Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / How Practice Develops
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org, that's www.a.
- 0:12Me TT a gr, oup dot-org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:20It is November. 17th 2022, its 7:35 p.m.
- 0:25Pacific time. This is, I love you.
- 0:27Keep going. And I thought that I would talk
- 0:30about how practice really develops.
- 0:35Its been in, one of the things that has been interesting to me
- 0:38recently, we start our practice in the beginning, depending on
- 0:47where you go. Go and who you ask?
- 0:50They offer particularly in meditation, the series of
- 0:54different strategies that you might use.
- 0:59And I think that really in a particularly in the way that in
- 1:04the west, we've secularized, everything it's hard to trace
- 1:09back. What the origins of the practice
- 1:11are that are being offered, particularly if it's completely
- 1:15in secular terms and there's no Ongoing reference to the source
- 1:20material where it came from. When I came to LA in 92 and
- 1:28started to practice of apassionata was in the tech not
- 1:32Han school and it started with a basic breath counting
- 1:36concentration practice, which I still teach quite a bit of the
- 1:41idea, then is to develop a level of concentration, which is
- 1:47called access concentration, which isn't jhana but it's a
- 1:52Json to John. Practice and also inside
- 1:55practice jhana is a word that means High concentration States.
- 2:03depending on the lineage of course in Tera vaada John and
- 2:06practice is something that's praiseworthy and encouraged but
- 2:11in tibetan practice for insensitive it's it's generally
- 2:16referred to as a dead end and not worth the time to practice
- 2:20once you have access concentration, that sufficient
- 2:23and you should then go into a path, there's five main
- 2:30traditions in Tibet Practice. In each of them have a path.
- 2:35that you would follow in the The tech not Han group that I was
- 2:44originally learning from. There wasn't a particular model
- 2:49or path that they were teaching. It was really the relationship
- 2:56to the teacher and the teacher of understanding that the
- 3:01descriptions of the practice that you gave and then
- 3:03recommending The Next Step. So that's about 30 years ago and
- 3:16I was not particularly trusting person 30 years ago, it would be
- 3:22fair to say that, my app, a capacity for epistemic trust was
- 3:27completely shattered. So, epistemic trust means that
- 3:32you trust that the person is telling you the truth and you
- 3:36trust that the Said that they're telling you what they're telling
- 3:39you is because it's meant to be helpful to you and in the
- 3:44childhood experiences that I had neither one of those things were
- 3:49true very often and so children rely on their Caregivers for
- 3:56survival and they really except in a kind of blind way, whatever
- 4:00is being offered to them. Epistemic Trust, Is this idea in
- 4:09the child parent relationship? Where the you think that the
- 4:12that your you have good parents and that their interest is
- 4:15actually in your development and you doing well, when you hit
- 4:20adolescence or puberty really there's a dramatic change in the
- 4:24brain where the the child's brain which is just this
- 4:28collection of unconnected axion's.
- 4:32That just can connect really quickly and too.
- 4:35Any information coming into, you can really soft pup,
- 4:39informations that it's coming in is radically prune back.
- 4:43So all of the all of the axons that are not connected are
- 4:46pruned back to the barest, scaffolding of connected things,
- 4:50which gives you a huge cognitive boost.
- 4:54A huge capacity, a greater capacity to think And it's at
- 4:59that time that you can then reflect on the childhood
- 5:02conditions that you had and evaluate whether or not you
- 5:07think that you were told the truth and you can evaluate.
- 5:10Whether you think that the reason what was said to you was
- 5:13meant to be in your interest or was actually in the service of
- 5:17your caregivers interest. If you make the decision that
- 5:22you were told the truth and that it was in your interest, then
- 5:26you can shift out of that parental, or authoritarian, or
- 5:33authoritative, or permissive roll.
- 5:36Those of the main ones into a kind of Mentor coach role with
- 5:42your caregivers. Who are they?
- 5:43They actually help you navigate through adolescence.
- 5:47They help you navigate through youth until you couldn't. find
- 5:51the direction that you're going in and if that doesn't happen,
- 5:57Then the epistemic trust Chatters and you have a hard
- 6:01time, believing? What?
- 6:02People tell you and you have a hard time trusting the
- 6:06motivation for why they're telling you what you're being
- 6:10told. Until I found coming out of my
- 6:14own childhood conditioning that I really didn't trust anybody
- 6:20and certainly not their motivations.
- 6:25I had a kind of wait and see attitude about what people said
- 6:29to me, Christian, I guess you kind of just answered it, but I
- 6:37was, I was curious how you actually learn new things if you
- 6:43had such a sort of basic distrust for like the words of
- 6:46others. Like, it makes me think of sort
- 6:48of, not, not to accuse you, but like, it makes me kind of think
- 6:51of like, people that are into like conspiracy theories. will
- 6:56not take information from certain sources, but they will
- 6:59readily take information from other sources in a way that
- 7:04maybe there is a pattern to it. I don't know.
- 7:08Sure cues. Well, I'm trying to think back
- 7:16to like, I probably had some issues with epistemic trust that
- 7:20I'm trying to imagine what my process for learning stuff was
- 7:24in that kind of, that kind of mindset.
- 7:31It's an interesting thing about conspiracy and conspiracy
- 7:34theories. I think that and actually two
- 7:44connecting connecting it to a Breaking of epistemic.
- 7:48Trust is probably a good idea. You don't trust authority to
- 7:52tell you the truth and if it's really broken, you suspect, the
- 7:57the reason that they're telling you what they're telling you.
- 8:05It. One of the great things about
- 8:08propaganda and to understand the nature of propaganda is that you
- 8:12always take something that's true and easily provable and
- 8:16then you tie it to something that's not true.
- 8:19But because the true aspect is easy to prove as true you can
- 8:27easily then begin to believe the thing that isn't true because
- 8:31it's associated with something that's true to nature of
- 8:36propaganda and people are That it use it in interpersonal
- 8:41relationships. We tend to call it gaslighting.
- 8:43I don't know if, you know, the terms that you do try to adjust,
- 8:48somebody's point of view, run line with what you want from
- 8:52them by that process of offering up something that's true.
- 8:56And then just slipping in right behind it.
- 8:59Something that isn't true. When you're unable to reflect on
- 9:06your, on your own situation and take responsibility for the
- 9:14choices that you made, it's very easy to begin a process of
- 9:19externalizing, the responsibility each other,
- 9:21someone else. It's called projective
- 9:24identification in Western psychology.
- 9:27You the conflict that you have internally, that you can't cope
- 9:31with you project out onto other people as an explanation and it
- 9:38relieves the, the the difficulty momentarily, which is actually
- 9:46what we're all going for. In those situations, the
- 9:50momentary relief is worth it. Even if there's a long-term
- 9:57negative consequence to it, it's actually the whole addiction
- 10:03process as well. The level of pain is too much
- 10:06you need relief from the pain. You find something, either
- 10:11process or substance that relieves the pain.
- 10:17And even though you don't deal with the underlying source of
- 10:19the pain in that moment, you have relief and that at it seems
- 10:24worth it because you kick the consequences down the road and
- 10:28don't consider them as part of the equation where somebody
- 10:31who's not at that. Level of pain, can more easily
- 10:39do the sums and see that those kinds of decisions actually have
- 10:43consequences that make the current situation worse going
- 10:49forward. And so are likely to lead to
- 10:51more pain. And then turn toward the
- 10:55experience of the present moment and attempt to address the
- 11:00issues that are happening in the present moment.
- 11:04The further away from dealing with the conditions of the
- 11:09present moment, you get the more fantastic.
- 11:15The explanations can get. On the other hand.
- 11:28Sometimes fantastic, explanations are not so far off
- 11:33which is the the problem of the true thing being married to the
- 11:37thing that isn't true. But you see that the value of
- 11:42ischemic trust, do you have in your life and are you are in
- 11:46relationship to people who you believe what they're saying to
- 11:50you? Or do you have some doubt about
- 11:53what they're saying to you? When you're forming that inner
- 11:57circle, people that are closest to you, you really want them to
- 12:02be people that you can have epistemic trust with that you
- 12:06can believe without having to worry about it.
- 12:10And usually, the way that that's demonstrated is they say
- 12:13something and they do that and it turns out to be true time and
- 12:21time and time again, so that you can begin to rely on them.
- 12:27And then whose interest is it that they're talking to about so
- 12:33something to pay attention to Most of the time, I find the
- 12:39great conspiracies in our culture are not hidden at all
- 12:43because they don't need to hide them.
- 12:46They just do them. And the truth of the
- 12:51powerlessness of that is what the rest of us find.
- 12:56So painful. and one of the reasons why we have a harder
- 13:01time looking at it, I as an example housing.
- 13:12It costs, four or five times, the amount of money to keep
- 13:15people homeless on the street than it does to house them.
- 13:22Wouldn't you think that in a society that keeps saying that
- 13:26there's no money to do this would just admit that, it cost
- 13:30four times as much to keep them on the street.
- 13:32And if it was just about the money that we would house them.
- 13:37But what's actually true is that it is about the money and that's
- 13:41a lot of money that can be made on keeping people on the street
- 13:47because that makes sense. Now, you say how can it possibly
- 13:52cost? Much to let people live on the
- 13:54street. We have it in Los Angeles, a
- 14:00list of people who are super users of resources.
- 14:06If you have a medical event that needs to be treated, then they
- 14:12have to send the ambulance. They have to send the fire
- 14:14department in Los Angeles often. It's the fire department that
- 14:18comes for medical service. We also have private ambulances,
- 14:23the police often have to get involved.
- 14:26Then there's the hospital visit that most people on the street
- 14:30don't have insurance. So the hospitals are mandated to
- 14:34provide emergency care whether or not a person can pay for it
- 14:39or not, but if they can't pay for, they build the county, this
- 14:43is all taxpayer money, right? so one of those Advanced could
- 14:49cause 13 or 15 thousand dollars, Not including Aftercare and then
- 15:00if you have two or three events suddenly you're at 45,000 in a
- 15:04month, right? That's a lot of money.
- 15:17So, back to practice. Hopefully a cheerier subject.
- 15:36So one of the things that happens I think early in
- 15:39practice or at least it to me and quite a few people I've
- 15:42talked to is that because the epistemic trust isn't there,
- 15:46it's very hard to form a relationship with a teacher who
- 15:49are you can rely on and actually accept the explanations that
- 15:54they're offering or the direction that they're offering.
- 15:59And so what you have is These initial contacts are brief
- 16:04contact with teachers and then a separation and then a long
- 16:08period of what we called, Dharma orphanhood where they're your
- 16:13student which is essentially an autodidact situation, where
- 16:17you're teaching yourself, how to do it.
- 16:21Without much contactor direction from somebody who's further
- 16:25along in the path certainly since the explosion of online
- 16:32forums. And so, on often, when I get
- 16:38into a Reddit or one of the other ones, it feels like a
- 16:44whole collection of Dharma or orphans giving each other
- 16:49epistemic Libro. Okin advice.
- 16:58And then trying again with the teacher but because, you know,
- 17:04people with broken epistemic trust, create these sort of
- 17:07Hazards for their teachers to get through, you know, like
- 17:10these these obstacle courses for their teachers to get through
- 17:13all of these setups one after another to see whether there
- 17:17they'll fail, you or not so that you can rely on them.
- 17:22And it's a, in some sense when you reflect released when I
- 17:26reflect back on my own. Is to with teachers, it's it's
- 17:31kind of funny how that the tests are so elaborate and how poorly
- 17:37people do a when they don't know they're being tested and to when
- 17:41the tests are really impossible and that that was true, all the
- 17:49way up until I met shinzen. And he he was unfailingly kind,
- 17:53but also unwilling to engage in any of it so that he managed to
- 17:58To somebody that I could learn from him.
- 18:01So, I think that in particular, if here on the end of practice
- 18:05where you've had a lot of suffering, a lot of difficulty
- 18:08and you're coming into practice, it's hard to rely on somebody, a
- 18:15teacher in particular, The and in the beginning, the Tibetan
- 18:20path was not an old possible for me because it's a, it's a guru
- 18:24oriented practice, and you have to really pick a teacher and and
- 18:31conform to their advice for you. But chins and, you know, 30
- 18:39years ago was more maybe 25 years ago when we met was Still
- 18:48the talking about Maha see and hadn't quite formulated.
- 18:51His five ways in the way and Maja see is that has a path
- 18:55which is called the progress of inside it.
- 18:59They published that translation of that called the manual of
- 19:04insight it's over, which is all sort of laid out their shins it.
- 19:07Of course, rejected somewhere, along the way maps, all
- 19:10together. And and so his is Method is
- 19:18again, based on the interaction of the student, with the teacher
- 19:23to be directed forward. I think because of my
- 19:26orientation was, so I need to be able to do this on my own
- 19:32because the likelihood of being failed by the teachers so high
- 19:36that it worth investing. So a really insecure insecurely
- 19:40attached point of view about the nature of relationships.
- 19:47And so the map was very useful to me.
- 19:51But then as you do the practice, as you say, develop access
- 19:55concentration, and then move into the pasta, you begin to see
- 20:02the nature of your conditioning and how it affects the way that
- 20:06you create the reality that you experience.
- 20:09I think that's one of the things that we really want to know.
- 20:15Is. What am I making?
- 20:22I think in the beginning, of course, of practice, my point of
- 20:26view was that I was experiencing things in a fairly realistic way
- 20:31that my understanding of what was happening in the way that
- 20:34the world was was actually not so far off.
- 20:40Not much sense at all that I created in each moment, the
- 20:44experience that I was having in the sense of defining it and and
- 20:51Those definitions creating the meaningfulness of it.
- 20:56So you have the capacity to send something the object that can be
- 20:59sense. When there's contact, a
- 21:01consciousness of that sensing experience arises, which is
- 21:05unattached on fixated, Undifferentiated.
- 21:10It's evaluated unconsciously for Veda now.
- 21:15Or is it Pleasant unpleasant or neutral is often how it's
- 21:23described? I would tend to think of, is it
- 21:25urgent? Do you need to get to it?
- 21:27Now does it not matter whether you get to it?
- 21:31Is there time for something pleasant?
- 21:33That's that's kind of how I think about it, then.
- 21:38Whatever sensing experience that is is compared to the perceptual
- 21:42database. If there's an entry in the
- 21:44perceptual database, that's close enough, that thread of
- 21:48meaning attaches to the present moment, it unfolds into
- 21:52conceptual reality. That is you fixate reality based
- 21:56on the condition meaning that you've Associated, which is
- 22:01about pattern recognition, really recognize the pattern of
- 22:06the present moment. You associate it.
- 22:07It with previous patterns which gives you a leg up because you
- 22:11have the history of what to do and those previous patterns
- 22:15situations, you have a memory of the outcomes of those so that
- 22:19you can pick your response in line with the kind of outcome
- 22:24that you want to have in that situation makes sense.
- 22:32And then you take in the outcome of that moment and it's attached
- 22:36to that thread. So the new outcome is attached
- 22:40to the all the previous outcomes in that thread of understanding.
- 22:46If you come into a novel situation that you don't find an
- 22:50entry in your database that maps onto a closely enough than the
- 22:54imagination kicks in, and begins to assemble a response to it.
- 23:00And then, you take an action and that novel experience, becomes
- 23:05remembered as an outcome in, and you've essentially begun a new
- 23:11thread of conditioning Karmic threatened, the term not making
- 23:19sense. When you begin to practice at a
- 23:28depth where you can see these experiences unfolding Moment by
- 23:34moment and you have enough Clarity, that you can recognize
- 23:40the attach, the attaching of meaning, to the undifferentiated
- 23:47sensing experience and the rolling out of conceptual
- 23:50reality. Then you can begin to understand
- 23:54that you really create conceptual reality in the way
- 23:59that you define in, not in the way that it is.
- 24:03This is very different than westerners have been trained to
- 24:07think about this Aris going back to Aristotle.
- 24:12Who whose opinion was that we take in the experience that's
- 24:19outside of us and create an Insight, an inner working model
- 24:25of what's happening. And that, that model that we
- 24:28take inside and create his largely accurate. and so in the
- 24:34west, it's very common for people to say that they know
- 24:38what's happening because they have the experience of that
- 24:43happening is very different than the eastern and Buddhist view
- 24:49where you take in the data, you form reality and then you
- 24:53Project Reality out and you live in the projection of reality
- 24:57whereas in the west you really think we take in?
- 25:00What's there create? A working model internally and
- 25:04then operate from that accurate representation of what's there?
- 25:10Epicurious who came along a few centuries later modified.
- 25:14It slightly by saying, if you have a strong emotional
- 25:18experience, while something is happening it can distort the
- 25:21perception but it's largely still an accurate perception of
- 25:26what's Happening. When we begin to see through the
- 25:34conditioned responses and we begin to see the limits that
- 25:41conditioning can impose on our capacity to imagine Alternatives
- 25:45and begin to open more directly into the experience of what's
- 25:50happening in the present moment. We also open up the possibility
- 26:00of defining it differently in the moment and changing our
- 26:05response to it. In each moment, what opens up in
- 26:13front of you is all of the possible choices that you could
- 26:17take in the moment? And then as soon as you pick one
- 26:21and soon as you fixate reality, all of the variations, all of
- 26:27the choices except for the one that you pick.
- 26:31Disappear. And then in the next moment, all
- 26:34of the possibilities that are linked to the choice that you
- 26:37just made open up. So in some sense in each moment,
- 26:42as you fixate it into conceptual reality, you then also choose
- 26:50the possibilities of the next moment and then we flow through
- 26:54this series of creations of the present moment in that way.
- 27:06When we begin to abandoned the conditioning that we've had and
- 27:11we begin to imagine Alternatives and may begin to choose
- 27:16differently than we did in the past.
- 27:19It's not that robust of a, of a change in Direction, it's easy
- 27:26to fall back into the samsara, the ruts, the cart wheel ruts
- 27:34that we're used to And it's only in this pushing into the
- 27:41experience of more sensitive and more accurate.
- 27:49Understanding of what's happening and how we Define the
- 27:54experiences that we have that. We can begin to consistently
- 28:00choose something that isn't and so deeply conditioned But it
- 28:08doesn't have much of a sense of resilience as I said, were or
- 28:13reliability in that sense. It's easy to fall out of that,
- 28:18but the more you do it, of course, the breadth of the, of
- 28:21the experience, or the depth of the database increases.
- 28:28So those new threads, which are very short in the beginner get
- 28:34longer, the more you use them and there's there's more
- 28:37vibrancy to them. And so because the body mind is
- 28:43such an economical system, if you pick a new path that
- 28:47actually is a better use of energy in intends to head in
- 28:54that direction. And then, as the database grows
- 28:59about variations of response to different circumstances, it
- 29:04becomes more and more robust. That's really this process of
- 29:07change. If you wanted to describe it in
- 29:15just to neuroanatomy, when you begin a new Direction, a new
- 29:21thought process. It's, it's a it's just a sliver,
- 29:25a hairs with the nervous to nerve tissue that's forming to
- 29:30create that those connections but the more you use it, the
- 29:34more robust it gets the more development, gets the things
- 29:38that you've been using it as a habit or Tree trunk to this tiny
- 29:43little vein of new neural material, but then the more that
- 29:48you use it, the more roast robust it gets.
- 29:51And when it gets robust enough to be competitive to the old
- 29:55habit, and it's more economical to body just naturally shifts
- 30:00into it. And they and you drop the old
- 30:04habit and then eventually, if you don't use it enough, it's
- 30:09actually prune. Back to the point where it isn't
- 30:13an option anymore. So you've some sense permanently
- 30:20changed it in this not disregarding impermanence as the
- 30:26nature of everything that making sense.
- 30:31So then what you find is that you simply are reacting
- 30:35differently than you used to react to the conditions that you
- 30:39face. Even though the self experience
- 30:43is largely the same, this is one of those conundrums that that
- 30:48sense of how, you know, yourself.
- 30:51He is unfazed by the fact that you're completely choosing
- 30:56things that you never would have picked before because the self
- 31:01experience is not actually the thing that's doing the choosing.
- 31:04That's not what's changing, but changing is the perceptual
- 31:09database and when the data there is different and you in that
- 31:14moment of Association and creating the meaning of what
- 31:19this present. It moment experience is happens.
- 31:24The self is still not involved in all of that.
- 31:27It's one new manifested into conceptual reality that then the
- 31:30self is able to reflect on it, but you've already chosen a
- 31:34completely different. So the experience of the self
- 31:37viewing that unfolding of the meaning that you're giving
- 31:42reality is still the same watching sensibility, making
- 31:49sense. So what we're really looking for
- 31:54is not so much that the self experience is different but that
- 31:57you're doing things differently, that's one way of assessing the
- 32:04way that the practice is working.
- 32:08And the more you do things differently, of course, the more
- 32:11robust, the change is until the change is just the new way in
- 32:16which you operate in the world, which the self just simply
- 32:19accept, as this is how it is. Now, without really much
- 32:24reference, the past sense of self.
- 32:28Peter. So George then after, if I'm
- 32:34following you correctly, we're able to see the threads of how
- 32:37these patterns are created and able to respond differently in a
- 32:41given situation and the self is able to kind of see that unfold
- 32:46and he had wind is the non identification come in and what
- 32:49didn't do, you know non-self, when I mean is that, is that the
- 32:54next kind of logical step in this?
- 32:56Seeing a different outcome, or how does that That arise that
- 33:00understanding. Well, I think that When we say
- 33:09that, there's no self, we don't mean that there's no self
- 33:14experience, we mean, that there is no ongoing condition ongoing,
- 33:21continuous constant self experience.
- 33:26What we mean is the self experience arises based on
- 33:31sensory conditions in each moment. and that it comes and
- 33:36goes just like all sensing experience comes and goes You do
- 33:43have a self experience and actually, it's quite useful.
- 33:45As a organizing principle, it's quite useful, in relating, to
- 33:50other people, and relating to the world.
- 33:54And you want to have a brilliant capable sense of self, which
- 33:57doesn't, which sees the nature of the self experience and so
- 34:03does not need to be defended. You don't need to defend your
- 34:07sense of self because it comes and goes.
- 34:11It's not substantial in that way.
- 34:19Years ago, Shenzhen was on the Red Road.
- 34:24Do know the Red Road, some of the indigenous practices, one of
- 34:28which was a sweat lodge. I don't know if you've ever gone
- 34:32into a sweat lodge, but when I, when I was new to the practice
- 34:38and new to shenzhen's world, we would go up to a sweat lodge in
- 34:42Malibu. Which was on the right property
- 34:47grandchild of Frank Lloyd, Wright, his property, that was,
- 34:53it was quite lovely. There was a pond and sort of a
- 34:56half-built Frank Lloyd Wright mansion and then this and nippy
- 35:03sweat lodge. And I remember with such
- 35:07satisfaction going into the sweat lodge, and, and sitting
- 35:12there and just Watching the self, give up after the first
- 35:16few minutes of, the heat just was completely gone.
- 35:23And then as my practice deepened, it became more and
- 35:26more tenacious until there was no amount of heat that they
- 35:30could throw in there. No amount of steam that would
- 35:32get the self experience to collapse.
- 35:35And some paradoxically, the, the deeper my meditation practice
- 35:43became the greater Equanimity with unpleasant circumstances
- 35:47became the more tenacious. My self experience was so
- 35:54paradoxically the greater the suffering, that's extreme
- 35:59conditions of the sweat lodge because the self, you know, held
- 36:04onto it its position at you, may begin to notice that the self
- 36:10experience comes and goes and each time the self experience,
- 36:14Arises it arises based on the conditions of the present
- 36:17moment, not the same self arising each time or it
- 36:23continuously witnessing Christian.
- 36:28And you're differentiating that experience of the self being
- 36:32defeated from just like dissociation.
- 36:37No I don't think it was dissociation as I drop down into
- 36:39a place of just being which you might call it an economist
- 36:47deeply Economist state but without the self.
- 36:51So everything was pretty undifferentiated on fixated.
- 36:56I had been practicing in sweat lodges for years prior to that
- 37:00but it was always this arduous experience.
- 37:04I think there's a Rephrase or it's called we would say I
- 37:11really had to suck dirt in that sweat lodge, which means that
- 37:15you're literally put your face against the Earth and to have
- 37:21the Earth. Cool.
- 37:22The air as you breathe in because it's so hot and that at
- 37:28that time, of course was much younger.
- 37:31And, you know, you look at me now, but there was a certain
- 37:36amount of machismo that we had, when we went into the sweat
- 37:40lodge, where it didn't matter, if we passed out or not, we
- 37:43weren't leaving I don't know if I'd even go into what now, but
- 37:52that's how it is. One of the reasons why
- 38:05meditation is such an effective way to work with this stuff as
- 38:08it operates in the perceptual database, more than it does, in
- 38:13the sense of self, you're not really changing your sense of
- 38:16self so much as seeing the nature of that self experience,
- 38:20which is that it comes and goes and it's based on the conditions
- 38:23of the present moment and that most of the time, the way that
- 38:29you make the Salford World proceed.
- 38:34The self experience arising, you're not operating from the
- 38:37sense of self. You're not making decisions from
- 38:39the sense of self. You're just observing what you
- 38:43do from the sense of self. Oh, this is what I'm doing now.
- 38:49This is what I'm doing now and wonder why I'm doing this?
- 38:53I wonder why I decided this is how it was, is sort of easier.
- 38:59Way of holding it. Wait a minute.
- 39:01This doesn't seem right? Let me remake the experience of
- 39:05conceptual reality in this moment.
- 39:07I'm feeling very threatened. I'm feeling very angry.
- 39:11I feeling that I need to defend by the experience of the sense
- 39:15of self. Let me just drop that and
- 39:17reform. The sense of self which then is
- 39:19curious about what the conditions are that would would
- 39:23have led me to form the experience in that way.
- 39:28Christian. Then isn't it a really
- 39:32different? Quality of experience to be
- 39:36watching your sense of self. Like you're separate from it,
- 39:39right then to be sort of inside of it, and not, Not sort of have
- 39:45that remove where you're just you're just in it we live in the
- 39:48forest, right? So right.
- 39:50So the that would be the the statement of identification when
- 39:55you're totally identified with the sense of self you think that
- 39:58it's real and that the way that the world appears to you is real
- 40:03So you're just act from that is that like the loss of
- 40:06mentalizing? Would you think I would say?
- 40:10But when you're not and you see it as just a sensing activity,
- 40:15like any other sensing activity, then there and you can maintain
- 40:19that Curiosity as to why In This Moment you're creating that
- 40:24self-experience, reacting to that World experience.
- 40:31And knowing that you've actually created that and you can
- 40:33recreate it differently if you need to.
- 40:39You're not obligated to the initial pass.
- 40:45The reality that you create, you're not obligated to the
- 40:48initial self experience, that you create they change.
- 40:54Anyway in each moment, if you pay, if you pay attention,
- 40:58everything is arising and passing Nothing is not arising
- 41:02and passing. So why don't we do a little
- 41:15meditation practice? I think that one of the ways to
- 41:23see this is to do the investigating, self-generated
- 41:31emotion technique. A lot of the times in meditation
- 41:41circles, the, your taught meditation techniques and then
- 41:47in conversation with the teacher were according to the map.
- 41:53You develop. The investigation that you're
- 41:59going to do in this particular strategy.
- 42:04What I, what I want you to begin to do is to monitor your thought
- 42:10process. We're looking for when the mind
- 42:15is quiet, there's no thinking going on when the mind is
- 42:19engaged in one-off thoughts, which are usually related to the
- 42:23present moment and when the mind is engaged in a repetitive
- 42:27thoughts. So, if you're ruminating about
- 42:30the past, it's usually some memory that circulating.
- 42:33If you're ruminating about the future, it's either planning or
- 42:39fantasy, something like that. And so what we're doing in this
- 42:45meditation is simply tracking that we're going to start with
- 42:49auditory space track visual space and also track emotion the
- 42:56body. Lucy is saying that you would
- 42:59rather do met to practice, but too bad.
- 43:07We're doing the positive that I we've done meta or weeks.
- 43:13All right. So, how did that go?
- 43:28I found it to be semi more difficult than other noting
- 43:31techniques that I've used in the past.
- 43:35Semi. Yeah, normally the noting that I
- 43:41use is kind of like, going through the three sides of
- 43:45atanas of just like thought feeling sensation, kind of body
- 43:49and then moving into Pleasant like feeling town.
- 43:52And then, mindfulness of mind if there's cry, craving her version
- 43:56around that or whatever is the Discrimination of the
- 43:58distractions coming up. That's how I tend to note as
- 44:03opposed to just only noting if there's something that's
- 44:06distracting, you supposed to consistently noting.
- 44:09If there's rest Yeah, I found that to be, I guess count.
- 44:17It was difficult for me to just continually, no rest, rest.
- 44:20Rest, rest, rest. But you did it anyway.
- 44:26Yes. Good epistemic trust, yes.
- 44:34And did you notice the body? Yes.
- 44:42And were you able to track the emotion of that?
- 44:46Good. There's a part two to this so
- 44:52we'll do that next time. Great.
- 44:55But not on Thanksgiving, which is next Thursday.
- 45:01Happy turkey the week. After happy butternut squash.
- 45:14Christian. I noticed that I can be like I
- 45:21can be totally aware of the theme or the story before I ever
- 45:26hear a single word of it, which I find kind of interesting.
- 45:29Like, I don't Quite know how that works.
- 45:33I was trying to sort of investigate that, but well, if
- 45:36you're really concentrated in auditory space, the cognition of
- 45:41the Clear Talk, usually precedes it.
- 45:43And if you're concentrated enough, you just know the
- 45:46thought without it ever breaking out into Clear Talk.
- 45:52So that that would be good enough.
- 45:59Yeah, I guess that's what it was happening.
- 46:01I was trying to figure out if I was just really not concentrated
- 46:03and not paying attention to the clear talk, or if it's usually
- 46:07the opposite of that. The cognition of the thought
- 46:13arises. And then if you're if you don't
- 46:15pay attention, the Mind speaks it out loud.
- 46:18It's one way to look at it to get your attention.
- 46:23Is sometimes. I wonder sometimes.
- 46:25I wonder like, am I? I would think.
- 46:30That being a musician, would train me to be an auditory
- 46:33thinker, but I sometimes it seems like I'm I'm not.
- 46:37I'm neither an auditory nerve visual thinker like, I'm just
- 46:40not a thinker. I don't know.
- 46:44Somehow is here and I don't know where it comes from, but I don't
- 46:49know if that's just me. Not paying enough attention or
- 46:51what you know, some music people are visual.
- 46:57That is sees you no doubt. My favorite conductor, says he
- 47:02conducts colors. He doesn't conduct sound.
- 47:08But more clarity is needed. So practice this more so you can
- 47:14really see what's happening. All right.
- 47:24So, thank you for your practice, really appreciate it.
- 47:28I have decided that I'm too old to continue doing daily Vlogs
- 47:32and so I'm switching the format of level 12, half days.
- 47:38So we're going to go from 3, Des longs to for half days on the
- 47:45level 1. So the if you haven't done a
- 47:48level one in a while or you haven't done it, we're going to
- 47:51do in In January, I think the next level one in the new
- 47:59format. I'm looking forward to that.
- 48:03We have a level-two starting. I think, in March there's going
- 48:07to be another EU. The last of the of the current
- 48:15level 1 EU is happening on Saturday and then we're going to
- 48:19do another level 1 in EU in April and I'm doing a short
- 48:28retreat in new tracked in June which is in the Netherlands.
- 48:35So far that's taking us I think far enough into the future,
- 48:40really appreciate your practice. I offer the teachings on a Donna
- 48:44basis, that means I offer the offer the teachings freely and
- 48:47then we hope that you'll make a donation to Metta group and help
- 48:51support me. And also the work metal group is
- 48:53doing. There's a link on the website to
- 48:55do that. Any amount is helpful, we really
- 48:58appreciate that. Thank you for coming and we'll
- 49:01see you soon. I hope enjoy your Thanksgiving.
- 49:04So Go back in two weeks. I, I,