Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #26: WBB Week 1 Recap, CSR Timeline of the first week, AP Poll Audit and Biggest Week 2 Games
Transcript
- 0:17Hello and welcome to episode number 26 of the Common Sense Rankings podcast, where we rank the resume, not the expectation.
- 0:23You are listening to the women's college basketball week one recap, where I'll talk about the biggest results from the first week of action, as well as some of the crucial matchups that involved power conference teams.
- 0:33I'll go through a timeline of the week detailing how the conference strength rankings and the CSR top 25 changed as more results poured in.
- 0:41We'll compare those results to AP poll and audit a couple of AP ballots.
- 0:45We'll take a look at how the tournament field would shake out according to the CSR, and look at the most important matchups of week number two.
- 0:53There were a total of 487 games played in Division I in the first week of women's college basketball.
- 0:5925 of those matchups were going to be crucial to the Common Sense rankings.
- 1:02When conferences play just once or twice, it's a must win for the leagues involved, because head-to-head matchups between every conference and every other determine a league's strength in the CSR formula.
- 1:13A win against a team from a stronger conference will net more points, and a loss to a team from a stronger conference will lose you fewer points.
- 1:21Of those 25 crucial matchups, the Power Five conferences played eight of them and did win all eight, so no serious implications surrounding the top conferences the first week.
- 1:30There were several big matchups between power conference schools.
- 1:33Connecticut played two Big Ten teams in their first three games, falling to Michigan in the middle of the week before beating Iowa on Sunday.
- 1:40South Carolina started their season with two easy wins, both over Power Four competition: first Maryland, then North Carolina.
- 1:47Arizona beat Stanford in a former Pac-12 member battle.
- 1:51West Virginia beat Georgia Tech, which launched the Mountaineers toward the top of the CSR.
- 1:55And finally, Florida beat UCF in an SEC-Big 12 showdown.
- 2:00Next, I did this with the men's recap in the previous episode, and I'll do it again for the women.
- 2:04I'm going to take you on a timeline of the week.
- 2:06I'll discuss how results impacted both CSR conference strength and the top 25.
- 2:11If you're listening to this podcast, there is a visual portion on YouTube if you are a more visual learner.
- 2:17The first update comes early in the afternoon on Monday, about 1:30 PM.
- 2:2112 teams had already won and four conferences already had winning head-to-heads over another.
- 2:26The ACC had two, then the Big East, Ivy League, and Sun Belt each had one.
- 2:30The other 28 conferences either had not played yet, had only played Division II teams, or had lost any matchups they'd played so far.
- 2:38Only one program had beaten a team from one of those conferences that had a winning head-to-head.
- 2:43That was the Notre Dame Fighting Irish.
- 2:45Since the team they defeated was from a superior conference, they got the nod at number one, followed by the rest of the teams that had wins over a D1 school: Butler, Georgia Tech, Coastal Carolina, Columbia, and Old Dominion.
- 2:56Schools with a D2 win then followed in spots seven through 12.
- 3:01With many more early women's games and now with 25 teams already sporting a win, I pulled another update at five o'clock Monday afternoon.
- 3:08There were now eight conferences with winning head-to-heads against another, led by the SEC with four, the ACC and Big Ten with three, then the Big 12 and the Big East with two.
- 3:18There were no teams with a win over the SEC, so any teams with a win over an ACC or Big Ten school would be atop the live CSR.
- 3:26Three teams had such a win: Arizona, Oklahoma, and South Carolina.
- 3:31Notre Dame slipped to fourth as the Big East was now better than just two conferences, fourth among all of the conferences in Division I.
- 3:37Numbers five through 18 had wins over those conferences that had no winning head-to-head matchups, and 19 through 25 were teams with wins over a lower division.
- 3:46At this point, we were using win margin as a tiebreaker, but that will quickly go away as more data rolls in.
- 3:52But for now, to distinguish between all these teams who have similar wins, I did use win margin as that delineator.
- 3:59As we start to move into the evening on the East Coast, more teams, especially from the large conferences, had finished their first game.
- 4:06At 7:30 Eastern, the ACC and SEC were atop the CSR conference strength, each posting five head-to-heads versus other conferences.
- 4:14The rest of the power conferences followed, but the American is tied with the Big 12 there in the fifth spot.
- 4:19Four conferences were tied with one head-to-head, and the remaining 22 were still waiting for their first.
- 4:25As no SEC team had yet lost, we looked to the two teams who beat ACC schools as our top two, Arizona and Oklahoma.
- 4:33Three schools had a Big Ten or Big East win.
- 4:35Those would be South Carolina, Cleveland State, and Notre Dame.
- 4:38UConn had a win over the Ivy League to take sixth.
- 4:41Then the rest of the top 25 were teams with wins over schools from those leagues who had yet to beat another head-to-head on the court this season.
- 4:49Some random names that jump out for the top 25 as of 7:30 Monday were Tulane, South Florida, Coastal Carolina, and Columbia.
- 4:58After another two hours, 21 conferences had made their presence known in the CSR conference strength, still led by the ACC and SEC with five conference head-to-heads each.
- 5:08The Big 12 moved up to tie with the Big Ten for third, and a win over the Big East was now the same as a win over the Ivy or the Missouri Valley.
- 5:16The Patriot and Atlantic 10 both went from zero to two head-to-heads in those two hours.
- 5:22Again, if you're not watching the video version of this podcast, I'm showing the conference rankings and top 25 after each round of games, and in this top 25, you'll see our ACC wins are still one and two, but Holy Cross has now joined the top three after their dub over Boston College.
- 5:37New mid-major teams to the top 25 as of 9:30 Monday, Princeton, Siena, Northern Illinois, George Mason, Richmond, Dartmouth, and Missouri State.
- 5:46This is hopefully showing how fluid things are, especially when data points are at a premium After the first full day of results, including all the West Coast late-night games, the SEC took a commanding lead in conference strength, going undefeated and beating teams from 10 different conferences.
- 6:03The ACC and Big 12 are a distant second with five each.
- 6:07It makes sense that the Pac-12 and West Coast Conference both improved their standing considering the location in the country, going from one conference head-to-head each to three, putting them level with the Big East, Ivy League, and Missouri Valley through the first day.
- 6:20So since the SEC remained undefeated as the top conference, as was the Big 12, it was the three teams with ACC wins that finished day one atop the CSR: Arizona, Oklahoma, and Holy Cross.
- 6:32The biggest changes came from number nine onward as conferences proved on-court superiority.
- 6:37From mid-major conferences, we welcome Air Force and Middle Tennessee to the rankings.
- 6:41Among this top 25 after the first day, there were 14 power conference schools and 11 mid-major schools, all of whom likely pulled off their upset on the first day of action.
- 6:53Following Tuesday, the ACC took the lead in the conference strength rankings, picking up head-to-head wins against six more conferences and surpassing the SEC as the strongest conference through day two.
- 7:04Each of the power conferences were right behind, with the Big Ten and Big East each with nine conference head-to-heads won, and the Big 12 with eight.
- 7:12The A-10 was up next with four, and there were still nine conferences tied at the bottom of the conference strength rankings with no head-to-heads yet won.
- 7:20Through Tuesday, no team had yet won two Division I games, so the top 25 is still based on whose win was the best.
- 7:27Thanks to the A-10's success Tuesday, teams with a win over that league moved up into the seven through ten spots.
- 7:33Those schools were Tennessee, who beat Duquesne, Middle Tennessee, who beat St.
- 7:37Louis, Columbia, who defeated Davidson, and West Virginia, who took down Rhode Island.
- 7:41Incarnate Word was our 25th team after Tuesday, having beaten Tulsa from the American Tuesday evening.
- 7:49Rolling on through Wednesday, the power conferences are continuing to separate themselves, the Big Ten rising to tie the Big 12 in third, and the Big East slipping to fifth.
- 7:58The Pac-12 and West Coast Conference joined the A-10 as the best among the mid-major conferences.
- 8:03Conference USA, the American, the UAC, and Mountain West all picked up another conference head-to-head on Wednesday.
- 8:11Six teams were looking at two Division I wins through Wednesday night, so with twice the number of wins as those with just one, it made sense to put them one through six.
- 8:19They were then separated by the conferences of the teams they defeated, as well as if those teams had played and won another game.
- 8:25In order, those teams were Rutgers, Virginia Tech, NC State, Louisville, Vanderbilt, and Alabama, all with two Division I wins.
- 8:34The rest of the top 25 is again ordered based on the conference of the school those teams defeated.
- 8:39Just one team moved up into the live top 25 after Wednesday, California Baptist, who beat Oregon State late Wednesday night.
- 8:45The team that dropped out to make room for the Lancers was George Mason, and the rest of the top 25 shuffled around.
- 8:52After another day of games, the power conferences continued to do power conference things.
- 8:57They each earned between one and four additional winning records against other conferences, only exacerbating the gap between them and the rest of women's college basketball.
- 9:06The Atlantic Ten and Pac-12 are tied for sixth in the conference strength rankings with five conference head-to-heads each.
- 9:12The Missouri Valley, Patriot, and West Coast Conferences round out the top ten.
- 9:16Wins over those conferences will mean more than wins over unmentioned conferences, and five leagues were still missing out on a winning record against a single conference through Thursday.
- 9:26As the Friday games drew to a close, the ACC and SEC stayed put with 15 conference head-to-head wins each, but the Big 12 leapfrogged both to put them atop the CSR conference strength.
- 9:37The Big Ten sits fourth just behind the ACC and SEC.
- 9:40There's then a large-ish gap to the Big East, and then another sizable gap to the mid-major conferences.
- 9:46Twelve conferences sit between three and five head-to-heads, so there's a very tight battle going for who will be the best conferences behind the traditional powers.
- 9:55After Saturday's action concluded, the power conferences were distancing themselves from the mid-majors, with the Big East stuck in no man's land between them.
- 10:02The Big 12, Big Ten, SEC, and ACC all sat with at least 15 head-to-heads over other leagues.
- 10:08The Big East had ten, then the American was down at seven.
- 10:12Other conferences with at least five leagues beat were the A-10, Conference USA, and Pac-12.
- 10:18At the end of the first week, the ACC was the first league to crack 20 conferences against which they had winning records, making an ACC win the most impressive in the CSR through week one.
- 10:28The Big 12 and SEC opened up a gap on the Big Ten, but after that it was more of the same.
- 10:34A MIAC and Ohio Valley win are worth the least right now as neither conference can say they've defeated another on the court this season.
- 10:42When the dust settled on the first week of women's college basketball, there was just one team to conclude the first week four and O against Division I schools.
- 10:50That'd be the Alabama Crimson Tide, who had held the top spot since winning their third game on Thursday.
- 10:55With data points just starting to roll in, four wins will look better than the three wins each of the next 24 teams have, but will soon change as more games are played.
- 11:04In spots two through four, there are three and O schools with a power conference win to their resume.
- 11:09As those conferences are setting themselves from the mid-majors, a win over a power conference team will allow a school to differentiate their resume from teams that have mid-major wins.
- 11:18West Virginia is second, with their highlight being Sunday's win over Georgia Tech.
- 11:22Number three is Kentucky, who have a win over NC State, and fourth is Florida, who have a Big 12 win over UCF.
- 11:28There is a definite upper tier of mid-major conferences, and the next eight teams in the rankings have a win over the A-10, American, or Pac-12.
- 11:36Number five is Columbia, who has two wins over the A-10.
- 11:39Number six is another Ivy League program, Princeton, also with an A-10 win.
- 11:44San Diego State has two wins over the American.
- 11:46The Aztecs are number seven.
- 11:48Miami is number eight with a win over FAU to start their season.
- 11:52Rice is nine, Virginia is number 10, California is number 11, and to round out this group is Rutgers at 12.
- 11:59The rest of the top 25 are all teams that started three and O, but the conferences of their opponents fall in the bottom half of the CSR conference strength.
- 12:0613 is Clemson, 14 Virginia Tech, 15 Ohio State, 16 Wake Forest, 17 TCU, 18 is Georgia, 19 is a MAC team, Miami, Ohio.
- 12:17Number 20 is Albany out of the America East, 21 Wisconsin, 22 BYU, 23 Kansas State, 24 Texas A&M, and at the end of the first week, number 25 is Butler.
- 12:30South Carolina, who is two and O with two Power Four wins, was 26th in the CSR through week one.
- 12:35Without more data on how good those two opponents are this season, the Gamecocks couldn't quite crack the top 25 after week one.
- 12:43When teams have similar wins on their resume, a differentiator is the wins of their opponents thus far.
- 12:48While it is just a small part of the resume early in the season, a portion of each team's CSR includes the wins of the teams they've defeated.
- 12:56Those data points are also included when constructing this top 25.
- 13:00All undefeated teams in the top 25 this week and nearly the entire top 100.
- 13:05The first one-loss team in the CSR is Connecticut, but they're all the way down at number 96.
- 13:10Early in the season, it'll be tough to overcome a loss, but UConn plays a ton of power conference teams.
- 13:15They will likely be the first team with a loss in the rankings if they can win their next few matchups.
- 13:21By conference, the CSR top 25 has six teams from the ACC, five from the SEC, four Big 12 schools, three out of the Big 10, a couple from the Ivy League, and one each from the America East, American, Big East, MAC, and Pac-12.
- 13:36The women's AP poll, by comparison, did not have any mid-major teams, instead electing 24 teams from the top four conferences and Connecticut from the Big East.
- 13:46We'll have a 76-team NCAA tournament in 2027, the first to be that large.
- 13:51The play-in game seed lines will likely be lower than they have been historically.
- 13:55The at-large play-in games in the theoretical bracket based on the CSR come between the 12 and 14 seed lines.
- 14:02Our multi-bid conferences, after just one week of games, the ACC and Big 12 would have 11 bids.
- 14:08The SEC would have 10, the Big 10 nine.
- 14:11There's a huge drop-off down to the Big East, who would have four deserving resumes.
- 14:15Then the America East, Big West, Ivy League, and MAC would each have two teams in the projected field as of this week.
- 14:22If we use the CSR formulas, the last four teams into the tournament are Tennessee, Kansas, Mississippi State, and Missouri, so three SEC teams and a Big 12 squad.
- 14:31The first four out are Canisius from the Metro, St.
- 14:34John's, Penn, and Colorado.
- 14:37If you want to check out what the entirety of the bracket would look like, head over to commonsensrankings.com and go to the women's basketball page.
- 14:44You can also put blind resumes against one another, see where conference head-to-head stand, and see the full one through 363 rankings updated daily.
- 14:52In the women's tournament, there are two regional sites, and the top four seeds in each quarter of the bracket play host for the first and second round.
- 14:59They also adjusted the seeding procedure to go straight snake through the first four lines, so no more adjusting seeding based on conference affiliation.
- 15:06In the first Philadelphia regional, Alabama is the top seed, Miami the two, Rice the three, and Wake Forest the four.
- 15:13In the second Philly regional, West Virginia would be the top seed with San Diego State at the two, Virginia at the three, and Ohio State at the four.
- 15:21In the Vegas three bracket, the one seed is Kentucky, the two seed Princeton, three is California, and fourth seed Virginia Tech.
- 15:28And in the Las Vegas four portion of the bracket, Florida is the one seed, Columbia the two, Rutgers the three, and Clemson the four.
- 15:37We've now reached the portion of the podcast where I put two resumes next to one another, team names and opponent names excluded, to show where the AP voters are misjudging teams.
- 15:46In blind resume test number one, team A is three and O.
- 15:49They have two wins over the Atlantic 10 and one over the Missouri Valley.
- 15:52Those three schools have a combined two Division I victories.
- 15:56Team B is one and one.
- 15:57They won against an A-10 team that has two other wins already, and they lost to an undefeated SEC school.
- 16:03Team A has not only matched team B's wins, but then they have two more.
- 16:07They also sit without a loss compared to team B's early defeat.
- 16:11Team A is Columbia, who did not receive a place on any voter's ballot this week.
- 16:15Team B is Maryland, who has proved they're only better than half the teams they've faced so far this season and yet are number 11 in the AP poll.
- 16:22In the CSR, Columbia is number five and Maryland is down at number 142.
- 16:28In blind resume test number two, team A is O and two.
- 16:32They lost to two undefeated SEC programs.
- 16:35Team B, meanwhile, is three and O.
- 16:36They have wins over a CAA team and two teams from the Metro Conference, and their opponents have a combined one Division I victory.
- 16:43So the question we're asking here, does losing to two good teams make a resume better than beating three below average teams?
- 16:48The CSR says no, but the AP voters say yes.
- 16:52Team A is North Carolina, who lost to Oklahoma and South Carolina to start the season.
- 16:57They've yet to prove they're better than anybody, and yet sit twenty-third in the AP poll.
- 17:02Albany is team B, undefeated, albeit against lesser competition, but nobody has proven they're better than the Great Danes.
- 17:08This is likely the best representation of power conference and brand bias that we're going to get.
- 17:13In the CSR, Albany is twentieth, while winless North Carolina is down at number two hundred and seventy-seven.
- 17:21The thirty-three AP poll voters for the women's basketball got off to a tough start in comparison with the common sense rankings.
- 17:27Of the top twenty-five on the court resumes this season, the AP voters correctly identified just four of them, and none of the top ten.
- 17:35While good is hard to come by, Kentucky was somewhat appropriately ranked.
- 17:38The Wildcats were closest in ranking between the CSR and AP, with the Wildcats being number twelve according to the voters, and number three according to the formula.
- 17:48Princeton managed to find their way onto a ballot, which is a win for the mid-majors, but the majority of the feedback I'd give would be bad.
- 17:55A defeated team is considered the twenty-third best in the country.
- 17:58A team with no wins considered better than twenty-nine teams with three Division I wins is just astounding.
- 18:04Oklahoma State is another one without justification.
- 18:07The Cowgirls beat a team from the MIAC and another from the SWAC so far, two of the lowest ranked conferences year in and year out, and their resume was judged as the nineteenth best in the country thus far.
- 18:18With just thirty-three voters up for the women's poll, there's less to sift through when looking for good and bad ballots.
- 18:24Following just one week of games, any team that has suffered a loss, regardless of who it was to, does not deserve a top twenty-five rank.
- 18:31All ballots had UConn and Iowa, but two voters left their one loss teams at just those two.
- 18:36Shout out to Kendall Lanier and Olivia Eisenhower for doing the right thing for undefeated teams.
- 18:42West Virginia is the highest ranked team in the CSR that made the AP.
- 18:46Marissa Sisk had the Mountaineers the highest, placing them 20th on her ballot.
- 18:50Lastly, Mel Greenberg was the lone voter to throw Princeton a bone, putting the Tigers as her 25th ranked team.
- 18:56Princeton is number six in the CSR this week.
- 19:00Among the many, many bad things, UConn sits two and one, yes, with a win over the Big Ten, but three voters thought their resume was second best, including better than the team that beat them.
- 19:09Those three voters were Camille Gear, Britt Delbarba, and Olivia Eisenhower, who finds herself on the good and bad side of the CSR this week.
- 19:17And lastly, I love recognition of mid-major success, but Fairfield is two and O with wins over two America East teams.
- 19:23They're number 61 in the CSR, but made Maggie Vanoni's ballot at number 24.
- 19:28Maggie may be a little too high on the Stags given the games they've played thus far.
- 19:33With the totality of resumes being considered in the Common Sense rankings, teams that schedule and win more games early will move to the top of the Common Sense rankings.
- 19:42There are four teams that could finish the second week at six and O, and would likely find themselves near the top of next week's list: Alabama, who's already number one, then Princeton, TCU, and Louisville.
- 19:53Twenty-nine more teams could finish the week five and O, so it may be another log jam in the top 25 next week.
- 19:59Twenty-seven matchups will lower the ceiling on a conference during week two.
- 20:03Those critical matchups include games between conferences that play just once or twice all season, so they are identified as must-wins for the conferences of the teams involved.
- 20:12For the bigger conferences, the ACC again back-loaded the crucial non-conference matchups, so a potential loss this coming week is able to be overcome.
- 20:21The Big 12 will have one when UCF takes on South Alabama.
- 20:25That will be the lone matchup between the Big 12 and Sun Belt this season, and is critical if the Big 12 wants to claim the title of best conference this season.
- 20:32As of this recording, that game had been completed Monday, and the Knights did manage to get the crucial win.
- 20:38The SEC will have just two matchups they'll need to win to keep pace with the other power conferences.
- 20:43Oklahoma plays San Jose State Tuesday night in the lone SEC Mountain West matchup this season.
- 20:49LSU plays Denver on Friday in the only game the SEC currently has scheduled against the West Coast Conference.
- 20:55Leading in the crucial matchups department this week is both the Big East and Big 10, each with three such games.
- 21:01For the Big East, Marquette will play in two of them, against the Big South's Presbyterian on Tuesday night and against Missouri State of Conference USA.
- 21:08Both matchups are the only games between those conferences this season.
- 21:12The third is Butler versus UT Martin of the Ohio Valley.
- 21:15For the Big Ten, two of their teams will play Samford of the Southern Conference, Indiana Friday and Purdue Saturday.
- 21:21If Samford can win either game, it'll lower the Big Ten's ceiling in women's basketball this season.
- 21:26The third game for the Big Ten is Wisconsin versus Delaware on Wednesday, the first of two Big Ten Conference USA games scheduled this season.
- 21:35And that will do it for another weekly recap on the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 21:39If you're a data nerd and want more data on the key games, you can follow me at comsenseranking on the socials and head to commonsensererankings.com, where I'll be updating everything every morning.
- 21:48There's also a weekly bracket build based on wins and losses, conference information, and a blind resume game if you wanna dig deeper into the active seasons.
- 21:56Thanks again for listening, and please, as you go about your day-to-day, use some common sense.