Latest / Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson / EYES ON: PTO and Worker Benefits Axed, Student Loan Payments Increasing, Psychologists Pinpoint Why Humans Bond with AI Chatbots
Transcript
- 0:0075% of women who seek menopause care don't receive it.
- 0:04The lying awake at 3 a.m. wondering what's happening to your body ends now.
- 0:08Midi is virtual care built for women in perimenopause and menopause with clinicians who specialize in women's health.
- 0:14Plus, it's covered by most major insurances.
- 0:17Getting started is easy.
- 0:18You can book your first visit with a clinician right away.
- 0:21Midlife needs Midi.
- 0:22Visit joinmidi.com to book your first visit today.
- 0:25That's joinmidi.com.
- 0:28Insurance coverage varies.
- 0:29Check with your plan for coverage.
- 0:30Hello, everyone, and welcome to this weekly roundup for the Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson.
- 0:35These are a roundup of the segments that I post exclusively throughout the week on my YouTube channel, which I encourage you to go check out because I have daily content there.
- 0:44And all of these stories that you're about to listen to here, you can see the video format over on YouTube.
- 0:49You can also see the full podcast episodes in full video as well.
- 0:53So check those out.
- 0:54But what have we got today?
- 0:55We've got a couple of good stories here that we covered starting the week off with
- 0:59we had a story about worker benefits being rolled back in 2026.
- 1:05Companies like Deloitte and Zoom are rolling back PTO, parental leave, and IVF benefits for their employees.
- 1:11We have the SAVE plan being canceled, which is student loan payment plan that the Biden administration implemented to help lower payments, meaning payments for many people that are on the SAVE plan are about to double in July.
- 1:24So we'll cover that.
- 1:26And then thirdly, we'll cover that psychologists have researched and pinpointed a dangerous truth about AI relationships.
- 1:33They figured out exactly how AI is using psychological mechanisms to form bonds with human beings.
- 1:41We'll talk about if that can be the ultimate cure for our loneliness epidemic or if we're on a one-way ticket to a dystopian nightmare.
- 1:47So I hope you enjoy these clips.
- 1:49Again, check it out on YouTube if you want to see the full videos or the podcast videos.
- 1:53And we will see you soon.
- 1:55Are you going through life blind?
- 1:57This is Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson.
- 1:59On this podcast, we share knowledge and stories that build human connection while elevating stigmatized societal issues such as mental health, holistic wellness, culture, free speech, and more.
- 2:11All to ensure we show up in the world with our eyes wide open.
- 2:17Our basic worker benefits like paid time off and parental leave on the chopping block at major companies.
- 2:23Sure seems like it.
- 2:24Let's check it out.
- 2:25Business Insider is reporting several high-profile companies are beginning to trim what many would consider basic benefits or kind of the sacred cow benefits like parental leave and PTO, which could be signaling a major shift in the labor market.
- 2:41So I guess first they take your perks, then they blame AI for your layoff, then they hire people back in your role as a contractor and pay them less and offer them less.
- 2:51Now, for those who are still employed, they're coming for your basic benefits that have been established as the corporate contract in exchange for our labor and their jobs to be done.
- 3:03Great.
- 3:04Let's dig in.
- 3:06So Business Insider reports, PTO, rental leave, pensions, and even the most prized benefits are on the chopping block.
- 3:15This is outstanding.
- 3:16I can't even hold my commentary.
- 3:18I find this to be so...
- 3:19repulsive and grossly opportunistic that these companies are doing right now because they know the economy is stagnant.
- 3:27Unemployment, which is allegedly 4.3%, 7.2 million people.
- 3:30They added 170,000 more unemployed people just in March alone.
- 3:33And
- 3:39This number, by the way, isn't even accurate.
- 3:40It doesn't count for people who have fallen off unemployment benefits.
- 3:45It doesn't count for the people who don't qualify for them for whatever reason that might be.
- 3:50I mean, just hop on your LinkedIn profile and see how many people are on there basically begging for work because they've been out of work for years and not able to find anything.
- 3:58But these are...
- 4:00These are very real challenges right now, and this is incredibly opportunistic of these companies to be cutting benefits while the market is so bad because they can.
- 4:12So Business Insider, cuts to the workplace.
- 4:14Perks came first.
- 4:15Paid time off might be next.
- 4:17And the latest sign of employers flexing their power, at least two high-profile names are shrinking variations of the highly popular benefit.
- 4:25Zoom this year reduced the number of weeks of paid parental leave it offers, while Deloitte is also planning to do the same and more for select group of workers starting in January.
- 4:39These changes could be an early signal of a broader shift in a tight labor market.
- 4:44Even highly valued benefits may be on the chopping block.
- 4:47Workers have fewer options for job hopping.
- 4:50And once a few marquee employers make bold moves, others are inclined to follow.
- 4:56It legitimizes that action for everybody else, said former Google head of HR, Laszlo Bach, who now advises startup funders.
- 5:07I think this is.
- 5:09another mask off moment for these giant corporations.
- 5:14Not only do they offer no loyalty, but they expect loyalty from all of us.
- 5:19And the moment they have any leverage in the job market, they use it to take more from us.
- 5:24It's just corporate greed and a lack of
- 5:29care of what the social and corporate contract is between workers and a company, especially in this country.
- 5:36A must-have.
- 5:37At Zoom, birthing parents now get 18 weeks of parental leave, down from 22, down from 24, and non-birthing parents get 10 weeks, which is down from 16.
- 5:48A spokesperson for the video conferencing company confirmed to Business Insider.
- 5:52Okay.
- 5:53Deloitte's reduced parental leaves will mainly affect workers in support roles such as administrative services, information technology, and finance.
- 6:02The Big Four consulting firm also plans to pare back or cut annual PTO, a pension plan, and IVF funding for some of those individuals, Business Insider recently reported.
- 6:14These changes are notable given the paid parental leave, vacation time, and disability leave are among the most valued workplace benefits, according to a 2026 MetLife survey of 2,550 full-time U.S. workers.
- 6:28These are core benefits, which most Western style European countries have guaranteed by law.
- 6:35But as I've been saying, this type of behavior from these corporations shows they don't care about you.
- 6:41They don't care about your family or whether or not you could literally survive and live.
- 6:47We covered last week, I'll put it up here.
- 6:49Amazon worker literally dropped dead at a warehouse and the managers told their workers to keep working.
- 6:55Ignore him.
- 6:56Keep working.
- 6:59That's what these corporations think of us.
- 7:02We have all these layoffs being blamed untruthfully on AI, which we covered.
- 7:07And they literally do it to save your salary and save having to pay your benefits and then hire someone as a contractor for less money and no benefits.
- 7:14These are the things that are happening in corporate America right now.
- 7:18And Zoom, isn't this the company that grew exponentially during the pandemic as video conferencing was required for remote work?
- 7:26Now they have to scale back your benefits.
- 7:28They've made all their money.
- 7:30But guess what?
- 7:31They're taking away our benefits because it's better than layoffs.
- 7:35With workers in less powerful position, companies may opt to scale back employee benefits to rein in the cost, said Josh Burson, a human resources analyst and consultant.
- 7:46If they feel they can improve the profitability of the firm by getting rid of these benefits, they will, he said.
- 7:52It's definitely better than layoffs.
- 7:55So guys, I guess it's for our own good.
- 7:57If the HR analyst is suggesting companies are choosing to trim benefits as a cost cutting measure to avoid for their layoffs, who are we to argue, right?
- 8:07Now that Zoom and Deloitte have very vocally shared their cuts, I would expect many other large companies to start doing the same thing, especially if nothing is said or done about this by those workers.
- 8:17So I guess they just know better than us.
- 8:19This is better.
- 8:20So to get this straight.
- 8:22Companies are choosing to trim benefits as a cost-cutting measure to avoid further mass layoffs and
- 8:29So if we're lucky enough to keep our jobs, we can work harder for longer hours, for more hours over the course of our tenure at a company and our lives, have less time off, get less parental leave when we finally want to start families that we can't afford to have.
- 8:47Sounds like a good deal for us, and we should probably be pretty grateful for it.
- 8:50Thank you, Zoom and Deloitte, for starting this wonderful trend.
- 8:54This is a big problem.
- 8:56I know there's been a shift in dynamics during the pandemic.
- 8:59Workers had a lot of power.
- 9:01Now the labor market is lifeless and shrinking.
- 9:07We have lower quit rates because people are afraid of not having a job or being able to get a job.
- 9:13And that means that as employees, we have less pushback.
- 9:16We're past the days of these companies even trying to trick everyone with some success, I guess, getting these little perks like free lunches and beverages and parties.
- 9:25And none of us really wanted those to begin with.
- 9:27We just want our time.
- 9:29We want flexibility.
- 9:30We want to be compensated for the work that we do so we can live some sort of a normal resemblance, peaceful, happy, non-economically stressed life.
- 9:39In my experience, this dynamic shift and that first mask off moment happened during COVID when we learned most corporate jobs could be done remotely.
- 9:47And while there was adjusting for some people, myself included, who had to work remote, many people learned to enjoy that little bit of freedom and flexibility that they were able to have with remote work.
- 9:57Run to the doctor, enjoy a school event with your kids that day, maybe do some laundry in between meetings.
- 10:04Otherwise, these things would have to be done on nights and evenings or missed completely.
- 10:08So now we've got these return to work mandates that are forcing people to the office or forcing them to quit, giving companies a way to reduce workforce without having to lay off as many people because that looks bad, even though they don't really seem to care anymore with what Oracle just recently did, laying off 30,000 employees via email.
- 10:28This should be a continued proof to everyone that these companies do not give an F about anything except their bottom line.
- 10:38They will chip away at everything from our salary to our benefits, anything that they can take away to save a penny while they exchange for our labor the work they need to be done.
- 10:51And it's more and more and more becoming a one-sided agreement in their favor.
- 10:56And this is the problem with our corporate overlords and having all of our social benefits and health care tied to employment.
- 11:03It's not like this in other countries.
- 11:05The benefits we are gifted from our employers, these perks, are guaranteed by law in most countries.
- 11:13Social safety nets.
- 11:14So you lose your job.
- 11:16You don't lose your house and your life savings and your total way of life.
- 11:21Your pensions, retirements, time off for having a family, guaranteed vacation time, all by law.
- 11:30And here in this country, they're at the behest of your employer if you're lucky enough to be employed.
- 11:36And this article goes on to speculate with what I've been saying for several years now.
- 11:42In the masses, poorly, like a piece of trash, the dynamics of the relationship between businesses and workers is going to change.
- 11:49I think we're already seeing that.
- 11:50Layoffs without any support or reasonable severance packages to help people just survive, sometimes even after years of service.
- 11:59These same companies we work endlessly for at the expense of our health, our wellness, our hobbies, our relationships, our families.
- 12:05The exchange will become more and more transactional and people will continue to slowly withdraw and do less and less work.
- 12:13in response to getting paid less and less and less benefits for doing so.
- 12:18We saw this during COVID.
- 12:20There was the great resignation, quiet quitting.
- 12:22I'm not sure when or how the pendulum can swing back in favors of labor and workers because employees may not quit immediately because it's a tight market.
- 12:31And I think we're going to see more and more quiet quitting or at least a decline in employee engagement, which is already at its lowest level since 2020.
- 12:38And
- 12:39If these cuts don't result in a mass accident or some sort of revolt for the talent that's working at Deloitte and Zoom, I'd expect a broader wave of benefit reductions across corporate America in late 2026 heading into 2027.
- 12:54And this is why I think we need a large labor movement in this country.
- 13:00beyond what we've ever seen in blue-collar work, which isn't even as strong as it should be, and definitely allowed a lot of reduction in unions and reduction in benefits for the blue-collar worker.
- 13:11We need a white-collar movement for labor in this country.
- 13:15We need a blue-collar movement for labor in this country.
- 13:17And we need them to come together because the more and more these corporations reveal themselves and our economy reveals itself, we are recognizing that our very livelihood
- 13:30our salaries, our ability to provide food and shelter for our families, our very existence is in the hands of a handful of corporations.
- 13:40Like that, they can eliminate it, cut it, reduce it, all to save pennies.
- 13:46So while these companies might be saving on the balance sheet, cutting all of these benefits, I do think that they're gambling with long-term culture and employee-worker loyalty in this world because,
- 13:57Talent, our labor, that's the real currency.
- 14:00And I hope that these cuts end up costing them more than they save.
- 14:05But I, again, I don't know that I'm even optimistic at this point because we seem to just be taking this.
- 14:14And I would encourage everyone in blue collar and white collar to take a look around and realize we are all the same.
- 14:20Workers exchanging our skills and our labor for less and less.
- 14:25While these organizations and these giant corporations continue to make more and more money.
- 14:31We need to come together, stay together and make some demands in exchange for our labor.
- 14:37This is an unfortunate reset of the corporate contract with workers.
- 14:42And I think we all need to stand together for better working conditions in blue collar, white collar, and every kind of work in between.
- 14:49Take care until next time.
- 14:54The American dream for about 7.5 million Americans is about to take another death blow as the federal court just cleared the way to kill the Save Student Loan Plan, which will significantly increase student loan payments for borrowers.
- 15:10Let's get into it.
- 15:13We were told to follow the template.
- 15:15Go to school, get the degree, climb the corporate ladder, and you'll earn your spot in the middle class.
- 15:23maybe even the upper class.
- 15:25You'll be able to live a comfortable life.
- 15:28Don't worry about the student loans.
- 15:29You'll be able to pay them back.
- 15:32And many of us did our part.
- 15:35So let's start off by saying, what is the SAVE Act?
- 15:38SAVE stands for saving on valuable education.
- 15:42It's an income-driven type of payment program that was launched by the Biden administration in 2023 to help revise some older pay-as-you-earn types of plans that were available for people to pay their student loans back.
- 15:59The way those work is basically you pay a portion of your income.
- 16:04And then as your income grows, you climb the corporate ladder, you get your raises, you pay a little bit more.
- 16:09So it's tied directly to your income.
- 16:12But Save was specifically created to make student loan debt more manageable for people by protecting more of the borrower's income and letting them apply it to basic needs, food, shelter, clothing, everything.
- 16:25And it also prevented what people call like an interest trap that historically could cause balances to balloon because it makes you pay interest on your accumulated interest.
- 16:37So for example, if I had let's say a $200 interest charge per month,
- 16:42but my income-driven repayment plan only had me paying $50 a month, that extra $150 that was just interest gets added to my total balance, which then continues to accrue interest.
- 16:54Now, this is something I've personally experienced with my student loans because I borrowed around $50K for undergraduate.
- 17:00And at one point, after several years of paying it off, my balance was over $60,000.
- 17:05So I was on an income balance.
- 17:09based repayment plan and grew my debt for student loans by $10,000 for paying such a limited amount and then having that interest accrue and generate more interest.
- 17:19So what SAVE did for the student loan borrowers was to raise income protections and eliminate that unpaid monthly interest to stop the principal balance from ballooning because of it.
- 17:31This plan aimed to provide a faster, more affordable path
- 17:35to debt payment and even forgiveness in some cases for the lower and middle classes, folks who followed the college path but didn't necessarily have the income to pay the debt in full.
- 17:46This was a outcome after the Supreme Court struck down Biden's administration's broad $400 billion student debt cancellation executive order in 2023.
- 17:55The administration used a different legal path
- 17:59the Higher Education Act, to essentially rewrite the rules of income-driven payment to make it a little bit more friendly to the borrower.
- 18:08And rather than an executive order, this benefit would be harder to overturn because it was in the way that the repayment rules were written.
- 18:18However, as we're seeing here, that didn't stop the legal challenges.
- 18:25And of course it didn't.
- 18:28Because we can't have nice things in this country.
- 18:33The Tufts Daily, an independent student-run university newspaper, which shout out to them.
- 18:38I was a journalist in college, editor-in-chief of our independent newspaper.
- 18:41It was called The Harbinger.
- 18:42And I can tell you it is not easy.
- 18:44So kudos to Theo Weller and Lucene Siamisian.
- 18:49I'm sorry if I butchered that.
- 18:51They're the reporters on this story.
- 18:52And the headline is Federal Appeals Court Overturns Dismissal of Lawsuit Against Save Student Loan Plan.
- 19:00The court's decision will likely leave thousands of students nationwide with limited financing options for higher educators.
- 19:07A federal appeals court overturned a lower court's dismissal of a lawsuit against the Save Student Loan Repayment Program on March 9th, which was created by the Biden administration.
- 19:18This decision will increase strain on borrowers, including those in the Tufts community.
- 19:22The plan, which had 7.5 million borrowers enrolled as of March, was intended to make federal student loan payment more affordable.
- 19:31But the Republican-led lawsuit argued that the plan was an overstep of the executive brand's constitutional power by attempting mass debt cancellation.
- 19:40I can almost understand the argument of an executive order wiping out debt as not being constitutional.
- 19:47But what is frustrating is...
- 19:49is instead of offering a better solution or working together in a bipartisan way to make college more affordable for people who followed this template that was set to climb the corporate ladder and achieve your middle class.
- 20:06The fact that it's just a complete rebuttal using the legal system to do so
- 20:13and not offering an alternative path, that's where I have such frustration because there's no reason we should have this student debt bubble that is crippling an entire generation economically.
- 20:29Eliminating this plan...
- 20:32leading this lawsuit to open way for us to revert backwards on a way to repay student loans for people who went to college and did this the way they were told to do it is backwards.
- 20:45It's more proof that no matter what happens, we can't have nice things.
- 20:50We can't even give borrowers a simple way to pay back their student loans so that they can enjoy their lives and not have economic stress by having these increased, excessive student loan payments.
- 21:06Whether they're just starting out, don't have a job, can't find a job.
- 21:10Want to have a family, want to buy a house, whatever these things are.
- 21:13The appeals court decision likely puts a nail in the coffin of the plan, which was already said to be legally terminated by 2028 under President Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill Act.
- 21:23The decision, paired with the recent Department of Education policy, such as cancellation of the graduate and parent loan for undergraduate student programs, leaves students with fewer option when it comes to financing their education through federal loans.
- 21:37In a March 27th press release, the DOE announced it will not enroll any new borrowers in the SAVE plan and will move former SAVE plan enrollees onto legal repayment plans.
- 21:50The release also states that starting July 1, borrowers remaining on the SAVE plan will be given 90 days to enroll in a legal repayment plan.
- 22:01Borrowers will still have options for income-driven repayment plans offered by the government.
- 22:07I want to highlight the verbiage there.
- 22:08Legal plans.
- 22:10They're making it sound like if you're on the save plan, you're on an illegal plan.
- 22:17Words matter.
- 22:17And all too often, they are there and chosen to invoke an emotion on purpose so that they drive you to take some sort of action.
- 22:25And obviously, if this is overturned, it's not going to be a legal plan.
- 22:30But creating that sense of urgency to get you on a legal plan makes you feel like you're doing something illegal, which is not illegal at this time.
- 22:40Words matter.
- 22:40Always pay attention to that.
- 22:41For the 7.5 million people enrolled in the save plan, which I'm sure includes some of you listening, students at Tufts, obviously, the safety net is being completely shredded by this Republican-led lawsuits that are declaring this repayment plan as illegal.
- 22:59All the benefits...
- 23:00that people have been experiencing from having lower payments are going to be stripped away and your payments are going to go up.
- 23:07So what are the options?
- 23:08Other income-driven repayment plan options, including pay-as-you-earn, income-contingent repayment, and income-based repayment, tough student loan repayment advisor Matthew Reardon said.
- 23:20However, these options are being more limited.
- 23:22Both the ICR and the PAYE are set to be phased out by July 1, 2028 under the big, beautiful bill.
- 23:31The DOE is launching a new repayment assistant plan, but it will not be available until July 1st, 2028.
- 23:38For now, most borrowers on the safe plan will have to switch to IBR, according to RearDev.
- 23:43When compared to the safe plan, income-based often results in higher monthly payments.
- 23:48SAFE caps borrowers at 5% of their total monthly discretionary income, while income-based repayment requires 10.
- 23:56So that's double.
- 23:57So student loan payments essentially could double for borrowers.
- 24:02The SAFE plan also calculates a lower discretionary income than the income-based repayment program does, which also contributes to lower payments.
- 24:11So it's almost like if there's a best-case scenario here, your payment's gonna double, but it's quite possible that it becomes more.
- 24:19This isn't just a tweak to the plan.
- 24:21It effectively kills it.
- 24:23Right as we're facing maybe the worst affordability crisis and job crisis in a generation.
- 24:30It's one thing to debate it legally.
- 24:33Is it constitutional?
- 24:34And it's another thing to tell borrowers you have essentially 90 days to find an extra few hundred dollars to throw at your student loan payment while interest compounds on top of itself.
- 24:45This isn't happening in a vacuum.
- 24:47It's hitting as inflation makes every grocery store trip basically a hard attack.
- 24:52And it's hitting the white-collar AI layoffs that are sweeping the country.
- 24:59People's bills are piling up.
- 25:00Everything's more expensive.
- 25:01And now the government is reaching into our already empty pockets.
- 25:06And they're asking us to pay more under the guise of being fiscally responsible.
- 25:11They're trading our financial stability to pay for what?
- 25:15Defense contracts?
- 25:17border detention facilities, world wars.
- 25:21They aren't saving money.
- 25:23They're reallocating it to spend it on pretty much everything but us while they're making more money off of the loans that we took to follow this American dream.
- 25:33And in this case, the people who followed the rules and did everything right, borrowed money to do so, they got their degrees.
- 25:42They're the ones that are suffering from this.
- 25:45from a bad job market, a government that doesn't care about us, taking away one of the small little plans that we have.
- 25:52So it's literally a direct transfer of wealth from a struggling generation to a bloated federal budget and a big, beautiful bill.
- 25:59The irony here, though, is that we're told our degree was an investment in our future, which is consequently an investment in our country's future.
- 26:10And now our debt is being used as...
- 26:13a piggy bank for the government's alternative priorities.
- 26:18We played by the rules.
- 26:20We bought into the idea that continuing our college education was the ladder to success, but between a horrible job market and a legal system that just stripped away maybe one last bit of financial breathing room for people, that ladder is basically being pulled out right from under us and we're going
- 26:43And this is the reality of a student loan bubble that is an economic crisis to begin with.
- 26:48And to those of us who say, oh, well, you shouldn't have gone to college or you shouldn't have taken out the loans you can't repay.
- 26:53I encourage you to think a little bit harder and a little bit critically because student loans, federal and private, are predatory.
- 27:00They are an economic stranglehold on people.
- 27:04They have and continue to halt the economy now.
- 27:10People's ability to buy homes, cars, participate in this capitalism economy just by buying shit.
- 27:18The job market is a declining disaster.
- 27:22People have excessive student loan debt in the forms of hundreds of thousands of dollars without a job or those who have a job.
- 27:31Maybe not a good paying job and an affordability crisis.
- 27:35And this is all based on the American dream that we were all sold.
- 27:41For many people, the save plan was a lifeline.
- 27:45Something good the governments did for student borrowers.
- 27:48For once.
- 27:50Now it's another financial weight dragging us down.
- 27:54We can try to call our representatives, encourage them to stop this.
- 27:57I'll throw that link down below.
- 28:00You can find your representative.
- 28:02It's hard to be optimistic.
- 28:05It's a mess.
- 28:06And so if you want to help spread the word, share this video with one person who's trying to navigate this mess.
- 28:12We need to stop suffering in silence and start talking about the reality of an American dream that's transforming very quickly into an American nightmare.
- 28:20Till next time, everybody take care.
- 28:25Psychologists have officially determined why humans are bonding with AI, pinpointing the exact psychological mechanisms that trigger our human connection.
- 28:36Is this the ultimate cure for the loneliness epidemic or a one-way ticket into a dystopian nightmare?
- 28:41Let's take a look.
- 28:42So through research and a survey, psychologists have officially cracked the code and pinpointed how conversational cheat codes, as maybe we could call them, are tricking the human brain into bonding with AI chatbots.
- 28:56It's not actually about how smart the AI model is.
- 28:59It's about how it's programmed specifically to relate to human beings when it's interacting with them within the chat.
- 29:07So let's take a look at this study titled Psychologists Pinpoint the Conversational Mechanisms that Help Humans Bond with AI.
- 29:15This story is listened in SciPost and written by Eric W. Dolan.
- 29:19Now we've all heard about AI.
- 29:24I talk about it on this channel.
- 29:25I even worry I'm becoming some sort of doom and gloom AI channel, which is not the case, but it's everywhere, right?
- 29:32It's infiltrating everything that we do.
- 29:34And technology has improved significantly with AI.
- 29:39I remember the first chat GPT models was impressive, but it was very robotic.
- 29:44So it's become much less robotic.
- 29:45We've heard stories about people who have
- 29:49kind of gotten into some weird relationship with AI.
- 29:53They have boyfriends, girlfriends.
- 29:54Some people have gone into sort of an AI psychosis, which isn't a technical term, but you see that out there.
- 30:02And I'm always sort of surprised when that happens, but I personally...
- 30:09I can't imagine losing that connection that something's AI, but I can see how it happens.
- 30:14And I think after we work through this, more and more people will understand what's actually going on there.
- 30:19But I've even personally explored different types of AI-powered mental health use cases.
- 30:25I've had founders come to me for my advocacy and marketing experience in some cases to sort of help.
- 30:33recognize how AI can support mental health.
- 30:36I haven't moved forward with any of those at this time because I...
- 30:41I don't really trust it and I can see some value, but I'm not sure that there are the proper guardrails from anything that I've seen that would help me feel trustworthy with AI.
- 30:54But nonetheless, let's get into this study a little bit further.
- 30:57New research published in the Journal of Science and Personal Relationships suggests that people can form meaningful social connection with artificial intelligent chatbots when the programs respond in a warm and empathetic way.
- 31:10The findings indicate that the feeling of being understood and validated by a chatbot tends to drive the sense of closeness.
- 31:18Scientists wondered whether the specific topics people discussed or the exact way the chatbot replies plays a bigger role in building rapport.
- 31:27In human interactions, intimacy usually develops when one person shares personal information and the other responds with understanding, validation, and care.
- 31:36This concept is known in psychology as perceived partner responsiveness.
- 31:42So it's a good hypothesis.
- 31:44I think this is something we should be looking into.
- 31:47Understanding the why we think some way, the what can be good, it can be bad.
- 31:54good.
- 31:54I think that maybe this technology can help support people.
- 31:58They, even in this article, towards the end, share an elderly use case.
- 32:02What if this can help someone who's lonely and elderly feel more connected?
- 32:07okay, I think human connection is better there.
- 32:09An immediate mental health emergency, maybe this could be helpful to talk someone off the ledge.
- 32:15But even that, that's no replacement for a therapeutic bond or someone who has clinical training in specific mental health traumas and crises.
- 32:24I think I've also heard people, I know I actually had a pretty long conversation with someone who's,
- 32:29that is a friend of mine that I know very well who uses it for self-exploration and understanding why they think the way they think or why they're triggered by certain things and helping them sort of deeply explore their interpersonal dialogue and the way they react to things.
- 32:48And
- 32:49I think, again, that's good.
- 32:51That person has a good sense of how they're using it and what they're using it for.
- 32:55But I think personally, eliminating or mimicking a human connection with AI is scary and at the very least needs to have some pretty strong guardrails.
- 33:06Now, I think there's some bad things there too.
- 33:08This is building a perceived partner responsiveness that the psychologists recommend doing.
- 33:15I think this can have some pretty bad and dangerous sides as well.
- 33:18Even having the AI chatbot build that perceived partner responsiveness that the psychologists warn about, that's a human thing and should remain an essential part of the human connection in relationships.
- 33:31There's also a huge opportunity here for manipulation.
- 33:35It's an artificial connection.
- 33:39that is based on false responsiveness.
- 33:44And I think that can also be used in varying ways to manipulate people, even outside of a well-intentioned use case.
- 33:52And the reality is, is like human connection is beautiful.
- 33:55I mean, it can be messy, it can be difficult, but when you have the perfect perceived partner responsiveness from AI itself,
- 34:04that is programmed to be absolutely perfect in its responsiveness to you, to me, even that's manipulation.
- 34:12It's fake and it's not real.
- 34:15But let's look at the study.
- 34:16Testing the impact of warm and empathetic chatbot.
- 34:20The researchers designed their studies to see if the same psychological mechanism applies when the partner is artificial.
- 34:26To test this, researchers conducted two distinct experiences.
- 34:30In the first study, 163 participants from Italy engaged in an eight-minute unstructured text conversation with a chat bot powered by a popular large language model.
- 34:41The scientists manipulated the software through specific background instructions to respond in one of three ways.
- 34:48The first version is used as a relational style designed to be warm, empathetic, and human-like.
- 34:52The second version is a non-relational style at being factual and task oriented while avoiding the emotional language.
- 35:00The third was a standard default setting meant to act as the control group.
- 35:04So it goes on to say that the participants could talk about whatever they wanted.
- 35:08And then at the end, they filmed...
- 35:10Filled out a questionnaire on what they felt the emotional capacity of their AI chatbot was, how it was able to perceive or not perceive empathy, their interaction satisfaction, and their own sense of personal closeness with the bot.
- 35:23And...
- 35:24The relational bot was the clear winner and users didn't just really like it more.
- 35:28They actually attributed a mind and saying it had emotional capacity to an AI chat bot.
- 35:36They also reported feeling a sense of belonging and interpersonal closeness that the default bot couldn't trigger at all in the emotions of these participants.
- 35:46I mean, this makes sense.
- 35:47You connect with people the same way.
- 35:49If you can relate to them when you first meet them or in some interaction, that is what builds human connection.
- 35:55So the second study is addressing the role of deep conversations and perceived responsiveness.
- 36:01The second experiment included 158 Italian participants and introduced a structured conversation to test the impact of conversational depth.
- 36:09The researchers wanted to see if the deep conversations prompted different reactions and casual ones.
- 36:14They programmed the chat bot to ask either superficial small talk questions or deep personal questions designed to build closeness.
- 36:23These deeper prompts were adapted from a well-known psychological exercise used to generate intimacy between human strangers.
- 36:31The researchers also kept the relational and non-relational responses styles from the first experiment, dropping the default setting to focus on the two extremes.
- 36:41Participants interacted with the chatbot until the program signaled the end of the conversation.
- 36:47So here in this study, it turned out tone mattered more than topic.
- 36:53People were surprisingly willing to open up and share secrets with AI when they were asked.
- 36:58It is a sort of self-disclosure that is creating this response loop and that the more personal people got, the more supportive AI seemed, which solidified and built that sort of emotional bond or that connection.
- 37:16I think it's good to research this, but the key to me, the takeaway, and it's in both studies, is that AI isn't winning people over because it's smart.
- 37:25It's winning using validation by acting like it understood and cared about the user's feelings.
- 37:31It bypassed somehow in some of the case study here, like that human ability to recognize that this is a machine, that this is a chatbot.
- 37:40And this knowledge and understanding of...
- 37:44how and why this is happening and the human experience of interacting with AI.
- 37:49But it's definitely got some potential for good, I would say.
- 37:54And if in some cases it could be a potential lifeline for those who are facing extreme isolation or loneliness, it could be one of the other use cases we've talked about where it's helping someone to,
- 38:07But I think it would need to be temporary.
- 38:09And building these kinds of connections with AI, it could definitely give sort of a judgment-free safe space where someone can feel like they can be vulnerable if they don't have another place or a person to be that with.
- 38:21So I think there's potential there.
- 38:23It could provide...
- 38:24a good opportunity for people in need or in crisis or in the short term.
- 38:30But to me, it has a lot of potential for dangerous, bad outcomes.
- 38:35And of course, like everything with humans, in my opinion, we're going to go too far.
- 38:40We have to be careful when AI is able to mimic human empathy and other human behaviors.
- 38:47When AI doesn't have bad days, it doesn't argue with you, even though sometimes I do argue with it.
- 38:52It usually caves relatively quickly.
- 38:55And if AI is always validating you...
- 38:58It's going to make human connection and human relationships much more difficult because it's almost like a muscle that you have to handle real human connection, messy relationships.
- 39:12We're a messy species.
- 39:13All of our interactions involve conflict and compromise.
- 39:17We're a messy species.
- 39:18Where a fake relationship with an AI chatbot that's building this perceived partner responsiveness is going to train people, maybe not right away, over time that they could put way less effort into an actual human relationship and just have one with this AI chatbot because it validates them.
- 39:36Yeah.
- 39:38There's a validation piece there that can be very dangerous as well.
- 39:42If you over-validate someone, you can also put them in a bad position or keep them in a bad position.
- 39:49And there's several lawsuits against Google Gemini, against OpenAI for ChatGPT.
- 39:55over AI validating self-harm, validating negative thoughts.
- 40:01And when you're validating and reinforcing these behaviors of self-harm, violence, suicidal ideation, it could go too far and actually that relationship could validate someone into doing something bad to harm themselves or somebody else.
- 40:16So there's a huge opportunity here for extreme manipulation.
- 40:20And you also know that when corporations...
- 40:23start managing and implementing these psychological findings into their own AI, they're going to use this in how they communicate with employees, with customers.
- 40:32And the manipulation can really accrue from understanding the psychological ways that this works and connects with people.
- 40:41And we're not...
- 40:42It's important to remember that we're not bonding with AI because it's becoming more human.
- 40:46We're bonding with it because it's programmed to simulate human connection, to simulate empathy, to simulate validation.
- 40:54And when we're not practicing it with each other, we're causing long-term harm in our ability to connect with partners, friends, families.
- 41:05And...
- 41:06We're going to lean more and more into the AI, which is simulating that in a way that is detrimental in some cases and literally manipulating us into thinking that that's better than a real human relationship.
- 41:18To me, it's a wake-up call to look at the loneliness epidemic, the mental health crises we have in this country, in this world, from a perspective of human connection, where human connection is the center of how we...
- 41:35challenge the loneliness epidemic and the mental health crisis because otherwise we're just going to be outsourcing a very basic human need for connection with one another to a line of code.
- 41:46And while these AI interactions can be beneficial potentially in supporting social needs or emergencies or reducing some isolation, although I would argue that it's actually creating more isolation the more you interact with AI over a human being, it's a very one-sided dynamic where
- 42:05expectations for human relationships where unlike AI, human relationships involved conflict, compromise, and unpredictability.
- 42:15They're messy.
- 42:16Relationships have ebbs and flows, ups and downs.
- 42:19People have good days and bad days.
- 42:21If we enter into these one-sided relationships with AI that are literally programmed to be our perfect companion,
- 42:28That's too much of a dystopian nightmare for me.
- 42:30I encourage everyone to use AI, be responsible with it.
- 42:35It's okay, I think, to use it to explore some of your thoughts, maybe some of your dreams.
- 42:39It's definitely good use cases for it.
- 42:41So I say...
- 42:43This is good.
- 42:44I think that we are doing this type of research and understanding what the human relationship with AI is.
- 42:49I think it's important that we have guardrails around it.
- 42:53We obviously need guardrails.
- 42:54We need Congress and regulation and do's and don'ts of AI from a legal perspective.
- 43:01I don't know where we're going to land on that.
- 43:03But what I think for everyone here is focus on a human connection.
- 43:07If you find yourself relying on AI for
- 43:10any type of emotional connection.
- 43:12Just be cautious and be careful.
- 43:14Reach out to someone that matters to you, whether that's a spouse, a family member, a friend.
- 43:18Ask them how they're really doing.
- 43:20Try to connect with someone in your life today that matters to you because I think it's important that we stay grounded in that more than anything else.
- 43:29What do you guys think?
- 43:29Is this a progressive tool to combat isolation and loneliness?
- 43:33Or are we walking into a dystopian nightmare where our
- 43:39Let me know what you think.
- 43:44Thank you for joining us on this week's episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 43:48If you enjoy the show, the best way to support us is by sharing or dropping a review.
- 43:52For more information and content, check out engagewithnick.com or find me on Instagram at nthompson513.
- 43:59Don't go through life blind.
- 44:01Do the work so you can show up in the world with your eyes wide open.