Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The Long Island Serial Killer Archives: Authorities Believe Heuermann Killed At Home
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the program. Over
- 0:04the past week, we have learned a whole lot about
- 0:06Rex Heuerman since he has been arrested. And the second
- 0:10that we learned that he had some kind of weird
- 0:12ass room down in his basement, I knew that we
- 0:15were going to hear some weird shit about what was
- 0:18going on down in that basement. However, I never expected
- 0:22to hear that this dude allegedly was killing people in
- 0:26his home. Now you want to talk about morbid, you
- 0:29want to talk about twisted. This is where your family lives,
- 0:33your wife, your kids, and you have women allegedly down
- 0:38in this torture room where you're killing them and doing
- 0:41god knows what to them. That's a whole different level
- 0:45of evil. I mean, even BTK didn't kill people in
- 0:48his own home. Neither did Gary Ridgeway. We're talking some
- 0:52John Wayne Gacy type of weirdo shit here. And then
- 0:56when you really start to think about it, and you
- 0:58go back and you listen to some of the interviews
- 1:00that have happened throughout the years, like the one with
- 1:03Richard Dormer, and he talks about how the investigators thought
- 1:08that the killer spent time with them quote unquote before
- 1:12murdering them, so that means obviously tortured them. And to
- 1:16do that he would need a place that's private, right.
- 1:19So with that in mind, and knowing that he had
- 1:22this so called gun room down in his basement that
- 1:25nobody was allowed into, well, it doesn't take a genius
- 1:29to start putting the pieces together. Now, does that mean
- 1:32he murdered every one of these women at his home.
- 1:35It does not, But the investigators are working off of
- 1:38the theory at the very least that one murder or
- 1:41more was committed in this home. So let's dive into
- 1:45this article from CNN and let's get ourselves caught up
- 1:49this morning on what's going on headline. Investigators in Gilgo
- 1:54Beach case operating on theory that the killings occurred in
- 1:58the suspects home. This article was authored by John Miller
- 2:02and Christina Maxuris. Since the spring of this year, investigators
- 2:08looking into the Gilgo Beach serial killings case have been
- 2:11operating on the theory that the suspect, Rex Ewerman, committed
- 2:15the killings in his Massapeka Park, New York home. Now
- 2:19that is bananas to even think about. And then you'd
- 2:23say to yourself, all right, well, how would he get
- 2:25these women into the house without anyone knowing? Well, it's
- 2:29pretty common when you're an escort, if you're going to
- 2:31somebody's home and they want some kind of semblance of privacy,
- 2:35what they'll do is they'll have the escort laid down
- 2:37in the back seat. So the escort lays down in
- 2:39the back seat, they drive into the garage, the garage
- 2:42door closes, and then from there right into the house.
- 2:46And nobody's the wiser. But even still, this is quite
- 2:49the risk. No bringing these women to your home to
- 2:52murder them and then depositing their bodies a mere six
- 2:56or seven miles away. A source involved in the investmentation
- 3:00told CNN the fact that the disappearance occurred during the
- 3:04times his family was out of town suggests he may
- 3:07have lured victims to the Long Island home. Investigators believe
- 3:12committing the killings at home would have given youer men
- 3:15control of the environment and access to materials that were
- 3:19found at the crime scene, including tape and burlap bags.
- 3:23The source said, and having the privacy of this little
- 3:26torture den certainly would give him the time that he
- 3:29wanted to spend with these women. God, that's morbid to
- 3:32say before he killed them. Now, I don't know if
- 3:35that means every single woman that this guy has killed
- 3:38has been killed at this house, but at the very
- 3:40least the investigators believe at least one woman was killed here.
- 3:45One of the reasons the search of the suspect's home
- 3:47has taken so long is because investigators are also combing
- 3:51for trace evidence that maybe linked to the victims. Multiple
- 3:54sources said. So when they go in there and they're
- 3:57looking for that kind of trace evidence, it's a painstace
- 4:00making process. They have to go through that house basically
- 4:03inch by inch, and they're looking for any little clue
- 4:07that would lead them to a sign that one of
- 4:09those victims has been in this house. The Gilgo Beach
- 4:13suspect lived less than six miles from where the remains
- 4:16were found. Huerman was arrested in New York City last
- 4:20week and charged with murder in the deaths of three
- 4:23of the Gilgo Four, a group of women whose remains
- 4:26were found along a short stretch of Long Islands Gilgo
- 4:29Beach in twenty ten. The fifty nine year old architect
- 4:34has pleaded not guilty in the killings of Melissa Bartholemy
- 4:37Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Costello. In a news conference
- 4:42last Friday, Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney said Hewerman's
- 4:47wife and children were both traveling when the killings were committed,
- 4:51and the suspect was alone in the Tri state area
- 4:54during those times. Huerman is also the prime suspect in
- 4:58the two thousand and seven disappearance and killing of the
- 5:02fourth victim, Maureen Brainerd Barnes. According to a ball application
- 5:06from prosecutors, he has yet to be charged in that
- 5:09homicide case, but the investigation is expected to be resolved soon.
- 5:14The document said, and I have no doubt, like I've
- 5:17said previously, that they're going to slap them with Maureen
- 5:20Brainerd Barnes death as well, and they're just waiting to
- 5:23have all of their ducks in a row to do that.
- 5:26Women traveled the area of suspects home. The police say.
- 5:30Bartholome's phone communicated with a Burner cell phone several times
- 5:35before July tenth, two thousand and nine, which was the
- 5:37last day she was seen alive, Authorities said in Huerman's
- 5:41bail application. On that day, cell tower records show the
- 5:46Berner phone traveled from Massapeka Park to Midtown Manhattan, and
- 5:50later that day, Bartholome's phone traveled from Midtown Manhattan to Massapeka.
- 5:55The application says Bartholemy's last phone location was recorded in
- 6:00Massapeka on July eleventh, two thousand and nine, at roughly
- 6:04one forty three am. A court document says less than
- 6:08a year later, on June sixth, twenty ten, Waterman was
- 6:12seen on surveillance footage leaving a hotel in the area
- 6:16of Apoggy around one point thirty one am. According to
- 6:20the Bell application, it was the last time that she
- 6:22was seen alive. Waterman's phone also communicated with a Burner
- 6:27cell phone at around the same time she left her hotel.
- 6:30According to the Bell application, cell tower records show her
- 6:34phone traveled to Massapeka Park, with its last location recorded
- 6:39in the area at around three eleven am, in the
- 6:42vicinity of the residence of Huerman. The Bell application says
- 6:47she was never seen alive again. And when you go
- 6:50back and think about what we heard earlier about the
- 6:53woman that was down in the basement doing some measurements,
- 6:56and how fired up Huerman got when she asked to
- 6:58go in there. It makes you wonder what the hell
- 7:01was really going on in that room. And I know
- 7:05that he had two hundred guns, and you know, some
- 7:07people say that's normal to have that kind of vault
- 7:10with two hundred guns, and I say that's crazy. You
- 7:14might be a firearms enthusiast and you might have two
- 7:17hundred firearms, but are you going to keep them hidden
- 7:20away from the light of day or are you going
- 7:22to be proud of that collection and want to show people.
- 7:25I would think that you'd want to show people your
- 7:28collection of two hundred firearms, at least not be embarrassed
- 7:31by it or keep it locked up in that room, unless,
- 7:34of course, you know you're not home or whatever, you know,
- 7:36so the kids don't get it. But besides that, if
- 7:39somebody's over, you'd want to go down there and show
- 7:42them your armory. Right, Hey, check out all my new guns.
- 7:44Look at this one, look at that one. But nope,
- 7:47Hureman wasn't doing any of that. In the case of
- 7:50the Costello killing, police say a burner phone contacted her
- 7:54the day before she vanished. In those communications, the burner
- 7:58phone connected to sell towers in West Amityville, and Massapeka Park.
- 8:03The Bell application says around the time of the communications,
- 8:07witnesses said a prostitution client went to Costello's residence where
- 8:12a person pretended to be her outraged boyfriend as part
- 8:15of a ruse and got the client to leave. The
- 8:18application says, that's called a trick roll. So they'll set
- 8:22it up to have some john show up to think
- 8:25they're getting some services. But they show up and there's
- 8:28people waiting for them to roll them and take their money.
- 8:31The Burner phone, which was located in Massapeka Park, message
- 8:36Costello's phone early the next day, on September second, twenty ten,
- 8:40saying that was not nice. According to the document, Later
- 8:44that day, Costello was again contacted by the Burner phone,
- 8:48which was at Massapeka Park. The Bell application says that night,
- 8:53the Burner phone traveled to the area of the woman's house.
- 8:57According to the document, on the night of September second,
- 9:01Costello walked outside her home, leaving her phone behind and
- 9:04was never seen alive again. And remember it was Amber
- 9:08Costello's disappearance that led them eventually to that Green avalanche.
- 9:13Now we can have the conversation for sure why it
- 9:16took them so long because this is something that should
- 9:19have been solved a long time ago if this evidence
- 9:22was there. But be that as it may. According to
- 9:25the Bell application, it was the tip by the pimp
- 9:29that led them to that avalanche. Strands of hair were
- 9:33key in the investigation. Strands of hair were among the
- 9:37key evidence that helped investigators bring Hewerman into custody. In
- 9:41the initial examination of Watermen's skeletal remains, investigators found a
- 9:46male hair from the bottom of the burlap that the
- 9:49killer had used a rapp her body, prosecutors said. In addition,
- 9:54female hair now believed to be from Heuerman's wife, was
- 9:57found on or near three of the victims, prosecutors allege
- 10:01in the bel application. And one thing that's pretty interesting
- 10:05about Rex Huerman's wife is that she's Icelandic and their
- 10:09genetic makeup is pretty unique. So I think that that's
- 10:12going to be pretty significant for the prosecution as well.
- 10:16How the hell is Huerman going to A explain the
- 10:18hairs and b explain that they're from somebody with Icelandic descent.
- 10:23Oh and by the way, iceland is on the cutting
- 10:25edge of genetic genealogy, and they have a database where
- 10:29like every citizen in the country is in that database.
- 10:32So if you're going to try and you know, get
- 10:35away with a crime, having a Icelandic wife who's leaving
- 10:39their hair around is probably not a good idea. But
- 10:43when they were found in twenty ten, the hairs were
- 10:46degraded and the DNA testing at the time couldn't yield
- 10:49the results investigators had hoped for. It wasn't until more
- 10:53than a decade later that improved technology offered answers. Once
- 10:58authorities identified Hugh as a suspect in early twenty twenty
- 11:02two using cell phone data, witness descriptions, and other information,
- 11:07they began watching him and his family and collected DNA
- 11:11samples from items in their trash. They got a complete
- 11:16sample of his DNA from leftover crust in a pizza
- 11:19box he discarded, and it matched the one from the
- 11:22male hair investigators had collected so many years ago. Tierney,
- 11:27the district attorney, has said, so how's he going to
- 11:30explain that? And I know some of you out there saying, well,
- 11:33the burden of proof isn't on him. Well, guess what
- 11:36the jurors are going to want to know? Why your
- 11:38hair was found on these victims. Okay, you can't just
- 11:41show up in court and say, you know what, it
- 11:43wasn't me, that's not my hair. Meanwhile, it's traced directly
- 11:47back to you. You better have a reason for why
- 11:50your hair is on one of these victims, and not
- 11:52only your hair, but your wife's hair as well. And
- 11:56if he did murder any of these women in the house,
- 11:59you know they are going to find DNA. They're going
- 12:02through that house inch by inch, and if there's anything
- 12:05to find, those forensic teams will find it. But as
- 12:09far as this information, this revelation that he might have
- 12:12killed at least one of the victims in the house,
- 12:14really does not come as a shock to me. Once
- 12:17we find out all of the other stuff from the
- 12:20investigators previously about how they think that he spent time
- 12:24with them he needed a private place so that he
- 12:27could take his time, and a lot of the investigators
- 12:30also believe that his MOO has changed over time. We
- 12:34had some dismembered bodies, and then of course we had
- 12:37the bodies that weren't dismembered, And for me, I'm wondering
- 12:40if the change in mo had to do with him
- 12:42getting a little bit older, or maybe he has a
- 12:44back problem or something like that. You know, dismembering somebody
- 12:48as a labor intensive type of deal. And we know
- 12:51that some of the women were cut up into pieces
- 12:54and found in different places, deposited in different areas. So
- 12:58could that have been when he was starting and he
- 13:01still felt like he could have been caught. He wasn't
- 13:03as brazen yet. And then as he evolved, obviously he
- 13:07got a little bit older and figured, you know what,
- 13:10I'm untouchable. They can't catch me. I don't even need
- 13:13to dismember these bodies anymore. Now. Of course, all of
- 13:16that is just speculation, but it seems like a logical progression.
- 13:20When you're somebody who's a serial killer, I mean, you
- 13:23start getting up with your fifties, close to your sixties,
- 13:27I'm sure you don't want to dismember people anymore, unless,
- 13:30of course, obviously it's part of his ritual. So there's
- 13:33still a lot that has to be unfurled here. But
- 13:36the more I look at it, and the more of
- 13:38these resources I read, and old documentaries and interviews with
- 13:43investigators I watch, the more I'm becoming convinced that it's
- 13:47only one killer that was depositing bodies here at Gilgo Beach.
- 13:51It would be one hell of a coincidence, folks, if
- 13:54it was more than one killer. Now, is it completely
- 13:56impossible that more than one killer is using this dumb
- 14:00or was using this dumping ground. Absolutely not. But when
- 14:04you look at these murders and you look at the
- 14:06similarities in them, to me, you can trace them all
- 14:09back to one suspect, and you can do that in
- 14:12a pretty convincing manner. So it's gonna be interesting to
- 14:15see how this all unfolds. And like I've said before,
- 14:19I have a real disgusting feeling in my stomach that
- 14:21this guy's gonna be tied to a lot more murders
- 14:24than anybody suspecting. All Right, folks, that's gonna do it
- 14:28for this one. All of the information that goes with
- 14:30this episode can be found in the description box.