Latest / A Little Bit Richer / The Psychology Behind Your Spending
Transcript
- 0:01Iona Bain: Hello, I'm Iona Bain, and welcome to A Little Bit
- 0:04Iona Bain: Richer, brought to you by Legal and General. Now, author
- 0:09Iona Bain: of Money on Your Mind: The Psychology Behind Your Financial
- 0:12Iona Bain: Habits Vicky Reynal is here to explain the psychology of
- 0:16Iona Bain: our spending. Vicky is a financial psychotherapist and runs her
- 0:20Iona Bain: own clinic in London. She offers psychological support to people
- 0:25Iona Bain: with money worries, such as overspending or debt, and combines
- 0:29Iona Bain: this with guidance on making healthier money decisions. She also
- 0:33Iona Bain: writes a weekly column for The Daily Mail, answering reader
- 0:36Iona Bain: questions as their financial psychotherapist. Welcome, Vicky.
- 0:41Vicky Reynal: Thank you. Thank you for having me.
- 0:43Iona Bain: Firstly, what is financial psychotherapy and how is it different
- 0:48Iona Bain: from financial coaching?
- 0:50Vicky Reynal: What I'm trying to help people do is unpick what
- 0:54Vicky Reynal: feelings or emotions might be driving their money choices. People
- 0:58Vicky Reynal: might come because they're overly generous and they don't know
- 1:01Vicky Reynal: why that is, and they know it's against what's best
- 1:05Vicky Reynal: in their financial interests but they can't stop themselves. What
- 1:08Vicky Reynal: I often find is that there's feelings that are unconscious that
- 1:12Vicky Reynal: are getting in the way. My job is to help
- 1:15Vicky Reynal: them unpack that and understand it so that they can
- 1:17Vicky Reynal: change the way they behave with money.
- 1:20Iona Bain: I'm imagining that your upbringing is really important in shaping
- 1:24Iona Bain: your relationship with money. I've heard that you form your
- 1:29Iona Bain: attitude to money by the age of eight. I'm wondering,
- 1:33Iona Bain: is there any truth in that?
- 1:35Vicky Reynal: There is some truth. I wouldn't pinpoint it to a
- 1:38Vicky Reynal: specific age because I think that a lot of experiences
- 1:41Vicky Reynal: that we have in later years will shape our relationship
- 1:45Vicky Reynal: with money in the longterm. Of course, the money lessons
- 1:48Vicky Reynal: that our parents teach us growing up will have an
- 1:51Vicky Reynal: impact on our relationship with money. If they tell us, "
- 1:54Vicky Reynal: Don't be too greedy," or, " Money corrupts you," that will
- 1:57Vicky Reynal: be in the back of your mind as you're trying
- 2:00Vicky Reynal: to ask for a raise, for example. But there's a
- 2:03Vicky Reynal: lot of non- money related experiences when we're young that
- 2:07Vicky Reynal: will shape what we do with money when we're old.
- 2:11Vicky Reynal: Let's say you've been bullied a lot in school, or
- 2:13Vicky Reynal: you felt different, you might find that, as an adult,
- 2:16Vicky Reynal: you tend to overspend when you're out with friends. It's
- 2:20Vicky Reynal: because you're trying to fit in.
- 2:21Iona Bain: It's like you're trying to buy acceptance.
- 2:23Vicky Reynal: Exactly. Which isn't about the money lessons learned, it's about
- 2:27Vicky Reynal: something very different. Or you might see people who really
- 2:30Vicky Reynal: struggle to spend money on themselves, so they become very
- 2:33Vicky Reynal: frugal. That might come from a feeling that you're not
- 2:37Vicky Reynal: really deserving of the good things that money can buy,
- 2:40Vicky Reynal: that you feel guilty any time you spend anything on
- 2:44Vicky Reynal: yourself. That might come from experiences growing up in which
- 2:48Vicky Reynal: maybe your parents were not paying a lot of attention
- 2:51Vicky Reynal: to you, or harsh teachers, or whatnot, that left you with
- 2:55Vicky Reynal: a really small confidence in yourself.
- 2:57Iona Bain: And low self-esteem.
- 2:57Vicky Reynal: Exactly.
- 2:57Iona Bain: Someone, I imagine, could be a big spender as an
- 3:01Iona Bain: adult, but maybe their parents are quite frugal actually. Can
- 3:05Iona Bain: you explain why there can be those kinds of differences?
- 3:08Vicky Reynal: Our relationship with money has to do with so many
- 3:11Vicky Reynal: different psychological factors, like our sense of deservedness, our personality,
- 3:16Vicky Reynal: which is why you see in families with many children
- 3:19Vicky Reynal: how siblings might end up having very different attitudes to
- 3:22Vicky Reynal: money even though they have the same parents teaching the
- 3:25Vicky Reynal: same lessons. Because what drives our overspending, it could be
- 3:29Vicky Reynal: coming from social pressures. Lifestyle inflation is very common. That
- 3:34Vicky Reynal: term basically describes a phenomenon, when your income rises, your
- 3:38Vicky Reynal: spending rises with it. Your costs go up and you
- 3:41Vicky Reynal: end up in a worse financial situation on this higher
- 3:44Vicky Reynal: salary than you before in the first place. Sometimes what's
- 3:48Vicky Reynal: driving it is internal rather than external. If we don't
- 3:51Vicky Reynal: feel lovable enough, we might go out there and spend
- 3:54Vicky Reynal: on maybe beauty products or gadgets. It's that internal insecurity
- 4:00Vicky Reynal: that might be manifesting through their spending.
- 4:03Iona Bain: Well, speaking of social pressures, they influence our spending behaviors
- 4:06Iona Bain: in so many ways. Can you give me a few
- 4:08Iona Bain: examples?
- 4:09Vicky Reynal: Yes. The fear of missing out is one that particularly
- 4:12Vicky Reynal: young people often talk about. There's a lot of insecurity,
- 4:17Vicky Reynal: sometimes of exclusion, sometimes it's about not being able to
- 4:22Vicky Reynal: feel part of the conversation next time you're with them.
- 4:26Vicky Reynal: And even fear of rejection or abandonment in some cases,
- 4:29Vicky Reynal: so you'll do it literally at all costs. You'll go
- 4:32Vicky Reynal: to that wedding abroad that you know you can't afford.
- 4:36Vicky Reynal: People can be so ashamed of admitting that they can't
- 4:39Vicky Reynal: afford something. But actually, what they end up finding most
- 4:43Vicky Reynal: of the times is that somebody else in that group
- 4:45Vicky Reynal: is just relieved that they said something.
- 4:47Iona Bain: Yeah.
- 4:48Vicky Reynal: Maybe there is a cheaper restaurant we can go to.
- 4:52Vicky Reynal: But we often feel ashamed and alone with our money
- 4:55Vicky Reynal: worries, and that stops us from questioning these social pressures.
- 4:59Iona Bain: And social media as well must be playing quite a
- 5:03Iona Bain: big role. How are you seeing that reflected in the cases
- 5:06Iona Bain: that you deal with?
- 5:07Vicky Reynal: If we are curious about comparing upwards, well, the algorithms
- 5:12Vicky Reynal: will pick that up and just feed us more of
- 5:14Vicky Reynal: that content. Which creates an illusion, because what we see
- 5:19Vicky Reynal: is people spending and we're assuming that they're in a
- 5:22Vicky Reynal: better financial situation. What we're not seeing is all the
- 5:25Vicky Reynal: debt that might be sitting behind some of the spending.
- 5:28Vicky Reynal: We're left with a sense of shame that everybody else
- 5:32Vicky Reynal: is doing better than us and we need to catch
- 5:34Vicky Reynal: up, and not a lot of critical thinking goes into
- 5:38Vicky Reynal: that.
- 5:39Iona Bain: There's also this concept of retail therapy. When does that
- 5:43Iona Bain: become problematic? Why do you think people turn to shopping
- 5:47Iona Bain: so much as a way to self- soothe?
- 5:51Vicky Reynal: Because it can be quite effective in the short term.
- 5:54Vicky Reynal: When you find something that you like and you buy
- 5:57Vicky Reynal: it, you get dopamine released in the brain, which means
- 6:00Vicky Reynal: that you do get a real sensation of feeling better.
- 6:03Iona Bain: You get a high.
- 6:04Vicky Reynal: It also distracts you, let's face it. Then the effect
- 6:08Vicky Reynal: fades away, and you're left sometimes with the guilt and
- 6:12Vicky Reynal: regret. But also, the feelings you were trying to avoid
- 6:16Vicky Reynal: are still there, be it the sadness, be it the
- 6:19Vicky Reynal: loneliness, the stress, whatever it was. Isn't it better to
- 6:24Vicky Reynal: just deal with the roots of the problem, rather than
- 6:27Vicky Reynal: trying to fix it with a quick boost that then will
- 6:30Vicky Reynal: leave you feeling worse?
- 6:31Iona Bain: Does it take quite a long time for people to
- 6:33Iona Bain: accept that they might have a problem with overspending?
- 6:36Vicky Reynal: There is a lot of denial around it. We can
- 6:39Vicky Reynal: justify it in our minds and think that it's normal.
- 6:43Vicky Reynal: I would invite people to think about what's this about?
- 6:46Vicky Reynal: Why did I have to go out there and spend?
- 6:48Vicky Reynal: Really acknowledge the cost, which is not just financial. It's
- 6:51Vicky Reynal: also all the anxiety it leaves people with.
- 6:55Iona Bain: Absolutely. In your book, you make a distinction between overspending
- 7:01Iona Bain: and financial self- sabotage, which is really interesting. Can you
- 7:05Iona Bain: tell me a bit more about why there's a difference
- 7:07Iona Bain: between the two?
- 7:08Vicky Reynal: Overspending can have so many different sources. One of the
- 7:13Vicky Reynal: reasons why we might be doing it is because we're
- 7:16Vicky Reynal: unconsciously trying to get into financial trouble. I've seen people,
- 7:20Vicky Reynal: for example, who were so scared of moving out of
- 7:23Vicky Reynal: their parents house, of becoming financially dependent, they kept spending
- 7:28Vicky Reynal: all their money, running out, so that they would have an
- 7:31Vicky Reynal: excuse to stay home. Another example that I've seen was
- 7:35Vicky Reynal: one young man who kept running out of money in
- 7:37Vicky Reynal: the first two weeks of the month. We were trying
- 7:40Vicky Reynal: to spot patterns. The question that unlocked the case, so
- 7:44Vicky Reynal: to speak, was when I asked, " Well, what do you
- 7:47Vicky Reynal: do when you run out of money?" He said, " I
- 7:49Vicky Reynal: call my dad." I said, " Okay, how's that relationship?" " Well,
- 7:53Vicky Reynal: I never speak to him anymore now that my parents
- 7:55Vicky Reynal: divorce."
- 7:57Iona Bain: Right.
- 7:57Vicky Reynal: You realize, well, that was his motive. This overspending was
- 8:01Vicky Reynal: all about ruining the financial situation so that he could
- 8:05Vicky Reynal: still have a relationship with his dad that he didn't
- 8:07Vicky Reynal: know how to have otherwise.
- 8:09Iona Bain: But once you'd unpacked that, it must have absolutely blown
- 8:13Iona Bain: his mind to realize that that's why he was doing
- 8:15Iona Bain: what he was doing.
- 8:16Vicky Reynal: It opened up a difficult question, which is how can
- 8:19Vicky Reynal: I have a relationship with my dad outside of this?
- 8:22Vicky Reynal: We needed to think about ways to build that relationship.
- 8:26Iona Bain: Really, it was more about finding better coping strategies for
- 8:29Iona Bain: that relationship that would then have a positive knock- on
- 8:32Iona Bain: effect for how he was managing his money.
- 8:34Vicky Reynal: Exactly. Overspending is one way to do it, but a
- 8:37Vicky Reynal: lot of people sabotage their finances by not attending to
- 8:40Vicky Reynal: them, not talking about money. Suddenly, they're in this big
- 8:43Vicky Reynal: mess because they weren't opening the bills.
- 8:46Iona Bain: Yeah.
- 8:46Vicky Reynal: Begin to unpack, " What am I gaining from this situation?
- 8:50Vicky Reynal: Why am I doing this?" It could be because, at
- 8:53Vicky Reynal: some level, you feel you deserve punishment and that's a
- 8:57Vicky Reynal: very painful thing to uncover. Certain people might go through
- 9:01Vicky Reynal: life with the sense that they don't deserve anything good. It
- 9:04Vicky Reynal: could be because you desire rescue and that makes you
- 9:07Vicky Reynal: feel looked after by other people.
- 9:09Iona Bain: Do you think sometimes people also fear failing as well?
- 9:14Iona Bain: That might explain why sometimes people don't want to tackle
- 9:17Iona Bain: their finances, because that way, they can't fail at it.
- 9:20Vicky Reynal: That's where sometimes the a- ha moment happens, when they
- 9:24Vicky Reynal: see that actually, the very thing I was terrified of
- 9:27Vicky Reynal: is happening through inaction. Is there a way for you
- 9:32Vicky Reynal: to get more hold of your sense of agency and say, "
- 9:35Vicky Reynal: Fine. I might not do it perfectly, but doing something
- 9:39Vicky Reynal: is better than doing nothing." People carry a lot of
- 9:42Vicky Reynal: shame when it comes to money, and a lot of
- 9:44Vicky Reynal: fear as well. A lot of times, what helps with
- 9:48Vicky Reynal: that financial anxiety is knowledge. It's beginning to identify what
- 9:54Vicky Reynal: is the fear about? A lot of that could be
- 9:56Vicky Reynal: about not understanding the terminology, or not knowing what the
- 10:00Vicky Reynal: options are.
- 10:01Iona Bain: And because it can also feel quite overwhelming. But I
- 10:04Iona Bain: guess, you got to start somewhere. Once you actually start
- 10:08Iona Bain: looking into these things, they're probably not as scary as
- 10:10Iona Bain: you think.
- 10:11Vicky Reynal: That's right. In fact, when you look at research, more
- 10:14Vicky Reynal: than 50% of the population suffers from financial anxiety. The
- 10:18Vicky Reynal: one thing that really decreases the level of anxiety is
- 10:22Vicky Reynal: financial literacy. The more we know, the less anxious we
- 10:26Vicky Reynal: feel about it.
- 10:27Iona Bain: Hear, hear. Knowledge is power. With that in mind, let's
- 10:31Iona Bain: get to know another concept, the scarcity mindset. How does
- 10:35Iona Bain: that lead to unhealthy financial behaviors?
- 10:39Vicky Reynal: Scarcity mindset is the financial equivalent of seeing the glass
- 10:43Vicky Reynal: half empty.
- 10:44Iona Bain: Right.
- 10:44Vicky Reynal: You're focusing on what you don't have, rather than appreciating
- 10:49Vicky Reynal: what you have and looking at the potential. A scarcity
- 10:53Vicky Reynal: mindset can be quite unhelpful because it leaves people feeling
- 10:57Vicky Reynal: very afraid and insecure financially. Some people, when they feel
- 11:02Vicky Reynal: that way, they might feel paralyzed, rather than starting with
- 11:06Vicky Reynal: small steps that can help them feel more financial resilience.
- 11:11Vicky Reynal: For example, putting away, even if it's five pounds a
- 11:14Vicky Reynal: week, can start building a safety net that's there for
- 11:18Vicky Reynal: emergencies. Isn't that better than not doing anything? I've also
- 11:24Vicky Reynal: seen people becoming very frugal or overworking, accumulating, hoarding money,
- 11:31Vicky Reynal: unable to enjoy it. Unable to ever feel like they
- 11:34Vicky Reynal: can stop and take a break, and say no to
- 11:36Vicky Reynal: a project. It's just that anxiety that it generates when
- 11:40Vicky Reynal: you feel like there just isn't enough, and you're constantly
- 11:44Vicky Reynal: battling with the worries about the future.
- 11:48Iona Bain: I'm wondering if Ebeneezer Scrooge had the scarcity mindset. If
- 11:52Iona Bain: he was a real person, he would do.
- 11:55Vicky Reynal: Absolutely. What you want is the opposite, the abundance mindset.
- 12:00Vicky Reynal: Which is one in which you can feel satisfied as
- 12:04Vicky Reynal: much as one can when it comes to money, but
- 12:06Vicky Reynal: at least you can appreciate that you have enough to
- 12:08Vicky Reynal: be doing certain things. Part of the definition of financial
- 12:12Vicky Reynal: wellbeing is about feeling happy and in control of your
- 12:16Vicky Reynal: financial choices. There's things that you can do to improve
- 12:20Vicky Reynal: your situation. But we can also get creative and think, "
- 12:24Vicky Reynal: Well, maybe there is a little side gig I can start." I don't know, "
- 12:28Vicky Reynal: I can sell a few things on Vinted or eBay."
- 12:31Vicky Reynal: Or maybe I can start tutoring to get some extra
- 12:34Vicky Reynal: cash. When we become paralyzed by fear, it stops any
- 12:38Vicky Reynal: creative thinking and that's what we need to get hold
- 12:41Vicky Reynal: of. What can I do?
- 12:42Iona Bain: Can people start to want more money because they feel
- 12:46Iona Bain: that what they have is never enough? Is that also
- 12:48Iona Bain: an example of a scarcity mindset?
- 12:51Vicky Reynal: Well, yes. It's a result of it. The problem is
- 12:54Vicky Reynal: that the goalpost keeps moving. If you don't get to
- 12:58Vicky Reynal: a place in which you can appreciate what you have
- 13:03Vicky Reynal: and work with those fears, reality check them. Am I
- 13:08Vicky Reynal: catastrophizing when I feel I don't have enough? Then you
- 13:11Vicky Reynal: won't be able to move past that, and there isn't
- 13:14Vicky Reynal: enough money in the world that will help you feel
- 13:17Vicky Reynal: safe enough if that sense of unsafety is coming from
- 13:21Vicky Reynal: somewhere else that isn't just financial.
- 13:23Iona Bain: Yes, because we do hear about incredibly wealthy people seemingly
- 13:28Iona Bain: never satisfied with how much money they have. But is
- 13:31Iona Bain: there some truth in the idea that, once you get
- 13:34Iona Bain: to that point, you're no longer satisfied with what you've
- 13:37Iona Bain: got? You're just thinking about what you can get next.
- 13:40Vicky Reynal: I think it comes down to what is wealth for
- 13:42Vicky Reynal: you, can you define that? Sometimes we get stuck thinking
- 13:47Vicky Reynal: that things will make us happy. But actually, when you
- 13:50Vicky Reynal: sit and think about the things that you value, it
- 13:53Vicky Reynal: might be time with family and friends.
- 13:55Iona Bain: Yeah.
- 13:56Vicky Reynal: Sometimes when you are stuck in this greedy pursuit of
- 13:59Vicky Reynal: wealth, it really begs the question, well, have you attached
- 14:03Vicky Reynal: more to money than it can actually deliver to you?
- 14:07Vicky Reynal: Is it that you're imagining it will make you more
- 14:10Vicky Reynal: lovable, it will attract more friends? There's all these symbolic
- 14:15Vicky Reynal: meanings that we give to money, and then some people
- 14:18Vicky Reynal: have the fortune or misfortune of finding out when they
- 14:21Vicky Reynal: have enough wealth that actually money didn't deliver on its
- 14:23Vicky Reynal: promise.
- 14:25Iona Bain: Yeah, you never want to get to that point where
- 14:26Iona Bain: you work so hard, and then you realize actually, it
- 14:30Iona Bain: wasn't the money that I needed after all, it was something
- 14:32Iona Bain: else. Yeah. For those listening who think that they might
- 14:36Iona Bain: have a scarcity mindset, what would you recommend for them,
- 14:40Iona Bain: in terms of turning that around and creating more of
- 14:43Iona Bain: an abundance mindset?
- 14:44Vicky Reynal: One thing is to catch yourself thinking about what you
- 14:49Vicky Reynal: don't have and try to very actively just shift what
- 14:54Vicky Reynal: you're focusing on to what you have. You might write
- 14:57Vicky Reynal: a gratitude journal about all the things that the money
- 15:00Vicky Reynal: that you have spent so far has helped you enjoy,
- 15:04Vicky Reynal: be it holidays or education. Some people find journaling really
- 15:09Vicky Reynal: helpful and it can be jotting the patterns. Or even,
- 15:13Vicky Reynal: just brainstorming with open questions. When I think about money,
- 15:18Vicky Reynal: I feel X. Or even going back to the first
- 15:21Vicky Reynal: money memories, that can be quite insightful. If all you
- 15:25Vicky Reynal: remember was parents taking a deep sigh at the till,
- 15:29Vicky Reynal: then you might begin to understand why you avoid the
- 15:33Vicky Reynal: topic of money. Or if you watched them argue about
- 15:35Vicky Reynal: it a lot when you were little, then you might
- 15:38Vicky Reynal: be avoiding the topic in your relationship. But there's a
- 15:41Vicky Reynal: lot of other things that can keep fueling this scarcity
- 15:45Vicky Reynal: mindset, like too much social media exposure. Are you always
- 15:49Vicky Reynal: looking at what other people have and comparing yourself unfairly
- 15:53Vicky Reynal: to that? Well, maybe try to do less of that.
- 15:56Vicky Reynal: Sometimes it's also about watching out what we read, because
- 16:00Vicky Reynal: there's a lot of news that maybe end up making
- 16:04Vicky Reynal: you feel more anxious. Choose reading that is more nurturing,
- 16:08Vicky Reynal: in which you're actually learning how you can improve your
- 16:11Vicky Reynal: situation, rather than dwelling into how much worse things could
- 16:15Vicky Reynal: get. Paying attention to all these things can really shift
- 16:20Vicky Reynal: your perspective onto what is within your control, what you
- 16:25Vicky Reynal: can do differently.
- 16:27Iona Bain: Absolutely. One of my mottos is focus on what's doable.
- 16:30Iona Bain: We can't achieve a perfect scenario with our finances, but
- 16:33Iona Bain: there are things that we can do. It's about getting
- 16:36Iona Bain: on with those things.
- 16:37Vicky Reynal: Yeah.
- 16:38Iona Bain: Can you suggest three simple money habits that will make
- 16:42Iona Bain: us feel more secure and satisfied when it comes to
- 16:45Iona Bain: money?
- 16:45Vicky Reynal: Well, money is still a big taboo. I would say
- 16:48Vicky Reynal: the first one is talk about it with people you
- 16:50Vicky Reynal: trust. If you're worried about money, why not open up to
- 16:53Vicky Reynal: somebody? You might find that they either have the same
- 16:56Vicky Reynal: worries, or might have some information that is useful. Talking
- 17:00Vicky Reynal: about it can help you make sense of things. My
- 17:03Vicky Reynal: second tip would be create a dedicated time in which
- 17:08Vicky Reynal: you attend to finances. That's helpful for people on all
- 17:13Vicky Reynal: ends of the spectrum. Find a time, maybe in the
- 17:16Vicky Reynal: week or in the month, in which you will review
- 17:19Vicky Reynal: your finances, maybe set some goals or look at your
- 17:23Vicky Reynal: accounts, whatever it is, and don't miss it. If you're
- 17:27Vicky Reynal: a couple, maybe it can be a money date in
- 17:29Vicky Reynal: which you jointly do that and talk about your finances.
- 17:34Vicky Reynal: Finally, I would say be curious about why you do
- 17:37Vicky Reynal: what you do with money. Pick up on the patterns. "
- 17:41Vicky Reynal: Oh, I always overspend when I'm out with friends." Or, "
- 17:44Vicky Reynal: It's always on a Sunday when I'm feeling lonely." I
- 17:47Vicky Reynal: think start by asking yourself why more often. That would
- 17:51Vicky Reynal: be my third tip.
- 17:52Iona Bain: Vicky, this has been a fascinating conversation.
- 17:55Vicky Reynal: Oh, thank you very much.
- 17:58Iona Bain: Thank you so much, Vicky. Lots of a- ha moments
- 18:01Iona Bain: there, for sure. Next time on the show, I'll be
- 18:03Iona Bain: joined by Helen Tupper from Amazing If to talk about
- 18:07Iona Bain: why our career paths need to be less linear and
- 18:10Iona Bain: more squiggly. I'd love it if you could follow the
- 18:12Iona Bain: podcast, leave us a review, and help others get a
- 18:15Iona Bain: little bit richer, too. You can keep up with the
- 18:17Iona Bain: show on YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram @ legalandgeneral. Thanks for listening.
- 18:22Iona Bain: Until next time, see you soon.