Latest / Politics By Faith w/Mike Slater / JD Vance and The Progressive Pagan Tone Police
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to Politics by
- 0:08Faith.
- 0:08It's where we take the news of the day.
- 0:10We bring it to the Bible.
- 0:11The point of this is
- 0:12we need to walk away with some peace and perspective
- 0:14cause there's new headlines every day and it's all very
- 0:16anxiety-inducing,
- 0:17but Ecclesiastes says there's nothing new under the sun.
- 0:20So thanks for being here to get the true story.
- 0:22Story of the day,
- 0:23JD Vance
- 0:24making the rounds and
- 0:29Left doesn't like his tone.
- 0:31Got a mean tone.
- 0:33Gotta watch that tone.
- 0:34The tone police are out.
- 0:36JD Vance is making the rounds because he's got a new book out.
- 0:39And he is also a great spokesperson for this administration.
- 0:43So,
- 0:43where Trump can
- 0:45sometimes be maybe rough around the edges,
- 0:47Vance is
- 0:48smoother,
- 0:49more polished,
- 0:49if you will.
- 0:50I don't know if that's entirely true.
- 0:52I think Trump is pretty smooth and polished too,
- 0:54in his own way.
- 0:56But
- 0:58Maybe the biggest advantage that Trump,
- 0:59excuse me,
- 0:59that Vance has over Trump is he's not Trump,
- 1:02so,
- 1:04As much,
- 1:05as much TDS.
- 1:08People have seething through their veins,
- 1:11pulsing constantly through their entire body and soul.
- 1:15They don't yet
- 1:18have the same hatred for JD Vance.
- 1:20They will,
- 1:21don't worry.
- 1:22But right now there's no such thing as JDDS.
- 1:26That's right.
- 1:27One day there will be.
- 1:28Oh,
- 1:29he's even worse than Trump because he actually believes what he's saying.
- 1:32That's what's
- 1:33Gonna happen.
- 1:35But,
- 1:36uh,
- 1:36there's certain places where I would much rather have the president be
- 1:40like negotiating with Iran,
- 1:42for instance,
- 1:42or,
- 1:43uh,
- 1:43Trump's great at these big press conferences.
- 1:46Obviously he's
- 1:47the best at the rallies.
- 1:49But when it comes to one on one with adversaries,
- 1:53I choose Vance all day on that one,
- 1:54all day long.
- 1:55You put Vance
- 1:56in that battle.
- 1:58Big rallies.
- 2:00Big press conferences
- 2:02Trump with another world leader,
- 2:04you put Trump.
- 2:06Someone versus,
- 2:07uh,
- 2:07you know,
- 2:08a Meet the Press lady or whatever,
- 2:10you just send JD on.
- 2:12No question.
- 2:14I,
- 2:14uh,
- 2:15like JD Vance are great with the ladies on The View,
- 2:18for instance.
- 2:19We played the entire
- 2:2025 minutes or so he was on.
- 2:22Uh,
- 2:23on my,
- 2:23my radio show.
- 2:24My one critique,
- 2:25if I had to have it,
- 2:26I critiques not even quite a nitpick,
- 2:28is the women on The View,
- 2:29they would,
- 2:30they would hit him with like 48 questions at one time,
- 2:33and he'd have to think in his brain,
- 2:35OK,
- 2:35I have 12 seconds to respond.
- 2:37Um,
- 2:38how can I possibly combine all of these questions?
- 2:41How am I gonna be able to find a cohesive thread,
- 2:44coherent thread that your incoherent questions
- 2:47and somehow come up with an answer that
- 2:49can best encompass everything that's been said here.
- 2:52With a twelve-second response and a smile.
- 2:56So there's times when he would say,
- 2:58OK,
- 2:58um,
- 3:01Let me say this,
- 3:03you go on and say,
- 3:03you could see his brain like try to put the pieces together.
- 3:07That's my one critique,
- 3:08my goodness.
- 3:09He did as good as any human can do
- 3:11in that.
- 3:13unenviable situation.
- 3:14But I wanna pick out this moment from the New York Times podcast.
- 3:18Russ Dothat is this guy's name,
- 3:20I don't know how to pronounce it or something.
- 3:21He's very upset.
- 3:24That the administration
- 3:26is not nice enough with their tone.
- 3:30Here's what he said.
- 3:33We could have a longer argument about the economics,
- 3:36but I just want to.
- 3:38Let's,
- 3:38let's stipulate
- 3:39that
- 3:40the Trump administration has in some way
- 3:44a kind of vision of
- 3:45rebuilding the working class
- 3:47that's connected to Christianity.
- 3:50Was that,
- 3:50was that hard to say,
- 3:51Ross?
- 3:51I'm stipulating for the sake,
- 3:53for the sake of argument and the fact that,
- 3:56that you have not given us 3 hours
- 3:58to have this discussion.
- 3:59We're stipulating it.
- 4:00It also seems to me.
- 4:03Like the administration has distanced itself in different ways
- 4:07from
- 4:08some other
- 4:09sort of
- 4:10obvious expressions of Christian influence
- 4:14on politics.
- 4:15Some of them more
- 4:16sort of liberal coded,
- 4:17some of them more conservative coded,
- 4:19right?
- 4:20Like the administration has been more hostile
- 4:23than any prior Republican administration,
- 4:25to say nothing of Democrats in the last 20 years,
- 4:28to the way we do humanitarian aid.
- 4:30It has kept
- 4:31religious conservatives,
- 4:33pro-life organizations especially
- 4:35at arm's length in a way that has led to a lot of criticism.
- 4:40And then,
- 4:41you know,
- 4:41let's,
- 4:42let's be honest,
- 4:43the tone
- 4:44of the administration.
- 4:46is not
- 4:48consistently a Christian tone.
- 4:50There is a tone of
- 4:52aggressive un-charity to people who aren't
- 4:54on board with the administration's policies.
- 4:56So I would,
- 4:57I would describe those as three
- 4:59areas where the administration has felt
- 5:01functionally
- 5:02post-Christian
- 5:04to me,
- 5:04and I'm curious what you think.
- 5:07Well,
- 5:08so,
- 5:08so,
- 5:08on,
- 5:08on the,
- 5:10the first point,
- 5:11um,
- 5:12Well,
- 5:13sorry,
- 5:13the third point,
- 5:14but I want to address first.
- 5:16So on the tone thing,
- 5:18this is,
- 5:19it's,
- 5:19it's very hard
- 5:20to
- 5:21rebut this
- 5:23because it's like fundamentally unfalsifiable
- 5:25because
- 5:26for every clip that you could show me
- 5:28of me or the president or some cabinet secretary
- 5:32saying something that in your view is un-Christian.
- 5:35I could show you another few clips of us doing
- 5:38something or saying something that is like very Christian.
- 5:40The nature of political communication
- 5:43in the era of mass media
- 5:45is that
- 5:46sometimes people are going to say jokes that are taken out of context.
- 5:49Sometimes people are going to make mistakes.
- 5:51I'm not saying I make mistakes.
- 5:52I talk about this in the book a little.
- 5:54In my book
- 5:54Communion,
- 5:55available where books are sold,
- 5:57I talk about the own mistakes that I've made
- 6:00as a
- 6:00Christian,
- 6:02there is there is an apology.
- 6:04To childless cat ladies and,
- 6:06and we,
- 6:07we don't need to get sidetracked by that.
- 6:08Go on.
- 6:08But,
- 6:09but you know,
- 6:10my,
- 6:10my point is like,
- 6:11I'm not saying we're perfect because we're not.
- 6:13My point is that
- 6:14the tone argument is in some ways,
- 6:16I think
- 6:17people see what they want to see.
- 6:20And I also think that tonal arguments are ways of frankly policing
- 6:26working class ways of communication
- 6:28and covering them
- 6:30in elite preferences.
- 6:31Like let metering.
- 6:35So let's talk about what's broken in this scenario here.
- 6:37So,
- 6:38yes,
- 6:38the Bible,
- 6:39God
- 6:40talks about the way
- 6:41we should speak.
- 6:42Proverbs 51,
- 6:43a soft
- 6:44answer
- 6:45turns away wrath,
- 6:47but a harsh word
- 6:49stirs up anger.
- 6:52The president,
- 6:53we've talked about this before,
- 6:54his game theory approach to talking with people and,
- 6:57and negotiating,
- 6:58but just everything,
- 6:59he will always start.
- 7:01Positive,
- 7:02he'll start kind,
- 7:04every time,
- 7:05always.
- 7:06He will always start
- 7:08with a soft
- 7:09answer,
- 7:10and a soft response and a soft initiation,
- 7:12always.
- 7:14First Peter 3:15 says,
- 7:16make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you,
- 7:21yet do it with gentleness
- 7:22and respect.
- 7:24The fruits of the spirit.
- 7:26One of them is kindness,
- 7:28another is
- 7:29gentleness.
- 7:31OK.
- 7:32Also
- 7:34We are told to speak
- 7:35boldly.
- 7:37Acts 4:31 says,
- 7:39and when they had prayed,
- 7:40they were all filled with the Holy Spirit and continued to speak the word of God
- 7:44with
- 7:44boldness.
- 7:46So what do we think boldness,
- 7:48what would boldness mean today?
- 7:50I bet
- 7:52based off of the
- 7:54New York Times editorial board,
- 7:56if they heard a preacher today
- 7:58speak with boldness,
- 8:00they might say,
- 8:01oh,
- 8:01that tone makes me uncomfortable.
- 8:04That's not
- 8:05very inclusive sound,
- 8:07and we talked about this just the other day.
- 8:08The Bible says there is one way to get to heaven.
- 8:12Oh,
- 8:12that's,
- 8:13I don't like your tone.
- 8:16Paul speaks about
- 8:17boldly proclaiming the gospel.
- 8:191 Thessalonians 2:2.
- 8:21But though we had already suffered,
- 8:22we had been
- 8:23shamefully treated at Philippi,
- 8:26as you know,
- 8:27we had boldness
- 8:29in our God
- 8:30to declare you
- 8:31the gospel of God
- 8:33in the midst of much conflict.
- 8:35How were they treated shamefully in Philippi,
- 8:38or I should say why?
- 8:40Is it because the people loved so much what they were saying and how they said it.
- 8:45No,
- 8:45that doesn't make any sense.
- 8:47They were treated shamefully,
- 8:49but what does that mean?
- 8:51Does that mean,
- 8:52uh,
- 8:52they,
- 8:53they,
- 8:53they preach the gospel boldly
- 8:55and then people went on Twitter and said,
- 8:57I don't like your tone.
- 8:59No,
- 8:59they were stripped
- 9:00and beaten with rods,
- 9:02all without a trial,
- 9:03of course,
- 9:04then thrown into prison and placed in stocks
- 9:07while bleeding from the beating they just took.
- 9:13And they weren't treated this way because the people of Philippi
- 9:15liked
- 9:16what they were saying.
- 9:19And think Albert Slater.
- 9:20These are two different things.
- 9:21There's what's being said,
- 9:23and then there's how it's said.
- 9:26And,
- 9:27you know,
- 9:28progressive can make the argument,
- 9:29and it's not accurate,
- 9:30but they can make the argument that,
- 9:31oh,
- 9:31they don't mind what the administration's saying,
- 9:33they,
- 9:34they just don't like how it's said.
- 9:35No,
- 9:36that's you
- 9:37trying to get around that's,
- 9:38that's just a trick.
- 9:39They don't,
- 9:41they don't like what the administration is doing,
- 9:43and they're trying to tone police it.
- 9:45As a way to
- 9:47seem like they're morally superior.
- 9:50So let's go over the 4 options though,
- 9:51right?
- 9:51I mean,
- 9:51there's 4 options,
- 9:52we can make like a,
- 9:53a chart of these 4 options.
- 9:54You have
- 9:55bad tone.
- 9:57Mean words
- 9:59Good tone,
- 10:00nice words.
- 10:02Bad tone,
- 10:04nice words.
- 10:06Or
- 10:06good tone mean words.
- 10:09So it's maybe I,
- 10:10maybe this example will work.
- 10:11We'll see how it goes.
- 10:12Uh,
- 10:12bad tone,
- 10:13bad words.
- 10:13I hate you.
- 10:16Good tone,
- 10:17good word,
- 10:17a nice word,
- 10:18uh,
- 10:18good,
- 10:19good tone,
- 10:19good,
- 10:19good,
- 10:19good.
- 10:20I love you.
- 10:22Oh,
- 10:23let's mix it up.
- 10:24Bad tone,
- 10:26good
- 10:27words.
- 10:28I love you.
- 10:30I love you.
- 10:32That's almost like too passionate.
- 10:34I was like,
- 10:34like,
- 10:34how do you do it like hatredly?
- 10:36I love you.
- 10:39Good tone,
- 10:41bad words.
- 10:43I hate you.
- 10:46The New York Times guy
- 10:48thinks it's best that we
- 10:49say or do
- 10:52bad things but in a nice way.
- 10:54That's like the Democrat way,
- 10:56do bad things but with a smile.
- 10:58Let's give a political example,
- 10:59maybe this will make more sense.
- 11:00So the Democrats,
- 11:01uh,
- 11:02They were so nice.
- 11:04When they opened up our borders.
- 11:07To millions of illegal aliens.
- 11:09Many of whom went on to murder and
- 11:11steal and destroy neighborhoods and take jobs and do
- 11:14terrible things.
- 11:14I just saw a story of,
- 11:16it was like,
- 11:16like 1700 maybe illegal aliens who were arrested in,
- 11:19I think,
- 11:20um,
- 11:20like the Houston area,
- 11:21and they went through all their crimes,
- 11:235 murders,
- 11:25170 burglaries,
- 11:2778 sex offenses.
- 11:29Like 50 against children,
- 11:3140 domestic abuses,
- 11:33500
- 11:34DUIs,
- 11:36just go down the list like,
- 11:37but,
- 11:38but it was all done with a smile.
- 11:40It's so nice and,
- 11:42and the poem on the statue says it's great,
- 11:44the poor tired huddled masses,
- 11:46we were so kind
- 11:48when we did this.
- 11:50That's the Biden way,
- 11:50like bad things but nicely.
- 11:53The Trump administration comes in and says,
- 11:55I actually think they said it quite nicely,
- 11:57but they say,
- 11:57you have to go.
- 11:59Oh,
- 12:00that's so mean,
- 12:01your tone.
- 12:04But this doesn't,
- 12:05like that's not even true what I'm saying here because like
- 12:08the real argument is,
- 12:09it's,
- 12:10it's,
- 12:10it's the right people.
- 12:11And,
- 12:11and this is what JD brought up,
- 12:12right?
- 12:13JD after that,
- 12:14the where the clip stopped.
- 12:15He said,
- 12:16let me just take a classic example.
- 12:17So the Biden administration had a very humane way of talking
- 12:22about immigration,
- 12:23about illegal immigration.
- 12:24It was very charitable.
- 12:25And some of the words that it offered
- 12:27that that to people who are coming into our country,
- 12:29I would say that it was not particularly charitable
- 12:32to the people who are living with the consequences
- 12:34of mass migration into our country.
- 12:37So at a certain level,
- 12:38what I think matters much more than perceived tone
- 12:41is actual conduct.
- 12:43Well said,
- 12:44JD Vance.
- 12:45There's a similar moment on The View as well,
- 12:47uh.
- 12:48So the questions from like a bunch of them at the same time
- 12:52was
- 12:53why
- 12:54or what the the first question from Whoopi was,
- 12:56what did black people do to this administration
- 12:59that you treat them so terribly?
- 13:01And JD was like,
- 13:02what?
- 13:02And Whoopi said,
- 13:04and she's like,
- 13:04what are you talking about?
- 13:05And they went around the table and they were all like,
- 13:06well,
- 13:07like erasing black history.
- 13:11And he's still like,
- 13:11I was like,
- 13:12what are you talking about?
- 13:13Um.
- 13:14But it was all like a tone argument.
- 13:17They're all tone,
- 13:18like the ladies didn't like that,
- 13:19they don't like the tone
- 13:21of
- 13:21this administration or whatever.
- 13:23And JD says,
- 13:24all right,
- 13:25we've taken over the police department in DC.
- 13:28Law enforcement in DC and there are half as many murders.
- 13:32Last year there were 42.
- 13:34This year at the same time period,
- 13:3520,
- 13:36and that's just murder.
- 13:37I mean that that's like
- 13:39all
- 13:39quality of life crimes are way down.
- 13:42People can go outside,
- 13:43kids can walk to school,
- 13:44it's a safe city again,
- 13:46and it's a predominantly majority black
- 13:48city.
- 13:48So these are black
- 13:49people's lives that have improved.
- 13:52So you may not like that we removed a
- 13:54black history overreach from the Black Lives Matter era
- 13:58at the Smithsonian.
- 13:59We removed like a sign that was in the Smithsonian about
- 14:01Thomas Jefferson's slaves or something.
- 14:04Is that the most important thing or do you care about
- 14:07actual black lives in DC?
- 14:11So that's a,
- 14:12that's a,
- 14:12I think that's like a perfect example of
- 14:14content and tone.
- 14:15So the tone would be,
- 14:17oh,
- 14:17you're erasing black history,
- 14:19like,
- 14:19no,
- 14:19they're not,
- 14:19but like even,
- 14:21but the content is,
- 14:22yeah,
- 14:22but we're saving black people's lives.
- 14:25Don't you care more about
- 14:27what's actually happening?
- 14:29All right,
- 14:29let me go to the Bible.
- 14:30So Jesus didn't always have a nice tone,
- 14:32we can't tell the tone,
- 14:33really what,
- 14:34what Jesus was reading,
- 14:35right?
- 14:36But
- 14:37I,
- 14:37I can't imagine him having a great tone
- 14:39when in Matthew 23,
- 14:40Jesus says to the Pharisees,
- 14:42woe to you,
- 14:43hypocrites,
- 14:44for you shut the kingdom of heaven in people's faces,
- 14:47for you neither enter yourselves nor allow those who would enter to go in.
- 14:50I don't think he said that like.
- 14:53Politely or something.
- 14:55There's 7 of those,
- 14:56by the way.
- 14:57Woes to you.
- 14:58Woe to you,
- 14:59scribes and Phar Pharisees,
- 15:01hypocrites,
- 15:02for you are like whitewashed tombs.
- 15:05Well,
- 15:05I mean,
- 15:05let me do it,
- 15:06let me do it kindly.
- 15:08I'm doing as nicely as I can.
- 15:09Woe to you.
- 15:11Scribes and Pharisees.
- 15:13Hypocrites
- 15:15For you are like whitewashed tombs.
- 15:19Which outwardly appear beautiful.
- 15:22But within are full of
- 15:24dead people's bones
- 15:26and all uncleanliness.
- 15:29So you also outwardly appear righteous to others,
- 15:32but within you you're
- 15:34full of hypocrisy and lawlessness.
- 15:39I don't think the people around were like,
- 15:40oh,
- 15:40he's got such a nice tone.
- 15:43Listen to his tone,
- 15:44wow.
- 15:46Or John 8:44,
- 15:47you are of your father,
- 15:49the devil.
- 15:51And your will is to your father's desires.
- 15:53He was a murderer from the beginning
- 15:56and does not stand in the truth because there is no truth in him.
- 15:59When he lies,
- 15:59he speaks out of his own character,
- 16:01for he is a liar and the father of lies.
- 16:03That's not very nice,
- 16:04Jesus.
- 16:06Revelation 2:20
- 16:08speaking about Jezebel,
- 16:09Behold,
- 16:09I will throw her onto a sick bed,
- 16:11and those who commit adultery
- 16:13with her.
- 16:13I will throw into great tribulation
- 16:15unless they repent of her works,
- 16:17and I will strike her children dead,
- 16:19and all the churches will know that I am he who searched mind and heart,
- 16:23and I will give to each of you according to your works.
- 16:26Yikes.
- 16:28What is,
- 16:29what is Ross Dothat from the New York Times
- 16:32think about that.
- 16:33Paul said in Galatians 1:8,
- 16:34but even if we
- 16:35or an angel from heaven should preach to you a
- 16:37gospel contrary to the one we preach to you,
- 16:39let him be accursed.
- 16:42As we've said before,
- 16:43so now I say again,
- 16:43if anyone is preaching to you a gospel contrary to the one you receive,
- 16:46let him be accursed.
- 16:47The cursed in Greek is anathema,
- 16:50and the definition is devoted to the direst of woes.
- 16:55It's not very lovely sounding.
- 16:59Paul in Galatians,
- 17:00or he called the Galatians foolish,
- 17:02he calls people liar.
- 17:05He calls false preachers ungodly
- 17:08and wretched wanderers.
- 17:10Micah said that that people hate good and love evil.
- 17:14That sounds judgmental.
- 17:20I think
- 17:22I think we need more of a strong tone.
- 17:26And
- 17:26I'm from Christians.
- 17:29And I don't
- 17:30really care if Ross Doha or whoever at the New York Times,
- 17:34they don't like it.
- 17:36We need strong tones when confronting hypocrisy.
- 17:39When guarding the truth,
- 17:42when protecting the church,
- 17:44when warning of judgment.
- 17:46And every time love requires it.
- 17:49True words
- 17:51in a strong tone
- 17:53is not bigoted.
- 17:55The truth
- 17:56demands nothing less.
- 17:59YouTube.com/apolitics by faith.
- 18:01If you're listening to this
- 18:02on podcast,
- 18:03thank you.
- 18:04You can watch it as well on our YouTube channel,
- 18:06YouTube.com.
- 18:08So if you can please subscribe,
- 18:09it'd be great.
- 18:09YouTube.com/apolitics by faith.
- 18:11Spread the word.