Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / Is a sexual activity wrong if it was learned from a sinful source?
Transcript
- 0:40Hello, and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. My name is JD, and I blog over at UncoveringIntimacy.com.
- 0:49And today we're going to be talking about whether or not a sexual activity becomes wrong if it gets learned from a sinful source.
- 0:56This is a question that comes up from time to time. It was actually asked a while ago as an anonymous question, but it didn't come through our anonymous form, so I kind of forgot about it.
- 1:07Plus, it's something I wanted to answer in its own post because it comes up quite often.
- 1:13So let's get into it today. You know, does it matter where you learn something? Does that change whether or not the thing itself is good?
- 1:21For example, let's say you had a prior porn addiction and you saw something that you wanted to try with your spouse.
- 1:27Does that make it now sinful? So here's a question that I received a while back that I'm going to answer.
- 1:33He wrote,
- 1:34My wife and I have a very active sex life. We enjoy a nice variety of activities and positions.
- 1:40Our frequency is definitely on the higher side, so I really have no complaints.
- 1:44We have used porn either separately or together for much of our relationship and are working on that issue.
- 1:49I understand the problems with that and the implications. That's not what this is about.
- 1:54Many of the things we do sexually have been learned and implemented from watching or reading porn.
- 1:58We have discovered many enjoyable activities from that area of our lives together.
- 2:03So here's the question. Does a sexual activity become wrong or sinful if it was introduced from a sinful source?
- 2:09I feel that as long as the activity involves a man and a woman married to each other, that activity becomes blessed in the marriage bed.
- 2:16I know that others who don't feel the same way. My wife is not completely sure. I'm wondering what your thoughts are.
- 2:23So what do we do with knowledge that comes from a sinful source?
- 2:26Here's my take.
- 2:30The first is that the source doesn't make the knowledge sinful to have or to use.
- 2:35For example, if you incorrectly use a tool like a wrench as a hammer, that just means you used it incorrectly, not that the tool itself is tainted.
- 2:44You wouldn't say that, well, this wrench is no good now to be used as a wrench unless you have destroyed the wrench in some way as the result of hammering with it.
- 2:53And we have many stories of people using talents that they gained in unchristian ways, turning their life around and using those same skills and knowledge to serve God.
- 3:02Others will often use the knowledge that they gained from previous life experiences to warn people of what happens when you turn away from God.
- 3:09And does that make their time away from God beneficial or something to be sought after?
- 3:15You know, of course not.
- 3:16But God will use any opportunity he can for a good purpose if possible.
- 3:21We read in Romans 8 verse 28, and we know that all things work together for the good of those who love God to those who are the called according to his purpose.
- 3:32And I think we should have the same attitude, not that porn is good, beneficial, or a good educational tool in any way, but let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater.
- 3:42A good example, I think, is that if you have been previously married, whether your spouse passed away or you divorced, more than likely you've gained some marriage skills from your prior marriage.
- 3:53Not just sexual skills, but maybe some of those too.
- 3:56I don't think anyone would suggest that you set them aside in a new marriage and start from scratch.
- 4:01Yet no one would consider that death or divorce a good means to an end of learning marriage skills.
- 4:07If anything, people would consider it an evil that you somehow managed to glean some small positive gain from, which, again, seems to be something God is not against doing.
- 4:18In Genesis 5 verse 20, we read,
- 4:21But as for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, in order that I bring about, as it is this day, to save many people alive.
- 4:31So, that's my first point.
- 4:33A second is, there's a caveat to that, in that the source of where you learn something does make the knowledge suspect.
- 4:43Now, that doesn't mean that because of the source of the knowledge, it doesn't automatically mean you can't use it, those skills or those ideas.
- 4:51However, it does make it kind of suspect, yeah, so that it's wise to examine it perhaps more carefully to see if the idea is good.
- 4:59For example, if you learned some communication skills in your prior marriage, but it ended up in divorce,
- 5:05maybe your communication skills aren't what you thought they were and need to be re-examined.
- 5:10Likewise, maybe you see a sexual activity or behavior in porn that all the actors seem to find arousing, and it turned you on as well.
- 5:18And maybe it's humiliating or degrading in some way.
- 5:22Those things should probably be left aside, and hopefully one day be forgotten.
- 5:25Now, there are some caveats here, as I've seen many wives express the thought of,
- 5:30I never thought I'd like X, but it turns out I do.
- 5:33And sometimes their initial reaction or belief is that some activity is degrading,
- 5:38and then later on they re-evaluate and decide it's not.
- 5:41Oral sex seems to fall into this category fairly often.
- 5:44In some cases, it goes the other way as well.
- 5:47At first they were okay with it, and later they weren't.
- 5:49So, sometimes what's degrading can be subjective and can change.
- 5:53But regardless of the permanence of that belief,
- 5:55if your spouse feels degraded by a certain activity or behavior,
- 5:59you shouldn't engage in it.
- 6:01That doesn't seem to be healthy or Christian to me.
- 6:03And some will argue that they get aroused by degradation,
- 6:06but I'm not going to agree with that one.
- 6:09I think there's an issue there that needs to be addressed.
- 6:12I don't agree with society's belief that consent is all that is needed to make something good.
- 6:16In other words, while I think it's not a good idea to throw out the baby with the bathwater,
- 6:21let's also not assume that there's a baby in the bathwater without checking it first.
- 6:26Some ideas are just without merit.
- 6:29And lastly, I think what happens a lot is then when a particular activity or behavior
- 6:34comes from a damaging source, it can often become a difficult reminder of that source.
- 6:39For example, if your spouse has had an affair, ends it, the marriage is rebuilt, and things are good,
- 6:44and one day they said,
- 6:45hey, would you be willing to try X?
- 6:48And through the course of the discussion,
- 6:50it's unearthed that it's something that they've done with their affair partner
- 6:54and never with their spouse, and it turns them on.
- 6:58Now, maybe the idea of the activity itself isn't unappealing to you,
- 7:01but the memory of the pain from the affair is now linked to it,
- 7:04and so you struggle to engage in it without bringing up these old wounds.
- 7:07Likewise, one might worry that a particular sex act
- 7:11might cause a relapse in porn use because of a triggered memory or experience,
- 7:15and these are valid concerns I think should probably be addressed and discussed.
- 7:19However, some decide to look at it from another perspective.
- 7:23They look at it as an opportunity to sort of reprogram
- 7:26or to reset what is mentally linked to that behavior.
- 7:29They kind of look at it as a challenge to say,
- 7:31you know, I want this to be associated with our marriage, not that other thing,
- 7:35and most seem quite successful at it.
- 7:37I'm not sure if I've ever actually heard of a couple who has tried this and failed.
- 7:41And I wonder if this falls under Jesus' advice for dealing with unclean spirits,
- 7:46where in Matthew 12, verses 43 to 45, he says,
- 7:50you know, when an unclean spirit goes out of a man,
- 7:52he goes into the dry places seeking rest and finds none.
- 7:56And then he says, I will return to the house from which I came.
- 8:00And when he comes, he finds it empty, swept, and put in order.
- 8:03And then he goes and takes with him seven other spirits,
- 8:05more wicked than himself, and they enter and dwell there.
- 8:08And the last state of that man is worse than the first.
- 8:11So shall it be with this wicked generation.
- 8:14So in other words, rather than cutting off this behavior entirely,
- 8:18they reassociate it with their marriage,
- 8:19using it to build intimacy rather than to destroy it as it had originally been done.
- 8:24You know, they fill that space again.
- 8:26They don't just leave it open for attack.
- 8:28So, does a sexual activity become wrong or sinful if it was introduced from a sinful source?
- 8:36I think there are some pitfalls and some caveats to be aware of.
- 8:39I think it takes a little bit more scrutiny and discernment and more communication,
- 8:44which is never a bad thing.
- 8:45But that doesn't necessarily mean that we should throw out anything that comes from a sinful source.
- 8:50So don't judge it all as one big mess.
- 8:53Look at each activity or behavior separately and judge them on their own merits.
- 8:56After all, if we ran away from anything anyone can see in porn,
- 9:01experience in affairs, or have during premarital sex,
- 9:04then you'd have nothing left for your spouse.
- 9:09And that's all I have today.
- 9:10If you like our podcast, we'd love it if you'd rate and review it on iTunes
- 9:15or whatever platform that you're using.
- 9:18If you agree or disagree with anything that I've said here or want to discuss it further,
- 9:23head over to the blog.
- 9:24You can check it out in the show notes.
- 9:26There's a link there.
- 9:26And you're more than welcome to comment.
- 9:29I think we need more discussion of things like this in our Christian communities.
- 9:33And it's sadly very lacking.
- 9:35So come and have a discussion.
- 9:37If you're afraid of having discussions like this in public, which is understandable,
- 9:42most people are,
- 9:43we have a forum for our supporters that is a lot more private.
- 9:47All the people there are people that know, love, and support our blog,
- 9:52even if it's only a dollar a month.
- 9:54But that's sort of how we vet out all the trolls
- 9:57and anyone who's not really that interested in growing their marriage.
- 10:01So if you're looking for a space of sex-positive Christians
- 10:05who are really only interested in helping you support your marriage
- 10:09and getting support for their own,
- 10:10then consider supporting us and our ministry
- 10:12so that we can continue to put out podcast episodes like this
- 10:16and blog posts and resources and webinars and all the things.
- 10:20And that's it for now.
- 10:21See ya.
- 10:22See ya.
- 10:23See ya.
- 10:23See ya.
- 10:23See ya.
- 10:23See ya.
- 10:24See ya.
- 10:24See ya.
- 10:24See ya.
- 10:24See ya.
- 10:24See ya.
- 10:24See ya.
- 10:25See ya.
- 10:25See ya.
- 10:25See ya.
- 10:25See ya.
- 10:25See ya.
- 10:25See ya.
- 10:25See ya.
- 10:25See ya.
- 10:26See ya.
- 10:26See ya.
- 10:26See ya.
- 10:27See ya.
- 10:27See ya.
- 10:27See ya.
- 10:27See ya.
- 10:28See ya.
- 10:28See ya.
- 10:29See ya.
- 10:29See ya.
- 10:29See ya.
- 10:30See ya.
- 10:30See ya.
- 10:31See ya.
- 10:31See ya.
- 10:32See ya.
- 10:32See ya.
- 10:33See ya.
- 10:34See ya.
- 10:34See ya.
- 10:35See ya.
- 10:36See ya.
- 10:36See ya.
- 10:37See ya.