Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Mini: Venus is lit
Transcript
- 0:00OK, Chelsea, I'm kind of tired of being the doom and gloom person.
- 0:03I don't want it to be negative news.
- 0:06So generally, I'm talking about the destruction of life on our planet.
- 0:09Well, guess what? CNN.com article posted January 29, 2024,
- 0:15written by Jacopo Prisco.
- 0:18That's quite the first name.
- 0:19You know what Jacopo's?
- 0:21Oh, I don't know.
- 0:23Actually, I think I know too many Jacopos.
- 0:27Yeah, OK.
- 0:27Like 10 of them. OK.
- 0:28That's interesting. I've never had that problem.
- 0:30Anyhow, name of the article.
- 0:32The discovery of a possible sign of life in Venus's clouds
- 0:36sparked controversy.
- 0:37Now, scientists say they have more proof.
- 0:39Four years ago, the unexpected discovery in the clouds of Venus of a gas
- 0:44that on Earth signifies life.
- 0:46Phosphine face controversy, earning rebukes in subsequent observations
- 0:51that failed to match this finding.
- 0:53Now, the same team behind that discovery has come back with more
- 0:57observations presented for the first time on July 17th at Royal
- 1:01Astronomical Society meeting in Hall, England.
- 1:04Eventually, they will form the basis of one or more scientific studies.
- 1:08And that work has already started.
- 1:11The data, the researchers say, contains enough strong proof that
- 1:15Phosphine is present in the Venus clouds, our closest planetary neighbor.
- 1:19Sometimes called Earth's evil twin, the planet is similar to ours in size,
- 1:24but features surface temperatures that can melt lead and clouds made of
- 1:28corrosive sulfuric acid.
- 1:30The work has benefited from a newer receiver installed on one of the
- 1:35instruments used for the observations, the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope in
- 1:39Hawaii, giving the team more confidence in its findings.
- 1:42Quote, there is also a lot more of the data itself.
- 1:45And quote, said David Clements, a reader in astrophysics at Imperial College London.
- 1:51Quote, we have three observations, campaigns, and in just one run, we got
- 1:55140 times as much data as we did in the original detection.
- 1:59And what we've got so far indicates that we once again have Phosphine detections.
- 2:05This is arguably more significant than the discovery of Phosphine.
- 2:09We're a long way from saying this, but if there is life on Venus producing
- 2:14Phosphine, we have no idea why it's producing it.
- 2:17However, if there is life on Venus producing ammonia, we do have an idea
- 2:21why it might be wanting to breathe ammonia end quote from the same guy.
- 2:25On Earth, Phosphine is a foul smelling toxic gas produced by decaying
- 2:29organic matter or bacteria.
- 2:31While ammonia is a gas with a pungent smell that naturally occurs in the
- 2:34environment and is also produced mostly by bacteria at the end of the process
- 2:38of decomposition of plant and animal waste.
- 2:41Quote, Phosphine has been discovered in the atmosphere of Saturn, but that's
- 2:45not unexpected because Saturn is a gas giant.
- 2:47There is an awful lot of hydrogen in its atmosphere.
- 2:50So any hydrogen based compounds like Phosphine or ammonia are what dominate
- 2:55there end quote said Clements.
- 2:57However, rocky planets such as Earth, Venus and Mars have atmospheres in
- 3:01which oxygen dominates the chemistry because they didn't have enough mass
- 3:05to keep the hydrogen that they had when they originally formed.
- 3:08And that hydrogen has escaped.
- 3:10Finding these gases on Venus is therefore unexpected quote by all normal
- 3:14expectations, they shouldn't be there, Phosphine and ammonia have both been
- 3:18suggested as biomarkers, including on exoplanets.
- 3:21So finding them in the atmosphere of Venus is interesting on that basis as well.
- 3:25When we published the Phosphine findings in 2020, quite understandably, that was
- 3:30a surprise end quote by Clements again.
- 3:33Subsequent studies challenged the results suggesting that the Phosphine was
- 3:37actually ordinary sulfur dioxide data from instruments other than those used
- 3:41by Clements team such as Venus Express spacecraft.
- 3:43The NASA infrared telescope facility and the now defunct Sophia airborne
- 3:48observatory also failed to replicate the Phosphine findings.
- 3:52But Clements said that his new data coming from Atacama large millimeter
- 3:57submillimeter array or ALMA rules out that sulfur dioxide might be a
- 4:02contaminant and the lack of Phosphine from other observations is due to timing.
- 4:07Quote, it turns out that all our observations that check with Phosphine
- 4:10were taken as the atmosphere of Venus move from night to day.
- 4:14And all the observations that didn't find Phosphine were taken as the
- 4:17atmosphere move from day to night end quote from Clements again.
- 4:21During the day, the ultraviolet light from the sun can break up molecules in
- 4:24the upper atmosphere of Venus.
- 4:25Quote, all Phosphine is baked out and that's why you don't see it.
- 4:29End quote Clements said adding that the only exception was the stratospheric
- 4:33observation for infrared astronomy, which made observations at night.
- 4:37But further analysis of that data by Clements team revealed weak traces of
- 4:41the molecule reinforcing the theory.
- 4:43It showed Phosphine inside the clouds of Venus at around the part per million
- 4:48level, which is exactly what we have largely been detecting.
- 4:51So it's beginning to hang together, but we still don't know what's
- 4:55producing it.
- 4:56Thank Clements.
- 4:57And I think that's a good place to stop it there, Chelsea.
- 4:59Anything you want to say?
- 5:00Think it's dinosaurs?
- 5:02You know what?
- 5:03They're actual specifically.
- 5:04You know what, if it is going to be any dinosaurs, it is pterodactyls because
- 5:07I don't know if we've talked about this on the podcast before, but the best
- 5:11speculation for life on Venus is that it's flying in the atmosphere.
- 5:17So if it's going to be a dinosaur, it's got to be a pterodactyl or at least
- 5:20some sort of floating p-rax.
- 5:22And then we just got to get used to the idea that the Venetians are pterodactyls.
- 5:27No one thought of that.
- 5:29No one thought of that.
- 5:29I don't know what the implications are with that either.
- 5:32We like look.
- 5:35Have we looked into Venus like what's going on on the surface or is too gassy?
- 5:41Well, we haven't really.
- 5:43And it's really weird because it's the closest planet to us.
- 5:46Like Mars is actually further away by a significant amount.
- 5:49There's only been one probe ever sent to Venus.
- 5:52And there's basically like two photos that came back from it because it got
- 5:56destroyed on the way to landing.
- 5:57I was going to say it's probably pretty turbulent in there.
- 6:00It's not only turbulent.
- 6:02It's incredibly acidic atmosphere.
- 6:04It is the warmest planet in the solar system and the pressure is just killer.
- 6:09So anything that lands there is promptly going to be destroyed.
- 6:12Really? Yeah.
- 6:13I bet it's on pterodactyls, but it's looking more and more like there's
- 6:19probably life even within our solar system.
- 6:22And heading back a few fringing minis ago, I wasn't going to say Venus
- 6:26because now we know there's pterodactyls.
- 6:28But second runner up is anything with an ocean because apparently they have
- 6:33large stores of oxygen.
- 6:36Yes, due to the electricity that happens in there.
- 6:38Yeah.
- 6:39Therefore electricity.
- 6:42Well, and there's an incredibly interesting history, too, to Venus of people
- 6:47seeing weird lights in the sky of Venus or the clouds of Venus is probably a better
- 6:52way to say it, like astronomers through the last 200 years have seen weird lights
- 6:57in the clouds of Venus, which can be explained through something living in the atmosphere.
- 7:03Well, that's pretty cool.
- 7:05Who said that?
- 7:06I would have to go look at it, but it's many like famous astronomers
- 7:10that have seen lights in the clouds.
- 7:12Oh, that's cool.
- 7:14Yeah.
- 7:14OK.
- 7:15I would have to make a whole episode out of that, though.
- 7:17Pterodactyls are wearing like those hard hats with lights on.
- 7:21I like to think they're having raves in the night sky and they're just.
- 7:25Yeah, like yeah.
- 7:26Yeah.
- 7:27OK.
- 7:28But anyhow, you you you got 48 hours to figure out what those pterodactyls are
- 7:34doing in the night sky there.
- 7:35You can publish your thesis, you know, send us your thesis before you publish it just
- 7:39so that we can make sure we're on the same page.
- 7:41But anyhow, you got 48 hours.
- 7:42We'll see you at the next episode.
- 7:44Bye.
- 7:45Bye.