Latest / Leader's Edge / Don’t Overthink It
Transcript
- 0:00Dan Pink: Especially in America, we're just way over indexed on positivity. I I think that we've been sold a bill of goods. We've been told that the way to be to lead a good life, be effective, etcetera, is to be positive all the time and never be negative, to always look forward, never look back. And that's just bad advice. It's unscientific.
- 0:15What we should be doing with our regrets then is not ignoring our regrets.
- 0:21Sandy Lycox: Welcome to the Leader's Edge podcast. I'm Sandy Laycocks, editor in chief of Leader's Edge. In this episode, I talk with best selling author Dan Pink on-site at the council's operations leadership forum, which took place in late twenty twenty five. It's the second time I've had the pleasure of interviewing Dan, and just like last time, it is an entertaining and insightful conversation. We start in on the topsy-turvy state of the world and the question he believes we should be asking ourselves.
- 0:52Dan Pink: So, I mean, I think the the the question we should be asking ourselves isn't what's next. Understandably, everything's so freaking weird. We wanna understand what's gonna happen next. What's the next shoe to drop? You know, is AI gonna take our jobs?
- 1:06Is it going to liberate us forever? You know, you you know, is the American political situation going to revive itself? Is it gonna get even worse than it is right now, etcetera, etcetera? And I think it's right now, it's just everything is so the kind of change that we're dealing with now is so massive that I don't think we can answer that question. And I think the better question is, what can I what can I do now?
- 1:30And and this I don't want to get too theoretical, but there is this idea, sort of the training that a lot of us have is that we analyze first and then act. That we figure stuff out and then decide what to do. And and that's okay. But I think now, the only way to figure out what the hell is going on is to try stuff and do stuff. And I think in that stumbling way, you know, in the dark when we start, you know, just start doing things, we might be able to figure out what's going on.
- 1:57But just sit sort of sitting there and analyzing, okay. Let me just think through what's gonna happen next is a fool's errand. I I'm really convinced of that.
- 2:04Sandy Lycox: Yeah. I think that makes sense.
- 2:05Dan Pink: Yeah.
- 2:05Sandy Lycox: There's paralysis by analysis there.
- 2:07Dan Pink: There's something like there's something like that. But even even even worse than that is that is that I don't know if we have the capability to analyze intelligently what's happening right now.
- 2:17Sandy Lycox: Yeah.
- 2:18Dan Pink: I think it's just too weird.
- 2:20Sandy Lycox: And no precedent?
- 2:22Dan Pink: Right. Exactly.
- 2:23Sandy Lycox: Yeah. Alright. You talk about when trying to solve problems Yes. The default approach that people have. So talk to us about what that and how it can be a problem.
- 2:39Dan Pink: When we try to solve problems, always wanna add stuff, do more. Mhmm. And in many cases, the answer is to take stuff away or to do less. And it's very, very hard because we have this meaning when we're in the in the dog and pony shirt just now, we talked about this idea this idea of like a a kind of a default setting, like on a computer. And our default setting and I think it's a very deeply embedded default setting among like smart accomplished people, is to do more.
- 3:07We're gonna add something. And I we really have to overcome that. We don't have to necessarily abandon that all the time, but we have to be much more ambidextrous about how we solve the problem. We have to recognize that, you know, sometimes you wanna add, yeah. But you also have to think about what we wanna take away.
- 3:20And one of the reasons for the feeling of overwhelm right now, in my view, is that we're always adding and never subtracting. This is one reason why you see a little bit of sort of steps in this direction with things like on this phone here that we're talking about. No. Seriously. On this phone here, you can put limits on how much you use social media, for instance.
- 3:44Like, that's a little bit of a subtraction. You can stop your notifications. Just those are I think to me those are small steps in in a world where we're feeling overwhelmed. It's like just the solution to feeling better and doing better is not to add more stuff. It really is.
- 4:01But we gotta we gotta overcome this default setting that it is.
- 4:05Sandy Lycox: Tell us about the don't do this list.
- 4:07Dan Pink: Well, this is an idea that's been around for a while. Sometimes it's called a stop doing list. It's a it's a don't list. It's something that I do I've done myself for a few years now, which is you basically you you think hard about what are some things, and I like to make it three just because I think three is always a good number. The high I mean, I am.
- 4:28It really is. Well, I mean, it's like, you know, two is a coincidence, three is a trend, you know. And three things that waste your time, distract you, divert your focus. And like think hard about those kinds of things, but also memorialize them. Write them down.
- 4:47I think there's a power there I mean, there's very clear there's a power to writing things down. And keep a list of things that you shouldn't do and like post it, like, in the way that you keep your to do list in view. And so I've done that and and and it's been really it's been really helpful to me to stop. It's been really helpful to me to to do those kinds of things. And it begins ever so slowly to begin to think a little bit more subtractively.
- 5:11Sandy Lycox: Give us one of the things that
- 5:14Dan Pink: On mine? One of the most important ones on mine is is don't answer email first thing in the morning. I mean, as silly as that sounds, it's really it's it's really transformative because that's what I want to do. Yeah. Because you get it there.
- 5:29It's there waiting for you. You know you can do it and you get that kind of quick hit of satisfaction like boom. One down, two down, three down, four down. Got rid of him, five down, six down. But it's but it's very I mean, when I say I don't even say very rarely the most important thing I have to do that day.
- 5:48It's never the most important thing I to do that day. And so you end up taking it. I'm much better off saying, What's the hardest, most difficult, most important What's the most challenging or most important thing I have to do that day? And take an hour to do that first. And that's been really helpful to me.
- 6:03But it's harder to enforce if it's like this kind of theoretical thing that you know you should do rather than something that is like, you know, this admonition staring you in the face at your desk like that. Doing small things actually matters a lot. And a lot of times we try too hard to come up with big comprehensive meta solutions, which are sometimes valuable, but in in this case just doing some small things, getting a little momentum, trying some stuff, making some progress is really important.
- 6:33Sandy Lycox: Next we talk about ways to keep yourself motivated and how to give feedback.
- 6:40Dan Pink: Well, mean all kinds of ways to stay motivated. I think day to day one of the most important things is to note that is to pay attention to the progress you're making. We know, again, have pretty good evidence that making progress is on a day to day basis the single most motivating thing that we do. We like to make progress. It feels good to make progress.
- 6:57It feels good to make progress on meaningful things. But we sometimes don't always see it. And so once again, it's a matter of coming up with a routine, a ritual that allows us to notice it and memorialize it. In this case, you're memorializing it not to look at it again but just simply to doing it. So, you know, if you go out today, if you also It's an exercise in noticing as well.
- 7:26So if you were to go out today, if I were to say to you, Here's your assignment for tomorrow, say, I want you to look pay it I want you to notice people doing kind things for each other. You will notice something. You will notice that in a way that you wouldn't have before. So if I say to you, you know, start noticing the progress you're making because you're gonna have to record it at the end, you start noticing more the progress that you're making. And it's it's one of those things that's the bang for the buck is really, really powerful on that one.
- 7:50Because it doesn't cost you anything.
- 7:52Sandy Lycox: Yeah.
- 7:52Dan Pink: So if we think about it, if it's timely, individualized, non punitive and then also forward looking, I think what that distills to is the best feedback is is actionable. And a lot of times we over index on positive or negative. And we obsess, oh, you know, I wanna be honest but I don't wanna be cruel or maybe I can sandwich the good stuff into the bad stuff into the good stuff. And what and what I think that's a diversion. What we want to do is like, Can I give you feedback that is actionable?
- 8:22Can I give you feedback that is actionable? And that captures everything. That actionable feedback is forward looking, it is individualized, it is non punitive, it just help people get better.
- 8:36Sandy Lycox: We move into the topic of regret, which Dan has studied extensively, starting with how regret is useful.
- 8:45Dan Pink: Regret is useful if we treat it right. So it's so it is inherently part of being human because everybody has regrets. Everybody has moments where they look back and they wish they had done things differently, hadn't done certain things. And it makes them feel bad. And that's actually really important, that it makes you feel bad.
- 9:03It's one of the most common emotions that human beings have. And so But if you think about it, we have this very common emotion that makes us feel bad and that sort of feels like, wait a second, what's wrong with us? Why are we so messed up? And we're actually not messed up at all because it's adaptive. It's stuck around evolutionarily for a reason.
- 9:22And I think the problem is, especially in America, contemporary America, we're just way over indexed on positivity. I mean it. Honestly, I think that we've been sold a bill of goods. We've been told that the way to lead a good life, be effective, etc, is to be positive all the time and never be negative, to always look forward, never look back. And that's just bad advice.
- 9:45It's unscientific. And what we should be doing with our regrets then is not ignoring our regrets. And so this hyper positivity says forget about it. Look forward all the time. Never look back.
- 9:57Always be positive. And that's bad advice. And so some people just ignore their regrets. And other people get captured by them. They wallow in them.
- 10:07And what we want to do is we want to think about them. We want to look at them as signal, as information, as data. And when we do that, to actually answer your question, Sandy, we have all kinds of evidence that it helps us become better negotiators. It can help us become better problem solvers. It can help I talked a little bit about some cognitive biases today.
- 10:23Can help us avoid cognitive biases. It can help us find more meaning in life. It just has some it's it's a teacher. But it's a teacher only if we if we treat it right. We don't run away we don't run away we don't, like, run away from it.
- 10:38We don't run away from it and say, Oh, I don't hear It's like a knock at the door. Right? So, somebody comes and knocks at that door right there. What can I do? I can say, I don't hear anything.
- 10:46That's that's a no regret. Or I can say, Oh my God, knock at the door. This has got to be the worst thing ever and I go hide underneath that table. Or I can say, hey, what's up? What do you need?
- 10:55Right? And just like look it in the eye and say, what are you telling me? Oh, that's what you're telling me. And when we do that, when we treat it in this very when when we think about our regrets, when we just stare them in the eye, it's a transformative emotion. But we haven't been taught how to do that very well.
- 11:14Sandy Lycox: Ben Dan tells us about a major demographic difference he found among people he surveyed about regret.
- 11:23Dan Pink: So I did this big quantitative study, as you know, where we surveyed about 4,500 Americans on various dimensions of regret. What do they regret? And and the reason that the sample was so big was to look for demographic differences in regret. And there weren't very many. I'm still surprised by that, how modest these demographic differences were on race, on religious belief.
- 11:49But the one difference was on age and it was massive. So you can have two kinds of regrets or sort of in the broad broad broad broad categorization of regret. You can have regrets of action. I regret something I did. I bullied somebody.
- 12:03I regret it. I cheated on my spouse. I regret it. Regrets of inaction. I didn't ask somebody out on a date.
- 12:11I didn't tell my grandfather that I loved him and then he passed away. And what what sticks with us over time are these inaction regrets. So that young people, 20 people in their twenties, had about equal numbers of regrets of action and inaction. But the older people got, the more they had more more inaction regrets than action regrets. And it was just endless.
- 12:36It's like So the time people get to their sixties, seventies, and eighties, it's three to one, four to one. It's so clear to me that over time, what people regret is what they didn't do. Because when we do When we have regrets of action, we sometimes will make sense of them. We can find a silver lining. I shouldn't have married that guy, but at least I have these two great kids.
- 12:55Create some sort of sense some, you know, some some sense making there. I bull we had a lot of regrets in my in the database of of bullying. And so you have people who's like, I bullied somebody twenty five years ago, but I found them on Facebook and I called them up and apologized to them. Okay? So you can make amends.
- 13:11But with the inaction regrets, you they stick with
- 13:14Sandy Lycox: you. Yeah.
- 13:14Dan Pink: And so if you look at I just remember if on that chart, if you look at I think the oldest people we had on the survey were in their early eighties. But if you look at the people in their early eighties, it was like four to one inaction regrets over action regrets.
- 13:30Sandy Lycox: You know what's interesting? Because with the inaction, your mind can go anywhere of trying to Oh, I didn't do this. So it could have been like this or this or this because
- 13:39Dan Pink: you That's didn't do part of it. So that's part of it. I think that's a very astute point. The part of it is the unknown. But part of it, particularly for things like boldness, is that people look back on themselves and they're not necessarily conjuring, oh my god, everything would have been great if I had asked that person out on a date or if I had gone on the trip.
- 13:56But they look back and say, what? Like, why didn't you just step up and do it? What's wrong with you? Yeah. You know?
- 14:03And I think that's it. We look back on our former selves and say, what? What were you so scared of?
- 14:11Sandy Lycox: Next, my colleague and podcast producer, Zach Ewell, weighs in with a few questions inspired by conversations with his mom, who has had a thirty year career in sales and has utilized some of Dan's selling strategies. Zach, tell us about the setup for this next question.
- 14:27Zach Ewell: Thanks, Sandy. My mom pivoted to a career in sales thirty one years ago, right after I was born. One of her favorite books to read at the time was Pink's Own To Sell As Human. She told me that with help from Pink's book, she was able to assist coworkers who came from different backgrounds transition into sales roles by linking past experiences, emotions, and skills to help them upskill at their job. Her question was this, could this apply to all people at work no matter their role?
- 14:59And if so, why did he choose directly to write about salespeople?
- 15:05Dan Pink: It is applicable to all people, but the reason I chose sales is that all people are salespeople. Like, that's one of the that's like one of the ideas in the book is that when you look at and we have some we did a piece of research on not as good as this this stuff from the regret, but we did a piece of research back, you know, ten years ago, twelve years ago on asking people what they do all day and trying to re categorize what they do all day. And we found that people are spending enormous amounts of their time basically persuading, influencing, convincing, controlling. And it doesn't They don't have to be in sales. They could be like a teacher.
- 15:37A teacher is a teacher is in the is is is persuading people. Managers are persuading people. Doctors and nurses are trying to get people to change their behavior and so forth. They're trying to get people to give up certain resources and change, you know, and and and getting people to redirect their behavior in the way that salespeople are. So I do think that that's one reason the book is called The Cell is Human is that it's part of what human beings do.
- 16:04It's part of what human beings have always it's just that it's become monumentally more important. Now I wanted to write a book about sales. I think this might be what she's asking. I wanted to write a book about sales per se because I felt like it was getting a bad rap. Big big time.
- 16:21What would what would happen is I was writing stuff I was writing about other kinds of other kinds of business stuff a couple decades ago. Mhmm. Back when there were things called magazines. I don't know. You might you might remember You got one of I might remember.
- 16:36Did a fair amount of long form magazine journalism on business. Mhmm. Some of the smartest people I met were salespeople. And yet among my smarty pants friend circle, they always look they they look down on that. And it's like, wait a second.
- 16:51I don't I don't understand this. Like, why do some people look down on sales and yet my experience dealing with these people is that some of these people are like the most astute interest like, they're really like astute and they're really effective and they're nothing like the stereotype, like what is going on there? And so that's why I wanted to to do that because I had an inkling that all of us are selling a lot and that and that sales had changed. And so that's that's that's that's why I wanted to do it. So I wanted to understand what people actually do all day, which is selling.
- 17:20But I also I didn't wanna I didn't wanna hide behind the word entirely behind words like influence or like that. I wanted actually to put a fine point out and say, hey, listen, guys. We're all selling all the time whether we like it or And selling is not this kind of dirty, horrible thing, especially now because it was salespeople could take the low road and we have experience as buyers when salespeople take the low road took the low road when there was information asymmetry. But now, there's no there's less and less information asymmetry, and it makes it very different.
- 17:58Zach Ewell: Next, I ask Pink about a salesperson's place in the world. With consumers having so much access to information than ever before due to AI tools, I ask the author if he believes salespeople are still the curators and clarifiers of information for consumers.
- 18:17Dan Pink: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think it has a bigger effect on more direct customer service. Because in customer service, there are a lot of, you know, lot of questions that are repeated and repeated and repeated and repeated and repeated.
- 18:32And it's probably gonna have a bigger role on the lower end of, like, sort of lower ticket sales items. But for higher ticket sales items, I think it becomes another accompaniment and that and that in the same way that a sales per salesperson or even a doctor would have to deal with someone coming to them with a stack of Google printouts. Now they're gonna come with saying, well, ChatGPT told me this and Perflexity told me this and Claude told me this. And they're gonna have to say, okay, here's here's where here's where they got it right, where they got it wrong. A lot of times what you'll see if people are using these large language models for these kinds of inquiries is they sometimes ask the wrong question and the salespeople know how to ask the right question.
- 19:21So I I don't think it I don't think it replaces that that contextual curatorial function. I think it forces them to up their game though.
- 19:34Sandy Lycox: Finally, we get around to a fun question for Dan. We ask him to tell us about three things on his desk, and here's what we learn.
- 19:43Dan Pink: Oh, that's a good question. Okay. Three things that are on my desk. So not not much significance of the big rubber ball band except I use rubber bands and I need a place to hold them and it also gives me something to bounce around. I was large.
- 19:57Was large. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know how I I don't know where I got that.
- 20:00I think actually somebody gave that to me. Again, just to share more about the the seedy details of my personal life. I actually really like I really like rubber bands. I really like ziplock bags. I think that those are so powerful.
- 20:16I think those are such ingenious tools. Like forget about large language models. Rubber bands and ziplock bags are awesome. Alright? Those are like two incredible inventions.
- 20:24So I do have a big rubber band ball there. What else is on there? I have this thing that my one of my daughters made in preschool where they took a I I I don't I have my computer. See, intentionally didn't bring down my bag because I didn't think I needed, I would show you my Ziploc bags because you can see I would be total proof of concept. I would open it up and say, Oh my god.
- 20:53You have like five, six Ziploc bags. I'm not I'm not joking. You would totally see that. So photograph I don't have the slide on me, but there's a so you know like a you know those those those clips that you used to if I wanted to fasten like a big thing of paper. Okay?
- 21:13Yeah. So so imagine the black part of that. Yeah. Alright? So that's the base.
- 21:17And in nursery school, made this thing where they took a photograph. My daughter's name is one of my daughter's name is Eliza. Photograph of Eliza, she must be three, four, from the front. And then a photograph of her from the back, and then they laminated it and stuck it in one of those things. And so you it's like a little thing.
- 21:37It's like a little figurine of her, but from the front and the back. That's cool. Yeah. And I've had it ever since she was in, so I have that on my desk too. And then the other thing I have on my desk is I got a lot of crap on my desk.
- 21:51Another thing I have on my desk is I have a stuffed you might have seen this in the photograph because it sits up I think I did. A stuffed doll. Okay. It's a Yeah. Stuffed That's not Okay.
- 22:03Stuffed doll. And that is do you know who that is?
- 22:05Sandy Lycox: It looked like a it looked almost like a gnome or not a but it didn't have a hat. Yeah.
- 22:10Dan Pink: Did not have a hat. Yeah. It was gnome like because it had gray hair and a It is a stuffed doll of Charles Darwin. Oh. Yeah.
- 22:21Who is one of my heroes because he, for a whole set of reasons in that, he went against conventional wisdom, he was someone who wasn't a scholar who made a big contribution to the world of ideas. And I designed my office in Washington behind my house in part based on his office, because he had an office and I saw there was an exhibit in London maybe twenty years ago of his office. And he had this office where he looked out on his yard, essentially. And so I I got a garage office and I was like, oh, you know what I wanna do? Let's knock this out and have a window and I can have like a Darwin like office.
- 23:03And so I have this and I celebrate Darwin Day, You know? And so and so my family gave me, like, a Charles Darwin doll that is sitting up there. Another thing that I have is a very generative question here. Is I have And it might have been in the picture because it would be sort of in that direction, is is a sign that says it might have it might have been there. It says beat the resistance.
- 23:31Sandy Lycox: Beat the resistance?
- 23:31Dan Pink: Beat the resistance, and it's and there's a signature there. And so there's a great book called The War of Art by Steven Pressfield. And it's a book about creativity. And it's a book that I picked up inadvertently, not inadvertently, but I picked up in the San Francisco Airport a long time ago because it had a shiny cover. No joke.
- 23:49It had a metallic cover. Was like, what the hell is this? Oh, this looks kind of interesting and it's short. Okay. It's a book about how people are creative and how people do good work.
- 23:58What he says is that every time that you sit down to do creative work, the whole universe conspires against you to make you stop, distract you, to make you procrastinate. And he calls that the resistance. And he's like, the job of being an artist is to beat the resistance. And so I saw him once and somehow he had that card and he signed it for me. And so on there it's beat the resistance.
- 24:25So great question. I mean, it's yeah. So I have and there's other there's other kinds of stuff out there too. You could go on for that. Oh my god.
- 24:34It's like we could do we could do like a whole 55. We could do a whole video series here where I walk you
- 24:40Sandy Lycox: through
- 24:40Dan Pink: of
- 24:40Sandy Lycox: this.
- 24:40Dan Pink: I have another thing. Okay. Here we go. I'll show you another thing.
- 24:46Sandy Lycox: That was Dan Pink talking with us on-site at the Council's Operations Leadership Forum. Thanks for listening. I hope you enjoyed our conversation. For more Leader's Edge podcasts, visit leadersedge.com or subscribe.