Latest / Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar / 12/3/25: Trump Demands Somalis Out Of US, Hillary Complains About Pro-Palestine TikTok, UK PM Tries To Silence Emily
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Hey, guys, Saga and Crystal here.
- 0:01Speaker 2: Independent media just played a truly massive role in this election,
- 0:05Speaker 2: and we are so excited about what that means for
- 0:07Speaker 2: the future of this show.
- 0:08Speaker 1: This is the only place where you can find honest
- 0:10Speaker 1: perspectives from the left and the right that simply does
- 0:13Speaker 1: not exist anywhere else.
- 0:14Speaker 2: So if that is something that's important to you, please
- 0:17Speaker 2: go to Breakingpoints dot com. Become a member today and
- 0:19Speaker 2: you'll get access to our full shows, unedited, ad free,
- 0:22Speaker 2: and all put together for you every morning in your inbox.
- 0:25Speaker 1: We need your help to build the future of independent
- 0:27Speaker 1: news media and we hope to see you at Breakingpoints
- 0:29Speaker 1: dot com.
- 0:34Speaker 3: Well.
- 0:34Speaker 4: In Donald Trump's marathon year end two hour plus cabinet
- 0:38Speaker 4: meeting at the White House yesterday, you won't be surprised
- 0:41Speaker 4: that he brought up the allegations that about a billion
- 0:44Speaker 4: dollars in taxpayer money was stolen in three different fraud
- 0:47Speaker 4: schemes perpetrated mostly by Somali's in Minnesota. Now, this is
- 0:54Speaker 4: what Trump had to say. We're gonna break it down.
- 0:56Speaker 4: But those are the allegations as they stand. Of the
- 0:59Speaker 4: people who have been try I believe only eight are
- 1:01Speaker 4: are not Minnesota and Somali's part of the diaspora, so
- 1:06Speaker 4: that's where this is coming from. Obviously, you've probably already
- 1:08Speaker 4: seen The New York Times ran a big story about this.
- 1:11Speaker 4: Semaphore reports that story came after or came out when
- 1:15Speaker 4: it did, because the New York Times was trying to
- 1:17Speaker 4: beat Chris Rufo of the Manhattan Institute and City Journal,
- 1:21Speaker 4: so conservative think tank to the Punch because they outlined
- 1:24Speaker 4: their story which is a bit different from.
- 1:27Speaker 5: The New York Times story.
- 1:27Speaker 4: And I think Ryan and I will get into why,
- 1:29Speaker 4: because Rufo actually alleged based on sourcing that some of
- 1:33Speaker 4: the money because it was going to remittances, which is
- 1:36Speaker 4: a huge part of Somalia's economy, we're funding al Shabab.
- 1:42Speaker 4: That's we're going to put aside for just one second
- 1:44Speaker 4: and take a listen here to what Donald Trump and
- 1:46Speaker 4: Christy Nome had to say.
- 1:48Speaker 5: Let's start with Trump yesterday.
- 1:49Speaker 6: Samaria's ripped off that state for billions of dollars billions
- 1:56Speaker 6: every year, billions of dollars, and.
- 2:01Speaker 7: They contribute nothing. The welfare is like eighty eight percent.
- 2:06Speaker 7: They contribute nothing. I don't want them in our country,
- 2:09Speaker 7: I'll be honest with you.
- 2:11Speaker 8: So we would say, oh, that's not politically correct.
- 2:13Speaker 7: I don't care. I don't want them in our country.
- 2:15Speaker 7: Their country is no good for a reason. Their country stakes,
- 2:20Speaker 7: and we don't want them in our country. I can
- 2:22Speaker 7: say that about other countries too. I can say that
- 2:25Speaker 7: about other countries too. We don't want them to help.
- 2:27Speaker 9: We got to.
- 2:28Speaker 7: We have to rebuild our country. You know, our countries
- 2:31Speaker 7: at a tipping point.
- 2:33Speaker 6: We could go bad.
- 2:34Speaker 8: We're at a tipping point. I don't know if people
- 2:36Speaker 8: mind me saying that, but I'm saying that we could
- 2:39Speaker 8: go one way or the other, and we're going to
- 2:42Speaker 8: go the wrong way if we keep taking in garbage
- 2:45Speaker 8: into our country. Elan Omar is garbage. She's garbage. Her
- 2:50Speaker 8: friends are garbage. These are people that work.
- 2:53Speaker 7: These are people that say, let's go, come on, let's
- 2:55Speaker 7: make this place great.
- 2:56Speaker 8: These are people that do nothing but complain.
- 2:59Speaker 4: And here's what Homeland Security Secretary Christy Noms said at
- 3:02Speaker 4: that same cabinet meeting.
- 3:03Speaker 3: You told me to look into Minnesota and their fraud
- 3:06Speaker 3: on visas and their programs. Fifty percent of them are fraudulent,
- 3:12Speaker 3: Which means that that wacko governor Walls either is an idiot.
- 3:18Speaker 3: Or he did it on purpose, and I think he's bold, sir.
- 3:22Speaker 3: He brought people in there illegally that never should have
- 3:26Speaker 3: been in this country, said they were somebody that they're not.
- 3:30Speaker 3: They said they were married to somebody who was their
- 3:32Speaker 3: brother or somebody else. Fraudulent visa applications, signed up for
- 3:37Speaker 3: government programs, took hundreds of billions of dollars from the taxpayers,
- 3:42Speaker 3: and we're going to remove them and we're going to
- 3:43Speaker 3: get our money back.
- 3:45Speaker 9: So no.
- 3:45Speaker 4: Echoing Trump's harsh language about Minnesota governor at Tim Walls there,
- 3:49Speaker 4: Trump called Tim Wallas quote seriously retarded. Over the weekend,
- 3:53Speaker 4: Walls went on Meet the Press and responded, here's a
- 3:55Speaker 4: little bit from them.
- 3:56Speaker 10: Certainly, I take responsibility for putting people in jail. Don't
- 4:00Speaker 10: get to just talk theoretically. We have to solve problems.
- 4:03Speaker 10: And I will note it's not just Somali's. Minnesota is
- 4:07Speaker 10: a generous state. Minnesota's a prosperous days, a well run
- 4:10Speaker 10: state or triple A bond rated. But that attracts criminals.
- 4:13Speaker 10: Those people are going to jail. We're doing everything we can,
- 4:16Speaker 10: but to demonize an entire community on the actions of
- 4:19Speaker 10: a few it's lazy.
- 4:21Speaker 4: So while taking credit there for what has been a
- 4:24Speaker 4: federal investigation, Walls really has not had much to do
- 4:27Speaker 4: with it. Ryan, there's a lot to talk about in
- 4:30Speaker 4: this story. What's your initial reaction to the back and
- 4:33Speaker 4: forth over the last few days.
- 4:35Speaker 11: That well, so, and we should should we get into
- 4:38Speaker 11: rufos more sweeping claims or first we can talk about
- 4:42Speaker 11: the general claims here, like is there is there you know,
- 4:47Speaker 11: public benefits fraud among the smaller community, uh, in Minnesota. Yes,
- 4:52Speaker 11: it's a thing like they you know, there have been
- 4:56Speaker 11: some major prosecutions and that's you know, two walls point
- 5:01Speaker 11: that have that have targeted.
- 5:02Speaker 9: Now.
- 5:02Speaker 11: On the one hand, if you go looking in a
- 5:05Speaker 11: particular community for more fraud, you're gonna find more fraud.
- 5:10Speaker 11: On the other hand, there's a there's a good piece
- 5:13Speaker 11: by case of Magan, who is a one of the prosecutors.
- 5:20Speaker 5: Is this the Minnesota Reformer piece?
- 5:21Speaker 3: Yeah?
- 5:21Speaker 5: Yeah, we can put this up on the screen. This
- 5:23Speaker 5: is actually really good. This is E five.
- 5:24Speaker 11: He was one of the prosecutors. He is himself of
- 5:27Speaker 11: Somali descent. I would recommend people go and go and
- 5:30Speaker 11: read this piece. But he makes a couple of points. One,
- 5:33Speaker 11: he says that a lot of the Somalis who are
- 5:36Speaker 11: here now in the United States.
- 5:38Speaker 5: This is from twenty twenty four, by the way, before
- 5:39Speaker 5: the stream blew up.
- 5:40Speaker 11: Right, He wrote this summer of twenty twenty four. So yeah,
- 5:43Speaker 11: these cases have been going on for a while. Said
- 5:45Speaker 11: a lot of them are have much more like education
- 5:49Speaker 11: and experience than they're able to use here in the
- 5:55Speaker 11: United States, you know, and you see this a lot.
- 5:58Speaker 11: Let's say, you know, somebody is you know, was like
- 6:03Speaker 11: a colonel in the military and is now driving an uber.
- 6:07Speaker 9: Or you know, or what have you.
- 6:09Speaker 11: And he makes the point that that's going to create
- 6:14Speaker 11: a lot of frustration that can lead to a desire
- 6:17Speaker 11: to take shortcuts to get back ahead to where you
- 6:20Speaker 11: feel like you should be because you worked so hard
- 6:22Speaker 11: your whole life and now and now here you are
- 6:26Speaker 11: and you feel like that's unjust because you and you've
- 6:28Speaker 11: got a family to support here, plus you're sending remittances
- 6:31Speaker 11: back to Somalia, and that's an enticement to fraud. He
- 6:36Speaker 11: also makes the point and this is this is a
- 6:39Speaker 11: point that applies across the country and applies, you know,
- 6:44Speaker 11: very particularly in South Florida, as well, it is true
- 6:47Speaker 11: that there are different communities that are more prone to fraud,
- 6:51Speaker 11: just South Florida being a perfect example of this.
- 6:56Speaker 9: What he what he argued is that.
- 6:59Speaker 11: We are the US system, or the state system is
- 7:02Speaker 11: set up to go after recipient fraud.
- 7:05Speaker 9: Like if you're.
- 7:08Speaker 11: Fudging the paperwork and you're ripping off the government, like
- 7:12Speaker 11: we're like, aha, we got you. But if you're a
- 7:15Speaker 11: dentist office, or you're a doctor's office or a fake
- 7:18Speaker 11: doctor's office, or you make fake wheelchairs or whatever, or
- 7:21Speaker 11: you give out free meals and the meals are funded
- 7:24Speaker 11: by the state or whatever, and you then pay off
- 7:32Speaker 11: give kickbacks to recipients. So now all your paperwork's kind
- 7:35Speaker 11: of in line. You're just not doing anything that is
- 7:38Speaker 11: harder for prosecutors and investigators to catch based on the
- 7:43Speaker 11: way that we're set up.
- 7:45Speaker 9: And that's all. That's a complaint I've.
- 7:46Speaker 11: Had about our public benefits system forever, which is that
- 7:51Speaker 11: think about who.
- 7:52Speaker 9: That is benefiting.
- 7:53Speaker 11: Those are the richer people who are pillars of the
- 7:56Speaker 11: community and who are donating big amounts to politicians, And
- 8:02Speaker 11: that's of people of European descent, Somali descent, Cuban descent,
- 8:07Speaker 11: Venezuelan descent doesn't matter like those types of people. Rick Scott,
- 8:12Speaker 11: for instance, is one of the greatest perpetrators. He's the
- 8:15Speaker 11: Florida Senator of medicare fraud in the history of the
- 8:18Speaker 11: United States. But because he is at the top of it,
- 8:27Speaker 11: he had to pay a gigantic fine, and I think
- 8:29Speaker 11: he admitted no wrongdoing or some nonsense like that, walked
- 8:33Speaker 11: away with the money, and then used the money to
- 8:35Speaker 11: buy a Senate seat. He's okay, like he's allowed to skate.
- 8:40Speaker 11: So that like that is we do need to change
- 8:43Speaker 11: the way that we investigate fraud. And it feels like
- 8:47Speaker 11: if AI is going to be good for anything, like
- 8:50Speaker 11: it's it's got to be good for this. Like you
- 8:54Speaker 11: we are at a point where we should be able
- 8:55Speaker 11: to figure out if you're actually making wheelchairs and selling them.
- 9:00Speaker 9: Are you really really selling wheelchairs or not? Right? Prove
- 9:03Speaker 9: it right, and we should be able to figure that out, Like.
- 9:06Speaker 11: You know, I don't give us some photos of the
- 9:08Speaker 11: wheelchairs or something and no stock photos like this. This
- 9:12Speaker 11: is a solvable problem, but it would take political willpower
- 9:16Speaker 11: because you're going after rich people, right, not just poor
- 9:20Speaker 11: people who are builking the system.
- 9:22Speaker 5: I think that's totally reasonable.
- 9:24Speaker 4: The Minnesota Reformer article you were just reading from again,
- 9:28Speaker 4: I think, you know. The other part of this is
- 9:30Speaker 4: we should be able to say, you know, and I
- 9:32Speaker 4: always put it this way, we're completely correct to be
- 9:35Speaker 4: sensitive about racism in a country that had a literal
- 9:38Speaker 4: chattel slavery system up until, you know, one hundred and
- 9:42Speaker 4: fifty years ago. It is like a huge, important part
- 9:45Speaker 4: of the country's history that would be ridiculous to just
- 9:48Speaker 4: get over.
- 9:49Speaker 5: That's, you know, not how it works.
- 9:51Speaker 4: And you know, Jim Crow is within living memory of
- 9:54Speaker 4: people today.
- 9:56Speaker 5: So we're right to be sensitive about it.
- 9:57Speaker 4: But it's also important that we don't let those claims
- 10:01Speaker 4: get weaponized, which is exactly what actually casey case. How
- 10:05Speaker 4: am I saying that I should say correctly? Megan in
- 10:08Speaker 4: the Minnesota Reformer admits, and it's not even an admission,
- 10:13Speaker 4: because Megan is totally happy to say, this is what's happening,
- 10:17Speaker 4: and more people need to be comfortable diagnosing the problem.
- 10:21Speaker 4: It has nothing to do with skin color, but it
- 10:22Speaker 4: was obviously involved with the Somali community. And Meghan writes,
- 10:26Speaker 4: our system of Quran provides a social safety net.
- 10:29Speaker 5: I don't think that I'm pronouncing that correct. That either
- 10:31Speaker 5: provides a social safety net in the form of.
- 10:32Speaker 9: Financial not to be confused with the book the book.
- 10:34Speaker 4: Right, It's spelled similarly, but not quite to not to
- 10:38Speaker 4: be confused with it provides a social safety net in
- 10:39Speaker 4: the form of financial assistance to those who have fallen
- 10:42Speaker 4: on hard times. Unfortunately, it has also been used to
- 10:45Speaker 4: financially support people who have been charged with defrauding the government.
- 10:48Speaker 4: And this is again like a billion dollar alleged billion
- 10:50Speaker 4: dollar money laundering operation. They're not the money laundering claims
- 10:54Speaker 4: are not flimsy. We're talking about housing programs, autism programs,
- 10:58Speaker 4: feeding our future, so kids who were supposed to hunger,
- 11:01Speaker 4: kids who are getting meals. And I've looked at the documents.
- 11:04Speaker 4: I don't think that this is a case of over prosecution, and.
- 11:06Speaker 5: Neither does Megan, who was an investigator in the Medicaid for.
- 11:10Speaker 9: Autifications part of the prosecutions right.
- 11:12Speaker 4: Of the Minnesota Attorney General Office. And so one thing
- 11:16Speaker 4: I just do want to say is that I think
- 11:18Speaker 4: DFL folks, Dems progressives, it's not good for them to say, hey,
- 11:25Speaker 4: this is a sad story for hardworking Minnesotans who are
- 11:31Speaker 4: generous and want to support refugees and are getting absolutely
- 11:35Speaker 4: screwed over by this.
- 11:36Speaker 5: By the way, Minnesotans who.
- 11:38Speaker 4: Are you know, of all stripes getting screwed over by this,
- 11:42Speaker 4: And Megan notes that Somali's got screwed over by this
- 11:46Speaker 4: were some of the victims of all of this, and so,
- 11:48Speaker 4: I mean it just I don't think it's good for
- 11:50Speaker 4: anybody to pretend that this isn't a problem in the
- 11:56Speaker 4: Somali diasper community, because what that does is open the.
- 11:59Speaker 5: Door or uh, for for people who.
- 12:02Speaker 4: Are racist and do have bad intentions to be like, look,
- 12:05Speaker 4: they're telling you you can't say it right, and that's
- 12:08Speaker 4: that's what's going to happen.
- 12:10Speaker 5: And people still have agency.
- 12:11Speaker 4: If they get suckered into that stuff, that's their fault.
- 12:14Speaker 4: But if we also can't be clear about what's happening
- 12:17Speaker 4: because people are dancing around, it's not good for anyone either.
- 12:21Speaker 11: Right, And he was writing kind of to the Somali
- 12:26Speaker 11: community saying, yes, like we need to clean this up
- 12:29Speaker 11: otherwise otherwise you know, the hammer is going to come
- 12:33Speaker 11: down and they're going to and you're going to get
- 12:35Speaker 11: a Christy nome situation where she's going to come in
- 12:38Speaker 11: and say, like, half your visas are now invalid, start
- 12:41Speaker 11: like rating people that.
- 12:45Speaker 9: And you know, it is important from a left.
- 12:48Speaker 11: Winging perspective that that they're in order to get buy
- 12:52Speaker 11: in for universal programs, that people trust that the programs
- 12:56Speaker 11: are being run honestly, because if if you don't look
- 13:01Speaker 11: like you're willing to root out fraud, then the right
- 13:05Speaker 11: can easily come in and be like, look, this is
- 13:08Speaker 11: all welfare fraud. Since they won't clean it up, let's
- 13:11Speaker 11: just get rid of the welfare.
- 13:12Speaker 5: It's the same thing with refugee programs.
- 13:14Speaker 4: It's important to get buy in for refugee programs that
- 13:16Speaker 4: people feel as though there's a respect for rule of
- 13:19Speaker 4: law and for the country the state that people are
- 13:23Speaker 4: being resettled in. I mean, Minnesota is a very very
- 13:26Speaker 4: generous refugee resettlement program. A lot of states in the
- 13:29Speaker 4: Upper Midwest, Oar Wisconsin definitely has that too.
- 13:32Speaker 5: A lot of states in America do, and it's.
- 13:34Speaker 4: Because a lot of Americans genuinely feel like they want
- 13:37Speaker 4: to be a place of refuge for people who are fleeing,
- 13:42Speaker 4: like a lot of very generous and kind hearted, normal
- 13:46Speaker 4: Americans who are happy to see a little bit of
- 13:48Speaker 4: their money go to these types of programs that the
- 13:52Speaker 4: state is running.
- 13:53Speaker 5: But you're going to lose buy in.
- 13:55Speaker 4: For them if people believe increasingly that certain community are
- 14:00Speaker 4: taking advantage of their kindness.
- 14:02Speaker 11: Yeah, and another point, and there's nothing And what people
- 14:05Speaker 11: need to be able to say is that there's nothing
- 14:07Speaker 11: unique or intrinsically bad about the Somali community. That fraud
- 14:13Speaker 11: often spreads through a tight knit community by word of mouth.
- 14:16Speaker 11: So and you can imagine how this would happen. And
- 14:18Speaker 11: this would be the case with say the Irish I.
- 14:22Speaker 5: Was going to say Irish Italians.
- 14:24Speaker 11: Yes, like I mean, obviously the programs are different at
- 14:26Speaker 11: the time, but the word of mouth system where somebody
- 14:31Speaker 11: says to you, hey, you know, if you switch providers here,
- 14:33Speaker 11: they're going to give you fifteen hundred bucks and you
- 14:36Speaker 11: might not even know why they're giving you fifteen hundred bucks.
- 14:40Speaker 11: And the reason they're giving you fifteen hundred bucks is
- 14:41Speaker 11: they want your number, and that they're going to say
- 14:44Speaker 11: they gave you all of these services that they didn't
- 14:45Speaker 11: actually give you, and then they're going.
- 14:47Speaker 9: To get ten thousand dollars.
- 14:50Speaker 11: You get free treatment or no treatment at all, but
- 14:53Speaker 11: you get fifteen hundred bucks, and then you tell your
- 14:55Speaker 11: friends like, hey, if you want a free fifteen hundred bucks,
- 14:58Speaker 11: go over these guys yep. And it feels like, really,
- 15:04Speaker 11: can I do that? And then a bunch of people
- 15:06Speaker 11: do it and get away with it. I'm like, well,
- 15:10Speaker 11: I'm a sucker at this point for not getting my
- 15:12Speaker 11: fifteen hundred bucks. And so yeah, So at that point,
- 15:17Speaker 11: it has to be kind of a top down situation
- 15:21Speaker 11: because like, just from a risk benefit situation, most people
- 15:25Speaker 11: are gonna be like, well, okay, I'll take fifteen hundred bucks.
- 15:28Speaker 9: It seems legali ish. I don't know, you.
- 15:32Speaker 11: Kind of know in the back of your mind you're like,
- 15:34Speaker 11: probably isn't right, but you don't know why, and it's
- 15:36Speaker 11: not right. And they're telling you like, just sign here
- 15:38Speaker 11: and the program was passed by the state.
- 15:41Speaker 9: And you'll get this money.
- 15:44Speaker 4: And I really think this is why you're starting to
- 15:46Speaker 4: hear the Trump administration talking about de naturalizing people because
- 15:50Speaker 4: they don't have a lot of legal pathways to boot
- 15:53Speaker 4: Somemali Americans from the country. Because his decision to remove
- 15:57Speaker 4: TPS so Temporary Protective status from Somali's it's like seven
- 16:02Speaker 4: hundred people in Minnesota out of a sixty thousand population,
- 16:07Speaker 4: roughly sixty thousand population. Those are the numbers I saw
- 16:10Speaker 4: in time. But seven hundred TPS recipients, that's not like
- 16:15Speaker 4: it's that's not what the Trump administration actually wants to
- 16:19Speaker 4: be able to do, which is why I think you've
- 16:20Speaker 4: started to hear them flirt with the idea of denaturalization
- 16:23Speaker 4: just over the last week or so. I mean, obviously
- 16:26Speaker 4: that comes up from time to time, but seven hundred
- 16:28Speaker 4: people on TPS. A lot of these people are American citizens.
- 16:32Speaker 4: They've been here for a long time, they've gotten citizenship.
- 16:35Speaker 11: So toward that end, that seems to be where the
- 16:38Speaker 11: Rufo piece comes in. So what Chris Rufo is arguing
- 16:42Speaker 11: is that not only is there this significant amount of fraud,
- 16:45Speaker 11: which is established and has long been reported, he's saying
- 16:48Speaker 11: it's then being funneled to Al Shabab, and his sourcing
- 16:52Speaker 11: for that is basically the blind claims of some.
- 16:57Speaker 9: Intel officials or something.
- 16:58Speaker 5: Right, that's like two officials like.
- 17:00Speaker 11: That, Like we're just like saying stuff like now, if
- 17:03Speaker 11: you send at enough remittances in general to any particular place,
- 17:10Speaker 11: like a powerful organization who's in that place is going
- 17:14Speaker 11: to wind up with some of the money.
- 17:15Speaker 9: Like that is, yes, that's how it goes, but that that's.
- 17:18Speaker 11: That's not like what he's trying to imply is that
- 17:22Speaker 11: that this is like some Al Shabab run operation right
- 17:25Speaker 11: to fund itself, right, And then there's just no evidence
- 17:27Speaker 11: for that whatsoever. And it would be rather striking use
- 17:32Speaker 11: of als Schabab's time if they were like, hey, let's
- 17:36Speaker 11: go through the Minnesota Like, I mean, it's crazier things
- 17:40Speaker 11: have happened, but like there's no evidence for it at
- 17:42Speaker 11: this point.
- 17:43Speaker 4: Yeah, I mean this is remittances from Somali's in Minnesota
- 17:46Speaker 4: are a huge motion of the economy of Somalia itself,
- 17:50Speaker 4: which is I mean that the same is true in
- 17:52Speaker 4: a lot of.
- 17:53Speaker 11: Central Americanists, Like remittance is like a third of the
- 17:56Speaker 11: economy or something.
- 17:56Speaker 4: It is massive, understand ass of Yeah, it is huge
- 18:02Speaker 4: and in Mexico actually really big too, And so that
- 18:07Speaker 4: the notion that some of that money is going to
- 18:11Speaker 4: Al Shabab is eminently believable. Whether it's a concerted operation
- 18:18Speaker 4: is a different question, And that's actually kind of similar
- 18:21Speaker 4: to the question of Cartel Dela Soles in Venezuela, which
- 18:25Speaker 4: the Biden actually was. It was the Biden DOJ's indictment
- 18:30Speaker 4: that walked through their allegations of state sponsored narco trafficking
- 18:36Speaker 4: in Venezuela, and a lot of what it amounted to
- 18:39Speaker 4: was people in the military here and there taking bribes
- 18:42Speaker 4: being involved. The question of whether Nicholas Muduro is using
- 18:46Speaker 4: this cartel to wage war UH on Americans with drug
- 18:51Speaker 4: trafficking is different. These two things are not the same.
- 18:55Speaker 4: So you can have some state involvement, or you could
- 19:00Speaker 4: have some Al Schabab benefits, but does that justify particular
- 19:05Speaker 4: It cannot be used to justify particular actions.
- 19:08Speaker 5: Different question. I think it's a different question.
- 19:11Speaker 4: So I think it's probably true that some of this
- 19:13Speaker 4: money ends up in the hands of al Shabab.
- 19:15Speaker 5: I don't see any other way to go.
- 19:17Speaker 9: Money is fungible.
- 19:18Speaker 11: Yeah, if a lot of them, and if it makes
- 19:20Speaker 11: up you know, it's hundreds of millions of dollars.
- 19:22Speaker 4: Now, if people take that to claim that this is
- 19:24Speaker 4: an intentional military operation from Al Shabab, lots more evidence
- 19:28Speaker 4: is needed.
- 19:29Speaker 5: Lots more evidence is on that front.
- 19:31Speaker 11: Yeah, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
- 19:34Speaker 5: Yes, so we will see, but not what was provided. Again,
- 19:37Speaker 5: we're talking about.
- 19:38Speaker 4: Seven hundred people maybe losing TPS and where it goes
- 19:41Speaker 4: from there hard to say. And whether that holds up
- 19:44Speaker 4: in court also hard to say.
- 19:45Speaker 5: Yeah, And on that note, actually.
- 19:47Speaker 4: Let's transition to our guests, saent Me Homdi Ryan, someone
- 19:52Speaker 4: who was in court battles with the Trump administration.
- 19:54Speaker 5: Over in the nation as well.
- 19:55Speaker 9: YEP.
- 19:58Speaker 11: Joining us today is British journalist Sammy Hamdi, who thankfully
- 20:03Speaker 11: is joining us freed from American detention. Sammy, thank you
- 20:07Speaker 11: so much for being here.
- 20:09Speaker 5: Thank you for having me.
- 20:09Speaker 9: Appreciate it so.
- 20:11Speaker 11: For people who don't know, you became kind of a
- 20:13Speaker 11: cause celeb when it comes to the question of free
- 20:17Speaker 11: speech and criticism of Israel here in the United States
- 20:21Speaker 11: when you were when you became a kind of high
- 20:25Speaker 11: profile iced detainee for about two weeks. He talked just
- 20:30Speaker 11: briefly for people who don't know the story about what
- 20:33Speaker 11: you were doing here in the US and how you
- 20:36Speaker 11: wound up in American custody.
- 20:39Speaker 9: Thank you very much.
- 20:40Speaker 6: Ryan.
- 20:40Speaker 12: So, I had the B one B two visa that
- 20:42Speaker 12: was valid for ten years. It was due to expire
- 20:44Speaker 12: in twenty twenty eight, and I had been visiting America
- 20:47Speaker 12: on numerous occasions over the past three years, in which
- 20:50Speaker 12: talking about the Middle East politics, whether it's talking about Syria,
- 20:54Speaker 12: was talking about the Gulf, and more recently about what's
- 20:57Speaker 12: happening in Palestline, what's happening in Gaza, this genocide that
- 21:00Speaker 12: is taking place. On my trips to America, I spoke
- 21:03Speaker 12: at you know, universities such as Berkeley, Stanford, Cooney and
- 21:07Speaker 12: these others, and welcomed in America and never really had
- 21:09Speaker 12: any issues going in and out of America. And then
- 21:13Speaker 12: two weeks prior to my detention, a right wing individual
- 21:17Speaker 12: called Dinnish de Suza put up a video of a
- 21:20Speaker 12: lecture that I gave in Kuala Lumpo, where I expressed
- 21:23Speaker 12: quite passionately that to the audience that they should keep
- 21:26Speaker 12: talking on social media. It's making a difference. Americans have
- 21:30Speaker 12: good hearts when they're seeing the truth. Their hearts are
- 21:32Speaker 12: flipping when they're seeing the realities of what's taking place
- 21:35Speaker 12: in Palestine, when they're seeing the images of Cindela's legs
- 21:38Speaker 12: blown off and her body hanging from the wall from
- 21:41Speaker 12: the force of the blast. When they're seeing Hindra Jab
- 21:43Speaker 12: and hearing the audio note where she's surrounded by her
- 21:46Speaker 12: corpses of her family in the car being shot at
- 21:48Speaker 12: by three hundred and twenty American bullets applied to the
- 21:51Speaker 12: Israelis and the Israeli's bomb the ambulance sent to save her.
- 21:54Speaker 12: Americans are moved by their hearts are changing as a
- 21:58Speaker 12: result of it when they see the video of Nahaban
- 22:01Speaker 12: Mercy on his soul holding his granddaughter, calling her the
- 22:04Speaker 12: soul of my soul. I was arguing in Kuala Lumpur
- 22:07Speaker 12: that we should have faith in humanity and that when
- 22:09Speaker 12: you speak through social media and provide the truth, it's
- 22:12Speaker 12: dispelling the propaganda of those supporting the genocide and the like.
- 22:16Speaker 12: Dinnish de Susa took this clip in which I was
- 22:19Speaker 12: arguing that there are hearts in corners we didn't think
- 22:21Speaker 12: possible that could flip like Candace Owens, Tucker Carlson, et cetera.
- 22:25Speaker 12: He took this clip and he tweeted Muslim Brotherhood Operatives
- 22:29Speaker 12: celebrates the role of Candace Owens and Tucker Carson in
- 22:32Speaker 12: spreading Islam in America, and Grok would respond and say,
- 22:35Speaker 12: this is absolute nonsense. Nothing in the video says anything
- 22:37Speaker 12: like that exactly, but an individual called Ted Cruz, Senator
- 22:42Speaker 12: of Texas decides to retweet it, and I land on
- 22:45Speaker 12: the attention of a lady called Laura Luma, who tweets
- 22:48Speaker 12: on the Monday as part of this Israeli lobby. Tweets
- 22:51Speaker 12: on the Monday and says there is somebody from the
- 22:53Speaker 12: UK who is touring the US criticizing the Israelis and
- 22:56Speaker 12: paraphrasing here, we need to get rid of his visa.
- 23:00Speaker 12: I didn't take it seriously in the sense that this
- 23:02Speaker 12: is America. There's a land of law. Laura Luma is
- 23:05Speaker 12: not the arbiter of free speech in the land of
- 23:07Speaker 12: the Free and Home of the Brave, as the American
- 23:10Speaker 12: calls itself. On the Wednesday, she tweeted, I'm in Congress
- 23:14Speaker 12: and I have good news coming in two days about
- 23:16Speaker 12: a certain so called operative touring the UK. At touring
- 23:20Speaker 12: the US at this moment, and I knew she's talking
- 23:22Speaker 12: about me. On the Saturday, I gave a lecture in
- 23:25Speaker 12: Sacramento at a care banquet the Council of American Islamic Relations,
- 23:29Speaker 12: in which I argued that American needs to be saved
- 23:31Speaker 12: from the Israel First lobby. I argued in that speech
- 23:35Speaker 12: that it is unfathomable that an American can freeze on
- 23:38Speaker 12: Magnificent Mile in Chicago and cannot access any funds to
- 23:42Speaker 12: save them from homelessness, while Congress gives fourteen billion dollars
- 23:45Speaker 12: to the Israelis First. It makes no sense. It makes
- 23:48Speaker 12: no sense that an American goes bankrupt because they can't
- 23:51Speaker 12: afford medical bills because eight billion dollars gets given by
- 23:54Speaker 12: Congress to the Israelis to give them free healthcare and
- 23:57Speaker 12: then commit genocide on top to slaughter the Palestinians. My
- 24:00Speaker 12: argument was that this is not just about American Israel
- 24:03Speaker 12: as one. Save America from a lobby that demands that
- 24:06Speaker 12: America suffers for the sake of genocide taking place in Palestine.
- 24:09Speaker 12: The following morning, I'm going through San Francisco Airport. I
- 24:12Speaker 12: was wearing a Malaysian battic, which is a noble dress
- 24:15Speaker 12: from Malaysia that Americans mistook for a disco shirt. I
- 24:17Speaker 12: don't know why, but in any case, I go through
- 24:20Speaker 12: the check in, I go through security, I look up
- 24:22Speaker 12: D thirty eight the gate to go to Tampa to
- 24:25Speaker 12: give another lecture. A gentleman approaches me and says, excuse me,
- 24:28Speaker 12: are you Sami Hamdi? I said yes. He said, sir,
- 24:32Speaker 12: I'm here to inform you that your visa has been revoked,
- 24:35Speaker 12: and it was revoked two days ago. I said to
- 24:37Speaker 12: nobody told me my visa was even under review. What
- 24:39Speaker 12: do you mean it's been revoked, he said, sir. Here
- 24:42Speaker 12: is the memo from the State Department. I read it.
- 24:44Speaker 12: It doesn't state any reason. It just says section this
- 24:46Speaker 12: article this we have the right to revoke it. I said,
- 24:49Speaker 12: did they give you a reason? He said, sir, they
- 24:51Speaker 12: just told me to wait for you here and to
- 24:53Speaker 12: pick you up. I said, okay. I was supposed to
- 24:56Speaker 12: go to London on second of November, six flights a
- 24:58Speaker 12: day from San Francisco. I'll just book a flight now
- 25:01Speaker 12: and just go to the gate for London. That's not
- 25:04Speaker 12: how this works, he said to me. Then six agents
- 25:07Speaker 12: appeared out of nowhere. They escorted me out of San
- 25:09Speaker 12: Francisco Airport. A black car with tinted windows was waiting
- 25:12Speaker 12: for me. I asked to call a lawyer. They refused,
- 25:15Speaker 12: and then when I told them there's no way I'm
- 25:16Speaker 12: getting in the car, my British citizen. I'm not some
- 25:18Speaker 12: random guy you find on the street. One of them
- 25:20Speaker 12: said relented and said, okay, you got one minute. I
- 25:22Speaker 12: called a lawyer who's in civil liberties. And then the
- 25:25Speaker 12: lady behind me, when I asked to call my family,
- 25:27Speaker 12: one of the agents pushes me against the car. That's enough,
- 25:30Speaker 12: you're under arrest. Now, cuffs me and they take me
- 25:32Speaker 12: on a six hour ordeal in the back of a
- 25:35Speaker 12: van to the middle of nowhere, someplace McFarland, and they
- 25:38Speaker 12: put me in a facility and I stayed there eighteen days,
- 25:40Speaker 12: and thanks to two federal judges who indicated that there
- 25:43Speaker 12: were serious breaches of a freedom of speech and therefore
- 25:46Speaker 12: my case should be expedited. The DHS lawyer in private,
- 25:50Speaker 12: I know what they were saying publicly, but certainly in
- 25:52Speaker 12: private they sort of said, listen, can we just clear
- 25:54Speaker 12: this up, go home and let the storm pass, and
- 25:56Speaker 12: we'll clear the record in that regard. But it was
- 25:58Speaker 12: quite the experience in that regard. But the final thing
- 26:01Speaker 12: I'll say here is before I hand back over, is
- 26:03Speaker 12: I know a lot of people focused on what happened
- 26:04Speaker 12: to me, but I think it should be placed in
- 26:06Speaker 12: the broader context, Ryan, in the sense that I think
- 26:10Speaker 12: that the extreme Israeli lobby bear in mind I was
- 26:13Speaker 12: not the first person they targeted. They actually went after
- 26:16Speaker 12: American citizens first to curtail the freedom of speech in
- 26:19Speaker 12: terms of what they can say about Israel. You'll remember, Ryan,
- 26:21Speaker 12: they went after American students who were with the American
- 26:24Speaker 12: Muslims for Palestine. They went after them in Michigan and
- 26:27Speaker 12: the judge ruled that the case should be dismissed. Then
- 26:29Speaker 12: they went after American citizens, telling.
- 26:31Speaker 11: Them that we had one of those American citizens on
- 26:34Speaker 11: this program.
- 26:34Speaker 12: Actually that's right exactly, and they went to in Nevada.
- 26:37Speaker 12: The judge said, this is absolute nonsense. We have freedom
- 26:39Speaker 12: of speech in this country. Then the extreme Israeli lobby said, okay,
- 26:43Speaker 12: we're struggling to go after American citizens. Let's go after
- 26:45Speaker 12: naturalized citizens. So they targeted Mattia Hasen and some of
- 26:48Speaker 12: these others and they failed. Then they said, okay, let's
- 26:50Speaker 12: go after Green card holders. We need to restrict the
- 26:53Speaker 12: rights of ordinary Americans to prevent them from accessing truth.
- 26:57Speaker 12: They went after Mahmud Khalil. They found that it's much
- 26:59Speaker 12: more difficult. The judges ruled he shouldn't be deported. His
- 27:02Speaker 12: case is thin and limbo, but he hasn't been deported yet.
- 27:04Speaker 12: Then they said, let's go after student visas. They went
- 27:07Speaker 12: after Romeasa ast Mosemado and other students. Let scare students
- 27:11Speaker 12: like Lyca Kurdia from preventing them from speaking out, and
- 27:14Speaker 12: they failed. The judges rule they should be released. Then
- 27:16Speaker 12: they thought, this is really bad. The constitution is against us.
- 27:19Speaker 12: We're unable to restrict American freedoms. We're unable to push
- 27:23Speaker 12: our way and prevent this truth from penetrating the filters
- 27:27Speaker 12: that we put on the flow of information in America.
- 27:29Speaker 12: Then they thought, there's a random UK guy from London
- 27:32Speaker 12: touring the United States. Let's go after B one, B
- 27:35Speaker 12: two visa and will take that as a victory instead.
- 27:37Speaker 12: And thankfully they failed. In the end, I was able
- 27:39Speaker 12: to go home free eighteen days in Ice, which was
- 27:42Speaker 12: a bit rough to be honest, but thankfully I'm home
- 27:45Speaker 12: and I consider it a win.
- 27:46Speaker 4: Well, let's take a look at the video Laura Lumer posted,
- 27:49Speaker 4: and I think this was twenty twenty three, but also
- 27:51Speaker 4: Homeland Security posted this video. Will play it in full
- 27:55Speaker 4: here so that people can see you what's in what's
- 27:57Speaker 4: in question?
- 27:58Speaker 13: Nettigno, who did not in visage that for the first
- 28:01Speaker 13: time since nineteen forty eight, the Palestinians would actually retake
- 28:06Speaker 13: land back from the israelis NTINIAU did not envisage that
- 28:11Speaker 13: for the first time since nineteen forty eight, the Palestinians
- 28:14Speaker 13: would be able to hold those territories for more than
- 28:17Speaker 13: seventy two hours.
- 28:18Speaker 14: We are pitying your people who brought a huge victory
- 28:21Speaker 14: since nineteen forty eight. Don't pity them. They don't want
- 28:24Speaker 14: your pity. Celebrate the victory. Allah has shown the world
- 28:29Speaker 14: that no normalization can erase the Palestinian cause. When everybody
- 28:34Speaker 14: thought it was finished, it's roaring. How many of you
- 28:37Speaker 14: feel it in your hearts when you got the news
- 28:39Speaker 14: that did it happened? How many of you felt the
- 28:41Speaker 14: euphoria ahlah welcome for how many of you felt it?
- 28:45Speaker 5: Why did you feel it? Because in despair vanish you said,
- 28:48Speaker 5: this only is alive? Okay?
- 28:51Speaker 4: So Sami obviously speech questions. I just want to put
- 28:54Speaker 4: aside for a second a question that a lot of
- 28:56Speaker 4: people might have is what was the huge victory that
- 28:59Speaker 4: was People should be celebrating and then feeling euphoria about
- 29:03Speaker 4: on October seventh or after October seventh.
- 29:06Speaker 12: Sure, I thinking that anybody who watches the full lecture
- 29:09Speaker 12: will see that the build up to it makes it
- 29:10Speaker 12: abundantly clear the sense that normalization was taking place over
- 29:13Speaker 12: the heads of the Palestinians. People were warning that you
- 29:16Speaker 12: have to engage the Palestinians in any peace talks. And
- 29:19Speaker 12: now it's abundantly clear, after everything that has happened, that
- 29:22Speaker 12: the Palestinians are relevant and that they must be included
- 29:24Speaker 12: in peace talks. Celebrate the victory that people are talking
- 29:27Speaker 12: about the Palestinians again and that people are no longer
- 29:30Speaker 12: steamrolling them in any talks and discussions about their particular future.
- 29:34Speaker 12: Which is why this video was inadmissible in court, because
- 29:37Speaker 12: it's been stitched out of the wider context, and even
- 29:39Speaker 12: the Department of Homeland Security found that it could not
- 29:42Speaker 12: be submitted. And the irony is that one week later
- 29:45Speaker 12: BBC would stitch a video of one of Donald Trump's
- 29:47Speaker 12: speeches and a BBC director would end up resigning as well.
- 29:50Speaker 12: I think anybody who watches the full lecture makes it
- 29:52Speaker 12: sees abundantly clear what I was talking about, and I
- 29:55Speaker 12: don't think something from memory that is islamophobic and targets
- 29:59Speaker 12: all Muslim representatives and anybody who talks as a Muslim.
- 30:03Speaker 12: I don't think that any court would take anything they
- 30:05Speaker 12: say seriously, which is why not even many of the
- 30:06Speaker 12: mainstream media managed to pick it up anyway. And I
- 30:09Speaker 12: do want to emphasize this particular point that nothing of
- 30:12Speaker 12: what was being said publicly ever made it into a
- 30:14Speaker 12: chart sheet or was even mentioned privately. In fact, on
- 30:17Speaker 12: the Wednesday, so eleven days after I was in the
- 30:20Speaker 12: lawyer for the Department of Homeland Security went to the
- 30:23Speaker 12: federal court and said, you have no jurisdiction to assess
- 30:26Speaker 12: the right of freedom of speech for Sammy Hamdy because
- 30:29Speaker 12: he's a foreign alien. The judge rule that not only
- 30:32Speaker 12: do they have jurisdiction, but in the words of the judge,
- 30:35Speaker 12: we believe there are serious signs that his freedom of
- 30:38Speaker 12: speech has been infringed. The following day, the Department of
- 30:42Speaker 12: Homeland Security appointed a specific lawyer for my case to
- 30:46Speaker 12: call email and text my lawyers and say to them, listen,
- 30:49Speaker 12: can we just make this go away? Will just you know,
- 30:51Speaker 12: clear the record. We will pull a few strings will
- 30:54Speaker 12: get you home, you know, and we can just forget
- 30:55Speaker 12: that all of this took place. And this is the
- 30:57Speaker 12: point that I'm emphasizing here in that this had nothing
- 31:00Speaker 12: to do with anything that I said. Everything that I've said,
- 31:02Speaker 12: there's nothing wrong. Even in that clip itself, it was
- 31:05Speaker 12: not admissible in court. The problem was, how do you
- 31:08Speaker 12: silence Americans from talking about what Israel is doing in Palestine?
- 31:12Speaker 12: How do you create a climate of fear where even
- 31:14Speaker 12: somebody who comes from the US UK, a journalist, is
- 31:18Speaker 12: frightened to talk about Palestine. How do we make Americans
- 31:22Speaker 12: stop spreading on TikTok what's actually happening in Palestine? Something
- 31:25Speaker 12: that Hillary Clinton yesterday complained about when she's talking at
- 31:28Speaker 12: a Zionis forum, something that Anthony blink and Romney complained
- 31:31Speaker 12: about when they said we need to ban TikTok, and
- 31:34Speaker 12: then the fifty billion purchase of TikTok for what? And
- 31:37Speaker 12: this is the point.
- 31:38Speaker 11: Actually, let me pause you on that real quick, because
- 31:41Speaker 11: we have that clip and it's I think it's really telling.
- 31:44Speaker 9: Let's roll f F one for people that.
- 31:47Speaker 15: Our students, smart, well educated young people from our own country,
- 31:53Speaker 15: from around the world, where were they getting their information.
- 31:57Speaker 15: They were getting their information from social media, particularly TikTok,
- 32:03Speaker 15: that is where they were learning about what happened in
- 32:05Speaker 15: October seventh, what happened in the days, weeks and months
- 32:10Speaker 15: to follow. That's a serious problem. It's a serious problem
- 32:15Speaker 15: for democracy, whether it's Israel the United States, and it's
- 32:17Speaker 15: a serious problem for our young people. And it was
- 32:20Speaker 15: frankly shocking to me how little the students we were encountering,
- 32:27Speaker 15: not only in this class we teach, which is a
- 32:29Speaker 15: very large class international relations about crisis decision making, but
- 32:34Speaker 15: students more generally. And that's why I mentioned the social
- 32:38Speaker 15: media piece of it, because when you would try to
- 32:41Speaker 15: talk to them, to engage in some kind of reasonable discussion,
- 32:48Speaker 15: it was very difficult because they did not know history,
- 32:51Speaker 15: They had very little context, and what they were being
- 32:54Speaker 15: told on social media was not just one sided, it
- 32:57Speaker 15: was pure propaganda. And so when you think about how
- 33:01Speaker 15: to tell Israel's story, and it's important, it's not just
- 33:05Speaker 15: looking internally, it's looking externally, and particularly looking at young people,
- 33:11Speaker 15: because you know, it's not just the usual suspects. It
- 33:16Speaker 15: is a lot of young Jewish Americans who don't know
- 33:19Speaker 15: the history and don't understand.
- 33:24Speaker 6: Eric.
- 33:24Speaker 15: I was talking to Condi Rice, and you know she
- 33:27Speaker 15: said in an interview that I did after the twenty
- 33:32Speaker 15: point plan came out. She and I were on CBS
- 33:35Speaker 15: and she said, you know, when people were chanting from
- 33:38Speaker 15: the river to the sea, she would ask the students
- 33:41Speaker 15: what river, what see? They didn't know I had the
- 33:44Speaker 15: same experience. A lot of the challenge is with younger people.
- 33:49Speaker 15: More than fifty percent of young people in America get
- 33:54Speaker 15: their news from social media. So just pause on that
- 34:01Speaker 15: for a second. They are seeing short form videos, some
- 34:05Speaker 15: of them totally made up, some of them not at
- 34:09Speaker 15: all representing what they claim to be showing, and that's
- 34:14Speaker 15: where they get their information.
- 34:16Speaker 11: And so that's at an event put on by Israel's
- 34:18Speaker 11: largest newspaper, israel I Own, which is funded by Miriam
- 34:22Speaker 11: Miriam Adelson. So that just to underscore your point about
- 34:26Speaker 11: attempting control of me.
- 34:28Speaker 12: But go ahead, but Ryan, I want to ask the
- 34:31Speaker 12: viewer to listen to what she's saying. She's not just
- 34:34Speaker 12: saying they will listen to TikTok. She's saying they weren't
- 34:36Speaker 12: listening to us. We are the gatekeepers of information. How
- 34:39Speaker 12: dore Americans go somewhere else. How do Americans exercise their
- 34:44Speaker 12: freedoms to listen to the likes of Ryan or Crystal
- 34:47Speaker 12: or Sero, the Palestinians or Martes Isaia. How their Americans
- 34:51Speaker 12: actually believe that the Constitution entitles them to go to
- 34:55Speaker 12: listen to information from sources other than that which we
- 34:59Speaker 12: feed them. How dare they go to breaking points instead
- 35:02Speaker 12: of CBS, where we've appointed Barry Wise in order to
- 35:05Speaker 12: filter the information that goes to Americans. How dare they
- 35:08Speaker 12: go and listen to Mehdi hassenin Zeteo instead of going
- 35:11Speaker 12: to listen to all of these other different outlets that
- 35:14Speaker 12: we set up specifically to make sure that the Palestinian
- 35:17Speaker 12: voice is never heard. And what Hillary Clinton is saying,
- 35:20Speaker 12: as others have said, as one of Obama's former speech
- 35:22Speaker 12: writers has been saying consistently, is is that we need
- 35:26Speaker 12: to tell the Americans how to interpret history. The lesson
- 35:29Speaker 12: from the Holocaust is not that we should support the oppressed.
- 35:32Speaker 12: It's that And then she goes on one, two, three, four.
- 35:35Speaker 12: The point that I'm saying here is this is not
- 35:37Speaker 12: something about Sammy Hamdy. It's not about the video that
- 35:40Speaker 12: you played. It's not about anything to do with me, whatsoever.
- 35:43Speaker 12: I got caught in the crosswind. This is about should
- 35:46Speaker 12: Americans be allowed to see the truth of what's happening
- 35:49Speaker 12: in the world, or should they only have the right
- 35:51Speaker 12: to listen to Hillary Clinton and listen to that which
- 35:54Speaker 12: Israel deems to be legitimate information that should go through.
- 35:58Speaker 12: And bear in mind when they talk about TikTok, they're
- 36:00Speaker 12: also talking about breaking points. They're also talking about zeteo.
- 36:03Speaker 12: They're also talking about the new media that is emerging
- 36:06Speaker 12: that is no longer beholden to these filters that used
- 36:09Speaker 12: to be put on the American people. And I'll finished
- 36:11Speaker 12: on this point, Ryan. I went to every state in
- 36:15Speaker 12: the US except New Hampshire, and I would go to
- 36:17Speaker 12: different places, whether it's Fort Worthe in Dallas and these
- 36:19Speaker 12: other places. I cannot stress that even the American who
- 36:24Speaker 12: was pro Israel and might be hostile to the information
- 36:28Speaker 12: coming out of Gaza in terms of denying the genocide,
- 36:31Speaker 12: denying the slaughter, denying the pictures. Whenever they saw those
- 36:34Speaker 12: graphic images. You saw Obama's former speechwriters saying, it's like
- 36:37Speaker 12: I'm talking through a carnage, you know, of dead children.
- 36:40Speaker 12: When I'm speaking to them. The reality is that she
- 36:42Speaker 12: mentions it. Hillary Clinton, you find even ordinary Jews and
- 36:45Speaker 12: these others American citizens waking up to what's happening. And
- 36:49Speaker 12: the tragedy of what's unfolding in America is this. It's
- 36:52Speaker 12: that you're no longer talking about America first. And I
- 36:54Speaker 12: don't hear me in Maga. I mean about the interest
- 36:56Speaker 12: of the American citizens. The whole politics at this moment
- 36:58Speaker 12: seems to be geared towards how do you control the
- 37:01Speaker 12: flow of information to the all American people for the
- 37:04Speaker 12: sake of a foreign government. And I was not detained
- 37:07Speaker 12: because I criticized the Americans or be it I've said
- 37:09Speaker 12: in the past, they shouldn't be supporting the genocide that's
- 37:11Speaker 12: taking place. Laura Luma came after me, not because I
- 37:14Speaker 12: criticized Washington, but because I criticized Israel. Ted Cruz came
- 37:17Speaker 12: after me, not because I criticized America, but because I
- 37:20Speaker 12: criticized Israel. This is not the America I think American
- 37:23Speaker 12: citizens want to live in or believe in. And that's
- 37:26Speaker 12: what Hillary Clinton is talking about. How do we silence
- 37:29Speaker 12: these voices before the Americans wake up? Because if the
- 37:32Speaker 12: Americans wake up, we get a Mendani phenomenon in New York.
- 37:35Speaker 12: If the Americans wake up, we get a situation in
- 37:38Speaker 12: New York where when Democrat and Republican establishment ally behind
- 37:41Speaker 12: Cuomo against Mendany, the people support Meddanni and mem Danieu wins.
- 37:45Speaker 12: The fight in America has nothing to do with Sami
- 37:48Speaker 12: or the like. It has to do with Israel first
- 37:51Speaker 12: versus America first. And again I don't mean Maga America first.
- 37:54Speaker 12: I mean the interest of American citizens. At this moment,
- 37:57Speaker 12: it looks like it's not clear who's going to win
- 37:59Speaker 12: in that regard. I got caught in the crosswind, but
- 38:01Speaker 12: thankfully I came out okay. But I do hope that
- 38:03Speaker 12: anybody listening to this can see the reality of what
- 38:06Speaker 12: Hillary Clinton is saying. She is saying to you, oh American,
- 38:10Speaker 12: that you have no right to exercise freedom in where
- 38:13Speaker 12: you get your information from. Listen to us, and will
- 38:16Speaker 12: tell you it's very all welly and very nineteen eighty four,
- 38:20Speaker 12: very the sense of you know, the news speaker and
- 38:22Speaker 12: all these others. And that's where I think the greatest
- 38:23Speaker 12: to America is not the Muslims. There's not anybody that's
- 38:27Speaker 12: been targeted by this sudden upsurge in media that Tucker Carson,
- 38:30Speaker 12: although I find it very weird that we're quoting him
- 38:33Speaker 12: left right senter these days, but it is what it is.
- 38:34Speaker 12: Given the changes that are taking place, it does feel
- 38:37Speaker 12: like an op. The greatest enemy to America today is
- 38:39Speaker 12: the one attacking American freedoms, and that attack seems to
- 38:42Speaker 12: be coming from Tel Aviv.
- 38:44Speaker 11: I did want to press on one thing you said,
- 38:45Speaker 11: because I think it really underscores how important your case
- 38:49Speaker 11: actually is, because it reveals how thoroughly the American people
- 38:54Speaker 11: are being lied to. So I want to press on
- 38:55Speaker 11: this you said. So you saw the clip that Laura
- 38:59Speaker 11: Lumer related. Along with that clip, she and other people said,
- 39:02Speaker 11: this is a terrorist supporter, This is a Muslim Brotherhood supporter.
- 39:08Speaker 9: This is somebody.
- 39:09Speaker 11: That is like training people in like digital like terrorism
- 39:14Speaker 11: or something like that. There are all these words that
- 39:16Speaker 11: they used to like make speech sound very scary, and
- 39:21Speaker 11: but what you're saying is that when it came behind bars,
- 39:27Speaker 11: the our government who was sharing these Laura Lumer ideas
- 39:32Speaker 11: and accusations, our government who's telling the American people that
- 39:36Speaker 11: they have detained a very scary person who is doing
- 39:39Speaker 11: terrible things when it comes to criticism of Israel. That
- 39:43Speaker 11: they didn't even attempt to make those allegations behind bars,
- 39:48Speaker 11: behind the scenes.
- 39:49Speaker 9: Is that? Is that right?
- 39:51Speaker 12: Not Tony? That right? Not Tony? Did they make those
- 39:53Speaker 12: allegations behind the scenes, Not only did they not even
- 39:56Speaker 12: allude to it or suggested or even presented in any
- 39:59Speaker 12: way whatsoever. The sense that my lawyer's got to Indeed,
- 40:03Speaker 12: that we got when the DHS lawyer came to talk
- 40:06Speaker 12: to my lawyers, the sense was that somebody had walked
- 40:09Speaker 12: into the State Department or the DHS and sort of said, guys,
- 40:12Speaker 12: what idiot listened to Laura Luma? Like one on hath
- 40:15Speaker 12: happened here? Why are media coming after us with all
- 40:18Speaker 12: of this attention? Who is this guy? And who even
- 40:20Speaker 12: revoked his visa? And why did you guys listen to
- 40:22Speaker 12: Laura Luma in doing so? And the lawyer was appointed
- 40:25Speaker 12: to clean up the mess very quickly. The sense that
- 40:28Speaker 12: we got was the government was almost saying, please allow
- 40:30Speaker 12: us to say face, We'll let you go home, return,
- 40:33Speaker 12: let the storm pass, supply for a visa again, etc.
- 40:35Speaker 12: And whatnot. But let's just make this very easy. We
- 40:37Speaker 12: can get you home within forty eight hours, because bear
- 40:40Speaker 12: in mind, some inmates, when they agreed to go home,
- 40:42Speaker 12: they still keep them there three months and they still
- 40:44Speaker 12: kill their two months. I was expedited for two within
- 40:48Speaker 12: forty eight hours because of the urgency with which the
- 40:50Speaker 12: Departmel of Homeless Security felt they needed to close this
- 40:53Speaker 12: particular case. And this is the point that I'm making.
- 40:56Speaker 12: Whatever they're telling you online or whatever the battle is
- 40:58Speaker 12: taking place on social media is not the reality of
- 41:01Speaker 12: what's unfolding before you. The reality is that there is
- 41:04Speaker 12: a pr battle. But privately, the government is very much
- 41:07Speaker 12: aware that there is this schism that's taking place. And
- 41:09Speaker 12: it's true even within the State Department. Whatever Mark or
- 41:12Speaker 12: Rubio says, whatever Tricia and I'm not sure what Pranunce
- 41:15Speaker 12: has said name is exactly whatever she's saying. There are
- 41:19Speaker 12: people in the State Department, and there are people in
- 41:21Speaker 12: the federal courts. There are people within the government who
- 41:24Speaker 12: are not happy with the way Israel First is taking
- 41:26Speaker 12: over US policy. There is resistance in these particular areas,
- 41:30Speaker 12: even around Donald Trump. And this is not a defense
- 41:32Speaker 12: of Donald Trump at all. Like there's many stuff that
- 41:34Speaker 12: to be honest, we can say it all day and
- 41:35Speaker 12: criticize his policies. But even around him, there is this
- 41:39Speaker 12: battle between Israel first and America first, which is why
- 41:41Speaker 12: you're seeing this clash that's manifested online between Tucker cars
- 41:44Speaker 12: and Candace Owens, Dave Smith and these others, and the
- 41:46Speaker 12: Ted Cruisers and the Dinish, the Seuss and Laura Luma.
- 41:49Speaker 12: It shows that the perception is not of a unified
- 41:52Speaker 12: government that's agreed on these things. There is a battle
- 41:54Speaker 12: for America that is taking place. I'm not saying one
- 41:57Speaker 12: side represents American I'm saying there is a battle for
- 41:59Speaker 12: the heart of America and the preservation of the rights
- 42:03Speaker 12: enshrined by the constitutions. The attack is coming from Tel Aviv.
- 42:07Speaker 12: I pray that the Americans wake up quick enough before
- 42:10Speaker 12: they wake up one day and find that Tel Aviv
- 42:12Speaker 12: has not only constrained their freedoms, but even managed to
- 42:14Speaker 12: amend their own constitution.
- 42:16Speaker 9: Okay, well, Sammy, thanks so much for joining us. You know,
- 42:18Speaker 9: really appreciate it.
- 42:20Speaker 12: Thank you for having me. I really appreciate it. Thank
- 42:21Speaker 12: you guys.
- 42:25Speaker 11: Speaking of the United Kingdom, we have a wild news
- 42:28Speaker 11: story at drop site News today that is an adapted
- 42:33Speaker 11: excerpt of a new book called The Fraud by Paul Holden,
- 42:38Speaker 11: and it uses expanded reporting and documents that are that
- 42:41Speaker 11: are also not included in the book because the book
- 42:44Speaker 11: is basically an investigation into the political operation of Sir
- 42:49Speaker 11: Keir Starmer, current UK Prime Minister.
- 42:53Speaker 9: The piece that he's writing for US.
- 42:55Speaker 11: Today looks at a secretly funded operation that Starmer and
- 43:02Speaker 11: his current chief of staff, Morgan McSweeney were running that
- 43:10Speaker 11: has some implications for work that Emily has done in
- 43:12Speaker 11: the past. So what they did is when Jeremy Corbin
- 43:18Speaker 11: was rising and was the head of the Labor Party,
- 43:22Speaker 11: they came together and said, how are we going to
- 43:25Speaker 11: undercut the support for corbonism and elevate Starmer? And so
- 43:32Speaker 11: they identified a lot of progressive media that had grown
- 43:36Speaker 11: up around the kind of corbonists rise and said we
- 43:39Speaker 11: need to undercut these folks.
- 43:43Speaker 9: And so they created.
- 43:46Speaker 11: Two organizations and this is what he's able to report
- 43:49Speaker 11: with these documents, and this is what hasn't been known before.
- 43:52Speaker 11: They created an organization called Stop Stop Funding, Stop Funding
- 43:58Speaker 11: Fake News, and another one.
- 44:01Speaker 9: Called the Center for Countering Digital Hate.
- 44:05Speaker 11: And so they presented themselves as these they're just grassroots
- 44:09Speaker 11: Britons who are concerned about fake news and misinformation and
- 44:14Speaker 11: disinformation out there, not that they were funded by secret
- 44:18Speaker 11: money from pro Israel elements that were funneling it into
- 44:24Speaker 11: the Cure Starmer political machine.
- 44:26Speaker 9: That's what he can report.
- 44:27Speaker 11: So this whole thing, this whole fake news scheme that
- 44:30Speaker 11: they were running, was not grassroots, just concerned Briton's. It
- 44:36Speaker 11: was a Cure Starmer machine aimed at destroying Jeremy Corbyn.
- 44:41Speaker 11: So they went after a bunch of left wing publications.
- 44:44Speaker 11: They also went after for Balance and for Fun a
- 44:47Speaker 11: bunch of populist right wing news outlets as well, including
- 44:55Speaker 11: Breitbart and The Federalist, and they went after them quite hard.
- 45:00Speaker 11: Turns out, Emily is quite familiar with CCdh Center for
- 45:05Speaker 11: Countering Digital Hate. So tell us what your experience was
- 45:10Speaker 11: with this what we now know is a Cure Starmer
- 45:15Speaker 11: machine operation, but at the time was said to be
- 45:20Speaker 11: just people concerned about fake news.
- 45:24Speaker 4: Yeah, well this is I think this actually is a
- 45:26Speaker 4: really important story because it wasn't just like maga news organizations.
- 45:31Speaker 4: Zero Hedge was also targeted at the same time as
- 45:34Speaker 4: a lot of other conservatives. Now we know Breitbart, but
- 45:36Speaker 4: back in twenty twenty Ben Collins, who.
- 45:40Speaker 5: I think was like the disinformation or misinformation reporter at
- 45:44Speaker 5: NBC News.
- 45:45Speaker 3: So this is a.
- 45:45Speaker 4: Journalist basically, I'm going to read this little section from
- 45:50Speaker 4: a story he published at NBC News at the time,
- 45:53Speaker 4: tattletaled to Google about a CCdh report on the Federalist
- 45:58Speaker 4: comment section. So this is a quote from his NBC
- 46:01Speaker 4: News story. Google blocked the Federalists from its advertising platform
- 46:05Speaker 4: after the NBC News verification unit brought the project to
- 46:09Speaker 4: its attention. Incredible, first of all, that you have a
- 46:12Speaker 4: journalist tattle tailing on another news outlets because they don't
- 46:17Speaker 4: like this news outlet on another news outlets comment section
- 46:20Speaker 4: to who took Google? Which os a YouTube So if
- 46:23Speaker 4: you're familiar with the YouTube comment section, that's a hilarious
- 46:28Speaker 4: move on Ben Collins point. On Ben Collins part, it
- 46:32Speaker 4: was always so maddening that a journalist would take the
- 46:37Speaker 4: CCdh report and then tattletale to a big tech company.
- 46:40Speaker 5: I mean, just infuriating.
- 46:42Speaker 4: And at the time, I mean I remember the entire
- 46:45Speaker 4: mainstream media cheerleading this report from Ben Collins.
- 46:49Speaker 5: Yeah, get them, get them.
- 46:50Speaker 4: Well, if you tattletille to Google and they shut down
- 46:53Speaker 4: your advertising platform.
- 46:55Speaker 5: You are out of business.
- 46:56Speaker 4: In twenty twenty, there has since been sort of parallel
- 46:58Speaker 4: efforts to.
- 47:00Speaker 9: Back up what was the effect that it had on
- 47:02Speaker 9: the Federalists.
- 47:03Speaker 4: So Jim Jordan came in and a couple of Republican
- 47:06Speaker 4: congressmen came in and pushed back on it, and it
- 47:08Speaker 4: went away.
- 47:09Speaker 5: It would have totally shut.
- 47:10Speaker 9: Down the web.
- 47:11Speaker 11: It destroyed the Canary, which is not not just the
- 47:14Speaker 11: Canary is now making a comeback, but the Canary is
- 47:16Speaker 11: a left wing outlet in the UK. It took The
- 47:18Speaker 11: Canary from an influential news outlet of twenty five to
- 47:22Speaker 11: thirty journalists to like one person right, and they took
- 47:26Speaker 11: credit for like just destroying it that way.
- 47:28Speaker 4: But sorry, go ahead, well no, And I mean that's
- 47:30Speaker 4: why you've talked about this recently. The speech protections in
- 47:35Speaker 4: the United States make especially if you're a journalist, can
- 47:38Speaker 4: make you very patriotic when you look at what happens
- 47:40Speaker 4: in the UK because Google. It was brought to Google's
- 47:43Speaker 4: attention that they had a clear legal problem on their hands,
- 47:47Speaker 4: and also that this type of activity was going to
- 47:51Speaker 4: animate Republicans on the anti trust front, which it absolutely did.
- 47:56Speaker 4: Now I would argue Google has played Trump a little
- 47:59Speaker 4: bit like a fit over the last six months plus
- 48:03Speaker 4: or I guess what, almost a year now since he
- 48:05Speaker 4: won the election, and big tech has been getting all
- 48:07Speaker 4: kinds of goodies from Donald Trump. But at the time
- 48:11Speaker 4: Google was freaked out because all of a sudden you
- 48:12Speaker 4: had these Republicans talking about repealing Section two thirty and
- 48:15Speaker 4: anti trust law and all of that, and so they
- 48:18Speaker 4: backed down pretty quickly, but it was still, I mean,
- 48:22Speaker 4: I think, really telling that a journalist was laundering a
- 48:28Speaker 4: report from what we now know to be a foreign
- 48:31Speaker 4: government's operation, well.
- 48:33Speaker 11: Hoping to be a foreign government foreign political party.
- 48:35Speaker 13: Yeah, yeah, So how.
- 48:37Speaker 11: Does it feel to know that it was a cure
- 48:39Speaker 11: Starmer machine operation that was masquerading as this kind of
- 48:44Speaker 11: good media watchdog.
- 48:46Speaker 4: It's not surprising at all because we saw it from
- 48:49Speaker 4: TABI did a lot of reporting back in the day
- 48:50Speaker 4: with the Global Engagement Center and Gabe Kaminski did a
- 48:53Speaker 4: lot of this too, that was propped up by the
- 48:55Speaker 4: American State Department that was putting media companies on blacklist,
- 49:00Speaker 4: including the federalists, including I think unheard where mcconumist got
- 49:03Speaker 4: on one at one point, not a conservative media outlet
- 49:05Speaker 4: at all, places like zero Hedge, like Headerodox things that
- 49:08Speaker 4: question Headerdox outlets that questioned the establishment.
- 49:12Speaker 5: They like, they were all being.
- 49:14Speaker 4: Targeted by actually also groups that were propped up by
- 49:17Speaker 4: the US State Department, where they were getting most of
- 49:19Speaker 4: their funding from you know, state and from other US
- 49:24Speaker 4: governmental or non governmental organizations that are mostly given where
- 49:28Speaker 4: their budget is mostly comes.
- 49:29Speaker 5: From the government.
- 49:30Speaker 11: It was clearly like ideologically aligned with, say like the
- 49:34Speaker 11: Clinton wing, and it flowed out of that whole Russia
- 49:37Speaker 11: Gate and all that. But that's a little different than
- 49:41Speaker 11: it being a straight up black ops operation run out
- 49:47Speaker 11: of the Starmer machine. Like it's one thing to be
- 49:51Speaker 11: like these these are our allies and our friends, and
- 49:53Speaker 11: we hope that like we can weaponize them a little
- 49:56Speaker 11: bit to our advantage. And it's different to be like, oh,
- 49:59Speaker 11: this is is cure Starmer's chief of staff.
- 50:01Speaker 5: It's crazy.
- 50:02Speaker 11: Who is setting it up and operating this thing or
- 50:06Speaker 11: or at least or at least is very heavily involved.
- 50:08Speaker 4: And I think that's a good point because it's especially
- 50:10Speaker 4: egregious than that you have a foreign government attempting to
- 50:14Speaker 4: influence the boundaries of free speech in the United States.
- 50:18Speaker 9: I'm like offended on the Federalist behalf.
- 50:20Speaker 4: We should all be I mean, we should just all
- 50:22Speaker 4: be offended as American parts behalf too, that an ally
- 50:26Speaker 4: like the UK would be interfering in what are what
- 50:29Speaker 4: is our far superior approach to free speech and the
- 50:33Speaker 4: press in the United States.
- 50:35Speaker 5: They have to clean up their own damn house.
- 50:37Speaker 4: And yeah, we make a lot of mistakes and the
- 50:39Speaker 4: Trump administration has had some crackdowns that journals should be
- 50:42Speaker 4: uncomfortable with and are uncomfortable with. But our system is
- 50:46Speaker 4: better than their system.
- 50:47Speaker 5: So how dare they.
- 50:48Speaker 4: Stick their fingers and mettle into our free press? Because
- 50:54Speaker 4: guess what it's going to come out. We're going to
- 50:56Speaker 4: figure it out. And drop side exists.
- 50:58Speaker 11: Drop side exists that the Federalists in bright Bart they
- 51:01Speaker 11: might be sobs, but they're our sobs. I care you will,
- 51:07Speaker 11: we will take them on. And also, why don't you
- 51:09Speaker 11: don't try to do this for us?
- 51:11Speaker 5: What's your problem with zero hedge?
- 51:13Speaker 6: Right?
- 51:13Speaker 5: Your problem with zero hedge is that they questioned.
- 51:16Speaker 9: And nogeal frage and like right, yeah, but the.
- 51:20Speaker 4: Problem with these organizations is that they question. It's happy
- 51:22Speaker 4: with TikTok, We covered this earlier in the show with
- 51:25Speaker 4: our guest. It's going to come for the left, just
- 51:28Speaker 4: because the kind of Clinton, like you said, Clinton wing
- 51:32Speaker 4: controlled a lot of our institutions post twenty seventeen and
- 51:36Speaker 4: used them to resist Trump and push back against Donald Trump.
- 51:39Speaker 4: So it was coming for the federalists in Breitbart and
- 51:42Speaker 4: zero Hedge whatever else.
- 51:44Speaker 5: It's coming for the left too. It's coming, and it's.
- 51:46Speaker 9: Going to game for him. Yeah right, yeah, exactly.
- 51:49Speaker 4: But that was always so my topic and gross and
- 51:52Speaker 4: especially that a like lefty journalists would participate in it
- 51:56Speaker 4: was really really disgusting.
- 51:58Speaker 5: Hope we learned a lesson though, I don't.
- 52:00Speaker 9: Okay, I get comment from him now now that he
- 52:03Speaker 9: knows that I didn't. I didn't realize that part of it.
- 52:07Speaker 5: Yeah, I'll send you. I'll send you some stuff.
- 52:09Speaker 11: Excellent, cool, good, Well, there should be some good follow
- 52:11Speaker 11: ups because you know, hopefully.
- 52:13Speaker 5: Hewn the onion now so joke.
- 52:16Speaker 9: I don't know, but so hopefully the.
- 52:18Speaker 11: Bright part and the federalists will actually follow this up. Yeah,
- 52:22Speaker 11: we'll see it goes from.
- 52:23Speaker 5: Here, Ryan, So glad drop side existence.
- 52:27Speaker 9: There you go.
- 52:28Speaker 11: All right, Well, interesting show today, so interesting, no doubt
- 52:31Speaker 11: about it. We'll be back on Friday.
- 52:34Speaker 5: That's right, we'll be back.
- 52:35Speaker 4: We've we have two shows left in studio before Christmas too,
- 52:38Speaker 4: so we'll be here next week week after out with
- 52:41Speaker 4: the gorgeous Christmas Lights and Christmas the.
- 52:43Speaker 9: Core and Against catch us December tenth at where where
- 52:47Speaker 9: is it? It's on Capitol Hill, like HEAs, a place called.
- 52:50Speaker 4: Row the Majestic Majestic Theater. You can check out the
- 52:55Speaker 4: description for the link. But yeah, Ryan and I are
- 52:58Speaker 4: debating that big tech does more harm than good. All right,
- 53:02Speaker 4: we'll feel We feel great about our our we were
- 53:05Speaker 4: morally confident in our position.
- 53:07Speaker 5: We're doing this with the lovely folks over at Reason.
- 53:10Speaker 9: If we lose, it was rigged.
- 53:11Speaker 5: If we lose, it was rigged. So make sure to
- 53:14Speaker 5: stay tuned.
- 53:15Speaker 4: If you're interested, come and see us in DC and
- 53:18Speaker 4: we will see you on Friday with more breaking points