Latest / Reformed Thinking / The Pilgrim's Progress by John Bunyan - The Hill of Difficulty
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to Reformed thinking.
- 0:01Glad. To be here.
- 0:02Today we're doing another deep dive into the Pilgrim's
- 0:06Progress. That's right.
- 0:07We're looking specifically at, well, a really significant part,
- 0:12Christian getting up the hill difficulty and then his stay at
- 0:15the palace. Beautiful.
- 0:16Yeah, it's quite a sequence. We've been looking closely at
- 0:18the text itself, the original source, and some notes around
- 0:21it. And the goal, as always, is to
- 0:24really unpack what Bunion's showing us here.
- 0:26We want to pull out the key insights from this section to
- 0:29help you better understand Christian's path and, well, what
- 0:33it might mean. OK, so let's get into it.
- 0:36Christian shows up at the foot of this hill and Bunyan calls it
- 0:39difficulty. Pretty straightforward name.
- 0:42And he's not alone when he arrives, there are a couple
- 0:44other guys with him, and there's a spring there too.
- 0:47The text mentions for refreshment.
- 0:49Christian drinks from it, right? Refreshment before the climb.
- 0:51But then there's this choice, isn't there?
- 0:53Right there at the bottom. Exactly a critical choice.
- 0:57The main path, the right way, goes straight up this very steep
- 1:00hill difficulty. But then there are these two
- 1:03other paths sort of branching off to the sides.
- 1:05They look easier. They look easier and they have
- 1:07names too. Oh yes, danger and destruction.
- 1:11Bunion isn't subtle about where those paths lead.
- 1:14No, not at all. So Christian sees this steep
- 1:17path the official way and these alternatives.
- 1:20What's his move? He picks the hard one go
- 1:23straight up the hill, and the text gives his reason pretty
- 1:26clearly. He figures the way to life lies
- 1:29here. He understands this is the
- 1:30appointed way, even if it's hard.
- 1:32Makes sense. What about the other two?
- 1:33The ones who arrived with him. Well, they see how steep it is
- 1:36and they bail. They take the easier looking
- 1:39options. The one who picks danger, he
- 1:41wanders off into some woods and gets lost.
- 1:43Never heard from again. Basically OK.
- 1:45And the other one? Destruction.
- 1:47He heads off towards some dark mountains, stumbles, falls, and
- 1:50the text says he rose no more. So yeah, those easy ways weren't
- 1:54so easy in the end. Wow, that paints a stark
- 1:57picture. Right away, the choice matters
- 2:00immensely, so Christian starts climbing the difficulty.
- 2:05It's not just a walk in the park, though.
- 2:06Oh. Definitely not.
- 2:08Bunyan describes it really vividly.
- 2:10He starts off trying to run up it, but it's too steep.
- 2:13He has to slow down to a walk and then before long it's so
- 2:16steep he's actually scrambling on his hands and knees.
- 2:18Hands and knees, it really conveys that physical effort the
- 2:22the struggle involved. This does it shows this isn't
- 2:25just a mental ascent, it's a hard climb.
- 2:27But there is some relief part way up the Arbor.
- 2:31Yes, about midway up there's this pleasant little shelter in
- 2:34Arbor, and the text specifically says the Lord of the Hill built
- 2:37it for tired travellers, a place of intended rest.
- 2:41Sounds like just what Christian needed after that climb for
- 2:43sure. He stops there, sits down, takes
- 2:47out his role. You know that certificate he got
- 2:49of the cross and reads it for comfort.
- 2:52He also looks over his coat, the one the shiny ones gave him.
- 2:54He's reflecting, seeking some spiritual encouragement.
- 2:57OK, so he takes a breather, reads his role, remembers the
- 3:00grace he received. Seems like a good pause.
- 3:03What happens then? Well, this is where things go a
- 3:06bit wrong. While he's resting there, he
- 3:10nods off. It starts as just a light sleep,
- 3:13a slumber, but then he falls into a really deep sleep.
- 3:16A deep sleep in this resting place, yes.
- 3:19And the crucial thing is, while he's a slick, he loses his role.
- 3:24It must have fallen from his hand or his pocket.
- 3:27And he sleeps for a long time until it's almost dark.
- 3:30He. Loses the role.
- 3:32Oh, that's bad. That's his assurance, isn't it?
- 3:34His pass, essentially. How could he sleep so soundly?
- 3:38He'd lose that. It's a cautionary moment, right?
- 3:40It shows the danger of, well, spiritual carelessness.
- 3:43Maybe even in a placement Forrest, you can let your guard
- 3:45down too much. Someone wakes him up actually
- 3:47quoting proverbs about the sluggard and the Ant A.
- 3:49Sharp wake up call. Yeah, and the consequence is
- 3:52pretty serious. It's delayed and hugely.
- 3:54The day is almost gone. So he gets himself together,
- 3:57finally reaches the top of the hill after that scramble, but
- 4:00the day's almost over. And his welcome isn't exactly
- 4:03peaceful either, is it? No, not immediately.
- 4:07As soon as he crests the hill, he sees two men running
- 4:09frantically back towards him down the path he just came up.
- 4:13Ah, these must be timorous and mistrust fitting names again.
- 4:16What's got them so spooked? They tell Christian they're
- 4:19hightailing it out of there because of danger.
- 4:21Just ahead they saw and I quote a couple of lions in the way and
- 4:26they were convinced the lions were going to pull us in pieces.
- 4:29Fear just completely overtook them.
- 4:31OK, seeing two guys running for their lives yelling about lions,
- 4:35that probably shakes Christian up a bit too.
- 4:37It definitely does, the text says.
- 4:39Fear grips him. He pauses, but then he thinks it
- 4:43through. If he goes back, he's heading
- 4:46back to the City of Destruction. Certain doom if he goes forward,
- 4:50OK, there's this fear of death, these lions, but beyond that is
- 4:53the goal. Life everlasting.
- 4:55So he weighs the options. Fear of death versus certainty
- 4:58of destruction. Right.
- 4:59And he chooses to press on. He resolves to face the danger
- 5:02ahead rather than turn back. That takes courage.
- 5:05After that decision, what does he do?
- 5:07Does he try to comfort himself? Yes, that's exactly his
- 5:09instinct. Yeah, after that scary
- 5:11encounter, he reaches into his pocket or wherever he kept it
- 5:14for his role. He wants to read it for
- 5:16reassurance, and it's gone. He feels around, checks himself
- 5:22and realizes his role is missing.
- 5:23Oh man, first a scare with Timorous and mistrust.
- 5:27Now he realizes his assurance is gone.
- 5:29That must have been a terrible moment.
- 5:30Absolutely devastating. Bunyan describes him as being in
- 5:33great distress, utterly perplexed.
- 5:36He calls the role his comfort, his pass into the social city,
- 5:40his assurance of his life and acceptance.
- 5:43Losing it feels like losing everything.
- 5:45Does he figure out where he lost it?
- 5:47Yeah. His mind goes back.
- 5:48He remembers falling asleep in that Arbor, halfway down the
- 5:51hill, and it clicks. That must be where he dropped.
- 5:54It So he's just climbed this incredibly steep hill, reach the
- 5:58top, face down his fear of turning back and now he has to
- 6:01go back down. He has to.
- 6:03There's no other way. He decides he must retrace his
- 6:06steps, find that role. And he asked God to forgive him
- 6:08for the foolish act of sleeping like.
- 6:10That that trip back down must have felt very different from
- 6:13the climb up. Oh completely.
- 6:15The text really emphasizes his sorrow, his self blame.
- 6:18He's beating himself up over the waste of time, the extra steps,
- 6:22and now he's really worried about night falling completely
- 6:25before he can get back up the hill again.
- 6:27Being benighted, as Bunion puts it.
- 6:29So he makes it back down to the Arbor.
- 6:31He does. He gets back there, sits down
- 6:33again, but this time he's weeping, just full of regret for
- 6:36his carelessness. Does he find it?
- 6:38Yes. Finally, after weeping and
- 6:41searching, he looks down under the settle, under the bench
- 6:44basically, And there it is, his role.
- 6:47What a relief that must have been.
- 6:49Huge relief, the text says. He grabs it quickly, trembling
- 6:52but also full of joy and gratitude.
- 6:54He thanks God for directing his eye to it.
- 6:56And then? Does he linger?
- 6:58No, he gets going right away. He heads back up the rest of the
- 7:01hill and interestingly, the source says he goes much more
- 7:04nimbly the second time. Maybe the relief gives him
- 7:07energy. Makes sense, he's got his
- 7:09assurance back, but that sleep still cost him time, didn't it?
- 7:12It did. By the time he reaches the top
- 7:15of the hill for the second time, the sun has set.
- 7:18It's dark, and that darkness immediately brings his sinful
- 7:21sleep back to mind. He remembers why it's dark,
- 7:24because he wasted daylight sleeping, and that renews his
- 7:26fear about those lions you heard about.
- 7:29OK, so it's dark. He's just recovered his role,
- 7:31he's worried about lions. But then he sees something
- 7:33hopeful. Yes.
- 7:35Just as he's feeling that fear in the darkness, he looks up and
- 7:38sees this stately palace right beside the road.
- 7:42It's called beautiful. He hurries towards it, hoping he
- 7:45can get lodging there for the night.
- 7:47A palace named Beautiful sounds promising, but getting there
- 7:50isn't straightforward either, is it?
- 7:52He runs into the very thing Timorous and Mistrust warned him
- 7:54about. Exactly as he gets near the
- 7:57entrance near the Porter's lodge, he sees them, two lions,
- 8:00one on each side of the path, in a narrow passage.
- 8:03OK, there they are, real lions. How does he react this time?
- 8:07Well, he's definitely scared again.
- 8:08He actually thinks about turning back, just like Timorous and
- 8:11mistrusted. And Bunyan adds a crucial detail
- 8:15here. Christian saw the lions, but he
- 8:19saw not the chains. He perceived the threat, but not
- 8:23the restraint on the threat. He didn't see they were chained,
- 8:26but someone helps him see that, Yes.
- 8:28There's a Porter at the gate of the palace.
- 8:30His name is Watchful, another great name.
- 8:32He sees Christian hesitating, looking like he's about the
- 8:35Bolt. What does watchful the Porter
- 8:37do? Watchful calls out to him, tells
- 8:39him not to be afraid, explains the lions are chained.
- 8:42They've been placed there specifically for trial of faith,
- 8:46to test pilgrims. They can roar, but they can't
- 8:49reach anyone who stays on the path.
- 8:51And he gives him instructions. Yes, Watchful tells him very
- 8:53clearly. Keep in the midst of the path,
- 8:55stay right in the center, and you'll be safe.
- 8:57And Christian does it. He walks between roaring lion.
- 9:00Yes, he follows Watchful's instructions, keeps to the
- 9:03middle of the path and walks right between them, the text
- 9:06says. They roared and he was still
- 9:08trembling with fear, but he passed safely.
- 9:10That's a powerful image. Understanding the situation
- 9:14following guidance allows him to pass a danger that seemed
- 9:18overwhelming. Right.
- 9:19It shows fear can be managed with the right knowledge and
- 9:22obedience. So he makes it past the Lions
- 9:25and gets to the gate where he starts talking with Watchful.
- 9:28OK, safe past the Lions. Finally at the gate, he has a
- 9:31chat with Watchful the Porter. What do they talk about?
- 9:34It's kind of an initial screening, you could say.
- 9:37Watchful asks the standard questions.
- 9:39Where are you from? City of Destruction?
- 9:42Where you headed? Mount Zion?
- 9:44What's your name? Christian, though, he adds, he
- 9:46used to be called graceless. Does he have to explain why he's
- 9:49showing up after dark? Yes, Watchful asks about that.
- 9:52Christian tells him the whole story.
- 9:53Falling asleep in the Arbor, losing his role, having to go
- 9:56all the way back down the hill to find it.
- 9:58And that's why he's so late. Watchful accepts his story.
- 10:01Seems so after hearing him out, Watchful rings a bell and this
- 10:06calls out one of the residents of the palace, a woman named
- 10:08Discretion. Discretion.
- 10:10Another significant name. What does she do?
- 10:13She comes out and talks with Christian too.
- 10:15Ask him more about his travels, what he's seen, who he's met
- 10:19along the way. Confirms his name again.
- 10:22She wants to understand his pilgrimage so far.
- 10:24And once she's satisfied? She calls for others from the
- 10:26household, prudence, piety and charity.
- 10:29It's quite the welcoming committee.
- 10:30And they welcome him. In yes, they bring him into the
- 10:32palace. Beautiful.
- 10:34They explained that the Lord of the Hill built this place
- 10:36specifically for the relief and security of pilgrims.
- 10:40It's designed to entertain and support people like Christian on
- 10:43their way. It's a place of spiritual
- 10:45community and rest. Before they even eat, they sit
- 10:48down and talk. It sounds quite structured.
- 10:50Very intentional, Bunion says. They engage in discourse before
- 10:54supper for the best improvement of time.
- 10:57They want to use this time for spiritual benefit.
- 11:00Piety, prudence and charity each talk with him.
- 11:03OK, what does Piety ask about? Piety focuses on his journey so
- 11:06far, what got him started? He mentions the dread of
- 11:09destruction and evangelists pointing him to the Wicked Gate.
- 11:12She asks about the interpreter's house.
- 11:14He talks about seeing Christ maintaining grace despite sin,
- 11:17the man of despair, the judgement dream, the man
- 11:20fighting his way into the palace.
- 11:21Kind of reviewing the key lessons he's learned.
- 11:24Exactly. She also asks what he saw at the
- 11:26cross, burden falling, the shining ones, forgiveness, the
- 11:29coat, the mark, the roll. He also mentions the sleepers
- 11:33simple sloth and presumption and the hypocrites formality and
- 11:37hypocrisy. Climbing the wall.
- 11:39He wraps up by acknowledging how hard the hill was, the scare
- 11:42with the Lions and thanking the Porter.
- 11:44So piety covers the external journey and foundational
- 11:47experiences. What about prudence?
- 11:50Prudence probes more into his internal state.
- 11:52Does he still think about his home country?
- 11:55He says yes, but with shame and disgust.
- 11:57Now desiring the heavenly 1, she asks about those inward and
- 12:01carnal quagitations, those sinful thoughts that linger.
- 12:04He admits they grieve him and are hard to shake off.
- 12:07Does he ever get victory over them?
- 12:08Prudence asks that too. He says rarely, only during what
- 12:12he calls golden hours, And he explains how he gets that
- 12:15victory by thinking about the cross, looking at his coat,
- 12:19reading his role or focusing on his destination, Mount Zion.
- 12:23So specific spiritual practices help him fight internal battles.
- 12:27Right. And finally, Prudence asks why
- 12:29he wants to get to Mount Zion so badly.
- 12:31He lists several reasons. To see Christ alive, to be free
- 12:36from all his current troubles and sins, to live forever
- 12:38without death, To be with like minded people, and ultimately to
- 12:43be fully eased of his burden by Christ himself.
- 12:45That gives a real insight into his motivations and struggles.
- 12:49Then Charity speaks with him. Yes, Charity asks about the
- 12:52family he left behind, his wife and four children.
- 12:54He gets quite emotional, explaining they were completely
- 12:56against him coming. He tried warning them, sharing
- 12:59his fears, praying for them, showing his distress, but they
- 13:02just mocked him or didn't believe.
- 13:04Why wouldn't they come? He explains his wife was afraid
- 13:07of losing the things of this world and his children were
- 13:09caught up in youthful pleasures. Charity then asked a tough
- 13:14question. Did his own life, maybe his own
- 13:17failings, put them off? How does he answer that?
- 13:21He's honest. He admits he can't boast about
- 13:23his own perfection. He knows he had failings, but he
- 13:26says he tried hard not to give unnecessary offense.
- 13:30He actually thinks if anything turned them off, it was his
- 13:33change, his great tenderness in sinning against God, which they
- 13:37saw as him being overly strict or too precise.
- 13:40So his attempt at holiness was seen as a negative.
- 13:42That's how he perceives it and charities conclusion from this
- 13:45is rather stark. She says it shows they are
- 13:47implacable to good, basically set against it.
- 13:50That's heavy. After all this intense
- 13:51conversation, they finally have supper.
- 13:53Yes, and the conversation continues, but the focus shifts.
- 13:57The text says all their talk was about the Lord of the Hill.
- 14:00What specifically about him? They discuss his deeds, how he
- 14:04was a great warrior who fought and defeated the one who had the
- 14:07power of death, shedding his own blood out of pure love.
- 14:11They talk about why he built this very house, his love for
- 14:14pilgrims, how he humbled himself, leaving glory, wanting
- 14:18companions in Zion, making pilgrims into Princess.
- 14:21Some even mention having spoken with him after his resurrection.
- 14:24It's all centered on Christ. Wow, what a contrast to the
- 14:28struggles and fears outside. So after that he finally gets
- 14:30some proper rest. Yes, they commit themselves to
- 14:33God's care, and Christian is shown to a large upper room
- 14:36called Peace. It has a window facing the east
- 14:39towards the sunrise, and there he sleeps soundly until morning.
- 14:43So the next morning arrives. Does Christian head straight
- 14:45out? Not immediately, there's more
- 14:47conversation 1st and then the family offers to show him some
- 14:50of the rarities of the palace. Beautiful things worth seeing.
- 14:52OK, like a tour? Where do they take him first?
- 14:55First they go to the study. There they show him ancient
- 14:58records, really important documents, things like the
- 15:01family history, the pedigree of the Lord of the Hill, showing
- 15:03he's the son of the Ancient of Days.
- 15:05So establishing Christ's divine identity.
- 15:08What else? They show records of his
- 15:11actions, his mighty deeds, also lists of his faithful servants
- 15:15where they live securely, and accounts of their own amazing
- 15:18acts. Things like subduing kingdoms,
- 15:21stopping lions mouths. You know, echoes of Hebrews 11.
- 15:24Right. The history of faith.
- 15:25Yeah, and records showing the Lord's willingness to forgive
- 15:29even those who had really opposed him.
- 15:31Plus other histories, prophecies about the future, predictions.
- 15:34It's like a deep dive into salvation, history and God's
- 15:37faithfulness. Sounds like powerful
- 15:39encouragement. Where next?
- 15:40The Armory. Yes, and they take him to the
- 15:43Armory, and this is significant. They show him all manner of
- 15:46furniture, meaning equipment provided for pilgrims,
- 15:49everything needed for spiritual warfare.
- 15:50What kind of equipment? Sword, shield, helmet,
- 15:53breastplate, all prayer, which likely means prayer itself as a
- 15:56weapon, or maybe something facilitating prayer and shoes
- 15:59that wouldn't wear out. The text makes a point that
- 16:02there was enough there for vast numbers of people, not just him.
- 16:05So God's provision is abundant. Do they show him anything else
- 16:07there? Yes, they also show him some
- 16:10specific, maybe unusual, engines or rules that God's servants
- 16:15used in the past to do amazing things, like Moses's rod, Jail's
- 16:19hammer and nail, Gideon's pitchers and trumpets, Shamgar's
- 16:23ox code, Samson's jawbone, David's sling and stone.
- 16:27Wow, examples of God using ordinary or maybe unexpected
- 16:31things for great victory. Exactly, and they also show him
- 16:34the sword that the Lord himself will eventually use to defeat
- 16:36the man of sin. It's a display of God's power
- 16:39and the means he provides. Christian was ready to leave
- 16:42after this, wasn't he? But they convinced him to stay
- 16:45longer. They do.
- 16:46They suggest he stay one more day so they can show him the
- 16:49delectable mountains. They say seeing them will be a
- 16:51further comfort as they're closer to his final destination,
- 16:55the desired haven. The delectable mountains sounds
- 16:58nice. Do they show him?
- 16:59Yes. The next morning they take him
- 17:01up to the roof of the palace. From there, looking S he can see
- 17:04this beautiful range of mountains in the distance.
- 17:07They tell him this is Emmanuel's Land, a place pilgrims often
- 17:09visit. And what's special about these
- 17:11mountains? From there, they tell him,
- 17:13Shepherds will eventually show him the very gate of the
- 17:15Celestial City. It's a preview, a vision to
- 17:18strengthen him for the roads still ahead.
- 17:21OK, so he's seen the history, seen the armor, gotten a glimpse
- 17:25of the goal. Now is he ready to leave?
- 17:27Now he's ready, but before he goes they take him back to the
- 17:30Armory, and this time they don't just show him the armor, they
- 17:34harnessed him from head to foot with what was of proof.
- 17:37They fully equip him for the dangers and assaults that are
- 17:40sure to come. They dress him in spiritual
- 17:42armor. That seems vital.
- 17:44Absolutely presented as essential preparation.
- 17:47So, fully kitted out, he heads for the gate.
- 17:49Yes, his new friends walk with him to the gate.
- 17:52He has another word with Watchful the Porter.
- 17:55He asks if any other pilgrims have come through recently.
- 17:58And watchful mentions someone Christian knows.
- 18:00Yes, Watchful says. Oh yes.
- 18:02A man named Faithful passed by not long ago.
- 18:05Christian recognizes the name immediately.
- 18:08Faithful is from his same hometown, a neighbor.
- 18:11Watchful adds that Faithful has probably already gotten down the
- 18:14other side of the hill by now. Ah.
- 18:16So he's not entirely alone on the path ahead.
- 18:18That must be encouraging too. Could be.
- 18:21Christian then says his goodbyes, thanks, watchful for
- 18:24all the kindness he was shown at the palace, and steps out
- 18:27equipped and heading towards those mountains.
- 18:30OK, let's try to pull some threads together from this whole
- 18:32section, looking back at Christian's experience from the
- 18:35bottom of difficulty to leaving the palace beautiful.
- 18:38What are some key things that jump out from the source?
- 18:42Well, one clear point is that Bunyan shows the path is tough.
- 18:45It's called difficulty for a reason.
- 18:47Yeah, it's not supposed to be easy.
- 18:49And because it's tough, setbacks can happen.
- 18:52That whole episode in the Arbor, falling asleep, losing the role,
- 18:56shows that even when you're trying to rest appropriately,
- 18:58you can slip up. Spiritual drowsiness is a real
- 19:01danger. But it also shows that losing
- 19:03that assurance, the role isn't necessarily permanent.
- 19:06He had to go back, faces mistake with sorrow, but he could find
- 19:10it again. Regaining assurance is possible.
- 19:12That's a hopeful note. And then there's the fear aspect
- 19:15with Alliance. Bunion seems to show that fear
- 19:18is definitely a test, but often the reality behind the fear is
- 19:23less threatening than it first appears if you have the right
- 19:25perspective and guidance. Knowing the lions were chained
- 19:29changed everything. Right.
- 19:30And the Palace Beautiful itself stands out as this model of,
- 19:33well, essential support for pilgrims.
- 19:36The fellowship, the focus, teaching, looking back at God's
- 19:39acts, talking through personal struggles, getting equipped with
- 19:42spiritual armor, getting that vision of the goal.
- 19:44All these things are presented as vital resources for keeping
- 19:48going on that difficult path. You need community instruction,
- 19:51equipment, and vision. And that conversation with
- 19:54Prudence about the carnal cogitations, that those
- 19:56unwanted, is a reminder too, isn't it, that the internal
- 19:59battle doesn't just stop. Bunyan shows Christian having
- 20:02specific ways to fight back, focusing on the cross, his
- 20:06standing, his assurance, the destination.
- 20:08So as you think about these challenges Christian faced, the
- 20:11steep climb, the sleepiness, the fear, the internal battles, and
- 20:15then the help he received at the palace, maybe consider how these
- 20:18map onto things in your own life or ideas you grapple with.
- 20:22What kind of support? What spiritual resources help
- 20:24you most when things get difficult?
- 20:27And maybe one last thought to chew on.
- 20:28Based just on what Bunyan gives us here, we see several people
- 20:32turn back or fall away. Those two guys at the bottom of
- 20:34the hill? Timorous and mistrust.
- 20:37Given that reality, what is it about the specific package of
- 20:40support Christian gets at the palace?
- 20:41Beautiful. That combination of community
- 20:44teaching, armor, and vision that Bunyan seems to suggest is
- 20:47uniquely fitted to help a person actually persevere and keep
- 20:50moving towards the Celestial City despite the difficulties.