Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Convertible Notes to Raise Capital
Transcript
- Lucas: Last year, US tech companies issued roughly seventy billion dollars in convertible bonds. That’s a record, and a big chunk of that came from companies that had only been public for a year or two. Luna: Convertible notes are a classic tool, but why are they suddenly so popular with recent IPOs specifically? Lucas: Because they solve a tension every post ipo growth company faces: you need capital to scale, but you don’t want to crash your stock price with a secondary offering that dilutes existing shareholders. A convertible note gives you cheap debt now, and if the stock does well, the bonds convert into equity later—at a premium to today’s price. Luna: So it’s like the company is betting on itself, and the bondholders get a piece of the upside if the bet pays off. Lucas: Exactly. And that kind of forward-thinking financing is what we dig into on this show every week. Luna: If you find these conversations useful, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Even a small contribution helps us keep the podcast ad-free. Lucas: Now, the mechanics. A typical convertible note might have a coupon of 1 to 2 percent—way cheaper than a straight bond—and a conversion premium of 30 to 40 percent above the stock price at issuance. Luna: Meaning the bondholder can convert each thousand-dollar bond into, say, ten shares only if the stock hits $140 when it’s currently at $100. Lucas: Right. If the stock stays below that, the company just pays the low coupon and repays the principal at maturity. It’s a win if the stock doesn’t soar. But if it does, the bondholders dilute existing equity. That trade-off is why companies time these carefully. Luna: Take MongoDB. They issued convertible notes in 2020 with a 0.25% coupon and a 35% premium. At the time, the stock was around $150. Within two years it hit $500. Those bondholders converted at a huge profit. Lucas: Great example. MongoDB’s stock later split, but the point stands. The convertible allowed them to raise over a billion dollars without a dilutive secondary. And because the coupon was so low, it barely dented their cash flow. Luna: But there’s a catch. If the stock tanks, the company still has to repay the principal. That’s a real liability. Lucas: Absolutely. That’s why you mostly see this from companies with strong cash flows or high insider confidence. Think of it as a middle path between equity and straight debt. Luna: Snap did a similar thing in 2017, right after its IPO. They issued $1.3 billion in convertibles with a 0.75% coupon. At the time, critics said it was risky because Snap wasn’t profitable yet. Lucas: And Snap did struggle post ipo. But the convertible bought them time. The low coupon meant they weren’t bleeding interest, and they used the cash to acquire competitors and improve their ad platform. By 2020, the stock had recovered enough that the conversion premium was within reach. Luna: So the convertible acted like a bridge loan with an equity upside for investors. It’s not for every company, but for high-growth tech, it’s almost standard. Lucas: Standard, but not automatic. The decision depends on how the market views the company’s volatility. Convertible investors are often hedge funds that run arbitrage strategies—they buy the bond and short the stock to lock in a return. Luna: That can actually put downward pressure on the stock price in the short term. Lucas: It can. But if the company is growing fast, the short interest gets absorbed. The key is transparency. Companies need to message why they’re issuing convertibles—usually to fund specific growth initiatives—so investors don’t see it as a desperate cash grab. Luna: Now, how does this compare to a traditional secondary offering? If a post ipo company needs, say, $500 million, they could just sell new shares. Lucas: A secondary offering dilutes immediately and often knocks the stock down 5 to 10 percent because the market fears supply. A convertible delays dilution and can even be structured with a capped call—a derivative that offsets some of the dilution if the stock soars. Luna: So the convertible is really a toolkit. You’ve got the coupon, the premium, the maturity, and then you can layer on hedges. Lucas: Exactly. And that’s why we’re seeing more innovation here. Some companies now issue so-called ‘convertible bonds with zero coupon’—they pay no interest at all, just a very high conversion premium. That’s effectively equity at a future price. Luna: Zero coupon? That’s essentially free money until conversion. But the bondholders are taking more stock price risk. Lucas: They are. And that tells you something about market sentiment. When a post ipo company can issue zero-coupon convertibles, it means investors are very bullish on its long-term growth. We saw that with a few cloud companies in 2021 and 2022. Luna: One risk I’ve seen is the accounting treatment. Convertibles can dilute earnings per share if they’re in-the-money, which can surprise analysts. Lucas: Right. Under GAAP, companies use the if-converted method—they assume the bonds are converted, which adds more shares to the diluted EPS calculation. That can make earnings look lower than they might otherwise be. So CFOs need to guide on that. Luna: And there’s the timing. Most post ipo companies issue convertibles after the lockup period expires, because that’s when the stock price stabilizes and the investor base is more established. Lucas: Good point. Issuing too soon after the IPO risks running into selling pressure from employees unlocking. Too late, and you might miss a favorable interest rate environment. It’s a delicate balance. Luna: Let’s tie this to current data. Today’s headlines mention Monday.com using AI to justify layoffs, which is controversial, but not convertible-related. However, we do see companies like Palantir—trading at 122—which has never issued convertibles, opting instead for equity. Lucas: Palantir is an interesting counterexample. They’ve been profitable and have tons of cash, so they don’t need cheap debt. But for a company like Rivian, which is burning cash, a convertible could be a lifeline. Rivian’s stock is around 16, down from its highs. If they issued convertibles at a 30% premium, it would be a vote of confidence that they’ll turn around. Luna: So the message the market reads from a convertible issuance matters as much as the math. Lucas: Absolutely. It’s a signal. Companies that are transparent about their use of proceeds—say, for R&D or capital expenditures—tend to get a better reception. Those that are vague get punished. Luna: What about the risk of a forced conversion? If the stock stays above the conversion price for a certain period, the company can force conversion, issuing shares whether the bondholders like it or not. Lucas: That’s typical. The indenture usually has a “soft call” provision. The company can force conversion if the stock trades above 130% of the conversion price for, say, 20 days. That lets the company clean up its balance sheet and avoid future dilution uncertainty. Luna: So the convertible is a flexible instrument that can morph from debt to equity on the company’s terms. Lucas: Exactly. And that flexibility is why we see them in about 60% of tech IPOs within the first three years. Whether it’s a direct listing or a SPAC, the convertible is a go-to tool. Luna: One last angle: recent regulatory changes. The SEC’s new rule on convertible note accounting—effective last year—simplified the treatment, making it easier for companies to avoid marking the conversion feature as a derivative. Lucas: That’s a big deal. Previously, companies had to bifurcate the conversion option and account for it at fair value each quarter, creating earnings volatility. Now, if certain conditions are met, the whole instrument is treated as a single liability with no separate equity component. That’s a simplification that encourages more issuance. Luna: So the regulatory tailwind is part of why we saw that record seventy billion last year. Lucas: It is. And I’d expect that number to grow as more companies realize they can access cheap capital without the stigma of a secondary offering. For investors, convertible notes offer a hybrid risk profile—debt-like downside with equity-like upside. Luna: As long as you understand the conversion mechanics and the company’s growth trajectory. Lucas: Right. So next time you see a post ipo company announce a convertible note, don’t just see debt. See a strategic bet on future growth, structured to keep existing shareholders whole as long as possible. Luna: And that’s a conversation worth having.