Latest / Chatter that Matters / Malcolm Gladwell - The Tipping Point
Transcript
- 0:04Hi, it's Tony Chapman, and welcome to that special edition of Chatter That
- 0:08Matters in collaboration with the Toronto Chatter of the American Marketing
- 0:11Association. And our guest today, Malcolm
- 0:15Gladwell. And our timing couldn't be better because
- 0:19Malcolm Gladwell that been inducted into Canada's Marketing Hall of
- 0:22Legends. Testament to a career where his insights,
- 0:26his compelling narrative, and his research that defined so
- 0:30many conversations, not just in business corridors, but across
- 0:33society, and to millions of people around the world. It's actually better
- 0:37as a species if we're trusting that if we are suspicious.
- 0:41It makes better sense as a species if we're trusting.
- 0:45Because think about it, virtually everything that we do of value in
- 0:48the world requires that we do have that kind of implicit faith
- 0:52in the honesty of others. You can't have a
- 0:56successful relationship. You can't cooperate with others. You can't build
- 1:00civil society. You can't start a company. You can't do anything unless
- 1:03you're willing to place your faith in others. His books from the groundbreaking The
- 1:07Tipping Point to his introspective Talking to Strangers, Malcolm
- 1:10invites us to see beyond the mundane, to explore how small changes can
- 1:14ignite significant shifts, and how misunderstood moments can shape
- 1:18our lives. Malcolm's genius lies in uncovering hidden patterns of
- 1:22human behavior, and his ability to weave these insights into stories that
- 1:25Matters, stories that challenge us, that inspire us, and provoke.
- 1:29As we chat today, we'll discover the inspiration behind his most pivotal moments,
- 1:33and the personal insights that guide his exploration of complex
- 1:37social truths.
- 1:42This is Chatter That Matters with Tony Chapman,
- 1:46presented by RBC. Malcolm Gladwell,
- 1:50welcome Chatter That Matters. Thank you. Happy to be here. 1st of all, I wanna
- 1:54just congratulate you for being inducted into Canada's
- 1:57Marketing Hall of Legends. There's a 100 luminaries in there. And,
- 2:01I mean, they use the word marketing, but it really is a hall of
- 2:05extraordinary builders and visionaries and thought leaders. So we're just
- 2:09delighted you're going to be taking your place that at our 20th anniversary.
- 2:12I am delighted as well. I'm very honored. It's testament to a career
- 2:16where I believe you, your narrative has crossed so many genres from
- 2:20business borders to society, academia, and I think it's just
- 2:24testament to the fact that you can cross so many different areas, and
- 2:28every one of them has a great appetite for what you do. I'm
- 2:31fascinated by your work because it's this incredible fusion of left
- 2:35brain and right brain. One of my first questions is is that because this
- 2:39DNA of your parents is roaring through you? And I wanna start maybe first
- 2:42with your mother, Jamaican, and she really had this sense of
- 2:46culture, that she really wanted to level the playing field, that she really wanted
- 2:49to let people know that we're all part of the human race.
- 2:53Yeah. I think that's a fair estimate, a fair
- 2:57description of my mother's perspective. She's by
- 3:02profession, a marriage and family therapist. And
- 3:06I assist, you know, Chatter I think is if you're looking
- 3:09for some kind of contribution of my mother's that way I'm thinking,
- 3:13the way I think, I think that's probably where you should start. I mean, she's
- 3:17someone who is profoundly curious
- 3:21about the human condition, about the ways in which people relate
- 3:24to each other, about, the kinds of struggles people have
- 3:28and how to fix them and how to help them. I mean, these are it's
- 3:32almost that perfect preparation for a journalist to
- 3:36have someone who's had who has that that
- 3:39range of interest Key be your be your own mother. And, you know, she wrote
- 3:43her memoir, Brown Face Big Master, I believe it was titled. In
- 3:47an article I read about it, you said that was also instrumental in the
- 3:51sense that she was, in some ways, hoping that you would
- 3:54continue to carry on that I don't wanna even use the word battle, but carry
- 3:58that torch forward to say that empathy and
- 4:01concern from one another is something that she felt was a
- 4:05very important attribute to, give to her son. Her book was probably
- 4:09the first adult book I read. By definition, it's gonna have an enormous
- 4:13impact on me. And it's a book that's very, very, it's
- 4:17funny, you can you can trace up, I think a bright line from that book
- 4:20to the books that I write, because it's a very much a book about an
- 4:24individual in the context of their world and
- 4:27environment, you know, where she's describing the kind of,
- 4:33the collision between who she was and what she believed and
- 4:36the place she found herself, the places she found herself, first
- 4:40Jamaica and then England, in the fifties and
- 4:44early sixties. And those are themes that I continue to explore on
- 4:48my own, that idea that there is is something very interesting
- 4:51happens when who we are meets where we are. And, you know, that
- 4:55vein that you mine, you know, I often use the word insight. You just You
- 4:59remind me sometimes of Jerry Seinfeld and Larry David in the sense
- 5:02that they call it a show about nothing, but when you watch the show, you
- 5:05realize it was something quite extraordinary happened, that they found
- 5:09something about how somebody thought, felt, or did that you draw
- 5:13parallels to. And that on the other side of it, though, it's not just that
- 5:16narrative. It's kinda your dad, the mathematician coming through because
- 5:20you back so much of those insights with with research
- 5:23and diving deeper into what you could have just written a
- 5:27book on intuition, but you seem to really combine that left brain and right
- 5:31brain. You can't have a father who is a mathematician and not also have
- 5:34a realize that your arguments have to have some rigor.
- 5:38You know, mathematics is all about, it's about proof. It's
- 5:42about showing how you reach your conclusion.
- 5:45It's about logic, it's all of those things. So
- 5:49it's easy I think to get lost in
- 5:53stories and descriptions when you're writing about people and their
- 5:56motivations. And not realize that, oh, you have to anchor what you're
- 6:00saying in something solid. You know, I've always tried to kind of
- 6:04find find the science that supports the arguments that I'm
- 6:07making. So there's something solid in
- 6:11what I'm writing about, not such as Malcolm sounding
- 6:15off. Have you ever abandoned something because you fell in love with this in sight?
- 6:18You really felt that this was something to to really explore,
- 6:22that that deserved a book. And yet, as you started doing research,
- 6:26it challenged some of that and and made you question whether this was in
- 6:29fact a branch on a tree that could turn into something. No, really because
- 6:33I Tony to start with the science. So I find
- 6:37my ideas come from reading the scientific
- 6:41literature and finding things that already have support. So it's not
- 6:45that I have a notion and then I go looking. It's that,
- 6:49I go looking and then have a notion. And as you're starting to create this
- 6:53book or this body of work, and I'm you know, I look at you're right.
- 6:56I mean, when I think of Tom Matters' In Search of Excellence and Jim
- 6:59Collins' From Good to Great, I mean, you know, when you started off with the
- 7:03tipping point, did you go out ever imagining that you would have something
- 7:06that would become part of people's vernacular, that Chatter almost
- 7:10overnight, people would start framing their situations,
- 7:14their circumstances, the momentum that might be behind a brand
- 7:18or a career as as the tipping point? I mean, I I, no one
- 7:21was more taken by surprise than I was, particularly with my first book, you know,
- 7:25I just came, seemed to come out of nowhere. I
- 7:29was just trying to describe something that interests me personally.
- 7:33You know, I was living in New York City and one day New York City
- 7:36was one of the most dangerous big cities in
- 7:40North America, and the next day it wasn't. And I just found that so
- 7:44bizarre and so inexplicable that I wanted to write about it.
- 7:47But I it never occurred to me that there would be some would have the
- 7:51kind of cultural reverberation that it did. I wanna back it up now because it
- 7:54led to the tipping point. I that no idea how much work you did as
- 7:58a journalist prior to it. But you go to the University of Toronto, and you
- 8:01take a history Three. Mhmm. And then you move very
- 8:05quickly south of the border and within very short
- 8:08order. I mean, you're not covering, you know, a cat and a
- 8:12tree. The work and that assignments they're giving you continue to grow
- 8:15as the papers that you start working for. So if you could just give us
- 8:19frame that sense of Chatter trajectory, and what
- 8:23was behind it that you could have so much momentum at such a young age?
- 8:26I got a job out of university, with a little tiny
- 8:30magazine in Bloomington, Indiana. I lasted there about 7
- 8:33months, and then I got fired. And then I went to Washington
- 8:37DC and worked for a think tank for about a year or
- 8:40so. And then I went to work for a little obscure, another
- 8:44obscure little magazine. And all the time I was
- 8:48freelancing though, for more serious
- 8:52magazines for things. And I caught the attention of an editor at that Washington
- 8:55Post. It was a time when the Washington Post was that heyday of
- 8:59newspapers when they were enormously profitable places, and they were
- 9:03hiring. You know, I can't I got very lucky. That the story
- 9:07by story doesn't happen today because newspapers aren't hiring. No way they were hiring back
- 9:10then. But, you know, when I went to work at the Washington Post in 1987,
- 9:14they were one of the most profitable big companies in the country.
- 9:18So they had resources that they were, and they're willing to take chances on
- 9:22young, unproven Matters. And they were interested in telling
- 9:25different kinds of stories because they could. And I got there right at
- 9:29the at the right time. And you're right. I was I avoided the
- 9:33normally, when reporters come in, they get assigned to the metro section, and they do.
- 9:37They write about casting trees and and,
- 9:41school board meetings. But I became a business reporter,
- 9:45which is was a non glamorous role at That Washington Post.
- 9:49But it was an incredible opportunity for a young reporter because
- 9:53I got to write about things on the national stage. That just greatly
- 9:56accelerated my, my growth as a journalist. Did you ever
- 10:00feel that the time an imposter, especially when you're going to The
- 10:04Washington Post, as you said, and you could clearly argue
- 10:08one of the top newspapers in the world, and then you're walking in to
- 10:11cover business Three, and you're not necessarily going in with a a
- 10:15Wharton RBC, or you're going in with a, you know, a Rolodex of
- 10:19of contacts. You're kinda just having to find your own way. And was there ever
- 10:22a time when you went, what am I doing here? Or did you always have
- 10:25that sort of inner confidence that there was a Tony, I could find it, and
- 10:28I could write about it? I'm not someone who's generally plagued by
- 10:32self doubt. And also, I felt like I was playing with house
- 10:36money. I mean, I was I was in the US. I had never imagined that
- 10:39I would RBC. I never imagined I'd have a job in journalism. I never imagined
- 10:43I'd be hired by the Ouachita Bose. It seemed like such a inexplicable
- 10:47series of events that brought me to where I was that I, you know, if
- 10:51it all fell apart, I wouldn't feel like I had failed. I would have just
- 10:54thought, oh, things have just gone back to normal. I was,
- 10:58even several years into my time at the Washington Post, I was still very
- 11:02seriously considering going to business school, which had been my goal
- 11:06for quite some time. So I didn't, it took me a while to kind of
- 11:09commit to what I was doing. I just so was just, it was more a
- 11:12lark than anything else. It was, I never kind of
- 11:16took it seriously enough to get to the stage where I might have
- 11:19imposter syndrome. One of the reasons we do these videos with the people in the
- 11:22legends generation coming up. And is that do you
- 11:26think that is a lesson in life for them to take maybe take some of
- 11:30the pressure off of those first 5 years or 10 years of your
- 11:33career and just go into Three, maybe not having the same
- 11:37confidence you did to say it was a lark, but just to go in there
- 11:40with to learn and experience and enjoy versus wondering
- 11:44what the next move on the chessboard will be? The most important thing I did
- 11:47and have done my entire career is I've always chosen the path that
- 11:51was the most enjoyable. I think you have to have
- 11:55fun. And when you're having fun, I think you do your best work and
- 11:58you're most appealing to Matters, and you learn the
- 12:02easiest. And so I just avoided things that I thought
- 12:06that I wouldn't enjoy. Now, by which I didn't mean that I, you know, I
- 12:09was avoiding all the kind of necessary apprenticeship, but
- 12:13I thought the apprenticeship was fun. I mean, I think I, you know,
- 12:17I enjoyed the fact that I didn't know anything about newspaper writing, and I got
- 12:21to learn. I just thought that was kind of thrilling that I got to master
- 12:24some new and there are all these brilliant people around me who are more than
- 12:27happy to teach Key, and I learned something else, which is that people
- 12:31do wanna teach young people. At least I had imagined
- 12:35that the working world would be hostile to you if you're you were
- 12:39starting out that somehow people would feel like it was
- 12:43a waste of time or a chore to teach young people what
- 12:47they were doing. I I I always found the exact opposite that
- 12:50senior people love nothing more than passing on.
- 12:54Once I realized that, that the system is set up to
- 12:58make you succeed if you just are enthusiastic and willing to work hard. You know,
- 13:02the connected tissue of of the American Marketing Association is this sense of
- 13:05mentorship. That's what the Toronto's Matters known for. Does it take
- 13:09a certain type of individual to be open to be
- 13:13mentored so that the people that have that knowledge are saying, I'm willing to
- 13:17invest in you, or do you think it's just something that we should all, as
- 13:20a society, realize it's out there if we just raise our hand and say
- 13:23we're looking for it. What's what's fairly universal is the
- 13:27desire of older people
- 13:31to teach, to pass on what they know. I almost feel like that's an evolutionary
- 13:35society could not have survived as long as it
- 13:39has, and grown as it has over the last 100 of 1000
- 13:43of years. If we weren't hardwired to want to pass along
- 13:47our expertise to young people. That's not cultural or
- 13:51specific to certain individuals. That's baked into us. The challenge
- 13:55is on the receiving end. Are you willing to learn from people like that? Are
- 13:58you is your mind open? Are you willing to work hard? Are you willing to
- 14:02make mistakes and not get discouraged? You know, I I think
- 14:06that all of the onus is on the is on the
- 14:09receiving party, not the sending party. Do you think in our society, in the
- 14:13western society, we are that open of an exchange between the
- 14:16elderly? I'm not talking about our indigenous population, but just in
- 14:20general, the western, maybe it's framed as Hollywood's western society,
- 14:24compared to some of the, you know, Asian and South Asian societies where it
- 14:28seems like the elderly are revered and the lessons in life are
- 14:31part of the journey of learning? As we speak, the 2
- 14:35candidates for president in the United States are respectively,
- 14:39that, late 70s early 80s, or whatever it is.
- 14:42So I don't know, it seems like the elderly are occupying
- 14:46some fairly significant positions in the West. I know
- 14:50what you're saying, I know that there are cultures that consciously
- 14:55elevate elders to a position of respect. But I,
- 14:59I, I think that we do the same. We just are not as kind
- 15:02of formal about it. I still, you know, I'm 60
- 15:06and I still find myself deferring to people older than myself
- 15:10who have had more experience. I mean, maybe the thing that's crucial
- 15:14is to disconnect age and experience. I think
- 15:17that the issue is not how old the person is. The Tony is, do they
- 15:20know more than you? Have they seen more? Where where that is the
- 15:24case, I think that most of us are willing to, to
- 15:28learn. And where did the movie you're at the Washington Post, and your
- 15:32career is moving, and yet you make another big move in your
- 15:35journalistic career to that New Yorker. Yeah, I had moved to New York to be
- 15:39the New York correspondent for the Washington Post and
- 15:42I wanted to stay in New York and that was gonna be
- 15:46difficult if I stayed with that Washington Post. But I also realized that I was
- 15:50better suited for magazine writing and book writing that I was for
- 15:53daily journalism. I was never a great daily reporter.
- 15:57It takes a certain degree of of energy
- 16:01and Compromise, I have to believe too. Yeah. And ultimately, I realized, you know, I
- 16:04wanna write things that are longer and take more time. What I do
- 16:08or more kind of thoughtful pieces. And so I, you
- 16:12know, I I I had learned what I felt I needed to learn from these
- 16:15Matters, and I I I was ready. This is when I was
- 16:18in that thirties. And you were becoming quite
- 16:22famous. Articles you were writing in that magazine were well
- 16:25received, But that's another big jump moving to that first book, as you said, the
- 16:29tip the tipping point. And and was it really because you saw how
- 16:33quickly New York had tipped for the better? Yeah. That was the impetus.
- 16:38I just was so mystified by it. You know, I got to New York in
- 16:41Three, and it was a frightening place. And then
- 16:45by 96, it wasn't frightening anymore. I just find it so
- 16:49weird. It really did feel like an epidemic had
- 16:52passed. And, I decided to take
- 16:55that metaphor seriously. What if it really actually was an
- 16:59epidemic? Well, how do epidemics behave? You know, that was
- 17:03that kind of, thought process I was following. That got
- 17:07me going, and then I decided, you know, there was a a million different directions
- 17:10sort of presented themselves from there. It
- 17:14just began to occur to me that I didn't understand why when we talk about
- 17:18contagious things, we confine our conversation to viruses or
- 17:21to to diseases. So many different things are other things,
- 17:25ideas, trends, song lyrics, are contagious in
- 17:29precisely the same way. I mean, I talk in the book about the word yawn.
- 17:33If I say the word yawn long enough, you will start yawning. Exactly. That's an
- 17:36incredibly contagious word. Our guest today,
- 17:40Malcolm Gladwell. Just think of Malcolm's body of work, that
- 17:43groundbreaking tipping point, that introspective talking to
- 17:47strangers. He invites us to see beyond the mundane. Key even
- 17:51explores how small changes can have a material impact
- 17:54on our lives and livelihood.
- 17:58What I love about your writing, is the way you
- 18:02bring characters to life, almost like it's fiction. You know, like
- 18:06Paul Revere, and you're and you're you're riding with that. And and where did that
- 18:10come from? Because that just started honing it as you started writing longer form
- 18:13with the magazines, or is that something that you were always from your
- 18:17history lessons in the past and the University of Toronto stuff that you just said
- 18:20the character development is so important that people don't buy
- 18:24yet another business book and read a chapter and weigh down their end tables. They're
- 18:28they're gonna get caught up in the story and ride with me. I think it
- 18:31comes from the New Yorker. That was something I learned. I began to
- 18:34study other writers that I loved and try and learn from
- 18:38them. Janet Malcolm, Michael Lewis, Adam
- 18:42Gopnik, all of whom that was their gift was,
- 18:47was capturing someone's character. And, you
- 18:50know, I I clearly consciously read their read their articles or
- 18:54their books, their journalism, and tried to figure out
- 18:58what they were doing and how I could kind of, learn to
- 19:01do the same thing. It did not it was not something that was in my
- 19:04repertoire before I, started taking
- 19:08magazine writing serious. Was there more of your dad or more of your mom coming
- 19:11through at that time of your life, or you've always felt this sort of
- 19:15balanced? Because when I read about your parents, I said, now I understand
- 19:19how you put these these pieces together. I think it was always a balance. I
- 19:22mean, at various times one one legacy may
- 19:26be in slight ascendancy over another, but I think in general, it's
- 19:30always been those 2 forces propelling me
- 19:33forward. The tipping point just I mean, it just takes off. It's it's
- 19:37a multimillion, bestseller. I have to believe
- 19:41your life changes dramatically at that point. No. Not really. I mean, I just
- 19:45I continue to do to write for Three New Yorker for another,
- 19:4910 years or more. It didn't change the kind of fundamental task
- 19:52of being a working journalist. It gave me confidence
- 19:56that what I was doing had a constituency, so
- 20:00that changed. You know, doors opened more easily if I wanted to talk to
- 20:04someone, if they knew, they know, someone knows who you are, they're more willing to
- 20:07talk to you. So that was easier, but it didn't
- 20:11alter much more than that. It's funny. It's kind of like literary
- 20:14success is a different kind of success than other other professional
- 20:18success. It's not a it's not a clear hierarchy. You know,
- 20:22you join the group of people who have written books, but
- 20:26it's not like, you know, the legal profession where you could
- 20:29point to someone who is the great rainmaker or the great
- 20:33trial lawyer of the generation or the great judge.
- 20:37There's not the same thing going on, I think
- 20:40in the literary world. And how hard was it Because I have to believe that
- 20:44you were suddenly in demand to come and speak at my conference. You know, we
- 20:47want Malcolm Gladwell. We wanna we wanna know the thinking behind the tipping
- 20:51point. Was that a was that a hard move for you to make, or did
- 20:54that come quite naturally as well? Well, that was a real learning curve. I mean,
- 20:58I had to kind of I did speaking for a couple of years, and
- 21:01then I decided that I would take it seriously. So I began to
- 21:05very consciously prepare in a different way to learn a lot more about
- 21:09the people I was, you know, I think the that in the first wave of
- 21:12speaking, people just go and they give a spiel about their book. It's
- 21:16the same spiel every time up. And I began to realize that that
- 21:20was not a way to have a sustained speaking career. And
- 21:23so I committed way more time and attention to
- 21:27my speaking, because I realized how central it was
- 21:30to getting my name out there and also how much I enjoyed it. It's way
- 21:33more enjoyable when you do take more time and you understand what your audience
- 21:37wants and you try and tailor something.
- 21:40That's so it could be useful, you know, so it's people, but talk should not
- 21:44be about you advertising your wares. It should be
- 21:48about you understanding what your audience needs.
- 21:52You know? Why did they bring you here? And what was the most wonderful
- 21:55thing someone has said to you after a speech? Nothing, you know, just in
- 21:59general. If people enjoy a clear enjoying themselves,
- 22:03you know, like if they're laughing, if they're clapping at the end, if they
- 22:06come up to me and I just you when you're talking, you know this, you
- 22:10look out in the room and you could tell whether they wanna be there or
- 22:13not. And if they're not on their phones, nodding off, then
- 22:17and you have their attention, then you've you've succeeded. That's that's what I that's really
- 22:21what I'm looking for. You know, this attention is a Key because I'm finding now
- 22:24that the audience is really often very disengaged from
- 22:28life because they've got the world with an arms race of desire. Have you
- 22:32changed your speaking style? Have you have you adjusted and adapted based
- 22:36on that next generation coming in, you know, wanting
- 22:39content at the speed of life? No. I'm not sure I agree with you, actually.
- 22:43I think what's going on is there's a I think attention
- 22:47spans have grown at one extreme and shrunk at the other
- 22:50Three. That what we're doing now is toggling back and forth between
- 22:55I mean, the same generation that watches
- 22:5810 second TikTok videos will also watch a 10
- 23:02part miniseries on Netflix. And spend 36 hours hammering down
- 23:06a video game for sure. I think what's gone on that way is the middle.
- 23:09I think people will commit to something that's compelling, or they wanna be
- 23:13entertained by something that's immediate.
- 23:17And they will happily go back and forth between those two states. So I watch
- 23:21a lot of biographies, of artists,
- 23:24and I'm always fascinated by the next
- 23:28move. And, you know, I have to follow-up that hit album with another
- 23:32album. How hard was it for you to get going on a second
- 23:35book knowing that in some ways you're gonna be judged by the success of your
- 23:39first? I don't remember feeling any great anxiety about it.
- 23:43I just remember that I took my time in figuring out what it was
- 23:47gonna be about. I was just waiting for something to seize my imagination
- 23:51as much as my first book that. And luckily, I found something relatively
- 23:55quickly that, you know, snap judgments and first impressions
- 23:59that could because I've just been talking to psychologists about them, and I
- 24:02just found it really interesting. My rule was simply if I'm interested in
- 24:06it, then chances are someone else will be too. How do you
- 24:10think Blink now factors into the world
- 24:14of AI where we have such intuitive software and big
- 24:18data? Does it have even more meaningful roles for people to say that their
- 24:21gut and their judgment is is paramount? It's a very interesting
- 24:25question. I don't know the answer to that. I don't really have a good answer
- 24:28to that. I that book was so conceived in this pre AI
- 24:31world that I haven't gone back and thought about it. I mean, I would imagine
- 24:35that, you know, since since good good
- 24:39judgment is the marriage of rational
- 24:42analytic thinking, and the expertise, the
- 24:46unconscious expertise board of experience, that I imagine
- 24:50AI may make good decision making
- 24:54easier. I mean, it helps us with the first of those 2, doesn't it? So
- 24:57that's my only sense that maybe I can see how overall it
- 25:01will make us better decision makers. Outliers was,
- 25:05to me, I would argue 10000 hours of practice,
- 25:09the math of your when you were born. I mean, that became
- 25:13conversation in the schoolyards. It traveled like liquid
- 25:16everywhere. Did you ever imagine it was gonna have that much impact? Because or
- 25:20did did you first write it as a business book? Or did you realize
- 25:24that hockey moms and dads would be starting to look
- 25:28at Chatter their kids are gonna get to the NHL based on what they saw
- 25:31out of that book? Yeah. I didn't it's funny. I I did not see that
- 25:33coming. I I thought it was interesting. I didn't think it would be the most
- 25:36talked about thing in the book. I've been amused to see how how far
- 25:40people have taken that 10000 hour rule. They take it far
- 25:44far further than I expected it would ever go. I'm not sure I even agree
- 25:47with many of the ways people have made made sense of that,
- 25:51argument. Parents still come up to me and say, I read your book and I
- 25:55held my kids back. You might have some kids coming that here in their
- 25:59thirties pretty soon wondering why they got held back because of the book.
- 26:03There's times that you've had critics that have come out.
- 26:06Sometimes, when I've read this criticism, it's almost, I would say, jealous
- 26:10because you you've caught the narrative, and people are now understanding complex
- 26:14subjects in a very tight meme like 10000 hours.
- 26:18How do you deal with does criticism bother you, or do you just go, that
- 26:21fuels me to to defend or to to push back on? I'm not very
- 26:25thin skinned, so I think maybe when you're younger, it
- 26:29hurts a little more. And then by the time you're my
- 26:32age, I mean, I've been doing this for so long,
- 26:36I don't, it doesn't. And you also, you become aware, what
- 26:40you realize is that all work has its share of supporters and criticisms
- 26:44and critics, and there's no way around it. You hope that
- 26:48the proportion is skewed in your favor. That's all you can hope
- 26:51for. You know, you mentioned Seinfeld before. Seinfeld,
- 26:55when it first came out, was panned. Critics handed it. I mean, so I
- 26:58don't know. You can't look at that and take criticism all that
- 27:02seriously. What do you think of Seinfeld? Oh, I think it's genius. I don't think
- 27:06the first season is nearly as good as the subsequent seasons. And so one of
- 27:09the things that teaches us, I don't know whether the critics were wrong. They were
- 27:12just premature. They thought they could judge it on the
- 27:16basis of the first couple of episodes. And maybe the lesson of that is why
- 27:19don't you just wait? Wait till the people running it have found their voice. So
- 27:23I got 2 things, themes that you've talked about, the sense of maybe there's
- 27:26a greater divide, the middle's disappeared. Mhmm. Does that exist even in
- 27:30terms of people that are supporters or against it? Three we've lost the middle
- 27:34ground? Because that's one of the things I'm looking at society, like, why do we
- 27:37seem to be so pushed far out, where North against the South, red
- 27:41against blue Mhmm. Canada, French against English. It seems to be a
- 27:45greater divide. Maybe it's just the news that we're taking, but do you do you
- 27:48think that middle is still there, that you can put something out and have
- 27:52somebody that's against and for, but the mass is really standing
- 27:55firm saying, this is something I love? Yeah. You know, it is it's
- 27:59true that this kind of disappearing middle, you can see it in all kinds of
- 28:03different domains. It's troublesome in some domains.
- 28:07In other domains, though, I don't know. It's funny.
- 28:10I think it's the kind of thing that it's probably a mistake to have
- 28:15one very generalized response. And at the same time, I would
- 28:18also say Chatter don't think that one way you could, one
- 28:22conclusion you could draw from this is that the generalist is dead.
- 28:26And all we have are people who know nothing and people who know a lot,
- 28:29right? But then there's lots of other evidence that says the
- 28:33generalist is now much more important and much more
- 28:37kind of accurate. Yeah. It's interesting because I'd love
- 28:40one day for you to take that on and biases and, you know,
- 28:44confirmation biases. Do we get pushed in such a little castle with like
- 28:48money people liking like money content, validating each other that
- 28:52we start loving that and hating the other, or is it just
- 28:56a wave going through? The other thing I wanted to just, you know, ask you
- 28:59about when you said earlier, you said, you know, the conditions were right for me
- 29:02at The Washington Post because they were hiring at the time. Do you think a
- 29:05New York City can happen again where in
- 29:09a very short period of time, this magic wand, this epidemic
- 29:13that you say can wash over a city and take it from a
- 29:17sort of chaos and and crime and confusion to
- 29:20to being something that people are very proud of? Oh, yeah. I mean, I think
- 29:24it can and will happen all the time. I mean, I think that's the nature
- 29:27of, you know, we saw a repeat of it over
- 29:30COVID. Homicides in major North American cities spiked over
- 29:34COVID. They're now plummeting. I mean, they're down.
- 29:38This year alone, I think in New York City homicides are down 25%.
- 29:42That's what the line looks like, epidemic
- 29:46line. The mistake was in thinking that these kinds of trends
- 29:50move gradually by nature. I
- 29:54think that the natural course is for them to veer up and down quite
- 29:57dramatically, And that when they do flat line for a while, that's the aberration. What
- 30:01the dog saw in that? Their New York stories, was that it was curious the
- 30:03motivation. Was that a publisher
- 30:08saying, Malcolm, we need another book, or was that your chance to say, I
- 30:12have a new audience out there, and there's some stories that deserve more
- 30:15attention? I think that probably a mixture of both. That New Yorker has a
- 30:19court where the writers own their Three. So you
- 30:23can do anthologies. And
- 30:27I made sense was that many of the people who read my books did not
- 30:30read my New Yorker articles. So I that this would be a fun way to
- 30:33expose them to that. And David and Goliath, was that a title that was very
- 30:37similar to your mom's memoir in the sense
- 30:40of the underdog that you called and the misfits that we
- 30:44were really framing these people on a very different lens than they
- 30:48should be thought of? I mean, the real impetus for David That is that it
- 30:51was a companion to Outliers. Outliers was
- 30:55concerned with how advantages lead to success,
- 30:59and David and Goliath was saying, well, sometimes
- 31:03the advantages look like disadvantages. We're compensating,
- 31:08usefully compensating for something that might otherwise
- 31:12be seen as a hindrance or a drawback or
- 31:16a constraint. What's interesting to me about the story of David and Goliath
- 31:19is David's adaptation to his own weakness.
- 31:23That adaptation to weakness is as common or more common,
- 31:27a kind of real world phenomenon than capitalizing
- 31:31on strength. The more I see, you know, I just read
- 31:34that, biography of, Elon
- 31:37Musk and his whole success stories about that.
- 31:41Why is SpaceX the way it is? Because he didn't
- 31:45have any money. And he didn't have the contacts
- 31:48at NASA, and he was supposed to do something entirely
- 31:52new. And that's why he succeeded so dramatically.
- 31:56Had he come in with $1,000,000,000 SpaceX never
- 31:59happens. Super interesting, you know, the very thing we
- 32:03think we do to enable an entrepreneur, give them lots of
- 32:07resources, in that case would have destroyed exactly
- 32:11what made him great. Do you think David and Goliath, I mean, to Key, it
- 32:14was so far ahead of its time when I look today at the
- 32:17disruptors that are attacking and taking down what we all
- 32:21thought were too big to fail because they didn't have the resources. They had to
- 32:25use their imagination. I mean, do you not think that that what you were
- 32:28writing back then is really what is we're seeing with
- 32:32capitalism today? At least a capitalism to me that's got a a higher sense
- 32:36of purpose and momentum? Yeah. A little bit. I mean, I think whenever
- 32:40we're in the middle of whenever you're in the middle of this of a kind
- 32:43of technological transition as we are now, I
- 32:47think that normal rules don't apply. The value of an
- 32:51entrenched position is diminished, and I think we're
- 32:54seeing examples of that. Maybe being forward,
- 33:00with all of your entrenched with your entrenched positioning out of your industry
- 33:04is a hindrance in adapting to an electric
- 33:07future. You know, I don't know. I mean, in some ways, if you're locked into
- 33:11the old way, it's harder to move to the new way. 2 biggest electric car
- 33:15companies in the world are startups, you know, BYD and
- 33:18Tesla. There's a lot of that going on, and the idea that biggest
- 33:22media companies in the world didn't exist a generation before. That's crazy. You know, we
- 33:26had media companies that were hugely
- 33:30important for over a 100 years and suddenly, it's Washington
- 33:33Post being one of them. Washington Post is today a money losing
- 33:37also ran. Do you ever think of yourself as a modern
- 33:41senseu, that the art of war? Like, as you start looking at how he
- 33:45approached competition, the marketplace,
- 33:49retreating and attacking. Because I look at some of the books you write, and you
- 33:52kind of somehow or other, you you bring some of those quotes
- 33:56to life in the most extraordinary fashions. Or is that just me with
- 34:00some wild imagination on it? Yeah. I don't know if I see it that
- 34:04In that That's Three good company to be in, but I'm not sure I'm deserving
- 34:07of that. I mean, but the enemy himself provides the opportunity to defeat the
- 34:11enemy. To me, in some ways, is what what David and Goliath was
- 34:15about. Yeah. Maybe. Yeah. I mean, it's a theme that has shown up in many,
- 34:19particularly, you know, people who think about the military think about this a lot because
- 34:23anyone well versed in the military knows that the army with
- 34:26the most resources does not
- 34:30always win. When
- 34:34we return more with Malcolm Gladwell, and then an interview with Alan de
- 34:37Poncier, the CMO of RBC, This interview took place
- 34:41last year, and given all we've learned from my chat with Malcolm
- 34:44Gladwell, it is even more relevant today.
- 34:53Hi. It's Tony Chapman. Investing in Canada, well, that Matters
- 34:57RBC combat
- 35:01climate Chatter. 500,000,000,000 for Future Launch, a 10 year program
- 35:05to prepare youth for the jobs of tomorrow, helping to discover the next
- 35:08generation of Olympians, artists monetizing their talents, women
- 35:11entrepreneurs pursuing their dreams, supporting mental health, and so much more.
- 35:16Investing in Canada, well, that matters to RBC.
- 35:212,008, something very special happened to me. I was inducted
- 35:24into the Canada's Marketing Hall of Legends. It's one of the proudest moments of my
- 35:28career because my family was Three, one of the proudest moments of my
- 35:32life. You Key, in this hall are people that have put a dent in the
- 35:35marketplace. We have visionaries who came up with ideas. We have business
- 35:39builders that not only established their brand in Canada, but around the world.
- 35:43With stewards of brands who found a way to engage the head and heart and
- 35:46hands of the consumer and the media. We have leaders and creators
- 35:50who've built campaigns that dance all over media. This is more than the
- 35:53hall of legends. If you think about it, it's the hall of learning.
- 35:57Imagine the intellectual resource that exists within it.
- 36:01The lessons in life, the journey, the overcoming circumstances,
- 36:05the tight ropes, the way they reinvented and reimagined the
- 36:09world. The American Marketing Association's Toronto chapter
- 36:12came up with this idea of curating this learning. And what
- 36:16they've done is they've created that lessons journey, lessons in leadership.
- 36:20We're gonna take some of the people that are in this call, spend some
- 36:24time interviewing them, draw out what they bring, not only
- 36:27to your livelihood, but ideally to your life. So thank
- 36:31you for being part of lessons in leadership and the
- 36:34legend's journey. What I call the assumption of
- 36:38transparency, which is when I see you,
- 36:42I observe your demeanor, your face,
- 36:45your expressions, your emotions, your body language, and I draw
- 36:49conclusions about that. And my assumption is that the
- 36:53way you represent your emotions on your face and with your
- 36:56body language is reflective, is consistent with the way you feel in
- 37:00your heart. If you smile at me, it means you're happy. If you
- 37:04frown at me, it means you're not happy. Right? That is
- 37:07true with some people, some of the time. But
- 37:11it is not true of many people a lot of the time.
- 37:15You're listening to Chatter That Matters with Tony Chapman presented
- 37:19by RBC. I wanna thank the Toronto chapter of the American Marketing
- 37:22Association for arranging my interview with Malcolm Gladwell.
- 37:27He's a new inductee in the marketing hall of legends. What we're doing
- 37:30is a series of interviews to institutionalize the
- 37:34learning that the people have found their way there.
- 37:39Talking to strangers, I loved how I think it was an
- 37:42interview you did with Oprah where she started personalizing her
- 37:46talks with strangers. I mean, what was the motivation behind
- 37:50that book? The people reading it at the end of it, what would be your
- 37:54desired outcome in terms of how they would maybe change something about
- 37:58themselves? I was just struck by how many of the cases I was reading about
- 38:01were examples of communication breakdown between
- 38:05strangers. You know, it was, I started that book with one of the signature
- 38:08cases from that wave of high profile
- 38:12police cases in the US. But the more I sort
- 38:16of thought about it, the more I realized that an extraordinary number of contemporary
- 38:20controversies were simply versions of the same problem that 2 people
- 38:24had attempted to communicate and failed. That is a premise
- 38:29for a book that was an enormously powerful one. Again, it takes me back
- 38:32to to trying to invite people back to the middle ground where
- 38:36where people might have opposing views, but if you take your time to communicate it,
- 38:39you you often find you have more in common than you thought. Yeah.
- 38:43Somehow I feel like we had we had lost track
- 38:47of that of the the tools, communication tools that bring us
- 38:50together. They've somehow been mislaid,
- 38:54and I wanted to find them again and bring them back to people's attention. Is
- 38:57there ever been a character in one of your books that you say is really
- 39:01me? Not really. Usually, I'm attracted to
- 39:04writing about people because they are very different from me. I would never
- 39:08interview someone who I thought there would be no point, you
- 39:12know, there would be nothing to learn. I'm interested in, I'm most
- 39:15interested in people, if they're not like Key, because I
- 39:19can, that maximizes the amount that I can learn from them. We're now
- 39:23seeing a lot of people that have built a network, that have built currency with
- 39:26a lot of people, no longer wanting to sing for Three supper. They wanna own
- 39:30their diner, you know, the Ryan Reynolds of the world, the Rihanna's. Is was
- 39:34that one of the motivations of you starting a podcast company versus just
- 39:38doing the podcast that you said, I have an ability
- 39:41to to create great content, and in
- 39:45doing so, that that be rewarded for it. Well, because as I
- 39:48quickly learned, I don't think there was no motivation. I think my motivation was
- 39:53I'd like to have the freedom to do cool things.
- 39:57And the easiest way to do that, to remove the friction,
- 40:01is just to have my own company. I wasn't doing it for
- 40:04economic reasons. And, you know, one of the things I've
- 40:08learned is that very, very, very few people in the podcast world
- 40:12get rich. It's not what it's about. You're giving
- 40:16up, in some senses, you're you're giving up that
- 40:20opportunity in exchange for freedom. That's what it's about. It's about
- 40:23freedom. That you can put together your own little crew, and you could
- 40:27publish it for free on a platform, and you don't
- 40:31have anybody saying you can't do it. And to me, that's what the value is.
- 40:35And, you know, it may be the case that incidentally, some people do
- 40:38well economically, but it's the, the far
- 40:42more important outcome is the liberty
- 40:46it gives you. So as we wrap up this interview, Key
- 40:49talked about mentorship earlier on and how important it is for the
- 40:53Toronto chapter. What advice can would you give to young
- 40:57people that would say to you, I just feel like the headwinds are pushing
- 41:01me in my back feet. Is the climate gonna melt? Am I AI gonna take
- 41:04away my job? Am I getting a university degree that I don't need? What
- 41:08advice would you give to them so that they could instead of thinking
- 41:12about impossibility, think about possibility? Find something that you're
- 41:15interested in, and be
- 41:19good at it. For example, as I always tell people who wanna go into
- 41:23journalism, who wanna write books or what have you,
- 41:26the most important thing is not working. If you want to prepare for that, it's
- 41:30not working for a journalistic enterprise. It's,
- 41:35finding something that you want to write about. If you want to be a foreign
- 41:39correspondent, the first thing you do is you learn another
- 41:42language, not look for a job as a foreign correspondent.
- 41:46If you know Chapman, and you have read deeply in German
- 41:50history and talk to German people and like hanging out in Germany,
- 41:54that's the way to become a foreign correspondent in Germany, right?
- 41:58Building a knowledge base that gives
- 42:01you authenticity and credibility in the
- 42:05marketplace. I had a guy drive me to the airport the other day and he
- 42:09was telling me about his son, who I said, what does your son do? He
- 42:13says, oh, he works as a producer at ESPN. I said, wow. How did he
- 42:16get that job? And he said, well, from the time he was 5
- 42:20years old, when other kids were watching Sesame Street, he was watching Sports Chatter
- 42:24on ESPN. And when he was in college, in high school,
- 42:27he started up, like a radio show, sports radio, and he would do play by
- 42:31play announcing of their school sports teams. And, you
- 42:35know, that makes sense. Right? He made himself the kind of person that
- 42:38ESPN couldn't butt higher. Right? How how did you turn that kid
- 42:42down? Like, he's like, you know, he's exactly what you want. Like,
- 42:46but he did that, and then he consciously
- 42:49sought to build his credibility as someone who's, you know,
- 42:53out of enthusiasm and love for and that's the
- 42:57kind of find the thing that you can build your own
- 43:00expertise around and for which you have enthusiasm and love, and you
- 43:04will be irresistible, I think, to others. I understand we have a book coming out
- 43:08in the fall. Is there anything we can tease in this show to let people
- 43:11Yeah. It's a sequel to The Sipping Point. So it's a return to my first
- 43:15book. And what are we gonna see out of that that sort of takes us
- 43:18into 2024 and beyond? Well, I'm really interested
- 43:22in how much on on establishing
- 43:25who's responsible for epidemics. Do they
- 43:29just happen, or are they the result of deliberate decisions that people
- 43:32make? And if they are, the la if the latter is true, then what are
- 43:35those decisions, and who are those people? So, Malcolm, I always end my
- 43:39podcast with 3 takeaways. And the first is just the word
- 43:43empathy came through almost everything. And so I think there's a lot
- 43:47of your mum and you, but I just love the way you always well,
- 43:50I interview people that are smarter. I I talk to people that are smarter. I
- 43:54mean, you just really have this great curiosity and
- 43:58love. I think the second one for every person living out there, whether
- 44:01you're 20 years old or you're 70, is just find that
- 44:05passion, pursue it, fall in love, and I love what you say. It'll make
- 44:09you irresistible. And that third thing is
- 44:12just how you continue to be
- 44:16curious. You're not doing a sequel to Tipping Point because it
- 44:20was the thing to do, is because you're now curious about how epidemics happen.
- 44:23And I think curiosity is one of the greatest attributes. And if
- 44:27you're living in a world with AI nowadays and you're curious, you've got
- 44:31yourself an army of Davids to work for you. So for all of that and
- 44:34more, we really appreciate you taking the time. And, again,
- 44:37congratulations for, joining us in, Canada's, Marketing Hall of
- 44:41Legends. Thank you so much, Tony. This was really fun.
- 44:46Last year, I had an opportunity to interview Alain
- 44:50Depoisier, the CMO of RBC. I've spent a lot of time with
- 44:53Alain over the years, and I truly value what he has to say
- 44:58about culture and marketing and the tipping
- 45:01point, where through social media, consumers and employees have
- 45:05a voice and their feedback can quickly turn from a whisper
- 45:09to a roar.
- 45:14Joining me now is Alan Key Ponce. He's the chief
- 45:18marketing officer of RBC. Alan, difficult times for
- 45:22marketers because there's a growing cynicism. There's a
- 45:25lot of, people standing on shifting sand. They're looking to blame.
- 45:30How does a brand navigate this climate when when you're going out with good
- 45:33intentions, when you're trying to do good things, knowing that
- 45:37that there's always gonna be people sitting in their armchair ready
- 45:41to fire social media slingshots? I think the most important thing that we try to
- 45:44do is really understand our purpose as an organization, make sure
- 45:48we have the culture that we need internally with all our staff and employees,
- 45:52and have conviction of, you know, our overall plan of
- 45:56delivering against that purpose. And what are the right programs and strategies
- 46:00we're gonna use to to bring it to life. But we're not perfect. You know,
- 46:03sometimes when we do things, we overlook specific situations
- 46:07or, we get feedback. The the great thing about
- 46:10social media is, you get lots of feedback And sometimes
- 46:14that downside of social media is you get a lot of feedback that maybe
- 46:18you don't wanna hear. But I think you're you need to be open to listening
- 46:21and constantly thinking about, are you on the right track and learning to grow over
- 46:25time? How do you keep your the younger generation inspired
- 46:29and motivated because they might read something or their parents might
- 46:33read something and and bring it to the dinner table where they feel they have
- 46:36to defend? How do you let them know that this is just the
- 46:40reality of the world today, and it's okay to have opposing points of
- 46:44view? I think it starts with your culture. I think it starts with,
- 46:47communication of really helping other everybody understand what is our overall
- 46:51purpose as an organization, what is our overall strategy, what are those
- 46:55programs we're gonna lean into? I think we also have to be transparent. And I
- 46:58think the wonderful thing about RBC is we have a culture where people are not
- 47:02afraid to speak up and ask questions and and challenge things,
- 47:06which I think is good. It helps us see different lenses. And as you get
- 47:09those different lenses, you actually make better outcomes and you make better decisions. So, I
- 47:13think you're if you think of your employees as that first kind of
- 47:16feedback mechanism, you'll probably learn a lot more before you go to
- 47:20market that you don't probably want to learn if you put something in market and
- 47:24it's kind of kind of just off the market a bit. And I'm curious as
- 47:27a leader nowadays where we are sometimes walking on
- 47:31eggshells because we're dealing with a lot of current of change. You
- 47:34know? We're dealing with gender equality. We're dealing with diversity,
- 47:38we're dealing with how an organization must stand beyond
- 47:42profit. Is it hard to give the individual
- 47:46the kind of feedback that they deserve? Feedback that is has
- 47:50empathy, but it's also very, very candid. Well, I I actually
- 47:53love the concept of radical candor and all the guiding principles. And I
- 47:57I actually it's one of the few things that I kinda
- 48:01think back to as as part of my leadership journey. And also as as
- 48:05part of our team, I think our organization at RBC has embraced it. You know,
- 48:09I think the guiding principle that I that I start with is you can't grow
- 48:12as an individual unless you get feedback. Like, if you're a professional athlete
- 48:16and you don't have a coach telling you, like, just take a tennis player and
- 48:19and, you know, you're working on your forehand. The great part about having a
- 48:23coach is they tell you what you're doing well and what areas that you can
- 48:25improve on. And they do it because they care about you and they want you
- 48:28to succeed. So if you take that same guiding principle for radical candor,
- 48:31you as a leader should want to give candid feedback to your
- 48:35employee, as well as receive candid feedback from them to you
- 48:38so that you can be so that you can grow. And it's just
- 48:42normal to get both positive feedback and maybe feedback that's not so
- 48:46good. But it starts with the concept of caring. And I think that's the piece
- 48:49that most resonates with me is if someone's giving me feedback and I know they
- 48:52care about me, then I'm more apt to listen to it. If they're just giving
- 48:56me feedback and I don't think they care about me, then I probably get a
- 48:59discount. I think the most important thing as a leader is to create an environment
- 49:04and a muscle that, you know, feedback is a good thing. That's
- 49:07how we grow. That's how we better. I think the worst or least helpful feedback
- 49:12I've ever received is when I only get positive feedback. Nobody's perfect. I know I'm
- 49:15not perfect. I'm far from perfect. But when they don't share their true
- 49:19thoughts or they sugarcoat constructive points, it really doesn't
- 49:23help you grow as an individual. And I'm not saying that you should go out
- 49:26and give people really hard critiques, but have the respect to be honest
- 49:30and constructive. If you really care about that individual, you want them to help
- 49:34them help them grow and succeed through constructive feedback. I thank you for letting
- 49:38me be part of that as well and, continued successes that, in
- 49:41your, marketing role. I appreciate it. Thank you. Chatter that matters
- 49:45has been a presentation of RBC. It's Tony Chapman.
- 49:49Thanks for listening. Let's chat soon.