Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1028: Leading Through Change: Adaptive Leadership in Public Health
Transcript
- 0:00This is Public Health Review Morning Edition for Monday,
- 0:03November 17th, 2025. I'm John Sheehan with news from
- 0:07the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.
- 0:11Today we'll be discussing adaptive leadership in public
- 0:14health and how it can help build trust, strengthen community
- 0:17partnerships, and Dr. meaningful change across systems.
- 0:21We have two guests from the Public Consulting Group.
- 0:24A founding member of Asto's Innovation Advisory Council, Ida
- 0:28Johnson is an associate manager. A part of the solution to
- 0:32today's problems, I think, though, isn't going to be just
- 0:34around the newest tool or the newest technology or the shiny
- 0:38thing, right? Really, it's going to be around
- 0:41the approach to leadership. And Lillian Shirley is a senior
- 0:44public health advisor. So adaptive leadership moves
- 0:47away from the top down leadership style and instead it
- 0:50gets guidance from those who are doing the work and experiencing
- 0:54the problem. It helps our science based data
- 0:58land in a way that communities can see how it relates to what
- 1:02they're experiencing. Drawing from real world
- 1:05initiatives, they'll share practical insights on adaptive
- 1:08leadership as well as leading with empathy, collaboration and
- 1:12purpose in today's complex public health landscape.
- 1:16I think that in public health, we often truly believe that
- 1:21leading all solutions with the science and the evidence is the
- 1:25the most prominent thing. And while yes, I agree that is
- 1:29important, maybe instead of solely relying just on that,
- 1:33when you can bring in an adaptive leadership mindset, it
- 1:36pushes leaders to think also about how that wisdom is really
- 1:41sourced from our communities. So if we start with the platform
- 1:45of our science clients, but then go into more of a curiosity and
- 1:49inquiry mindset, understanding how the communities actually
- 1:52interpret and relate to it, this is going to be more beneficial
- 1:56and advantageous. So of course, that doesn't mean
- 1:59that we're just asking communities how they want us to
- 2:01fix the problem, rather asking about their perspective on how
- 2:05the problem or the challenge is really understood and how they
- 2:09feel it, right? How do they relate to the
- 2:12solutions that we can provide them?
- 2:14Does it make sense for their daily lives?
- 2:17This should really be able to help tailor your decision making
- 2:20and then move forward with the programmatic or the technical
- 2:23issues, right? So in looking at the landscape,
- 2:26our community engagement practices have absolutely
- 2:29improved over the past five years, right?
- 2:31But there really needs to be that follow up step to the
- 2:34collection of input and drawing out from our communities and
- 2:39really making sure that the priorities and the practices to
- 2:42help their families are relevant to them so that we can get the
- 2:46best outcomes and that adaptive leadership will allow us to flex
- 2:50in a way that is more responsive.
- 2:52Adaptive leadership moves away from relying solely on the
- 2:56science as the reason to adopt health practices, but rather
- 3:00present the science and then ask how could this work in your
- 3:03life? What's missing?
- 3:05And I don't think we can say this too often or repeated
- 3:09enough. Kind of go into inquiry as
- 3:12opposed to didactic. Understand what that guidance
- 3:16means to the community and how they would apply it.
- 3:19Being honest and transparent with humility and working to
- 3:23achieve a solution together with those constraints.
- 3:26These are not new ideas, but these are ideas I think we have
- 3:30to remember there isn't something new maybe going back
- 3:34to that basics. It's important to be honest
- 3:37about resource deficits, limitations, and challenges that
- 3:41public health agencies face. But also being forthright about
- 3:46what you can do allows people to manage expectations on how
- 3:50programs can deliver and also how they may find solutions and
- 3:55offer it to us on how to deliver.
- 3:58Ida says that public health leaders can begin applying
- 4:01adaptive leadership into their communication strategies.
- 4:04I actually worked in hospital administration for nearly a
- 4:07decade. And what I've seen working in
- 4:10that operations world is that traditionally communication has
- 4:13fallen on the shoulders of the community health workers, the
- 4:16navigators, right, those on the frontline.
- 4:19However, as I mentioned earlier, everything rises and falls based
- 4:23on leadership. So this task should really be
- 4:26shared by everyone within the agency.
- 4:28And it's the leadership responsibility to really be able
- 4:31to relate, be among the community in a different we
- 4:35can't continue to delegate it solely to the community health
- 4:37workers and those delivering those services.
- 4:40And collaboration with other public health agencies can
- 4:43definitely improve messaging to communities.
- 4:46To start, we really need to, you know, get to the balcony, so to
- 4:51speak, get the bird's eye view of the problem.
- 4:53And once we do that, the public health leaders really can
- 4:57continue to build those partnerships with other agencies
- 5:01like the social services, child welfare and aging and disability
- 5:05services, those Human Services, right, to address common complex
- 5:09problems like homelessness, substance abuse, the chronic
- 5:13disease, working together. If we do that, then we're
- 5:16breaking out of the silos of funding in programs.
- 5:19And that's something that's needed in these times.
- 5:21Learning from these agencies about how they're approaching
- 5:24some of the same issues and problems from their purview, and
- 5:28then build on that where our knowledge and expertise can
- 5:32really, really help. I do think that this is
- 5:35especially relevant with the emergency and incident response
- 5:39strategies that oftentimes require resources from multiple
- 5:44parts of our safety net. And it doesn't just start with
- 5:47going to the meeting. We've all been to the meeting,
- 5:48right? You have to be informed with the
- 5:50strategic plans of other agencies so that we can pull
- 5:54those best ideas. And so when we're understanding
- 5:57their goals and priorities, we can align with our shared values
- 6:02and determine where everyone's capabilities and strengths can
- 6:05really complement theirs. I just wanted to share just this
- 6:09week Oregon announced an initiative called Move Oregon
- 6:13Health Forward Pledge and it's an initiative that has a
- 6:16concrete and accountable basic health and all policies approach
- 6:21has a plan across the various sectors in the state, including
- 6:25importantly not just Human Services, but business partners
- 6:29for how to reach public health goals in that state.
- 6:33In addition, in Maine, Maine Health has a system wide
- 6:37initiative that forwards public health community outcomes, again
- 6:41working across sectors with a common goal.
- 6:45These are not things that we don't know and understand.
- 6:49For instance, health and all policies is something that has
- 6:53been part and parcel of our public health practice, both
- 6:57academically and as we've done our community health improvement
- 7:02plans, et cetera. But this really puts a
- 7:05discipline around it and a shared commitment to focus on
- 7:09this, for leadership to have that as a priority.
- 7:12I totally agree wholeheartedly and these are excellent
- 7:16examples. I would also say that PCG has
- 7:19done many cross sector initiatives to facilitate this
- 7:23type of shared problem solving with representatives from
- 7:26behavioral health, substance use, and health plans.
- 7:29I've seen this and supported work in Maine, in California,
- 7:34Oregon, and in other states nationally.
- 7:37And what this looked like was getting the frontline providers
- 7:40together, the managers, the directors in mapping out the
- 7:44barriers, yes, with the sticky notes from, you know, pre 2020
- 7:48and brainstorming possible solutions to their thorniest
- 7:52problems. Using a quality improvement
- 7:55process to really govern those conversations and have them
- 7:59centered around things that are as complex, from data sharing
- 8:03and data sharing agreements to the more common ones, such as
- 8:06just the resources that are limited and our coordination and
- 8:10care. Here are some of Ida and
- 8:13Lillian's final thoughts. I think one of the things that
- 8:16we heard loud and clear at NATO this past summer is that we
- 8:20really do need to start working with our Human Services agencies
- 8:25because our public health work comes out of the Human Services
- 8:29practice area. Here at Public Consulting Group,
- 8:31we are very familiar with that and have seen time and time
- 8:35again that we are all working on the same problems.
- 8:38And if we come to the table with our mindset of that health and
- 8:43all policies and saying how do you all work towards this
- 8:47problem, I think that we really, really can get far, especially
- 8:50in these times and build up a resilience in relationships that
- 8:55can be sustained over the next several decades.
- 8:59Yeah. And I would just add to that,
- 9:02you know, language changes and it comes to different ideas and
- 9:07different, you know, things come and go, you know, as time goes
- 9:12on. But I think one of the things we
- 9:14need to remember in public health as a profession, public
- 9:18health has always been about social justice.
- 9:21And it's our discipline and our work and our commitment to our
- 9:25communities that has helped make many, many outcomes for healthy
- 9:31communities. And we know, we know there's the
- 9:35little programmatic work that makes a big difference.
- 9:38And then there's also the overall system work that has
- 9:43made a difference. But we should stay optimistic
- 9:46because we know that we're connected to the communities
- 9:50that we face, and we know that everyone wants health for their
- 9:55families, their children and their communities, and that's
- 9:58our job. Lillian Shirley is a senior
- 10:02public health advisor and Ida Johnson is an associate manager,
- 10:06both of the Public Consulting Group, a founding member of
- 10:09Asto's Innovation Advisory Council.
- 10:12You can learn more about them at publicconsultinggroup.com or
- 10:16find the link in our show notes. I'm John Sheehan, and this has
- 10:20been another edition of Public Health Review Morning Edition
- 10:23from the Association of State and Territorial Health
- 10:26Officials.