Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Advent Calendar-Dec 15th-Spirit Island
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin. We look the best games of all time
- 0:17according to Board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar. Fiddley, I
- 0:29believe that's how you described the game over long in Fiddley. Yeah, Fiddley,
- 0:33the last time we played it might have been the only time you played.
- 0:35And I'm not really sure. I played this game twice, one without
- 0:38you, one with you. Now. It's too bad that my wife Sam
- 0:41isn't here because she loves this game. She does love it. She's always
- 0:44asking for it, right, and the game, and we never play it.
- 0:49We should, we should play it again. We should add this to
- 0:51the list of games we're gonna play. Yeah, we have been a lot,
- 0:55right. You know what we got. I think it's a ride Legacy
- 0:58yep, Clank Legacy. What else? Uh Google Google Gong now, Spirit
- 1:03Islands Yep, there was there was something else we mentioned earlier, Mombasa.
- 1:07I think, yeah, that's right, what you mean earlier, like on
- 1:11previous day, earlier, this week, this week, that's right. I
- 1:15really wish we could play games as often as we just like sit here and
- 1:18talk about them. Honestly, I feel like all I do is podcast about
- 1:22games. But this, this game, I think is uh, it is
- 1:26worth a chat. So she's always asking you to play it. We don't
- 1:30play it. I think we should play it. We should give it another
- 1:33another toss, because I think it might be among the best co op games.
- 1:41Really explain explain that, so Pandemic suggest I say Pandemic is the best
- 1:45co op game, but it was like a co op game before there was
- 1:49any way to deal with the alpha gamer problem. Yeah, and Spirit Island
- 1:53does not succumb nearly as much to this problem because there's so much she fucking
- 1:59seven your individual mechanism does once once you get in the flow, it's not
- 2:04that bad. The thing is, you do have to pay attention to what
- 2:07your power is capable of doing. You really can't understand everyone else's bored well
- 2:14enough to make decisions for them. So it's a true co op where you
- 2:19do have to depend on everybody else in the game making the best choice because
- 2:22you can't make it for them, unlike in Pandemic, where you can you
- 2:25can just sit there and be a dickhead and tell everybody what to do.
- 2:28It doesn't work that well in Spirit Island. I guess the theory it could,
- 2:31but I've never seen it happen, so I am not so. The
- 2:36first hobby game I played that really blew me away was Pandemic, and I
- 2:40thought I was a fan of co op games, and then I realized.
- 2:44I bought Ghost Stories and sold it because't like that game. So I didn't
- 2:47like it, and I realized that Time Stories have about time stories. Time
- 2:53Stories is dog shit like that. Either. It's very popular, though,
- 2:54no, just because of the fucking the writing is awful. But I thought
- 3:00that I would be a co op game and I realized I'm not. Okay,
- 3:04I prefer competitive game. I will play a card game. I'm not
- 3:07dead set against them, but but I'm not a co op game player by
- 3:09nature. But my biggest issue with SO, I think there is a so.
- 3:17I think part of the co op thing is that you need an alpha
- 3:23player in a co op game. Why because, well, not exactly that,
- 3:30but you need to all I guess that counts you out. You need
- 3:32to all know the rules of the game, so you can make suggestions,
- 3:38and you can comment on other people's play, and you can cooperate when a
- 3:45lot of the game is obscured to you. And frankly obscured by just fiddley
- 3:51fucking rules. Then it stops being a co op game and it starts being
- 3:55a multiplayer solitaire game with a communal win condition. I don't pres feel that
- 4:00this is a fair as fair depiction and accurate prediction of the game. I
- 4:04think it's actually you. You do cooperate, but like I can't sort of
- 4:09look at your board and decide for you which exact power you should use and
- 4:12how. It's more like, here's what I can do, what can you
- 4:15do? And you're like, oh, if you're gonna do that, I'm
- 4:16gonna do this, and then you work it out with each other. Because
- 4:19the brilliant thing about Spirit Island, and this is what makes any co op
- 4:21game brilliant? Thing? Is it that the brilliant thing about Spirit Island.
- 4:26I think you'll agree this is what makes him a co op game brilliant,
- 4:28Not Spirit Island. It's hard to win, It's very hard. There was
- 4:32a trend, So there was a trend around about twenty fourteen, twenty fifteen,
- 4:40and I think, like many trends, I think he was kind of
- 4:43propelled by Tom Bassel's common trade. I think he's been I think he's been
- 4:48incredibly influential on the bold gaming world in ways we don't really think about it.
- 4:54Bo Have you been incredibly influential on the world co has some that's all
- 5:00designed a game? Yeah? Yeah, couple? Yeah? Has he really
- 5:01yeah, like what Vicious Fishes and nothing personal? Has he worked with Ube
- 5:06Rosenberg on a game? No? No, just checking, just just checking.
- 5:10But co ops starting to become easy. And there is no greater dissatisfaction
- 5:16than starting to play a co op game and realizing on your first play that
- 5:20you're gonna do it. That is crapt. Yeah, and Spirit Island's not
- 5:25like that, So I think Pandemic legacy gets over that issue. But actually
- 5:28you're just trying. You're trying to win twelve and not one. But and
- 5:32Spirit Island isn't like this. It's hard. Ghost Stories is hard Pandemic when
- 5:38you first play it, if you're not a gamer, especially, it is
- 5:42hard. It takes time to win, and I think this is vital.
- 5:46If you don't have that, then you play the game once and you're like,
- 5:49I'm fucking done with this now. So there are two things you need
- 5:54to learn in Spirit Island. One is like the basic mechanics of the board
- 5:57game. Yeah, and the other would be the mechanics of your like force
- 6:00of nature or whatever the hell it's called, and what. Once you figure
- 6:04out how your character works, it's not a big deal. And of course,
- 6:09if you know how the basic board mechanics work, you you can play
- 6:15it with the the anticipation of what's going to happen as well as like the
- 6:18challenge, the threat how likely you are to be able to survive the next
- 6:24round. And I haven't even played like through all of the scenarios and all
- 6:28these like historical appa. What do you mean? Oh yeah, okay,
- 6:33good, good, good joke. Can they even hear this? The music
- 6:39in the background? You think this is gonna carry over? Yeah? Probably?
- 6:42I mean, if not, I suppose you could do the editing work
- 6:44of like you know it. Are you gonna listen to this recording and if
- 6:47you don't hear the music, insert the wham song here? Now? No?
- 6:53Why not? Because I'm not an asshole? Would you have to pay
- 6:55for it? No? Like, do you have to pay rights for it
- 6:58when it's in the background? I mean I think do you put these on
- 7:00YouTube? No? Because YouTube can filter that shit out? Yeah? Yeah,
- 7:04no, YouTube, I have a subscription to a music provider. Yeah,
- 7:08it gives me a permanent license for the that I use, not to
- 7:12wham no to their own music library. I thought you put your podcast on
- 7:15YouTube used to didn't you YouTube? Why don't you do it anymore? Because
- 7:18it distracts from my YouTube, my actual YouTube videos admin on air, and
- 7:23I think it ruins the algorithm. Anyway you were saying, Yeah, so
- 7:26I think that this game is completely grockable. When you have like a new
- 7:30characters, spirit whatever, it takes a bit of time to get used to,
- 7:34but it's like exciting to get new powers. It's exciting. It's like
- 7:38there's like a deck building component which is very cool, and there are combos
- 7:41which are very cool, and you you get to grow more powerful over time
- 7:45and be able to exert more influence on the board. But the challenge also
- 7:48ramps up in concert, so it never feels like it's too easy. You
- 7:53never feel like you're about to win. You have to puzzle it out.
- 7:56You have to figure it out, and you have to cooperate to do it
- 7:59or it doesn't work. And I was really surprised by this game because we
- 8:03kind of bought it on a lark and then immediately after we bought it,
- 8:07it became impossible to buy and it seemed like a special fine And I do
- 8:11think it holds up and I don't play it enough and we really should add
- 8:16it to our Christmas game. What do you think about the anti colonialist elements
- 8:20of the game and that I actually think it's quite clever. So when I
- 8:24was in high school, my English teacher asked us to write, like,
- 8:28like write the Three Little Pigs from the Wolf's point of view, okay,
- 8:31which I thought was stupid. Then I got to write BeO Wolf war.
- 8:33Let's tat I could write bo Wolf from Grendel's point of view, kind of
- 8:37thing that's been done as well. Yeah, yeah, it's it's that kind
- 8:43of thing. That was both Grendel and the Three Little Pigs at the same
- 8:46time. No, no, like from the wolf's point of view, it
- 8:50is more take a Grendel was like, oh, that's the same thing.
- 8:58Yeah, what's different about these both monsters? I mean, do you think
- 9:01the big about Wolf is a monster? Just misunderstood? No, he's a
- 9:05monster much less Grendel monsters like a Grendel's like a dragon, isn't he is
- 9:09he isn't he I don't think he's really like described clearly, we don't really
- 9:13know what he is. I'll just I'll just read it now. I think
- 9:16he's a monster. I'll read a night Verily. He had a coat of
- 9:20black, a beard black flecked with gray. Verily. He came from the
- 9:26Isle of the Newest Jerseys. I didn't know you could read Middle English band
- 9:31I mean, sorry, Old English. His name was Stephen Syrek and he
- 9:37had the smallest winky in Christendom. That's that's direct from Beowolf. You're you're
- 9:43you're a gentleman and a scholar. Ben I am in like in so many
- 9:48ways. So yeah, I'm actually I'm looking for let's see, can I
- 9:52find the original Beowolf in Old English? This is this is really good content,
- 9:58great content. Can you read Old English live on the fucking radio?
- 10:03Well, I'm trying to find something that isn't a fucking English transition. Here
- 10:09we go, Project Gutenberg. They've got a lot of ship projects that's usually
- 10:13like the real thing, you know that's owned by Star of Three Men and
- 10:16a Baby and Police Academy. Steve Guttenberg. I don't think that's true.
- 10:20It refers to project I think it refers to a different Gutenberg. It's a
- 10:24fucking translation low the spear Dane's glory through splendid achievements, the fulk King's former
- 10:31fame. We have heard of how princes displayed then their prowess in battle off
- 10:37chilled the chefing from I can't fucking read anymore because of my eyesight, from
- 10:41scathers and numbers from many of people, their mead benches tore since first he
- 10:46found him friendless and wretched? How much of this you're gonna read? The
- 10:48Earl had had terror comfort he got for it, waxedneath the welkin world on
- 10:54our gain, until all his neighbors or sea were compelled to bow who is
- 11:01and bring him their tribute. It's super interesting, an excellent I'm glad it's
- 11:05going on this long. That should have been the line that was good cooning.
- 11:09Who makes Steve Kutberg a star? OOI do oo do? Number five
- 11:18is alive? Then five is a lot Ali Sheedy Steve Gutenberg? What a
- 11:22dream pair anyway? So that seeing they had like nude scenes in movies,
- 11:26why don't they do that anymore? Kids? Film? Do you know who
- 11:28else is? In in that movie who would go on to be a great
- 11:31star? Who's the bad guy in the movie. I can't remember. Who's
- 11:35the other person who goes on to be a great Sarah Jessica Parker, she's
- 11:37in that movie. She smuggles number five out of the fucking I don't even
- 11:43remember, not even a little bit anyway. So yeah, so what do
- 11:46you like? Do you like the anti colonialist element? I mean, I
- 11:50don't really feel it as such, Like I said, I think it's just
- 11:52like a clever take. What if we did an anti settlers And that's kind
- 11:56of what it is, right, it's anti settlers, And I don't do
- 12:00you think there's like a political valence to it, Ben Well, I think
- 12:03people like to leverage your political valence to make themselves look good on the medias
- 12:07of socials. I don't. I don't think that it really like it plays
- 12:13this up very much, do you know? I think I think it's there,
- 12:16but the game does not make a big deal out of it. You
- 12:18know, do you like playing Watwig Gerda and Geir Dagham Lethalinga selling free Boden
- 12:31off shield shifting Scathena Priata Monaga. Thank you for listening. You can support
- 12:39the show at Patreon dot com, forward slash five g f D, and
- 12:43join the discord by going to five g f d dot com. Have a
- 12:46very merry Christmas. Stuff