Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️114 | Public Inquiry special Clean Air Strategy Public Consultation |
Transcript
- 0:05Unknown: Good evening and welcome to this bonus episode.
- 0:10I had intended to take a break from the public inquiry for a few weeks, but then Northern Ireland's new clean air strategy consultation caught my attention, and I found myself wondering whether the left-hand of government has the faintest idea what the right-hand is doing.
- 0:28Because while one government department is busy telling us how important clean air is, other departments are responsible for decisions that could introduce substantial new sources of pollution into places where air is currently relatively clean,
- 0:47and that seems to me to be a rather peculiar way of going about improving air quality.
- 0:54Now, before anybody accuses me of being opposed to progress, let me take you somewhere that has been making considerable progress on this very issue.
- 1:03London,
- 1:05not somewhere most of us would immediately associate with fresh air, but a city that has spent years trying to tackle the damage caused by traffic pollution.
- 1:18The introduction and expansion of the ultra low emission zone known as EULAS has been controversial, expensive for some, and politically divisive, but according to a report published by the Greater London Authority in March 2025, roadside nitrogen dioxide concentrations across London in
- 1:432024 were estimated to be 27% lower than they would have been without Eulens and its expansions.
- 1:52That's a substantial improvement, and although it doesn't mean London's air is suddenly clean,
- 1:59it does demonstrate what can happen when a government decides to do something about pollution and follows through?
- 2:07And that brings me back to Northern Ireland, where we are now developing our own clean air strategy. I welcome it, and I hope it succeeds.
- 2:18There's something a bit ironic about watching London spend enormous amounts of money trying to recover cleaner air, while here in The Sperrins we are having to campaign to protect the clean air we already have.
- 2:32And the more I look at how environmental decisions are made in Northern Ireland, the more I wonder whether our government has properly joined up its own thinking,
- 2:44because clean air, as it turns out, is everybody's responsibility,
- 2:48which sometimes means that it's nobody's.
- 2:53Let's begin with Dera, the Department of Agriculture, Environment, and Rural Affairs.
- 2:59This is the department responsible for environmental policy,
- 3:03and it is the department behind the new clean air strategy.
- 3:08When Minister Andrew Moore launched the consultation, he acknowledged that there is no safe level of air pollution.
- 3:20That is an important statement, particularly coming from the minister responsible for protecting our environment.
- 3:28The strategy sets out ambitions to reduce emissions, improve monitoring,
- 3:34strengthen the evidence on air pollution, and encourage cooperation across government.
- 3:40All very welcome,
- 3:43but I am interested in what happens when those ambitions meet the real world.
- 3:49Because a strategy is one thing, making sure it will actually influence the decisions being taken elsewhere in government is quite another,
- 3:59and that's where things begin to get interesting.
- 4:04Take the Department for the Economy.
- 4:06Among its responsibilities is mineral development, including the licencing framework for mineral prospecting and extraction.
- 4:17Now, there is nothing
- 4:19inherently unreasonable about a government wanting to understand its mineral resources, or considering their economic potential.
- 4:30But mineral development can also bring significant environmental risks, and those risks do not disappear simply because a project might create jobs or generate revenue.
- 4:43Here in The Sperrins, we have the proposed Dalharian gold mine at Coronalt, which would involve underground mining or processing, substantial machinery, heavy vehicle movements, and a mine waste facility.
- 4:58All activities that require.
- 5:00Careful consideration of their potential environmental effects.
- 5:06So I would be interested to know how the Department for the Economy reconciles its responsibilities for mineral development with the government's ambition to reduce air pollution.
- 5:18When mineral licences are granted or mining proposals are being considered. How much weight is given to protecting existing good air quality?
- 5:29And is there a clear requirement to demonstrate that mineral development is consistent with Northern Ireland's wider environmental objectives?
- 5:39I'm not suggesting that the Department for the Economy should make planning decisions, because that is not its role.
- 5:48But surely, the economic ambitions of one department should not be pursued in isolation from the environmental responsibilities of another.
- 5:59Otherwise, we risk finding ourselves in the rather absurd position of one department encouraging industrial development, while another is left trying to manage the pollution that may result.
- 6:13Which brings us to Department for Infrastructure.
- 6:17DFI has responsibility for the planning system,
- 6:21and it is through that system that major developments, proposals are examined, and decisions are made.
- 6:29The proposed Cornell gold mine is currently the subject of a public inquiry,
- 6:34where the environmental evidence is being tested in considerable detail.
- 6:39Now, I'm not going to revisit all that evidence today.
- 6:43Those of you who have been following our regular podcasts will already know how much ground we have covered.
- 6:51But one thing has become very clear to me:
- 6:55environmental assessments depend heavily on predictions about what may happen in the future.
- 7:02Constantly, we hear about modelling and mitigation and monitoring, and the conditions that may be attached to planning permission.
- 7:09And while all of those have their place, they do not remove the uncertainty involved in predicting how a substantial industrial development will operate over many years in the future.
- 7:23So I'd like to know how DFI intends to reflect the ambitions of the Clean Air Strategy in major planning decisions.
- 7:32If government policy is to prevent pollution at source,
- 7:36should that not be a central consideration when deciding whether to permit a development that may introduce new sources of emissions,
- 7:47and when planning conditions are proposed to control pollution,
- 7:51who ensures that they are sufficiently clear, enforceable, and capable of protecting the public?
- 8:00Because,
- 8:02as we all know, there is a world of difference between writing a condition and making sure it works.
- 8:10Which brings me back to DERA, D A E R A, and in particular the Northern Ireland Environmental Agency (NIEA)
- 8:19. NIEA has important responsibilities for environmental regulation and enforcement, although the the precise powers involved depend on the activity and the legislation under which it is regulated.
- 8:34And this is where I begin to lose patience with the comforting language of environmental protection. We have a government department developing policy, another overseeing planning decisions, and yet another involved in mineral development, and various regulators and councils
- 8:49responsible for different aspects of monitoring and enforcement.
- 8:54Each with its own statutory responsibilities,
- 8:58each operating within its own particular legislative framework, and presumably each confident that it is doing precisely what it's supposed to do.
- 9:09But from the perspective of somebody living near a major industrial development,
- 9:14none of those administrative distinctions
- 9:19is terribly reassuring.
- 9:21If pollution becomes a problem, people want to know who is responsible, who has the authority to intervene, and how quickly can something be done.
- 9:31They do not want to spend weeks trying to establish whether their concern belongs with a council, a regulator, or another Government department.
- 9:42And pollution, unfortunately, is not known for its patience with administrative procedures.
- 9:51Dust does not stop travelling while somebody establishes jurisdiction.
- 9:56Nor does an emission suddenly become harmless because it falls between the response.
- 10:00Of two public bodies,
- 10:02that is why I believe the clean air strategy needs much more than a commitment
- 10:08to departments working together.
- 10:11It needs clear accountability, independent monitoring, adequate resources, and enforceable standards.
- 10:20And I would like to see particular attention given to rural areas where substantial industrial developments are being proposed,
- 10:31because there is a tendency to think of air pollution as an urban problem,
- 10:36something associated with traffic congestion, busy roads, and densely Populated cities,
- 10:43but rural communities are not immune to pollution, and the introduction of major industrial operation can change the sources of emissions to which people are exposed.
- 10:55Here in Sperrins, we have relatively clean air, peatlands that have developed over 1000s of years,
- 11:03rivers carrying clean water down through the valleys, and an extraordinary variety of wildlife, the badgers and the hares, the birds and countless smaller creatures that live here are all part of a landscape in which the air, land and water are connected.
- 11:20Airborne pollution does not necessarily remain an air quality issue.
- 11:25Depending on the pollutants involved, it can settle onto vegetation and soil and water, with consequences for sensitive habitats.
- 11:35And sometimes, I think our government departments are so busy dividing the environment into their separate areas of responsibilities;
- 11:43that they risk forgetting the natural world has never operated according to departmental boundaries.
- 11:51The birds have not read the clean air strategy. The
- 11:54peatlands are unlikely to be reassured by an interdepartmental working group, and the rivers will continue to carry whatever finds its way into them.
- 12:07There's also a question of fairness here.
- 12:10Much of the discussion around improving air quality focuses on changes ordinary people may need to make:
- 12:17cleaner vehicles,
- 12:19different heating systems and changes to everyday habitats,
- 12:24to everyday habits,
- 12:27all reasonable things to consider, but not necessarily affordable or practical for everybody.
- 12:33A pensioner living in rural Tyrone may have no access to natural gas, limited public transport, and little money to spare for replacing a heating system,
- 12:44yet we are prepared to consider major industrial developments that could introduce additional emissions,
- 12:52provided the necessary assessments and regulatory requirements are satisfied.
- 12:59I find that contradiction difficult to accept.
- 13:03Surely, the responsibility for for preventing pollution should fall most heavily on those creating the greatest risks and those with the resources to control them. And surely, government should be helping ordinary households make cleaner choices rather than placing additional financial burdens on
- 13:25people who may already be struggling,
- 13:28Minister.
- 13:30I welcome your clean air strategy, and I welcome your acknowledgement that air pollution poses risks to public health.
- 13:38But I'd like to ask how you intend to ensure that the ambitions of your department are reflected in decisions taken elsewhere in government?
- 13:48Because while DERA is developing policies to reduce pollution,
- 13:52the Department for the Economy has responsibilities for mineral development.
- 13:58DFI oversees major planning decisions and environmental regulators and councils must deal with the practical business of monitoring and enforcement.
- 14:09How are you ensuring that these responsibilities work together to protect communities?
- 14:16And more specifically, what will your clean air strategy mean for people living in places like The Sperrins,
- 14:24where a major industrial development is being considered.
- 14:29Will there be independent monitoring of existing air quality before such developments begin?
- 14:36Will the results be publicly available?
- 14:39And will the authorities responsible for enforcement have the powers and resources to act quickly if pollution becomes a problem.
- 14:49I am not asking you to interfere in the outcome of the public inquiry.
- 14:52I am asking you to explain how your vision for cleaner air will translate into a meaningful protection for communities.
- 15:00Facing the prospect of additional industrial emissions,
- 15:05I would genuinely welcome a response, and would be very happy to share it with our listeners.
- 15:10And perhaps the minister might encourage some of his colleagues around the executive table to join the conversation,
- 15:20because
- 15:22we have all been struck by how little visible political engagement there has been with the wider environmental questions raised by the Cornell proposal,
- 15:31local people have spent years examining evidence, attending meetings, raising concerns, and trying to understand the consequences of a development that could affect their communities for generations,
- 15:44and yet our elected representatives have, for the most part, been remarkably quiet,
- 15:52almost indifferent.
- 15:54Now, I appreciate that politicians may be reluctant to comment on a live planning application.
- 16:01There is a huge difference between prejudicing a planning decision and asking whether the environmental protections available to the public are adequate.
- 16:12Surely, that is precisely the sort of question our elective representatives should be asking.
- 16:19And if Northern Ireland is serious about developing a clean air strategy, I would have thought that every MLA and councillor should be interested in how it will be implemented, who will enforce it, and whether it will protect the communities they represent.
- 16:38Because ultimately,
- 16:39this is not simply about Dalradian or The Sperrins. It is about the sort of environmental protection system we want in Northern Ireland.
- 16:48One in which government departments pursue their individual objectives and hope that Everton somehow comes together in the end,
- 16:58or one in which protecting public health and environmental is a responsibility shared across government with clear standards and somebody answerable when those standards are not met. I know which I would prefer,
- 17:13and I suspect most people would agree.
- 17:16I keep thinking about London and the enormous effort that has gone into improving its air quality, we have evidence that determined action can make a difference.
- 17:26But surely there is an equally important lesson to be learned.
- 17:31It is far better to protect clean air than to spend years trying to recover it once it has been lost.
- 17:38Here in The Sperrins, we are fortunate to have a landscape that remains relatively unspoiled, with communities, wildlife, rivers, and peatlands that deserve proper protection.
- 17:50And I would like our government to recognise that protecting what we already have is every bit as important as repairing what has been damaged elsewhere.
- 18:01So I hope Northern Ireland's clean air strategy becomes something more than another document full of admirable intentions. I hope it brings genuine cooperation between departments, proper accountability, and the political determination to prevent avoidable pollution.
- 18:21Because if our government cannot coordinate its own responsibilities to protect the air we breathe, I think we are entitled to ask what exactly all those departments, agencies, and strategies are achieving,
- 18:35and perhaps before we introduce new sources of pollution into some of our most beautiful and environmentally sensitive places, we might consider the extraordinary lengths other communities are having to go in order to clean up theirs.
- 18:53Thank you for listening, and if you think that these questions deserve wider attention, please share this podcast with friends and family, and particularly with your elective representatives.
- 19:06And if you'd like to follow what's happening at the Coronel Public Inquiry, you can find our regular podcast coverage and sign up for the for the weekly newsletter to the Save Our Sperrins website. Because clean air should not depend on where you live, which department is responsible, or how much time
- 19:25and money your community can afford to spend defending
- 19:30it. See you all soon.
- 19:32You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Front Line.
- 19:38Thank you for joining us today.
- 19:41All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about
- 19:58protecting our land and community.
- 20:00And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.