Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / She Escaped His Van… And Uncovered a Serial Killer | Jeffrey Willis
Transcript
- Zalle: You pissed me off. I'm sorry. Nicholle: You had that much emotion about it, ⁓ my God. Zalle: Ha ha ha. ⁓ Nicholle: Whoo. Zalle: Huh. It was supposed to be a short walk home, just a few blocks, late on a Saturday night in Norton Shores, Michigan. The kind of walk a sixteen year old girl takes a hundred times without thinking twice. The air was cool, the streets were quiet, and somewhere behind her she heard a van slow down. The man inside was old enough to be her grandfather. Glasses, graying hair, the kind of face you pass in a grocery store and never remember. He smiled. Offered her a ride, she said no, politely. The way girls are taught to say no to strangers. But then he offered her his phone, said she could call for a ride, and when she leaned in to take it, the doors locked. She asked again, then she demanded, let me out, let me out, let me out. But he didn't let her out. He reached under the seat. He reached under the seat and pulled out a gun. What happened next? What she did next would crack open two murders that police had been chasing for three years. Murders no one had connected. Murders that had left two families shattered in a community terrified of a killer that they couldn't find. She jumped from a moving van, hit the pavement, rolled, and ran, pounded on a stranger's door until someone opened it, until someone believed her, until someone called nine one. And when police searched the van, they found something that would change everything. A toolbox, a padlock, and inside, handcuffs, chains, syringes, and a laminated diagram of the human body showing exactly where to inject. This is the story of a grandfather who wasn't. Nicholle: He wasn't a grandfather. Zalle: ⁓ this is a story of a grandfather who wasn't. A furniture factory worker who built something horrifying in his silver minivan and a sixteen year old girl who refused to become the next folder on his computer. Nicholle: no on Coffee and Crime with Mom, we're telling the whole story. The disappearances, the toolbox, the escape, and the man who looked so normal that nobody suspected him until one girl said. Zalle: But first, coffee moment. Okay, Mom So Nicholle: So I have a journey. Zalle: You have a dream. Nicholle: journey. For my coffee moment, I have a journey. Zalle: You have a journey. ⁓ yeah, you should not just throw that out there like that. You my brain didn't process that very well. Nicholle: What are we talking about coffee? Zalle: fuck are you talking about? ⁓ so what is the dream about? That's why I was like, what do you mean? Okay. And is that the new is that a new frappe? Nicholle: hearing it in. So I found this hibiscus tea. You know this story, but I'm telling it here now. It's first time. Breaking news. So I found this hibiscus tea, right? And I made it, I saw a video and so they put a little bit of honey, some lemon juice and he put cinnamon sticks. I'm not that bushy. So I just sprinkled a little bit of cinnamon in there. This was the best tasting tea. Zalle: I know you're not drinking hibiscus tea. Nicholle: that I have ever had in my entire life. All of my 50 years, I've never tasted tea that tasted like this tea. And then something said, can I have hibiscus? And then we looked it up and it said, no, that I could die if I drink more hibiscus. So today I just have my regular whipped coffee. So that was my journey. Zalle: Why the hell did we need to know about this whole story about this hibiscus tea? For you to tell us you got some whipped coffee. Nicole, I'm hanging up. I'm over it. I'm over it. Nicholle: I'm just trying to say that I tried something else, but it didn't work out. So I'm back to my coffee. Zalle: Okay. Okay. All right. You're annoying. And water. I am drinking Nicholle: and water. You need a nap. Zalle: I need a nap. I am drinking mocha ⁓ mocha latte. I am not. I am not frumpy at all. Nicholle: You need a nap, you're frumpy. Okay, you don't sound grumpy whatsoever when you say that. Okay. Zalle: And 'cause I'm not. 'Cause I'm not. Drinking my mocha latte, that's what I got today. Okay. I needed something old school and comforting because this case was bonkers, okay? For one reason, because the guy looks like everybody else's grandpa. Glasses, soft voice, worked at a furniture factory, went to church, and his van was literally a rolling torturing chamber. So it's so many, like what? Nicholle: Okay. Bye. Peace. Yeah. Okay. Zalle: What moments throughout this that it I just needed a some real basic. Nicholle: Right, right, I get it. And the only reason we know about any of it is because of that 16 year old girl. Because she had the guts to jump out of a moving vehicle. And if she hadn't, we might still be wondering what happened to the other two women who had vanished without a trace. Zalle: And then the computer files literally had a folder on his computer called VIX with their initials and the dates. It's like he wanted to get caught because he just but he couldn't c he couldn't stop himself. He had to just make sure it was super organized. Because thank you for this folder. Nicholle: Yeah. Thank you so much for your organization. Thank you. We appreciate it. He made it so easy. He made it so easy to follow the evidence. He laid it all out. Zalle: We no n we no longer need a a verbal confession. Yes. It was all right there. Nicholle: All right, so let's get into it. I can definitely hear that. Zalle: Go lady. Go sit down. Go. You're tripping. Sat down. That ain't setting down. Go. Do the bug. Go. Nicholle: Let me close this door right quick, they just came back in. Did you just say shit? Okay. and soon as you're to get it. Zalle: All right. Is you ready? Nicholle: Well... Zalle: I know you're not on your phone. Put your phone down. Put your phone down. We're in the studio. Nicholle: I just got some from Walmart. Did I order some from Walmart? do I say? we know that. Okay, all right, I'm done. Zalle: You're fired. Nicholle: You can't fire me, ma'am. Zalle: fired pink slip in the mail. All right. Stay there. Picture this. Nicholle: Okay, I'll home. Zalle: Picture this. It's April twenty sixth, twenty thirteen. Jessica, how you say her last name? Here Haringa. Nicholle: Here ringa, here ringa. Zalle: Jessica Haringa is twenty five, a single mom, working a late shift at an Exxon gas station in Norton Shores, Michigan. She's been there for three years. She knows the routine, she's closing up. This is a regular day night for her. Nicholle: Right, just a normal night, a normal job she does all the time and the kind of shift that millions of people work every single day. Zalle: Except this night, Jessica never makes it home. Her car is still in the lot, her purse, her jacket, her cigarettes all left behind. A coworker comes to check on her and finds the gas station empty, the cash register untouched, the surveillance system. It wasn't working that night. Of course that happens all of the time. Nicholle: Wow, of course. A witness across the street, Susan Follett and her husband riding their motorcycles, they see a silver minivan pull behind the gas station. The van doesn't go to the front where the pumps are, it ducks behind the building, which at that time of night is definitely weird. They keep an eye on it and they see a man driving. A few minutes later, the van leaves and Jessica is gone. Zalle: This reminds me of that other case we did with that woman who went missing from her gas station job and her husband went to go and he had left that stolen car down the street. Yeah. So obviously the police launch a massive search. Seventy-five officers from fourteen specialized divisions. Aviation, behavioral sciences, technical services, intelligence analysis, they're all out there looking for her. That's a lot of Nicholle: Mm-hmm. That was one of the first things. Yeah, yeah. Wow, a lot of analysis. Zalle: Important yeah. Yeah. Twelve thousand man hours go into the search. Okay. Fourteen hundred tips were given for them to, you know, work off of and thirty-three search warrants were distributed. Twenty residential searches were done by consent. And then twelve ground searches and two underwater searches were all conducted and they find nothing. Nicholle: Bye. Mm-hmm. Wow. Zalle: No body, no DNA, no answers. All of this and nothing. Nicholle: That's crazy. And Jessica's mother, Shelly, becomes the face of the search. She holds vigils, she puts up flyers, she begs for information, and for three years, she gets silenced. Zalle: And that is so crazy that they brought up all of these people. That is a lot of people, a lot of searching and to find nothing. And it normally does turn up like end up where it is just the moms that become the main face. Yeah. Okay, but so the thing that haunts me about this particular one was that the gas station had no working cameras, no security footage, nothing to tell the police what happened. Jessica literally vanished into thin air. Nicholle: a lot. Yeah, so often. Zalle: And I'm so tired of being like, ⁓ yeah, the cameras don't work. Man, I'm not working. If the cameras don't work, I don't work. Like at night. Nicholle: At the gas station at night time? Absolutely not. So let's name her again. Jessica Harenka, 25 years old, a mother, a daughter, and a woman who went to work one night and just never came home. Zalle: Then in June sorry, then on june twenty ninth, twenty fourteen, in Dalton Township, Michigan, Rebecca Bletch. Please forgive me if I butchered that. Rebecca Bletch is twenty six, a mother, a wife. She goes out for her daily jog on automobile road. A rural stretch. She runs a she's run a hundred times before. Nicholle: And it's a beautiful summer day. She's wearing her running gear, listening to music, just a woman taking care of herself, getting her exercise. Zalle: And this circles back to when we were talking about as women, there's just certain things that I would never do in ⁓ r running on a rural in any rural area. Listening to music with both headphones in, absolutely not. You gotta have at least one headphone out, some kind of light, some mace. Nicholle: Yeah. Definitely. That's what I was thinking. Yeah, that's what I was thinking. I got to be able to hear something. Uh, I think I was just talking to your dad about that. I was like, think about it. Like for you, you would just go out. You wouldn't think twice about it for women in general. It's not a fear. It's not like I have a fear that comes to mind. It's just knowing that I can't do that. Like that thinking of her doing that makes me anxious. Zalle: Something. Yeah. That I can't do it. Yeah. Anxious, so anxious. A neighbor finds her body on the side of the road. At first, police think it's a hidden run, but then they see the bullet wounds. Three shots to the head. Execution style. Shell casings scattered nearby. Which is so horrible. She just was trying to run the girl just trying to get her groove on. You know what I'm saying? Trying to get her body back. She had kids trying bounce back in. It would be a man out here hating on her. Nicholle: us. bright. Yeah Right? And, Rebecca was a fighter. She had defensive wounds. She tried to get away, whoever did this was methodical, cold, and they left her on the side of a rural road like she was trash. Zalle: This instantly pisses me off. So the police start their investigation. They look for connections to Jessica Haringa because it was the same county with similar timeframe, and both women had been abducted or attacked in isolated areas. But there was no physical evidence actually linking the cases. No DNA, no witnesses, just two dead or missing women, and a whole lot of questions. Because obviously Nicholle: Yes. Zalle: Nothing is coming up for either one of them. Just the showcasings. And that's it. Nicholle: Right, they have nothing. ⁓ And Rebecca's family is devastated. Her daughter, Ellie, is just a kid. Her sisters, Nicole and Jessica Josephson are shattered. And for two years, they get no answers. Just the knowledge that whoever killed Rebecca is still out there. And that's horrible to think that your loved one is gone and left on the side of the road. And the police have no idea who did it. Like they may not have to pay for this. Zalle: So heartbreaking. Right. But Sergeant Lisa, please say her last name. Nicholle: Ferreres. Zalle: Sergeant Lisa Ferres of the Nicholle: Tuskegee. Zalle: Sergeant Lisa Ferrez of the Muskegon County Sheriff's Office later told 2020, I hate to call it a cold case because we're still actively working on it and we didn't stop, but we had no solid leads, which is understandable. Obviously, I'm sure that's a horrible term for the police to even have to use cold case for those who are working on it. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right? Mm-hmm. Yeah. And ⁓ Rebecca's family talked about the agony of those years, the not knowing, the fear that every day brings. I think that I've never been in these situations. I think that would be the hardest right after what you just read. Zalle: Where are you at? Okay, I don't have that on mine, but continue. Nicholle: You don't, okay, so are we not at the same thing? Zalle: Go ahead. Keep going. I'm just gonna Nicholle: So that would be, not knowing would be one of the hardest things because your mind can just come up with the worst case scenarios constantly. So now we're at act three. Zalle: Found it okay, cool. I was on the earlier one. That's why I had forgot had went back to try to do something for the TikTok. Was on the wrong tab. Okay. Well thank goodness the script was the script the same from what I was saying to yours, or was I just spitball it? ⁓ okay. I was I'm shocked you ain't never said what the hell is you reading? What are you reading? Okay. Nicholle: Mmm. And so far, yeah, no, no, was the same. No, no, I would. I'd be like, wait, where we at? Where we at? No, we got it. Zalle: Okay. Then April sixteenth, twenty sixteen, two years after Rebecca's murder, three years after Jessica's disappearance, Madison Nygaard. Nygaard? Madison Nygaard is sixteen years old. She's walking home from a late night party in Norton Shores. It's Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Why? I'm gonna skip that. Madison Nygaard is sixteen years old. She's walking home from a late night party in Norton Shores alone. Nicholle: A silver minivan pulls up. The driver is a middle-aged man, white, glasses, grandfatherly. He offers her a ride and she says no at first. But then he lets her use her phone to call for a ride. And when she gets in the van, he locks the doors, pulls a gun and drives. Zalle: Madison later described what happened next as I asked to use his cell phone and he was like, It's dead. And he's just staring at me the entire time. And I'm like, let me out, let me out, let me out. And he's just staring at me. And then that's when he reached under and grabbed his gun. That's gotta be horrifying for a 16 year old. Cause first of all, why did you offer me the phone to turn around and be like, it's dead? And now you're just staring at me? Nicholle: ⁓ my goodness, for ⁓ my goodness. Right. Right. And then you're just staring at me. ⁓ my goodness. That's terrifying. Zalle: Yeah. I d just started hitting his ass. I'ma hit you before you even got a chance to grab some shit because you're being fucking creep. Nicholle: Right. But Madison is smart. She's brave and she waits. She watches for a moment and when the van slows down, she unlocks the door and jumps. She hits the pavement, rolls and runs. She pounds on the door of a nearby house. The homeowner opens the door, sees a terrified teenage girl and calls 911. Zalle: And she definitely has props for that shit because you have to think about being in her situation. First of all, most people aren't gonna jump out of moving vehicles because of the fear of getting hurt on the jump. Okay. That's fear number one. Secondly, she's probably it most definitely terrified for her life after this weirdo just grabbed her into this van and has a gun. So she's fighting two fears. So she really had to just pick which one am I more afraid of and just Nicholle: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. Zalle: Fuck it, just jumped out of the van. So kudos to you, Madison, because to be a teenager, smart thinking. You didn't let fear paralyze you. The 911 call though, it is chilling. Madison is hysterical but coherent. She describes the van, she describes the driver, she describes the gun, and within hours, police have a name. Jeffrey Willis. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yes. Smart thinking. Yeah. Authorities believe Willis attempted to shoot at Madison as she fled, but the gun jammed. Two unspent bullet cartridges were found near the scene. Zalle: Which is e that is even more horrifying because that was that would whatever y'all believe in, whatever higher power, that's what that was. Yeah. That is what that was. Yeah. Willis is arrested that same night, thankfully. He he is a forty six year old grandfather, a furniture factory worker, a guy who lives with his wife in Muskegon Township. He has no criminal record, no red flags. Heck. Nicholle: Right. That was her guardian angel. That was her guardian angel because that is terrifying. Zalle: Go. Go Go. You ready to go night night? You ready to go night night? Then go watch your TV. You come in here again, you're gonna go night night. No. Then get out. He looks so funny walking away with this little blurry thing on. Nicholle: you Zalle: No red flags, just a normal looking guy in a normal looking van. Nicholle: But when police searched that van, they find something that changes everything. A hidden compartment behind the driver's seat, a padlocked toolbox, and inside that toolbox, handcuffs, rope, chains, a small gag, a ball gag, leather restraints, syringes, vials of insulin, Viagra, poo, and a laminated diagram of a human body showing injection sites. Zalle: The insulin is to kill them, obviously. Yes. It's so it's a r it's a rape kit, a t a a torture kit, a mobile murder chamber, which is insane because you have obviously had to spend time in putting this compartment into the car and then making this kit. And it was all just hidden in this minivan that he was just driving around and grabbing women. Horrifying. Nicholle: Yes. you thought about it. Mm-hmm. Mm. Zalle: And and men are Yeah, you don't have to worry about anything. We're not the problem. no, it's not. It is not. But and we're not saying that it's men that is the problem. We're saying that when women speak up, what I'm saying is that when women speak up about, hey, these are the kind of fears that we have to live day by day, men are normally like, Yeah, you don't have we don't know, you're making shit up, it's your own anxiety. But no, it's not. Like, look at how many cases it is like this. And the there what they weren't doing shit to nobody. Nicholle: It's not all men. Yeah, it's not all men. I get tired of hearing that. Bye. Bye. Mm-hmm. Right. Great. Nope. Nope. Zalle: How people normally like, ⁓ they're they have they're a prostitute or they're doing this or they're doing that. It's none of these stigmas in these cases for you to even so what is the reasoning? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. But ⁓ I wasn't saying it to counter you. I'm saying that that's what men say. It's not all men. Of course it's not all men. That's not the point. The point is that the men that it is that do do these things terrorize women. And then when they say something about it, it's been normalized for them to feel like they're being hysterical or overreacting, even when they notice things that are off about men. Zalle: No, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. When they notice things, yes. Yes. That's why so many women in like stalking cases, once it gets to the point where somebody's actually kidnapped them or they're hurt, they've ignored their intuition for how long because the police have been like, ⁓ well they're that's nothing, or friends have tried to downplay it, or even they they have in their own mind tried to make it seem like, ⁓ maybe I'm tripping. Because of what it you know, how people talk to us, like you all make things up, you're being extra and no we're not. We literally have to fear for our lives every day, just going to the car. Nicholle: Yeah, so it's ridiculous. Right. Right. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Everywhere. Zalle: Just walking out of the door. Like those two women in that apartment complex. I can't even remember what case that was, where they both on separate occasions, they went to go wash their clothes and they left their back door open or whatever it was so they could get back into their house. And somebody went in. This man went into both apartments and killed both of these women in the same apartment complex. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Wow. Zalle: They were just trying to wash clothes. Nicholle: just living their daily life. Zalle: Living their daily life. But for this situation, the van is just the beginning. Police also search Willis's home and find a portable hard drive. And on that drive, a folder labeled VIX, obviously for victims. And inside are subfolders with initials. Okay. Subfolders with their actual initials. One says J H, one says RB, Jessica Haringa. Rebecca Bletch, that's how I said it. Bletch. Nicholle: Relax. He kept photos, dates, and notes. He was cataloging his crimes like they were trophies, like they were a project. Prosecutor DJ Healson described the discovery. They discovered a file folder labeled VIX. Inside that folder, there were two subfolders, one containing the initials of Rebecca Bletch. Yes. So you could just cut that part out. Go ahead. Zalle: That's repeating what I just said. And then there's the gun. A twenty-two caliber pistol found under the driver's seat. Ballistics testing matches it to the shell casings from Rebecca Bletch's murder scene. The same gun that killed her was in the van that Madison escaped from. And there was more. Willis' DNA was found on the weapon and blood matching Bletch's was found on athletic gloves discovered in the van. He didn't he didn't even try to clean it up. He kept everything in one spot. He just knew he wasn't gonna get caught. Nicholle: He didn't. He didn't. didn't. And prosecutor DJ Heelson describes the moment they connected the cases. He says, it was like watching a puzzle come together in real time. The van, the gun, the computer files, the timeline, everything pointed to one man. Zalle: That had to have been awesome for the police to be able to be like, we finally got him. Yeah. Right. But here's the part that makes my blood run cold. Okay. Wilson had been driving around in that van for three years. Three years. And nobody knew. Not his wife, not his family, not his coworkers. He was a grandfather who went to work, came home, and then went out hunting people in his minivan. It wasn't even like Nicholle: Like, yeah, you're right. That is so terrifying. Zalle: Yes, because it's not even like one of those, you know, like kidnap vans, like we call them, the white vans with the slidey doors. You know, it wasn't even one of the it's just a regular, daggula, gray minivan. Nicholle: Right. Mm-hmm. That's crazy. That is terrifying. Madison Nygaard, I know, Madison Nygaard in her firsthand account described the fear, the calculation, the split second decision to jump. She says she knew if she didn't get out, she wouldn't get out at all. Zalle: Horrifying. Yep. That's what I was saying. She had to decide which one she was more afraid of, not living or getting Kurt jumped out of this fan. So then we fast forward to November two thousand seventeen. Jeffrey Willis goes on trial for the murder of Rebecca Blitz. The prosecution's case is built on the ballistics match, the computer files, and the pattern of behavior. But there's no DNA from the crime scene, no eyewitness, just science and circumstance. And it sucks because I mean Nicholle: Right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: If you look back, that's not always the best for cases, even if it is a solid case, because what do we do with no DNA and no body? Yeah. Nicholle: You're right. Because if it's circumstantial, of circumstantial almost leads right into a shadow of a doubt because we have nothing solid saying this. And Willis's defense attorney, Fred Johnson, argues that the evidence is circumstantial, that the gun could have been planted, that the computer files don't prove murder. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Nicholle: that Willis is a weird guy with weird hobbies, not a killer. Okay, I'm sorry. The computer files definitely says, I mean, there's for me, like, wow, a circumstantial is not DNA. Right? It's circumstantial is not DNA, but that is circumstantial evidence that brings everything together, even though we don't have DNA, because before there was DNA, they still put people in prison. Zalle: Okay, so what is the weird hobby? Okay. How does that not okay, ⁓ yes, yes. Nicholle: sometimes, you know, rightfully so. Zalle: But he had photos of these women, n like the dates they were murdered, notes about all of that. And I'm sure that they didn't put the the dates, at least especially for which one? It was Jessica, who wasn't heard from again. They just have the day she disappeared. You don't know that's the day that she died. So, you know what I'm saying? The information he has in there definitely screams killer. Nicholle: Right. I don't know what they're talking about. Mm-hmm. That's right. That is like right before confession. Like we have all the details he unwittingly gave us. Zalle: I don't I don't understand I don't understand that. It sucks 'cause that it has to be labeled under circumstantial, but for you to be like, it's a weird hobby w so what is the hobby? Nicholle: How do you explain the details in the information that they have? It links him to those women. it's not like he has a file with multiple many names in there and these three women just happen to be on this list. Those are the folders on that drive. Zalle: Yeah. And then the rape and torture kit in the van. It's just those. Yeah. Obviously. So luckily, the jury didn't buy that he wasn't a killer. Okay. They saw the toolbox. They see the VIX folder. They see the timeline. Rebecca's murder in 2014. Madison's escape in 2016. Both connected to the same van, the same gun, the same man. Nicholle: May. Woof woof woof woof Zalle: So on November second, twenty seventeen, Jeffrey Willis is convicted of first degree murder. Nicholle: And six weeks later, on December 18th, 2017, he's sentenced to life without parole. But here's the part that shows you who he really is. Willis refused to sit and listen to the victim's impact statements. On his way out of court, he blew a kiss to Rebecca's family. Zalle: He literally did. He literally did, which was in I saw a picture. I don't have it. I gotta go back and get. And so because because of him doing that, refusing to hear what they had to say, they made it a law in Rebecca's name, where now that's not an option. You're forced to hear the victim statements. You don't have the choice to get up. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right, it shouldn't be. If we have to gag you and tie you to the chair, you are going to listen to them. Zalle: Yeah. But Rebecca's sister, Jessica Josephson, said he got his way and got to walk out and not listen to us. But the sheriff had an idea. He asked prosecutor DJ Hilson if they could play the audio of the family's victim impact statements during Willis's transport from court to prison. Brilliant. But because now you don't have a fucking choice. Sit your ass in the back and listen to what they had to say. Yeah. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. That is the, You don't have a choice. That's right. It will stop if it goes longer than this ride to the prison. Zalle: Yeah, yeah. And obviously the prosecutor agreed, okay, and they played it loud and then they played it over and over again. Because if you had just sat in the courtroom, you only would have had to listen listen to it one time. But then you tried to blow them a kiss on the way out, like kiss my ass. ⁓ okay, yeah, we got something for you. Here we go. I will put it on the prison speakers and play that shit for forty eight hours straight. Yeah. Nicholle: Right. Amazing. That's right. It's amazing. ⁓ yeah. ⁓ yeah. That's right, we're playing for everybody to hear every night at three o'clock in the middle of the night. We're going to play this. Zalle: We could play this shit. Yeah, what is wrong with you? Nicholle: And defense attorney Fred Johnson confirmed they played it loud and they played it for him over and over again. He didn't stand up there and take it, but he heard it. Zalle: As he should have. And Rebecca's family in the courtroom. Rebecca's family is in the courtroom. Her daughter Ellie, now a teenager, watches the man who killed her mother be led away in c in handcuffs. Her sister Nicole and Jessica hold each other and cry. It's not closure, it's justice. And justice is all they have. Me? Use your back. May twenty eighteen, six months after the blush conviction, Willis goes on trial again, this time for Jessica Haringa's kidnapping and murder. But there's a problem. Jessica's body has never been found. There's no DNA, no crime scene, just a missing woman and a fan a fan. A van full of horror. And this is gonna be horrible because like we were saying earlier, nobody, no case. You really can't charge anybody without the body. Nicholle: Press it. Mm-hmm. So prosecutor DJ Hilson has to build a case without a body. He uses the computer files, the VIX folder with Jessica's initials. He uses the witness description of a silver minivan and he uses the pattern, isolated location, vulnerable women and abduction. And he uses medicine like guards testimony. What Willis did to her is what he did to Jessica. Zalle: Willis's cousin, Kevin Bloom, becomes a key figure. Block as a sergeant at the West Shoreline Correctional Facility, a state prison in Muskegon Heights. He knew Wilson, obviously, because that was his cousin. What did I say? Okay. He knew Willis. And under questioning, he admits that Willis confessed to him that he helped Willis dispose of Jessica's body. Nicholle: Wellies. He knew Wellies. Wilson. What? Zalle: and that he knew where she was buried. Nicholle: Wow. Bloom told police he saw Jessica with an obvious head wound, face down, hands out, tied. She was naked and wasn't moving. He said Willis had been following or watching Jessica, hit her to make her unconscious, then got her in the van. He said Willis raped her, used sexual toys and torture. Then they wrapped her in a sheet and drove her to an area on Sheridan Road near Laketon Road. where Willis had already dug a hole and placed shovels. Together they buried her. I hope this man goes to prison. That is ridiculous. Zalle: So the fact this tells you how prepared though that Willis was at you already had the hole dug with shovels there you Nicholle: Right. Zalle: Why not do it by yourself? Why get your cousin involved to help get rid of the body? You already got to the point where I mean, yes, but you're already to the point where you've got the at the the correctional facility. But by but you already have the whole duck. It's nothing you just gotta put dirt on top of her. You've done everything else. What now you tired after all the torture? Nicholle: Well, because clearly your cousin is an idiot and went along with it and he works there. Yeah. It had to be, he probably got some type of pleasure out of including someone else in on it. It had to be, because he had done it by himself already. Zalle: Maybe. Maybe. Yeah. But Bloom leads police to the field. They search for days. They find nothing. Jessica Horinga is still missing, but Bloom's testimony, his admission that Willis told him everything, becomes the cornerstone of the prosecution's case. Nicholle: On May 16th, 2018, Jeffrey Willis is convicted of Jessica Haringa's kidnapping and murder. Another life sentence. The judge makes it clear Willis will never see the outside of a prison again. Zalle: As he should not. Nicholle: right. And I hope they torture him in prison every day. I hope that he has ingrown toenails that his stomach hurts so bad from the bad food in there that all he could do is sit on the toilet. And I hope that they just gang rape him on a nightly basis. Zalle: Jessica's mother Shelley. ⁓ go ahead. I'm gonna definitely take that last part out. I'm gonna leave the ingrown toed out. Nicholle: I hope that they gang rape him out, they take pipes and ram him up his ass. Zalle: Jessica's mother Shelley. Okay. All right. Are you done? Okay. Jessica's mother Shelly is in the courtroom. She's been searching for her daughter for five years. She still doesn't have a body to bury, but she has justice. And she said something that breaks your heart. I just want to bring her home, even if it's just her bones. Nicholle: but not enough to kill him. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm gonna stop interrupting you. I'm But here's something heartbreaking. Jessica's family has never publicly supported Willis's prosecution. They never believed he is the person responsible for her disappearance. They contend that she is still alive. ⁓ my goodness, hope can be horrible sometimes. Zalle: Heartbreaking. It really can. It really can. That makes it hard though, you know, like for them to say that this is who did it and the family be like, Yeah, but we don't really support that. Nicholle: Because think about how hard you have to work to make yourself believe that she's alive and you're not going to let go of that that easily. Like because there is nobody for the parents that shows how difficult these circumstantial cases can be because even the parents don't believe it because it's hard for them to let go of the belief she's still alive without her body. Do you need to go check on the boy? Zalle: After five years. Yeah. Right. I heard something moving. I was like, What okay. I'll die. What was he doing? The boy got rocks. Nicholle: Give me a second. What was he doing? Zalle: He's stacking them on the counter. Nicholle: You are brave because I feel like he is always gonna throw whatever he has in his hand. Zalle: You had to come in here. Nicholle: We're almost done. I can tell by my scroll bar on the side, we're almost to the bottom. I need just two minutes, Taylor. Finish what you're doing. Give me two minutes. You can take all this time. Zalle: Are you done then? Move your hand. Are you done boo boo? Can you wipe your butt? Nicholle: I don't have any insurance. Zalle: Do you see these pants? Nicholle: Huh? Are they big? I can't really see because of the blur. Zalle: These pants these pants used to like stick into my stomach where I couldn't wear them and now they just fit. Like they're almost they're almost big. If I move around too much, they start to like fall down. I know! Nicholle: there to be. Awesome. Alright, Zaynlee. Give it just a minute, girl. You're gonna be walking around with that body you had before them babies. Zalle: I know I mean like Jamaian gonna know what to do with me. He don't know what to do with me. Nicholle: I bet you ain't gonna be talking about I don't know if this is working. You don't be like come give me some of that pretty booty you got. Give me some of that. Don't even worry about it. ⁓ Do I see a figure behind you in the other door or what's that behind you? Zalle: Well, bet don't even worry about it because me and Devin gonna be outside. Fuck you mean You mean in this? That's Nicholle: in that other doorway. Is that just their room? It's like a dark, like back, back toward their room. Is that just like the entrance to their room? Zalle: In the actual doorway? Yeah, that's their room. That bathroom doors in the middle and then the little thing, the little blur on this end. Is that sh bike thing Jermaine got for jelly. Yeah, don't do that. For jelly. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Oh, okay. He got for what? Jelly. I thought he said, you said from Cali. I was like, why? They got, we got bikes here. Oh, okay, go ahead. Let's finish it up. Let's get it done so we can go on about our day and regroup, work on this. I'm gonna pick one. I'm gonna pick a big one. Do you want it to be the yoga shop killer? Just what you want it be the next. Zalle: No, Jelly got a little bike. You could push him in. Okay. That has to be one of the ones that we do because it's already done. We could just get it out of the way. Nicholle: Okay, work on that one. I'm gonna work on another. I'm come up with the one for us to do not for next Monday, but the one the following Monday. And that way we have all them weeks to study. Zalle: Okay, do the book, get out. Go on. Do pick that one and pick another small one. That we can do on no. Nicholle: Okay, look at that. Am I losing hair right here? Okay. Zalle: I'm gonna hang up. I'm gonna hang up. Okay. Cause you the one that be like, you gotta watch your words. You gotta watch your words. And every time we get on here you got something to say about which to look Nicholle: I don't see my, I don't look at myself. ⁓ you're right. You're right. You're right, Zayley. You're right. You're right. You're right. But maybe it's just tone wrong. Zalle: Don't wanna look at it! Nicholle: Why are you so angry? It's okay. Zalle: Let it go to go. GET OUT HERE! ⁓ you wanna kiss me? Okay. Go get your own. Go. Trying to keep him up tonight. That's why he's not asleep. See how today goes without a nap. Go, no, no, no, go in your room. Because you decide you don't want to put your drawers back on. Okay. But we need to stop and talk about Kevin Bloom because his story is maybe the most infuriating part of this whole case, or one of the most infuriating parts of this whole case. Nicholle: Yeah. Kevin Laverne Bloom was a Michigan Department of Corrections prison guard, a sergeant at West Shoreline Correctional Facility, a law enforcement officer. And he knew what Willis did. He knew about Jessica, he knew about the body, and for three years, he said nothing. Zalle: It wasn't until the police questioned him after Madison's escape that he finally cracked. On june twenty first, two thousand sixteen, he was charged for lying. Hold on. He was charged with lying to a police officer during a violent crime investigation. He told police information about Jessica's air Jessica's disappearance that wasn't public, then recanted it. He was charged with the same crime in the Blesh case. Get out! Here, here, I don't want it. Doodab, come here. Here. make you go night night. Then get your ass on. Go play. Go. Go play. Bye. Bye. Stedaddle. Well Nicholle: Ready? Zalle: He told pol I'm yeah, I'm gonna re read the last thing 'cause he came in kind of naked. He told police information about Jessica's disappearance that wasn't public, then recanted it. He was charged with the same crime in the Blesh case. Nicholle: Okay. Bloom pleaded guilty to both counts on August 26, 2016, and he was sentenced to time served, but that was just the beginning. He was also charged with being an accessory after the fact when he admitted he saw Willis with Jessica's body and helped him bury her. Zalle: The fact that he was sentenced to time served. Nicholle: ⁓ I'm not talking because nothing I say you're going to be able to keep on this recording. Zalle: Okay. All right. On November twenty seventh, two thousand seventeen, Bloom pleaded no contest to accessory after the fact. And on January ninth, twenty eighteen, he was sentenced to time served four hundred and seventy-six days in jail plus five years probation in order to wear a GPS tether for at least one year. He walked out of a courtroom a free man. Nicholle: He was a prison guard who helped cover up a murder, who saw Jessica's naked body found, who helped bury her, who said nothing for three years while her mother searched and he walked free. I'm not saying anything, I'm just not even gonna. Zalle: Yeah. investigators are still visibly angry about Bloom's sentence as they should. As the fuck they should, because why did you waste my time for you to sentence this piece of man to time served? Nicholle: They should. I mean, like, I understand that he didn't kill anyone, but he is a correctional officer who knew and helped bury her and said nothing. He should be in that same prison that he was a guard at. There's absolutely no way he should be walking anywhere free. Zalle: Bury her. Yeah. Yeah, no, he should not. He sh should not. What I say? They said that Bloom could have ended the search years earlier. He could have given Jessica's family peace. Instead, he protected his cousin and let a mother suffer. Which is that is what he did. Nicholle: And here's the kicker. That is exactly what he did. And here's the kicker. Bloom's light sentence was partly because prosecutors needed his testimony to convict Willis. They made a deal, justice for Jessica in exchange for leniency for the man who helped bury her. It's a trade that still sits wrong with a lot of people. And I know that they have to make these deals in order to get the information. for them to tell them what's going on. But I don't think anybody should walk free for that type of, that there's just, you need to spend some time in jail. Zalle: No. Sometime. For sure. I agree. In twenty eighteen, Michigan Governor Rick Snyder signed House Bill 4123, the Rebecca Bliss Law. It the Rebecca Blitz Law into law. It requires convicted criminals to physically be present in the courtroom and listen to victim impact statements during sentencing. No more walking out like Willis did. No more blowing kisses to grieving families because ⁓ he should have got knocked off. Fuck out for doing it in the first place. Nicholle: He should have. Her family did good because we'd have been on the news. Yeah, no doubt. Absolutely no doubt. Michigan, I'm so mad. The Michigan House passed it 105 to two in March of 2018. It was signed into law on May 24th, 2018, effective immediately. State representatives Holly Hughes. Zalle: Mm-hmm. ⁓ yeah, we would have jumped all the bailiffs to get to him. Nicholle: State Representative Holly Hughes from Muskegon County created the bill after watching Willis refuse to hear Rebecca's family speak. Zalle: But there's another legacy here. Jessica Hiringa's Jessica Heringa's disappearance helped push legislation requiring security cameras at gas stations, the very thing that could have prevented her vanishing. Her mother Shelley had been advocating for it since twenty thirteen. Nicholle: But Jessica Haringa is still missing. Her body has never been found. Her mother Shelly still holds vigils, still puts up flyers, still hopes that someday, somehow, she'll bring her daughter home. Zalle: Shelley is often seen at memorials. She's surrounded by family, friends, strangers who never met Jessica but feel like they know her. Because her face has been on flyers, on news reports, on social media for years. She's become a symbol, a reminder, a ghost that haunts the community. Nicholle: And Jeffrey Willis, he's serving two life sentences in Michigan prison. And he's serving two life sentences in a Michigan prison. He'll die there. But for the families, that's not enough because they still don't have Jessica. They still don't have all the answers. They just have a man in a cell and a van that's been crushed into scrap metal. Zalle: And I feel like it's so hard to be like, Yeah, okay, we got justice because now he's in prison, but like he's alive. Nicholle: Right. Zalle: He's alive. Whoever wants to come see him can come see him. Yeah. Nicholle: That's why I said I that every day is miserable, is hell for him in that prison. Zalle: Mm. The van was destroyed after the trials. Too horrific to be sold, too tainted to be reused. It became evidence, then it became trash. But the memory of what was inside it, that stays with everyone who saw it. Nicholle: and Madison Nygaard, she said prosecutors decision to drop the attempted abduction charges against Willis felt like a huge slap in my face. She wanted her day in court. She wanted to look him in the eye and say, you didn't win. But prosecutor DJ Hilsen explained Willis had been convicted of two separate counts of first degree murder. He was essentially going to die in prison. There was no need to move forward with another case. And I hate that for her. Zalle: That is your personal fucking opinion. You don't want to move forward because he had yeah, be for because what you're saying, what he said is correct. He does have these two already. So on a like logical standpoint, I get what you're saying. But you have to think of somebody who just went through all this horrible shit. I don't give I don't care about logic. Fuck logic. I care about emotions and being able to heal. And for somebody Nicholle: Yeah, I hate that for her. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. And she's the one who made it possible for you to find him to find who killed these other two women. Right? No, no way. You know, no, I'm sorry. Zalle: Yes, and you just dismissed her charges. No, no, no. You I definitely should have been able to look him in his face and told him you're one, you're a fucking coward. And two, this is what the fuck you get and I'm the reason why you're in here. Nicholle: Right. and Right. Yeah, it's me. And the fact that she wanted that day in court, that she wasn't fearful. She is the reason that he was caught. She was strong enough. And I don't want to say strong enough to make it seem like people who don't do it aren't strong, but she had whatever it took within her to jump out of that van to get away from him. And she was only 16 years old. She deserved her day in court. And you know, Zayli, I've been thinking about what this story really means. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Yeah, she did. Yeah. Nicholle: It's story about the monster next door, the grandfather who wasn't, the furniture factory worker who built a torture chamber in his minivan, and the man who looked so normal that nobody suspected him until this 16-year-old girl refused to be his next victim. Zalle: It's also a story about bravery, about Madison Nygaard who jumped from the moving van rather than becoming a folder on a computer. About the investigators who never close the files, about the families who never stopped searching, about a law that says no criminal gets to walk out while victims still have something to say. Nicholle: Jeffrey Willis spent years hiding behind a grandfather's mile. He built a torture chamber in his minivan. He cataloged his victims like they were trophies. And he would have kept killing if Madison hadn't said no, if she hadn't jumped, if she hadn't run. Zalle: Yeah, so which makes it even more fucked up that she didn't get her day in court because sh because on top of all of this, I don't feel like she even thinks of herself as a hero. I feel like she just did what she had to do to survive. But for obviously Jessica Haringa's family and for Rebecca Blett's family, or for every woman who might have been in the van after that, she was everything because she's literally the only reason why he was stopped. Nicholle: That's right. That's right. That's she's the only reason. Yeah. Jessica. No, She had to go through that trauma, but she got out of there and she is the reason that he's in prison now. Jessica Haringa is still missing. Rebecca Blitch is still gone, but they're killers behind bars and a 16 year old girl proved. Zalle: Literally the only reason why. It wasn't the cops who caught him. It wasn't like they saved the day. It's because of Jessica. Yeah. Nicholle: that sometimes the only way out is through the door, even if it's moving at 40 miles an hour. Zalle: This has been Coffee and Carn with Mom, I'm Zalee. Nicholle: and I'm Nicole. Stay caffeinated, stay curious, and we'll see you next time. Zalle: I'm gonna move. Why didn't we say that earlier? ⁓ well, it could stay there. Nicholle: What? Zalle: Normally we say that at the beginning. Welcome to Coffee and Carn with mom the zaily and I'm Nicole right here. Nicholle: ⁓ yeah, but it's just, and thank you for this has been Coffee and Crack. It's just Andy. If you want to take that out, I don't care, but it's just Andy. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. No, I'm just saying I don't know why we didn't say it earlier. Nicholle: We did say it, didn't say it all. Zalle: Mm mm. Nicholle: ⁓ okay. Well, you can always play that clip of us that we have wherever it's at, the recording we first did. Zalle: Okay, so let's just do you can say welcome to Coffee and Crying with Mom. I'm Nicole or however you do it. And then I'll say I'm Zaylee. And then I'll just edit it in where we had the w today we're telling the whole story, the disappearances, the toolbox. No. Or you wouldn't just leave it. Nicholle: So you just want me to say, welcome to Coffee and Cry. I'm Nicole Mom, and then you say your part, and you're just gonna put that in there. Yeah, that's fine up here. Welcome to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Nicole, mom. Zalle: And I'm Daily. And then I'll just push that in there in the part are okay. Nicholle: Okay, awesome.