Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Warren Buffett's 200 Billion Dollar Mistakes Explained
Transcript
- 0:00What if I told you that the greatest investor in human
- 0:02history, the Oracle of Omaha, made like, easily avoidable
- 0:07mistakes that cost him an estimated $200 billion?
- 0:10200 billion with AB. Yeah, billion, not million.
- 0:15I mean, when you hear the name Warren Buffett, you probably
- 0:18picture a guy who approaches the stock market like, you know, a
- 0:21MasterCard counter at a blackjack table.
- 0:23Right, just totally calculated. Exactly like he sits down,
- 0:26strips out all the emotion, calculates the probabilities
- 0:30perfectly, makes the bet, and just walks away with a fortune,
- 0:33right? We kind of like our financial
- 0:35geniuses to be completely infallible.
- 0:37Well, yeah, it's a very comforting narrative, isn't it?
- 0:39I mean, we want to believe that there's some secret, flawless
- 0:43formula out there that we just, you know, haven't cracked yet.
- 0:46We just assume that when someone reaches that level of wealth,
- 0:48their decision making process is basically a supercomputer.
- 0:52But the reality of human psychology is well, it's
- 0:55infinitely more complicated and frankly, a lot messier.
- 0:59It really is, and that is exactly what we are dissecting
- 1:02today in this deep dive. We are completely flipping the
- 1:05script. Love it.
- 1:05We're looking into five of Warren Buffett's most
- 1:08catastrophic financial failures. We're not going to talk about
- 1:11his winning portfolio at all. So we're just looking at the
- 1:14disasters. Only the disasters, because the
- 1:17mission for today's deep dive is to prove that studying the
- 1:21multibillion dollar blunders of a master is actually much more
- 1:25valuable and way more relatable than trying to blindly copy his
- 1:29successes. Oh, absolutely.
- 1:31Because when you study a success, you're often studying
- 1:34this weird mix of skill, timing, and, let's be honest, a healthy
- 1:38dose of luck, right? But when you study A, especially
- 1:42at this massive scale, you are almost always studying human
- 1:45nature. You're looking at the
- 1:46psychological traps that catch all of us.
- 1:48Yeah, and by breaking down the mechanics of these mistakes, you
- 1:51know, from bruise egos to pure unadulterated fear of missing
- 1:55out, you can learn how to identify those exact same blind
- 1:58spots in your own life. But hey, real quick, before we
- 2:01jump into the psychology of all that, a quick heads up for you
- 2:03listening. If you want to access more
- 2:05advanced researches, applications and our latest
- 2:08published personal intelligent multi agent deep value
- 2:11intelligence. Welcome to explore and join the
- 2:14Deep Values dot AI community. Yeah.
- 2:17And if you want to track the total market temperature, you
- 2:19are very welcome to search and download the iOS app The Buffett
- 2:23Indicator right from the Apple App Store.
- 2:25Perfect. And just a quick disclaimer we
- 2:27got to do all analysis today is based on publicly available
- 2:30sources and you know maybe subject to revisions or
- 2:33differing interpretations. Right, and all contents from
- 2:36this channel is for information and research purposes only and
- 2:39does not constitute investment advice.
- 2:40So please conduct your own due diligence before making
- 2:43investment decisions. Always do your homework.
- 2:45OK, so let's get right into it. Because the irony of this first
- 2:49massive mistake is just too good To understand.
- 2:53His biggest blunder, we actually have to go back to the very
- 2:56foundation of his empire. Oh.
- 2:57This is the best part, right? The company that has become
- 3:02literally synonymous with ultimate wealth, Berkshire
- 3:05Hathaway, was originally his biggest mistake.
- 3:07It really was. I mean, today we know Berkshire
- 3:10Hathaway as this massive multinational conglomerate
- 3:13holding company it owns, like insurance giants, railroads,
- 3:17energy companies. The same thing basically.
- 3:18Yeah, everything. But back in the 1960s, when
- 3:21Buffett first started buying shares, Berkshire Hathaway was
- 3:24just a failing textile mill in New England.
- 3:28It was a dying business in a dying industry just getting
- 3:31totally crushed. Buy cheaper labor elsewhere.
- 3:33And here is where the whole supercomputer narrative just
- 3:36falls apart. He didn't buy this textile.
- 3:38No, because he looked at the books and found some hidden gem.
- 3:41No, not at. All he bought it out of pure
- 3:43petty spite. Pure spite.
- 3:45It's crazy. He was actually planning to sell
- 3:47his shares back to the company and just walk away.
- 3:49He had a verbal agreement with the manager of the mill on the
- 3:52exact price per share for a tender offer.
- 3:55But when the official written offer arrived, the manager had
- 3:58shaved a few cents off the agreed upon price.
- 4:00It was a tiny difference financially, but it completely
- 4:04bruised Buffett's ego. He felt insulted.
- 4:07So in retaliation, instead of just taking the slightly lower
- 4:10price and walking away from a dying business, he decides, you
- 4:14know what, I'm going to buy a controlling interest in the
- 4:16entire company. Yeah, he spends millions to take
- 4:19over the board for the sole purpose of firing the manager
- 4:23who insulted him Just. To fire the guy.
- 4:24Just to fire him, which you know, he successfully did.
- 4:27He got his revenge. But then the reality set in.
- 4:30He was now the proud owner of a failing textile.
- 4:33Mill, right. Congratulations.
- 4:34Exactly, and the mechanics of a failing textile mill are brutal.
- 4:38It's a highly capital intensive business so that means even as
- 4:42it's dying it constantly demands more and more cash just to keep
- 4:46the machines running and stay afloat.
- 4:48Wow, think about this dynamically.
- 4:49Buying Berkshire Hathaway just to fire the manager is basically
- 4:53like buying a failing debt ridden restaurant just to prove
- 4:56to the owner that his soup is too salty.
- 4:59That is the perfect way to look at.
- 5:00I love that you eat the salty soup.
- 5:02You get offended and your reaction is, well, I'm going to
- 5:05take on the lease, the plumbing issues and the feeling health
- 5:08inspection just to show you how bad you are in making soup.
- 5:12Right, you really showed. Up.
- 5:13It's hilarious, but the opportunity cost is terrifying
- 5:16when you actually run the numbers.
- 5:18The opportunity cost is the real tragedy here.
- 5:21I mean, sunk costs are the time and money you've already spent
- 5:24and just can't get back. Emotional investors try to fix
- 5:28their sunk costs. Rational investors walk away.
- 5:32Buffett spent decades trying to fix the textile mill, pouring
- 5:36capital into it that generated terrible returns.
- 5:39He actually later calculated that if he had just swallowed
- 5:42his pride, walked away from that petty slight, and put that
- 5:45initial capital directly into the incredible insurance
- 5:48companies he bought years later. The ones that actually made him
- 5:51rich. Yeah.
- 5:52The difference in compound value would be roughly $200 billion
- 5:56today. $200 billion. So the lesson for you listening
- 6:00is to aggressively check your ego at the door.
- 6:02Like never make an investment, or a career move for that
- 6:05matter, out of pride. Absolutely.
- 6:07Some costs are an illusion. Sometimes the most probable
- 6:10thing you could do is just admit you took a hit and cut your
- 6:13losses. Cutting your losses is
- 6:14essential, but understanding how you pay for an asset is just as
- 6:19critical as knowing when to walk away.
- 6:22Which brings us to a fundamentally different kind of
- 6:24mistake he made in 1993. OK, what happened then?
- 6:28Well, pride blinded him with the textile mill, but a few decades
- 6:32later it was a total misunderstanding of the currency
- 6:35he was spending. This is the story of the Dexter
- 6:38Shoe Company. Yes, it is.
- 6:39So Buffett bought this main based shoe manufacturer for over
- 6:43$400 million. He thought I had a great brand
- 6:46and a really strong competitive advantage.
- 6:48On paper, sure. Right.
- 6:49But almost immediately after the ink dried on the deal, the
- 6:53business landscape fundamentally changed.
- 6:55The market got flooded with incredibly cheap foreign shoe
- 6:59imports, Dexter's competitive advantage just evaporated, and
- 7:03the value of the company went all the way to 0 a complete
- 7:07wipeout. Yeah, a total wipeout in
- 7:09business happens. I mean, you can't predict every
- 7:12macroeconomic shift. But the reason this keeps
- 7:15Buffett up at night isn't the fact that the shoe company
- 7:17failed, it's the mechanism of the purchase.
- 7:21Instead of paying with cash from his massive reserves, Buffett
- 7:24paid for Dexter Shoes using Berkshire Hathaway stock.
- 7:27OK, wait, I have to push back here 'cause I think a lot of
- 7:30people might not see why that's so catastrophic.
- 7:32OK, how so? Well, if you work at a startup
- 7:34and get stock options, or if you're a CEO issuing shares,
- 7:38paying with stock often feels like using Monopoly money.
- 7:41Right, it does feel that way. Yeah, like you aren't grinning
- 7:43your bank account, you're just printing a few more certificates
- 7:45out of thin air. Why is paying with your own
- 7:48stock actually so dangerous? That is exactly the trap.
- 7:52It feels free, but it is actually the most expensive
- 7:55currency on earth. To understand why, you got to
- 7:57look at the mechanics of equity versus cash.
- 8:00OK, cash is a depreciating asset.
- 8:03A dollar today is worth a little less tomorrow because of
- 8:05inflation. It is the cheapest payment tool
- 8:08you have, but your stock, your equity is a claim on the future
- 8:13compounding growth of your entire enterprise.
- 8:16Oh, I see where this is going. Yeah, if you truly believe your
- 8:18company is going to grow and succeed, handing over your stock
- 8:22is like giving away a winning lottery ticket before they
- 8:24announce the numbers on television.
- 8:25Wow. You're carving off a piece of
- 8:27the very engine that generates your wealth.
- 8:29Precisely. And because he used his own
- 8:32wealth engine to buy a shoe company that went bankrupt, the
- 8:35tragedy just compounded. The shoe company vanished, but
- 8:39the the Berkshire shares he handed over to the sellers
- 8:41continued to grow, split and compound in value over the next
- 8:4430 years. Oh, man.
- 8:46Yeah. Today, the stock he gave away
- 8:48for a worthless shoe company would be worth over $10 billion.
- 8:52$10 billion for a company that went to zero?
- 8:55That is just physical pain. It hurts to even say it out
- 8:58loud. It really does.
- 9:00The take away here is to fiercely protect your own
- 9:02equity. If you believe in your own
- 9:05future, whether that's your company's stock, your ownership
- 9:07in a small business, or even just your own time, don't trade
- 9:11pieces of that future away Lightly.
- 9:14Spend cash because cash doesn't compound.
- 9:18Absolutely. So we've seen how ego can force
- 9:21you into a bad position, and how using the wrong currency can
- 9:24multiply your losses. But those are errors of action.
- 9:27Sometimes the most devastating mistakes are errors of inaction.
- 9:31This happens when your disciplined rules turn into
- 9:33intellectual blind spots. Which brings us to the trap of
- 9:36the closed circle and arguably his most famous miss, which is
- 9:40the Internet boom of the 2000s, specifically Google.
- 9:42Oh yeah, the Google miss. Now for some context for you
- 9:45guys listening, Buffett is famous for survivingthe.com
- 9:48crash because he had an ironclad rule.
- 9:51He only operated within his circle of competence.
- 9:53Meaning he only bought what he understood.
- 9:55Exactly. If he didn't fundamentally
- 9:58understand how a business made its money, he wouldn't invest.
- 10:02That rule saved him from buying into allthoseworthlesspets.com
- 10:05startups. It was a vital survival
- 10:08mechanism. Discipline keeps you alive in
- 10:10financial markets. But there's a very fine line
- 10:12between discipline and stubbornness.
- 10:15With Google, he didn't just miss a random tech startup because he
- 10:18didn't understand server architecture or the underlying
- 10:21code. The agonizing part of this
- 10:24mistake is that he had the data right in front of it.
- 10:27Because he publicly admitted later that he actually knew
- 10:30Google's advertising model was an absolute goldmine, he didn't
- 10:33have to guess. No, he saw it first hand.
- 10:36He saw it because his own subsidiaries, like the insurance
- 10:39giant Jico, were paying Google fortunes every single day for
- 10:42clicks. He literally saw the cash
- 10:45leaving his own companies and funneling directly into Google's
- 10:48monopoly. The mechanics of the situation
- 10:50were undeniable. He observed a clear toll bridge
- 10:53like competitive advantage, which is the exact kind of
- 10:56business he loves to own. His bread and butter.
- 10:58Yeah, but his rigid adherence to his old mental model, that whole
- 11:03stereotype that tech is unpredictable and outside my
- 11:05circle, just blocked him from acting on the objective reality
- 11:10staring him in the face. So how do you tell the
- 11:12difference? Like how do you separate good
- 11:14discipline from bad stubbornness?
- 11:17Because honestly, I think about it like an old school salesman
- 11:20who refuses to use a smartphone for his business.
- 11:23OK. I like that.
- 11:24He considers himself a landline expert.
- 11:26He knows how copper wires work. He trusts landlines, so he
- 11:30completely ignores mobile technology.
- 11:32At some point, he's not being a disciplined communicator.
- 11:35He's just in denial that the world has moved on.
- 11:38That analogy hits the nail on the head.
- 11:40Discipline is sticking to your strategy when the noise gets
- 11:43loud. Denial is ignoring a permanent
- 11:46shift in reality because it challenges your existing
- 11:48framework. That makes a lot of sense.
- 11:50Buffett's mistake wasn't that he failed to predict the future.
- 11:53His mistake was that he refused to update his mental models when
- 11:56the empirical evidence demanded it.
- 11:58So for you listening, the application is clear.
- 12:01Having a circle of competence is great, but that circle shouldn't
- 12:04be a closed fortified castle. You have to actively,
- 12:07continuously expand the perimeter.
- 12:10You have to. If you aren't constantly
- 12:12learning new models and updating your worldview based on new
- 12:14evidence, you are going to miss out on the dividends of the next
- 12:18era. And missing out has secondary
- 12:20consequences. When you realize you've missed a
- 12:23massive technological shift, it triggers deep emotional
- 12:27reactions. And he's super dangerous.
- 12:29Exactly missing the tech broom created a psychological pressure
- 12:32cooker which perfectly sets up the next psychological trap.
- 12:36We need to look at the extreme swings of emotion.
- 12:39Let's talk about those emotional extremes, starting with
- 12:41impatience. Yeah, because if there's one
- 12:43thing Warren Buffett is known for, it's extreme patience.
- 12:46Like his favorite holding period is forever.
- 12:49Forever. But back in 1966, he completely
- 12:51lost his nerve with one of the greatest brands on Earth, Walt
- 12:54Disney. Oh, this one is painful.
- 12:57The setup was flawless. He met with Walt Disney himself,
- 13:01saw the incredible value of the theme park, the intellectual
- 13:04property, the back catalog of films.
- 13:05It was a perfect value investment.
- 13:08Couldn't be better, right? So he bought 5% of the entire
- 13:12Disney company for about $4 million. 4 million, That is an
- 13:15absolute steal. A historic steal.
- 13:17The fundamentals were fantastic, the management was visionary,
- 13:21but he only held that stock for a little over a year.
- 13:24The stock ticked up, he made a respectable 50% profit, and he
- 13:28just sold his entire stake. He got impatient and cashed out.
- 13:31He sold 5% of Disney for a quick buck.
- 13:33Yes, and the way to visualize this mistake is profound.
- 13:38Selling a company with compounding fundamentals that
- 13:41early is like planting an oak tree in your backyard, eagerly
- 13:44waiting a year for it to sprout a few green branches and then
- 13:47immediately chopping it down to use as firewood.
- 13:50Oh that is so sad. Right.
- 13:52You get a tiny bit of warmth for one evening, but you completely
- 13:55sacrifice the massive towering forest that was guaranteed to
- 13:58grow if you just left it alone. Chopping the tree for kindling,
- 14:03That, that hurts to think about. If he had just sat on his hands
- 14:06and left that tree alone, that 5% stake in Disney with
- 14:10dividends reinvested would be worth north of $15 billion
- 14:14today. 15 billion. The mechanics of compounding
- 14:17interest are almost invisible in the short term, but they are
- 14:20just explosive in the long term. For the everyday person
- 14:23listening, this is perhaps the most vital lesson.
- 14:26If you buy into a great asset and the fundamental reasons you
- 14:30bought it haven't changed, the hardest and most important thing
- 14:33you can do is absolutely. Nothing.
- 14:35Just sit there. Just sit there.
- 14:36Holding long term is the the single most reliable way for
- 14:39ordinary people to build generational wealth.
- 14:42The magic isn't in timing the market.
- 14:44The magic is in the waiting. But waiting is excruciating when
- 14:48the entire market is going completely insane.
- 14:51Yeah, and that brings us to the final, and to me, the most
- 14:55shocking regret on this list. This one always surprises
- 14:57people. It's the absolute opposite of
- 14:59chopping the tree down early. It's planting a tree in the
- 15:02middle of a hurricane. I'm talking about Konoka
- 15:04Phillips in 2008. Oh boy, the zenith of the
- 15:07global. Exactly, I read the details on
- 15:10this and I literally could not believe it.
- 15:12In 2008, oil prices were skyrocketing toward $150.00 a
- 15:18barrel. The news was constantly talking
- 15:20about peak oil, energy crises and how prices were going to the
- 15:24moon. It was hysteria.
- 15:25And Buffett, the man whose entire philosophy is built on
- 15:28the phrase be fearful when others are greedy, got
- 15:31incredibly greedy. He bought heavily into the oil
- 15:35giant Konica Phillips at the absolute top of the market.
- 15:37And shortly after his massive purchase, the gleaming financial
- 15:40crisis hit, demand plummeted and oil prices violently crashed.
- 15:45He lost billions almost overnight.
- 15:46Overnight I am still stunned by the mechanics of this one.
- 15:50Buffett getting FOMO like getting swept U in a
- 15:52macroeconomic hye cycle. It violates his core identity.
- 15:55It really does. But in a weird way, it's
- 15:57profoundly comforting. It is so reassuring to know that
- 16:00even the most disciplined mind in finance can still panic by at
- 16:03the top of a market because they're terrified of missing out
- 16:06on a trend. It's the ultimate proof that
- 16:08nobody is immune to market hysteria.
- 16:11What happened here was a severe case of style drift.
- 16:14Style drift. Yeah, Buffett is a bottom up
- 16:17value investor. He looks at individual
- 16:19businesses, but with Conoco Phillips he tried to play a top
- 16:22down macroeconomic game. He thought he could perfectly
- 16:25predict the global energy commodity cycle, which he
- 16:28couldn't. No, he fell victim to blind
- 16:31confidence just assuming that because he was a genius in one
- 16:34area, his predictions in another area must be infallible.
- 16:38You forgot what game he was playing.
- 16:39Exactly. When you step outside your core
- 16:42strategy during a period of peak market euphoria, you are playing
- 16:46with fire. The lesson for us is deep
- 16:49humility. Absolutely.
- 16:50Whether you're buying stocks, real estate, or crypto, you have
- 16:53to respect market cycles. When the emotional temperature
- 16:56of the room is at a boiling point, when everyone around you
- 16:58is panicked or euphoric, you have to step back.
- 17:01Never assume you can outsmart A hysterical crowd.
- 17:04OK, let's let's pull all of these threads together.
- 17:06We have just walked through a staggering $200 billion resume
- 17:11of failures. We've learned that you should
- 17:14never invest based on ego or pride because some costs aren't
- 17:17real. We've learned to protect your
- 17:19equity like a winning lottery ticket because cash is cheap but
- 17:24your future is expensive. We saw why you must constantly
- 17:27force your circle of competence to expand so you don't get left
- 17:30behind in denial. We learned to hold on to great
- 17:33companies and let compounding do the heavy lifting.
- 17:36And finally, we saw why you must maintain absolute humility when
- 17:40the market cycle gets wildly emotional.
- 17:42When you lay it all out like that, it brings us to the
- 17:44ultimate realization of this entire analysis.
- 17:47When you look at this mountain of expensive errors, you realize
- 17:51that Warren Buffett's true genius isn't what we thought it
- 17:54was at the beginning of this deep dive.
- 17:56It's not the flawless card counter at the blackjack table.
- 17:59No, not at all. His actual undeniable superpower
- 18:02is his psychological resilience. Think about the mental fortitude
- 18:06it takes to make a $10 billion error with Dexter Shoe or a $200
- 18:11billion error with the textile mill and not let it completely
- 18:15destroy your confidence. I would be devastated, right?
- 18:19But he openly admits to his shareholders when he is wrong.
- 18:21He dissects mechanics of his failure generously.
- 18:25And most importantly, he guarantees that he doesn't make
- 18:27that exact same mistake twice. So he treats his mistakes as an
- 18:32education rather than an indictment of his character.
- 18:34Precisely. The ability to survive your own
- 18:38worst decisions and adapt is far more profitable than trying to
- 18:41be perfect from day one. That is a massive perspective
- 18:45shift and it brings me to a final thought I want you to Mull
- 18:47over as we wrap up today. But actually, actually real
- 18:49quick before that. If you like to access wider
- 18:52topics including life and investing philosophy, please
- 18:54subscribe to our sister channel, Deep Values.
- 18:57Yeah, and don't forget to like this video.
- 18:59Much appreciated. Yes, thank you guys.
- 19:01All right, so back to that final thought.
- 19:03We started by talking about the pressure of perfection.
- 19:05You know that flawless financial ideal.
- 19:08But if the greatest investor in the history of the world has a
- 19:11resume of failures this massive, maybe it's time we completely
- 19:15rethink our relationship with our own mistakes.
- 19:18I love that. Instead of hiding your
- 19:19professional regrets or agonizing over that time you
- 19:22bought at the top or sold at the bottom, what if you reframe
- 19:25them? What if you view those painful
- 19:28missteps as a heavily funded research and development
- 19:31department for your future success?
- 19:33Buffett paid billions for his master class and patience,
- 19:37currency and humility. So as you look back on your own
- 19:40life and your own decisions, ask yourself what is the billion
- 19:43dollar lesson hiding inside your biggest regret?