Latest / Bloomberg Law / Oil Companies Try To Move Climate Deception Cases
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: Climate deception lawsuits have been brought by states against the
- 0:13Speaker 2: big oil and gas companies across the country, but the
- 0:16Speaker 2: cases are currently locked in legal battles over whether federal
- 0:20Speaker 2: or local judges should hear them. And that was exactly
- 0:24Speaker 2: the question before the DC Federal Appellate Court. Does the
- 0:27Speaker 2: District of Columbia's climate liability lawsuit against Exxon Mobil, BP, Chevron,
- 0:33Speaker 2: and Shell belong in federal court or state court? My
- 0:36Speaker 2: guest is environmental law expert Pat Parento, a professor at
- 0:40Speaker 2: the Vermont Law and Graduate School. Pat tell us a
- 0:43Speaker 2: little about these so called climate deception lawsuits.
- 0:47Speaker 3: Yeah, DC's lawsuit is based on its consumer protection law,
- 0:53Speaker 3: and there are several other cases. Minnesota, Massachusetts, Connecticut have
- 0:57Speaker 3: filed similar cases based on both their state statutes that
- 1:02Speaker 3: protect consumers from deceit or fraud and also common law
- 1:06Speaker 3: claims for the same sort of deception. There's another class
- 1:10Speaker 3: of cases that's actually bigger. There's more of them that
- 1:13Speaker 3: are more classic torque cases. They began as nuisance cases.
- 1:18Speaker 3: They've now sort of morphed into deception and failure to
- 1:23Speaker 3: warn type cases. So, all of these climate liability cases
- 1:27Speaker 3: against the oil companies, some of them have included coal,
- 1:31Speaker 3: some of them have even included plastics manufacturers, but the
- 1:35Speaker 3: bulk of the cases are suing the big oil companies,
- 1:39Speaker 3: the so called carbon majors, and some of them are
- 1:43Speaker 3: seeking compensation sort of cost recovery for the costs of
- 1:48Speaker 3: adapting to what we now see, are you on rushing
- 1:52Speaker 3: impacts of climate change, sea level rise, storm surge, and
- 1:55Speaker 3: so forth. The District of Columbia case is a little different.
- 1:59Speaker 3: It's the making penalties for deception, false advertising, and so forth, greenwashing,
- 2:05Speaker 3: and it's also seeking what's called disgorgement of profits. So
- 2:10Speaker 3: it's seeking to recover. You know, oil companies have been
- 2:13Speaker 3: raking in win fall profits right lately, and they're seeking
- 2:17Speaker 3: to recover some of those profits to be distributed to consumers.
- 2:22Speaker 3: In this case, it would be within the District of
- 2:24Speaker 3: Columbia and the other states would be in those states
- 2:27Speaker 3: as kind of a rebate back to consumers. So fascinating
- 2:30Speaker 3: cases all around.
- 2:32Speaker 2: Yeah, So, the attorney for DC said the claims are
- 2:35Speaker 2: based on the deceptive conduct of the fossil fuel companies,
- 2:39Speaker 2: not on the admissions or production of fossil fuels.
- 2:42Speaker 1: He said, quote, we have no quarrel in this.
- 2:44Speaker 2: Litigation with their emitting greenhouse gases. We don't even have
- 2:48Speaker 2: a quarrel with them marketing their products in the District
- 2:50Speaker 2: of Columbia.
- 2:51Speaker 1: As long as they don't.
- 2:52Speaker 2: Market their products in a deceptive or misleading way, that's
- 2:55Speaker 2: our quarrel in this case.
- 2:58Speaker 1: So what's happening here?
- 2:59Speaker 2: As in other cases against the fossil fuel industry, they're
- 3:03Speaker 2: locked in battles over whether federal or local judges should
- 3:07Speaker 2: ultimately hear the merits of these cases.
- 3:09Speaker 1: Does his argument go to whether it's federal or local?
- 3:13Speaker 3: Yes, it does, And he's right to the extent that
- 3:16Speaker 3: these cases are based strictly in the District of Columbia case.
- 3:20Speaker 3: They're based strictly on laws ordinances that have been enacted
- 3:25Speaker 3: by the District of Columbia, which of course is not
- 3:27Speaker 3: a state. It wants to be, but it's not a state,
- 3:30Speaker 3: and so there's no federal connection whatsoever to the claims.
- 3:35Speaker 3: There are causes of action that the District of Columbia
- 3:38Speaker 3: has filed against the oil companies. The oil company's arguments
- 3:42Speaker 3: are completely spurious on that point about where they belong.
- 3:46Speaker 3: They belong in this case in the District of Columbia
- 3:49Speaker 3: court system. There's one thing though about what the DC
- 3:53Speaker 3: lawyer is saying that's not quite one hundred percent, and
- 3:57Speaker 3: that is when it comes to the measure of damages, right,
- 4:02Speaker 3: how much are you actually going to charge the company
- 4:07Speaker 3: as the damage from the deception that has to do
- 4:10Speaker 3: with the impacts of climate change, which of course are
- 4:13Speaker 3: related to the emissions. So you see what I mean.
- 4:16Speaker 3: There's a little bit of this ingenuity here in saying
- 4:20Speaker 3: it has nothing to do with emissions. Of course it does.
- 4:23Speaker 3: It goes to the question of if you win your argument,
- 4:27Speaker 3: as I think they will, by the way that the
- 4:29Speaker 3: companies have been deceptive and have misled consumers, what's the
- 4:34Speaker 3: damage from that? In other words, what would have happened
- 4:37Speaker 3: had you not been deceptive, had you not lied? Would
- 4:41Speaker 3: things be any different? Would they be any better? Would
- 4:44Speaker 3: consumers have stopped buying gas guzzling cars, would they have
- 4:49Speaker 3: been able to afford electric vehicles? You see what I mean.
- 4:52Speaker 3: So when you get into the to the sort of
- 4:55Speaker 3: second phase of these cases, which is what's the real
- 4:58Speaker 3: damage from all this, that's when it's going to get
- 5:02Speaker 3: very interesting.
- 5:03Speaker 2: So this first phase jurisdiction, what was the industry argument
- 5:07Speaker 2: for trying to get this into federal court? Why did
- 5:10Speaker 2: they think it should be in federal court? Or why
- 5:12Speaker 2: do they say they think it should be in federal court.
- 5:14Speaker 3: Yeah, it's what I call pretzel logic. Okay, So the
- 5:18Speaker 3: way it works is the oil companies the defendants claim
- 5:23Speaker 3: that these cases because it's global in nature. Again, they're
- 5:27Speaker 3: making the argument the case is really about emissions, right,
- 5:31Speaker 3: and so they're saying that is classically a question for
- 5:36Speaker 3: federal jurisdiction. You can't have fifty states plus the District
- 5:41Speaker 3: of Columbia running around filing lawsuits against us. These should
- 5:45Speaker 3: be litigated in federal court because they're interstate and global
- 5:50Speaker 3: in nature, the impacts, the damage that you're really talking
- 5:53Speaker 3: about here. And then they say, and because there is
- 5:58Speaker 3: no federal law, they should all be dismissed. So that's
- 6:01Speaker 3: the pedsologic part of it. First of all, it's governed
- 6:04Speaker 3: by federal law, so they belong in federal court. But
- 6:08Speaker 3: since there's no federal law, they should be dismissed. And
- 6:11Speaker 3: that's where the judges in the DC's circuit. And two
- 6:15Speaker 3: of them were Trump appointee judges. We're scratching their heads
- 6:18Speaker 3: and saying, wait a minute, how can this be right?
- 6:21Speaker 3: How can you be saying, first there is federal law,
- 6:23Speaker 3: and then federal law disappears. I don't get it. So
- 6:27Speaker 3: I'm predicting that the DC Circuit is going to send
- 6:29Speaker 3: this case back to the District of Columbia court.
- 6:32Speaker 2: So explain why the industry is fighting tooth and nail
- 6:36Speaker 2: to force these cases into federal court.
- 6:38Speaker 1: Why they want them in federal court.
- 6:40Speaker 3: They want to fast track to the Supreme Court. They
- 6:43Speaker 3: want to get these cases back in front of the
- 6:46Speaker 3: Supreme Court and tossed out completely. That's what they're shooting for.
- 6:50Speaker 3: They don't ever want to go to trial. They don't
- 6:52Speaker 3: want to have any depositions, they don't want to have
- 6:55Speaker 3: any discovery. They want to try to spike these cases.
- 6:58Speaker 3: They tried to get the Supreme Court to take an
- 7:03Speaker 3: appeal from this other class of cases I mentioned, these
- 7:06Speaker 3: more tort based, con nuisance based kinds of cases, But
- 7:10Speaker 3: the Supreme Court just recently said no, thanks, we're not
- 7:13Speaker 3: going to look at them right now. Maybe later, but
- 7:16Speaker 3: right now we're staying out of it, and.
- 7:18Speaker 2: Has the industry basically struck out in these cases. I
- 7:21Speaker 2: think the DC District Court judge. There were at least
- 7:24Speaker 2: thirteen other district court judges and five appeals courts that.
- 7:28Speaker 3: Disssst them all. Yeah, the defendant oil companies has lost
- 7:32Speaker 3: every single attempt to move these cases into federal court.
- 7:37Speaker 1: Are any of the cases moving forward?
- 7:40Speaker 2: I read that the first one of these was brought
- 7:43Speaker 2: by coastal California communities in twenty seventeen.
- 7:46Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 7:47Speaker 3: The case in front right now, interestingly, is Honolulu, and
- 7:52Speaker 3: in Honolulu, the state court judge has already denied. The
- 7:57Speaker 3: case was sent back from federal court to state court
- 8:02Speaker 3: in Hawaii, and the Hawaii state court judge has already
- 8:05Speaker 3: denied the oil company's motion to dismiss based on the
- 8:10Speaker 3: argument that these claims are pre empted by federal law.
- 8:14Speaker 3: There's two different federal doctrines going on here, and it
- 8:18Speaker 3: gets very confusing. I'm sure one is whether the Clean
- 8:23Speaker 3: Air Act has displaced federal common law, which would otherwise
- 8:29Speaker 3: govern sort of interstate pollution problems, right, But the other
- 8:32Speaker 3: doctrine that the companies are arguing is that the Clean
- 8:37Speaker 3: Air Act also preempts state law that's one that the
- 8:41Speaker 3: Supreme Court is ultimately going to have to decide I
- 8:44Speaker 3: predict and in.
- 8:45Speaker 2: Several of these cases, appeals courts have ruled twice to
- 8:49Speaker 2: affirm the state courts are the right venue.
- 8:52Speaker 1: At what point does discovery start?
- 8:54Speaker 2: I mean, how long can they keep litigating the jurisdictional issue?
- 9:00Speaker 3: Run their string on that, and the Hawaii judges are
- 9:03Speaker 3: poised to start discovery. There's a petition pending in the
- 9:07Speaker 3: Hawaii Supreme Court, which is their sort of last gas
- 9:12Speaker 3: effort to prevent discovery. But again, my colleagues at the
- 9:16Speaker 3: University of Hawaii Law School know their court very well,
- 9:20Speaker 3: are pretty confident that the Hawaii Supreme Court is not
- 9:23Speaker 3: going to stop the cases and that discovery is probably
- 9:27Speaker 3: going to get underway in Hawaii this year.
- 9:30Speaker 2: Do we think the industry is afraid of discovery, very
- 9:34Speaker 2: afraid of discovery, incredibly afraid of discovery.
- 9:38Speaker 3: Yeah, somewhere along that spectrum they're very afraid because you know,
- 9:42Speaker 3: now you're talking about subpoenaing former CEOs of Exxon and
- 9:48Speaker 3: BP and Shell all the rest, putting them under oath
- 9:52Speaker 3: and asking them very pointed questions about what did you
- 9:56Speaker 3: know when did you know it. What did you do
- 9:58Speaker 3: with the information? Why does your advertising say one thing
- 10:02Speaker 3: when your internal documents say something else. Why are you
- 10:06Speaker 3: filing securities reports with the Securities in Exchange Commission that
- 10:10Speaker 3: are not fully disclosing the risks and the dangers that
- 10:13Speaker 3: you knew about. In fact, one of the more recent
- 10:16Speaker 3: studies of what the companies knew concluded company scientists knew
- 10:22Speaker 3: more than government scientists about the dangers of climate change,
- 10:28Speaker 3: earlier than some of the international organizations like the Intergovernmental
- 10:32Speaker 3: Panel on Climate Change new So all of this is
- 10:36Speaker 3: going to come out, it's going to become public, and
- 10:38Speaker 3: it's going to go into evidence in front of a jury.
- 10:41Speaker 3: And that's what they're terrified about.
- 10:43Speaker 2: Pat Is there any way that or the numbers too
- 10:46Speaker 2: great for the industry to settle some of these cases.
- 10:50Speaker 3: I think some of the defendants, you know, there's a
- 10:53Speaker 3: range of culpability here. Exxon's the worst. From everything that
- 10:57Speaker 3: we've seen, documents that have been released, statements that have
- 11:00Speaker 3: been made, et cetera. Exon is really the ringleader of
- 11:04Speaker 3: the deception campaign and organizing even the American Petroleum Institute
- 11:08Speaker 3: and others to carry out this propaganda of deceit. We
- 11:12Speaker 3: don't know very much about climate change. Still a lot
- 11:15Speaker 3: of unanswered questions, still a lot of research needed, and
- 11:18Speaker 3: so forth. But some of the other companies are sort
- 11:21Speaker 3: of less egregious in their conduct. They might try to
- 11:24Speaker 3: peel off and settle that. That happened with the tobacco cases.
- 11:28Speaker 3: Some of the tobacco companies decided, you know, stop the
- 11:31Speaker 3: bleeding and let's get out of these cases. And that
- 11:35Speaker 3: could happen in these cases.
- 11:36Speaker 2: Thanks so much for being on the show. Pat. That's
- 11:38Speaker 2: Professor Patrick Parento of the Vermont Law and Graduate School.
- 11:43Speaker 2: Another setback for federal prosecutors in their efforts to pursue
- 11:47Speaker 2: charges of public corruption against state and local officials, the
- 11:51Speaker 2: Supreme Court threw out two fraud convictions during former New
- 11:55Speaker 2: York Governor Andrew Cuomo's administration, one involving Joseph, a former
- 12:01Speaker 2: campaign manager and longtime confidante to Cuomo. During the oral arguments,
- 12:06Speaker 2: Justice is from across the Court's ideological spectrum had expressed
- 12:10Speaker 2: concern that the government's position would put influential lobbyists and
- 12:15Speaker 2: those who hire them at risk of prosecution. Here are
- 12:19Speaker 2: Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Elena Kagan. So it
- 12:23Speaker 2: sounds like that's an effort to break down the concept
- 12:25Speaker 2: of political power.
- 12:28Speaker 5: You're proposing a test which, as the Chief Justice suggested,
- 12:33Speaker 5: doesn't need to have any of that. You don't have
- 12:35Speaker 5: to be a former official, you don't need to be
- 12:38Speaker 5: a future official. I don't think you can give me
- 12:41Speaker 5: that test without making it look like the guys just
- 12:44Speaker 5: a really, really good lobbyist.
- 12:47Speaker 2: These are part of a long line of Supreme Court
- 12:49Speaker 2: cases that criticize federal prosecutors for overreaching in public corruption cases,
- 12:55Speaker 2: dating from tossing the conviction of former Virginia Governor Bob
- 12:59Speaker 2: McDon donal in twenty sixteen to tossing the convictions of two
- 13:03Speaker 2: political allies a former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie in
- 13:07Speaker 2: twenty twenty in the Bridgegate scandal. Joining me is Nicole Ingish,
- 13:11Speaker 2: a former state court judge and federal prosecutor. She's currently
- 13:15Speaker 2: a partner at Dorsey and Whitney. Tell us about the
- 13:18Speaker 2: case against Percoco.
- 13:20Speaker 4: So, Joseph Percoco was a former aid to then Governor Cuomo,
- 13:25Speaker 4: and he was charged and convicted of conspiracy to commit
- 13:30Speaker 4: honest services fraud. And that was from the time when
- 13:34Speaker 4: he was no longer working for Governor Cuomo as an aide,
- 13:39Speaker 4: but at the time he was serving in a campaign capacity,
- 13:43Speaker 4: and at that time he received some money thirty five
- 13:46Speaker 4: thousand from a development company who wanted to avoid this
- 13:51Speaker 4: costly union related requirement, and he used his influence basically
- 13:56Speaker 4: to get rid of that requirement.
- 13:59Speaker 2: So was his argument at the Supreme Court basically that
- 14:02Speaker 2: he was a lobbyist during that time or not an
- 14:05Speaker 2: employee of this state.
- 14:07Speaker 4: His primary argument was that he was charged under a
- 14:10Speaker 4: particular statute that requires the government to show that the
- 14:16Speaker 4: person charged has in some way engaged in not serving
- 14:22Speaker 4: the public with their honest services. And what he argued
- 14:26Speaker 4: is that because he didn't work for the government at
- 14:29Speaker 4: the time of this particular charge, he couldn't owe a
- 14:32Speaker 4: duty to the public to provide honor services, so this
- 14:35Speaker 4: charge needed to be overturned.
- 14:38Speaker 1: Tell us what the Supreme Court decided and why.
- 14:41Speaker 4: The Supreme Court decided that if a person is going
- 14:44Speaker 4: to be charged with honest services fraud, they wouldn't necessarily
- 14:48Speaker 4: have to beat someone who works for the government in
- 14:52Speaker 4: order for an honest services charge to be sustained, but
- 14:56Speaker 4: there needed to be a pretty close tie in. So,
- 14:59Speaker 4: in other word, if a person is going to be
- 15:01Speaker 4: charged with honest services fraud, they could be somebody who
- 15:05Speaker 4: has authority delegated to them as an actual agent of
- 15:09Speaker 4: the government, but somebody who is merely a private citizen
- 15:13Speaker 4: cannot be charged with that crime.
- 15:15Speaker 2: How did they handle the fact that even though he
- 15:18Speaker 2: was working on the campaign, he still had access to
- 15:20Speaker 2: his offices and continue to use them to conduct business.
- 15:24Speaker 1: Did they touch on that?
- 15:26Speaker 4: They didn't consider any of those activities to be sufficient
- 15:32Speaker 4: because they were concerned that as a private citizen, he
- 15:36Speaker 4: could have more or less been acting like a lobbyist.
- 15:39Speaker 4: And they were concerned that the statute was being applied
- 15:43Speaker 4: in an overly broad way and it could encompass people
- 15:47Speaker 4: who have legitimate lobbying activities getting paid to you seek
- 15:53Speaker 4: redress from the government. And so the concern was that
- 15:57Speaker 4: if he was found guilty of on a services fraud,
- 16:01Speaker 4: than the statute could apply to people who are doing
- 16:04Speaker 4: legitimate lobbying activities.
- 16:07Speaker 2: This decision, I don't think came as a surprise to
- 16:10Speaker 2: many people. Explain how the Supreme Court has narrowed the
- 16:14Speaker 2: reach of these federal corruption laws in recent years.
- 16:18Speaker 4: This definitely was not a surprise, and I think it's
- 16:21Speaker 4: telling that by the time the case got to oral argument,
- 16:25Speaker 4: the government itself had basically conceded that in each of
- 16:30Speaker 4: these cases that the fraud statutes were overly brought and
- 16:34Speaker 4: wouldn't have applied, and the government tried to save them
- 16:37Speaker 4: by arguing some different theories that they hadn't raised below.
- 16:40Speaker 4: So it was definitely not a surprise. The Supreme Court,
- 16:44Speaker 4: going back to its McNally decision in nineteen eighty seven,
- 16:47Speaker 4: has made it clear that these federal fraud statutes don't
- 16:51Speaker 4: authorize federal prosecutors to define what good government means for
- 16:57Speaker 4: state and local officials, so the fraud statutes don't criminalize
- 17:00Speaker 4: all acts of dishonesty or corruption. And instead, the Supreme
- 17:04Speaker 4: Court has made it clear that the federal fraud statutes
- 17:07Speaker 4: are limited to protecting property rights, and the only exception
- 17:12Speaker 4: is for what's called honest services. That's the charge at
- 17:16Speaker 4: issue in Percoco. But since the Supreme Court's decision in
- 17:21Speaker 4: twenty ten in Skilling, honest services cases themselves have been
- 17:26Speaker 4: limited to those that involve, you know, traditional bribes or kickbacks,
- 17:30Speaker 4: and now after per Coco, of course, honest services cases
- 17:34Speaker 4: need to involve a government employee or someone you know
- 17:38Speaker 4: acting as an actual agent of the government. And what
- 17:42Speaker 4: McNally and Skilling and other cases since then have provided
- 17:47Speaker 4: is that the justices are very concerned about federalism and overreach.
- 17:53Speaker 4: So they're worried, as Justice Kagan said in the twenty
- 17:57Speaker 4: twenty decision in Kelly versus the United States, the new
- 18:01Speaker 4: Jersey Bridgegate scandal case, that if left unchecked, the federal
- 18:06Speaker 4: government could use criminal law to enforce its own view
- 18:10Speaker 4: of integrity in broad loss of state and local policy making.
- 18:16Speaker 4: And they're also concerned, the justices are that fraud statutes
- 18:20Speaker 4: could reach legitimate activities like paid lobbyists who don't owe
- 18:25Speaker 4: a duty to the public and who are legitimately getting
- 18:28Speaker 4: paid to petition the government.
- 18:30Speaker 2: Why do you think those ideas cut across ideological lines
- 18:34Speaker 2: on the court.
- 18:35Speaker 4: I think it's really interesting that most of these cases
- 18:38Speaker 4: have been unanimous or nearly unanimous, and as you say,
- 18:42Speaker 4: they do cross ideological lines, which is not something that
- 18:46Speaker 4: we see very often. And I think the reason behind
- 18:49Speaker 4: that is the liberal justices tend to be very skeptical
- 18:53Speaker 4: of criminal laws that don't clearly put people unnotice of
- 18:57Speaker 4: the behavior that is criminal. That's often known as the
- 19:01Speaker 4: doctrine of lenity, that if criminal statute is somewhat ambiguous
- 19:07Speaker 4: or open to different interpretations, it should be interpreted in
- 19:10Speaker 4: a way that is most beneficial to the criminal defendant.
- 19:15Speaker 4: Conservative justices believe also in the rule of lenity, the
- 19:19Speaker 4: same as liberal justices, but they also emphasize how Congress
- 19:24Speaker 4: should not let unelected prosecutors and judges decide what should
- 19:29Speaker 4: be criminal, and they are more sensitive to First Amendment issues,
- 19:35Speaker 4: as we've seen in cases like Citizens United and others,
- 19:39Speaker 4: in which the conservative justices are more sympathetic to the
- 19:44Speaker 4: idea that money and politics could well be for legitimate purposes.
- 19:50Speaker 2: In the concurring opinion, Justice Gorsuch said the Court should
- 19:55Speaker 2: have gone further and defined precisely when a duty of
- 19:58Speaker 2: providing honest services arose. With all these cases, Why hasn't
- 20:02Speaker 2: the Court actually done that?
- 20:05Speaker 1: Why leave it ambiguous?
- 20:07Speaker 4: Right? Well, the Court feels that it's not the court's
- 20:10Speaker 4: job to define what a criminal statute should provide. It's
- 20:15Speaker 4: Congress's job. They end up doing it case by case
- 20:19Speaker 4: on the facts of the case presented to them, but
- 20:22Speaker 4: the general principle is that's for the legislature to do so.
- 20:27Speaker 2: Now this goes back to the federal court, and this
- 20:31Speaker 2: was based on the jury instruction, So possibly could he
- 20:34Speaker 2: be tried again on these It seems.
- 20:37Speaker 4: That the court may have left that possibility open, but
- 20:42Speaker 4: that remains to be seen on whether there's any possibility
- 20:48Speaker 4: of retrying either of these defendants. The various theories that
- 20:53Speaker 4: the government argued in the propellate case are ones that
- 20:58Speaker 4: were not presented below. So the case has been remanded
- 21:02Speaker 4: and it remains to be seen whether it could be retried.
- 21:07Speaker 2: They only reversed on some of the convictions, right, he
- 21:10Speaker 2: still has other convictions in place.
- 21:12Speaker 4: That's correct, and there's quite a lot of things still left.
- 21:16Speaker 4: He was convicted of a count of bribery with respect
- 21:19Speaker 4: to some other payments, and to my understanding, he served
- 21:24Speaker 4: his time in prison and has been released.
- 21:28Speaker 2: What's the future for these kinds of prosecutions of public corruption?
- 21:33Speaker 4: To a large extent, what the Supreme Court is saying
- 21:36Speaker 4: is their preference is to leave this up to the
- 21:40Speaker 4: state prosecution system. I don't think that's necessarily a good idea,
- 21:46Speaker 4: because the federal system is uniquely better situated to handle
- 21:51Speaker 4: public corruption cases somebody who worked in both the federal
- 21:56Speaker 4: system and the state system. The federal system has the
- 22:00Speaker 4: requisite resources to handle public corruption. These kinds of cases
- 22:04Speaker 4: take a lot of resources. They typically involve multiple agencies,
- 22:08Speaker 4: a fair amount of time in front of the grand jury,
- 22:11Speaker 4: the use of insiders cooperators. The state system, in contrast,
- 22:16Speaker 4: is a bit overwhelmed, I would say, in most jurisdictions,
- 22:20Speaker 4: and it's dominated by violent crime cases and drug cases,
- 22:24Speaker 4: and typically local law enforcement doesn't have, you know, the
- 22:27Speaker 4: time or the expertise to handle these kinds of cases.
- 22:31Speaker 4: And there's also the issue of how does a state
- 22:34Speaker 4: or local authority investigate what might be a counterpart in
- 22:38Speaker 4: a state or local agency. So it really does make
- 22:42Speaker 4: sense for public corruption cases to be brought federally. But
- 22:46Speaker 4: the problem identified in these cases by the Supreme Court
- 22:49Speaker 4: is that the key statutes prosecutors typically rely on mail
- 22:53Speaker 4: and wire fraud were not designed for these cases. So
- 22:58Speaker 4: after this, if you are going to bring these cases
- 23:01Speaker 4: in state court, which I don't think is a good idea,
- 23:04Speaker 4: chances are the federal prosecutors will need to find a
- 23:09Speaker 4: way to have their case fit, you know, within the
- 23:12Speaker 4: property fraud statutes or the Honest Services Statute. The Supreme
- 23:17Speaker 4: Court has given some guidance on how future corruption cases
- 23:20Speaker 4: might survive after these cases. In per Coco, prosecutors will
- 23:24Speaker 4: need to apply common law agency principles when they're bringing
- 23:28Speaker 4: on a services fraud theory, and in a case involving
- 23:32Speaker 4: a private citizen. After Seminelli, prosecutors will need to stick
- 23:36Speaker 4: more closely to traditional property theories when bringing mail and
- 23:39Speaker 4: wire fraud cases, so they really will need to show
- 23:43Speaker 4: that there is a scheme to defraud another out of
- 23:46Speaker 4: money or property. Or Another option is for prosecutors to
- 23:51Speaker 4: find one of the existing statutes, not the fraud statutes,
- 23:54Speaker 4: but the others that might fit the conduct more closely,
- 23:57Speaker 4: things like the Hobzac, the Travel Act, Federal Program Bribery Statue,
- 24:02Speaker 4: and others. Any final thoughts, Even though these cases look
- 24:07Speaker 4: like the Court is just antagonistic towards public corruption prosecutions,
- 24:13Speaker 4: that's not really what these cases are about. These cases
- 24:16Speaker 4: are about the Court's concern about federalism, about the idea
- 24:20Speaker 4: that federal courts are courts of limited jurisdiction, and also
- 24:25Speaker 4: about their concerns regarding due process and the rule of
- 24:28Speaker 4: lenity that if a statue has any ambiguity, it should
- 24:33Speaker 4: be construed in a way most favorable to the defendant.
- 24:36Speaker 2: Thanks so much for being on the show. That's Nicole Ingish,
- 24:39Speaker 2: a former Minnesota State court judge and federal prosecutor. She's
- 24:43Speaker 2: currently a partner at Dorsey and Whitney. And that's it
- 24:47Speaker 2: for this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you
- 24:49Speaker 2: can always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg
- 24:52Speaker 2: Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 24:56Speaker 2: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast slash Law,
- 25:01Speaker 2: And remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 25:04Speaker 2: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
- 25:08Speaker 2: and you're listening to Bloomberg