Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Supreme Court Chevron Decision and Credit Unions
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:37episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:39Today's podcast is going to be about Supreme Court decisions that
- 0:44Will likely impact credit unions.
- 0:47Two weeks ago, Friday, the Supreme court came out with two relevant decisions.
- 0:52They are Chevron and I posted about Chevron on LinkedIn, which is going to
- 0:58be what I focus on here in this podcast is talking through what I posted on
- 1:02LinkedIn after reading through it.
- 1:04The first time my take on what it will mean for NC way and banking
- 1:10regulators in general, and then also.
- 1:13There was a second case called Jar Kezi or Jar Keezy versus the SCC, and that
- 1:19impacts civil money penalties, which are rare in credit unions, but This decision
- 1:24will likely make them even or rare.
- 1:27All right.
- 1:27So back to Chevron,
- 1:29so Chevron deference was a legal doctrine in the United States
- 1:34administrative law that was established by the Supreme court's
- 1:381984 decision in Chevron USA versus the natural resource defense council.
- 1:44The Chevron Doctrine required courts to defer to a federal agency's
- 1:49reasonable interpretation of an ambiguous statute that the agency
- 1:54is charged with administering.
- 1:56And what happened was, since 1984, there have been many court decisions and Supreme
- 2:02Court decisions where essentially, I'll call it in a baseball term, tie goes to
- 2:07the runner, the runner being the agency.
- 2:10Someone sues an agency, says you're not.
- 2:13Following the Federal Credit Union Act, and it goes all the way to court
- 2:18or to Supreme Court, and they decide that if it falls into the area of the
- 2:25law being ambiguous, and the agency, See also Now, if they interpreted that
- 2:32and that interpretation was reasonable, they will defer to the agency.
- 2:38Now what has happened under Chevron being overturned is that they will
- 2:43no longer defer to the agency.
- 2:45So it will be decided by the court.
- 2:50And that can be any court on the federal court along the way, all
- 2:53the way up to the Supreme Court.
- 2:56The decision from late June of 2024 overrules the Chevron deference,
- 3:03a long standing legal doctrine that required courts to defer
- 3:07to federal agencies reasonable interpretations of ambiguous statutes.
- 3:12So two key words are, is the statute ambiguous and was the federal
- 3:17agency's determination reasonable?
- 3:20The key points of the decision are majority opinion written by Chief
- 3:24Justice Roberts holds that Chevron deference is incompatible with the
- 3:29Administrative Procedures Act or the APA and the proper rule of courts.
- 3:35The court states that judges must now exercise their own independent judgment
- 3:40in interpreting statutes rather than deferring to agency interpretations.
- 3:45The majority argues that Chevron was poorly reasoned, unworkable
- 3:50in practice and inconsistent with separation of powers principle.
- 3:55The court overruled Chevron on ground saying.
- 4:00The doctrine's flaws outweigh the need to uphold precedent.
- 4:04So there's years and years of precedent, but they're saying that doesn't matter.
- 4:09Justice Kagan writes a dissenting opinion joined by two others stating
- 4:15that Chevron was correctly decided and reflects Congress's intent.
- 4:20Overruling it will cause massive disruption for the legal system.
- 4:24Which is probably true.
- 4:25The majority is improperly expanding judicial power at the expense of
- 4:30agencies expertise, the decision is likely to have wide ranging impacts
- 4:35on administrative law and regulatory policies across many areas of government.
- 4:41The court vacates and remands the lower court decisions that have a.
- 4:44that had applied Chevron deference in the specific cases under review.
- 4:48This ruling represents a major shift in how courts will review agency actions and
- 4:53interpretations of statutes going forward.
- 4:57Now, a question that was posed was, does this apply to past decisions?
- 5:03Now, the court did address this specifically in the opinion, and
- 5:06according to the majority, the six versus three that overruled Chevron.
- 5:11The decision to overrule Chevron does not apply.
- 5:14Automatically invalidate prior cases that relied on Chevron deference.
- 5:19Justice Roberts writes, by overruling Chevron, though the court does not
- 5:23call into question prior cases that relied on the Chevron framework,
- 5:28the holdings of those cases that specific agency actions are lawful.
- 5:33Including the Clear Clean Air Act holding of Chevron itself are still subject to
- 5:38statutory review, despite the court's change in interpretive methodology.
- 5:45The court states that mere reliance on Chevron in a past decision is
- 5:50not enough on its own to justify overturning that decision.
- 5:54There would need to be some additional special justification beyond just
- 5:59the fact that Chevron was applied.
- 6:01However, Justice Kagan, in her dissent, expresses skepticism about this assurance.
- 6:08She argues that courts motivated to overturn old Chevron based decisions
- 6:13could easily find or manufacture a special justification to do so.
- 6:18Kagan also points out that even if prior judicial decisions are not
- 6:24automatically overturned, many agency interpretations that were never
- 6:28challenged under Chevron May now be vulnerable to new legal challenges.
- 6:33For example let's say there was a challenge on field membership, but as
- 6:38defined in the federal credit union act, which there have been, there
- 6:41was a situation where a judge ruled against NCUA on the determination
- 6:46of what the definition of rural was.
- 6:49And so I appealed that and later went on to win saying at the higher level,
- 6:53they decided that NCUA under Chevron.
- 6:57That there would be a deference to NCUA in that regard.
- 7:00So that deference would go away.
- 7:02So what I anticipate may happen, and this was pointed out to me by
- 7:06someone who will remain nameless at NCUA, who pointed out, pointed me
- 7:11in the direction of field membership when I started thinking about this.
- 7:14And I want to thank him or her for that.
- 7:17And anyway, so, the definition of rural, you could see someone go get
- 7:21a community charter and then the ABA sue on behalf of banks, and then
- 7:25that work its way through the system.
- 7:27And all of a sudden, voila, the field of membership rules
- 7:30get tighter because of Chevron.
- 7:32That's a specific example that That I think is which shows
- 7:35the real world ramifications of Chevron's impact on credit unions.
- 7:41Back to my post on LinkedIn, I want to go to that and walk through
- 7:48the major issues as it relates to Chevron and credit unions.
- 7:52And the issue I discussed there was, will this impact agency guidance?
- 7:57Now, By way of background, so you have the Federal Credit Union Act, which is which
- 8:01is put in place by a Congressional Act and from there, you have NCRA regulations,
- 8:07which further extrapolate and expand and interpret and create regulations
- 8:14as required for for working within the confines of the Federal Credit Union Act,
- 8:19for example commercial loan rule rule on risk based net worth, for example.
- 8:24The Federal Credit Union Act put in place prompt corrective action.
- 8:28And then when Congress did that, they said NCUA needed to interpret the
- 8:32Federal Credit Union Act and write a regulation in response to that.
- 8:35Now that regulation could be found to be in violation of the Federal Credit
- 8:39Union Act in a situation where the Federal Credit Union Act was determined
- 8:45to be ambiguous and then the regulation interpreted that in the past, that
- 8:53would be, again, tie goes to the runner, they would rely On the agency.
- 8:57Now, in the future, when it's pursued, that would be decided by the judges.
- 9:02Now, back to the LinkedIn post and the topic of guidance.
- 9:07You've got the Federal Credit Union Act approved by Congress.
- 9:09You have regulations approved by NCUA.
- 9:12And then you have guidance.
- 9:13Now I've said in other podcasts that the way the other banking regulators
- 9:17do guidance is a little bit different.
- 9:19They actually put it out for public comment and CUA does not do that.
- 9:22They just issue it after either a review by the board chairman or if
- 9:27the board chairman wants to seek the input of the other board members,
- 9:31they can, but the final ends with the CUA board chairman, for example.
- 9:37Letters to credit unions on liquidity.
- 9:39Letters to credit unions on indirect lending.
- 9:42Letters to credit unions on third party due diligence.
- 9:45Letters to credit unions on priority letters, which comes out every year.
- 9:51That is guidance that NCWA relies upon in its examination.
- 9:55And links it to safety and soundness.
- 9:57So you can also get into safety and soundness.
- 10:00Is it defined in the Federal Credit Union Act?
- 10:02No.
- 10:02Is it referenced in the Federal Credit Union Act?
- 10:05Yes.
- 10:06And then NCUA interprets that and links all this guidance to that.
- 10:09So I think there's potentially, theoretically, an opportunity for
- 10:14guidance to be impacted heavily.
- 10:16And here's how.
- 10:17Number one, I would say, There is a reduced deference to NCUA agency
- 10:23guidance documents, which are often interpret statutes or regulations
- 10:27will no longer receive automatic deference from courts under Chevron.
- 10:32This could weaken the practical force of such guidance.
- 10:36In the end, I'll explain the likelihood of this and the timelines for this, etc.
- 10:39But because of Chevron, guidance is now, in and of itself, a
- 10:45weaker position for an agency to take, any agency, including NCUA.
- 10:51Number two, increase vulnerability to the credit union challenge.
- 10:55Without Chevron deference, NCUA guidance will likely be more vulnerable
- 11:00to appeal and legal challenges.
- 11:02Courts will now apply their own judgment in interpreting statutes
- 11:05potentially disagreeing with agency interpretations more frequently.
- 11:09Again, statute regulation, guidance, guidance is an extrapolation
- 11:15of regulation, which is an extrapolation of the federal credit
- 11:18union act and congressional acts.
- 11:20And all of that now is in play.
- 11:22Potentially don't get too excited, potentially.
- 11:26And we'll explain that at the end.
- 11:28Heightened scrutiny.
- 11:29NCOA may need to provide more robust justifications for their interpretations
- 11:34and guidance documents, knowing that courts will scrutinize them more closely.
- 11:39So what happens if you know somebody is going to scrutinize you?
- 11:41You move a little bit more methodically.
- 11:43That could slow things down.
- 11:44It could also be a positive in that NCOA won't issue nice to have guidance.
- 11:50They'll only issue need to have guidance.
- 11:53Number four, potential decrease in guidance.
- 11:56As I just said, NSUA might become more cautious about issuing guidance
- 12:00documents, particularly on contentious or ambiguous statutory provisions due to
- 12:07the increased risk of judicial override.
- 12:10Note that in material, so A material amount of NCOA guidance is very
- 12:16dated, emphasis on the word very.
- 12:19This is because staff avoids bringing it forward to the board because of
- 12:23the risk the updates make the guidance less effective due to board influence.
- 12:28Now, ironically, Chevron does the same.
- 12:30It takes the power from staff and agencies and puts it with
- 12:33politically appointed judges.
- 12:36Now I mentioned indirect lending guidance and third party due diligence guidance.
- 12:40That's more than 10, 15 years old.
- 12:43Now, has it stood the test of time?
- 12:45Some could argue it.
- 12:46Yes.
- 12:47Some could argue, no, I'd probably be in the middle because other agencies
- 12:50have come out with other guidance, which is actually more robust and better.
- 12:54Then what NCOA has now, why don't they bring it forward?
- 12:58Because the staff, in my opinion, and I've seen this discussed and heard this
- 13:03discussed is wary that if they bring it forward, that they'll get more teeth.
- 13:08They might get less teeth.
- 13:09And so old guidance that is good.
- 13:12The NCOA staff will not try and make it perfect.
- 13:15If good is good enough.
- 13:17And usually it is again, don't let perfect be the enemy of the good.
- 13:21And CUEA staff doesn't bring it forward.
- 13:23So unless a compelling reason for guidance comes out or a board member
- 13:27says, I think we should rewrite this, the old guidance tends to stand.
- 13:32Now that doesn't mean that credit unions can't push against that
- 13:36envelope, but again, we'll explain that a little bit more as we get
- 13:39closer to the end of this discussion.
- 13:42Now there could be a shift in focus.
- 13:44NCOA may put more emphasis on formal rulemaking processes, which typically
- 13:49carry more legal weight rather than relying on guidance documents.
- 13:53While this is a slower overtime, it may be the better resolution.
- 13:57Now, again, NCOA board will only likely take regulations forward
- 14:04that they absolutely deem necessary.
- 14:07And but I could see that guidance becomes less and less under this
- 14:11and regulations come into play, theoretically, but more on that.
- 14:15Now, will there be a retroactive impact?
- 14:17I went into this a little bit, but while the court states that past judicial
- 14:21decisions rely on Chevron are not automatically invalidated, guidance
- 14:25and legal interpretations that has not been subject to judicial review.
- 14:30May be more vulnerable to new challenges.
- 14:33For example, think of a Federal Community Charter that gets approved in 2025.
- 14:38Will the ABA sue?
- 14:39You bet, and they might win, so that tightens up field membership and reduces
- 14:44the value of the Federal Charter.
- 14:47Uncertainty is an issue.
- 14:48There may be a period of increased uncertainty as agencies and regulated
- 14:52entities adjust to the new legal landscape and courts develop new approaches
- 14:57to reviewing agency interpretations.
- 15:00Interestingly, as an aside, , I saw an article about how and actually
- 15:05was speaking with a client who is an attorney who indicated that there are
- 15:10full classes on Chevron and that the client mentioned that, and then lo and
- 15:14behold, I saw an article Where this discussion was that all these classes
- 15:19in law schools are going to have to be reworked because, it said everything
- 15:23that they said was yellow is now purple.
- 15:25So they need to flip the case, the class because of this case and Chevron
- 15:32used to provide that difference.
- 15:33Now it doesn't.
- 15:34And what does that mean?
- 15:35That's going to be part of that upheaval in the legal system
- 15:38that was referenced earlier.
- 15:40So there could be a potential legislative response.
- 15:43Congress might respond by being more explicit in delegating
- 15:47interpretive authority to agencies in future legislation, or by
- 15:50clarifying existing statutes.
- 15:52Now this to me might be the best case, in some situations, but it's a double
- 15:57edged sword, as writing a law with the intent of being explicit is different
- 16:02than actually achieving that in the end.
- 16:05So as Congress in their infinite wisdom tries to come up with better
- 16:08language that is not ambiguous, guess what words are ambiguous.
- 16:13I think that's going to be a heavier lift than what others think might
- 16:18be the case, but there could be definitely an effort by Congress.
- 16:21Will they succeed?
- 16:22They rarely succeed at anything these days.
- 16:24So I doubt it.
- 16:26How about safety and soundness?
- 16:28Now I'm still thinking this one through, but I think credit unions
- 16:31that want to appeal will have a better chance of winning if they
- 16:34attack safety and soundness.
- 16:36Why is that?
- 16:37Because it's very discretionary.
- 16:39It's very ambiguous, but here's what I was saying early.
- 16:44Don't celebrate too quickly.
- 16:46Because appeals are an extremely heavy lift and to really get traction, it would
- 16:51have to go beyond the walls of NCUA and you'd have to take it down the judicial
- 16:56path to get ultimate turnover here.
- 16:58Meanwhile, you still need to comply with the examination while the appeal
- 17:02and or court challenge is going on.
- 17:04Said another way, You will likely find yourself in the same situation
- 17:09that my clients find themselves every time NCUA writes something in an exam
- 17:13report or has a discussion with them.
- 17:16They decide if they want to go along, to get along.
- 17:19NCUA, just like everybody, has good ideas, bad ideas, and mediocre ideas.
- 17:24The good ideas you're going to go along with, the mediocre ideas you
- 17:28might decide to go along, to get along.
- 17:30Bad ideas are going to be where you decide That you might want to appeal and then
- 17:35ultimately appeal beyond the walls of NCUA, but you're going to want to approach
- 17:40that very carefully because it's a long journey with a lot of associated costs
- 17:45and more often than not, you are better.
- 17:48You're going to find out that you best try and negotiate with NCUA to get the best
- 17:54possible exam result, the best possible document resolution, et cetera, et cetera.
- 17:59There will be some situations, I think.
- 18:02Where credit unions will push back or banks will push back or
- 18:06people will push back on the IRS or people will push back on the EPA.
- 18:11And as these rules get rewritten, most likely at other agencies, there
- 18:17will be guidance that will come out on guidance for federal agencies and
- 18:21there will be an improvement here where agencies will have to Put things more
- 18:27in regulation and be more clear in regulation and stick to the actual law.
- 18:33And this is going to be a long journey.
- 18:34So while there is, while this has far reaching impacts on every federal
- 18:41agency, and I think we will see some of the overreach of the CB CFPB or
- 18:47the presumed overreach, depending on which side of the table you're on.
- 18:51I believe you'll start to see people push back on key situations.
- 18:56And then when those things are decided at the Supreme court level, we'll see
- 19:00agencies get a little bit more scared about their guidance, a little bit more.
- 19:06Reasonable.
- 19:08In their regulation, and in the end, this is a very, very good thing.
- 19:13Now, there's lots of chatter in credit unions about this.
- 19:16There's lots of chatter at NCUA.
- 19:17I had some other retirees that were sending out thoughts on this.
- 19:22As I mentioned, I had some NCUA staff reach out to me relative to it.
- 19:26And in the end, I think this is good for credit unions.
- 19:29Now, I want to pivot to another case.
- 19:32Pause.
- 19:32I
- 19:33want to pivot to another case that I mentioned, which is Jarkezy.
- 19:37Jarkezy.
- 19:37Jarkezy.
- 19:38On who appealed, which is Jari against the SEC.
- 19:43Now this decision, the Supreme Court has significant implications for
- 19:49banking agency's ability to assess penalties through administrative.
- 19:53Proceedings.
- 19:54It calls into question the constitutionality of administrative
- 19:57proceedings used by banking regulators to impose civil money
- 20:01penalties or civil penalties.
- 20:04The court ruled that the SEC's use of in house administrative lodges judges
- 20:09to impose civil penalties for securities fraud violations was unconstitutional
- 20:14as it violated the defendant's Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial.
- 20:19Many bank agencies like the OCC, Federal Reserve, and FDIC and NCUA
- 20:23use similar administrative processes to assess civil money penalties
- 20:27against banks and individuals for violations of banking laws.
- 20:31The reasoning in this decision Suggests that processes may now be constitutionally
- 20:37suspect the court held that when the government seeks to impose civil
- 20:41penalties, defendants have a right to a jury trial in federal court rather
- 20:46than an administrative proceeding.
- 20:48If the claim is analogous to 1, that would have required a jury trial at common law.
- 20:54This likely means banking agencies will have to bring civil penalty actions
- 20:58in federal court, rather than through internal administrative processes, by
- 21:03the way, NCOA's process is internal admin and administ, an internal
- 21:07administrative process, if they want to impose monetary penalties on banks.
- 21:12credit unions, banks, or individuals.
- 21:15It may significantly reduce banking agencies abilities to quickly and
- 21:19efficiently impose penalties through streamlined administrative proceedings.
- 21:24Federal court litigation is typically more time consuming and resource intensive.
- 21:30The decision potentially impacts dozens of federal agencies beyond
- 21:34just banking regulators that have relied on administrative proceedings
- 21:37to impose civil penalties.
- 21:40However, the full scope of the ruling impact on banking agencies is not
- 21:44entirely clear as the court focused specifically on security fraud claims.
- 21:50There may be attempts to distinguish other types of banking violations.
- 21:54Banking agencies may need to reassess and restructure their enforcement
- 21:58processes in light of this decision to ensure they comply with the 7th
- 22:02Amendment jury trial right when seeking to impose civil money penalties.
- 22:06Thank you for your time, In summary, this ruling seems to significantly curtail
- 22:10bank regulators ability to unilaterally impose civil money penalties through
- 22:14administrative proceedings, likely requiring them to pursue such penalties
- 22:19through federal court actions instead.
- 22:21However, the full implications may take time to play out as agencies and courts
- 22:26grapple with applying the decision to different regulatory contexts.
- 22:30So what does this mean for credit unions?
- 22:33Here's the thing.
- 22:34NCUA rarely, and I mean rarely, uses civil money penalties.
- 22:38They will jump over that and go to conservatorship actions, quite frankly,
- 22:42if they feel that there is a need.
- 22:44They occasionally would do it for filing of late 5300s and then waive
- 22:49it, and they would occasionally do it when someone has been put in jail and
- 22:54that there, there was fraud involved.
- 22:57I've had discussions with credit unions where they have to sign
- 23:00a letter of understanding and agreement that might be published.
- 23:03Or they enter into a cease and desist order which might be
- 23:06subject to civil money penalties.
- 23:08And I, when I have those conversations, I say, NCUA uses
- 23:12civil money penalties very rarely.
- 23:14And because of this decision, I think it will be even more rare.
- 23:18It's not really, while it's on the decision tree of what NCUA
- 23:21could do, this makes it even more remote that NCUA will do it.
- 23:26That's all I've got for you today.
- 23:28I hope you have a good week and stay tuned.
- 23:31This Chevron decision, how it impacts credit unions, how it impacts guidance,
- 23:35how it impacts regulations, it's going to be a long journey, but I
- 23:38think over time the ruling will.
- 23:41Make it better for credit unions and harder for N.
- 23:45C.
- 23:45U.
- 23:45A.
- 23:46And harder for other banking regulators.
- 23:49And it's going to be very interesting to see what cases get brought forward
- 23:54to start moving the ball here.
- 23:57But I think it will be something that we see the Supreme Court dealing with
- 24:01here in the next few years and then understanding the ramifications of that.
- 24:06And again, in summary, while it's going to make NCWA relying on
- 24:09guidance harder, I don't think it's going to happen immediately.
- 24:12And I don't think it's going to be something that you're
- 24:14going to feel in the front.
- 24:15The front lines with with your examination, should you find yourself in
- 24:19a situation where you want to appeal or you think that there's overreach or you
- 24:23think you have a good case for this reach out and let's have a discussion and I
- 24:27can walk through whether or not I think it might make sense for you to do that.
- 24:31All right, this is great.
- 24:32Chatting with you again here again, and I appreciate you listening as always.
- 24:36This is Mark.
- 24:37This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors
- 24:47Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 24:51your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 24:55of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 24:59If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 25:02out our services at marktreichel.
- 25:04com.