Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 15% Debt Yields Are Breaking the AI Data Center Math
Transcript
- 0:00What if I told you that the company's building the future of
- 0:03artificial intelligence, the ones that are supposedly, you
- 0:06know, changing human history and dominating the news cycle right
- 0:09now? What if they're quietly getting
- 0:11crushed by the exact same boring math that dictates your monthly
- 0:15credit card bill? Yeah, it's a completely
- 0:17different narrative than what you see on TV, right?
- 0:19Exactly. So today we're looking right
- 0:22past all the AI hype. We're doing a deep dive into
- 0:25this massive data dump from a recent market wrap by the
- 0:28investor Steve Iseman. And this source material
- 0:31outlines shifting market narratives, spiking debt yields,
- 0:34and just a whole slew of recent corporate earnings reports.
- 0:37It really is a phenomenal collection of data, but you
- 0:41know, raw data alone isn't enough for us.
- 0:43Our goal today is to filter this entire avalanche of information
- 0:47for you through a very strict Benjamin Graham and Warren
- 0:50Buffett style deep value lens. Right, because we don't care
- 0:54about the shiny stories. Exactly.
- 0:57We are stripping away those shiny narratives and hunting for
- 1:00the absolute truth about a company's owner earnings.
- 1:04We really want to know how durable their business modes
- 1:07actually are, how management is allocating capital, and maybe
- 1:11most importantly, where the real margin of safety lies in a
- 1:14market that frankly feels increasingly disconnected from
- 1:17reality. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:19Because if you're holding a broad S&P index fund right now,
- 1:22you might be looking at some of these top line tech revenues and
- 1:25feeling pretty great about your retirement.
- 1:28But as we get into this, you'll see why the biggest take away
- 1:30from our source material isn't about what large language models
- 1:34can actually do. No, not at all, right?
- 1:36It's about how the unforgiving math of the fixed income market
- 1:39is quietly dismantling these high flying equity stories.
- 1:43Yeah. So to understand any business's
- 1:45intrinsic value, you always have to start at the bedrock of its
- 1:48capital structure. I mean, that means looking at
- 1:50sovereign and corporate debt, because the cost of borrowing
- 1:54money dictates a business's entire reality.
- 1:57And the source actually starts by highlighting this fascinating
- 2:00divergent at the sovereign level, specifically between
- 2:04French and US bonds. Yeah, Let's look at the numbers
- 2:07there because they're wild. France's debt to GDP ratio has
- 2:11hit 120%. And in the macroeconomic world,
- 2:14I mean that is the danger zone big time.
- 2:16So because of that massive debt load, the premium that investors
- 2:20demand just to hold French 10 year bonds over safer German
- 2:23bonds, it just spiked. It went up by 16 basis points to
- 2:27175 basis points, which is actually the highest level since
- 2:32the European sovereign debt crisis back in 2011.
- 2:35All right, and for anyone not fluent in Bonn speak, a basis
- 2:38point is just 100th of a percentage point.
- 2:41So 175 basis points spread basically means France has to
- 2:45pay 1.75% more in interest than Germany just to convince people
- 2:50to lend the money. Which sounds small, but it's
- 2:52really not. Oh, it's huge.
- 2:54When you're rolling over billions of dollars of national
- 2:56debt, that tiny fraction of a percent represents A
- 2:59catastrophic drain on a country's budget.
- 3:02But, and here is the critical value investing lesson about
- 3:06what we'd call a macro mode. By pure numerical logic, the
- 3:10United States should be in the exact same crisis.
- 3:13The US debt to GDP ratio is also sitting right around 120%.
- 3:18Wait, so why isn't the bond market punishing the US the way
- 3:21it's punishing France? Well, because the US dollar
- 3:24enjoys A structural monopoly on global liquidity, it's the
- 3:28global reserve currency, right? So the entire international
- 3:31financial system, we're talking trade, cross-border banking,
- 3:35commodity pricing, it all functions on U.S.
- 3:37Treasuries. Wow, so they're kind of trapped
- 3:40into using it. Exactly.
- 3:42Major institutions worldwide are practically forced to own U.S.
- 3:45debt just to do business. Absolutely no one is forced to
- 3:49own French sovereign bonds. So that right there that is a
- 3:52macro mote. OK, so the US has this
- 3:55incredible structural protection, but when we step
- 3:58down from, you know, the luxury of sovereign debt into the
- 4:01reality of corporate debt, specifically in the AI sector,
- 4:05that structural protection just vanishes.
- 4:08The math gets brutal really quickly.
- 4:10Oh, it really does. Yeah, the source points to this
- 4:13neocloud company called Cor Weave.
- 4:15They're a major player in building out AI data centers,
- 4:18and they just saw the cost of their debt climb dramatically
- 4:21from a 9% yield up to a 15% yield.
- 4:25What's fascinating here is that that is the exact number that
- 4:29should stop every single investor in their tracks.
- 4:32I mean a 15% cost of debt doesn't just like slow down
- 4:35growth, it completely annihilates your future free
- 4:38cash flow. How so?
- 4:40Like, break that down for us. Well, in Dee value investing,
- 4:43intrinsic value is basically just the discounted value of the
- 4:46cash that can be taken out of a business during its remaining
- 4:49life O Let's look at the actual mechanism here.
- 4:52If you borrow a billion dollars at a 15% interest rate to build
- 4:55an AI data center, you have to generate $150 million in pure
- 5:00bottom line cash profit every single year just to pay the
- 5:03interest. Just the interest.
- 5:04Just the interest. You haven't paid down a single
- 5:06cent of the actual loan and you definitely haven't made a dime
- 5:09for your shareholders. So the returns you need to
- 5:12generate just to break even, They become astronomical.
- 5:15I do have to challenge that premise a bit though.
- 5:18I mean, history shows us that in technology it's basically a
- 5:21winner take all game, right? If Core Weave stops building
- 5:25because the debt is too expensive, won't Amazon or
- 5:27Microsoft just crush them? Aren't these companies
- 5:30essentially forced to take that 15% debt just to survive the AI
- 5:34arms race? Because equity investors seem to
- 5:37be happily buying that growth story regardless of the capital
- 5:40intensity. Oh, they certainly are, but
- 5:43you're highlighting the exact trap that value investors try to
- 5:46avoid. As the source brilliantly puts
- 5:49it, equity investors love stories, but fixed income
- 5:53investors care about math. Math doesn't lie.
- 5:57Right. You cannot convince a bond
- 5:58market to lend to you at a low rate just because you have this
- 6:02terrifying story about your competitors beating you in the
- 6:04AI race. The bond market is entirely
- 6:08agnostic to your fear of missing out.
- 6:11You know it demands to see predictable cash flows.
- 6:13Makes sense? So if a major player like Core
- 6:16Weave is raising debt at 15%, that sets a benchmark for the
- 6:20entire industry, Basically means the underlying economics of
- 6:24building AI infrastructure are deteriorating rapidly.
- 6:28So that tension between a visionary story and harsh
- 6:30financial reality, I mean, that brings us to the ultimate case
- 6:33study in capital allocation. We have to talk about Elon
- 6:36Musk's empire. Oh yeah, we definitely do.
- 6:39If we're hunting for true owner earnings, the recent numbers
- 6:42from SpaceX and Tesla are just a master class in why you really
- 6:46have to read the fine print. So let's look at SpaceX first.
- 6:49If you just glance at the top line, it's pretty mind blowing.
- 6:52Total revenue was up 161% year over year.
- 6:55That's a massive jump. Massive the space division, hit
- 6:58$1.8 billion. Starlink, their satellite
- 7:01Internet business, hit 5.2 billion with a crazy 2.4 billion
- 7:05in profit. And their superintelligence
- 7:07division, which houses things like the Grok AI, that jumped to
- 7:11over 7.6 billion in revenue with a positive $431 million in
- 7:15profit. Sure.
- 7:16And on the surface, that looks like an unstoppable growth
- 7:18engine, right? But when we apply that Warren
- 7:21Buffett lens, we have to aggressively ignore the top line
- 7:25and hunt for the capital expenditures, the CapEx.
- 7:28Because CapEx is the money a company has to spend on physical
- 7:31assets just to like maintain or grow its business, right?
- 7:34Exactly. And CapEx eats free cash flow
- 7:37for breakfast. So the source points out this
- 7:40glaring red flag. Spacex's total CapEx for the
- 7:44quarter was an unbelievable $29.6 billion.
- 7:48Wait, almost 30 billion in 1/4? Yeah, that is up 185% from the
- 7:53previous quarter. And on top of that, there's star
- 7:56based facility down in Louisiana has a projected $100 billion
- 8:00budget. OK.
- 8:01So they're pulling in billions in revenue, but they are
- 8:05shoveling 10s of billions out the door just to build the
- 8:08physical infrastructure. Precisely.
- 8:10And look at the underlying mechanics of what they're
- 8:12actually building. Starlink was originally pitched
- 8:15to investors as this ultimate cash cow, a high margin business
- 8:19that would basically fund the mission to Mars.
- 8:20Right, that was always the story.
- 8:22But now Starlink is pivoting to compete directly with major
- 8:25mobile carriers like T-Mobile. Competing in global
- 8:28telecommunications means putting heavy hardware absolutely
- 8:32everywhere. So it's transforming Starlink
- 8:34from a cash generator into a massive cash drain.
- 8:38To fund this, SpaceX is going to have to raise billions in
- 8:41capital. And as we just established with
- 8:43Core Weave, raising capital for heavy infrastructure right now
- 8:46is painfully expensive. Wow.
- 8:48OK, so while SpaceX is burning through cash to build the
- 8:52future, Tesla seems to be hitting a pretty hard wall in
- 8:56the present. According to the source, Tesla's
- 8:58total revenue growth was exactly 0%.
- 9:02Ouch. Yeah.
- 9:03The automotive business, which is what actually makes the cars,
- 9:06that was down 1% to $20.5 billion.
- 9:10Energy generation was down 16%. Earnings per share dropped 4% to
- 9:16$0.48. The only thing keeping the top
- 9:19line completely flat was their services division, which grew
- 9:2233% to 4.6 billion. You know for a company that the
- 9:26market prices as this hyper growth tech innovator, 0%
- 9:30revenue growth is a structural crisis.
- 9:33I mean, the core automotive division is actively losing
- 9:36market share to really aggressive Chinese EV
- 9:39manufacturers. Yeah, they're facing huge
- 9:40competition there. And so, to justify its current
- 9:43stock price, Tesla's narrative entirely hinges on solving
- 9:46autonomous driving. But the source notes that
- 9:49despite all the promises, there is no real indication of
- 9:52imminent scalable success in that area.
- 9:54Which makes the recent news out of Elon Musk's camp absolutely
- 9:58wild to me. He just disclosed that a
- 10:00committee was formed to discuss merging Tesla with SpaceX.
- 10:03And from a value investing standpoint, I mean combining a
- 10:06cash burning space company with a stalling automotive company.
- 10:10It sounds like tying 2 heavy rocks together and just hoping
- 10:12they float. How does merging 2 capital
- 10:15intensive businesses solve anything?
- 10:17Well, a disciplined value investor always has to steal man
- 10:20both sides of an argument, right?
- 10:23So let's look at the bulk case for this merger.
- 10:25The visionary story. The idea is that it creates an
- 10:29unparalleled, vertically integrated compute and AI
- 10:32infrastructure giant. You combine Tesla's AI hardware,
- 10:36battery tech and robotics with Spacex's massive data centres
- 10:40and global satellite connectivity.
- 10:42Basically you build this closed loop tech ecosystem.
- 10:46OK, I see the story, but I'm guessing the deep value bear
- 10:49case is far less romantic than that.
- 10:52Oh, absolutely. The bear case is that this is
- 10:54the ultimate example of what legendary investor Peter Lynch
- 10:57called diversification. Diversification.
- 11:00Right. Yeah, merging for the sake of
- 11:01empire building rather than any real economic synergy.
- 11:05You're taking a highly capital intensive space in AI business
- 11:08that desperately needs cash and merging it with a 0 growth
- 11:12automotive business that's struggling to defend its own
- 11:14turf. So it just muddies the waters.
- 11:17Exactly. For an investor trying to
- 11:19calculate intrinsic value, this is a nightmare scenario.
- 11:23It creates an incredibly opaque entity.
- 11:25It completely destroys your margin of safety because it
- 11:28ruins your visibility into the true free cash flow of the
- 11:31underlying businesses. You can no longer tell which
- 11:33division is subsidizing the massive losses of the other.
- 11:37Yeah, that is a huge red flag. Well, let's shift from digital
- 11:40empires in space to digital empires here on Earth, because
- 11:43Meta is also bleeding cash to build an AI mode, and the sheer
- 11:47scale of their spending is just hard to comprehend.
- 11:50It really is. Here's where it gets really
- 11:52interesting. On the surface, Meta had a
- 11:55blowout quarter. Revenue hit $64.6 billion, which
- 11:59is up 26% year over year. And crucially, their average
- 12:03price per ad was up 14%. Wow.
- 12:06Yeah, that is incredible pricing power, right?
- 12:09Advertisers are willing to pay significantly more for the exact
- 12:11same inventory. And that pricing power, that is
- 12:15the hallmark of a truly great business.
- 12:17But again, we have to follow the math all the way down the income
- 12:20statement. While Meta's revenue grew 26%,
- 12:23their costs increased by a staggering 68%.
- 12:28Oh wow. Yeah, and the most jaw-dropping
- 12:31figure from the source, the one that should honestly terrify any
- 12:34long term holder, is that Meta has formally agreed to spend
- 12:37$825 billion in the future on leases and contracts, primarily
- 12:43for AI infrastructure and computing power.
- 12:45Wait, $825 billion? That's almost a trillion dollars
- 12:51in future liabilities just to try and stay relevant in the AI
- 12:55race. Yep.
- 12:57I mean it's like taking out a trillion dollar mortgage to buy
- 12:59a massive fleet of delivery trucks, but knowing the trucks
- 13:02will be completely obsolete in two years, and worse, knowing
- 13:05that anyone else can just download the blueprints to build
- 13:08their own trucks for free. That is the perfect analogy, and
- 13:11that is exactly why the source concludes that Despite that
- 13:14massive ad revenue, Meta effectively no longer has any
- 13:17positive cash flow when you factor in these looming gigantic
- 13:20commitments. That's insane for a company that
- 13:23size. It is you have to ask the
- 13:25fundamental Buffett question, is this capital allocation actually
- 13:29building a durable economic mode?
- 13:31And the source makes a very compelling argument that large
- 13:34language models and agentic AI applications currently have zero
- 13:38mode. Because it's all moving too
- 13:40fast. Exactly.
- 13:41The technology is advancing so rapidly and open source
- 13:44alternatives are so abundant that any breakthrough you make
- 13:48is commoditized almost instantly.
- 13:50If you are committing hundreds of billions of dollars to lease
- 13:54depreciating hardware for a moatless product, you are
- 13:57systematically destroying owner earnings.
- 14:00Man, it sounds a lot like the cautionary tale of IBM, which
- 14:04our source also touches on briefly.
- 14:06IBM reported a pretty paltry 5% revenue growth.
- 14:10I mean, they still command a $240 billion market cap, but
- 14:13they've essentially morphed into just a software and tech
- 14:16consulting firm, right? And they are at massive risk of
- 14:20being entirely disintermediated by the very AI tools Meta is
- 14:24building. They went from being the
- 14:26absolute bedrock of the tech world to a company that
- 14:30basically lost its Moat completely.
- 14:32Yeah, IBM is the ghost of tech future for companies that
- 14:35misallocate capital during a major technological shift.
- 14:38But you know, it's not just the digital tech moats that are
- 14:40under siege right now. We're seeing traditional
- 14:42physical infrastructure modes bleeding cash just to survive
- 14:46this new environment of high interest rates and bizarre new
- 14:49competition. Yeah, the source playfully calls
- 14:51this the Telepocalypse, which I love.
- 14:54Look at the telecom sector. AT&T actually posted pretty
- 14:57decent numbers. Earnings per share were up 20%
- 15:00to $0.65, and revenue grew by 5.3%.
- 15:03But the stock absolutely tanked, dragging giants like T-Mobile
- 15:07and Verizon right down with it. And why did that happen?
- 15:10The catalyst was that Elon Musk reaffirmed his intentions to
- 15:13establish Starlink as a fourth major mobile operator in the US,
- 15:17and even traditional cable monopolies like Comcast are
- 15:20feeling the heat. They lost 144,000 broadband
- 15:24subscribers in the quarter. What you're witnessing there is
- 15:26a narrative shift violently attacking a traditional
- 15:30oligopoly. I mean, for decades telecoms
- 15:32were the ultimate dividend paying value stocks because
- 15:35their moats, the physical wires in the ground and the cellular
- 15:38towers we're just too unbelievably expensive for any
- 15:41new competitor to replicate. You couldn't just build a new
- 15:44AT&T. Exactly.
- 15:46But the market is now pricing in the reality that AT&T and
- 15:49Verizon are going to have to massively increase their own
- 15:51capital expenditures just to defend their existing turf
- 15:55against a competitor who is beaming Internet down from
- 15:57space. Right.
- 15:58Speaking of oligopolies tethered to Macromath, the source also
- 16:02dissects the financial gatekeepers, specifically
- 16:05Moody's and Equifax. Moody's operates one of the
- 16:08widest, most impenetrable moats in the entire global financial
- 16:12system. Unquestionably.
- 16:13Yet their earnings per share of $4.14 actually missed Wall
- 16:17Street estimates. I mean, it was technically up
- 16:19from $3.60 last year, but their core ratings business revenue
- 16:24actually declined by 1%. How does a literal monopoly lose
- 16:27revenue? Well, it comes right back to the
- 16:29interest rate mechanism we discussed at the very beginning
- 16:31of this deep dive. Moody's business model is
- 16:34brilliantly simple. They get paid a fee every single
- 16:38time a corporation issues a bond.
- 16:40OK, but when the Federal Reserve raises interest rates, money
- 16:43becomes very expensive to borrow.
- 16:45Consequently, corporations delay issuing new debt.
- 16:48Fewer bonds issued means Moody's rates fewer bonds, which means
- 16:52their revenue drops. So their Moat is completely
- 16:55intact. I mean, no one is launching a
- 16:56start up in their garage to compete with Moody's, but their
- 16:59owner earnings are entirely tethered to the reality of the
- 17:02interest rate cycle. That makes total sense.
- 17:06And Equifax is facing kind of a different structural threat,
- 17:09right? They posted a decent quarter
- 17:11with US mortgage revenue up 15% and overall revenue up 10%.
- 17:16But their stock is struggling because federal regulators are
- 17:19actively targeting the credit scoring system.
- 17:22Yeah, they're trying to dismantle Equifax's pricing
- 17:24power by mandate, which is a huge external risk you always
- 17:28have to factor into intrinsic value.
- 17:29Right, which brings us perfectly to the ultimate traditional
- 17:33asset, the one most heavily impacted by interest rates,
- 17:36housing. Oh boy, yeah.
- 17:39The Home Builder NVR is widely considered a bellwether for the
- 17:42real estate market. They just saw their earnings per
- 17:45share drop 20% to $89.45, but more importantly, their new
- 17:50orders are dropping fast. They brought in just under 4400
- 17:54orders, missing the estimates of around 5000 by a wide margin.
- 17:58Which is very telling. Very.
- 18:01So what does this all mean for the average person looking at
- 18:03real estate as an investment? Because the source is incredibly
- 18:07blunt about what this means for housing as a store of value.
- 18:10If we connect this to the bigger picture, it is a pure math
- 18:14problem that is entirely broken the housing market.
- 18:17Mortgage rates are trapped over 7% During the pandemic.
- 18:21You know millions of homeowners refinanced into these 3%
- 18:24mortgages. For a new buyer today to have
- 18:27the exact same monthly payment as an existing homeowner, the
- 18:31actual purchase price of the house would have to drop by
- 18:33almost half. Half.
- 18:36That's incredible. Yeah.
- 18:38And because sellers absolutely refuse to take that kind of
- 18:41massive loss on the purchase price, the market is completely
- 18:44frozen. Existing home sales are sitting
- 18:46at multi decade lows. And meanwhile, the carrying
- 18:49costs for holding that real estate are skyrocketing.
- 18:51Insurance premiums are soaring, property taxes are way up.
- 18:55The source states point blank that the days of buying a home
- 18:58to build wealth are over, at least for the foreseeable
- 19:01future. It's a harsh reality.
- 19:03Their verdict is that housing prices will likely fall, and
- 19:06buying a house right now is a terrible misallocation of
- 19:08capital compared to renting. Yeah, when the cost of capital,
- 19:12meaning your 7% mortgage rate, exceeds the realistic
- 19:15appreciation of the house, your equity is actively being eroded
- 19:18every month. For a value investor, an asset
- 19:21is only worth the cash it produces.
- 19:23Right now, buying a house at peak prices with a 7% mortgage
- 19:26while paying soaring insurance and taxes, it just produces
- 19:30deeply negative owner earnings for the buyer.
- 19:32Well, we have covered a massive landscape today.
- 19:35We've gone from the mechanics of French sovereign debt to Elon
- 19:38Musk's huge capital expenditures, Meta's $825
- 19:42billion AI gamble, and the frozen housing market.
- 19:46Let's pull all of this together. If you are a patient deep value
- 19:51investor listening to this, what is the practical take away from
- 19:54Steve Josem's Market Wrap? The overriding synthesis here is
- 19:57that we are firmly transitioning from an equity market driven by
- 20:01visionary narratives. Back to a market governed by
- 20:04fixed income math. The math always wins.
- 20:08It always does. The era of 0 interest free money
- 20:11is officially over. So for the discipline value
- 20:14investor, this means you must demand a rigorous, undeniable
- 20:18margin of safety. You really need to avoid
- 20:20companies with massive moatless capital expenditures, like these
- 20:24speculative AI data center build outs that require 15% debt
- 20:28yields. And you must avoid companies
- 20:31with 0 growth models masquerading as tech innovators.
- 20:34So what do you look for instead? You look for businesses with
- 20:37durable, predictable free cash flow that isn't being entirely
- 20:40consumed just to keep the lights on and fend off the competition.
- 20:45And if you want to run these numbers and check the math on
- 20:47owner earnings and intrinsic value yourself, you can grab the
- 20:50free Deep Values app for iOS. You could also check if the
- 20:53broader market is overpriced using the Buffett Indicator app
- 20:56on iOS or the Bubble Watch app on Android.
- 20:59Highly recommend checking those out.
- 21:01Yeah. And if you want to dive into
- 21:03full research reports from our multi agent AI analyst, Deep
- 21:07Value Intelligence, head over to Deep values dot AI.
- 21:10We've put all those links right in the show description for you.
- 21:13Before we sign off, I want to leave you with one final thought
- 21:16to Mull over, kind of building on everything we've discussed
- 21:19today about capital allocation and moats.
- 21:22If the world's biggest tech giants are now being forced to
- 21:25spend hundreds of billions of dollars on physical
- 21:27infrastructure and energy just to maintain their existing
- 21:30market share against each other, should we stop valuing them as
- 21:34high margin software disruptors and start pricing them like
- 21:37capital heavy utilities? Wow.
- 21:40That is a phenomenal question about the future of tech
- 21:43valuations because as we saw today, you can build beautiful
- 21:46financial castles in the sky with a good story, but
- 21:49eventually the gravity of fixed income math always brings things
- 21:53back down to earth. Thank you for joining us on this
- 21:56deep dive. Keep weighing the numbers.
- 21:58Always look for that margin of safety and we'll see you next
- 22:00time.