Latest / No Way Out / Reading People Rarely Works: Poker Tells & the Real OODA Loop | Zach Elwood
Transcript
- 0:00Zach Elwood: I think a lot of people are are will say things like when they hear that you've played poker for a living or or done something similar, they're like, Oh, I can never, you know, I can never stand to take such chances or do such gambling.
- 0:10Zach Elwood: But I think at the end of the day, so much of what we do is gambling.
- 0:14Zach Elwood: It's like we're we're gambling by staying at the same job for a long time, or we're gambling by, you know, deciding not to leave our spouse, even though we think it's a bad relationship.
- 0:26Zach Elwood: Like all these things that we do, kind of inertia-wise, are also making decisions.
- 0:31Zach Elwood: And it they're all they're all various forms of, they have analogies to gambling because there's so much decision-making and and uh chance and uh unknowns involved, and we're constantly navigating all these things every day, you know, and just just things like poker make it more clear about how much of this stuff is outside your control, you know, in that in that environment.
- 0:53Zach Elwood: But I think it's it's so true on so many levels.
- 0:55John R. Boyd: When we have max entropy at max like disorder, which is that it's called what chaos.
- 0:59John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 1:02John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then there is no way out.
- 1:05John R. Boyd: Once we can eliminate the feature just by it, well, bottom of all, we don't know how to do this.
- 1:10John R. Boyd: We want to get a max out between our actions and our situations we deal with.
- 1:15John R. Boyd: If we have a mismatch, we can't cope, right?
- 1:17John R. Boyd: And there is no way out.
- 1:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not many people come on the podcast No Way Out with the coolest last name that sounds like a first name from a famous movie.
- 1:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, but today I have Zach Elwood.
- 1:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's a podcaster, has an interesting history with poker.
- 1:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh I really came across his work recently when I was talking to Kent Clisby, tells and and uh fraudsters and things like that.
- 1:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Zach, welcome to uh No Way Out, man.
- 1:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How are you doing?
- 1:44Zach Elwood: Hey, thanks, Punch.
- 1:45Zach Elwood: Appreciate it.
- 1:46Zach Elwood: It's an it's an honor to be asked.
- 1:47Zach Elwood: And yeah, I get the Elwood Blues uh reference from Blues Brothers to get them out over the years, yeah.
- 1:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, our generation would get that, but I think uh the newer generation is gonna go, what the hell are you talking about?
- 1:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So hey, speaking of what the hell are you talking about?
- 1:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh poker.
- 2:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh what did you learn in poker?
- 2:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh how did that bring you to podcasting?
- 2:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So poker to podcasting.
- 2:06Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 2:06Zach Elwood: So I used to play poker for a living.
- 2:09Zach Elwood: It was around, you know, I'm I'm pretty getting up there in years.
- 2:12Zach Elwood: This was back in like 2003 to 2007 time period.
- 2:16Zach Elwood: Then just on the side after that.
- 2:19Zach Elwood: But uh when I played a lot, I often thought it was strange that there wasn't a better book on poker tells.
- 2:26Zach Elwood: So aka poker behavior, reading behavior in poker.
- 2:30Zach Elwood: And I had ideas for writing the book over quite a few years, and that was during the the poker boom, which really got going in 2003.
- 2:37Zach Elwood: A lot of people were playing poker back then.
- 2:39Zach Elwood: I was always surprised there wasn't a better book on poker tails because I and people I know in the poker scene thought that the stuff that was out there was quite weak, and then years later, uh a good book that hadn't really been written.
- 2:53Zach Elwood: I mean, you had Mike Carrow's Poker Tales, but that was a pretty old book.
- 2:56Zach Elwood: That was from like the 1980s, and that's a good book, but it also felt dated and it felt like aimed at very simple players, amateur players.
- 3:03Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 3:03Zach Elwood: So yeah, flash forward to 2010, I started working on a book just because I was like, well, maybe nobody else is gonna write it, I'll try writing it.
- 3:12Zach Elwood: Didn't know how it would go, but it got a lot of respect and uh a lot of people liked what I said with that book, and a lot of it to summarize what people liked about it, it was a lot about thinking about situational context because you know, for example, somebody who's made a big bet, that's a very different situation from somebody who's waiting for somebody else to act.
- 3:30Zach Elwood: You know, there's like an aggressor versus a non-aggressor type of dynamic.
- 3:34Zach Elwood: So I examined those kind of dynamics in there and talked about the importance of the situation, which people really liked.
- 3:39Zach Elwood: It was more of a framework for thinking about tells versus like describing this means that, you know.
- 3:45Zach Elwood: Uh so people really liked that, and then that led to me being incentivized to spend more time going down the tells rabbit hole, and I wrote a book on verbal poker tells.
- 3:53Zach Elwood: I spent eight months full time researching and writing that one.
- 3:56Zach Elwood: And uh I watched like, you know, a hundred plus hours of poker footage and took notes when I played to work on like this kind of dictionary of common meanings for these things people say when they're playing poker.
- 4:09Zach Elwood: So yeah, I was most proud of that work.
- 4:11Zach Elwood: Wrote created a video series for poker tells, did another final book, which was meant to be my final thing I had to say in the poker tell space.
- 4:20Zach Elwood: And uh yeah, and since then I've consulted for quite a few high-stakes players.
- 4:23Zach Elwood: I recently just consulted for the World Series of Poker main event uh player who got sixth, Rami Hamood, and uh did some poker teles consulting for him.
- 4:33Zach Elwood: I currently have an ongoing thing for almost a year now, consulting for a high-stakes player who plays a Macau, and what we watch a lot of uh poker footage from streams, including opponents that he sometimes plays with, this kind of thing.
- 4:45Zach Elwood: So, yeah, that's kind of a summary of what I do, and I and I want to emphasize that I don't think of myself as some sort of poker tells genius.
- 4:53Zach Elwood: I'm just a guy who's you know went down the rabbit hole researching and thinking about it a lot.
- 4:57Zach Elwood: And uh I barely even play myself these days.
- 5:00Zach Elwood: I'm pretty out of the poker scene, but still keep my uh you know, foot in the water or toe in the water, whatever it is.
- 5:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 5:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We try to explain uh you know the difference between uh uncertainty and and a little bit of certainty using uh chess versus a poker analogy.
- 5:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, a lot of people you could play chess, you it's all the pieces are on the board, there's nothing uh you know, all the information is already out there.
- 5:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in fact, you just brought up context.
- 5:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have information from the environment to the other person as well.
- 5:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Poker, you you have that, but you also have uh you don't have perfect information.
- 5:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not everybody has well actually I would say nobody has perfect information in poker.
- 5:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, right.
- 5:35Zach Elwood: It's a very hidden information game, uh incomplete information game compared to chess, where it's a complete information game, right?
- 5:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 5:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 5:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you have to make uh decisions under conditions of uncertainty with some time pressure.
- 5:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so it's a great way to think about uh how things are happening today, right?
- 5:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you know the transfer from your space to our space, uh to business, to markets, you name it, is is I I think there.
- 5:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In aviation, there there's a problem in aviation, in fighter aviation.
- 6:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We generally we don't know where our threats are all the time, but we have a pretty good idea where they are, and we have ways to suppress them.
- 6:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's um it's I'll argue it's more complicated.
- 6:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Your space is gonna be a little bit more complex.
- 6:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, it's not to say uh we're gonna categorize and say your space is harder than my space or my old space, but we can learn lessons from each other.
- 6:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In fact, I think you're yeah, you you mentioned the other day that you're reading um which one of Gary Klein's book books are you on right now?
- 6:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sources of power, like the well-known one.
- 6:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 6:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 6:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and Gary studied a lot of aviation, uh, you know, he has a lot of that in his past, and there's actually an interesting connection to the show through Gary as well.
- 6:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But you know, my my point behind all this is you have lived experience where you get put into a pressure cooker, or or you did in the in your past, and then you get to learn from that.
- 6:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then kind of like Annie Duke has has written books on this, uh, and I think some of the great things she writes about lineup with complex adaptive system thinking, and this is very important, separating decisions from outcomes, right?
- 6:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh uh that's something she points out that she learned from poker.
- 7:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But you really got into the uh the podcasting space and uh you know you're having conversations with people that identify fraudsters and things like that.
- 7:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can can can you talk a little bit about that and what you're exploring on your podcast?
- 7:17Zach Elwood: Yeah, it's uh it was never really something I set out to do, and how it happened was, you know, I I I'm most well known for my my biggest claim to fame is my poker tells work.
- 7:27Zach Elwood: So I was trying to parlay that a little bit, and I was thinking about what I could do in a more mainstream area, and I've always been interested in psychology and behavior.
- 7:36Zach Elwood: That was what led to my interest in poker tells in the first place.
- 7:38Zach Elwood: So I thought about having just a general psychology slash behavior focused podcast, and that's what led to the podcast.
- 7:45Zach Elwood: And uh and honestly, yeah, getting into the the nuance of it, it's like when I first started out with the podcast, I thought I would I you know, poker tells was kind of my niche.
- 7:55Zach Elwood: I didn't really have a lot of viewpoints on like general behavior experts and such, but as I went down this rabbit hole and I started thinking there was a lot of just bad information by these people who call themselves behavior experts, and that includes anything from just like kind of exaggerated credentials or exaggerated claims by people who actually have you know legitimate uh credentials to all the way to like straight up frauds and you know pathological liars.
- 8:24Zach Elwood: You know, there's a spectrum of these people who you know, because it there's something about the behavior reading space that really pre-selects for there's there's a huge demand for this stuff, first of all.
- 8:35Zach Elwood: So that kind of explains why all these people kind of enter the fray of various qualities and you know, a lot of them do a lot of exaggerations, but the big demand for this sexiness of reading people, you know, whether it's high-stakes environments or whether it's like reading people for like dating or romantic reasons or whatever it is, there's there is this sexiness when it comes to reading people, which I think helps account for my success too with the poker tails work.
- 9:02Zach Elwood: It's like not not those people, a lot of people who bought my books shouldn't have been buying it, they should have been focused on strategy.
- 9:07Zach Elwood: But the poker tails is a much sexier topic, right?
- 9:10Zach Elwood: And I yeah, and so that demand I think leads to a lot of just unethical and and weird stuff in the behavior reading space.
- 9:18Zach Elwood: So that's how I got into Chase Hughes, got on my radar, and I had this I had heard uh a five-minute clip of him on a on Jordan Harbinger's podcast, and I was like, this there's something wrong about this guy.
- 9:31Zach Elwood: This and I and I and so I went down the rabbit hole of uh looking into him, and I didn't even know what I didn't even expect to find much, and I just kept finding more and more ridiculous things.
- 9:39Zach Elwood: And I so I did a podcast episode about that.
- 9:42Zach Elwood: That was like almost two years ago, or maybe more now, and that got a you know, that that first episode's gotten like a hundred and seventy thousand plus views on YouTube.
- 9:49Zach Elwood: So that was a you know, but it and I kept putting out more on him and started delving into other stuff too, because I'm like, there is just so much of this stuff, there's like a whole industry of people that really exaggerate things and put out bad information and they make a lot of money doing it.
- 10:06Zach Elwood: You know, there's a big incentive to do that stuff, you know.
- 10:09Zach Elwood: So yeah.
- 10:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I wonder, uh, you know, it's kind of messy when you read people.
- 10:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's that you can't put people in a box.
- 10:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I I can't remember if you're if you looked at uh pseudoscience like NLP and and Myers Briggs and all that.
- 10:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you know, we work in the side of organizations, people like to be put in a box, you know, I'm I'm this color or you're that color, and you know, I'm this and you're that.
- 10:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's not how the world works.
- 10:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I don't think you could do that uh necessarily in in poker.
- 10:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In fact, I would say this if if you sat me down next to you or you put me at a table, I couldn't read anybody, right?
- 10:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just don't have that experience.
- 10:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, I have a little bit of experience, but not in that context.
- 10:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you would have to coach you would have to coach me on that and be kind of sloppy or messy.
- 10:47Zach Elwood: Well, and it's worth pointing out the nuance in these areas because it's like, I mean, for the large part, you know, most of the time I can't read people either.
- 10:55Zach Elwood: You know, it's like it we're talking about, I always go out of my way to emphasize there in poker tail, when it comes to the poker tells, I mean, it's like a lot of people have this perception that poker is all about reading people or something or picking off bluffs based on behavior, but it's like I emphasize that even good readers of tells might only change a decision based on a tell like a couple times in a full day, eight-hour session.
- 11:17Zach Elwood: You know, we're so we're talking about when things line up well and when you have the confidence to sway a judgment, right?
- 11:24Zach Elwood: And and a lot of those things might not even they'll be far from 100%.
- 11:26Zach Elwood: It'll be more like, okay, there's a few factors based on the way they play the hand, and I get a little bit of sense from the behavior.
- 11:33Zach Elwood: But I think it's really worth pointing out in the same way that it's hard to read people in high-stakes real world domains, it's hard to read people in poker and other games.
- 11:42Zach Elwood: But I think that the thing that I've really focused on, you know, because I think some people would be surprised because I criticize a lot of behavior experts on my podcast.
- 11:50Zach Elwood: A lot of people will be like, well, what's different about what you do in the poker space and what they do?
- 11:54Zach Elwood: And I think there's just many differences between these kind of more game-like scenarios versus like interrogation, real-world scenarios, because the thing about the game scenarios is like they're very formalized, they have various rules, they have physical objects that you're moving and focusing on.
- 12:13Zach Elwood: They have uh you get to see somebody in different situations multiple times in these formalized environments, you know, like a poker hand from somebody going from bluffing to you know value-betting a strong hand a few minutes later.
- 12:25Zach Elwood: It's like you get to see these variations, and you don't really have this kind of like formal environment when it comes to like interrogations and such, which helps, which helps explain why trying to use behavior in real-world non-game environments is so hard.
- 12:39Zach Elwood: And then you also, you know, it's hard to base decisions on such minor things in real-world scenarios because you know, we're we're talking about different different sources of information are worth different things.
- 12:51Zach Elwood: So you can't really, it's really hard to justify basing a major real-world decision on some minor behavioral thing, but you can do that in the game because, as you said, especially in an incomplete information environment, your your decisions are often so close anyway.
- 13:05Zach Elwood: So you can like veer one way or another based on like pretty pretty weak information, not you know, information that's that's can be meaningful, but that's far from 100% reliable.
- 13:15Zach Elwood: It can make your decisions better, especially over the long term if you're making a lot of them.
- 13:20Zach Elwood: But that's hard to make an analogy to to like you know, making a major decision in an investigation or an interrogation or something based on uh something that's like far from 100% right reliable, right?
- 13:30Zach Elwood: So that that's I think there's a lot of differences, and that's how I see it, and that's how I've grown to see it over the years, wondering like, why is this so actionable in these domains but not in these other domains, right?
- 13:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well as you're talking about this, I was thinking about uh being in a flow state.
- 13:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you have some risk, you're present, you're focused, you know, you're engaged in the environment in that situation.
- 13:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So as as somebody who's trying to read somebody, you're you're likely going to be um very focused and present in in that situation.
- 13:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Whereas other times people aren't always going to have that.
- 14:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It it might be just a a slice of a day uh where you went from being a dad to being a uh an executive in in the last hour, so your identity's changing throughout the day.
- 14:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In in your case, you you're you're in a bubble, right?
- 14:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're kind of like in a bubble and and and you have a lot of context and a lot of experience from that.
- 14:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And so so therefore, you know, it I I think it is really hard to bring all that and those lessons from there and say, this is exactly how it's done, because we don't it context matters.
- 14:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, I I think that's where I'm going with that.
- 14:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is context really matters.
- 14:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's why I think maybe why you you recognize that there's a lot of um folks present misrepresenting themselves as experts in these fields when you know you you can't do it yourself.
- 14:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, how do you explain this to your your you know, your girlfriend or your your best buddy how this works if they've ever played poker or uh it it just doesn't work like that?
- 14:52Zach Elwood: It's very complex.
- 14:53Zach Elwood: Yeah, it's yeah, yeah.
- 14:54Zach Elwood: There's a lot of context, it's very complex, and even you know, even having a lot of knowledge on it, it's quite hard to do when you're up against people that you know are are pretty are fairly skilled, right?
- 15:07Zach Elwood: Like these things are very hard.
- 15:08Zach Elwood: So, yeah, seeing the nuance in once in one domain helps you see a lot of the bullshit about how people make these sweeping claims, confident claims about what you can do with these amazing things you can do with X, Y, Z.
- 15:21Zach Elwood: Right.
- 15:22Zach Elwood: I think that these things apply to other domains too.
- 15:25Zach Elwood: There's all sorts of people that inflate their credentials and what you can do with the information that they'll be training you with, right?
- 15:32Zach Elwood: There's that that's just a general pattern, but I think it is interesting how common that is in this like behavior reading body language type you know environment.
- 15:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I think there's a another aspect to that, uh to this, and that is the the consumer.
- 15:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, the consumer of these fraudsters, if you want to call them that, or these folks they want a zempic answer to something, right?
- 15:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They want a pill, they want a one-size-fits-all approach, they don't want to have to think.
- 15:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh that's human nature.
- 16:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Humans are naturally lazy.
- 16:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We you know, we're always taking, we have heuristics and biases, we always take shortcuts, and we like the heroes.
- 16:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We like yeah, we we like heroes.
- 16:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We like heroes coming over and telling us how things work, even though heroes don't necessarily exist in in uh in this type of environment.
- 16:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's usually a group of people working together.
- 16:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh but going back to those empic uh analogy, you can't come tell me I want that this is messy.
- 16:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to know how to do this, and I want a Myers-Briggs approach, and I want to know step one through five, and you're gonna tell me that.
- 16:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what they want.
- 16:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And those are the people that are gonna be susceptible to the the Chase Hughes out there, right?
- 16:38Zach Elwood: Yeah, I was thinking of uh it makes me think of there there's a great book about the limitations of using behavior, nonverbal behavior for deception detection by the by Tim Levine, who wrote this book, Duped, talking about how it just doesn't work for that, you know.
- 16:52Zach Elwood: And uh if you read review Amazon reviews that once stood out to me where one guy was like, I'm gonna trust the people that uh, you know, are former law enforcement people and the body language experts, they've got the real experience.
- 17:05Zach Elwood: And it's like I think that just really summarizes like there is this real demand, and some people are like, even if you walk them through why these things aren't very useful in these various domains and explain to them what the research shows and even what practitioners, you know, why practitioners will critique these things, it's like for some people that's they just want to they just want those answers and they want to find the the the you know mystical or or elite powers of whatever sort, the secret powers, they're see, they're gonna seek those out no matter what.
- 17:35Zach Elwood: And if you're not gonna give it to them, they'll find somebody else who will, right?
- 17:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if you're traveling through an airport and you go to the bookstore there and you pick up uh Blink by Malcolm Gladwell or another book by him, then or I can't remember who came up with the 10,000-hour rule and and who amplified that.
- 17:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But you pick up these uh what do you call uh they're kind of like soda pop pop culture books, you know, and people buy into them.
- 17:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think Blink captured some of this as well.
- 17:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is there a connection to what Malcolm Gladwell wrote and and some of the things that you uncovered?
- 18:04Zach Elwood: Yeah, there's a really interesting thing there, actually, where Malcolm Gladwell and Blink he promoted Paul Ekman, who is is a well-known behavior/slash deception detection researcher.
- 18:17Zach Elwood: Like the show Lie to Me was very loosely based on Paul Ekman's ideas.
- 18:21Zach Elwood: The the renown that Paul Ekman got from that book in early 2000s, I think it was from Blink, led to him.
- 18:29Zach Elwood: I think there was a direct line from that to his ideas being used in the Lie to Me show, but also for the TSA Spot program, which ended without, you know, with a lot of criticism and a lot of money wasted and not really showing any efforts.
- 18:43Zach Elwood: And I think, I mean, I've talked to a lot of behavior researchers, and they they're usually they don't like the drama of calling out people directly, but you can put the pieces together.
- 18:51Zach Elwood: Like Paul Ekman is perceived as a quite unethical, low quality person who over the years got worse and worse.
- 18:58Zach Elwood: Like he became more narcissistic and promoted his ideas more and more despite what the research said, and claim made these claims about how he could detect.
- 19:07Zach Elwood: You know, there's a congressional testimony for the spot program where he claimed he could detect you use his methods, microexpression methods to detect deception at like 80 to 90 percent, basically.
- 19:17Zach Elwood: I think that was just like almost a perjury from what I know.
- 19:20Zach Elwood: So just to say there's an interesting connection between Malcolm Gladwell's blink, but then but then later also Malcolm Gladwell, I don't know if he was doing it to kind of like cancel out what he did with Paul Ekman, uh, because he really set up Paul Ekman as being this like amazing wizard of like truth detection, and it just wasn't that's not true at all.
- 19:39Zach Elwood: If you dig into what Paul Ekman has done, it's just it's not that impressive from everything I know and from behavior experts I've talked to.
- 19:46Zach Elwood: But then Malcolm Gladwell also later in a later book uh promoted Tim Levine's work, which was actually showing the huge limitations of uh that his book Duped uh showed the the huge limitations of using nonverbal behavior for deception detection.
- 20:02Zach Elwood: You you really can't do it, the signs are really faint and unreliable, and there's many reasons why, you know, the basic fact that if you're in high-stakes adversarial environments, you'll tend to act really nervous and such, so indicators of you know whether you're innocent or or guilty, so indicators of uh anxiety don't really mean much in these in these situations.
- 20:20Zach Elwood: But just to say, yeah, Malcolm Gladwell has played a role, I think, in uh promoting people for good or bad or bad.
- 20:25Zach Elwood: And Tim Levine's not the other one, only one who points out the uh you know, the fact that the research shows deception detection can't really be done with nonverbal behavior, but he's he was a he's been a prominent person in the area.
- 20:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that that that connection to Gladwell uh it it kind of repeats now on podcasts.
- 20:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a lot of great podcasters out there.
- 20:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You got uh Diary of a CEO, you have uh Sean Ryan.
- 20:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We could talk about that too if you want to.
- 20:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have uh and what I mean great, uh popular, uh Joe Rogan.
- 20:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 20:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So pop culture kind of drives a lot of things.
- 20:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if you get if you make your way onto one of those podcasts, uh you you made it, right?
- 21:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're you're you're on, you're you're somebody.
- 21:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just like Gladwell picking up on Ekman's work, hey, I'm you know, it I don't think there was any uh malintent by Gladwell to to write that, right?
- 21:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just hey, this is what was available information.
- 21:14Zach Elwood: It's an exciting story, and you know, I I mean similar to the podcasters, it's like we're all drawn, even the most ethical journalists or or authors or whatever are drawn to exciting stories, and that's what Malcolm Gladwell is drawn to, and sometimes he makes mistakes and sometimes he gets it right, or sometimes it's debatable.
- 21:31Zach Elwood: But I think uh yeah, I think we're all especially in the internet age, everybody's seeking these clicks online, so that drives more people to just embrace these kind of exciting stories to get clicks that don't really even care at some level, some some of them whether it's true or whether the person is trustworthy or whatever, it just gets clicks, you know.
- 21:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So yeah, but but an expert like I'm gonna call you an expert, but I we don't like using the term expert in here, but somebody has is I'm always skeptical of the expert term, yeah.
- 21:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you You're a student of of you know verbal cues, nonverbal cues, and you pick up pick up this from uh Gladwell and Ekman, and that you you go down that and that's your expertise or that's your uh area of uh familiarity.
- 22:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then when the Chase Hughes thing came up, I didn't I don't I don't know Chase.
- 22:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you know, just because I served in the Navy doesn't mean I know Chase uh Hughes.
- 22:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when my friends were asking me to go, hey, dude, you got to go get this guy on your podcast.
- 22:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, hey man, I'm a small podcast.
- 22:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's hard to get these big names on here when they're making $30,000 to $50,000 an hour to go talk at a keynote or to do a keynote.
- 22:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's a different level.
- 22:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Like you you're you usually fall to the bottom of the queue on a podcast when you reach out to those folks.
- 22:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, you do make it on there, but so I started doing my uh due diligence and I'm like, man, this doesn't add up.
- 22:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, the the context of his background, I couldn't find much on it.
- 22:50Zach Elwood: Well, he'll he'll do, and he'll also do literally any podcast.
- 22:53Zach Elwood: If you have 10 followers, he'll probably be on your podcast.
- 22:55Zach Elwood: So just everybody, so everybody knows, yeah.
- 22:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, yeah, yeah.
- 22:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So but but it very believable.
- 23:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not saying what he's saying is wrong.
- 23:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm just saying, you know, alarm bells went off in my head, and that's actually one of the reasons I found you, or how I found you, was start pulling on that uh that thread a little bit.
- 23:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, wait a minute, there's there's something not adding up here.
- 23:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I let my buddies know this, and they're like, dude, what do you mean?
- 23:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's he's I'm Joe Rogan.
- 23:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's been on the Chipcats.
- 23:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do you mean?
- 23:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 23:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, I'm just saying there's something not adding up.
- 23:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And again, just doing a little bit of work, having some context in the Navy and knowing what those roles do.
- 23:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, nah, these things don't add up.
- 23:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then something else that I, you know, from my background, there's a lot of military-themed consultancies out there that you you start, you you know, jump out of the cockpit or you know, jump out of the the rafters in your flight suit and you get all excited.
- 23:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're a hero.
- 23:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're already using your veteran background to promote yourself, and I'm like, it's okay, it's kind of cool.
- 23:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then you're saying things that don't line up to what the science says.
- 23:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, did you pick up a damn book when you got out of the military?
- 23:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you know that that's not how that works?
- 23:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it doesn't matter.
- 23:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What matters is you're selling to the fears and egos, if you want to call it that, of of the customer.
- 24:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and there's there's room for that.
- 24:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So God bless these guys that go out there and sell these folks that are kind of gullible, but that's not the that's not the space I want to be in.
- 24:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know?
- 24:14Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 24:14Zach Elwood: And I was just talking about this yesterday with my with my girlfriend, and because we we watch a lot of this content.
- 24:20Zach Elwood: I got her interested in some of this stuff.
- 24:22Zach Elwood: But yeah, there is such a and and I don't want to go down the you know, uh I've got criticisms of of Joe Navarro too, but he the thing about Joe Navarro, he's kind of he showed the model of how you could do these things, especially in this behavior uh reading people space, of like taking the template of like I have I and he did have, you know, he obviously has legitimate FBI credentials.
- 24:46Zach Elwood: He was in the FBI, did some impressive uh, you know, had some impressive work in there, but then like the template of like taking that and then selling it to a mainstream audience, right?
- 24:57Zach Elwood: There's and converting that into what the audience is hungry for.
- 25:01Zach Elwood: And I've talked to people behind the scenes, peep ex-law enforcement people who talk to me off the record about these things, and there is a big you know, peep when people think about getting out of the the uh the military or law enforcement and they're retiring or whatever, and they're thinking about what can I do next, there is this thing like, oh, I can be a speaker, I can sell some books, I can get get some good speaking engagements and make a good amount of money.
- 25:27Zach Elwood: Some of those things are quite lucrative.
- 25:29Zach Elwood: I can do private consulting, you know, XYZ.
- 25:32Zach Elwood: And I think there is this kind of template where it's like I'll I'll write a book um making my you know, making my experiences sound impressive.
- 25:40Zach Elwood: I'll I'll pitch myself as maybe a uh you know, some sort of expert in the reading people or interrogation or you know, whatever domain it is.
- 25:49Zach Elwood: And uh yeah, so there's a there's a real template there.
- 25:52Zach Elwood: And I think I talked to one person specifically who was describing like seeing these people who they knew were not good at their jobs, they had known from working with them, and they were having suc, those other people were having success at that model.
- 26:05Zach Elwood: And this person was basically like, they're doing it.
- 26:08Zach Elwood: Why why can't I do it?
- 26:09Zach Elwood: You know, like so that and they're like, they're the I know that person didn't do a good job when they were, you know, in whatever agency, but they're doing really well with this, you know, expert uh credentials consultancy/slash speaking thing.
- 26:23Zach Elwood: So why not?
- 26:24Zach Elwood: Well, I'll do it too, because I know I'm better than that person, right?
- 26:27Zach Elwood: So there is this uh kind of competition amongst people who are trying to all do this thing from my from what I've gathered.
- 26:34Zach Elwood: That's how I see it.
- 26:36Zach Elwood: And that's not to say it's all you know, there there are consultants needed.
- 26:39Zach Elwood: It's not to say it's all bad work or anything, it's just to explain why there is this kind of template and why there can be this competition to get the most attention and why you find people wording things in vague, ambiguous ways to try to ramp up their perception of what they did, right?
- 26:55Zach Elwood: So there's just a lot of ambiguous language use, and that's even leaving aside like the Chase Hughes who are completely like on another level of exaggerated things.
- 27:05Zach Elwood: I'm talking I'm talking about people who are in the more realistic realm of kind of like a lot of people exaggerate their resumes and such, you know.
- 27:12Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 27:12Zach Elwood: So yeah, that's just what I've learned talking to a lot of people in the space over the years.
- 27:16Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 27:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, I might be okay with that.
- 27:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I might be mostly harmless.
- 27:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, it's is it gonna really harm an organization?
- 27:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know.
- 27:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But you had Pete Blair on recently, and and we had him on recently.
- 27:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Pete brought up four P's uh from uh John Vervake and talked about procedural knowledge, and and uh when he brought that up, I mentioned to him that you know that's that's why leadership books are garbage because they they they you misremember the past and you start attributing things to things that didn't happen, and you write a book.
- 27:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So going down the formula you just kind of laid out there, uh, from the military side, you go to the military, do your reserve time, do your active duty time, whatever, get out.
- 27:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You may have been a horrible person, horrible aviator, horrible at whatever, but it doesn't matter.
- 27:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What matters is you you you served and you and now you come out and you write a book, you misremember the past, you write it all up, talk about all these awesome things you did and how they transferred to your world, right?
- 28:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then that's the formula.
- 28:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and the truth is we just we just covered that.
- 28:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That is not how it works.
- 28:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It doesn't work.
- 28:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh this this pattern emerges over and over.
- 28:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I think that's probably what you've experienced from observed from from your time on your podcast and everything else you've done in your past.
- 28:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's kind of how vibes are things.
- 28:21Zach Elwood: It happens in many domains, like the same, the same kind of you know, template or or or playbook.
- 28:26Zach Elwood: I think it's like it's uh and the thing I've also thought about is like it's so it's quite easy to make exciting anecdotes and tell exciting stories, and you know, even to tell interesting, kind of like Gladwell, it's it's quite easy to tell weave interesting narratives of whatever sort and get people involved.
- 28:48Zach Elwood: And like something being interesting and captivating does not mean it's true.
- 28:53Zach Elwood: It doesn't, you know, it doesn't if it's pr if just because it's persuasive in a in a in a small story doesn't make it true.
- 29:00Zach Elwood: But I think we like you said, we are captivated by these ideas of like, oh, I can get these simple tips and I'll completely rework my strategies or my success in these areas.
- 29:10Zach Elwood: You know, it's like that's very that's a very sexy thing, yeah.
- 29:13Zach Elwood: Uh but I mean there are good things to be learned.
- 29:16Zach Elwood: There are good things, yeah.
- 29:17Zach Elwood: Not to not to say there's plenty of good ideas out there.
- 29:21Zach Elwood: It's just to say there's also a lot of mediocre to bad ideas floating around, and it can be hard unless you have the domain knowledge, it's hard to distinguish between them.
- 29:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you know, challenging assumptions is important, and I think this kind of fits in the space that you're coming from too.
- 29:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when I'm watching or listening to a podcast, and I think a lot more people are watching now, you gotta pay attention to what are the motives behind the people, the guests, uh, what what are they trying to promote?
- 29:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's okay.
- 29:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There, there's I I do enjoy listening to podcasts.
- 29:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a lot of great information out there.
- 29:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just be careful, right?
- 29:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I know you wrote a couple books uh recently about uh diffusing American anger and how contempt destroys democracy.
- 29:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think it this is important.
- 30:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This discourse that we can have on podcasts and conversation is is really valuable.
- 30:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A little danger in that.
- 30:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about what brought you to write those books about polarization?
- 30:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sure.
- 30:12Zach Elwood: Yeah, I uh Yeah, and I should preface it by yeah, I think I think some people sometimes criticize me of being super pessimistic on when it comes to the media front.
- 30:22Zach Elwood: And it's not that it's not that I don't think these conversations of whatever sort are important.
- 30:28Zach Elwood: It's also I just think we need to bring a lot of skepticism to them, like we're talking about.
- 30:32Zach Elwood: It's like, yeah, but to tie that to the polarization work, I I went down the rabbit hole of toxic political polarization and conflict in general, and then it started out, you know, it was kind of my journey was yeah, I was very, you know, anti-Trump, and then I was issuing a lot of insults to Trump supporters online, but then I got curious about you know, how is what I'm doing contributing to this cycle of uh contempt and you know uh political polarization and such, and how you know I I'm doing the same things that I dislike in other people, etc.
- 31:05Zach Elwood: etc.
- 31:05Zach Elwood: Uh so I got down this rabbit hole and I had on on my podcast uh that I use that as a way to kind of inquire about this conflict dynamics and how they play out in general in groups or nations or whatever.
- 31:18Zach Elwood: And there's just and what I and then I wrote those books which were they're both they have a lot in common.
- 31:23Zach Elwood: I wrote one for a l more liberal anti-Trump audience, which is the How Contempt Destroys Democracy.
- 31:28Zach Elwood: The other ones for everybody.
- 31:30Zach Elwood: Um but I they they're they're quite similar.
- 31:32Zach Elwood: But I yeah, I wanted to share what I had learned through the research and the talks that I done from my podcast.
- 31:40Zach Elwood: That's how those books came about.
- 31:41Zach Elwood: But yeah, I do think it I think it ties into what we're talking about because there are just it's so easy to embrace narratives, simplistic narratives of whatever sort, and that yeah, that ties into polarization and conflict because it I think how what drives polarization, toxic polarization, is these simplistic narratives that we have about each other.
- 32:02Zach Elwood: And so we we come to see the quote other side as all entirely bad or almost entirely bad, and so we speak about them in more insulting and pessimistic ways, and they perceive the other people the other people perceive us doing that about them, so they view us as this monolithic bad group, and so they talk about the other side in increasingly bad and insulting ways, and it just drives this conflict that gets worse and worse.
- 32:26Zach Elwood: So that's what interests me.
- 32:28Zach Elwood: I uh the conflict dynamics of uh of those situations and the psychological and emotional underpinnings of them and how they get worse and worse and ramp each other up and self-sustain and self-reinforce and everything.
- 32:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's why understanding human behavior is so darn important is to, you know, we talked about the the the Malcolm Gladwell and the podcast connection and how we want to buy things that are simplistic.
- 32:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We want the Ozempic things of the world.
- 32:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Human behavior is important to learn.
- 32:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm again, I'm like you, we're not experts on the show or anything like that.
- 32:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We just we're students of this always exploring things.
- 32:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So orientation, genetics, culture, experience, combining with information from the environment.
- 33:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Orientation determines how we sense, decide, and act, how we perceive reality.
- 33:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So going along your lines there about Trump, years ago I got to spend time in 2005.
- 33:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I went down to Atlanta to spend time inside CNN headquarters, right?
- 33:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: To sit down with the producers.
- 33:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I was I wasn't alone.
- 33:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I was in uniform, a military uniform, and I was there with about 10 to 15 other military officers, all O4s uh lieutenant commanders or majors.
- 33:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we got to experience firsthand what what drives their behavior?
- 33:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why why was CNN showing a war in this light?
- 33:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why were they cutting videos in that way?
- 33:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We had I had an experience, right?
- 33:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I part of, you know, was in the wars, got to experience what the producers are seeing and why, and that carry that changes your orientation on how things are presented to folks.
- 33:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course, if you ever came out and said, Oh, I got you know, I'm anti-CNN, and people would squash you, go, ah, you know, they're they're pro-CNN or anti-Fox.
- 33:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Media is dangerous, man.
- 34:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It really is.
- 34:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's why we see the the rise of podcasting and the popularity of it, it's good and bad, a double-edged sword, right?
- 34:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're starting to gain access to the and um again, I'm I'm with you.
- 34:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't want to bash anybody but the Chase Hughes of the world.
- 34:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They they get promoted through through the system.
- 34:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But it's it's it's I I do believe if you look back at the last election, how important podcasts were in getting well, at least the way I understand how important podcasts were in getting the word out or getting engagement with day-to-day folks.
- 34:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, you know, I think that's kind of what you're doing on your podcast as well, is you're you're communicating to folks that, hey, this is what I've seen in my lifetime.
- 34:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here's how it might apply, and here's something to consider, and and so forth.
- 34:43Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 34:44Zach Elwood: I think like you say, it's a du it can be a double-edged sword because I think a lot of people I've been accused of being super negative about, you know, oh, you don't want people to have discussions, you don't want people to have interviews, you know, podcasts.
- 34:56Zach Elwood: And I'm like, no, I'm not against those things.
- 34:58Zach Elwood: I just think it's good to be a little bit more skeptical and do some betting.
- 35:02Zach Elwood: And there's plenty of people in the world to interview, and you don't have to interview people that have been shown to be lying all the time, right?
- 35:08Zach Elwood: Like that's that's my only argument, is like it's not about what their stances are, it's just about trying to aim for talking to people and promoting people that you know you know have are uh not not at the bottom of the barrel, basically.
- 35:22Zach Elwood: But yeah, I I I like you say it's a double-edged sword.
- 35:25Zach Elwood: It's like there's the internet has done many good things in terms of making communication very easy, but that's that also comes with uh downsides, right?
- 35:34Zach Elwood: Because like making communication very easy can bring out the worst and uh worse than us theoretically, you know.
- 35:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's the say I'm gonna there's a saying I'm gonna borrow, and it goes like this every village has an idiot, the internet brings us together, right?
- 35:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 35:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the good there's good and bad in every everything, right?
- 35:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 35:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 35:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Nothing wrong with being a village idiot.
- 35:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh yeah, I might be one.
- 35:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know.
- 35:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not saying you are.
- 35:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm I'm I I just I'm curious.
- 36:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's all all going on air.
- 36:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 36:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you have over what, 200 episodes?
- 36:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that right?
- 36:04Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 36:05Zach Elwood: And uh some of those are standalone, me talking, but I'd say I've interviewed more than like 170 people, maybe something like that.
- 36:14Zach Elwood: More than I I expected to.
- 36:16Zach Elwood: It's been a weird thing.
- 36:17Zach Elwood: I've almost quit a few times because I'm like, it's not like I make I'm I hardly make any money at this, and it's just been a labor, labor, labor of love.
- 36:25Zach Elwood: And I've thought about quitting a few times and just because it's eats up so much time, you know.
- 36:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It does.
- 36:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 36:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's talk about that because uh uh you you and I are in the same boat.
- 36:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh this doesn't make money.
- 36:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh it gets us leads every now and then, and I'll I'll be honest with that.
- 36:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It gets me in trouble sometimes.
- 36:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But 170 folks.
- 36:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here you are talking to Clint Kent Clisby.
- 36:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a few other guests that you've, you know, I've had Gary Klein on the show, I have Dave Snowden, had the world second the world's most cited neuroscientist, and Carl Friston.
- 36:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: These are not people I would get to normally have the opportunity to speak to if I didn't have a podcast.
- 36:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's the big positive.
- 37:00Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 37:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 37:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I would say that you and I are winning in that case, right?
- 37:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We we get to have these conversations.
- 37:06Zach Elwood: Yeah, no, it's great in that regard.
- 37:08Zach Elwood: It's like I I've been able to ask people questions that I've been really curious about.
- 37:12Zach Elwood: It's really made me more knowledgeable.
- 37:16Zach Elwood: And even now I still occasionally ask some of these people questions via email where I just have a random question and they answer me.
- 37:22Zach Elwood: So it's like you know, it'd be great to parlay that into something money-making.
- 37:27Zach Elwood: But uh, you know, which is why I I I've been thinking about this book on reading behavior, not that you know whether that makes money or not is is another story, but you know, it it's a big investment I've put into these things that you know that that we all wonder how we can we can turn those things into things that getting back to that thing of uh you know, how can we turn our experiences into something that pays for us?
- 37:51Zach Elwood: You know, I have the same questions.
- 37:53Zach Elwood: But yeah, it's at the at the bare level of even if I never do that or m never make much money from it, it's like it has been tremendously educational and led to some great networking and and uh talking to people and such, so that's great, yeah.
- 38:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what about AI AI?
- 38:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How does that for SI now, how does uh uh superintelligence fit into both uh understanding people beh people's behavior and then what you're doing with the podcast and and writing books?
- 38:21Zach Elwood: Well, um yeah, I don't know if you know that uh saw that recent one I did where examining the you know how AI is being used for parsing language patterns for deception detection, which it does a you know a pretty good job, you know, but the there's decent studies showing how it beats humans when it comes to analyzing text and and such.
- 38:43Zach Elwood: So that's an interesting application.
- 38:46Zach Elwood: Then there you also have you know there's various programs out there, apps, applications that are uh and services that are offering various parsings of behavior, whether it's nonverbal or uh verbal content, uh to you know, like improve sales presentations or you know, uh detect things that are that are weak or possibly vague for uh improvements or or spotting red flags or whatever.
- 39:16Zach Elwood: So just to say various people and organizations are using AI to basically do the analysis that might take people longer to try to do that more quickly.
- 39:27Zach Elwood: But you know, I think there's always going to be a limit for those things because in the same way there's huge limits on pretty much any deception detection, because at the you know, if you think about like even if they somehow found some combination of things, verbal or non-verbal, that were was high heavily tied to deception, everybody would anybody that heard that would just change those things, right?
- 39:48Zach Elwood: You know, if we're leaving aside um things that that are involuntary uh signals in our bodies or whatever.
- 39:55Zach Elwood: So just to say there's a limit to those things because a lot of real world applications require high confidence to use them, right?
- 40:02Zach Elwood: You're not gonna fire or hire somebody based on something that's only like, you know, 60% reliable, averaged or whatever.
- 40:10Zach Elwood: So there's major limitations, but that that's what I've uh you know heard about and and uh but I'm sure we'll see as things progress.
- 40:18Zach Elwood: It seems like things are progressing very quickly on the uh AI front.
- 40:23Zach Elwood: So I'm sure there'll be things that come out that are very interesting in the next few years that we couldn't have imagined, maybe when it comes to behavioral analysis of whatever sort.
- 40:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So on back to the behavioral analysis and and the big picture side that you're presenting on on your show.
- 40:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I think some of your claims are some of the the basic techniques that people are believe work don't necessarily work.
- 40:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is is that is that true?
- 40:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, going back to the beginning of this our conversation.
- 40:48Zach Elwood: Yeah, when it comes to real-world deception detection, and I don't I don't consider you know reading behavior in in games like poker.
- 40:54Zach Elwood: It has nothing to do with deception detection for what it's worth, uh which also helps separate it.
- 41:00Zach Elwood: You know, uh but yeah, there's there's just a lot of myths about nonverbal behavior and the uses of it for like spotting lies.
- 41:08Zach Elwood: There's if you actually delve into the research and even just apply some critical thinking and and notice what you notice in your day-to-day life, you'll find that uh yeah, it's uh there's just a lot of bad information there.
- 41:19Zach Elwood: I I would recommend reading Tim Levine's book, Duped, or listen to I've interviewed him three times for my podcast, and that's a probably good introduction to what he thinks.
- 41:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh, that's Tim Levine on Duped, is that correct?
- 41:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, his book is called Duped.
- 41:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 41:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not the yeah.
- 41:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What what about uh what about uh intuition?
- 41:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How does that uh fit into um you know those spidey senses, that interoceptive capability, listening to your gut?
- 41:44Zach Elwood: Yeah, I think uh I mean I don't think I'm gonna say anything groundbreaking here, but yeah, I think uh intuition can be great and but often it is not.
- 41:52Zach Elwood: Uh we often you know we often make mistakes.
- 41:55Zach Elwood: So I think if you're thinking about trying to apply things programmatically or operationally, I think it's important to try to take the things that you think are strong about your gut senses.
- 42:08Zach Elwood: If you think you you have a if you think you have gut senses or if you think other people have applied their their instincts, it's I think it's good to try to figure out what were the factors in that, right?
- 42:18Zach Elwood: Like that's what uh in Gary uh Klein was it's Gary Klein, right?
- 42:22Zach Elwood: And his sources of power book, that's what he was doing too.
- 42:25Zach Elwood: It was like, let's take these gut reactions and decisions that they even thought were like some kind of psychic power and deduce what the actual factors were, which a lot of times were not obvious to the people, right?
- 42:39Zach Elwood: And that happens in poker too.
- 42:40Zach Elwood: Like I've talked to plenty of high-stakes poker players, and I've had the experience myself where I had an inkling that, you know, a strong guess that somebody was bluffing or not bluffing, but couldn't really put my finger on it.
- 42:52Zach Elwood: But that was what I was trying to do with my poker tails work was get through to what are driving some of those kind of reactions and putting them into a conscious framework and saying, well, what what are the factors that people are sensing, even if they sometimes don't even know what they're sensing, like an experienced player's playing with something, somebody and getting a sense of them over time, what are those things they're getting a sense of exactly?
- 43:17Zach Elwood: And can we talk about them?
- 43:19Zach Elwood: Because I don't I don't think they tend to be of much use until you actually lay out the the factors, like the actual factors, because you know, we know that our gut can be quite wrong sometimes, so getting to the heart of what is actually driving those those reactions and and uh sensations and such is important for making them operationally useful.
- 43:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me ask you this.
- 43:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When it comes back to poker and when you work with the uh SOP folks, uh what series of poker, I believe it is, how how do they factor in probabilities with uh gut feeling or or talk to me about that.
- 43:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean it Yeah.
- 43:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, if I'm fifty five percent leaning in one direction, walk walk me through how that works.
- 43:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because I think leaders have to go through that.
- 44:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They have a probability.
- 44:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, we we need a probability.
- 44:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's no certainty anything, right?
- 44:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So even a 99% chance of probability of something going one way doesn't mean it is, right?
- 44:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So walk me through that.
- 44:16Zach Elwood: No, you're you're asking, and it makes sense you're asking these questions because I think a lot of people are not good at talking about probabilistic aspects.
- 44:23Zach Elwood: Like you said, many people like the is it this or is it that kind of thing, right?
- 44:27Zach Elwood: So a lot of people are bad at trying to use probabilistic information.
- 44:32Zach Elwood: But that's really when it comes to the strong poker players, that's really what they're asking themselves.
- 44:37Zach Elwood: They they have a sense of how valuable XYZ behavioral patterns are.
- 44:43Zach Elwood: They watch somebody for a while, they have senses sense based on player-specific things they've noticed.
- 44:49Zach Elwood: So in practice, they're putting the pieces together from how that person has fundamentally played the hand.
- 44:55Zach Elwood: They're getting a sense of how much they're the behavioral read.
- 45:01Zach Elwood: And again, these are things that don't happen very often.
- 45:03Zach Elwood: You know, it might only be a couple times a session or less if you're talking about skilled players for for when somebody might be actually changing a decision based on a read, right?
- 45:13Zach Elwood: So these things have to align, but they're they are thinking like, oh, I think, you know, say it's a spot where they really are from a fundamental strategy perspective, they feel like it could go either way, like it's even money, whether they call this bet on the river or fold.
- 45:29Zach Elwood: And you're often, you know, because poker is such a is such an incomplete information game, and because people do try to balance their behaviors to be unreadable, right?
- 45:39Zach Elwood: They're their betting behaviors and their their fundamental strategy behaviors, they're trying to be balanced, right?
- 45:43Zach Elwood: And they're trying to put you in spots that are kind of break-even from a fundamental strategy point.
- 45:49Zach Elwood: So you are often in these spots that could go either way.
- 45:52Zach Elwood: And that means that even a weekly reliable behavioral read can be very valuable because you know you're playing with somebody, and professional players often play with people for you know days, weeks, even months, regular players, right?
- 46:07Zach Elwood: They're they're not we're not we're leaving aside the tournaments, we're talking about the cash games that go on like every day that they're playing in, right?
- 46:13Zach Elwood: These are these are just games they that go on every day.
- 46:15Zach Elwood: So uh these small behavioral reads, even if they're weakly reliable, can play a role.
- 46:20Zach Elwood: So, you know, say somebody's bet on the river, and they uh let's say they are doing more, they're they're looking at you more than they usually do, and you're like, oh, I think the fact that this player's willing to make some eye contact with me, and the fact that their eyes are fairly loosely moving around and have a good amount of movement, I think that that makes it like, you know, 70 plus percent reliable or something that they're uh that they're relaxed and have a strong hand.
- 46:49Zach Elwood: So you fold based on some of these small things that you don't always see.
- 46:53Zach Elwood: You won't always get those reads from those people.
- 46:56Zach Elwood: But when you do get those reads, they'll lead you to one direction or another.
- 47:00Zach Elwood: So that explains why even weakly reliable information can be valuable in a game setting where the uh the uh the decisions are often quite close from a from a behavioral or from a fundamental strategy perspective.
- 47:15Zach Elwood: But then you also have the other spectrum too, where some tells are just extremely reliable, like some behaviors.
- 47:22Zach Elwood: Um, there's some behaviors that I would just act on as a cult read.
- 47:27Zach Elwood: And I'll give you an example, like and it makes sense that they're the more the most valuable ones in that realm are the verbal statement ones, because just like in the real world statements, what we actually say contains so much more information than the small non-verbal stuff.
- 47:41Zach Elwood: But you know, for example, I have a clip of me, you know, folding based on a a verbal tell when and the announcers were like, oh, that was he basically he there was no reason for him to do that other than the verbal statement.
- 47:53Zach Elwood: I'm like, yeah, it's it's just such a valuable verbal statement, and it was basically like one of the most valuable patterns in the verbal realm in poker is when a player is making a bet, if they're willing to weaken their hand range even slightly when they're betting, it's very unlikely they're bluffing because bluffers don't want to even indirectly remove strong hands from their range.
- 48:16Zach Elwood: But players with strong hands might be willing to do that because in their mind they're thinking, like, maybe uh if I remove a strong hand from my range, that person might be more likely to call.
- 48:27Zach Elwood: So you have these patterns that play out in direct and very indirect, subtle ways where players will basically weaken their own hand strength after betting, and they'll say something, you know, you can ask them a question like, oh, do you have this hand?
- 48:40Zach Elwood: Like that's medium strength, you'll say, like, do you have oh, two pair?
- 48:43Zach Elwood: And they'll be like, No, I don't have two pair.
- 48:45Zach Elwood: That makes it very likely that they're they have a strong hand because a bluffer wouldn't want to reduce their, you know, remove, weaken their own range, right?
- 48:52Zach Elwood: So, and that's the one that I had the clip of me acting on where they were like, oh, that was a verbal read.
- 48:57Zach Elwood: So just to say there's some tells, some behaviors that are much more highly rated as reliable than other tells, and so experienced players get a sense of what are the weakly reliable tells and what only matters if you maybe have some player-specific history and observation versus what are the highly reliable patterns that you could act on as a cold read.
- 49:19Zach Elwood: So that's and that's all domain-specific knowledge in the same way that you know cops get a sense of like, oh, he phrased it this way, he's probably you know lying or guilty, right?
- 49:29Zach Elwood: Like there's all this domain-specific knowledge because you've seen this behavior play out in in so many different contexts multiple times, right?
- 49:36Zach Elwood: But yeah, the probabilistic element, it's it plays a big role in in poker or any incomplete information game, not just tell-wise, but that's also a fundamental part of you know adjusting to another how a player's how a player plays.
- 49:50Zach Elwood: Like if they raise too much, they bet too much, they're too aggressive.
- 49:53Zach Elwood: You adjust your strategy to reflect that too, right?
- 49:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're you're adjusting on the on the fly to these to these things that they're like.
- 50:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you're coaching somebody on these, you know, how do you read somebody else?
- 50:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But how are do you also coach them on how others read them?
- 50:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and it yeah, it depends.
- 50:10Zach Elwood: Usually the the most intense work I've done is when there is footage of the person I'm I'm consulting for.
- 50:17Zach Elwood: So yeah, we do do that too.
- 50:19Zach Elwood: Although usually I will say, you know, uh, if someone is I I think a lot of people are too scared of uh other people reading them because when you when it gets down to it, if you're somewhat familiar with the major ways that information can leak, you're gonna do a pretty decent job of uh remaining unreadable at poker.
- 50:37Zach Elwood: Like that's bad for me to say because it makes people less likely to hire me, but I'm I'm a big believer in being very forthright, because it is true that like many, you know, people are hard to read in general, and and you add in if you're a decent player, you've probably put a good amount of work into removing your most obvious tells.
- 50:54Zach Elwood: So if you're trying hard to do that, you're probably doing pretty well.
- 50:57Zach Elwood: Leaving aside like some there's some involuntary stuff, like that's why people some people wear like collared shirts or scarves because they're afraid of these neck pulse tells when they're bluffing and such.
- 51:07Zach Elwood: So uh but yeah, it can it can go pretty deep on some of that stuff.
- 51:11Zach Elwood: But by and large, you know, it's hard to read people, and if you're trying you're trying pretty well at it, you're probably doing a pretty good job.
- 51:18Zach Elwood: Uh well.
- 51:18Zach Elwood: I mean, I mean as far as being unreadable, yeah.
- 51:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me ask you this.
- 51:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh would you advise kids to play poker?
- 51:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it a good life skill to have?
- 51:27Zach Elwood: I mean, leaving aside the chance that they might become addicted to gambling, I think it's a it's a very good uh it's a it is a very good train training for these probabilistic ways of thinking and risk management ways of thinking.
- 51:41Zach Elwood: I mean, that's I think that it is great for that.
- 51:43Zach Elwood: I mean, it's it's been great for me in terms of thinking about life that way.
- 51:47Zach Elwood: And I think there's something kind of therapeutic in thinking about, you know, poker teaches you to think in terms of like you can't be results-oriented.
- 51:54Zach Elwood: All you can do is make the best decisions you can at any given time.
- 51:58Zach Elwood: Like the results are gonna go the way they're gonna go based on a number of factors outside your control.
- 52:03Zach Elwood: So all you can do is try to make the best decisions you can and you know, let the cards far fall where they may otherwise.
- 52:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's important because uh going back to what we brought up earlier about procedural knowledge and people writing books about leadership, people forget that luck has a lot to do with the outcome.
- 52:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's resulting, you know.
- 52:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Same thing in the market, right?
- 52:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You want a good process, you debrief the process, and and sometimes you have great outcomes and a shitty process, right?
- 52:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But ideally you have a good process and good outcomes and bad outcomes.
- 52:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh those like you said, that luck has a factor.
- 52:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Talk to me a little bit about decision making, yeah.
- 52:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah, decision making is key.
- 52:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And let me go back to the part of the oodaloop is you have a decision that's made and then you have an outcome.
- 52:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And an outcome has to go through the environment, just like poker.
- 52:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that could be really positive or really negative based on nothing you did.
- 52:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we want to separate that.
- 52:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Talk to me about luck a little bit, and then we'll wrap it up here.
- 53:01Zach Elwood: Well, yeah, on that topic, I do think it is important even just in life, you know, as a ph philosophy, it's like you can't be too you can't beat yourself too much on these very short, small sample things that happen in your life, right?
- 53:16Zach Elwood: Like there's so much out of your control in life and business or whatever.
- 53:20Zach Elwood: It's like I I think a lot of people are so results-oriented where things go their way and they're like, oh, I was a genius, I did a great thing there, and then or if things don't go their way and they had something really bad happen, they're like, I'm an idiot, I I am a complete loser, right?
- 53:34Zach Elwood: And we I I mean, I've I've dealt with that too.
- 53:36Zach Elwood: Like, you know, it's I think one of the biggest when it comes to risks in life, generally, like psychologically, emotionally, I think being kind of traumatized by beating ourselves up for various things that go wrong in our life is a big emotional risk, you know, when it comes to depression and anxiety and these kinds of things.
- 53:56Zach Elwood: So I think focusing on the fact that, yeah, there's only so much we can do.
- 54:00Zach Elwood: We can just we can try to do the best we can.
- 54:03Zach Elwood: We only know what we know at any given time.
- 54:05Zach Elwood: We try to make the best decisions we can, but there is so much out of our control.
- 54:09Zach Elwood: There's there's so much chance, there's so much luck.
- 54:11Zach Elwood: I think there's so much luck and chance, even in things that people don't think are luck and chance related.
- 54:17Zach Elwood: I think it's just embedded in so many things we we do, you know.
- 54:21Zach Elwood: Uh, I think a lot of people are are will say things like when they hear that you've played poker for a living or or done something similar, they're like, oh, I could never, you know, I can never stand to take such chances or do such gambling.
- 54:32Zach Elwood: But I think at the end of the day, so much of what we do is gambling.
- 54:36Zach Elwood: It's like we're we're gambling by staying at the same job for a long time, or we're gambling by, you know, deciding not to leave our spouse, even though we think it's a bad relationship.
- 54:48Zach Elwood: Like all these things that we do kind of inertia-wise, are also making decisions, and it there are all they're all various forms of they have analogies to gambling because there's so much decision making and and uh chance and uh unknowns involved, and we're constantly navigating all these things every day, you know, and just just things like poker make it more clear about how much of this stuff is outside your control, you know, in that in that environment.
- 55:14Zach Elwood: But I think it's it's so true on so many levels.
- 55:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, hey, Zach, yeah, I appreciate you coming on.
- 55:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh People Who Read People.
- 55:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, I really enjoyed the podcast.
- 55:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm glad I found it recently.
- 55:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The uh uh one of my favorites is um Pete Blair, actually, because he was talking about a connection between the ecological dynamics or the constraints-led approach, which is a big thing right now, everybody's talking about constraints, and interrogation.
- 55:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I was like, man, I did I I completely missed that with him.
- 55:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I didn't know there was a dimension.
- 55:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 55:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh well, yeah, I'd love to have him back on because he's doing a lot of stuff with uh training and using constraints-led approach, which we we argue is is uh easily connected to observe or into side act loop with the environment.
- 55:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you got five books?
- 55:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that correct?
- 55:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I got five, I counted five.
- 55:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Anything else you have?
- 55:59Zach Elwood: Yeah.
- 56:00Zach Elwood: Um no, that's that's it.
- 56:02Zach Elwood: And and just thanks a lot for uh if you be if people want to check out my stuff, it's at behavior dash podcast as my podcast, and then reading poker tells.com is my poker stuff.
- 56:11Zach Elwood: But um, yeah, thanks a lot for having me on.
- 56:13Zach Elwood: It's an it's an honor.
- 56:13Zach Elwood: I don't get asked on too many podcasts these days, so I appreciate it.
- 56:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, this is fun.
- 56:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I just wanted to kind of shoot the shit with you, see what's going on, because a lot of things you're talking about are things we're talking about, and uh you know, people really need to pay attention to I'll take I'll say the key phrase.
- 56:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The environment has a lot to do with what's going to happen to you, right?
- 56:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So just separating decisions from outcomes is critical, learning how to do that, understanding good process, uh, and of course reading people.
- 56:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh maybe sometime down the road we can dive a little bit deeper into uh just analyzing things on on different podcasts, what's going on with uh you know, next time we see Chase Hughes run around saying something.
- 56:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, have him on your podcast.
- 56:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, he probably you know yes and just appear on it.
- 56:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I you know what?
- 56:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I I was I think he lives around me.
- 56:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Last I checked, I I I understand he lives around here, so that might be easy just to sit down.
- 57:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But if he hears me talking about this, him like this, I'm pretty sure he'll go after that.
- 57:05Zach Elwood: I try to get him on my I try to get him on my podcast.
- 57:08Zach Elwood: People were like, why don't you invite him on to talk to him?
- 57:10Zach Elwood: I'm like, I'd love to.
- 57:11Zach Elwood: He's got a lot of great things to say.
- 57:15Zach Elwood: Don't get me wrong.
- 57:15Zach Elwood: I'm I'm a big fan of the big.
- 57:16Zach Elwood: Well, you know, a a a broken pathologically lying clock is right a few times a year, you know.
- 57:22Zach Elwood: I just yeah, just saying.
- 57:24Zach Elwood: Just it's easy to say things that are true and okay.
- 57:28Zach Elwood: You know, that's that's a low bar.
- 57:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's all I'll say about it.
- 57:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 57:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh you you do pay attention to sports, do you though, don't you?
- 57:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you watch a lot of sports or no.
- 57:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 57:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh no, there's a lot of connections to where this applies, and and like I said, having the guys talk about guys like Peepler talking about constraints led approach, education of attention is important.
- 57:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's kind of what you we're talking about here is uh how do you attune yourself to the things that are going on in the environment?
- 57:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do you you know, don't just take things for uh face value, challenge assumptions and keep asking questions.
- 57:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Zach, I appreciate it, man.
- 58:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh hopefully we connect here soon.
- 58:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But make sure you check out Zach's podcast, people uh who read people.
- 58:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks again, Zach.
- 58:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thank you.
- 58:10John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 58:11John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then.
- 58:13John R. Boyd: There is no layout.
- 58:14John R. Boyd: Plus, we can eliminate the feature just cited.
- 58:20John R. Boyd: Well, odd though, we don't know how to do this.
- 58:23John R. Boyd: There is no layout.