Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️110 |Public Inquiry Week Begin 12th. Oct Ecology Manipulation Day 1 |
Transcript
- 0:09Unknown: Today at the Coronalt public inquiry, we spent much of the morning discussing the future of badgers and Irish hares, and by the afternoon we had moved on to a debate about biodiversity calculations that were supposed to demonstrate an environmental gain from the proposed gold mine. I am
- 0:30absolutely outraged by what we've been listening to today. Entire families of wild creatures quietly going about their lives in the Coronel area, breeding, feeding, raising their young, and occupying territories that their species have inhabited for generations, are now being treated as obstacles
- 0:51to be cleared out of the way. And there's something deeply sinister about the language being used to describe it: habitat manipulation, displacement, relocation programmes, specific tactics. These are living creatures with established homes and territories and family groups,
- 1:15and we are witnessing proposals for the systematic displacement of entire families and communities of other living beings from their ancestral habitats-badgers, hares, newts, lizards, and countless other creatures-quietly going about their lives, breeding, raising their young, and belonging to
- 1:38this landscape since time immemorial, and listening to the extraordinary catalogue of habitat manipulation, forced displacement, and relocation programmes, I find myself reaching for the word pogrom. I know the terrible human history carried by that word, and I don't use it lightly. But it is
- 2:02deeply disturbing hearing about a planned programme that would drive whole communities of living beings from their homes to clear the way for industrial development, and somehow, in the sanitised language of environmental consultancy, all of this becomes ecological mitigation, and the most
- 2:26important part of it all is the apparent acceptance that the animals must surrender their homes to make way for the mine. We began the day with the badgers, territorial creatures with established sets, foraging grounds, pathways, and family groups that can occupy the same territory for generations.
- 2:51Unfortunately, some of that territory is exactly where Dalradian wants to build its industrial infrastructure. NIEA was broadly content with the latest surveys, although concerns remained about survey boundaries, set classifications, and future licencing. There was even disagreement over whether
- 3:13certain holes belonged to badgers or rabbits, and the differences between British and Northern Irish badger legislation. Dr. Hammond explained that even long inactive sets can have licencing implications here. Dalradian psychologist Miss Rogers said surveys had been ongoing for
- 3:37around 10 years, with set 13 now identified as the main set, then came the artificial replacement set. Apparently, if suitably designed and located, the badgers should discover their new accommodation, encouraged if necessary by trails of peanuts. So there we have it: a compulsory relocation programme,
- 4:03a new build property, and complementary peanuts. Presumably, a favourable review will be expected once they've settled in. Of course, badgers need more than a new front door. Around 64.8 hectares of foraging habitat will be lost or affected, although the applicant considers the impact
- 4:26insignificant, because alternative habitat exists, and restoration is proposed. That's more than 90 football pitches, and apparently the badgers can move elsewhere, as though the surrounding countryside were an enormous vacant housing lot with no existing residents, and then we got to talk about the
- 4:51explosives again. The applicant's assessment concluded that was highly unlikely blasting would have any measurable effects. Wildlife, really, an industrial gold mine with underground blasting proposed throughout the year over many years, and apparently the wildlife is unlikely to
- 5:14notice it. Concerns were raised about vibration, disturbance, and the changing location of underground operations, while the applicant pointed to vibration limits, exclusion zones, and mitigation measures. Meanwhile, I imagine the badgers trying to get on with their lives while human beings debate
- 5:37the precise distance at which an explosion becomes an acceptable feature of their domestic arrangements, and finally the security fencing openings could apparently be provided to allow badgers to follow their established routes, with details left to ecological management conditions. So somewhere around
- 5:59the mine infrastructure and water management ponds. We may have specially designed badger doors, and if a badger can squeeze through these, there is the obvious question of whether a curious child might manage it too. At this rate, the badgers will probably need a site induction, laminated access
- 6:22passes, hard hats, and wear high vis vests. Questions also remained about keeping wildlife out of dangerous areas, particularly the ponds.
- 6:34The applicant referred to fencing and safety provisions, but the practical arrangements have yet to be discussed, and then we moved on to the Irish hare, a wonderful creature, so much a part of The Sperrins landscape. Often, whiles out walking, I experienced them suddenly rising from the heather
- 6:53and disappearing across the hillside. The applicant's original assessment recorded just four hares, Doctor Mark Ruddock pointed out that foresightings tell us very little about the actual population, particularly when no dedicated Irish hare transect survey had been undertaken. Miss
- 7:18Rogers acknowledged this, but maintained that habitat assessments, observations, and population density assumptions were sufficient. The applicant concluded that surrounding bog and farmland could accommodate displaced hares, with no species-specific mitigation required. Then came another
- 7:39wonderful piece of ecological terminology, habitat manipulation. Apparently, the vegetation can be trimmed to make the area unsuitable for hares, encouraging them to move before construction begins. In other words, destroy the comfort of their existing homes and hope they take the hint. And heaven
- 8:00help any hedgehogs or small creatures caught in the path of those trimmers during this carefully managed eviction programme. Then there are the leverets, young hares sheltering in shallow depressions, unable to flee like the adults. An ecological clerk of works or e cow would check before clearance
- 8:21and protect any young found until they could move. I find this deeply upsetting. These are living creatures raising their families in the landscape they have always known, and we are discussing how to drive them out while protecting the young that cannot escape. Somehow, the deeply sanitised language of
- 8:41habitat manipulation makes the whole business sound like routine ground maintenance. Towards the end of the morning, the commissioner began asking NIEA on whether those receiving habitats had been assessed to establish that they could accommodate the displaced animals, particularly if other
- 8:59protected species were already living there. Doctor Hammond explained that species had been assessed individually, but acknowledged there had been no specific collective assessment of how displaced animals might interact with wildlife already occupying the surrounding habitats. And there it was: all
- 9:18these creatures being moved into neighbouring territories, without a combined assessment of whether there was room for them, Dr. Rudock outlined the ecological principles governing translocation, including existing populations, carrying capacity, territorial behaviour, animal welfare, and impacts on
- 9:39other species. He also identified gaps in baseline information for proposed newt and lizard receiving areas. Once again, we were examining the impacts species by species with separate mitigation proposals and assumptions, although these creatures all belong to the same. Interconnected ecosystem.
- 10:04The countryside surrounding the mine is already somebody else's home. It isn't an enormous vacant holding area waiting to accommodate the casualties of industrial development. After lunch, we moved to biodiversity calculations, and the day took another interesting turn. Conor Fagan for FODC challenged
- 10:26Dalradian's claim of biodiversity net gain. Biodiversity net gain isn't a mandatory planning requirement in Northern Ireland as it is in England, but Dalradian had chosen to include these calculations in its environmental case, and when the council examined the figures
- 10:46using the statutory metric employed in England, it found a significant net loss, where Dalradian had claimed a gain. An error in the applicant's calculations was subsequently acknowledged. The discussion examined how existing habitats had been valued, optimistic assumptions about how quickly
- 11:06replacement habitats could reach their intended condition, and whether mitigation and compensation were being counted again as additional environmental benefits. Dr. Ruddock raised concerns about ecological equivalence and double counting, creating habitats elsewhere doesn't
- 11:25automatically replace the ecological value of what has been destroyed. Then Conor Fagan introduced a wonderfully memorable phrase from an English High Court judgement: a developer consuming its own smoke. The principle was that measures introduced to compensate for environmental
- 11:46damage cannot automatically be claimed as additional benefits. Imagine demolishing somebody's house, building replacement accommodation down the road, and congratulating yourself on making a magnificent contribution to the housing supply. Dalradian disputed the suggestion that its ecological
- 12:08improvements lacked value and maintained that biodiversity net gain wasn't essential to its planning case. But another issue emerged. The council had raised concerns about these calculations previously, yet the errors remained when the inquiry reached this evidence. The commissioner questioned why they
- 12:28hadn't been corrected earlier, including in the applicant's statement of evidence.
- 12:36Fagan strongly objected to attempts to repair the calculations during the hearing, when there had been an earlier opportunity to address them, the commission allowed references to existing evidence but refused to accept fresh biodiversity figures. And then Fagan brought the entire argument back to its
- 12:55essentials. He pointed out that Dalreadin accepts environmental harm, faces conflicts with planning policy and has now acknowledged errors in its biodiversity calculations. Strip away the claimed biodiversity gains, ecological betterment, and compensation being presented as environmental benefits, he
- 13:20argued, and Delray's case comes down to one thing: the supposed economic benefit of the gold mine. According to Fagan, the applicant was asking the commission to accept substantial environmental harm because the economic benefits were claimed to outweigh it, and he went further, arguing that even on
- 13:42Dalradians' own economic analysis, those benefits came nowhere close to outweighing the damage. I spoke briefly at the end of today's session about who would profit from the destruction of our biodiversity and who would carry the environmental risks, because the environmental risks will be
- 14:03borne by the badgers, the hares, the newts, the lizards, and all the other living beings who call The Sperrins home, as well as the people and the landscape itself, and long after the gold has been extracted, and the profits disappeared, our children and grandchildren will inherit an impoverished
- 14:21ecosystem, a diminished natural heritage, and a landscape forever changed by what we allowed to happen here. There was today, thankfully, some positive news. The commission confirmed that our additional expert witnesses could contribute within the specific scope of the inquiry evidence,
- 14:44and Dr. Mark Ruddock demonstrated today exactly why independent expertise matters, bringing the discussion back to ecological relationships, the realities of displacement, and the evidence needed to protect wildlife. Because the badgers, hares, newts, and lizards have no voice in this inquiry, they
- 15:06have no barristers, consultants, or opportunity to object to losing their homes. That responsibility falls to us who care about them and the public bodies entrusted with their protection. I would dearly love to see even a fraction of the effort being devoted to manipulating habitats,
- 15:27relocating wildlife, and calculating environmental benefits directed towards keeping these creatures safe in the places where they already belong, because when our environmental protection system becomes so accommodating to development that wildlife is expected to make all the
- 15:46sacrifices. We have lost sight of what environmental protection was supposed to achieve, and the badgers of The Sperrins shouldn't have to move house, accept a few complimentary peanuts and hope for the best just because somebody has found gold beneath their feet. Thanks very much for listening, and
- 16:07I'll see you all tomorrow. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the
- 16:25conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these
- 16:43voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.