Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Bullsh!t Incorporated: Conspiracists and Cons in a Ridiculous World (with Dave Farina)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. He is host
- 0:58of the YouTube channel Professor Dave Explains, which currently enjoys a subscriber account I
- 1:03think of like two and a half million people. He's got over a thousand
- 1:07videos posted which teach chemistry, physics, biology and economics and other stuff.
- 1:14He is author of a book came out a couple of years ago called is
- 1:18This Wi Fi Organic? A Guide to Spotting misleading science Online. Dave Farina,
- 1:26thanks for coming, brother, Thanks for having me so. One of
- 1:30the reasons we're talking today is that I've been watching some fireworks on Twitter between
- 1:37you and are the id apologist intelligent designers or flat out creationists or who are
- 1:44these people? So I assume you're talking about the Discovery Institute. Yep,
- 1:48I'm talking about the Discovery And so, to be clear, creationism and intelligent
- 1:53design are synonymous. ID is rebranded creationism to try to sneak it in to
- 2:00public school science curricula. They're synonymous. But yeah, these guys, it's
- 2:05a propaganda mill out of Seattle whose purpose ultimately is to erode the separation of
- 2:12church and state through various means. Right now it's mainly been this whole get
- 2:16intelligent design into public science class. But yeah, they're wealthy backers, have
- 2:23ulterier motives. Don't they go call religious PhD types. I'm thinking, of
- 2:29course, of doctor Stephen Meyer, who wrote the book Signature in the Cell,
- 2:34which I think has really been sort of cast off by mainstream scientists.
- 2:38Is that correct? I mean, did you have you seen Signature in the
- 2:40Cell and the other work by Meyer? Yes? So I have been going
- 2:44down the line of the Discovery Institute roster and putting out debunk video after debunk
- 2:49video discrediting all of their primary contributors. Number two in the series is Stephen
- 2:53Meyer. So I talk quite a lot about that book and his other works.
- 2:55All of it is science denial, all of it is pseudoscience, and
- 3:00all of it is squarely discredited by every respected member of the field, which
- 3:04he's not a part of. He is a doctorate in philosophy of science at
- 3:07any rate. All of these people in the Discovery Institute, they get the
- 3:09doctorates simply to posture as informed people when they're really just apologists. Most of
- 3:15them have never published any actual scientific literature, or if they've done a couple,
- 3:20they've since moved on and now just write books full of lies. This
- 3:23is what makes Meyer yet another apologist hack, just like the rest of them.
- 3:29To a lay person, does he sound like he knows what he's talking
- 3:31about? Yes? Does he sound like a reasonable, grounded person yes?
- 3:37Does he sound sincere in his convictions? Yes? Is he actually any of
- 3:42those things? Not even a little bit. It's a facade, a costume
- 3:46he wears for those who only need a friendly tone and a message they want
- 3:50to hear, but have no desire to actually learn a thing about science.
- 3:54He is fully aware of all the research he contradicts in his content. His
- 4:00career is centered around it. One could therefore say that Meyer is slightly more
- 4:04sophisticated than some apologists in that while some of his lies are blatantly obvious to
- 4:11anyone who got to be or better in ninth grade biology, some of them
- 4:14do require an investigation of the primary scientific literature, an investigation he knows that
- 4:19not a single member of his target audience will produce. But that's why I
- 4:24bring the investigation to you, so that we can all conclude, together,
- 4:29religious or otherwise, that, like everyone else affiliated with the DII, Meyer
- 4:34is a complete fraud. Well, Dave, is this people using a degree
- 4:39outside of their field? Did they get it from a religious institution or was
- 4:43it from a degree mill or all the above? I know it's a broad
- 4:46question. Yeah, So the DII they tried to posture as very credible.
- 4:50So I don't think any of them have fake diplomas from degree mills like Kent
- 4:55Hovind or something like that. They have real degrees. So see Meyer has
- 4:58a real doctorate in flaw science from Cambridge or something. I forget where he
- 5:02got that. So it's a real degree. It's not like he doesn't have
- 5:05a doctorate, but he certainly does not understand biology. I mean, if
- 5:10you watch my debunk of him. In particular. Most of it is about
- 5:13the Cambrian explosion, because that's what he talks about in that book, but
- 5:15there's also a lot of stuff that he says about very basic biology, very
- 5:19basic genetics, which demonstrates that he doesn't even understand this topic at like a
- 5:24high school level. I'm really not exaggerating either that or he's just genuinely,
- 5:29you know, just lying through his teeth about it. So I've got,
- 5:30yeah, I did, Casey Leskin, Stephen Meyer, Michael b. He
- 5:34Gunter Beckley, I'm squaring up for some more. There's some other figures that
- 5:39definitely need to be taken down a notch. But it's just fraudulent top to
- 5:43bottom. It's a propaganda mill. There's no scientific glidity to any of it,
- 5:46and that's just how it is. Well, let's talk about the Cambrian
- 5:49explosion. This was pitched when I was sort of being introduced to it,
- 5:55and I was a I don't know if I was young or that was a
- 5:57creationist, right, Adamy Garden's name, I think, And I was in
- 6:00that for a long time, too long, I'm embarrassed to admit. But
- 6:04even when I came out one of the pitches was that you know, this
- 6:09was an accelerated evolution that happened just like that, And then I began to
- 6:14research Cambrian and it didn't happen just like that. Do you want to get
- 6:17into it for me? Sure? I mean they like to exploit the colorful
- 6:23language and make it seem as though. I mean you'll see images where it's
- 6:27literally like a bang graphic and then all of these organisms tumbling out as though
- 6:31too. I'm going to talk. Can you explain quickly? So it's just
- 6:36a palaeontological event, right, We're talking about something in the history of life
- 6:40on Earth where new Phila emerged very rapidly, So new types of living organisms
- 6:46emerged relatively rapidly, and by relatively rapidly, we're talking about a time span
- 6:50of about eighty million years, so we're definitely not talking about any kind of
- 6:56a snap of the fingers. But they try to downplay the breadth of the
- 7:00event. They flat out lie about the paleontological evidence leading up to the event.
- 7:04So they say that all of these animal forms emerged sort of instantly in
- 7:09this event, whereas in fact, in the ediacre and strata, so the
- 7:13period immediately before the Cambrian there's a lot of lead up to it. I
- 7:16mean, it's going to get pretty esoteric pretty fast. But in that debunk
- 7:21I I sort of show how the very very nitty gritty details that Meyer tries
- 7:27to present about the event are just flat out fabricated. They're just false.
- 7:30Moving on chronologically from the Cambrian explosion, Meyer lies about every other era he
- 7:36attempts to discuss. But the Cambrian Explosion isn't the only such event in the
- 7:41history of life. There are many. A little bit later in the fossil
- 7:44record, there's an event called the Great or Division Biodiversity Event, or GOBI,
- 7:48where there's a whole slew of new forms of life that come into existence.
- 7:53And then as you go up and down the sedimentary column, you find
- 7:57that the first winged insects first, the first dinosaurs, the first turtles,
- 8:03the first birds, the first marine reptiles, the first flowering plants, the
- 8:09first flowering plants come into the fossil record, an event that's now known as
- 8:15the Big Bloom, the biological Big Bloom. And then another striking event occurs
- 8:20in the Eocene period, where you get the first mammals and where they're between
- 8:24fifteen and seventeen new orders of mammals that come suddenly into to the fossil record
- 8:28again with no discernible connection to similar creatures in the lower strata beneath the Eocene.
- 8:35Every single one of those claims is flat out wrong. I can't remember
- 8:39it was Meyer somebody else who was trying to say that the sedimentary leaders of
- 8:45the Grand Canyon proved the Great flood Noah's flood in the Book of Genesis chapter
- 8:50six. Have you addressed that at all? Like, oh, look,
- 8:54the layers prove the flood. So I don't know if he does that one.
- 8:58That's usually more of a Young Earth creationist claim, because the thing is
- 9:03that maybe ken Ham, maybe ken Ham or Great Comfort of these guys,
- 9:07because the thing is the DEI is trying to pose as as scientifically rigorous as
- 9:13possible, and so to do that, they have more or less distance themselves
- 9:18from Young Earth creationist claims. So I don't think that any of them overtly
- 9:24state that they're Young Earth creationists. I think they're sort of accepting of geological
- 9:28time for the most part, so they wouldn't necessarily be the ones to do
- 9:33the whole like the flood made the Grand Canyon thing or anything. But a
- 9:37day was as if a million years or a million years was as if a
- 9:41day. I mean the goalposts ever moving kind of thing. Yes, I
- 9:46want to come back to the apologists with PhDs, etc. But first I
- 9:52was just browsing your channel doing my due diligence, and I saw that you
- 9:56had something about psychology. And I've been having these discussions recently about the Myers
- 10:01Briggs personality Test, which actually had an employer give all of the employees back
- 10:09at one of the radio stations I worked at. And this is like a
- 10:13ninety plus question test was developed ninety years ago for the purposes of recruitment,
- 10:22whether it's business or the military, etc. And it's supposed to divide people
- 10:26into like one of fourteen fifteen sixteen personality types. And this is supposed to
- 10:30pigeonhole people into what they are. And as I understand, Dave, it's
- 10:35bullshit, right. Have you gotten into Myers Briggs? Yeah, I mean
- 10:39from my limited understanding, the test is very limited because it fixates on binaries.
- 10:45And so you said, I mean it's about four categories and each is
- 10:48a binary. So two to the fourth yees sixteen categories based on these four
- 10:52categories, So I mean it's I don't think it's completely useless. I think
- 10:56everybody can identify introvert extra things like that. But like many other personality tests,
- 11:01yes, it is highly highly limited, and I think not really taken
- 11:05seriously by psychologists in a rigorous way. At least you think we can.
- 11:09I mean, are there tests? Can you distill the complex person down using
- 11:13questionnaires? You think to an extent? I mean, I think this thing
- 11:18about the Big five, I forget exactly what it was. I covered it
- 11:22in one of the psych tutorials, which were written by a psychologist for me.
- 11:24There are ones that are taken to be more credible than Myers Briggs.
- 11:30But I don't think that any psychologist points to one specific test and says this
- 11:33is the be all, end all determination of personality. That's if it's even
- 11:39possible. It's still highly impractical to assess in that kind of a format.
- 11:45Science denialism. I was talking to somebody recently about the fact that here in
- 11:50the twenty first century we have people who deny the existence of germs, or
- 11:56at least germ theory. So this is a trend I've noticed, actually,
- 12:01because this is something that is being committed in astrophysics by Charlatan's in the realm
- 12:07of astrophysics as well as biology. So this new trick of the charlatan is
- 12:11to go back in time in the history of science and find obsolete science from
- 12:16whether it's fifty years ago or one hundred fifty years ago or whatever, and
- 12:20then simply lift it and use it as though it's a viable current paradigm because
- 12:24the thing is that it comes prepackaged with buzzwords and talking points. That makes
- 12:28their job really easy. So right now, with biology, it's terrain theory.
- 12:33So if you go way back to the time of Louis Pasteur, there
- 12:35was this discussion of okay, we just figured out that pathogens exist. There's
- 12:39bacteria, and then later we found out that there's viruses, and then we
- 12:43had to figure out that they caused disease. And we figured this out a
- 12:46very long time ago. So any other competing idea of what pathogens do or
- 12:50don't do was discarded a very long time ago. So people who want a
- 12:54pedal science now they just go back in time. They take terrain theory.
- 12:58They use the terminology of the time and go, hey, this is a
- 13:01competing thing. No it's not. It hasn't been for two hundred years,
- 13:03So what are you talking about. We know what bacteria and viruses do.
- 13:07This is insane. The field of virology is the thing that exists. We
- 13:13study viruses. So it's not even just that some people deny that pathogens cause
- 13:16disease. Some people literally deny the existence of pathogens. They say viruses do
- 13:22not exist. It's bananas. Don't you just want to get in the car
- 13:28and just drive over the class I mean, you see this and you're like,
- 13:31I thought we were progressing, not regressing. It's not just the anti
- 13:35back stuff that we see and the flat earthers opposition. Yeah, flat Earth.
- 13:41What a great example. Like the dumbest thing any adult human can believe
- 13:46is just mind boggling than anyone going, yeah, let's get psychological. Why
- 13:50do you think people buy into it? Is it tribes? Well, it's
- 13:54it's okay. I mean, if we're being completely honest, it is a
- 13:58combination of delusion, narcissism, and a severe cognitive deficit. So it's exclusively
- 14:05people that have zero capacity for critical thought that also fantasize about being I'm the
- 14:11neo in the matrix. I'm this one who knows the truth, and all
- 14:15these sheep are bought the lie because the thing is that flatter. It's not
- 14:18like anti vacs, like the notion that oh, Pharma put a thing in
- 14:22the vaccine. Okay, it's wrong, but like, it doesn't violate the
- 14:26laws of physics to think that there could be something harmful in a vaccine,
- 14:30whereas flat earth is so easily debunkable by naked eye observations in logic a toddler
- 14:35could understand. So it's totally indefensible to engage in this. The only explanation
- 14:41is this idea of conspiracy and the government. And it's not even the government,
- 14:45well, it's every government all over the world, one huge cabal of
- 14:48lizard people that are controlling everything that has ever happened in history to what for
- 14:54what? For what purpose? Right? It doesn't even achieve anything. Well,
- 14:58the reason I was talking about tribes on it. It's probably the formost
- 15:01on my mind because I'm working on a presentation about this sort of in group
- 15:07a group psychology social identity, where these people can get together and they hold
- 15:13groups and meetings and conventions and the fact that the rest of the world disagrees
- 15:18with them actually helps to validate them or make them feel validated. Right,
- 15:24the more they the more we're persecuted for our truth, the more we know
- 15:28we must be onto something. And then they're around all of these other validating
- 15:33personalities and they come together and becomes really an evolved example of social cohesion tribes.
- 15:39And then furthermore, they establish these little communities and then they vie for
- 15:43supremacy within the community, so they have little conferences, and then the different
- 15:48flat earthers are all wanting to be the one that talk at the thing.
- 15:52Or honestly, it's true of any conspiracy theory. We're talking about anti vacs,
- 15:54we're talking about anything qan on all of these things. What you've said
- 15:58is completely accurate and aplies to all of them. And this is unfortunately the
- 16:03downside of the Internet. Right now that we are in the information age,
- 16:06we have the democratization of information, and so you can no longer suppress information.
- 16:11You can't hide the fact that a government is butchering its people in some
- 16:15corner of the world because people are going to get on Twitter and expose it.
- 16:18But also, these people who made this ridiculous community would not they were
- 16:22not able to find each other prior to the Internet. So this is the
- 16:26downside of the information age, and unfortunately it is proving to be an unbelievable
- 16:32problem, an enormous problem. Coming up next with Dave Farena, we got
- 16:37to hear both sides equal time, teach the controversy. We're going to get
- 16:41into why that's just a bunch of crap. Next. Lots of free thought
- 16:52conferences still to common twenty twenty four. Beyond the individual tour stops that I've
- 16:57got coming up, Saint Louis, Fort Worth, Houston, I'll be in
- 17:02Toronto, Bentonville. There are some major all weekend events BAJA Cohn, the
- 17:08Bluewater Atheists, Humanist Agnostics Conference August ninth through the eleventh, the Kentucky Free
- 17:15Thought Convention September seventh, The Freedom From Religion Foundation National Convention will be in
- 17:22Denver. That's the last weekend in September, and then the last weekend of
- 17:27October is CSI. Cohn and Professor Brian Cox, Neil de grast Heysen and
- 17:34others are going to be there for that. Wow. Lots of stuff on
- 17:38the horizon. The Thinkingatheist dot Com slash events as all the details continuing now
- 17:48with Dave Farina. Okay, I'm hearing this a lot and it makes me
- 17:56crazy. We need to make sure both sides of the issue are presented,
- 18:02and this can be about germ theory, flat Earth, COVID whatever. And
- 18:07it drives me crazy because first of all, it distills it down again that
- 18:10there must be an arb answer, right, it's a binary way of looking.
- 18:14And two, I feel like it's giving credibility to people who show up
- 18:18with the wankiest bullshit on the planet and we're supposed to give them equal time.
- 18:22Do you address the idea like we must address teach the controversy kind of
- 18:26thing. What's your approach? I mean, my approach is to call it
- 18:30out where I see it. So I have a zero tolerance policy for this
- 18:34kind of stuff. Where I see pseudo science, I call it out.
- 18:37I call it for what it is. So No, I absolutely do not
- 18:41think you know two plus two is four. We're not entertaining the idea that
- 18:45equals five or three or square or whatever anything else. I mean, what
- 18:49would you do with those people though? I mean if they show up and
- 18:52demand an equal seat at the table. Are we supposed to just like laugh
- 18:55them out of the room or you know, what's the move depending on what
- 18:59you what room you mean specifically, I mean, I just make content on
- 19:02the Internet that exposes all of these lies. If we're talking about like a
- 19:07conference or something, then the you know, let's say we're talking about a
- 19:11particular field of science, then the experts in that field determine who's invited that
- 19:15conference. And so there's no flat earthers that are invited to the astrophysics conference.
- 19:19So there's no danger of them, I mean unless they barge in and
- 19:22then everyone just points and laughs at them and they get dragged away by security.
- 19:26But unfortunately, on the Internet, on Twitter and things like that,
- 19:30everybody has a right to have a profile and say what they want, and
- 19:36this is one of the main ways that this misinformation is spreading. And so
- 19:38on those platforms where everyone does have a say, which from a certain perspective,
- 19:44they ought to, I just like to expose and humiliate and berate them
- 19:49relentlessly. There are many other strategies. I encourage other people to take more
- 19:53nuanced approach to it, but I'm just not that guy. If you're going
- 19:57to talk about flat earth or if you're going to spread live. It's like
- 20:00yesterday, this woman that keeps popping up in my feed said something about,
- 20:04you know, injecting hydrogen peroxide is a great therapy. It's like you're gonna
- 20:08get people killed. And I used very strong language, and like, this
- 20:14woman is a monster. Report this tweet, get this profile banned from Twitter.
- 20:18When you're putting people's lives in jeopardy, we're not gonna do the Oh,
- 20:22I see what you're saying. No, no, no, no,
- 20:23this is ridiculous. You're wrong, You have no clue what you're talking about.
- 20:26This is dangerous. You deserve to be booted from the platform. It's
- 20:30like whack a mole though. I mean, I'm not saying it's not important.
- 20:33Yeah, but you know you're cut off one head and man, ten
- 20:37more appear, especially these days, right. Yeah, it does feel very
- 20:41disheartening and it does feel futile at times. And so I'm definitely not sitting
- 20:47here going like, oh, I know exactly what to do, Everybody follow
- 20:49me. I'm just sort of doing what's available to me given the tools that
- 20:52I have. But that's why part of my outreach is to go to universities
- 20:56and talk to science students and say, hey, are you perhaps not so
- 21:02thrilled about the prospect of a career either working in the lab or teaching at
- 21:07a university. Here's this third option, science communication. We need you.
- 21:11We need young scientific minds who are passionate about storytelling or content creation or public
- 21:18outreach or whatever it is. We need you got we need an army here,
- 21:22right. We need a lot of people working on this problem exclusively figuring
- 21:25out how to get the public to understand science. That is a problem in
- 21:29technical fields that I was talking to Kara Santa Maria about it. You know,
- 21:33to have such a great thing to communicate, but we don't have a
- 21:37lot of weal, we have more, but we don't have nearly enough communicate
- 21:40ors right to tell the story of science. Yes, you agree, I
- 21:42would agree because this concept of a career science communicator, which is what I
- 21:47am, is still relatively recent. Ready. It used to be, like
- 21:49everybody thinks to Carl Sagan, sort of the godfather of sycom, and he
- 21:53was an astronomer. He was a prominent astronomer, and then he pivoted to
- 21:56the public outreach, and then you know, say with Neil Tyson and a
- 22:00lot of these people. And there still are a lot of people in the
- 22:03scientific and medical communities that take some of their time to communicate their science,
- 22:07which is very laudable. And I applaud them and I appreciate them because they're
- 22:11experts in their field. However, they're very busy. They do science,
- 22:15they are doctors, they are all these other things. This is what I
- 22:18do. This is what I do. I look at what the public is
- 22:21saying, what they're thinking. I try to figure out where they're going wrong
- 22:23where I can correct it. This is all I am thinking about. And
- 22:26we need thousands more people doing exactly this. Okay, Dave, tell me
- 22:32about this guy, just because I've been watching I have a spot in the
- 22:36cheap seats and I've been watching the scrap going on between you and is a
- 22:40doctor James Tour to you? Are am I saying it right? Yeah,
- 22:45just like the normal word. Yeah, who is doctor James Tour? And
- 22:49what the hell is going on? So he is a chemist at Rice University,
- 22:55and he's also a creationist and apologist who lies about origin of life research.
- 23:00So earlier we were talking about the Discovery Institute. So most of the
- 23:04Christian nationalist anti science propaganda in the biological sciences is directed at evolution, so
- 23:11they all are trying to deny evolution and they want intelligent design in the public
- 23:15school science classes, et cetera. But James is the only one that has
- 23:18tackled origin of life research, so not the evolution of life, but its
- 23:22origin how the first living cell came about. And he's able to do this.
- 23:27He's the only one amongst them who's able to do this because he is
- 23:30a chemist. He is a working publishing chemist, so he has a command
- 23:34of the chemistry pernacular and he's able to fool people into thinking that he knows
- 23:38what he's talking about, even though he does not work and this anything remotely
- 23:42related to this field. He does material science, so he makes graphene and
- 23:47nanocars and things like that, which has absolutely nothing to do with the origin
- 23:49of life research. He does not understand the field and he grossly misrepresents it,
- 23:55slanders researchers in the field, and basically tries to paint the entire field
- 23:59of thousands thousands of researchers as totally invalid top to bottom, a complete scam.
- 24:04Pretends to be neutral about it, but obviously, as a creationist,
- 24:07he believes that God created life. He's ideologically opposed to the idea of a
- 24:14biogenesis or life arising from natural processes, and so he has been sort of
- 24:19handpicked by Discovery Institute to be the wing of the DII single handedly that attacks
- 24:26origin of life research. And he's been doing this for years. I caught
- 24:29wind of it and started making content debunking him. It went back and forth
- 24:33and escalated to the point where this clamor for debate arose, and so we
- 24:37did finally do that a couple weeks ago at Rice University. My opponent's favorite
- 24:41origin of life expert, professional Lee Cronin now writes and says on multiple occasions
- 24:47that quote, origin of life research is a scam unquote and quote there are
- 24:52lots of layers to the scam unquote. A scam means a dishonest scheme or
- 24:56a fraud. It's beautiful if professional Lee Pronin has been scientifically born again.
- 25:03Of course, the idea that an origin of life researcher would be admitting that
- 25:07his entire body of work is fraudulent is totally idiotic, and any rational viewer
- 25:12can surmise that this tweet is a joke with zero further context. Still,
- 25:18one can find this further context by googling for ten seconds. Here is Lee
- 25:22explaining to podcaster Lex Friedman what he meant origin of life research is a scam.
- 25:30So if this is Shakespeare, can we analyze this word? Why is
- 25:33the origin of life research a scam? Aren't you kind of doing origin of
- 25:37life research? Okay, it was tongue in chic, But yeah, I
- 25:41think and I meant it as tongue in chic. I'm not doing I'm not
- 25:45doing the origin of life research. I'm trying to make artificial life. I
- 25:51also want to bound the likelihood of the origin of life on Earth, but
- 25:55more importantly to find origin of life elsewhere. But let me directly address the
- 26:00There are many many good chemists out there doing origin of life research, but
- 26:03I want to nudge them, and I think the brilliant There's no question the
- 26:08chemistry they are doing, their motivation is great. So what I meant by
- 26:12that tweet is saying that maybe they're making assumptions about saying, if only I
- 26:18could make this particular type of molecules, say this RNA molecule or this phosphodiester
- 26:26or this other molecule. It's going to somehow unlock the origin of life.
- 26:30And I think that Origin of life has been looking at this for a very
- 26:34long time. And whilst I think it's brilliant to work out how you can
- 26:40get to those molecules, I think that chemistry and chemists doing Origin of life
- 26:45could be nudged into doing something even more profound. Big surprise. For the
- 26:52full conversation, visit the interview link below. Lee is saying that the creation
- 26:56of artificial life is more interesting to him than getting a pre se historical model
- 27:00of how life arose on Earth. As you can see, James really shows
- 27:04his true colors immediately with this stunt. He is freely admitting that he has
- 27:10zero interest in truth, zero interest in a good faith conversation, and that
- 27:15it's all one big, fat act. It was really almost juvenile. Dave
- 27:19Farina gets owned in this clip boom, and then you come in and you're
- 27:25like, how freaking dishonest can you be? Am I reading that right?
- 27:27I mean I was browsing pretty quickly, but so the debate was very chaotic,
- 27:33but ultimately he ended up humiliating himself more than anything I said to him,
- 27:37because he was just acting like in a very juvenile way. He was
- 27:42just shouting and shrieking over me. This man has said multiple times that I
- 27:48have called him stupid. I have never called him stupid because I don't think
- 27:51he's stupid. I have said he's clueless on this topic. I have said
- 27:55he cannot read the scientific literature. That doesn't mean stupid. This man has
- 27:59become a news and then he went out and in twenty fifteen he started an
- 28:03educational site, which is huge. Stupid people can't do that. I admire
- 28:08him. This is an educational site, and I have never called him stupid
- 28:14because he's not stupid. He's not stupid. So I admire him for his
- 28:18educational site. And from what I understand, I'm not a musician. From
- 28:22what I understand with people who said he's an excellent musician, I admire him
- 28:26for that as well. His wife is here, he's a father, he
- 28:29has two children. I admire that that a man can have a wife and
- 28:32two children and stay married and do these things these days. That is wonderful.
- 28:37That is wonderful. So basically, James is shocked that my wife hasn't
- 28:41left me yet and wow, Dave can play music. Wasn't this supposed to
- 28:45be about the science. I never said Dave was stupid. I just said
- 28:48his content is a manure dump. I just said everything he says is wrong.
- 28:52I said he's clueless. I said he doesn't know chemistry. Although again,
- 28:57who's used my content to pass his class? Anybody here? That's what
- 29:03I thought, James, he doesn't know chemistry, yet I'm helping your students.
- 29:08Isn't that interesting? Thank you? Yeah, thank you. This is
- 29:11how easy it is to get James to unravel. He refuses to admit that
- 29:17he was completely out of line in repeatedly proclaiming to his viewers that I don't
- 29:22understand chemistry, despite the fact that he is now pretending to praise me on
- 29:27my chemistry tutorials, which his students used to pass his class. So I
- 29:33explain chemistry better than he does, Yet somehow I still don't know chemistry.
- 29:38The hypocrisy is off the charts. He is absolutely incapable of admitting that he
- 29:45was way out of line with all of the accusations he made in his content.
- 29:48Instead, he triples down with the same old crap. Would you like
- 29:52to retract any of these statements, are there perhaps origin of life? No,
- 29:59just frain and chemistry? No, oh, I don't know. I
- 30:03don't know chemistry. Anybody you saw it tonight. Comn could not sweak without
- 30:08a script he has people right, you could do it. You could do
- 30:11it. So it's been an incredible damage control campaign from Discovery Institute after that
- 30:18debate. They just started posting blog posts after blog posts, dozens of them,
- 30:23just you know, Dumbfarina. He's no match for the brilliant tour and
- 30:27all these things. Uh, And then that's what you're seeing from his flock
- 30:30as well. They'll try to figure out ways to edit together little things to
- 30:34go haha, you know tour want. But it's like any neutral party that
- 30:38actually watches the debate from front to back is like, who is this guy?
- 30:44And why is he screaming at the top of his lungs and what is
- 30:47he talking about? I'll play Devil's advocate. How do you know he's lying?
- 30:52And he doesn't genuinely believe because he's brainwashed like many other believers who might
- 30:56well known in science. So let's be clear. He he believes that God
- 31:00created life because of scripture, and that's totally fine, But when we're talking
- 31:04about the minutia, when he says all of the biology text books say this
- 31:10thing and it's some dumb thing that he made up, and I go,
- 31:14no, they don't. Here's all the books that you just listed. This
- 31:17is what they actually say. They don't say that thing you said. Can
- 31:18you respond? And then he just fumbles, fumbles fumbles. You said that
- 31:23origin of life research is a boutique field with only a dozen people working on
- 31:26it. That's a lie. Here's a list of hundreds of people working in
- 31:30the field. Why did you tell that lie? So very specific lies,
- 31:33comparing direct quotes to reality and forcing him to respond, I mean, without
- 31:37a doubt, proved that he is a liar on this topic with very very
- 31:41specific claims that he's made. But it's true. I do ultimately believe he's
- 31:45not a Kent Hovind, He's not a used car salesman. He does genuinely
- 31:49believe ideologically what he says he believes. But then that's where the cognitive dissonance
- 31:55comes in. He's a scientist that is denying science because he puts faith above
- 31:59science. Dave Farena, do you spend any time on Hovind? But even
- 32:02when I was a believer. I didn't know who he was. Yeah,
- 32:05I just just did not I didn't care. He was not my radar.
- 32:07And I kind of got the vibe that the only reason people may know his
- 32:10name now is because of atheist activists who are always throwing shit at him and
- 32:15saying, hey, this is crazy, you know, and I'm throwing a
- 32:17spotlight on him. I don't know, is there merit in going after the
- 32:22Hovens, et cetera. Well, I mean I would want to push back
- 32:25on the idea that people didn't know him. He was very very influential a
- 32:30lot of people. No, I'm just saying I didn't forget for sure.
- 32:32Yeah, yeah, yeah, I mean he was very very influential, and
- 32:36he was going to all the schools, and he had his little his video
- 32:38series and he would send that out and everything. So I think that it's
- 32:43been very effective and everybody kind of dog piling to expose him, and then
- 32:45documentaries came out that he, you know, is abusive to women, and
- 32:50then he was harboring a pedophile and all these things, and so that culminated
- 32:52in him. I think all of that spotlight is what culminated on him losing
- 32:57his YouTube channel, so he doesn't have access to the platform anymore. And
- 33:00that's an incredible victory that he doesn't have access to the tool that he was
- 33:04using to proselytize. I mean, it's big. But if I draw that
- 33:07line of demarcation between I don't know, twenty years ago, like three prison
- 33:12term when he was doctor Dino and they have an auditorium speaking to I don't
- 33:15know, hundreds of young children, I get that. I get that,
- 33:19yeah, But now I feel like he's just sort of hold up in the
- 33:21basement with a webcam. And I mean, I'll call him, I'll call
- 33:24him irrelevant. I mean, am I wrong on that? Well, he's
- 33:28certainly irrelevant in particular now that he doesn't have access to YouTube anymore, and
- 33:31in fact, nobody talks about him or cares about him anymore. But he
- 33:35used to be publishing content very consistently, and in my mind, anyone who
- 33:40is influential with their lives should be dealt with. Am I part of the
- 33:45problem? I just brought him up? So now, am I actually an
- 33:47example of the type of thing that I was saying someone else? This is
- 33:52a deep one, like I'm literally in a feedback loop on a hamster with
- 33:55right right, keep me up tonight. Sorry, it's a set of mirrors.
- 33:59Yeah. So here's the thing. I obviously a lot of people cite
- 34:02that, and I think that it can be damaging to bring attention to someone
- 34:06if you don't also adequately expose them. If you adequately expose them in doing
- 34:12so, it's a net positive because you're calling attention to the fraudulents of somebody
- 34:15and demonstrating that fraudulence very very effectively and thoroughly. So as long as you
- 34:22do that, it's good. I'll add a layer to that onion that if
- 34:25they are making an argument that is common elsewhere, then debunking it in one
- 34:30context relates to the other context. That would Yeah, And inevitably the script
- 34:35is very similar for all of those, especially the young Earth creationist types.
- 34:37Is they just all go to answers in Genesis and pull it off of the
- 34:42thing and it's just bottles my mind. They think the Earth is younger than
- 34:45the Sumerian civilization, and I just think, what, how like, how
- 34:49do we get there? What's going on? There are trees older, they're
- 34:52living trees that are older than how they say the earth is. That's why
- 34:58the current incarnation of the Chris propaganda in the biological science is very dangerous because
- 35:02they're trying to present themselves as more credible scientifically. That's why they are distancing
- 35:07themselves from younger creationism. They're accepting a geological time, but that lends them
- 35:12the credence to then lie profusely about all of these other aspects of science.
- 35:15So it has to get dealt with. I was talking to a buddy of
- 35:19mine, Dave Fitzgerald, and said, if you needed proof of evolution,
- 35:22just look at the creation story or Christianity, right, because they've gone many
- 35:27of them have gone from well literal six days six thousand years ago to the
- 35:32days were millions of years, to an old earth. But it's still true
- 35:37to some of its metaphor, and it means something else. And so we're
- 35:39seeing all of this, you know, it's like silly putty. They just
- 35:44molded into whatever it needs to be to try to stay relevant. Is more
- 35:46and more people become the evolutionaryly literate. If they're rational, those are the
- 35:52rational ones. The irrational ones simply deny all of that to one degree or
- 35:57another. Next up with science communicator Dave Farina. What about a biogenesis?
- 36:06Where did the first cell come from? This is a favorite argument of apologists.
- 36:12Well, of matter can't be created or destroyed. Who created the first
- 36:17cell? Now? Would? Dave responds, We'll find out. Continuing with
- 36:28Dave Farina, he is a science educator and host of the Professor Dave Explains
- 36:35YouTube channel. Okay for a second, let's pinball back to a biogenesis.
- 36:42This is one of the arguments for God that I'm glad you're here because I
- 36:45want to I want to hear what you have to say. Matter cannot be
- 36:49created or destroyed? Where did the first cell come from? A biogenesis?
- 36:54All these things tying in together as proof that there must have been a creator
- 37:00or that first cell? Where did life come from? How do you address
- 37:04these types of questions? Well, so, I mean it's a straw man
- 37:07to bring up matter being created. Certainly, matter, the matter that comprise
- 37:12the first living organism, wasn't created ab initio, right. I mean,
- 37:15if you want to go all the way back to early cosmology, we understand
- 37:17how stars form and how atomic nuclei are fused in stars and then they're spread
- 37:22out, and then a planet's sary system forms, and then planetary formation.
- 37:25So none of that has to do specifically with biology. But that is all
- 37:30to say that the very small molecules that were the starting place for the assembly
- 37:35of the first life, they're a given. They're everywhere. They come to
- 37:38us from. They're made in space and they come to you know, they
- 37:42land on the Earth on asteroids from space, and then they're also synthesized here.
- 37:45So we're starting from small molecules, and then those make the building blocks
- 37:50which then polymerize to make the long chains. And then there's this field of
- 37:53chemistry called systems chemistry that talks about how these sets of molecules can evolve by
- 37:58honestly Darwinian principle over time to yield the first proto cell. So this is
- 38:02incredibly esoteric and incredibly complicated, and it's almost pointless for me to try to
- 38:08describe it in any more detail right now. But it's a vibrant field with
- 38:13thousands of people working on it all these different steps, and we made an
- 38:15incredible amount of progress over the past seventy or eighty years. But if someone
- 38:20says the first cell came from somewhere, I mean that's a loaded statement obviously,
- 38:27because many of them are coming from a religious background. But your response
- 38:30would be, what the first cell, the first cell coming from somewhere meaning
- 38:35God made it, or a meaning it came from space like panspermia. I
- 38:37mean they are going to attach agency in the form of a designer, a
- 38:43deity, you know, a first mus er kind of thing. You know.
- 38:46My response is you're free to believe that, but there is absolutely like
- 38:51to pretend that that's a scientific belief is absurd, especially in the light of
- 38:54the progress that the field has made over the past decades. But it's just
- 38:59this is the God the gaps. And so Jamestre is going to push back
- 39:01against this and say, I don't believe in the God of the gaps.
- 39:04No, you have a gap in your knowledge that you fill with God.
- 39:07That's the God of the gaps. And this gap used to be wider.
- 39:09We used to say, what's volcanoes, Oh, it's a god doing this
- 39:13thing. What's lightning? Zeus is going like that, what's disease? Oh,
- 39:15the God send the demons and the dow thing. So we used to
- 39:19be God is everything, and then it just the gaps got smaller and smaller
- 39:22and smaller and smaller, and the only two places there's even a remote gap
- 39:27is the origin of life in the origin of the universe, and honestly,
- 39:29the one for the origin of life is kind of no room for him anymore.
- 39:31I just love watching the apologists because they always start with the deistic,
- 39:36right, this real negulus, faceless other that began at all, the watchmaker,
- 39:42and then they take this chasm size leap into their specific deity with a
- 39:45proper name, right, who lived at certain times and did certain specific things,
- 39:52And I'm like, well, the man. And then I never am
- 39:55really able to see how they connected those dots, except for it's fair sure,
- 40:00right, yeah, yeah, sure, that's the faith. And in
- 40:02fact it is a very important distinction to make, because of course the DII
- 40:07is trying to paint me as this ultra militant, angry atheist, which is
- 40:10simply not the case. I am an atheist, but I don't make content
- 40:14on atheism, and I don't really much care, and I would never attack
- 40:17a d'ist who chooses to maintain that God of the gaps in the creation of
- 40:22the universe, if you believe that a god made the universe, I don't
- 40:25care. I'm not even going to try to argue with you, it doesn't
- 40:28matter to me, but you're absolutely right that they will take that concept and
- 40:32then try to make the leap to the god of their faith without realizing that
- 40:37they're just imposing so much on it, but then second of all, denying
- 40:40science where they're trying to put their god. So the problem is that people
- 40:45are not aware of origin of life research. They don't even know it's a
- 40:47thing that exists, and so they're just rejecting an entire field because it's inconvenient
- 40:52to them. Do you think we are born with an evolved predisposition to look
- 40:59up been try to find a cosmic father. Figures there's something evolutionarily wired in
- 41:06us. I think that we are predisposed to seek answers, and where answers
- 41:12are not there, we will fill it in. And divinity has classically been
- 41:17the go to answer, so pre scientifically it was the only answer. And
- 41:22now we're able to actually answer questions in a logical, empirical way. And
- 41:29so I think that science has made atheism a defensible position, or at least
- 41:32more defensible. I think there was always some defense for it, but now
- 41:36it's much more viable to defend a position of atheism. So I don't know
- 41:40necessarily that we're hardwired to seek divinity. I just think that we seek answers.
- 41:45That and the fact that we're afraid to die. And plus I think
- 41:49as long as there is suffering in this world, people will construct a mechanism
- 41:52for coping. I mean, that's fair, right, I mean, surely
- 41:55my body's broken now. One day I'll have a new body. I miss
- 42:00my great grandmother, one day will be reunited. I mean we're meaning makers
- 42:05in that way. I was poor in life, so I'll be rich and
- 42:08in the afterlife. If you could fix the classroom, I'm sure you have
- 42:14opinions about the format of education, maybe even especially here in the United States.
- 42:21What are we getting wrong? Like, if you could change the way
- 42:22we teach science, what would you do? So I do get this question
- 42:29a lot, and it's always very difficult for me to answer, because the
- 42:31problem is that I don't immediately see gaping problems. I myself received a very
- 42:37good public school education in the sciences, included which I took with me to
- 42:43college to then major in chemistry, and I did a master's in science education.
- 42:45So we looked pretty rigorously at the NGSS. The new science standards and
- 42:51everything, and like to me, on the federal level, the rubric that
- 42:55the framework that's implemented, I don't see a major problem there. Of course,
- 43:00the issue then is funding, right, It's education is dramatically underfunded and
- 43:04teachers are underpaid, and so that's where you get the gaps. That's where
- 43:07you have low income areas where there's no good teachers. They don't have any
- 43:09resources. And so to me, it's just money. And I'm not that
- 43:15this is not my field, and I don't really know anything about policy,
- 43:17but in my naive mind, if I was president and I could issue executive
- 43:22orders, I would take a big old chunk out of defense, put it
- 43:24into education, pay teachers ninety k a year, give them all the resources
- 43:29they need, stop making them buy stuff out of their own money to bring
- 43:31to school, things like that, And I feel that that would be the
- 43:36difference. But I don't know, I don't know if well. I think
- 43:40we all have subjective perspectives. You know, I worry sometimes we are training
- 43:46people to take tests, but we're not really igniting the fun, you know,
- 43:51we're not lighting the spark of curiosity. And a lot of people would
- 43:54the awe and wonder the sagan esque kind of stuff. Make sure it was
- 43:59being a bit. It's romantic. Yeah, about the idea of teaching,
- 44:02you know, it ultimately boils down to the individual teacher. Some teachers have
- 44:06that gift, some don't. But if if the position was better paid,
- 44:08we'd be getting better, more talented teachers. Certainly, I felt that I
- 44:13received that I enjoyed. I took biology, chemistry, AP, chemistry,
- 44:16AP physics, and in particular in chemistry, I felt I enjoyed it.
- 44:22I was curious and I learned, and I was able to apply knowledge.
- 44:25And then in college I major in chemistry and thought, this is great,
- 44:29this is really cool stuff. You know, tell me about your channel,
- 44:31I mean, pitch you give me the give me the brochure for those just
- 44:35now being introduced to you as we wrap up. So the main goal of
- 44:38the channel has always been to offer curriculum aligned academic tutorials for as many academic
- 44:45subjects as possible, obviously mainly science, but just sort of spanning the gamut.
- 44:50So I want to teach you chemistry, biochemistry, biology, physics,
- 44:54math, astronomy, ecology, botany, geology, everything that I can at
- 45:00a very basic level, so usually like kind of freshmen undergraduate like one oh
- 45:06one style learning, And so this is a place you can go if you're
- 45:09curious, if you want to learn something with a little bit more depth than
- 45:13some edutainment video, right, a little bit more. There's more meat there,
- 45:16but it's not something that is going to kill you. You're not going
- 45:20to be so completely lost. I mean, for some of my content you
- 45:22would there is prerequisite knowledge, but it's relatively easy to bite into and get
- 45:29a moderate understanding of the basics of a field of science. Well, I'll
- 45:34link everything in the description box, but I mean, I'm I try to
- 45:37stay above a lot of that, but i just find myself watching this back
- 45:42and forth between you and the Discovery Institute, etc. And I'm just it's
- 45:45like watching Thunderdome. I don't know why they keep doing it, because they
- 45:50will make their little posts character assassinating me. I'll reply mocking them because they're
- 45:55children, and then I end up ratioing them because they're will get you ten
- 46:00likes, and then my comment gets seventy likes, and then it's just dozens
- 46:05of people all making fun of them and how they're idiot liars, and it's
- 46:09just like, why do you guys even have a Twitter presence? Everyone here
- 46:13is dunking on you. What are you even doing here? It's really funny
- 46:16to watch, all right, the channel it's called Professor Dave explains and I
- 46:22will link that and everything else in the description box. You're a great science
- 46:27communicator and a lot of fun to talk to you. Thanks for indulging me.
- 46:30Great to have you, Thanks for having me. Follow The Thinking Atheist
- 46:34on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like
- 46:38mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and
- 46:43resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our
- 46:49website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.