Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 159: Why France's Future Must Be Human-Centered with Rahaf Harfoush
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Wendy Shenuda. Last week I spent more than an
- 0:14hour on the phone with the person I tend to turn to when
- 0:17the world feels insane, and my feelings equally so.
- 0:21Rehoff Harfouche, both a dear friend and friend of the show,
- 0:24is a digital anthropologist whose research and writing on
- 0:27technology and digital culture have been instrumental in my own
- 0:30understanding of big picture ideas and how technology in
- 0:34particular plays into the paradigm shift the world is
- 0:37experiencing. We talked about hyper
- 0:39normalization, which she has described as feeling the
- 0:42disconnect between everything being broken or in a state of
- 0:45collapse, and yet also oddly normal institutions and people
- 0:50in power go on pretending as if everything is going to go on the
- 0:53way it always has. We talked about having no
- 0:56emotional preparedness for the shifts that are taking place,
- 0:59nor the ability to grieve what we're potentially losing.
- 1:03And we also spoke about how global interconnection means
- 1:06that we cannot speak about the future of France, where we both
- 1:09live, without considering the impact that decisions made much
- 1:12further afield by other nations will have on that path.
- 1:17I asked her back on the show to talk about the specific
- 1:19crossroads and how we can understand what it might mean
- 1:22for France particularly, but not at all limited to its own
- 1:26development in technology and innovation.
- 1:29Ultimately, as you'll hear, the conversation begins with her own
- 1:33anecdote of adaptability, and then we go on to discuss the
- 1:36resilience of societies, the impact of geopolitical shifts
- 1:40and innovation in France amidst global disruptions.
- 1:44We tackle systemic change and how cultural values shape our
- 1:48response to crises and technological evolution.
- 1:51But also we talk about the opportunity that France has now
- 1:55to shape its future. I hope you enjoy the
- 1:58conversation, Raha. If you were thinking about you
- 2:02think about your family in Syria a lot.
- 2:05One of the things that I have been thinking about is really
- 2:09challenging the concept that collapses final.
- 2:14It's not really final because what I'm learning from looking
- 2:17at my family in Syria is how quickly and, and how much we can
- 2:20adapt. And, you know, my family has
- 2:23been in Syria for a long time. And even during the last regime,
- 2:28there were electricity shortages.
- 2:30You know, Syria's under a lot of sanctions.
- 2:32It was hard to get things. So food was expensive.
- 2:35But I just remember my aunt telling me about her day and she
- 2:40had this very particular schedule because they roll
- 2:43electricity in different neighborhoods so that different
- 2:46neighborhoods have electricity at different times.
- 2:48And I think when she told me the story, she was getting about 3
- 2:51hours of electricity a day and one of those hours was between
- 2:563:00 AM and 4:00 AM. So she was waking up at 3:00 AM
- 3:00and 4:00 AM, which just became normal, right?
- 3:02This just became what you do in order for her to plug things in
- 3:08that needed charging, etcetera. And we went to Dubai on a family
- 3:14trip to celebrate my dad's birthday.
- 3:17And I remember seeing her walk into the kitchen and not turn on
- 3:21the light. And I was like, what are you
- 3:24doing? And I'll never forget.
- 3:26She was just like, Oh, my God, I totally forgot to turn on the
- 3:29light because they just got used to moving through the house
- 3:33without electricity. They just got used to waking up
- 3:35at 3:00 AM. They just got used to.
- 3:37And so I think in a way, our adaptability is part of the
- 3:41challenge that we face because we'll just say, oh, I guess
- 3:45travel's not accessible now. Oh, I guess we can't afford a
- 3:48car because gas isn't affordable.
- 3:50Oh, I guess we have to buy less because food is more expensive.
- 3:53Oh, I guess there's just shortages.
- 3:55Do you remember during the pandemic where there was like,
- 3:57no mustard for a couple of months?
- 3:59And it's like, it's just going to be things like that.
- 4:02And that was the Ukraine war. Actually, yes, it was the
- 4:05Ukraine war and Canada and. Canadian climate issues that
- 4:10hurt the mustard seeds, Yeah. So that's what I think it's
- 4:13going to be. I think it's going to be this,
- 4:15these unpredictable disruptions, slowly at 1st and then more and
- 4:19more where we might spend some weeks where, you know, people
- 4:23are on their bikes because gas is like, I just, I just think
- 4:26it's going to be really unpredictable and we're just
- 4:28going to get used to rolling with it.
- 4:32The question is, and how we got to this topic is, you know, we
- 4:37were meant to begin by talking about France and innovation and,
- 4:41and startup culture and what the future looks like, which is
- 4:45perhaps not so rosy. And then we are sitting here on
- 4:50April 7th with the looming threat of something happening
- 4:53because of one loon publishing his dire wishes for all to see
- 5:04and, and, and without considering the repercussions of
- 5:07such words. And so to your point, you said
- 5:11before we started recording that, you know, it's so hard to
- 5:15know what's going to happen in the next 48 hours, let alone
- 5:17next week, given the weight of this.
- 5:20And yet some people seem to be operating as if it's just
- 5:25another day. And and so it is very difficult
- 5:28to imagine what's worth talking about.
- 5:32How do we keep going? And that's hyper normalization
- 5:35as well, which you obviously you didn't coin that term, but you
- 5:38went significantly viral in the last year for having brought it
- 5:42back to the fore. And the last time, I don't know
- 5:44if you remember this, but the last time you came on the show
- 5:47was a few years ago. And we talked and think it was
- 5:50during the pandemic as well. And we were talking about how
- 5:53you handle grief and how you handle when it feels like your
- 6:00world is, is sort of spiraling out of control.
- 6:03And you said you can, you control what you can control.
- 6:06And you've always told me that. And you, you know that that's
- 6:09true whether we're talking about Paris and how to make sure the
- 6:12community continues to thrive even in hardship.
- 6:15That's true for the rest of France, but that's true
- 6:17everywhere. And so I, I guess this is just a
- 6:21preface to say there are so many bigger issues looming despite
- 6:27what we're going to talk about today that could influence the
- 6:31outcome of what we're saying, right?
- 6:34I yeah, I think, I think that in order to be able to talk about
- 6:40France and in order to be able to talk about anything that's
- 6:44going to be country specific, we have to sort of acknowledge that
- 6:47we are standing at this like pivotal point where things are
- 6:54going to be very different, like before and after breakpoints,
- 6:58you know? And so these are those moments
- 7:01where the world is just never going to be the same afterwards.
- 7:05And in the case of the Iran war, I think it's very interesting
- 7:11that that event has completely changed the trajectory and it's
- 7:15just like pulled us into a completely different timeline.
- 7:18And I think that's important because I find that a lot of
- 7:22people are shying away from complexity, and I understand why
- 7:26it's overwhelming. There's so much you have to
- 7:28know. There's so many things happening
- 7:30at once. It's changing all the time.
- 7:32But at the same time, I think that's even more reason to both
- 7:38take the time to understand what is happening on like a really
- 7:43big macro level in our society. And also somatically, as I have
- 7:48been struggling to do every single day, to process the
- 7:51immensity of that change. Because there are changes that
- 7:55are coming down the pipeline that I think in the long term
- 7:59might actually be really good, but in the short term are going
- 8:03to be hard and violent and they are going to cost people their
- 8:08lives. And we here in France, in the
- 8:10West, we're very privileged. We are going to be buffered from
- 8:14feeling a lot of these consequences.
- 8:17And that is an immense privilege I don't take for granted.
- 8:20It's just heartbreaking to see that this is going to happen.
- 8:25And so, you know, to talk about France, we have to talk about
- 8:29where we are in the world. We have to talk about the
- 8:31interconnection of geopolitics. We have to talk about who is
- 8:35controlling the technology and the ideology of the technology,
- 8:39who is setting the cultural standards of success, Because
- 8:43that's what we have to unravel if we're going to have this
- 8:46conversation. And that's going to involve
- 8:48unlearning and for many people, challenging a lot of assumptions
- 8:52that have been true for decades, that were true five years ago,
- 8:57were true 10 years ago, but they're no longer true today.
- 9:01And human beings, we like certainty.
- 9:03So there's a lot of resistance when you try to tell people the
- 9:06way of life that you've been living, the way you envision
- 9:09your future, your retirement success, your business, the the
- 9:13evolution of technology. Those are not going to look like
- 9:16the way that they looked in the past.
- 9:18Right. And are you saying also, because
- 9:20one of the themes I know you've explored quite a lot is this
- 9:23idea of growth is the metric that's most important to the
- 9:27functioning, to the function of the world.
- 9:29And you're, I mean, is that one of the ideas that may have been
- 9:33true, you know, 15 years ago and that now it's absolutely not
- 9:36true, but the powers that be continue barreling forward with
- 9:39that goal in mind. That's exactly right.
- 9:42When you think about business, when you think about success,
- 9:46when you think about the economy and how we measure GDP and how
- 9:50we measure how well a country is doing, right, The the story
- 9:55underneath that is based on a set of assumptions about the
- 9:58world that were true when commerce started.
- 10:01At the time, you know, that was that we have unlimited resources
- 10:05that are never going to run out. And at the time that was true.
- 10:09Before there was 8 billion people on the planet, that was
- 10:11true, true, right? We that there was going to be
- 10:14freely available, almost not freely, but like cheaply
- 10:17available oil that was going to be just like a surplus of it, an
- 10:21abundance of it. We saw this and how we built
- 10:23businesses in America, in North America, we saw how we built
- 10:28suburbs, like even the design of suburbs were done car centric on
- 10:33the assumption that a commute is not going to be a big deal
- 10:35because oil is cheap. And then we talk about success.
- 10:38When you talk about success in business, when you what, what do
- 10:41we look at? We look at growth.
- 10:42If your company has not earned more this year than last year,
- 10:45then that's a problem if GDP has not grown, if jobs have not been
- 10:49added. So we have become obsessed with
- 10:52Ascent. We have been obsessed with that
- 10:54line always moving up and to the right, right light goes up.
- 10:57And that has been the only thing.
- 10:59And for a long time, the planet, our sweet planet, our home has
- 11:05been doing its best to accommodate that.
- 11:08It has been doing its best. And then we built global trade.
- 11:12We built a Society of cheap goods, plastic goods, freely
- 11:16available goods where, you know, like I don't know the exact
- 11:19statistics, but the majority of pieces of clothing that end up
- 11:23in landfills and how we are, we're consuming, you know, X
- 11:26amount of times more than what we can, you know, sustainably
- 11:30replenish. So all of those things were
- 11:32true. And now we keep passing like
- 11:37planetary system limitations, and we keep thinking that we're
- 11:43going to be able to do this forever.
- 11:44And the problem with that is the second you start talking about
- 11:48degrowth, the second you start talking about a different
- 11:51metric, I mean, the UN just recently published a study
- 11:55saying that normal business models are going to have to
- 11:59pivot to something other than GDP because we are facing
- 12:03planetary collapse. And so now we're asking
- 12:06countries, take everything that you thought was true about what
- 12:10success is, and you're going to have to find something
- 12:12different. And then don't forget those
- 12:14trickle down to individuals. You, you expect, right?
- 12:17You expect as an individual that you're going to keep getting
- 12:20raises, that you're going to keep earning more money, that
- 12:23your life is going to keep getting better, that progress is
- 12:25going to keep moving forward, that you have all these
- 12:27expectations. But that expectation is rooted
- 12:30in infinite growth. And what we're learning from the
- 12:33planet is there is that we cannot have infinite growth.
- 12:38The entire concept is a lie. And if we don't adjust, the
- 12:41system is going to adjust for us because we are hitting
- 12:45limitations of water and oil and materials and chemicals and like
- 12:50all of these resources. Well, let me ask you, because
- 12:53you consult with a lot of very big companies in the world and
- 12:58big important people. I'm obviously saying that in a
- 13:00vague way, but you know who want your thoughts and your opinions
- 13:06and value your expertise? Are they hearing you when you
- 13:10say that? Or is it sort of you're, you're
- 13:13always too far ahead and they're not ready yet?
- 13:15No one's ready. It's been interesting.
- 13:20There are clients who are more open to hearing this, but a lot
- 13:26of them are really not like maliciously, not in a bad way,
- 13:30not in an ignorant way. I really think we don't have the
- 13:33emotional capacity as a society to deal with these types of
- 13:37complex issues. We were never really taught how.
- 13:40And I think for a lot of people it's so overwhelming and scary.
- 13:44There's also just a denial all the time, like it's going to be
- 13:48fine. It's going to be fine.
- 13:49And I think it's because so far it has kind of been fine, you
- 13:55know, for the most part for, for, not for everybody, but not,
- 13:59no, definitely not definitely not for everybody.
- 14:01But so the message is always really hard because sometimes I,
- 14:05you know, see these like internal events and these
- 14:07internal meetings and they want to talk about new technologies
- 14:10and new markets. And nobody's really saying or
- 14:14acknowledging the elephant in the room, which is the entire
- 14:18ideological foundations of how we built this business might no
- 14:24longer be true. And that requires such a shift
- 14:30in thinking that I just don't think a lot of executives are
- 14:36setting aside the time to do it. And honestly, we have such a
- 14:38weird, out of whack system that's all about like,
- 14:42shareholder return. You know, I was just going to
- 14:44say you have to convince. Yeah, you have to convince board
- 14:47members. Even if ACEO or someone you know
- 14:49believes in that shift, you're you're now have to convince
- 14:53everybody else that they need to agree to earn less.
- 14:56That's why I'm kind of looking. This is why I go back to like
- 14:59what we said earlier about being pragmatic, that these changes
- 15:02are going to be really difficult and turbulent because a lot of
- 15:05these organizations might not survive in the form that they
- 15:09are in now. But I do know there are a lot of
- 15:12people that are working in the space that are poised to take
- 15:15advantage of it, right? So if this is what's gonna
- 15:18happen, the same thing that happened in the pandemic.
- 15:20I mean, I think of the the anti fragility framework, right that
- 15:25that was created by Naseem, Nicholas Taleb Naseem, the guy
- 15:29who did who wrote Black Swan. And he said there are three
- 15:32categories. There are three possible
- 15:34responses to a giant market shock or to huge disorder.
- 15:39There are the companies that are not resilient.
- 15:41They will just die. If you cannot adapt, you will
- 15:44die, right? There are the companies that are
- 15:46resilient, that will like eke out and survive and just manage
- 15:50to kind of hold on to the status quo That I think is the majority
- 15:53of companies that they were, you know, they're just going to do
- 15:56their best to like brace themselves until they can't
- 15:59brace themselves anymore. And then I think there's the
- 16:01category of anti fragile. And these are the people that
- 16:04understand what's coming and that are preemptively building
- 16:08models to face this new world, that are thinking about what
- 16:13does regenerative capitalism look like?
- 16:16What do new models of building businesses look like?
- 16:18What does human centric innovation look like?
- 16:20What is ethically based technology look like?
- 16:23And they're starting from now to build it.
- 16:26And you know, I guess time will tell, but the market, some
- 16:30point, the parameters that are limiting the market are going to
- 16:34force you to pay attention. It's like, it's like when you're
- 16:37injured, if you ever had a doctor say to you, like if you
- 16:39don't pay attention to your pain, your body will just get
- 16:41louder and louder and louder until it forces you to pay
- 16:44attention. So that's what I think it is.
- 16:46I think right now we're getting the twinges, the twinges, the
- 16:49twinges. And soon they're going to turn
- 16:50into screams, They're going to turn into storms, they're going
- 16:53to turn into different types of collapses because we are not
- 16:57paying attention to the root of the issue.
- 17:00So with all that said, how do you think France is poised to
- 17:07react in this moment? We started this conversation
- 17:11before actually anyone or before recording, which was the the
- 17:16starting point was OK, we have a new mayor who wants to create a
- 17:19second Station F in Paris, Station F being the massive
- 17:23European tech hub in the 13,000 D small.
- 17:27That was Macron's sort of pet project.
- 17:30He wanted Paris and France specifically to be an innovation
- 17:34and startup hub. That has happened to a degree.
- 17:39But recent funding results would suggest that France's unicorns
- 17:43are actually doing quite poorly. And actually many of its
- 17:46startups are failing. And France's now ranked beneath
- 17:49the UK in terms of most failures.
- 17:51And so this creates an opposition to to the the, you
- 17:56know, optimism that there once was even within the heart of
- 17:59COVID. So what how do these two themes,
- 18:03I guess, connect? You talked earlier about
- 18:05interconnectedness and how that is something we cannot ignore.
- 18:09And how could a country like France, which has perhaps a
- 18:13deeper social foundation and A and a slightly more human
- 18:17centric vision of society than the US or North America, how do
- 18:22these things overlap? And what did?
- 18:24What could that mean for the future?
- 18:27I mean, I was very skeptical about Station F from the
- 18:30beginning because anytime I hear somebody compare it to like the
- 18:34Silicon Valley of I'm already like, uninterested, you know,
- 18:39Because my theory has always been that if you have to copy,
- 18:43you're always gonna be a step behind.
- 18:45And I have always posited that these unicorns are actually
- 18:49Trojan horses because we are bringing in companies that we
- 18:55are trying to replicate a success strategy that's very
- 18:59American and a success strategy that is based on very specific
- 19:03investment objectives. So in Silicon Valley, a lot of
- 19:08this, one of the not the only, but one of the most popular
- 19:11strategies is this thing called blitz scaling, which was used
- 19:14for Uber, for Airbnb, for a lot of these like big tech
- 19:18companies, where what happens is try to do 2 things.
- 19:21You want to dominate the market, right?
- 19:23You want to dominate the market. You don't have a revenue model.
- 19:26You assume that you're going to figure out a revenue model at
- 19:29some point. And then you have these giant,
- 19:32like hundreds of millions of dollars of investments that can
- 19:35subsidized business models that aren't profitable for years,
- 19:39like Uber was unprofitable for over a decade, right?
- 19:44And during that time, they are able to charge €6 a trip to
- 19:51undermine and under and undercut the prices of taxis, the prices
- 19:56of other things, right? So they can come in and they can
- 19:58do it. The problem with blitz scaling
- 20:01is that by definition, it requires only one company to be
- 20:05the winner. And this is what I have been
- 20:07screaming from the rooftops from the beginning, is that you're
- 20:11bringing in an ideology where a. A lot of the money and the
- 20:16ideology of the funding that's coming from the US, they don't
- 20:19care about a thriving ecosystem. They don't care about a human
- 20:23centric technological future. They want 1 multi billion
- 20:27companies so that they can exit and take their cash and go.
- 20:31And so This is why when you look at the unicorns in France,
- 20:36they're just replicating that same model.
- 20:38And in venture capital, you know, you might invest in 10,
- 20:42you know, 20 companies, and maybe one of them is going to be
- 20:45successful, the rest of them are going to fail.
- 20:48So then you had countries like France that said, we want
- 20:51innovation, but we're going to replicate a model that honestly,
- 20:54by definition, is quite predatory because they know that
- 20:58the bulk of these companies are going to fail.
- 21:00So they're all like trying to bet on this one winning success,
- 21:05which I think is really weird. The second thing is, which from
- 21:08a cultural lens is so aggravating to me, is that the
- 21:11person that coined the phrase Unicorn used it specifically as
- 21:17a symbol that the ecosystem was out of whack because unicorns
- 21:22are not real. You're not supposed to see
- 21:24unicorns. And the the the premise
- 21:27originally was if you see a Unicorn, there's a problem in
- 21:30your ecosystem. And instead, somewhere along the
- 21:33way, much like the phrase pull yourself up by the bootstraps
- 21:37started out as satire because it's physically impossible to
- 21:41pull yourself up by your bootstraps.
- 21:43Somewhere along the line, we mix that up and suddenly unicorns
- 21:48became the symbol of success. And then you have the president
- 21:52say we have X amount of unicorns.
- 21:53And meanwhile it's like the Unicorn is so individually
- 21:57focused, which is also very North American and it does not
- 22:00concern itself with this collective.
- 22:02It does not concern itself with society.
- 22:04So for me, when we started talking about Station FI was
- 22:08like, this is weird because parts of the strategy are
- 22:13directly are directly in opposition of key tenants and
- 22:18values of French life. And from the beginning, I just
- 22:21had a lot of skepticism because I thought this is very
- 22:24aggressive. It's very individualistic.
- 22:26It only cares about revenue. They only care about growth.
- 22:29And then because this was the strategy for so long, you had
- 22:33entrepreneurs that were building businesses that they wanted to
- 22:35sell quickly, not businesses that were going to add actual
- 22:38long term value to the society. When you look at a lot of the
- 22:41services and a lot of the say a lot of the unicorns, when you
- 22:44look at who is actually benefiting other than the
- 22:47investors, very small amount, I would say a nominal amount of
- 22:51the French people are benefiting from all of these valuations.
- 22:55So then going back to what is innovation like, what is the
- 22:58point then? What is the point of sponsoring
- 23:01and investing all of this money to To reward a version of
- 23:06innovation that, by explicit definition, needs everyone else
- 23:11to fail so we can have one winner.
- 23:14You raise such a, a chilling point and you know, I know that
- 23:18you were part of the constant numeric.
- 23:21You were part of a committee that that you know, was people
- 23:25from all sorts of backgrounds, right.
- 23:26We're coming together to to weigh in for the president on
- 23:30issues regarding technology, digital life, digital culture.
- 23:33You you worked on disinformation campaigns, but it almost seems
- 23:38like he has been Co opted by the Silicon Valley movement.
- 23:43And if it means that there are more wealthy people to
- 23:48conceivably employ people in France, is that not the shortcut
- 23:53maybe that, you know, our, our government has made here that,
- 23:57you know, if you're building something big, regardless of
- 24:00whether ideologically it's sort of not fully aligned.
- 24:04But if it means you're going to have job creation, especially
- 24:07when unemployment has been, you know, at various points,
- 24:10especially before Macron took over, you know, quite high.
- 24:14Do you think that comes into the calculus at all, even though
- 24:17long term it's a a short sighted vision?
- 24:21I don't know. I mean David Graeber had the
- 24:22whole concept of bullshit jobs. If you want to create startups
- 24:25as bullshit jobs, that's fine. Like that's a strategy.
- 24:28If you have people that are willing to create jobs, sure.
- 24:31I just always think that the type of innovation that is being
- 24:36chased, it's not one that is aligned long term with the
- 24:40interests of friends or its people.
- 24:42It's not. And I know this is really hard
- 24:44and I know I people might not agree with me and that's OK.
- 24:47But like we're talking about short term, long term here.
- 24:50Like I think short term sure looks really good.
- 24:53But long term, when you look at what's happening, it's like we
- 24:56are building innovation, at least in North America, we're
- 25:00building innovation models that like don't really care about
- 25:04people or ecosystems. If they just don't, they don't
- 25:08care. When you look at, you know, when
- 25:09you look at the inception stories of Facebook or when you
- 25:14look at the, the harm that has been perpetuated by X, right?
- 25:18It's like this is very clearly a reflection of priorities.
- 25:23As a digital anthropologist, my argument has always been that
- 25:27whether we like the reflection or not, whether we like what we
- 25:30see or not, the technological ecosystem is always a reflection
- 25:33of society's priorities. Whatever flowery words you say
- 25:37aside, when you look at how the tech works, that tells you what
- 25:41is actually important. It's like how people say they
- 25:44value privacy, but then they consistently undermine their own
- 25:48safety protocols when they use some of these apps.
- 25:51So they say one thing, but actually they prioritize
- 25:54convenience more than privacy. That's fine.
- 25:57Like, I'm not judging. I'm just saying this is like
- 25:59what it is. And my problem is, is that we're
- 26:02hitting a limit where capitalism by nature is starting to get
- 26:07into its end phase. We've really pushed it as far as
- 26:11it can go. Like one could argue that the
- 26:13current AI boom that we're seeing is the natural extension
- 26:16of hyper capitalism. Because capitalism is always
- 26:19what, extracting labor from workers.
- 26:22Now we're just not even need. Now we don't even need workers.
- 26:25We have extracted cognitive. Friction.
- 26:28Their brain. And so soon, soon we won't need
- 26:32it at all. And when you look at research
- 26:33papers, when you look at like Project AI, Project 2027 where
- 26:38they looked at or AI 2027, I think it's called, which was
- 26:41just written as a scenario exercised by a bunch of like
- 26:44really smart people. One of the scenarios was that
- 26:47they, that, that they posited was that the people that are
- 26:50pushing for these changes envision a layer of the economy
- 26:55where business is being done only with AI, that you have an
- 26:59AI company with an AI agent that's buying from another AI
- 27:03agent and another AI company. And it's generating all of this
- 27:06value, which then goes only to the ownership layer.
- 27:10And so my, my, my thing is, it's like, sure, if it creates jobs,
- 27:14I'm not against startups, I'm not against innovation, I'm not
- 27:17against investing in entrepreneurs, I'm not against
- 27:20creating national pride. I'm not against and developing
- 27:23talent OR technology. I'm not against any of that.
- 27:26I'm very for that that I am against is doing so by using a
- 27:32model that has been proven now without a doubt to harm human
- 27:36rights, to harm the environment and to create more inequality,
- 27:40to create a lot of dangers. So my question has always been,
- 27:44what is the innovation thesis of France?
- 27:47What is our vision if we did not have to pay attention to China
- 27:52or to Silicon Valley? What is our vision of the
- 27:56future? What is our vision of what we
- 27:58want innovation to be? And I think Europe, if we can
- 28:01just hold on, is better positioned in the long term
- 28:04because we're already starting to see the exploitation that is
- 28:09happening when these regulations are not there to stop people.
- 28:13And so then you'll go and I'll let you, I'll stop rambling.
- 28:16But then you'll kind of go and you'll have people say, well,
- 28:19regulation slows innovation down.
- 28:22And it's like, maybe, but what kind of innovation is being
- 28:26slowed down? What type of innovation do are
- 28:28these regulations preventing? Because if the if the thesis is
- 28:32well, we don't need regulation because we want to be able to
- 28:35break things in an opportunity to be first, to be biggest, to
- 28:38be the richest. To me, I don't care.
- 28:40I'm not motivated by becoming a Unicorn or becoming a
- 28:43billionaire. I want drinkable water for
- 28:46people. And I want, you know, like just
- 28:49just for, for fair wages and for people to be safe like that, you
- 28:53know? And so I just think it's wild to
- 28:56me that we continue to let other countries set the context of the
- 29:01debate where in that container where we're having the
- 29:03conversation, they've already assumed a bunch of things that
- 29:07we have to also assume are true just by acknowledging the
- 29:11regulation conversation as an example.
- 29:13So one challenge to this is the overlap currently between a very
- 29:20toxic problematic company that has signed deals with France and
- 29:24that's Palantir. And Palantir is in the news all
- 29:26the time for very good reason, because it is terrifying.
- 29:31And it's head honchos have a very nihilistic view of, of the
- 29:36future and, and sort of the role of humans in it, sort of an
- 29:40inconsequential factor for them. I guess.
- 29:43What do you make of that? Is that again, just another bump
- 29:46in the road and that, you know, France will have to come to, you
- 29:49know, kind of like how it worked with McKinsey in the past.
- 29:52And then it finally was like, no, we're not going to do that
- 29:54anymore. And, you know, why is it that
- 29:56they they they bring on despite all of the evidence to the, the
- 30:03evidence that points to the, the very harmful nature of some of
- 30:06these companies that could backfire on them and their
- 30:09overall goals, right. You know, France, with its
- 30:12vision of security and privacy and and all these sorts of
- 30:16things, then goes and works with a company that could feed all
- 30:21that data to the worst people in the world.
- 30:24Yeah, I agree and I honestly don't know.
- 30:26Sometimes I think it stems maybe from the desire to be more
- 30:30America like, right. This goes back to this posturing
- 30:33of we of their the ideal, they have the most sophisticated
- 30:37technology. We want some of that that
- 30:39technology I think it has. It is a betrayal of the French
- 30:46people to bring a company who has been quite explicit in their
- 30:52vision about what the future should be like.
- 30:55And to have that vision be so different than the values of
- 31:00France as a country is insane. And I think it's one of those
- 31:04things of we're letting I go back to Trojan horse like we're
- 31:07letting this company, which is first of all, the idea of
- 31:10letting any foreign company at all have access to this data is
- 31:15absolutely abhorrent to me just from a very basic national
- 31:18security perspective. I just, I would not.
- 31:22I would not personally. Even if it meant we couldn't do
- 31:25some of the surveillance things. I would not.
- 31:27Because everything I have learned about this company,
- 31:31everything I have learned about their view of the world, their
- 31:34view of the future, how they view people, how they view
- 31:37privacy has just given me chills.
- 31:41And I don't understand. I've tried to raise it.
- 31:43I think this should be something that every French citizen should
- 31:46be raising to their elected representative.
- 31:48I think we should be making a really big push in general to
- 31:53cut any of these ties with these organizations because it's it's
- 31:58why don't we just give them the keys?
- 32:00We've literally given them the keys to all of our data, and on
- 32:05what? On a pinky promise that they're
- 32:07not going to. It looks extremely egregious
- 32:10when you think about the move that France made recently or in
- 32:13the last, you know, just since January to get rid of American
- 32:18tech products on government computers, right?
- 32:20So no more, no more Microsoft Teams or whatever that is, you
- 32:24know, none of none of those systems and to prioritize French
- 32:27systems. So on the one hand, you have
- 32:29them doing this and then having contracts with some very
- 32:32nefarious actors. I don't, I mean, this is where
- 32:36it's almost and look, if, if we can give them a little bit of
- 32:39grace here, right? To not to not assume malice,
- 32:43right? It's like, I understand that the
- 32:45world is changing. And I think if you were to tell
- 32:48French people or if Europe was to consider whether or not the
- 32:53United States was an ally, I think any other answer other
- 32:57than yes, of course they're an ally would have been unthinkable
- 33:01a year and a half ago. Like, we're talking about a
- 33:04relationship that has persisted since after World War 2.
- 33:07We're talking about, again, assumptions you make about the
- 33:11world, about just the way that things are.
- 33:13So I can understand why all of a sudden you have government,
- 33:17which as a machine moves pretty slow, that has to all of a
- 33:20sudden update state. It's like mode of operation
- 33:25because that that, you know, that party that we thought were
- 33:28on our side is no longer on our side and then looking at the
- 33:31cascading ramifications of that. So I would be very interested, I
- 33:35don't have that information. I would be very interested to
- 33:37understand more of the conversations, the
- 33:40justifications, the protections they're putting in place with
- 33:43Palantir. But I just think it's a, it's a
- 33:45huge risk in terms of national security, in terms of all of our
- 33:49data, especially considering when you look at that like what
- 33:52Palantir wants to do, they want to create full data profiles of
- 33:57every single individual. That is terrifying.
- 34:01That should terrify every single person listening to this.
- 34:04And then to have them like be weaseling their way into into
- 34:09France. I, you know, I'm concerned.
- 34:11I'm not happy about it, that's for sure.
- 34:13I would, I do need to like educate myself a bit more on
- 34:16maybe they've put limitations on that, but I don't know.
- 34:18I just don't trust them. I just don't trust them at all.
- 34:21Well, like you said, it's kind of like a pinky promise and you
- 34:23know, we're just supposed to take that as valuable given all
- 34:28of this. And it feels like obviously a
- 34:30very complex conversation that requires more than 1/2 hour and,
- 34:34and particularly as it pertains to France.
- 34:36But you've you've raised so many interesting points.
- 34:39And I hope that everyone listening does understand that
- 34:41we can't just talk about France and Paris specifically in
- 34:45isolation because it really is part of this whole network.
- 34:49What do you hope Paris becomes? As you know, given the show is
- 34:53called The New Paris, what can Paris as the place where all of
- 34:57these decisions are being being made and where the tech
- 35:00companies primarily are being created?
- 35:02What do you hope for the future of this city and how it
- 35:06influences the rest of the country?
- 35:07If you had a magic wand, what would you say you would want to
- 35:10have happened? I think as a Canadian who moved
- 35:15to Paris because I just absolutely loved city with all
- 35:19of its imperfections, I think one of the things that I've
- 35:22always said is that the Parisians in my experience, have
- 35:27an understanding of how to live a life that is human centered
- 35:32and not work centered. And this has been a huge part of
- 35:35my work and understanding the cultural differences, right?
- 35:38I think that the way that French people are in the streets every
- 35:44time something happens is I think incredible.
- 35:47I look at the complacency of places like Canada where it's
- 35:50like, I wish people would get in the streets and would show up.
- 35:53I think the protection of unions, the protection of worker
- 35:56rights, the protection of human rights.
- 35:58Even just when you look at Paris itself, even just local
- 36:01businesses, even, you know, we're not the last time I went
- 36:04home, back to, well, not hold. The last time I went back to
- 36:06Toronto for a visit, I was really struck by the lack of
- 36:10local businesses and how everything was franchised, for
- 36:13example. So what I would love to see is I
- 36:16would love to see the city recognize that this is a City
- 36:19made for humans. It's a City made for people.
- 36:22And the way that we are planting trees and making it less car
- 36:28friendly and having more bike lanes and having more
- 36:30sustainable solutions. I would like to see more
- 36:33participatory tech. One of the things that I love, I
- 36:36live in the 11th as, as you know, many people that we know.
- 36:41And one of the things that I love is I love that the Mary of
- 36:45my Arandi Small that you could go on to paris.fr, you can make
- 36:48an account and then you could make suggestions about
- 36:51initiatives in your neighborhood and then people vote on them.
- 36:54I would like to see that in tech.
- 36:56So many decisions that are made in the tech world are being done
- 37:00by people that were not democratically elected and that
- 37:02are making decisions about all of our lives.
- 37:04So when I look at Paris, when I look at the new mayor, when I
- 37:07look at the walkable city we've created, the 15 minute city
- 37:10we've created, when I look at the local businesses, when I
- 37:13look at the attention to art and to culture and to craft and to
- 37:17food, I think this is a city that understands that these are
- 37:22the things that are worth living for.
- 37:25Good food, good friends, good conversation, safe cities, good
- 37:29education, culture. Like, isn't that what the point
- 37:32is? And I think the lesson there is
- 37:36that Big Tech keeps getting us to optimize.
- 37:39All Big Tech wants to do is optimize.
- 37:42Optimize what? More productivity, more
- 37:44performance, more revenue. And every time we go with that,
- 37:48we are taking a step away from the reality of a day-to-day life
- 37:53that I think most of us would be happier and healthier living in.
- 37:57I don't know if we can say that was a mic drop, but it sure felt
- 38:00like Rahaf. It is always so thrilling and
- 38:07inspiring to talk to you even in the hardest moments because I
- 38:11think your words are so needed right now and I think they're
- 38:15needed in in the upper echelons of of governance.
- 38:19If only those those people would be listening to this show.
- 38:23Who knows, maybe they are, but I hope everyone takes the time to
- 38:28let what you've shared here today sink in.
- 38:31And I know you have other work that you're you're about to
- 38:34release into the world that people can hopefully continue
- 38:39to, to pursue this thinking you've been working on something
- 38:42called humane productivity, which I imagine will come out in
- 38:46the next year or so. OK, so, and in the meantime,
- 38:51people can follow her at Fushi, at the Ampersand, sign FOUSHY on
- 38:57Instagram, sign up for her newsletter.
- 39:00I feel like this is just the cycle we're in.
- 39:02You need to come back every couple years and do a status
- 39:04check. I'd love that.
- 39:06I'd love that. Thank you so much for having me.
- 39:10That's the show for today. If you're listening on Spotify,
- 39:13be sure to check out the poll related to this episode by
- 39:16scrolling down in your app. There are more exciting
- 39:19conversations to come this season, so I hope you'll
- 39:21subscribe or share the show with a friend if you've been enjoying
- 39:24what you've heard so far. As always, you can find more
- 39:28from me at lindsaytremuta.com and at the New Paris Dispatch on
- 39:31Sub Stack at Treyento.