Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Testing the Official Story: Investigating a Killing in the Amazon" with Gisela Pérez de Acha
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to a stage talk titled Testing
- 0:03the Official Story, Investigating a Killing in
- 0:06the Amazon. Open source researcher, trainer and
- 0:09Bellingcat volunteer community member Gisela
- 0:11Perez da Acha joined us this week. She unpacked
- 0:15her investigation into the killing of an indigenous
- 0:18leader by Brazilian military police, from the
- 0:21original police statements suggesting the young
- 0:23man was armed to the literal smoking gun evidence
- 0:27found by Gisela's team. that disputed this official
- 0:30story. You can find links to all of the resources
- 0:33mentioned in the talk in the podcast description.
- 0:37This talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Maher, on
- 0:39Thursday the 12th of November, 2026, in the Bellingcat
- 0:43Discord server. Thank you so much, everybody,
- 0:52for joining. Welcome, everyone. Today we're going
- 0:56to be talking about how digital evidence can
- 0:58be used to scrutinise official accounts of events.
- 1:01I'm delighted to be joined by Gisela Perez de
- 1:04Ache. Gisela is an investigative journalist,
- 1:07a Bellingcat volunteer community member, and
- 1:09the founder and CEO of FactFinder, an online
- 1:12OSINT school. She also co -created the first
- 1:15multidisciplinary OSINT investigative reporting
- 1:18course at a US university at UC Berkeley, alongside
- 1:23Alexa Koenig, who we've had before on this podcast.
- 1:27Do go listen to that episode. I'll link it in
- 1:29the chat in a second. and David Barth, though.
- 1:33Today, Gisela is going to take us through an
- 1:34investigation into the killing of Isaac Tembe,
- 1:37a 24 -year -old leader of the Tembe indigenous
- 1:40people in the Brazilian Amazon, who was shot
- 1:42dead by military police in February 2021. The
- 1:46police claimed they had opened fire in self -defense,
- 1:49but that account was disputed by the Tembe community,
- 1:52and Gisela and her team set out to examine what
- 1:55had happened using open source records. Zella
- 1:58described what she plans to go through today
- 1:59as the most simple and underrated OSINT techniques
- 2:02to solve a homicide. Sometimes basic techniques
- 2:06and creative thinking can help reveal public
- 2:08information buried online. In fact, we had a
- 2:11talk about that only a couple of weeks ago on
- 2:14a cold case murder with our resident researcher,
- 2:18Peter, and you can listen back to that on our
- 2:21podcast as well. We'll walk through how the investigation
- 2:24unfolded, how her team found and verified that
- 2:26evidence and what this case tells us about the
- 2:28role of open source research in investigating
- 2:31incidents involving an institutional body. During
- 2:34the talk, please place your questions in the
- 2:37chat, accessible on the right hand corner of
- 2:39your screen, so we can ask them during the Q
- 2:42&A section. But please remember that this is
- 2:44being audio recorded for the podcast, so if you
- 2:47don't want me to mention your username, Please
- 2:50add that as a note in your question and I will
- 2:53endeavor not to do it. Gisella, thanks so much
- 2:56for talking to us today. Tell us a little about
- 2:59how you first became involved in this case and
- 3:01what the investigation involved. Thank you so
- 3:05much for having me. It's always such a pleasure
- 3:08to be here with the Bellingcat folks. I'm always
- 3:12very, very grateful. So this story came about
- 3:16because we got a grant. by from the Pulitzer
- 3:19Center, the Pulitzer Center for Investigative
- 3:21Reporting. And they gave us a grant to work in
- 3:28the Brazilian Amazon. So our idea was to find
- 3:31a story. There's so much open source geographic
- 3:36information data in the Brazilian Amazon. Brazilians
- 3:39are so good at using OSINT to analyze and report
- 3:45on the Amazon. that our idea was sort of like
- 3:48to take all of that open source data, as well
- 3:51as all the killings of Indigenous leaders in
- 3:54the region, to try to find where violence and
- 3:59land theft could converge. So basically, Isaac
- 4:04was killed in 2021 by the military police. He
- 4:07was a beloved 24 -year -old Indigenous leader,
- 4:11like you said, of the Tembe tribe. And the official
- 4:15version is that the Tembe's tribe was
- 4:19out hunting when a ranch hand heard one of their
- 4:25shots from their shotgun and immediately alerted
- 4:28the military police. The military police is this
- 4:31really archaic institution that Brazilians have
- 4:34inherited from the dictatorship, the military
- 4:37dictatorship. And what were they doing responding
- 4:41to this call? an accountability question in and
- 4:46of itself. But they went to the area and they
- 4:51said that as soon as they came into the ranch,
- 4:54the Tambe started shooting at them as they ran
- 4:57from different directions. And they shot back
- 5:00in self -defense, killing Isaac. When they found
- 5:04him, they found him, they did a sweep of the
- 5:06area, the military police did a sweep of the
- 5:08area. They found him face down with a Taurus
- 5:12handgun. Next to his body the Taurus handgun
- 5:15that according to them was used to shoot at them
- 5:18In this sort of like they they describe it sort
- 5:22of like as an ambush, right? so Osen actually
- 5:26revealed that this wasn't true and that the military
- 5:29police lied about what happened that day and
- 5:32I'm gonna explain why I Think a lot of what I
- 5:36do as a journalist, and this is not very Bellingcatty,
- 5:42is mix open sources with closed sources. To me,
- 5:46that's where the real magic happens. And the
- 5:49real privilege that I have as a journalist is
- 5:51to actually mix these two things. And what I
- 5:55mean by that is that I don't think that, I don't
- 5:59think that we could have necessarily solved this
- 6:03without the court cases. court cases are open
- 6:08source once they have been, how do we say, um,
- 6:13resolved or once, you know, a resolution has
- 6:16been sort of like dictated by a judge. But in
- 6:19this case, it was closed source and one of our
- 6:22sources gave the court records to us. So just
- 6:27to situate sort of like what the court records
- 6:30say and let's go back in time. It's February
- 6:3412th of 2021, and Isaac Tembe and other six young
- 6:41Tembe men canoe across the river. So there's
- 6:45basically, their village is called the Jacare
- 6:47Indigenous Village, and there's a really big
- 6:50river, the Guam River, a really big, really important
- 6:53river in the Amazon. They canoed across the river.
- 6:56to hunt capybara, which probably rings a bell
- 7:00for a lot of folks here. Capybara is a really
- 7:02big rodent. It's a really prized hunting meat.
- 7:07It's really prized meat. And also like, I think
- 7:10it's, this is really important because it's not
- 7:14that hunting for the Tempe indigenous tribe,
- 7:18it's not a sport. It's not like in the US or
- 7:20in Europe where you go out to hunt because it's,
- 7:23I don't know, I guess fun. I'm a vegetarian,
- 7:27so it's hard for me to relate to hunting as fun,
- 7:30but you know what I mean. It's like a general
- 7:32sport. And capybaras are also like the internet's
- 7:38most famous rodents. They saw capybara on the
- 7:41other side of the forest, on the other side of
- 7:43the river, sorry. And this other side of the
- 7:47river is where a lot of native forest is still
- 7:51untouched. Unfortunately, deforestation brings
- 7:55a real risk to tembe communities and to indigenous
- 7:58communities in the Amazon because it's not like
- 8:01they go to the supermarket to buy their beef.
- 8:03They have to eat what they hunt. They have to
- 8:06eat what they kill. They survive on the nuts,
- 8:09fruits, and everything that the Amazon provides
- 8:13to them. So deforestation is like a real threat
- 8:15on their livelihood. It's not just, you know,
- 8:19vibes or environmental vibes. So that day they
- 8:24saw the capybara, they crossed the river, they
- 8:26carried with them machetes and a couple of really
- 8:29old hunting rifles. The sun was setting and the
- 8:33nag would be moonless, which was really good
- 8:35for hunting. This I learned in talking to them.
- 8:40They split up to cover more ground and reduce
- 8:43noise. As they pushed north, The hunting party's
- 8:48path took them to the edge of the rainforest
- 8:50and towards a ranch owned by one of the region's
- 8:54most powerful men. His name is Nedio Lopez Salas.
- 9:00And this man is like a big fish in a small pond.
- 9:05He owns so many cattle ranches, but he also owns
- 9:10radio stations, hotels, water parks. He's sort
- 9:13of like the rich guy in the area. He's been fined,
- 9:18these court records were open source. He's been
- 9:22fined for deforesting black indigenous territories.
- 9:27He's been accused by regulators for exploiting
- 9:29his workers, for improperly using pesticides.
- 9:33And yet his stature is such that local folk songs
- 9:36celebrates him as the creator of the Brazilian
- 9:40bull and the king of Acai. And there's a, they
- 9:44even made a song for him, which is like Hillary's,
- 9:47like a Brazilian folk song, where they just like
- 9:51sing him praises for being the King of Açaí.
- 9:54You know, Açaí, this like little berry that in
- 9:58Europe and North America, we eat in a frozen
- 10:02bowl. Well, Netio produces that as well. Nereo
- 10:08is like a super interesting person in this investigation
- 10:11because actually once they cross the river, it's
- 10:17immediately Nereo's land. That used to be ancestral
- 10:19indigenous hunting ground. Now it's cattle breeding
- 10:24ranches ran by Nereo. So they cross the river,
- 10:28and this is what court records say, and they
- 10:33shot something. The ranch hand heard a gunshot.
- 10:39He panicked, the ranch hand panicked and called
- 10:43Nedio's son. In Brazilian we call him Nedinho
- 10:48because Brazilian is like little Nedio. So he
- 10:53thought it was a robbery. He thought someone
- 10:55was robbing cattle and immediately called his
- 11:00police friend. This Nadino, the son of Nerio
- 11:05says himself in the court records, he says it
- 11:07several times. And I think this points to the
- 11:10importance of like reading court records through
- 11:14and through, going through court records, every
- 11:16single page, turning every single page. He says,
- 11:19I called my friend in the military police because
- 11:23I thought it was a robbery. The court records
- 11:28actually said there's several contradictions.
- 11:31First, A team of forensic investigators come
- 11:34to the site and they concluded that the physical
- 11:36evidence largely contradicted the account. To
- 11:43start with, the military police lied about how
- 11:48many times they shot. Each of them said they
- 11:53had shot an X amount of times and the forensic
- 11:55team actually found a lot more shells and casings.
- 11:58So that in itself was already something pretty
- 12:01weird. And this is where it gets really interesting
- 12:06because we got, and let me see if I can try to
- 12:11describe it without seeing it on the screen.
- 12:15We got this really strange screenshots of what
- 12:20we're going to be the GPS coordinates of the
- 12:24car. They were so strange. I have them right
- 12:29next to me here. It says event, whether it's
- 12:33a parking or a stop. Driver, which was not registered.
- 12:38Start time, finish time, duration and distance.
- 12:41That's all we had. A really weird screenshot.
- 12:45Kudos to my colleague, Sacha Shell. Because I
- 12:48gave him this and I was like, figure it out.
- 12:50And he was like, what am I supposed to figure
- 12:52out? This is like a really nonsense screenshot.
- 12:57And then we had another screenshot, which is
- 12:59just, you know, when you like put a route on
- 13:03Google Maps. when you're like, oh, I want to
- 13:05go to X site and it'll sort of like draw like
- 13:09a blue line until you get to your destination.
- 13:12We had another screenshot of that blue line.
- 13:15We were like, what am I supposed to do with this?
- 13:18But then, boom, right? As an OSINT investigator,
- 13:22OSINT researcher, whenever I see satellite imagery
- 13:26on a court record, that's already a win because
- 13:29it means that there's a clue there. It means
- 13:32that that is something that I can definitely
- 13:34start to put together. So there was a satellite
- 13:39imagery of the headquarters of Nettio's Ranch
- 13:45and a time, 7 .55 PM. So we knew that at 7 .55
- 13:54PM, the police car was at the ranch headquarters.
- 13:59And then that allowed us to take the other two
- 14:02screenshots and overlay them in Google Earth
- 14:04Pro, which I really hope it doesn't disappear.
- 14:08I am so sad that they're making Google Earth
- 14:11Pro desktop disappear. I don't want to use the
- 14:13web version. I mean, I guess it's like, I understand
- 14:17it's probably like, you know, a business decision.
- 14:22But that allowed us sort of like the satellite
- 14:27imagery of the ranch. allowed us to overlay it
- 14:31with the actual GPS records that only had the
- 14:37time. One, two, three, sort of like it had when
- 14:42the car had started, when the car had stopped.
- 14:45I'm reading it right here. It's right in front
- 14:46of me. And we, it turns out that the police car
- 14:51left the police station at 7 .09 PM. It drove
- 14:57for 38 minutes, and it finally stopped at the
- 15:04ranch's headquarters for six minutes. And then
- 15:08finally on the actual GPS records, we see that
- 15:13from 8 .01 to 8 .55 PM, the police car went somewhere
- 15:20else and stopped for 53 minutes. You're wondering,
- 15:24is that when Isaac was killed? are those 53 minutes
- 15:29when Isaac was actually killed. So we went to
- 15:32Google Earth Pro, like I said, we overlaid all
- 15:36the screenshots that we had, we filled in the
- 15:38blanks, also showing how Ozend is not just like
- 15:42shiny tools and tricks, but really a mentality
- 15:46of... an intelligence mentality. And that's why
- 15:51I know that the term changes, and I just posted
- 15:54about this on LinkedIn. I know the term changes
- 15:57and I know that some folks don't like the intelligence
- 16:00part of it because it sort of like alludes to
- 16:02some sort of like, I don't know, spying or, you
- 16:07know, a sort of like prosecutor or law enforcement
- 16:10work. But if you just take it by itself, this
- 16:15detective -like ability of seeing something really
- 16:19flat, really flat information and making it live
- 16:23through the OSINT tools that we have, like Google
- 16:26Earth Pro Desktop. Taking that and extrapolating
- 16:30that, that is intelligence work. That is not,
- 16:32I mean, it's investigative work, but it's like,
- 16:36I call that intelligence work. And I think this,
- 16:39what we did here, take really stale, flat court
- 16:42records and overlay them with very simple QGIS,
- 16:49and not even QGIS, very simple Google Earth Pro,
- 16:53really made the information take a whole new
- 16:56dimension that allowed us to figure out several
- 17:00things. The next thing was the ballistics report.
- 17:08So essentially, let me just, before I go to the
- 17:12ballistics, okay, the ballistics report. And
- 17:16the ballistics report had three, four weapons.
- 17:21I'm looking at it right now. Let me just open
- 17:23it here. It had four weapons. Three of the weapons
- 17:28that belonged to the three military policemen.
- 17:32Three of the weapons that belonged to the military
- 17:34policemen. Two of those weapons were the same.
- 17:37They were this Imbel Carbine's 5 .56 caliber.
- 17:42And then the other one was a... I don't know
- 17:49how to translate this from Portuguese. A rifle,
- 17:52let's say. The three of them were semi -automatic
- 17:53weapons, which is also insane. And keep in mind
- 17:56for Americans in the audience, weapons are illegal
- 18:00in Brazil. Like you can't own a weapon. That
- 18:04is illegal. And the fourth weapon in the Ballistic's
- 18:08report was Taurus .36 caliber with the serial
- 18:14number 1666167. the weapon that the military
- 18:19police alleges that belonged to Isaac. And so
- 18:28essentially, let's go back in time. And this
- 18:32is what ended up happening. The Tembe tribe crossed
- 18:38the river at 5 p .m. We knew that it was getting
- 18:42dark, not only because they told us that it was
- 18:45getting dark, but... because we actually saw
- 18:47on Zonkalk that it was getting dark. So again,
- 18:50this to the point of like Ozen tools and techniques
- 18:53can also be narrative devices. I'm not going
- 18:55to believe my sources when they tell me it's
- 18:57dark. I'm actually going to take a tool and try
- 19:00to actually verify that it was getting dark.
- 19:03This is important because somebody saw something
- 19:05move in the middle, you know, of the bushes and
- 19:09shot at it. But guess what? Turns out this thing
- 19:14that they shot was a really expensive breeding
- 19:17bull from Nedio. It was not a capybara. They
- 19:23shot one of Nedio's bulls. As they shot it, as
- 19:29they shot it, the ranch had heard what it had
- 19:34actually, the shot, called Nedino. Nedino, who
- 19:38in turn called his friend at the military police.
- 19:41And the timid tribe says that the military police
- 19:44came in shooting. just point blank shooting.
- 19:46They didn't even identify themselves. The police
- 19:49say, oh no, we, you know, we asked like police
- 19:52who's there and they started shooting at us running
- 19:54from all different directions. In the end, everybody
- 19:59ran except for Isaac and we were able to determine
- 20:05pinpoint exactly where Isaac hid with satellite
- 20:08imagery. Everyone ran really quickly and Isaac
- 20:12hid in these bushes. There were a lot of drawings
- 20:16in the court cases where the police simulated,
- 20:19they have this really cool thing in Brazil that
- 20:21is called the simulated reproduction of the facts,
- 20:24where forensic experts asked the policemen separately
- 20:30to reenact what had happened that day. And that's
- 20:35where a lot of the inconsistencies were found.
- 20:38But there were, the forensic team did drawings.
- 20:41of where the police said that things had happened.
- 20:44And again, we were able to overlay these drawings
- 20:47on top of the satellite imagery on Google Earth
- 20:50Pro and figure out exactly where the police had
- 20:53shot from and where Isaac hid, according to the
- 20:57testimony of the other people in the hunting
- 20:59party. So Isaac hid in the bushes, everyone else
- 21:02ran. And then what the other people in the hunting
- 21:06party say is that they heard yelling and screaming.
- 21:10And then finally, one single shot. And that's
- 21:15when they knew that Isaac was dead. The police
- 21:21found him face down with this Taurus .36 caliber,
- 21:26which according to ballistic records had a serial
- 21:29number 1666167. And this detail particularly
- 21:36was particularly enraging for the Tembe community
- 21:39that are really, you know, it's this 12 house
- 21:41village. They're really tight. And they were
- 21:46just really, really angry about the fact that
- 21:51the military police said that Isaac had a gun.
- 21:55This is a criminalizing act in itself, they said.
- 21:59Owning a gun is illegal. It's not, you know,
- 22:02it's not like the US where you have a gun and,
- 22:05you know, it's fine. Like nothing happens. He
- 22:08was, Isaac was a pacifist. Isaac was studying
- 22:12to become the professor of his village. And it
- 22:15was just infuriating for his family members to
- 22:19think that he would have a gun and to think that
- 22:21he would shoot a gun. They often said that he
- 22:23didn't even know how to shoot a hunting rifle.
- 22:25How is he going to know to shoot a gun? So in
- 22:29my ozone brain, I saw these ballistics reports,
- 22:33which had all the weapon specifications, including
- 22:37the serial number. So of course I went to Google.
- 22:42And I did my Boolean searches, which is my due
- 22:46diligence as a reporter. Every time I see court
- 22:48records, my brain is always like, what can I
- 22:51drop in advanced search? I scour court records
- 22:55thinking, what are good keywords? What are good
- 22:58things that will lead me to unlock different
- 23:01things? So I put Taurus in quotation marks, which
- 23:06is also a really common weapon in Brazil. By
- 23:08the way, I think it's a Brazilian brand. And
- 23:11capital letters. Calibre in Portuguese, no quotation
- 23:15marks. And the serial number in quotation marks.
- 23:231666167. File type PDF. I did this with all the
- 23:27weapons. I remember it was really late at night.
- 23:30It was like midnight. And it was not my first
- 23:35try. I probably tried like five or six other
- 23:38keywords. But it's always like a trial and error
- 23:42and I guess a lot of people in the audience will
- 23:43identify It's always like you try one thing.
- 23:45It doesn't work. You try another thing It doesn't
- 23:47work and it's not until like the fifth or sixth
- 23:50Sometimes I'm like laying awake in the middle
- 23:52of the night and I think of a keyword and I'm
- 23:54like, oh my god I haven't tried this keyword
- 23:55so I was translating the court records and organizing
- 23:59them in chronological order Those of you who
- 24:02have worked with court records probably know
- 24:04by now that I don't know why on earth The facts
- 24:08in a court record are never in chronological
- 24:11order. Never in chronological order. It kills
- 24:14me. It kills me. How are you going to understand
- 24:17the story of a homicide, of a murder if you don't
- 24:20organize it in chronological order? So the first
- 24:23things that I do when I get court records is
- 24:26reorganize them in chronological order on Google
- 24:28Docs. Everybody always asks me like, why can't
- 24:31we put them in a spreadsheet? I'm like, no. Resist
- 24:34the temptation of putting your chronology on
- 24:37a spreadsheet. Every single story that I work
- 24:40on as an investigative reporter gets, my biggest
- 24:45epiphanies come from working on a chronology
- 24:48in a plain old Google docs. Why because sometimes
- 24:51you need Google Docs is sort of like a place
- 24:54where I start writing Sometimes you need six
- 24:57pages to explain what happened at 6 p .m Sometimes
- 25:00you just need a paragraph and I feel like the
- 25:03format of spreadsheets is so constraining. It's
- 25:07sort of like I can't You know, I can't like Go
- 25:14on and on and on for six pages in a freaking
- 25:16spreadsheet cell. It like limits me. And you
- 25:20don't need a data analysis on the chronology.
- 25:22I promise. I promise. It's the document where
- 25:24you start thinking, where you organize your thoughts,
- 25:27where you start writing. I would not, other than
- 25:30all the shiny OSINT tools and techniques, I would
- 25:33never get anywhere without a chronology. And
- 25:35I think this case is a very good example of that.
- 25:40So I was working through the chronology. It was
- 25:42a Sunday, really late at night, translating the
- 25:45court records, really immersed, marinated in
- 25:48the case, trying to think of what happened, the
- 25:52implications, trying to put the pieces of the
- 25:53puzzle together, following intuitions, getting
- 25:57different hypothesis, getting things wrong. So
- 26:01I searched for each of the weapons, their brand,
- 26:04their caliber, and their serial number. And for
- 26:08each one, I tried, I don't know. 6 to 10 different
- 26:12sets of keywords. But when I tried this, forest
- 26:16and calibre and 1666 167 file type PDF, you're
- 26:21not going to believe what I found. Like, I love
- 26:24the internet. This is absolutely insane. I found
- 26:28a PDF from 1991, a scanned PDF from 1991 that
- 26:37said that a Taurus gun. caliber 36, serial number
- 26:441666167, had been confiscated in 1991 because
- 26:51a military firefighter, part of the military
- 26:53forces, had killed himself with that gun. So
- 26:59that gun should have stayed in an evidence locker,
- 27:04managed by the military police. We found the
- 27:10gun that the military police said. they had found
- 27:16next to Isaac, that they said that Isaac had
- 27:20shot them with that. And here's where my responsibility
- 27:24as a journalist comes. I cannot say that the
- 27:28military police planted that gun. That would
- 27:31not be accurate. But you all can, you know, get
- 27:37to your own conclusions. You all can, you know,
- 27:40the readers and the listeners can... make their
- 27:44own conclusions on this. And I mean, this is
- 27:49just a testament of the power of Boolean and
- 27:55file type PDF searches, the power of organizing
- 27:59things and being so immersed in the material,
- 28:04the power of looking for keywords in whatever
- 28:11document I ever get my hands on. So we found
- 28:22the smoking gun, as one would say, talk about
- 28:25a smoking gun. And I think especially now, the
- 28:29more that AI, you know, LLMs and like chatbots
- 28:36are getting trained, the more things are going
- 28:39to be digitized. The more things, the more and
- 28:42more digital life is just like growing. So I
- 28:47can very proudly say. And partly thanks to our
- 28:51work, I called the prosecutor so many times.
- 28:54I called the poor, that man is on my speed dial.
- 28:59The two military policemen, so the forensic report
- 29:02found that out of the three military policemen,
- 29:06like I said, two of them had the same weapon.
- 29:09And those two, the imbaled carbines, the forensic
- 29:14report concluded that those two were the guns
- 29:17that Uh, one of those two guns had shot, uh,
- 29:22Isaac in the back. He probably, we don't know
- 29:24if he ran away, if he was walking away. Uh, he
- 29:27got shot in the chest from the back, died almost
- 29:30immediately. And there were a lot of inconsistencies
- 29:33after that as well. The military police said
- 29:36that they took him directly to the hospital from
- 29:38the GPS records. We know that's not true. They
- 29:42made several stops along the way that we can't
- 29:45explain, and we don't know why this happened.
- 29:49Isaac, when he got to the hospital, was already
- 29:51dead. And then the military police also lied
- 29:55about they went back to the killing spot that
- 29:59same night, which makes, again, absolutely no
- 30:03sense. Again, as a journalist, I can't say why.
- 30:06I can't imagine several reasons why a military
- 30:09police would go back to the killing spot on the
- 30:12same night. But we don't actually know that part.
- 30:17So I'm proud to say that I think this work has
- 30:21been really impactful because the two military
- 30:23policemen who had that gun, who carried that
- 30:31inbuilt carbine, have just been indicted. They
- 30:37were just indicted for murder, which is why I
- 30:40dared to use the word murder when I talk about
- 30:43this. If they hadn't been indicted, just legally
- 30:46speaking, it would be hard for me to say murder
- 30:48because I don't want to, like, you know, get
- 30:51sued for defamation or anything like that. And
- 30:55so that's the story. That's the story of Isaac
- 30:59Tembe and the story of how... We found the gun
- 31:04that the military police said ISAC shot them
- 31:09with. What an incredible investigation that is.
- 31:17And we've got a couple of questions already coming
- 31:19in. Somebody's already said, talk about smoking
- 31:23gun. A very quick question from Scoot is, is
- 31:28there a published article on this? Is there of
- 31:31somewhere people can read a little bit more?
- 31:34So this is the sad part. Um, we, I did a talk
- 31:39that I can share with you all. We're editing
- 31:42it. Uh, we published this on a sort of like YouTube
- 31:46format, leaning into the creator journalism economy.
- 31:51A side part is, for that question, I think the
- 31:54side part is that, uh, I worked on this story
- 31:57for three years and we wanted it to be so perfect
- 32:04that we missed our publishing window. These types
- 32:09of stories were evergreen before Trump won the
- 32:13election in 2024. And after that, the world has
- 32:16just been such, you know, we're at the brink
- 32:20of third world war constantly. So it was just
- 32:26really hard to place this story for an international
- 32:29audience. And we did a lot of, it was not strictly
- 32:32open source. We did a lot of like... Oh, uh,
- 32:35you know, close source, sourcing reporting as
- 32:38well. So, it never actually got published. Did
- 32:43the indictment reference your research? Uh, it
- 32:46did not. It did not. It did not, no. The fact
- 32:52that there were international journalists looking
- 32:54into this and I was asking about like, there's
- 32:56a footnote and page 436. Have you looked into
- 33:01that and what do you think? The prosecutor was
- 33:05like, I really felt like I had to read this through
- 33:08and through. And when I did, the inconsistencies
- 33:11were so big that it was inevitable to lead to
- 33:16the indictment. Yes. It's always good to put
- 33:22a little pressure on, especially using your international
- 33:28standing. I wanted to ask, because a lot people
- 33:32can come across interesting material online every
- 33:36day. And this PDF obviously was a really vital
- 33:39piece of material. How, if you come across a
- 33:42document like that, how do you establish its
- 33:45provenance and assess whether it's authentic
- 33:47when it's from such a long time ago, particularly
- 33:50as it was a scanned document? And what might
- 33:53remain uncertain about that? That's a great question.
- 33:58To be fair, I did not find this unlike, you know,
- 34:03described, you know, this was actually hosted
- 34:09on the website of the military station where
- 34:16the gun was supposed to be withheld. So it was
- 34:20actually hosted in the military website. And
- 34:24I think that makes the verification a lot easier.
- 34:26Like if I had just freaking found it on like,
- 34:29you know, like a dump or like I don't know, like
- 34:35an onion site? Like, I think that verification
- 34:37would have been a lot harder, but since it was
- 34:40literally posted in the website of the military
- 34:45station where this gun was supposed to have been
- 34:47well -held, I think that's what made it just
- 34:52a lot more straightforward. That is a very good
- 34:55question. Actually, I hadn't gotten that question
- 34:56before. It's an excellent question. It's always
- 35:00like, yeah, but because what if you find it in
- 35:02like, I don't know how do you pronounce scribed,
- 35:04scribed, scribed? Yeah, whatever. This like document
- 35:10and hosting sort of like platform. I think we
- 35:14would have had to make a lot of calls to the
- 35:18military station with the gun was withheld because
- 35:22to really try to figure out, you know. whether
- 35:25somebody had killed themselves with this exact
- 35:27gun and get somebody to confirm it for us. I
- 35:29think that's how I would have gone about it.
- 35:32I really admire the work of Bell and Cat in that
- 35:37they don't make calls like this because I don't
- 35:41know. I just feel like all the richness and a
- 35:44lot of the verification is just like one call
- 35:46away. But hey, maybe that's why everyone's so
- 35:48talented. it forces you to do everything with
- 35:52open sources. And I really, really admire that.
- 35:56But that's a very good question. Yes. It's really
- 36:02important to get multiple sources when you can.
- 36:05Scribd, by the way, apparently is how you say
- 36:08it. Scribd. Thank you. Earlier we had a question
- 36:12about the ballistic evidence that was provided
- 36:15by the military. Did they find evidence that
- 36:19the gun from the 1991 suicide had been fired
- 36:22at the crime scene of the Tempe crimes? There
- 36:25was nothing in the court records about that.
- 36:28That would have been a really good, you know,
- 36:35clue or lead. There was nothing in the court
- 36:37records about that. But what I can say is that
- 36:40there were no shelves or casings other than the
- 36:44military policemen weapons on the ground. as
- 36:48per the forensic team. Speaking about this particular
- 36:54case, how important was it to understand the
- 36:57wider context of the Tempe people's relationship
- 37:00with the land and the surrounding authoritative
- 37:03figures? How did that shape the way you approach
- 37:06this investigation? And is investigating disputes
- 37:10in the Amazon particularly particularly different
- 37:14to other investigations of human rights nature?
- 37:17Are there other factors here that you have to
- 37:19consider when looking at this particular region?
- 37:24That's a very good question. I come from a hard
- 37:30line of investigative reporting training where
- 37:34it took me three years. You know, like we did
- 37:38this for three years and I pretty much become
- 37:44an expert in whatever topic you're reporting
- 37:47on or investigating. I don't have a beat. My
- 37:49beat is any wrongdoing around the world. And
- 37:55just taking really the time to understand A,
- 37:59the geographical dynamics. And this is where,
- 38:02again, GIS became really, really relevant. B,
- 38:06the work with interviews with anthropologists
- 38:09about what that land used to be like. land regulation
- 38:14in terms of that land I know was ancestral indigenous
- 38:18hunting grounds because I saw from the shapefiles
- 38:22that older shapefiles said it was indigenous
- 38:25land and then a process of demarcation happened
- 38:29which is where the Brazilian law and the Brazilian
- 38:33constitution officially recognized an Indigenous
- 38:36territory and give it a formal shapefile, give
- 38:39it a map, give it a formal shapefile. This happened
- 38:41in the 80s. So that ancestral hunting land actually
- 38:46did not make the demarcation, did not make the
- 38:49official process of recognizing the Indigenous
- 38:51land and everything below the river that the
- 38:53Timbuktu crossed was actually what was recognized
- 38:57in the end. And again, it's the beauty of journalism
- 39:01and why I love journalism so much. We talked
- 39:03to a lot of prosecutors because one of the questions
- 39:06was, first, one of the prosecutors actually said
- 39:10that it's a very sad reality in the Brazilian
- 39:14Amazon where military policemen are used as private
- 39:18security guards for rich ranchers and landlords.
- 39:24So that's like really important context, right?
- 39:27And then second, we had a lot of questions about
- 39:33like, wait, what if, especially with an American
- 39:36mindset of what if the indigenous people bought
- 39:39the gun after it was confiscated, after this
- 39:43military fireman killed himself with that gun,
- 39:47it was confiscated, what if it got sold in the
- 39:50black market? Which I'm Mexican in my Mexican
- 39:53brain, like that doesn't happen. But the editors
- 39:56were American and I was like, okay, you know
- 39:57what, let's call the military prosecutor. So
- 39:59the guy who's in charge of sort of like judging
- 40:05and overseeing the military police. And he said,
- 40:08no, he said, there's no way this gun should have
- 40:12never exited the evidence locker. It should have
- 40:15remained in the hands of the military police.
- 40:17So that already gave us another sort of like.
- 40:21another degree of certainty. And unfortunately,
- 40:27I think it is not just like bad apples. I think
- 40:34there are, we saw many cases of abuse by the
- 40:39military police in this part of the world. There
- 40:43are massacres, documented massacres from the
- 40:47times of the military dictatorship and after.
- 40:51And of course, you know, it's like saying hashtag
- 40:55not all men, hashtag not all military policemen.
- 40:58I'm sure there's very good people who do their
- 41:01work, you know, in a very righteous way, but
- 41:06it seems to rather be a systemic problem, especially
- 41:10if we take the words from the prosecutor that
- 41:12military policemen are used as private security
- 41:16guards for rich landlords. I love hearing about
- 41:21the about the interviews that you do because
- 41:24even though at Bellingcat we do any work with
- 41:26open sources, we are very honest in the fact
- 41:29that a lot of our work is a starting point, a
- 41:32jumping off point that could be taken further
- 41:34with that kind of investigation. From what you've
- 41:38just said, actually, Hillman's comment really
- 41:42fits into that and perhaps you can build on it
- 41:44a little bit more because you touched on it just
- 41:46a second ago. They asked, do you have any confidence
- 41:49that systematic systemic changes have been made
- 41:53to the force itself to avoid this in the future
- 41:55rather than the individual bad apples this time
- 41:57getting caught. Is there any sign that this case
- 42:02has helped somewhat the communities in this region
- 42:08or has there been, despite the indictments, has
- 42:12there been any changes or any progress on the
- 42:16ground that you see? That's a very good question,
- 42:20too. Thank you, everyone. We're coming in for
- 42:22all their super cool questions. I love Discord.
- 42:24I love the Balink and Discord. I'm such a groupie.
- 42:28Everyone's so smart and nice and nerdy. I love
- 42:31it. I mean, I do think that this indictment is
- 42:36a very big win. We have not seen very many indictments
- 42:41in other similar cases. So the fact that this
- 42:44happened already, the indictment is a very, very
- 42:47big deal. I've been following the case. I've
- 42:50been following the interviews and the depositions
- 42:53with the military policeman and the prosecutors
- 42:56are doing such a good job. We have to wait to
- 43:00the resolution and see what happens, but I have
- 43:03no doubt and the prosecutor said so himself.
- 43:06Well, one of the prosecutors said like, I have
- 43:08no doubt this will send a chilling message in
- 43:10the region of like, if you're a military policeman
- 43:13and you engage in any wrongdoing. This can happen.
- 43:18You can be indicted. You can be processed. You
- 43:20can be prosecuted. So I do think it'll send a
- 43:24positive message as any, you know, it's sort
- 43:27of like a very Foucault view on the criminal
- 43:31process. It's pedagogical in the sense of everybody
- 43:36else who sees this and is a military policeman
- 43:38might hold back because of seeing actual consequences
- 43:42and not leaving an impunity, right? Fingers crossed.
- 43:46Hey. Just bringing you back to this whole concept
- 43:51of using different types of sources, and as Sutton
- 43:54and I have put it, combining old school journalism
- 43:58with open source research. They've asked, investigative
- 44:01reporting is probably where the two naturally
- 44:03come closest, but do you see other areas of reporting
- 44:06that could be enhanced by broadening the tool
- 44:09set, seeing as you've got a kind of a legal background
- 44:13as well? Yeah, I mean... I'd love, yeah, my legal
- 44:17background makes me love court records. I know
- 44:20how to go to court records. I know how to analyze
- 44:22court records. And I love taking that and putting
- 44:24it to use in open source and OSINT mindsets,
- 44:30tools and tricks and tips. I think the other
- 44:34side of this is, that's why I started a company
- 44:38to teach OSINT fact finder, because I just feel
- 44:42like everybody should be doing. Everybody should
- 44:45be doing OSINT. Everybody should be. I feel like
- 44:48OSINT is something you just sprinkle in any investigative
- 44:51process and it'll make things a lot better. OSINT
- 44:55in the set of tools and OSINT as in the method
- 44:58and the mentality of taking things into a next
- 45:01nerdy level. But that's my goal. That's my vision.
- 45:07Just sprinkle OSINT in anything you have. Just
- 45:10file type PDF things for fun. You know, it's
- 45:14like encrypting for fun. It's like, it's an interesting
- 45:17question because it's sort of like, to me, security
- 45:21and OSINT are two sides of the same coin. The
- 45:24more you do OSINT, the safer you have to be.
- 45:28And the more you do OSINT, the more you realize
- 45:29how much information anybody out there could
- 45:32get on you and your family and your loved ones
- 45:34and your habits, et cetera. But it's almost like,
- 45:39like asking ourselves whether everybody could
- 45:43use security, whether everybody should be safer
- 45:46online. It's like, yeah, I don't care if you're
- 45:49a teenager or a mom or an aunt or a grandma,
- 45:53everybody should be safer online. I think it's
- 45:55the same with OSIN, and especially given the
- 46:00epistemic crisis that we're going through, this
- 46:02crisis of truth where we don't know where the
- 46:07line between... reality and falsehood is anymore
- 46:10and how that is also undermining democracy in
- 46:15itself. And I know that Elliot Higgins talks
- 46:17a lot about this. So the more we take ozone out
- 46:21there to the world and the more we allow people
- 46:24to do the most basic ozone research, I think
- 46:30the stronger of a society we'll have. So those
- 46:34two things sort of like going hand in hand. To
- 46:36the question specifically in journalism, I would
- 46:40love journalists to do more QGIS work, geographic
- 46:45information work. I feel like we miss out on
- 46:48a lot of stories just because we don't understand
- 46:50the territorial dimension of that or the mapping
- 46:53dimension of that. There's great work being done
- 46:57in conflict reporting, of course, with open sources
- 47:00and closed sources. And I would love to see more
- 47:03local journalism, hyper -local journalism. So
- 47:07like in your town, in your state, and wherever
- 47:11you're living, I think there's a lot of really
- 47:15cool oath and applications at a hyper -local
- 47:18level as well. I hope that answers the question.
- 47:22Absolutely. And thanks for mentioning Elliot's
- 47:23work on that. I've linked his PDF, the epistemic
- 47:29security paper that he made. in the chat. Just
- 47:33going back to you were talking about how you
- 47:36love interrogating court records. Hillman's asked,
- 47:41do you know of any resources online slash books
- 47:44that you'd recommend on how to interrogate court
- 47:47records better? For those of us who don't have
- 47:51a legal brain, how do we get better at that?
- 47:55For those of us who didn't go to law school,
- 47:59Listen, court workers are painful. I'm not going
- 48:01to lie, especially when it's like tens of thousands
- 48:04of pages and you're like, um, swimming. And there
- 48:08was another story that I was working on what
- 48:09there was lawfare. So there was like a really
- 48:12concrete lawfare is this really concrete and
- 48:15coordinated, uh, intimidation campaign via lawsuits.
- 48:19And there were so many, it was so many of them.
- 48:22It was so overwhelming to even follow. It's used
- 48:25as a very common intimidating tactic. I don't
- 48:29have any resource at the top of my head, but
- 48:33what I can say is organize things in chronological
- 48:37order, period. Like just, it's time consuming,
- 48:42it's tedious, you know, I feel like we... Investigative
- 48:48reporting sounds kind of like you're like James
- 48:50Bond drinking martinis in the Brazilian Amazon,
- 48:53and it's super glamorous. One's like, talk about
- 48:55the story when I'm done. But it's such tedious
- 48:58work. And the good things only come out from
- 49:02investing time, energy, and, you know, just sitting
- 49:05through with good music and plowing through either
- 49:10a spreadsheet or really annoying court records.
- 49:13I think my biggest, biggest piece of advice is
- 49:17organize things in chronological order. Organize
- 49:21things, reorganize things in chronological order.
- 49:23I don't like copy pasting because I like memorizing
- 49:27things. My previous editor used to say that it's
- 49:30like marinating yourself in the material, like
- 49:32a piece of salmon. You just want to be marinated
- 49:35and impregnated in the case all the time. So
- 49:39in order to marinate myself, I don't like copy
- 49:41pasting. I like really just like taking things
- 49:44and rewriting them, writing them in my own words,
- 49:48writing my thoughts, writing my impressions,
- 49:50writing my questions, color coding. So the chronology,
- 49:56again, is the document where I think. It's the
- 49:59document where the best ideas come from. My biggest
- 50:02piece of advice would be... reorganize the facts
- 50:06in chronological order, and you'll see how things
- 50:09just start opening up. From having really obscure
- 50:12things and a really obscure document to just
- 50:15like, oh, you know, decision, decision, fact,
- 50:20fact, fact, and all of that starts coming together
- 50:24slowly. And with time, you just become better
- 50:26at being able to jump through. I really confused
- 50:32in court record. When I was a young, I used to
- 50:35work, I interned in the Mexican Supreme court.
- 50:39And my only job for three years as an intern
- 50:42and then an employee was to reorganize court
- 50:45records in criminological order. Reorganize whatever
- 50:49the document said in chronological order for
- 50:51the judges. That was literally my only job. And
- 50:55I have taken that with me in investigative reporting.
- 50:57And it's the best tip that I can ever give you.
- 51:01Amazing. Yeah, I was only a court reporter for
- 51:05a very short period of time and the UK courts
- 51:07are pretty unique actually. But something that
- 51:11got me a little bit more comfortable in those
- 51:13settings is just exposing myself to multiple
- 51:16different types of cases and court records and
- 51:20trying to understand the legal speak. And I think
- 51:23it varies per country as well. So if you have
- 51:25some time just to sift through all cases. It
- 51:29could help just to get some familiarity with
- 51:31certain terms and things that you should be looking
- 51:33for as well. However, I do not have the expertise
- 51:36that Hisela here has. Perhaps it's a Bellingcat
- 51:41challenge idea sifting through old court records.
- 51:43I must chat to our team about that. We've only
- 51:46got a couple of minutes, five more minutes. So
- 51:49I wanted to ask you about this particular investigation
- 51:55where you were kind of challenging an official
- 51:58account, because that is something that often
- 52:01comes up in human rights investigations, unfortunately,
- 52:04where there's an official account and the digital
- 52:08evidence might dispute what has been claimed.
- 52:12Is there a particular piece of advice that you
- 52:15would give to someone investigating an incident
- 52:17where the official account is disputed, but perhaps
- 52:21access to traditional evidence is limited? Is
- 52:25there anything that you might have learned from
- 52:28going kind of against the official account or
- 52:32trying to find this information that helps kind
- 52:37of corroborate what those on the ground were
- 52:39saying? I don't know if there's like a set like
- 52:45solution or idea or mentality. I think it's very
- 52:49case dependent. I'd say that the very first place
- 52:55to start is just question the official narrative.
- 53:00I used to teach journalism at UC Berkeley and
- 53:02I taught that for a while and it always struck
- 53:05me how little students questioned official narratives.
- 53:09Doesn't matter where it comes from, just question
- 53:13the official narrative. And it's kind of cool
- 53:17because the more you do it, the more you... developed
- 53:22sort of like this spidey senses of, mm -hmm,
- 53:26something's off. And following that intuition
- 53:30when things are off and those spidey senses where
- 53:32things don't make sense has been one of the most
- 53:34important things. And again, I come back to very
- 53:39simple boolean site and file type PDF searches,
- 53:44good keywords, and having the discipline to creatively
- 53:48come up with all these different terms. I think
- 53:51that's what I would come back to because it really
- 53:54depends if it's a conflict, you know, a bombing,
- 53:57you have satellite and geolocation. This case
- 54:00was more like pushing back against the things
- 54:04that we knew were suspect given how enraged the
- 54:09Tembe tribe was about that gun. I'm sure that
- 54:24will be the case. But as you mentioned, there
- 54:26should be a video coming out of you talking about
- 54:29this case. Is that correct? We had a question
- 54:32earlier as well about whether Brazilian media
- 54:35has reported on any of this. Is there any way
- 54:38other people can find out a little bit more about
- 54:41this? Has it been covered locally? The killing
- 54:46was covered locally. I don't think the case has
- 54:48been covered as much. And, but I will keep you
- 54:52all posted if they're ever convicted or reigned.
- 54:56Uh, they have the two of the two military policeman
- 54:58have pleaded not guilt, not guilty. So I'm following
- 55:02the case very closely. It's been a big part of
- 55:05my life and. And yeah, uh, stay tuned for the
- 55:09YouTube talk. There's a YouTube, we're putting
- 55:11a, uh, a full 20 minute YouTube talk, which is
- 55:16sort of like our way of. publishing this really
- 55:20big story after it came out. Please do publish
- 55:23that in here. Please do share it with us and
- 55:26we'll make sure to include it in the server,
- 55:28but also I'll make sure to include it on the
- 55:31description of this podcast as well. So if you're
- 55:33listening back a couple of weeks after, it might
- 55:36be there. Thank you so much, Zola, for today.
- 55:40It's been great to hear this incredible story.
- 55:43I can't wait to watch that video and do keep
- 55:46us updated if it goes. anywhere else. And you
- 55:50can find out more about Gisela and her work by
- 55:53checking out her websites, which I've included
- 55:56in the comments section here, but I'll also include
- 55:59it in the description of the podcast. As mentioned,
- 56:03she is the CEO of Fat Finder, which is an amazing
- 56:07initiative that's teaching everybody the basics
- 56:11of open source research, which is amazing. And
- 56:15in two weeks' time, we'll be back with another
- 56:17stage talk. But for now, thank you, everybody.
- 56:21Thank you so much. Such a pleasure to be here
- 56:23with everyone. I love you guys. Thank you for
- 56:27listening to the stage talk. If you'd like to
- 56:30catch a stage talk live where you can ask the
- 56:33guest questions, join the Bellingcat Discord
- 56:35server by visiting www .discord .gg slash Bellingcat.
- 56:42The music you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer
- 56:46Self and is courtesy of Artlist.