job
- 30:04with these stats and I will keep dishing him out so people, you
- 30:07know, they can go in and have a look for the self.
- 30:09But you're right, what you said there, Gary, I mean, Steve G
- 30:12played those eight job games. He's averaging 26 1/2, you know,
- 30:16and Stan was down to 18. Like I said, Phil was 15, Nicky
- 30:2019, you know, Vishal 32, but Johnny Whiteheads up there with
- 30:2520, nearly 28. Yeah, yeah.
- 30:28If we, if we're going down into picking who scored the most runs
- 30:31and who, you know, who's most attractive to watch and that
- 30:33might be a criteria for somebody and there's nothing wrong with
- 30:36that because you everyone wants to see probably the most
- 30:38attractive cricket, then we'd probably pick a different side.
- 30:41But that just wasn't my approach in this case to my friend.
- 30:44Yeah, OK. I've got to say that I in my
- 30:48team was Stan, you know, and my rationale for that was it was it
- 30:55was extremely committed, work very hard, was a real talent.
- 30:58You know, early in his career, I didn't see much of him then, but
- 31:01he could, you know, really good attacking type of player.
- 31:07And, you know, and the fact that he's been there all the time and
- 31:09I know this is really cloudy in my judgement and I understand
- 31:12that and maybe I'm being too biassed, you know, that way.
- 31:16And I have no problem players, you know, leaving and they going
- 31:19proing, you know. But I do like that commitment
- 31:21side and the one that would, you know, if you're in a bunker and
- 31:25who sat stood around you, I think I knew what next to me and
- 31:29it would probably be stamp Johnny would be he'd be probably
- 31:33trying to chase some pigeons around or something or do
- 31:37something daft. And so I think the best way we
- 31:40can, you know, and then I'm thinking we can't squeeze
- 31:43standing anywhere else. You know, that's we have to be
- 31:45realistic. You know, he's an opener is is
- 31:48nothing. But could we squeeze Ben or
- 31:52Johnny in at 3:00 and 4:00? So Stan gets in there.
- 31:55So what we will do for the time being is leave that the second
- 31:59opening spot open. So Benzin, the number 2 will be
- 32:02left open and it's it's been trimmed down to Johnny White,
- 32:07said Steve G and and Stamp. And we can come back to that
- 32:11once we've looked at the next maybe 3 or 4 batters.
- 32:17So I will go on for my options for 3-4 and five, you know, got
- 32:22to be genuine batters. So my first one who's got to be
- 32:27batting at 3 or 4, depending on the line of what we do is Bless.
- 32:31I'll quickly go around the room. Is anyone going to disagree that
- 32:35Bless shouldn't be in in that 3-4 or five?
- 32:39Ahead of it #3. OK.
- 32:42OK. You you're happy with that?
- 32:45I'm sure you are. Absolutely.
- 32:46Yeah, yeah, no issues whatsoever.
- 32:49He's got as, as we were just talking about 50s and hundreds
- 32:51today. He's got more than them three
- 32:53put together in both categories. Yeah.
- 32:56And then bad tracks that they're playing on, then bad tracks that
- 32:58they're playing on didn't seem to bother him, yeah.
- 33:01But he slogged it then. Do you think we've talked about
- 33:05bleds enough on this podcast? I mean, he's he's lower house,
- 33:09as great as bats, if not player right, And is Korea has gone
- 33:15from the 80s and still playing now and still, you know, still
- 33:19supporting the team and still producing, you know, still
- 33:23contributes and to the team. And I think the quantity of
- 33:27runs, a discord is incredible across lots of different eras.
- 33:31And to still stay relevant as a cricket, I think it's
- 33:34remarkable, especially, especially because, you know, we
- 33:37play at a reasonable level. It's not, you know, like it's
- 33:40not a game that we just happen to play.
- 33:43It means something to people, doesn't it?
- 33:45So to have played with it, I can't believe that I've played
- 33:48with him since 2009. And it's been magnificent to be
- 33:52able to do that and also be chauffeur for the past, I don't
- 33:55know how many years that's been thoroughly enjoyable.
- 33:58Well, you're better off being his chauffeur than him being
- 34:01your chauffeur for that stopping us.
- 34:09Agree with you Joe. And I think it's testimony to
- 34:13the below that we don't even need to discuss the fact that
- 34:16you know, he's in there. Whether it's whether it's it
- 34:19could only be 3 or 4. I can't think down at 5:00.
- 34:22So so blessed is is definitely in as far as other people
- 34:29around, you know, we've got the two that are in the side.
- 34:31We've we've named another three that could be in and I'm going
- 34:35to throw this out there to you in my team in that top five.
- 34:40There's got to be a place for Fincher for me.
- 34:43There's got to be and I but my reasoning behind that is the
- 34:48ability he's got as an all round cricketer, not just the batting
- 34:52or the bowling. The way he thinks about the game
- 34:54he's fielding. You know he's a strange lad.
- 34:56He's a quirk in his own right, the way he plays.
- 34:59We've all played with him, but he is a talent that just will
- 35:03win your games from from nowhere or will always be there to
- 35:07contribute in some way. You know, he's he's bowling
- 35:11cannot be under underestimated and I think if we're not picking
- 35:16him, this is me, my sales pick. If we're not picking him,
- 35:19there's some serious good players if he's not getting in.
- 35:23Agree 300%. Everything that you just said
- 35:27there. I mean, that's why I haven't got
- 35:28him opening. I just threw him up there
- 35:30because, you know, he did open batting for a while for his
- 35:32Inter, but he's I've got him down in my team at 5:00 because
- 35:37he's going to be bowling in my team again for the balance and
- 35:40you know, and the, the, the good quality options we had up top.
- 35:44But it's at 5. I had Blizzard 3, the pro, I've
- 35:47picked up four, and I had Finchy at 5:00.
- 35:51Yes, he has to be in. He has to be in the 10 best
- 35:54amateur players that we've had. He has to be.
- 35:56Yeah, I I do agree with what you're saying to there Gav, But
- 35:59we're, you know, we're obviously singing from the same sheet.
- 36:02Let's see what Gooch thinks, because I know I don't like
- 36:04finching. And I I couldn't have a team
- 36:07without finishing it, that's for sure.
- 36:09But I won't, he's not at 5 in my team.
- 36:12I think we're forgetting someone who could bat at 5 and I've got
- 36:17finishing down at six or seven, probably 7 actually, looking at
- 36:20who I've got at six. But my Fives Francois as an
- 36:22amateur, he's amateur record 4 hours.
- 36:24He qualifies, he qualifies to play as an amateur.
- 36:27He's played enough games as an amateur.
- 36:29He scored a phenomenal amount of runs.
- 36:32I mean, he would forget his bowling.
- 36:34He, he would get in the side as a batsman, as an amateur
- 36:37batsman, and then if you're chucking in his bowling as well,
- 36:40Patrick in a cup final as an amateur bowler.
- 36:43He, he, he definitely makes the side.
- 36:46I know you could, you could argue that him and Finchy will
- 36:49potentially do a similar kind of job.
- 36:51But I've I've got room for him both no question and just on
- 36:55volume of runs. I'd have him at 5 and Finch a
- 36:58bit further down. Oh, you agree with Finchley
- 37:01being in the the? Finch is in, definitely.
- 37:04Yeah, yeah. The top half of the team, Joe
- 37:07Martin, I mean, let's we can talk about Frankie separate.
- 37:11Would Fincher be in your team? Absolutely.
- 37:13OK. So we can discuss batting places
- 37:15once we've got these these players together.
- 37:18Gary Fincher. All day, yeah.
- 37:21Right end off. So Finch is in.
- 37:23He's the third person in, albeit we're not sure where he's going
- 37:27to bat. 5000 runs, 400 wickets for 16.
- 37:31Yeah, yeah, he's a game changer. I won't have him anywhere near
- 37:35captaincy. What was your reason for that,
- 37:40Joe? So thinking the modern era go
- 37:42down as one of the most unsuccessful, unpopular captains
- 37:46we've ever had. Unsuccessful and unpopular.
- 37:49Yeah, yeah, all I've said to his face.
- 37:51So there's no issue there all. Right.
- 37:53Just just give us some examples. Well, I mean, let's look at how
- 37:58it ended. You know, he got banned for
- 38:00falling out with the opposition professional at Burnley and then
- 38:04quit. So so not only do we have to
- 38:08deal with the discipline issue, we had to find another captain
- 38:10in the middle of the season. Brilliant, brilliant, right?
- 38:14So we've established Finch, he's not going to be captain.
- 38:17Let's look at you know, we've got, so we've got at least
- 38:20another two, maybe 3. Couldn't push it to four further
- 38:24the batters because we've got 2 bowlers in there, you know, and
- 38:27Ben can also bowl. Let's talk about Frankie.
- 38:31I think Gav, I'll come to you first.
- 38:32Just talk me through your thoughts around Frankie.
- 38:36Be in your side. If he is, why?
- 38:39And if he's not, why not? Yeah, I thought, yeah, we're
- 38:42always going to be in my team. I actually had Finch at 5:00 and
- 38:45I have Frankie at six. But what I understand what Joe
- 38:48said about weight of runs and I think we're splitting as if one
- 38:51were at five and one were at six.
- 38:53Yeah. I mean, it's a no brainers in
- 38:55that team. Like you say, the battle ball.
- 38:57When if when, if this came to us, Yeah, they were a pro.
- 39:00His bowling were phenomenal ball.
- 39:02Well, like Joe says, there's an amateur, there's a batter.
- 39:04You look at the way to run this course and see how since his
- 39:07bowling has got less and less and less and yeah, just goes
- 39:12bucket loads. But to watch plays all around
- 39:16the wicket, yeah, he's in there. It was in my team.
- 39:21And again, you know, once we've once we've finally got to an 11,
- 39:24it's going to be it's going to be good fun talking about his
- 39:26batting order and where they go and either team play.
- 39:30But yeah, another easy selection for me is in.
- 39:33Good, good. Gary, your thoughts on Frankie?
- 39:37Yeah, I had him in two in Blaze and Fincher coming in, in that
- 39:45in that sort of order only really from why would you not
- 39:49have Blaze with 17,000 on batting as I, you know, if he's
- 39:52not going to open batting at three, it's good shape.
- 39:55You could toss it out. I just think, you know, Francois
- 39:58probably wouldn't. I don't know.
- 40:00You guys played with him. I haven't.
- 40:02You know, I've seen Bleds go through the gears and really,
- 40:06you know, taking innings away at the end.
- 40:10And I just think doing that and batting with what what obviously
- 40:13wouldn't be a weak team, but batting through with Laura, I
- 40:17just think that'd be better. So, yeah, Frank, Frankie in
- 40:21whether you like, say, you bowl him or not, Yeah.
- 40:23Thinking is an amateur job. Job.
- 40:27Perfect point about his about his status.
- 40:29He's right. Yeah, yeah.
- 40:30No, I, I agree with that Gary, but I'll come, I'll come on to
- 40:34that Duche. Anything to add over and above
- 40:36what you mentioned when you were discussing Finch here in in that
- 40:40position? Yeah, he's he's played six full
- 40:44seasons for as an as an amateur as Frankie.
- 40:47Well, I'll say full seasons. There are a couple in there
- 40:48where he where he he only played 14 and 13 games, but in in six
- 40:53seasons is 2018, six hundreds in the last six seasons.
- 40:58There will not be many in the league who can, who can live
- 41:02live with that. No.
- 41:03That's my point, Joe, about him batting, batting longer through
- 41:06the innings. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 41:10Very good player and like say he's bowling as well so I won't
- 41:13have any any problem with that. I so then my view, it's funny
- 41:19really with Frankie when he proved, when he came for that
- 41:21and he proved for three years. It was a bit of a strange call
- 41:25initially when you know, knew him.
- 41:29He came into the side of I'd obviously finished but watching
- 41:32a lot and I had I found him an incredible cricketer, how he
- 41:37could change again. And he was, you know, we say a
- 41:40real intelligent player, a real thinking cricketer.
- 41:44But then you chat to him afterwards.
- 41:46And I'm not sure if he is a real thinking cricketer, but I
- 41:50remember watching him and he would come on, this is when he
- 41:54was a pro. It would come on to both in a
- 41:56really significant part of the game for just two or three
- 41:59overs. And we'll just stop that pro
- 42:02from scoring or, you know, dominate the game, which upset
- 42:06their rhythm, whether it was a partnership or an individual.
- 42:09And it's a change the game. And I really admired him in
- 42:13respect of that from right from back, you know, as a pro and you
- 42:18won the league with him. And then I look at him now, you
- 42:21know, and he's such a character in in the way he plays and he
- 42:25clearly is struggling to bowl now, you know, because of what
- 42:29he's done in his career, you know, maybe an age thing and a
- 42:32fitness thing, you know, so he he hardly ever bowls on the last
- 42:35couple of years. And yet he's completely changed
- 42:38it with his batting now how he dominates games with the bat for
- 42:41the first team in the last couple of years.
- 42:43You know, when we look to in a bit of trouble or even over a
- 42:46period of two or three games, you know, nosing away or
- 42:49somewhere where it's looking difficult and we've we've not
- 42:52played that well, he all of a sudden just grinds out to either
- 42:56a 30 or gets to 30 and 40 and then you can see he's going to
- 42:59get 100 and you know, and for those reasons, I can't leave him
- 43:04out either. So.
- 43:05So that's the the 4th definite that's in.
- 43:08Hold on. Hold on.
- 43:10Oh, I haven't. I haven't picked him as an
- 43:13amateur. I thought you went.
- 43:15I thought I came to you earlier. You know, Joe Martin, go on and
- 43:19be outrageous. I mean, we're talking about the
- 43:21pros lesser, aren't we? But I haven't picked.
- 43:23I've picked him as an amateur. OK.
- 43:25Because this must be so difficult for you, John, must be
- 43:28painful for you actually making a decision and picking players
- 43:32and you want 25 aside, I think normally.
- 43:37I've picked a squad, get ready. Definitely.
- 43:40They'd all be involved, yeah. I've not picked him as an
- 43:44amateur. Well, I think we know what
- 43:46you're saying, Joe. You might as well say.
- 43:48I think he had an incredible impact on the club as a
- 43:53professional. He I think he probably changed
- 43:56the course of it actually. After we won the league in 2005,
- 43:59we didn't win anything until 2011 and he brought a culture to
- 44:05the club over those three years and the years after that.
- 44:08That was a real winning mentality.
- 44:10His impact on making cricketers better certainly did for me and
- 44:17he did that for Paddy as well. The fact that as a pro he won
- 44:22everything that you can win and was an outstanding performer too
- 44:27has meant that he I picked him as my pro.
- 44:30There were other people, there were other professionals that I
- 44:34could include in that, but Francois's just his impact on
- 44:39that team at that point. He was the right man at the
- 44:42right time. And I think, I think it's
- 44:45immeasurable actually. A bit emotional to that, Joe.
- 44:48Francois, I say this to Francois a lot.
- 44:50He's he's genuinely one of the most inspiring people I've ever
- 44:53met. He inspires me now when I go and
- 44:55sit at when I watched, I was at his house on Saturday and I
- 44:58watched Gladiator with him and my brother and and his wife were
- 45:02there as well. But it's just it's a very
- 45:05inspiring chat your. Brother's got married.
- 45:08Francois's wife. All right, Yeah, I know what
- 45:13you're saying. But you know, I feel and maybe
- 45:16us for a baby cheating the system a little bit in, we're
- 45:21trying to get him in and the quality pro.
- 45:23The 100%, but that's alighted within the.
- 45:27Absolutely allowed. I'm not going to.
- 45:29I don't think, I don't think you're cheating.
- 45:30I think it's, I think it's fair. I'm just looking at the pros
- 45:35I've played with and the ones that I've seen because that's
- 45:37only, that's only what I can measure things on.
- 45:40Yeah. OK, so so.
- 45:44Can I just say, Jazz, before you move off that topic, that that
- 45:47view about Francois's pros also backed up by a very well
- 45:51respected judge who I was talking to last weekend, Charles
- 45:55Cotton would also go down that route.
- 45:58Think about all all the pros he's played with and captained.
- 46:01Yeah, he's he's view echoed. But what Joe was saying there
- 46:05about impact and everything else.
- 46:09So it is maybe something that we will leave it.
- 46:13I will just pencil him in because it could be that Joe
- 46:16Martin persuades us for to squeeze another amateur in and
- 46:20leave him as pro at the end of this.
- 46:23I know Gaff's shaking his head thinking not in a million years.
- 46:26Let's just, you know, it's a democratic process this.
- 46:30So let's let's pencil him in and then see who else that we could,
- 46:35we could move around. So I, I personally think we need
- 46:39one more batter at least. So I will just throw it out
- 46:43there, You know, and we're talking now between 456, maybe
- 46:477. I'll just throw some names out
- 46:50there, Charlie Cotton and Hassan Khan Pancakes Tripathi.
- 46:55Obviously we've we've got Frankie in there.
- 46:58You know, wiki keepers. Let's start to get that into our
- 47:01minds as well, because wiki keeper could squeeze in whether
- 47:04that's he get or, or Joe Martin or, you know, Scott it chippy.
- 47:09Let's have a start getting those in our minds.
- 47:12Anyone else's thoughts on that? Higher middle order spots, maybe
- 47:162 spots. Yeah, this was the way I went
- 47:20about it is I I just thought I selected my captain and it were
- 47:26a no brainer for me really. But whilst I've been listening
- 47:28and whilst this has been going on, I've thought perhaps, you
- 47:31know, doing pick 11, we'll be doing pick 11.
- 47:33And then because of the characters that are going to be
- 47:35in that team, a lot of them have captains anyway.
- 47:38Do we then just pick a captain from that?
- 47:40Whereas when I was on my own doing it, I picked a captain
- 47:43because that was one of the facets of of the bloke who I
- 47:47picked. It would be in my 11 and I would
- 47:50have The Who we've named so far in my team.
- 47:55The next person who I've got in our bat at 7 would be Charlie
- 47:58Cotton and it'd be my captain. Because if you know, you can
- 48:02look and think, well, you know, there's, there's been other
- 48:04players might jump at your passers, but you actually look
- 48:07at Charlie's record and you and you look at the runs, you know,
- 48:09you just just shy 6000 runs. You know he's 16.
- 48:12He's 6 in his you know, he's 6 in the list.
- 48:16He's played some huge innings over the years in some massive
- 48:21games. He's he's captained successful
- 48:24teams, captained by example, catching some strong people.
- 48:28You know, watching that team when he worked captain, they'd
- 48:30gone through a brick wall for him.
- 48:32The best field, best amateur field I've ever seen of the
- 48:35absolutely unbelievable and then hell of a player to boot.
- 48:39So that's who I am genuinely at #7.
- 48:43I mean, you know, but I can play as well.
- 48:45But because of all those strings to his ball, he was my captain
- 48:49and he was at #7. OK, Duke, what's your thoughts
- 48:52on that? Was was Charlie and your team?
- 48:55I absolutely hate seeing this but I'm fully we have on this.
- 48:581CC would be my team. Most successful captain the
- 49:05club's ever had. Longevity.
- 49:08Fantastic fielder. Still now at the age of 44, a
- 49:12ridiculous fielder. The cup game at Ramsbottom this
- 49:18year but nobody else in the team maybe the pro accepted would
- 49:22have would have done what he did there.
- 49:24The catch to get rid of their pro that went to the moon and he
- 49:27just right at the business end of the game with a cup semi
- 49:31final at stake. And he just he just pouched it
- 49:33like it was nothing. And then the last ball of the
- 49:36game or the penultimate ball of the game, they need 2 to win and
- 49:40they take two to him and he he throws it right over the stumps
- 49:44for a run out. We win the game.
- 49:46I mean, talk about clutch. He's batting all right.
- 49:50You could look at his average and look at other people who
- 49:53could potentially bat in that spot, like Hassan, who's been
- 49:56mentioned a number of times. Matt Walker, he'd throw him into
- 49:59there. Bosch, Pan cage.
- 50:02There's plenty of people who've probably got slightly better
- 50:04numbers than Charles in the middle order.
- 50:06But as a package, again, I'm struggling to see how you'd
- 50:10leave him out. Captain batsman, Fielder Shui
- 50:14either. Yeah, Joe Martin.
- 50:17I completely agree, I picked him as captain bat at 7 again
- 50:22similar to Ben in those really big games he always shows up.
- 50:25The 2018 cup final when he battered with Mark Cosgrove for
- 50:29a long period of time and got man of the match as the game was
- 50:32outstanding. Unbelievable fielder as
- 50:35everybody said. It reminds me a bit of like
- 50:37action man, like all action and can kind of do anything.
- 50:42Does he have a scar on his G? And he's always in combat.
- 50:47If he can't see him, he yeah, I think he's a definite for me.
- 50:52And I've picked him as captain as well because because we won
- 50:55everything was the cup league title, double, T20, Yeah.
- 50:58Magnificent, Gary. Any views over and above what
- 51:01they've said? Well, I I'll.
- 51:03Throw another name in who was there for slightly different
- 51:07reasons. Again, probably a little bit
- 51:09controversial because he did play many games for equality.
- 51:12Cricketer and the left hand bat. Everyone we've gone for so far
- 51:16is right hand this guy bat and bolded many double 500 wickets.
- 51:20550 sorry 50 wickets, 500 runs in a in a season and played
- 51:25minor counties played for like a second.
- 51:27You know, good pedigree cricketer.
- 51:30You didn't. We'd obviously only saw it for a
- 51:31couple of seasons in three seasons or something at Laurice.
- 51:34So again, sort of loses out on the argument of longevity and an
- 51:39overall contribution. But John Hartley, I'd have, you
- 51:43know, he could hit a big ball. He could, you know, really turn
- 51:47the game in a few overs in that middle order.
- 51:50And that would just be another name that kept coming back to me
- 51:53about just having that balance side like, say, left hand back
- 51:57sharpish bowler. Yeah, they were just another
- 52:00one. I can't add anything to what you
- 52:02guys have said about Charlie. Absolutely not.
- 52:05Yeah, I I agree with, you know, and you could throw Bush into
- 52:09that as as well into that sort of, you know, position within
- 52:14the side. And but you're right, what you
- 52:15say about the left-hander, it's a good option, Gary.
- 52:19And I think, you know, we may be, we move on.
- 52:21You know, we could have a full team of all rounders really.
- 52:25But you know, but so be it. Would anyone?
- 52:28So we've got three votes for Charlie.
- 52:31I've got to say he was in my side.
- 52:33So, Gary, would you leave Charlie in or would you want to
- 52:36wait until we discuss the rest of the batters?
- 52:39Yeah, we're getting fairly low down now, aren't we in the
- 52:42order? So you're talking about specific
- 52:44batters, but I mean, I can't go against Charlie.
- 52:48OK, so that is we've got 5 definites and that doesn't
- 52:52include an opener and Fincher. Sorry, it doesn't include
- 52:55Fincher. So we need another opener if
- 52:57it's not going to be Fincher. So that will be 6 batters.
- 53:02Do we discuss? I think what we'll do because
- 53:04it's rolling on now it's 9:20. I think we discuss wiki keeper
- 53:09and then we try and make a decision on the the extra
- 53:15batter, you know, the extra opener, whether it's, I think
- 53:17it's between Steve G, Stan and Johnny.
- 53:20And if, if we do decide on Steve G or Stan and then we look at
- 53:23Johnny coming in at at 4-5 O 6. So wiki keepers, I'll start on
- 53:30this. You know, we've got the the
- 53:33absolute legend that is Brian Higgin broke a lot of records,
- 53:37played in an era. I know Dutch won't have it.
- 53:40He'll just keep screaming and shouting that it's it's all the
- 53:43same. But he was in a poor side,
- 53:46carried them for a lot. If you listen to, you know what
- 53:49Stan says, I've got a lot of rooms.
- 53:52I've got to say, you know, for my tuppent worst is that I don't
- 53:57think he was as good a wicket keeper as the three others I've
- 54:01got on my list, you know, and that's Joe Martin.
- 54:03I know it's difficult to talk about that Joe whilst you're on
- 54:06here. Chris Scott or Chipper and I
- 54:08wouldn't even put Jack McGregor in that.
- 54:09I think I think he gay, you know, was outstanding at what he
- 54:13did at the time and how he managed it, but technically it
- 54:16just wasn't the the training or the understanding of, you know,
- 54:20certainly with spin balls that we that he would get into my
- 54:25side. So, you know, as a wicketkeeper
- 54:27who battered low down. So I would have to consider
- 54:30consider he get to either go in as a batter early on, but but
- 54:33not wicketkeep. So unfortunately they apologise
- 54:37if you're listening. The best wicketkeeper I've seen
- 54:41or played with, and this is around his, you know, his
- 54:44technical ability, you know, and his management to the game with
- 54:47Chris Scott. He was just, you know, the way
- 54:50he could pick the ball up, his attitude and he had this aura
- 54:54about him, you know, where he was always in the game.
- 54:57You know, he used to be gutted. He used to try.
- 54:59I don't know if anyone's aware of this.
- 55:01He used to tell me, I think I've told Joe Martin that at the
- 55:04start of the game he would be he would try to go through every
- 55:08game and not miss field any ball, whether it's been thrown
- 55:11in by a fielder, whether he's, you know, he's taking the ball
- 55:15from the bowler or anything. And he'd get really crossed
- 55:18himself every time he miss fielded one or but he didn't
- 55:21catch it correctly correctly. But his batting wasn't up to it
- 55:25when he came in. So I've got rid of Scott Chippy
- 55:29was outstanding the way he was, you know, way he played when
- 55:33when Corrie was in the team, worked hard, stream the
- 55:38proficient, really good clean pair of ham that you know, would
- 55:42always seem to stick in there. But again, he's batting just
- 55:44wasn't up to it much. So I would go for Joe Martin in
- 55:48my side gaff. What's your thoughts?
- 55:52Yeah, I hear what you say about the, the names that you've and I
- 55:57think probably all, all fathers have probably got, you know, the
- 55:59same names really. And you know, they're covered.
- 56:02The teams, sorry, the keepers that we played with, with
- 56:06regards to Iggy. I didn't play with Iggy
- 56:08obviously when they were younger, but it still kept
- 56:11helping us out and what have you, you know, the start of my
- 56:13career. So I played with Iggy Chippy.
- 56:16I agree with what you were saying.
- 56:17Never played with Scotty, unfortunately I've never.
- 56:21I've only played with Joe after the start.
- 56:23But I've watched a lot of Joe and obviously, you know, I
- 56:27watched Jack McGregor. Now I hear what you say about
- 56:31Iggy and you know, perhaps being stood up there were others
- 56:36better than him. And I would agree again with
- 56:39what you said. But again, I just always refer
- 56:42back to what I've said about other players when I was looking
- 56:44at my team and because of his batting, I did pick again.
- 56:49Sorry Joe, but I I did pick again because I had Iggy at 8:00
- 56:56because the only I would I was only picking 1 spinner in my
- 56:59team. Therefore, I don't think
- 57:01standing up would have been a massive issue, if I'm being
- 57:04honest. So I had him at 8 to not that I
- 57:07don't think that battle line up needs lengthy, but again, just
- 57:10to add a bit of a bit of someone coming in to take to you know
- 57:14who, who would score those runs. I hear what you say and I agree
- 57:18with what you were saying about how you brought the other the
- 57:20others down chippy, etcetera and and definitely draw.
- 57:24But I would go for it because I'm only picking, I was only
- 57:28picking one spinning in my team and just his ability with the
- 57:32bat and obviously a decent wicketkeeper in any event, so I
- 57:37picked again. OK, OK, wicketkeeper.
- 57:42Yeah, same names to the chase. Sorry Joe, I went Scottie purely
- 57:49not seen anybody play cricket like I mean you, you just knew
- 57:54like say everything you carried about him, you you knew he was
- 57:56professional standard. He was, he was just about and
- 57:59you talk about standing up only picking 1 spinner you have he
- 58:03just stood up to we won't pick a bowler today who he couldn't
- 58:06stand up to seriously. And he'd have got an extra 1015
- 58:11wickets a season even if he worked stumpings or caught me
- 58:14out or whatever, by the fact that he was just there with the
- 58:17stifled runs. I saw him do it.
- 58:19He was. He was amazing.
- 58:21Yeah, Jazz, you're right. The one weakness was his
- 58:24batting, albeit again. And throw it in there, just
- 58:26another left-hander. But yeah, you know, he's
- 58:29averaging sort of single figures.
- 58:30So he's not going to sort of add anything in like the top 98 to
- 58:349:00, is it? But but for a pure, wicked,
- 58:37wicked keeping, purist sort of view on that, I won't be Scotty.
- 58:42OK, Gary, thank you. This is going to be an
- 58:44interesting debate then dude. Only the one I struggle with the
- 58:49most. And again, same names.
- 58:53I loved watching McGregor keep, I thought stood up to the likes
- 58:57of Finchy and Matt all back then and probably even Johnny Russell
- 59:02at various stages of games. He was brilliant to watch.
- 59:07Probably the best out of that wicketkeeper that I played with.
- 59:11I only played with Scotty a very, very few times when I
- 59:13first got into the 2nd 11 and I can't remember of what I've
- 59:16obviously had lots, of, lots of people talk about him.
- 59:20Chippy wonderful character to having back in and around the
- 59:24place recently again. Excellent wiki keeper Joe Martin
- 59:28watched him stand up to draw plenty of times in tight games.
- 59:33But I went for a year as well and what's what swung it for he
- 59:37give for me was if you look at if we're batting this wiki
- 59:40keeper at #8 all respect to Joe, what what's what's Joe's role
- 59:44going to be batting at #8 in that in that side.
- 59:48He probably doesn't suit his style of play at all to bat at
- 59:52#8 whereas Higi would probably slot right into that #8 spot
- 59:58perfectly. So yeah, I get I take what
- 1:00:01you're saying about standing open.
- 1:00:03And if I were picking a pure, just a glove man would probably
- 1:00:06be Jack Butt. If we're picking someone to come
- 1:00:09in at #8 in that side, I'm going for Brian.
- 1:00:12OK, so we've got two votes for Brian Higgin, one vote for Chris
- 1:00:17Scott, and one vote for Joe Martin.
- 1:00:20I know it's very difficult. Joe Martin, just give us your
- 1:00:24views as a wiki keeper as to who you would pick and why.
- 1:00:30There were two. There were only two names
- 1:00:32because one. I only actually saw one wiki
- 1:00:35keeper, well one that I can actually remember wiki keeping,
- 1:00:40and the other one was on quantity, so it was between Higi
- 1:00:45and Jack McGregor. Jack McGregor is by far and away
- 1:00:49the best wicket keeper I've seen as an actual wicket keeper.
- 1:00:52Unbelievable, by far and away the best.
- 1:00:55And Iggy for the kind of weight of weight of runs.
- 1:00:59And you know, he holds the record, the club record for the
- 1:01:03the most number of victims based, I mean, based on my team
- 1:01:08actually picked Jack because I don't think I didn't think I
- 1:01:11needed a batter for the team that I picked because I picked a
- 1:01:14different, I picked another batter who also bowled.
- 1:01:18So I thought if I got a wiki keeper that can make the
- 1:01:22difference, if he can stand up to anything then that would that
- 1:01:26would be desirable. So I picked.
- 1:01:28I picked. OK, so we're real loggerheads
- 1:01:31there. We've got four different
- 1:01:34wicketkeepers and we've got a vault.
- 1:01:36You know, there's 2 voting for Higa and then one, one of us for
- 1:01:41the other three. I've, you know, this is awkward
- 1:01:46because he's sat here, but I don't care.
- 1:01:48He's I don't think you can. For what job?
- 1:01:51I'm just kind of persuade one of you to move across and I know
- 1:01:54you won't do it, Joe Martin. But I just think for what Joe
- 1:01:57brings, you know, for commitment, for longevity, for
- 1:02:02games, you know, play the, the, the reliability and also the
- 1:02:06batting. Could I not, you know, Gav or or
- 1:02:09Gary or Duke, could I not try and justify that?
- 1:02:12We've got to get him in there. If we need someone to go out
- 1:02:15there and open batting and bat for 30 overs and get 40, then
- 1:02:21we've we've got him and kind of persuade either of you to
- 1:02:24reconsider. I think, I think for me, I think
- 1:02:28Joe may have, you know, a valid point.
- 1:02:30And again, when you're picking your sides, you know, I mean,
- 1:02:33it's frustrated to me over the years that, you know, Joe's
- 1:02:35always at #11 and he's got, he's got 100 for God's sake, the boy
- 1:02:39you can play. But I thought Joe, what Joe said
- 1:02:41was right about with that top, with that top six or seven, you
- 1:02:46know, we're going to want someone to come in at 8 and you
- 1:02:49know, jaw, even even in form is not going to come in and start
- 1:02:52with bang, bang, bang, bang and starting start teeing off wicket
- 1:02:56keeping. I absolutely agree.
- 1:02:58You know, at times, you know, it'll take catches and the stuff
- 1:03:02that make you just stand up and clap, you know, absolutely
- 1:03:05brilliant. Love the boy to pieces like we
- 1:03:07do. We all chippy and Jack and
- 1:03:09people like that. You can only pick 1.
- 1:03:11And I think purely based on balance of team, that's all mine
- 1:03:14is on balance of team. That's that's how I made my
- 1:03:18vote. That's that's who I picked.
- 1:03:21I've I've changed my vote to Higgy.
- 1:03:23Let's. Brought that on.
- 1:03:29I think it'd be, it would be quite enjoyable to watch.
- 1:03:32I think it would be, I think and and you know, he's a, he's a,
- 1:03:35he's a record holder. He should be in this team,
- 1:03:38definitely. He's only a record holder
- 1:03:40because you're still playing. Well, we can address this at the
- 1:03:4360 year 1. Can you be persuaded, Gary, to
- 1:03:47move at all? I'm not.
- 1:03:48I'm not yet. I'm not.
- 1:03:50Yeah, I'm, I'm. I just think, you know, this is,
- 1:03:53this is going to sound really horrible.
- 1:03:55I just think there is, there's such a difference in the ability
- 1:03:59of some of those wicketkeepers stood up and stood back and it's
- 1:04:03a weakness for the side. Well.
- 1:04:05It's valid. You can't, you can't convince me
- 1:04:08yet until we've discussed the bowlers because the the three or
- 1:04:11four bowlers who I've got in my side.
- 1:04:15I just think a night keeper. And if it's not Scott and you
- 1:04:19think, you know, Jackie's is a better bet or had a better
- 1:04:23batting, better quality batter, then then that's that's where
- 1:04:27I'd be going at the moment. Based on what I think I'm going
- 1:04:31to add to in terms of my bowling.
- 1:04:32If the bowlers are different, then fine.
- 1:04:34I think we've got we've got a stellar batting line up without.
- 1:04:36I think it's got a point because if.
- 1:04:40We're going to need someone to pick Corey's wrong and.
- 1:04:43We could go for chipper. Well, we'd have to go for
- 1:04:46Chippy, won't we? Because we all know that story,
- 1:04:48don't we? When Chippy and it is, it is
- 1:04:51something to discuss. That's why we can't, we can't
- 1:04:54finalise that. We're cheaper now because you
- 1:04:57know, you're talking about the rooms that Brian got and the
- 1:05:01ability this, you know, it's not in question, but we're talking
- 1:05:04about the make up of the side. Do we need it?
- 1:05:06When you look at the quality that's already there, do we not
- 1:05:09just need an outer now? All right, good wicket keeper.
- 1:05:13But that's the that's but that's that's the age-old question.
- 1:05:16And that question will be asked if people picking teams forever
- 1:05:19because they talk about it in England, don't they?
- 1:05:21They talk. Should you pick, should you pick
- 1:05:23the best wicket keeper or should you pick someone who, who is
- 1:05:27more than adequate, who can, who can then perhaps do a job at 8
- 1:05:30or whatever? It's a very, I thought Gary was
- 1:05:33right, You know, let's talk about the bowling attack because
- 1:05:35that might, but I think it's an impossible question too.
- 1:05:38You're never, you're never going to call me a definitive answer,
- 1:05:40right? Because.
- 1:05:42We are talking about, we are talking about a bloke who's got
- 1:05:45500 victims. It's not like we're not saying
- 1:05:49we're either picking Jack or Frank, for example.
- 1:05:54And that's no disrespect to Frank or Charlie or Nicki.
- 1:05:58You know, we're not talking about part time wicket keepers
- 1:06:01who come back. We're talking about a guy who's
- 1:06:03got 500 victims. So I don't know.
- 1:06:06I won't have an issue picking as a wicket keeper in that in that
- 1:06:11side just purely from a keeping point of view.
- 1:06:14And I think what extra that he brings with the with the bat and
- 1:06:17the style and everything, I'd, I'd like to see him in there,
- 1:06:20but we'll see. OK, right.
- 1:06:22We'll see. Do we want each 25 to 10?
- 1:06:25We would cut it there. Or do we do one more?
- 1:06:28Yeah, I think cut it now and then we'll do the bowlers
- 1:06:30perhaps in a different section next week.
- 1:06:32Yeah, it's just the bowlers and the pro and the one all rounder.
- 1:06:36But I think the all rounders to the into that lower middle order
- 1:06:40automatically on the you know, I was thinking the all rounders
- 1:06:43were going to be Johnny Hartley Bush and it would, you know,
- 1:06:47genuine and Fincher. But I think we're getting those
- 1:06:50sorts of people in with with Frankie.
- 1:06:52So so let's leave it there. So we're, you know, we've.
- 1:06:55Just been through Jesse. We've got then.
- 1:06:57So the definites of Ben, Bless, Fincher and Charlie, they're all
- 1:07:02definites. As amateurs we've all agreed
- 1:07:05that Frankie will be in but I think we're waiting on the make
- 1:07:08up of the side as to whether he's going to be in as amateur
- 1:07:12or pro wicket keepers. We, we've unfortunately and I
- 1:07:16can't handle yet in this, but we've, we could only break it
- 1:07:21down to three at the moment. But again, the make up of the
- 1:07:24side maybe could could dictate how we manage that going
- 1:07:29forward. Thank you, Lisa.
- 1:07:32He's not a definite Lisa. When When are we picking manage
- 1:07:35and scorer? Oh good shout guy.
- 1:07:37Team Manage. I have food tech Pete.
- 1:07:41Right. Put Norman Dale down.
- 1:07:42Yes. Are you all right with that?
- 1:07:44The scorer. Yeah.
- 1:07:46Yeah, as long as he brings his bet, he's felt Tips.
- 1:07:49You won't really make a time again, will you?
- 1:07:51If you think they felt tips, I will, I will.
- 1:07:54So anything else that we need to to discuss?
- 1:07:58I think we we're recording again next Monday and we'll try and
- 1:08:01finish it. Then we'll get it to a stage
- 1:08:03where we've only got half an half an hour left.
- 1:08:07And if we can do it live, that would be great.
- 1:08:09I don't get, I guess you're not up north in the over Christmas
- 1:08:12period Gas. It's not.
- 1:08:14Decided, yet could be not decided.
- 1:08:16OK, well if you are then then that could work out a treat.
- 1:08:20So we'll just quickly run range. It's been really enjoyable that
- 1:08:23talking about it and looking at the figures that we've had, you
- 1:08:27know, going through the figures clearly do think it's exactly
- 1:08:30the same plane now as it was in the don't.
- 1:08:33Put words in my mouth. I never said exactly the same.
- 1:08:35What I said was the difference is in quantifiable.
- 1:08:38So. So we'll leave that for for
- 1:08:41debate, maybe give us some comments the listeners through
- 1:08:45the the website or on on Twitter gap anything before we wrap it
- 1:08:49up. No, no, I thought that we were
- 1:08:51thought that. I mean we're always going to be
- 1:08:53good, weren't it? But I enjoyed that talking about
- 1:08:56the same players, I think there was some definites that were
- 1:08:59going to be in Word there. Let's be honest about it.
- 1:09:01But not really looking forward to next week, mate.
- 1:09:04Yeah, enjoyed it. Brilliant.
- 1:09:05Thanks, Gav. Gavs anything before we just
- 1:09:08wrap up? No good to be back on with you
- 1:09:10boys. Good, good lad, Good lad, Duch.
- 1:09:13Not from me, Jess. Well, thank you very much for
- 1:09:16for dialling in. And finally, Joe Martin,
- 1:09:18anything yourself? I can't believe you've not
- 1:09:20picked me. No, I'm only joking.
- 1:09:26I know you did, Jess. Yeah, well, you'll be on my
- 1:09:30Christmas card list. Don't.
- 1:09:32Lie. Thanks on your way out, Joe.
- 1:09:35No, I'm only joking. No, Very enjoyable and we're
- 1:09:38going to have an excellent team by the end of it.
- 1:09:40Brilliant. Thanks very much.
- 1:09:42I can see the title of this podcast.
- 1:09:44I can't believe you didn't pick me.
- 1:09:45Bye everyone. Thanks very much for listening.
- 1:09:49This this is likely to come out before the the second part,
- 1:09:53which would make it, I think really, really good and wet
- 1:09:57people's whistles for the the bowling end of it.
- 1:10:00So thanks everyone for listening and we'll catch up very soon.
- 1:10:24Gordon Gordon, send more house to save the house.