Latest / The Mental Health Evolution / Ep 59: High-Potency Cannabis and the Developing Brain with Libby Stuyt
Transcript
- 0:00(Transcribed by TurboScribe. Go Unlimited to remove this message.) This podcast is part of the Frederick Podcast
- 0:02Network.
- 0:03Learn more at listenfrederick.com.
- 0:05Welcome to Mental Health Evolution, a podcast about
- 0:08what's changing in mental health and why it
- 0:11matters.
- 0:12I'm your host, Rachel Harrison, inviting you into
- 0:15honest conversations with people from all perspectives in
- 0:18the field, clinicians, tech founders, investors, insurance companies,
- 0:22and all the folks in between.
- 0:24Let's explore what's working, what's not, and what's
- 0:27next.
- 0:33Welcome to the Mental Health Evolution podcast.
- 0:37I am so excited to share with you
- 0:40today this conversation with Dr. Libby Stout.
- 0:43The first time I had Dr. Stout on
- 0:46my podcast, we talked all about ear acupuncture
- 0:49to treat addiction, and it was a very
- 0:51fascinating conversation.
- 0:53But recently, there have been articles that have
- 0:55been coming out and warnings about the impact
- 0:58of THC on the developing brain.
- 1:01A lot of articles specifically talk about adolescents,
- 1:05but as Libby brought up today in the
- 1:07conversation, this also applies to developing fetuses.
- 1:11There's a couple really interesting points in here
- 1:14about how the cannabis of today is different
- 1:18than the cannabis of the 60s through 80s,
- 1:21and what she is seeing in terms of
- 1:25medical symptoms as well as mental health symptoms
- 1:29in people that are using cannabis, because everything
- 1:33has changed.
- 1:34And it is now a pretty big industry,
- 1:37and opening up the doors to saying that
- 1:40it's legal has maybe made it more accessible
- 1:44to young people.
- 1:45And the impact on their brain is very
- 1:47different than the impact on an adult brain.
- 1:51So with that, listen in.
- 1:53I hope you will enjoy this conversation as
- 1:57much as I did.
- 1:58I definitely learned some interesting takeaways, and hopefully
- 2:01it gives you some food for thought.
- 2:04Welcome back to the Mental Evolution podcast, where
- 2:08we talk about how the landscape is rapidly
- 2:11evolving in the mental health industry.
- 2:13Today, we are welcoming back a guest many
- 2:16of you may remember from our previous podcast,
- 2:19the mental health entrepreneur.
- 2:20Dr. Libby Stout is a board-certified psychiatrist
- 2:24and senior instructor at the University of Colorado
- 2:27Health Science Center.
- 2:29She also is a trainer for the People's
- 2:31Organization for Community Acupuncture.
- 2:34When she joined us before, we had a
- 2:36fascinating conversation about the use of acupuncture in
- 2:40addiction treatment.
- 2:41We will link that previous episode in the
- 2:44show notes, so you can listen to that
- 2:46one as well if you are interested.
- 2:48Today, we're going in a different direction.
- 2:50Dr. Stout has spent over three decades working
- 2:53in Colorado with people who have co-occurring
- 2:56mental illness and substance use disorder.
- 2:58And she has been watching something unfold in
- 3:01real time that she says not enough people
- 3:03are talking about.
- 3:04And that is the mental health consequences of
- 3:06today's high-potency cannabis on young people.
- 3:10Colorado was one of the first states to
- 3:12legalize recreational marijuana, which means Dr. Stout has
- 3:15had a longer window than most to see
- 3:18what happens in a community when cannabis becomes
- 3:20normalized, commercialized, and increasingly potent.
- 3:25She has become one of the most knowledgeable
- 3:26voices in the country about what this means
- 3:28for adolescents, and we are grateful to have
- 3:32her back.
- 3:33Welcome, Dr. Stout.
- 3:35Thank you.
- 3:35I'm really glad that you're bringing up this
- 3:38conversation.
- 3:39It's really important.
- 3:40Definitely.
- 3:41All right.
- 3:42Well, let's go ahead and just dive in.
- 3:45Since this show is all about what's happening
- 3:48in the mental health industry, I would love
- 3:51to hear kind of an update.
- 3:53What are you seeing in mental health treatment
- 3:55in regard to cannabis?
- 3:57Some have said it's a treatment for anxiety
- 4:00and PTSD.
- 4:02Some have viewed it as a harmful substance.
- 4:05What are the current trends that you are
- 4:07seeing?
- 4:08Well, it really depends on the population you're
- 4:11talking about.
- 4:12I think the worst harms are for anyone
- 4:15with a developing brain.
- 4:18That would include babies in utero, so mothers
- 4:21using cannabis can really affect their child, and
- 4:25then going all the way up until mid
- 4:27-20s, because your brain is still developing, until
- 4:30mid-20s.
- 4:31There's a great deal of research showing that
- 4:34cannabis can be very detrimental to the developing
- 4:37brain.
- 4:38So most recommendations are that if you are
- 4:42going to use cannabis, then you should wait
- 4:44until you're like mid-20s before you even
- 4:47start, and then you're going to reduce a
- 4:50lot of the potential risk factors, problems that
- 4:55are associated with many mental health conditions.
- 4:58It doesn't eliminate them, though.
- 5:00I mean, people are still very susceptible to
- 5:02this, and it depends on how much they're
- 5:07using, what they're using.
- 5:09And that's part of the problem is that
- 5:11the general public has not really been educated
- 5:17on this.
- 5:18They don't know about marijuana.
- 5:23They just, you know, a lot of people
- 5:24are thinking about the marijuana of the 60s
- 5:26and 70s.
- 5:27They might have used then, and it was
- 5:29just something that helped them chill out and
- 5:31have the munchies.
- 5:34But the marijuana of today is very, very
- 5:40different.
- 5:41It has dramatically increased in potency, and that's
- 5:46what we're dealing with.
- 5:48So the higher the potency, the higher the
- 5:51risks for developing addictions.
- 5:56The high-potency products are extremely addicting, whereas,
- 6:00you know, the old-time marijuana wasn't really
- 6:02considered addicting.
- 6:03But this stuff is extremely addicting, and once
- 6:06people are using it regularly, it's very difficult
- 6:09to quit.
- 6:12So can you talk a little bit about
- 6:14those potency differences?
- 6:16I mean, I can just keep going on
- 6:17and on.
- 6:19I'm curious, like, when you talk about the,
- 6:23in the past, sort of what the levels
- 6:26were and versus now, what, can you give
- 6:30us, kind of, quantify some of those differences?
- 6:39Sure.
- 6:41So back in the maybe 60s through 80s,
- 6:45the highest potency of THC in the plant
- 6:49was 2% to 3%.
- 6:55And of course, it's been around for centuries,
- 6:58and that was all really the content of
- 7:02THC.
- 7:02However, once we got things legalized, like, you
- 7:08know, the first states that legalized medical marijuana,
- 7:11and I think that was California, and then
- 7:14we legalized recreational marijuana, that was, the first
- 7:18state was Colorado, we started seeing significant increase
- 7:23in potency.
- 7:24So the people in the industry who were
- 7:27doing the plants did a lot of genetic
- 7:29modification of the plants to increase the production
- 7:33of THC.
- 7:35So they made it where the plant spent
- 7:37all of its energy making THC, which then
- 7:40it couldn't really make the other components like
- 7:42CBD very well.
- 7:44And so CBD, which is, you know, considered
- 7:47possibly something that might be helpful, has really
- 7:52never increased.
- 7:53And so it's stayed relatively level in terms
- 7:57of its content in the plant, and the
- 7:59THC is dramatically increased.
- 8:02And so now, we have an average of
- 8:06THC in the plant up to 20%, depends
- 8:09on where you are in the country.
- 8:12But we have plants that they say go
- 8:14up to 30%.
- 8:15And then we have the concentrates.
- 8:19And the concentrates didn't really hit the market
- 8:22until 2010.
- 8:25And it's been since then, we're seeing more
- 8:27and more problems.
- 8:29And that's when they started using things like
- 8:32butane and propane and carbon dioxide to isolate
- 8:37THC from the plant material, and then they
- 8:43can make it ultra concentrated.
- 8:45And they make these products like different names,
- 8:49wax, chatter.
- 8:51These are very high concentrated products that then
- 8:55people smoke with blow torches.
- 8:57I mean, basically, you put a tiny little
- 8:59piece of this on the head of a
- 9:01nail, and you heat it to very high
- 9:03intensity and suck in the vapors, and then
- 9:07you're getting very high potency THC.
- 9:10And some of these go all the way
- 9:11up to 90.
- 9:12So there's even crystalline THC 99.9%
- 9:16pure, that's available.
- 9:19And many of these things are available in
- 9:22the medical market.
- 9:24And of course, there's been no studies demonstrating
- 9:27these are helpful for anything medical, but they're
- 9:31in the medical market.
- 9:32And so people believe that they must be
- 9:36safe, they must be healthy, they must be
- 9:38good for you.
- 9:39And, you know, this includes things like edibles,
- 9:42this includes things like drinks, because there has
- 9:46been attempts to put caps on things in
- 9:50terms of how much milligram dose of TA
- 9:54is available.
- 9:56Many places have not done that.
- 9:57And it really hasn't helped much.
- 9:59And then the other problem we have is
- 10:01not just the cannabis industry, the marijuana industry,
- 10:05but it's also the hemp.
- 10:07And so that has been a really new
- 10:10emerging problem because of the Farm Bill.
- 10:13So the Farm Bill back in 2018, actually
- 10:16legalized hemp nationwide.
- 10:19And it was supposed to be that you
- 10:22could only have delta 9 THC, less than
- 10:260.3% by dry weight.
- 10:29But the industry figured out how to get
- 10:31around all that, because they found out that,
- 10:34you know, a lot of people are growing
- 10:35hemp for the CBD, but they found if
- 10:38they take CBD, and they heat it and
- 10:41add some acid, they can turn it into
- 10:45THC.
- 10:46And so that's how we've developed delta 8,
- 10:52delta 10 THC acetate called intoxicating hemp products
- 10:58that are just as devastating.
- 11:00So any THC is a problem in the
- 11:05developing brain.
- 11:06And so many states have actually decided to
- 11:10make these products illegal, intoxicating hemp products, which
- 11:15then, you know, that's still a lot of
- 11:17CBD because that's not an intoxicating product.
- 11:19But all the other ones have been made
- 11:22illegal.
- 11:23And that has varied by state.
- 11:25I mean, there are many states where you
- 11:27still can get them in gas stations, convenience
- 11:31stores, kids can easily get them, and kids
- 11:34are having significant problems from these.
- 11:37And they're mostly mental health issues, you know,
- 11:40where people become psychotic, they become suicidal, they
- 11:45have worsening depression, they have severe anxiety, panic
- 11:49attacks.
- 11:50And kids are ending up in the emergency
- 11:51room with these.
- 11:54And that's really problematic.
- 11:57Yeah, it is.
- 11:58And I love this recent article, actually, that
- 12:01came out this month, and we will attach
- 12:03it in the show notes for our listeners,
- 12:06but really flagging some of these concerns for
- 12:09adolescents specifically.
- 12:12And I love that you're identifying the developing
- 12:14brain in a couple of ways, both for
- 12:17a developing fetus as well as adolescents.
- 12:20That makes a lot of sense to me
- 12:21when we look at marijuana's impact on a
- 12:24developing brain and some of these higher concentrate,
- 12:27higher, actually chemically induced strains, really, that we're
- 12:32talking about here.
- 12:33What are some of the things that you're
- 12:36seeing in terms of patterns?
- 12:38I hear a lot of teens, especially, you
- 12:41know, the phrasing out there is like, hey,
- 12:43at least this is all natural.
- 12:45Hey, it's better than drinking.
- 12:47These are all things that I think are
- 12:49commonly put out on social media or whatnot
- 12:53that teens are saying to support their cause.
- 12:56What would you say to all of that?
- 12:58Yep.
- 12:59I mean, that that is a significant problem.
- 13:02The perception of harm is significantly reduced in
- 13:06young people.
- 13:08And I basically say that is on the
- 13:11hands of the industry and our government, which
- 13:14basically allowed the industry to heavily market and
- 13:19advertise these substances as medicine.
- 13:22And so that's what we saw in Colorado
- 13:24before we legalized recreational.
- 13:27We had medical and they were touting it
- 13:31for everything.
- 13:32I mean, they're saying it helps everything.
- 13:34Most states have multiple indications for medical marijuana
- 13:37where there's no research behind it or the
- 13:41research doesn't support it.
- 13:42A good example is post-traumatic stress disorder.
- 13:45That is something that multiple people think is
- 13:49very helpful.
- 13:51And I'm sure you can talk to many
- 13:53veterans who say that it's been a godsend
- 13:56for them, that it really helped them.
- 13:59However, research doesn't support that.
- 14:02So there has been no well-designed, long
- 14:06-term study supporting the use of cannabis for
- 14:10PTSD, because what they're finding is it just
- 14:12makes people worse.
- 14:13Yes, it seems to work initially.
- 14:16Yeah, it does, because what it does is
- 14:19it numbs people.
- 14:20So people who are having symptoms of PTSD,
- 14:24like intrusive thoughts or hallucinations or severe delusions
- 14:29that that, you know, things are happening and
- 14:32they're very scared, easily triggered, they use marijuana,
- 14:35especially the high potency products.
- 14:37And yes, they're numb.
- 14:39And so it takes away all of those
- 14:41symptoms.
- 14:42And so they feel much better.
- 14:44Problem is, in order to keep those symptoms
- 14:47at bay, the person has to use every
- 14:50day, if not all day long.
- 14:52And then that sets them up for cannabis
- 14:56use disorder, which is basically addiction to cannabis.
- 14:59And so what they find is, you know,
- 15:01they're using regularly and then they try to
- 15:04stop and they're having really bad withdrawal.
- 15:08But they think the withdrawal is really just
- 15:10their symptoms coming back and that the medicine
- 15:12has worn off.
- 15:13So they have to keep taking the medicine.
- 15:15And this becomes very like a vicious cycle.
- 15:20And then they have increased problems.
- 15:23So then they start developing problems with suicidal
- 15:26ideation or suicide attempts or psychotic symptoms.
- 15:31So if you look at the literature, the
- 15:33scientific literature, organizations like the Department of Defense
- 15:37and the Department of Veterans Affairs have come
- 15:40out with their recommendations for people treating post
- 15:43-traumatic stress disorder.
- 15:45And they recommend totally against using any cannabis
- 15:49or any cannabinoid products because they have seen
- 15:52the problem.
- 15:53And most of the studies show that the
- 15:55people just get worse in the long run.
- 15:58And so that is something I think people
- 16:00need to know.
- 16:02And I saw that myself all the time
- 16:04in the treatment program I was running because
- 16:07kind of the biggest diagnosis we ever saw
- 16:10was complex post-traumatic stress disorder with substance
- 16:14use engaged in that.
- 16:17So the kids are definitely getting these messages
- 16:22that, oh, it's good for you.
- 16:23It's good.
- 16:24It will help you.
- 16:24And so they're very attracted to using it.
- 16:28And even though some people do think, well,
- 16:32if you legalize it, that'll take away the
- 16:35think that this is something they could do
- 16:37to get away with it.
- 16:38That doesn't seem to do anything.
- 16:40I mean, the legalization has made it seem
- 16:43safer.
- 16:44And that's one of my concerns about this
- 16:47recent attempt to reschedule medical marijuana from a
- 16:53Schedule 1 to a Schedule 3.
- 16:55And that will go further in this to
- 16:59make people think, oh, there's nothing wrong with
- 17:01it.
- 17:01It's really good.
- 17:02It's healthy.
- 17:03And it isn't.
- 17:05Yeah.
- 17:06And I just think about how really the
- 17:08doors have been so opened.
- 17:11Like now you have this whole industry, right,
- 17:14around medical and recreational marijuana.
- 17:18And there's a marketing component to that, right,
- 17:24of going in.
- 17:25And I mean, you can go into these
- 17:27places and do just what you want it
- 17:30for.
- 17:31And these are what's recommended if you're of
- 17:34a legal age to do it.
- 17:36And yeah, they're now in the business of
- 17:39wanting to sell you something which is a
- 17:42different position than like a doctor, right.
- 17:46Or somebody kind of saying this is what
- 17:48it would be potentially good for.
- 17:52I don't know.
- 17:52It seems like there's no going back.
- 17:54So how do we help?
- 17:57I guess that's my question.
- 18:00Yeah, no, I don't think that we can
- 18:02go back.
- 18:03I do think that the government could put
- 18:05in much stricter regulations and that would have
- 18:11to be state by state.
- 18:12The states have, I think, very poor regulations.
- 18:17And I really do think the potency cap,
- 18:20there should be a cap on the amount
- 18:22that people can take at any one time,
- 18:25the potency of the THC in the product.
- 18:29But that has been something the industry has
- 18:32fought tooth and nail.
- 18:34They really are not supporting that.
- 18:37And of course, many legislators do get money
- 18:40from the cannabis industry.
- 18:42And the hemp industry.
- 18:44And they have worked very hard to keep
- 18:47these organizations still going.
- 18:50I see these companies as really addiction for
- 18:54profit companies because they know their product is
- 18:57extremely addicting.
- 18:58However, they have not acknowledged that.
- 19:03I mean, many times I say, oh, these
- 19:05things are not addicting at all.
- 19:07And, you know, if you're thinking back to
- 19:08the old time marijuana, well, yeah, it wasn't
- 19:12that physiologically addicting, but now it is.
- 19:15And, you know, we're seeing more and more
- 19:18health consequences, not just mental health, but, you
- 19:21know, effects that make sense because, you know,
- 19:24we know these things about tobacco.
- 19:25If you're smoking tobacco for years and years,
- 19:28you have cardiac problems, you have lung problems.
- 19:30We're starting to see those things with chronic
- 19:33use of marijuana.
- 19:35But one of the really big concerning ones
- 19:38is this cannabinoid hyperemesis syndrome.
- 19:41And this is something that is relatively new.
- 19:46I mean, it's been around for centuries.
- 19:48I've actually seen reports of it in the
- 19:50ancient literature, but it was extremely rare.
- 19:54And what that is, is this idiosyncratic reaction
- 19:57to marijuana because marijuana is supposed to help
- 20:01with nausea and vomiting.
- 20:03So, you know, that's one of the FDA
- 20:05approved indications for the cannabinoids that have been
- 20:09pharmaceutically created, like dronabinol, for people with have
- 20:14chemotherapy induced nausea and vomiting.
- 20:17However, what we're seeing, and this is especially
- 20:20with the high potency products that people are
- 20:22using regularly, the exact opposite where people are
- 20:26having extreme abdominal pain, nausea and cyclical vomiting
- 20:32that they cannot stop.
- 20:34So it's actually been coined the term scrommeting,
- 20:38because when people come into the emergency room,
- 20:41they tend to be screaming and vomiting because
- 20:43they're in so much pain and they're vomiting
- 20:45excessively.
- 20:47And this used to be, like I said,
- 20:50extremely rare.
- 20:50It happened occasionally.
- 20:52Now it is flooding emergency rooms.
- 20:54Most emergency room doctors I talk to say
- 20:58that they're seeing at least one every shift.
- 21:01And this is something that has taken a
- 21:04while for people to recognize.
- 21:06So even health care professionals, physicians are not
- 21:09recognizing this right away and they're not diagnosing
- 21:12it.
- 21:13And so we just recently got finally an
- 21:17ICD-10 code for cannabinoid hyperemesis syndrome.
- 21:21And the research is showing that there is
- 21:23dramatic increase in these diagnoses because people are
- 21:27finally looking at it and thinking about it.
- 21:31And, you know, when I work with patients
- 21:33that have this, it's very hard to convince
- 21:36them that their, quote, medicine could be doing
- 21:40that to them.
- 21:41And so they don't accept it.
- 21:43They don't really want to know that that's
- 21:46the case.
- 21:47But because they keep doing it, this has
- 21:51actually killed people.
- 21:53And the marijuana industry has always said that,
- 21:55you know, one of the things good about
- 21:57marijuana, different from alcohol, is that it can't
- 22:01kill you.
- 22:02Well, yeah, it can.
- 22:04I mean, it doesn't kill you with the
- 22:05overdose.
- 22:06However, in people like this who have this,
- 22:09if you vomit enough to get rid of
- 22:12all your electrolytes, you actually can kill your
- 22:15kidneys and die from that, or you can
- 22:18have a heart attack and die from that.
- 22:20And so there have been more and more
- 22:22people dying from cannabinoid hyperemesis syndrome.
- 22:26And the simple solution is to stop using
- 22:29cannabis.
- 22:30And that's what people have a really hard
- 22:32time understanding.
- 22:33And when I work with people who have
- 22:35this, you know, and I finally convince them
- 22:38that it is the cannabis causing it, well,
- 22:41then they can't quit because the withdrawal is
- 22:43so uncomfortable.
- 22:45And we don't really currently have anything available
- 22:48for cannabis withdrawal.
- 22:50You know, there are companies working on medications
- 22:52to help with this, but they're still in
- 22:55phase two, phase three trials.
- 22:57And so we're kind of away from that.
- 23:00And what I've found, the only thing that
- 23:02really helps somebody who really can't quit is
- 23:05getting into an inpatient treatment program where they
- 23:08can be isolated from the drug.
- 23:10It is really, really difficult.
- 23:13And then another interesting thing is I just
- 23:16saw a case report.
- 23:18This is a new case report on a
- 23:2015 year old who developed Warnake syndrome from
- 23:25cannabinoid hyperemesis syndrome.
- 23:28And that that's very troubling.
- 23:30And it made me think, how many of
- 23:33these have people been missing?
- 23:35Because I don't know if you know anything
- 23:37about Warnake, but Warnake-Korsakoff is a syndrome
- 23:40that happens mostly in very severe alcohol dependence.
- 23:46So people who are heavy, heavy drinkers and
- 23:48they don't quit and they drink for years
- 23:50and years, what happens is they develop this
- 23:53syndrome where they become confused.
- 23:57They develop a really bad nystagmus where their
- 24:00eyes are moving back and forth and they
- 24:02could be delirious.
- 24:03I mean, it's really a problem cognitively.
- 24:07And that is usually because the person is
- 24:10drinking so much, they're not eating properly and
- 24:13they haven't, they don't have enough vitamins.
- 24:16So the biggest problem is thiamine.
- 24:18So they lack thiamine.
- 24:20And I've actually treated people like this with
- 24:23alcohol induced Warnake's.
- 24:25And it's amazing when you give people thiamine,
- 24:28how you can reverse it.
- 24:30If it's not gone too far, you can
- 24:32reverse it pretty quickly.
- 24:34So this is now showing that these are
- 24:36young people.
- 24:37This is a young person who has, you
- 24:40know, been using marijuana, developing cannabinoid hyperemesis syndrome,
- 24:45where so somebody is vomiting all the time,
- 24:47they can't eat.
- 24:48And so developing this kind of syndrome that
- 24:52is usually happening only in very old people
- 24:55with alcohol problems.
- 24:57So that is just something people need to
- 25:00be paying attention to.
- 25:02The other place you can see Warnake's in
- 25:04the mental health field is people with severe
- 25:07eating disorders.
- 25:08So people who have severe anorexia and are
- 25:11not eating anything, they could end up having
- 25:14this as well.
- 25:15Gotcha.
- 25:16Well, this has been very enlightening.
- 25:19I think there are so many implications, certainly
- 25:22for substance abuse treatment and for folks that
- 25:26are working with adolescent populations.
- 25:29If you had something to just leave our
- 25:32listeners with a final thought or encouragement or
- 25:37action step, what would that be, Dr. Stout?
- 25:40Well, I think the biggest thing is going
- 25:41to be with more education.
- 25:43There are many organizations working, trying to educate
- 25:46young people and their parents and trusted adults,
- 25:51many organizations.
- 25:52One I work with is called One Chance
- 25:54to Grow Up.
- 25:55They do an awesome job.
- 25:57Johnny's Ambassadors do a good job.
- 26:00Every Brain Matters does a good job.
- 26:02These are all about educating people about the
- 26:04problems with cannabis, especially the brain.
- 26:07And I think that if more people were
- 26:11aware of this, then we might, because I
- 26:14do think this is helping.
- 26:16I think a lot of the education that
- 26:19is happening now has helped decrease youth use.
- 26:24So most of the studies like Healthy Kids
- 26:27in Colorado and different studies around the country
- 26:30are showing that less and less kids are
- 26:33using drugs.
- 26:34The one place that kind of changes is
- 26:37with vaping.
- 26:39Vaping is still a big problem.
- 26:42And of course, you can vape nicotine, you
- 26:44can vape THC, you can vape pretty much
- 26:46everything.
- 26:48And another problem are the edibles.
- 26:51But I do think that the more we
- 26:54educate people, the better it's going to be.
- 26:57I really like this.
- 26:58Another organization says educate before age eight.
- 27:02And I agree with that completely because I've
- 27:05seen so many young people that by the
- 27:07age of nine are already engaged in using
- 27:10substances.
- 27:11And it usually is because their parents are
- 27:14using or the people they're living with are
- 27:16using.
- 27:17And they're getting the message that this is
- 27:20OK to do.
- 27:21And we really want to see if we
- 27:24can't change that.
- 27:25And then we need treatment that, you know,
- 27:29this is why I think the problems like
- 27:31harm reduction have not been working very well.
- 27:35They're not working as intended.
- 27:37I mean, there is a good side to
- 27:39harm reduction where I think where we supply
- 27:41needles and clean needles, clean syringes, that kind
- 27:45of thing, because that has really helped reduce
- 27:48public health problems like diseases.
- 27:51Many people think that encourages people to use.
- 27:53I don't think so, because people can use
- 27:55no matter what.
- 27:57And if they have dirty needles, they're going
- 27:59to use dirty needles.
- 28:01So it's not encouraging people to use.
- 28:04But what the problem with harm reduction is
- 28:06they don't go far enough to do things
- 28:08to try and get people into treatment.
- 28:13And so there was a recent Atlantic Monthly
- 28:15article talking about how harm reduction doesn't seem
- 28:19to be working and how all these problems
- 28:21and shouldn't seem to be more that we
- 28:24need to be do more coercive treatment, like
- 28:27coerce people into treatment.
- 28:29And in my experience, that doesn't work.
- 28:31I have never been able to get somebody
- 28:34to accept treatment who was forced to go.
- 28:37What I think works is you offer people
- 28:39alternatives.
- 28:41And like the treatment program that I ran
- 28:44for 20 years before they closed it was
- 28:48this program where people, you know, they would
- 28:52come in and tell me, oh, they made
- 28:53me come here.
- 28:54And I said, no, I think the judge
- 28:56actually said, go to jail or you could
- 28:59go to treatment.
- 28:59And you chose treatment.
- 29:01And so you're actually here voluntarily and you
- 29:03can leave at any time.
- 29:05And so we had really good success.
- 29:07We have many, many people doing really well
- 29:11in that form of offering treatment.
- 29:14But the other thing that I really think
- 29:17helps, and I talked about this on the
- 29:19last podcast when I was there, was the
- 29:21ear acupuncture.
- 29:23That is something that really has shown in
- 29:26research to increase retention and participation.
- 29:30And so I think that harm reduction centers,
- 29:33in addition to handing out clean supplies, should
- 29:37offer ear acupuncture treatment where these people then
- 29:41can feel like it because it does help
- 29:43with withdrawal symptoms.
- 29:44It does help people calm down and relax.
- 29:48And people then start feeling better about, well,
- 29:51maybe I can go to treatment.
- 29:53I've seen it happen because I was working
- 29:55with a harm reduction program in Southern Colorado.