Latest / Consumerpedia / 98 - The Benefits of Shopping Locally
Transcript
- 0:02It's something we often hear about during the holiday
- 0:04shopping season. Shop local.
- 0:06Of course, local businesses would like you to shop with them
- 0:09year round. And from all indications, the
- 0:11shop local movement is catching on in many places.
- 0:14I'm her Weissbaum, the Consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 0:18checkbook.org. Welcome to Consumerpedia at
- 0:21checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:24consumers select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:27Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:30any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:34completely independent and objective.
- 0:36Now here's the host of Consumerpedia America's consumer
- 0:40expert, the consumer man Herb Weisspaum.
- 0:43The Shop Local movement encourages us to buy goods and
- 0:46services from locally owned, independent businesses rather
- 0:49than national chains or online giants.
- 0:51It's both an economic strategy and social campaign aimed at
- 0:55supporting the local economy, fostering community identity and
- 0:58promoting sustainability. Here to talk about all that?
- 1:00Jen Barger, Checkbooks director of content.
- 1:03Hi, delighted to be here. This is a topic that's very
- 1:06close to my heart. And Stacy Price, founder of Shop
- 1:09Made Brands. Her stores only sell products
- 1:11made in a specific area. And she has now eight of those
- 1:14in DC, Maryland and Virginia. Hello, Stacey.
- 1:17Hello, thanks for having me. So Stacey, it sounds like Shop
- 1:20Local has really taken off. I would say so.
- 1:23I've been working in this movement for a couple of decades
- 1:26now, and I'm excited to say that my job is less telling people
- 1:32why they should shop local and more providing the space for it
- 1:35to happen. What sort of products do you
- 1:37sell in the stores and how many small companies do you think
- 1:40sell through those stores? Anything that you could imagine
- 1:43using and buying, we carry in our stores.
- 1:46So imagine the best home and gift store with the added bonus
- 1:50that everything is made by your neighbors.
- 1:53We currently in our eight locations, we serve somewhere
- 1:58around 850 makers and then more with pop up markets and
- 2:05different spotlight activities. So.
- 2:06Stacey, you have been quoted as saying we're changing the face
- 2:10of retail. What do you mean by that?
- 2:11I think that the the sheer mass of people that are sourcing
- 2:16local and the majority of consumers that are supporting
- 2:21the movement are reminding everybody else that we all get
- 2:25to vote with our dollars. We get to show developers that
- 2:29we want these businesses in our community.
- 2:32We get to show the big boxes that we don't need them as much
- 2:37as they think that we need them. And we get to show people that
- 2:41are skilled and and entrepreneurs feel that they can
- 2:45create a living by manufacturing something or by starting their
- 2:50own business. Jen, from previous episodes, we
- 2:53know you like to shop. He just wrote a story for
- 2:56Checkbook about your attempt to shop local for 30 days, and
- 2:58we're going to dive into that in the next segment.
- 3:01But right now, I'd like to know what appeals to you about
- 3:04spending your money with a small independent retailer.
- 3:06I think that it's because you get to know often the
- 3:10shopkeepers or sometimes you get to know the people who are
- 3:13making something. I mean, you might get to know a
- 3:17local artist and you're like, you know, I love your painting,
- 3:20but it's not big enough for my living room.
- 3:23And they might make you one that's the right size.
- 3:25So it's it's really about forming relationships and it
- 3:30makes you closer to your neighbors as well as
- 3:33economically supporting them. So that's what appeals to me.
- 3:36It's just a different kind of shopping that takes a lot of the
- 3:40bland out of your retail experience.
- 3:42So devil's advocate kind of question here for you, Stacy.
- 3:45If I shop at Target or Home Depot or Lowe's or whatever,
- 3:48local people are being employed, local people are making a living
- 3:52from my purchases. So how is that different from
- 3:54shopping at a local store? True, local stores are are going
- 3:58to 100% put employing local residents as a top priority, but
- 4:05they're also going to put all of their other business practices,
- 4:10doing all of their other business practices with local
- 4:12businesses a priority. So they're going to use a local
- 4:16printer, they're going to use a local cleaner, they're going to
- 4:19source all of their local supplies from the local hardware
- 4:22store. They're probably going to
- 4:24prioritize their sourcing, if not from local manufacturers,
- 4:29but then from other independent manufacturers in the US.
- 4:33So we know all the statistics about how local businesses are
- 4:38more willing to give back to their community, whether that's
- 4:42through a canned food drive that's going on right now due to
- 4:45SNAP benefits or it's a donation to schools.
- 4:50I can't tell you how many gift cards I donate on a weekly
- 4:54basis. We are just known.
- 4:56Local businesses are known to give back to their communities
- 4:59in a larger sense than the big box stores.
- 5:02So both from spending money to companies that help the store
- 5:05like a printer or whatever, and also giving back to the
- 5:08community because you're in the community, so to speak.
- 5:10Yeah. We did an informal analysis of
- 5:13our books last year, Herb, where we looked at, you know, we are a
- 5:17local store, We source only local and we prioritize using
- 5:23only local vendors for all of our business operation
- 5:27practices. And we configured that 91 cents
- 5:31of every dollar that you spend in our businesses go right back
- 5:36into their community. Wow, that's great.
- 5:39You know, we have stores in my state similar to what Stacey's
- 5:41doing. They're called Made in
- 5:42Washington. They only sell products made in
- 5:44Washington. We go there for special presents
- 5:47and holiday gifts and they have such a variety of products, all
- 5:50sorts of local jams and chocolates and more than two
- 5:52dozen locally roasted coffee, such as Bigfoot blend.
- 5:55Of course, we'd have that out here in Washington.
- 5:57So not only these are a wonderful selection, but the
- 5:59people who work in the stores also know the products they're
- 6:03selling, unlike when you go to a big box store.
- 6:05Jen, is that one of the appeals to you?
- 6:06I totally think it is. And one of the things, you know,
- 6:09I, I travel a lot and one of the things that I love to do when I
- 6:12travel even is shop at local places.
- 6:14Because I mean, do you really want to go to England or even to
- 6:19New York City and shop at Zara when you could shop at a local
- 6:23boutique? Because, you know, you can
- 6:26usually get those things from a chain store online anyhow.
- 6:29And it's not, I don't know, it's not, it's not adding that much.
- 6:32It's not giving you a taste of something different or local.
- 6:36What would it be like to only shop local for 30 days?
- 6:39Jen tried that, and she'll share her experience with us next.
- 6:43I'm her Weissbaum, the consumer man.
- 6:45And this is Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 6:49At checkbook.org, we have the answers to your consumer
- 6:52questions 24/7. That's checkbook.org.
- 6:55We're a unique nonprofit that can help you with select local
- 6:58service providers, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 7:01Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 7:04any business, we recommend, you can rely on Checkbook to be
- 7:07completely independent and objective.
- 7:10Our advice is always free. Ratings of local services are
- 7:13available with a subscription. If you live in one of these
- 7:16seven metro areas and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us
- 7:19out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San
- 7:23Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC Get your
- 7:27free 30 day subscription by going to checkbook.org/consumer
- 7:31Pedia. Surveys show that many people
- 7:35would like to shop local more often, but that's not always
- 7:38easy to do. Jen, for your latest checkbook
- 7:40article, you tried to only shop local for 30 days and found it
- 7:44challenging. Tell us the rules you set up for
- 7:46yourself and what you did. Well, so the rules I set up for
- 7:48myself and for my husband were that we had to suspend our
- 7:52Amazon account. We could not purchase anything
- 7:56at a store that was a chain unless it was a local chain.
- 8:00So that meant groceries, that meant pharmacies, that even
- 8:04meant shoes. And strangely we both needed
- 8:06shoes in the month we did it in. So and we had to report
- 8:10everything because one of the things we were doing and it's
- 8:12not super scientific, but we were tracking whether or not it
- 8:16was more expensive to shop locally.
- 8:20And we'll let you reveal that in a minute, but tell us what the
- 8:22experience was like. My husband was kind of mad
- 8:25because he does more of the grocery shopping and he loves
- 8:27Harris Teeter but they're a chain and so he but he had to
- 8:31keep to the experiment. We found that some things were
- 8:34more expensive. We eat a lot of fish and getting
- 8:37fish for a reasonable price did end up being more expensive at
- 8:41our local market. Was it better fish?
- 8:43Maybe. So we did that.
- 8:45And we also, for example, I moved all of my prescriptions
- 8:50from CVS to a local pharmacy called Chafeli.
- 8:55Don't, please don't ask me to spell that, but I moved it
- 8:58there. And while there were a few
- 9:01inconveniences with moving to Chafeli, like for some reason,
- 9:04since they've been around since, I don't know, 1880 or something,
- 9:08they don't have a system where they auto renew and they don't
- 9:11text you when RXS are ready. But they're nicer and they don't
- 9:15sell their toothpaste from behind a plastic screen like
- 9:19they do at CVS. So I was a convert.
- 9:22I'm at now at Sheffalies for life.
- 9:24Things like that were a challenge.
- 9:25And my husband, who's a recently retired economist, he kind of
- 9:29got into it and he, but he found that instead of being able to go
- 9:32maybe to 1 store like the Harris Teeter, he ended up going to
- 9:36multiple stores. And I usually go to the farmers
- 9:38market every weekend. So the farmers market really we,
- 9:41we ate more seasonally, I'll tell you that.
- 9:43And it did make us shocked less in general because you don't,
- 9:47you know, I have an on and off affair with the Amazon.
- 9:50You know, I break up with them constantly and then end up and
- 9:53then end up going back because I need something like why I need 8
- 9:55inch tall tapers for Thanksgiving and I can't find
- 9:58them anywhere. But it made a shop less so that
- 10:01was, I think, good. By the way, my father was a
- 10:05independent pharmacist in King of Prussia, PA, back when it was
- 10:08a sleepy little suburb outside of Philadelphia.
- 10:10And I know the way we treated customers as compared to when
- 10:13the big chain thrift drugs came in was night and day, the way we
- 10:17took care of people and what we did.
- 10:18My father delivered for free. He once walked in the snow to
- 10:21deliver prescriptions to people. And the thrift drug who, Yeah,
- 10:24maybe the, you know, the ice cream was two cents a gallon
- 10:27cheaper or something, but there was no customer service
- 10:29whatsoever. But people went for the price,
- 10:31and sometimes they're not the same.
- 10:33You have to decide which way you want to go.
- 10:34Yeah. And I also feel like people at
- 10:37these chain stores, I have nothing against the CVS in my
- 10:40neighborhood. The pharmacists are good there,
- 10:42but they're overwhelmed. And I've not saying the local
- 10:45pharmacy seems pretty busy too, but they do seem to pick up the
- 10:49phone if I call and it's just an altogether more pleasant
- 10:52experience. I think corporate places maybe,
- 10:55who knows if there are quotas, but they, you know, they have to
- 10:57implement policies that are often more about the bottom line
- 11:01and less about the customer. Like, for instance, those you
- 11:04know, everything is locked in a plastic screen now at CVS, which
- 11:08makes you know, shopping for things that aren't drugs is
- 11:10very, it's a very unpleasant experience.
- 11:13Did you find some situations you absolutely had to just go with a
- 11:16big name retailer? Well, I stepped on my e-reader
- 11:21midway through the month and I'm a big reader.
- 11:23I can really can't exist without an e-reader.
- 11:26And I stepped on it, I cracked it, I tried to keep reading on
- 11:29it. And then I, I went down a whole
- 11:31rabbit hole and I was like, well, I can switch to there is
- 11:34this great app called bookshop.org is that enables you
- 11:39to buy books from independent retailers even if you don't show
- 11:43up in person. So here in DC, we can, you know,
- 11:46do it at politics and prose or there's a local bookstore in my
- 11:50neighborhood called Lost City Books.
- 11:53But what I found was that with e-reader, I went back and forth.
- 11:58I almost bought a new iPad, but I, I did buy a new Kindle.
- 12:02And now Jeff Bezos and I are, you know, playing Footsie again
- 12:06on the Kindle, which I hate. But you know, I just, I, I
- 12:09couldn't justify the 400 more dollars that a new iPad was
- 12:12going to be so. You mentioned something to me
- 12:15before we started taping, which was that you consider Ace
- 12:18Hardware to be shopping local. Well, because they are, and
- 12:21Stacey may know about this as well, is that many of them are
- 12:24local franchises. They're usually locally owned.
- 12:27And so I know that the one in our neighborhood, because Stacey
- 12:31and I live about a block and a half apart, that that's locally
- 12:34owned. So you know you're going to need
- 12:37nails or paint. Yeah, they are a Co-op.
- 12:40So they are all independently owned and inside of a Co-op.
- 12:45And so the ones in DC are not only a part of the Co-op but
- 12:49they are employee owned. Bonus points for our
- 12:52neighborhood ace. Might not be the case
- 12:55everywhere. Or is it all a Co-op?
- 12:56Every ace is a Co-op. OK, good.
- 12:59And that counts as local to you, Stacey.
- 13:00Yes it does. And they give out, you know,
- 13:02free dog treats, so. Whether you have a dog or not,
- 13:06Stacey, what's your reaction to what Jen's experience?
- 13:08You know, I, I got, I had the pleasure of talking to Jen about
- 13:12this, but while she was in the middle of it.
- 13:15And you know, I've always been a localist for as long as I can
- 13:18remember, but I am not a purist. I still have a Kindle.
- 13:22I try to get my books from the library, but I still like that
- 13:27one click on my Kindle there. I still order shoes from
- 13:33Anthropology. There, there.
- 13:35There are always going to be things that people are going to
- 13:38choose to buy either out of convenience or because those
- 13:42things aren't being manufactured in their city or sold by
- 13:46retailers in their city. And I think that's OK.
- 13:49I think we can't expect people to be absolute, but I think that
- 13:53we can encourage people to be thoughtful and to educate them
- 13:58on what is around them and what they can purchase right there in
- 14:03their neighborhoods and why it is important.
- 14:06And again, I feel like our consumers and a lot of a lot of
- 14:10our country are very Privy to that.
- 14:12And you told me the pandemic helped local stores.
- 14:15Yeah, because I think, you know, again, I think that that was the
- 14:18consumer. The consumer created their own
- 14:21campaign for us during the pandemic.
- 14:25Like there was so much chatter around supporting local business
- 14:29that didn't just come from us as businesses, it came from the
- 14:34community. And so during that holiday
- 14:37season, we actually had our best holiday ever, accepting only 5
- 14:43people, you know, at a time in some of our stores.
- 14:46You know, I think the consumer knew that they had to, they
- 14:49understood the assignment. And, and I would say that, you
- 14:52know, since then we've had to message it less.
- 14:56Again, it's about just making it convenient, finding more ways to
- 15:01to meet people where they are and just, you know, continue to
- 15:05show up for your community. You know, I think that the
- 15:08community will continue to show up for small and local business.
- 15:11By the way, am I the only person in America who doesn't have a
- 15:14Kindle and doesn't want a Kindle?
- 15:16Maybe. Maybe.
- 15:18It's so convenient when you travel.
- 15:20And I always need a new book. And so I can't, you know?
- 15:23Yeah. I love I love E readers.
- 15:25Stacy, what about Etsy, which sells products made by
- 15:28individuals or small businesses? Is that how's that fit at all
- 15:31this? When Etsy got started, it was
- 15:34amazing. Somebody creating a product
- 15:37could go to Etsy, They could use Etsy.
- 15:40Etsy created synergy, kind of similar to what we are doing
- 15:43right on a local level. Etsy on an international level
- 15:46would allow, you know, a small artisan to put their items
- 15:50online and someone across the world could find them and find
- 15:56them in a more successful way than finding their own website.
- 16:00Through the years. I, I have to say Etsy is not as
- 16:04clean as it, it used to be. So, you know, Etsy used to be
- 16:08very strict on who it allowed to sell goods on its website.
- 16:13It used to always be handmade goods.
- 16:16And now you, you can go on Etsy and you can still find those
- 16:19things. So I 100% am still an Etsy
- 16:22shopper. I still go to Etsy.
- 16:24You just have to be careful because there are sellers on
- 16:28there that are selling things that are made in China or, you
- 16:31know, made in India or, you know, all of a sudden I'll order
- 16:35for a light fixture for one of my stores thinking that it is,
- 16:39you know, handmade and it will take two months to get to me
- 16:42because it is on a cargo ship. So you have to be careful with
- 16:46Etsy. It's just not as clean.
- 16:48Thanks for explaining it. I'm glad I asked.
- 16:49OK, so you want to do more if you're shopping locally, how you
- 16:52going to do that? We'll talk about that with
- 16:54Stacey and Jen next. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 16:56man, and this is Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 17:01Consumerpedia Fast Facts According to Capital One
- 17:05Shopping, American shoppers spent an estimated $3.74
- 17:10trillion at local stores last year, equivalent to about half
- 17:14of all retail sales. For every $100 spent at local
- 17:18stores, $68 remains in the local economy.
- 17:21Dollar spent at an independent business may recirculate in the
- 17:25local economy an average of 6 to 15 times.
- 17:29Small businesses make up to 136% more charitable donations per
- 17:33employee than businesses with 500 or more employees.
- 17:39You know, my wife and I try to shop with local stores whenever
- 17:42possible. For example, we have a local
- 17:44jeweler who provides excellent service and we try to purchase
- 17:47many of our plants and flowers from the local nursery here in
- 17:49Bellevue, WA. The quality is excellent, but I
- 17:52got to be honest with you, they do charge more than Lowe's or
- 17:54Home Depot. We do it deliberately to support
- 17:57them, but some people can't afford the higher prices.
- 17:59How do we deal with that fact? So what I found in this
- 18:03experiment of shopping locally for 30 days with, with a few
- 18:07slip UPS, I found that that's not always true.
- 18:10So I mean, it can be. And I get, and my husband and I
- 18:14live downtown in DC and we don't have kids and we have a lot of
- 18:18stores we can walk to. But we were surprised that it's
- 18:21not, you know, your local nursery might not always be more
- 18:25expensive than Home Depot. I think it just it we couldn't
- 18:28come up with anything firm on whether that was really true.
- 18:32But quality is important also if you get a plant that dies, a
- 18:35really beautiful plant. So that's why we're willing to
- 18:37pay a little bit more. Sometimes that may be the trade
- 18:39off. Yeah.
- 18:39But I think it's also like, say, the farmers market while we were
- 18:42doing our experiment and just generally in life, I shop at the
- 18:46farmers market in my neighborhood a lot.
- 18:48And yeah, sometimes things are more expensive.
- 18:51But, you know, when blueberries are in season, they taste better
- 18:55when you get them from the farmers market, you know, So I
- 18:58think it ends up being worth it. Or maybe.
- 19:00And one of the things I said in the article was that because we
- 19:03sort of put ourselves on this limitation, you know, we live in
- 19:07Washington, DC, there is not, believe it or not, crab meat at
- 19:10our farmers market. So we ate a lot more vegetarian
- 19:15for that month that we shopped locally because the fish and
- 19:18meat, well, they have them at some local stores.
- 19:20They do tend to be a little more expensive.
- 19:22But I feel like overall it just made me a more mindful shopper
- 19:26than usual. Stacey thoughts on the price
- 19:28points? Well, I was going to.
- 19:29I was just going to bring up the thought of also social capital.
- 19:33Not that you want to go into shopping local expecting this,
- 19:38but you know it. It's about relationships.
- 19:41So if you always are going to the farmers market to buy your
- 19:44goods and you happen to be there often somebody will say, oh, we
- 19:49have this leftover and they give it to you.
- 19:52And there's an added bonus that you get from the relationships
- 19:56that you build with store owners or farmers market vendors,
- 20:00etcetera. That pays off in other ways,
- 20:03whether it be leftover merchandise at the end of an
- 20:07afternoon or a special invitation to a.
- 20:10Discount sip and shop, or a favor in another way?
- 20:13That's something to consider. Final question for both of you,
- 20:17For people who want to shop locally more, how do they start?
- 20:20Jen, you wrote about that in your checkbook story.
- 20:22The farmers market is a great place to start.
- 20:24You know, I know there are some people that don't live that
- 20:26close to a farmers market, but there's generally one almost
- 20:29everywhere. So I think try to do something
- 20:32like that. I think a local pharmacy is a
- 20:35particularly good way to do that because of how insurance works,
- 20:38etcetera. Your drugs are not going to be
- 20:40more expensive there and you might even get, I mean, a really
- 20:43stupid example. I was getting a Valium for an
- 20:46MRI like a few months ago and you know, I put the RX in and
- 20:51I'm sure it was going to be like a dollar at CVS.
- 20:54But my local pharmacy was like, this is stupid.
- 20:56We're not charging you. Now it's a silly little example,
- 20:58but it is that sort of like person to person thing that
- 21:02they're maybe not nickel and diming you.
- 21:04They might have to charge a bit more, but they're not nickel and
- 21:07diming you. Or one thing that I did find is
- 21:10that many local places are willing to price match.
- 21:13Now, I, I don't sort of advocate you going in and being like, Oh
- 21:16my God, like I need toilet paper and this, you know, like you are
- 21:21charging $0.05 more than Target. Can you do that?
- 21:24But what happened to me was I needed, I needed an electric
- 21:28tooth flosser because my dentist recommended that and the local
- 21:31pharmacy was willing to order me one for the same price as
- 21:34Amazon. And I was like, sure, OK.
- 21:37I mean, I don't think did they make a lot of money on that?
- 21:39Probably not, but they were willing to do it and it made me
- 21:43feel a lot better about about buying it.
- 21:45This is a great time of the year to look at.
- 21:50You know your holiday markets that are all around you.
- 21:53You already have a shopping list for holiday gifts.
- 21:56Go meet some of the small artisans that are making goods
- 22:01and get out into your community. That's a great way to to spend
- 22:05your dollars locally. Well, this has been a lot of fun
- 22:08and put me in the mood for holiday shopping.
- 22:10As a matter of fact, want to thank our guest
- 22:11jenvargercontentmanager@checkbook.org. Thank you, Jen.
- 22:15Thank you, it was fun and you know if you're shopping for me,
- 22:17my shoe size is 9. Thank you for saving me the
- 22:20trouble of having to ask. Thank you very much.
- 22:22And Stacy Price, founder of Shop Made Brand.
- 22:24Stacy, thank you so much and continued success with your
- 22:27businesses. Thank you.
- 22:28Thanks. By the way, you can read Jen's
- 22:30article What Does It Really Take to Shop Local on checkbook.org
- 22:34and you'll find stacy@shopmadeindc.com.
- 22:38Shop made in va.com com and shop maiden md.net.
- 22:42Before we go, a couple of other consumer pedia podcasts you
- 22:45might want to check out. Number 96, checkbooks, holiday
- 22:48shopping tips. Number 95 sale prices are
- 22:51usually fake discounts, A checkbook investigation and #92
- 22:56thrift store shopping advice. And with that, we're out of
- 22:59time. We hope you'll rate this
- 23:00episode. It's really helpful.
- 23:02And follow us on Apple podcast, Spotify or wherever you listen
- 23:06to your podcasts. Remember, we release new
- 23:08episodes every other Thursday. Thursday.
- 23:10Another way you can support this show is to follow us at
- 23:13Consumerpedia on Facebook and Instagram, at consumerpedia.org
- 23:17on Blue Sky, and at my Consumerpedia on X.
- 23:21You can find me at consumerman.com.
- 23:24I'm her Weissbaum, always looking out for you.
- 23:27Until next time, be smart and shop wisely.
- 23:30Happy holidays. Consumer Pedia is a public
- 23:33service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 23:37helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 23:39You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 23:42and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 23:45unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 23:48seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 23:52Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Minneapolis, Saint Paul,
- 23:56Seattle, San Francisco and Washington DC.
- 23:59To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 24:01checkbook.org/consumer Pedia Consumer Pedia.
- 24:05Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.