Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #38: The Funnel of Causality - Why We Vote the Way We Vote
Transcript
- 0:00It's the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:02I'm your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:04Today, we're gonna talk about the funnel of causality.
- 0:09Have you ever wondered why some people vote the way they do?
- 0:12Or maybe you wonder what exactly influences you to vote the way you do.
- 0:18Enter the funnel of causality.
- 0:20It's a diagram that lists all the internal and external forces in the short term, medium term,
- 0:26and long term that are then distilled into what our vote choice is.
- 0:31And these forces are pictured as, you guessed it, a funnel where there's a really big opening
- 0:37where you throw in all these factors impacting the vote.
- 0:41You get to the narrow end, and then boom.
- 0:43You have vote choice.
- 0:45While you were young, you may have been taught that during elections, we all come together,
- 0:50pensively debate the choices on our ballot in our minds, and then come to the most informed
- 0:56decision that we possibly can.
- 0:59In reality, however, none of us are 100% independent in our thought processes where we
- 1:06eschew any potential biases.
- 1:09That's why we represent the ultimate reasons for vote choice as a funnel.
- 1:13It's a represent representation of how we filter all the information coming into our
- 1:19brains even if we don't consciously think about all of it.
- 1:23We all have these factors that go in to influence our vote whether we realize it or
- 1:30not.
- 1:31So what's the story behind the development of the funnel of causality?
- 1:36What does it look like?
- 1:37How does it work?
- 1:38And why should you care?
- 1:42That's on that's what's on tap for today's episode.
- 1:45I actually wrote an article about this on medium.com way back, like, I don't know, 2019.
- 1:52It it's definitely not as in-depth as what this is going to be.
- 1:56So I'm gonna include a link on that article to this episode, and I'll include an article to
- 2:03the art to include a link to that article in the show notes for this episode.
- 2:10But this is gonna be a lot more in-depth.
- 2:12So if you are coming from that Medium article, thank you so much for reading and coming to
- 2:18check out the podcast.
- 2:20But to get into the origins of the funnel of causality, we must go all the way back to the
- 2:28school of thought that is commonly dubbed the Columbia School, named after Columbia
- 2:33University.
- 2:34There was polling before then, but that didn't really delve much into the reasons for people's
- 2:39vote choices.
- 2:40Just mostly was just who are people voting for, and what do they think about some of these
- 2:45issues?
- 2:45But not really diving into the, oh, that's why they are voting for so and so.
- 2:52The this that modern, what we call modern academic study of voting research, why people
- 2:59vote the way they they vote, can be traced back to 1940 to a group of researchers from Columbia
- 3:06University, hence, Columbia School.
- 3:09They were headed by the venerable Paul Lazarsfeld, who's an Austrian born social
- 3:14scientist who founded Columbia University's Bureau of Applied Social Research.
- 3:20And on his team, he also included Bernard Berylson and Hazel.
- 3:24Hopefully, I'm gonna say this correct.
- 3:26Good day.
- 3:28Berylson was the head of the center for advanced studies in the behavioral sciences at
- 3:33Stanford University, and Good day was a pioneer in the field of political psychology and also
- 3:39notable for being a female social scientist at a time when there were very few.
- 3:44And it's only a couple of decades after women gained the right to vote through the, the
- 3:49nineteenth amendment.
- 3:51So during the seven months leading up to the nineteen forty presidential election, the
- 3:56election that year, which was Franklin d Roosevelt versus Wendell Willkie, and then FDR
- 4:02went on to win his third term.
- 4:05The researchers tracked a sample of 600 people from Erie County, Ohio.
- 4:11So a a decent sample, but only from one town.
- 4:15And there were multiple interviews over time so that they could make these cross sections of
- 4:20how exactly people's votes changed or didn't change over time.
- 4:24And that led to the groundbreaking book called the people's choice, how the voter makes up his
- 4:30mind in a presidential campaign.
- 4:33In short, the nineteen forty studies results said that the actual campaign, so newspaper
- 4:39articles or newspaper ads, radio ads in general, and so on, had little to no effect on
- 4:47individuals.
- 4:48The actual campaign didn't seem to matter.
- 4:51What actually mattered was the brand loyalties based on religion and social class and these
- 4:57interpersonal interactions with their friends and family.
- 5:01It was this.
- 5:02If you ever heard the phrase demography is destiny, it didn't originate from here, but it
- 5:07was kind of emblematic of that philosophy of whatever your demographics are, that's going to
- 5:13determine what exactly you think and how life works for you.
- 5:19The Columbia group then would follow that up.
- 5:23Instead instead of good day, though, they brought on William and McPhee.
- 5:26They followed it up with a study into the nineteen forty eight presidential election,
- 5:30which was Harry Truman and Thomas Dewey.
- 5:34Now you may remember that for the infamous picture of Harry Truman holding a newspaper
- 5:43erroneously declaring ahead of time that Thomas Dewey won the election because polling at the
- 5:49time did not track a lot of these undecided voters in the two weeks leading up to the
- 5:57election, and they there was a surge for what seemed to be a surge for Harry Truman, and he
- 6:05would go on to defeat Thomas Dewey.
- 6:07So McPhee was William M.
- 6:09McPhee, Columbia University says he invented the first computer simulation model of voting.
- 6:16And so he was brought on, and then they published another highly influential book
- 6:21called voting, a study of opinion formation in a presidential campaign.
- 6:26And this time, they studied Elmira, or is it Elmira?
- 6:30I'm not sure.
- 6:31But Elmira, New York or Elmira, New York.
- 6:35And they sort of refined that 1940 study.
- 6:38They brought on or they paid more attention to political issues, how respondents perceived or
- 6:46misperceived their favorite candidate's issue stands when they conflicted with the
- 6:51respondent's own views.
- 6:52So how did they take this whenever a candidate had a different view from them, how exactly did
- 7:01they respond?
- 7:01Did they filter it and say, oh, well, actually, he they the candidate really actually agrees
- 7:06with my point of view because of this and this, or, well, I still like this candidate.
- 7:12Basically, how did they rationalize all that?
- 7:17And down downplayed the role of the parties and the mass media again and emphasized conformity
- 7:24of their social networks and increasing said conformity over the course of the nineteen
- 7:29forty eight presidential campaign.
- 7:31So once again, did not seem like people were really changing their minds much.
- 7:36So it was that whole interpersonal interactions with people in their religious and social class
- 7:42groups.
- 7:43So the short way to describe the Columbia School is that their model was rooted in
- 7:50sociology.
- 7:52Once again, it's that large largely suggesting that demography is destiny.
- 7:56But like all pioneering work in a field of study, there were shortcomings.
- 8:01There was a lot more to people's choices than just the sociological aspects, and those would
- 8:06get built built upon after the Columbia studies, especially by a group known as now
- 8:13today known as the Michigan School.
- 8:16And their work was largely in the nineteen fifties and nineteen sixties.
- 8:20And so they built upon the findings of the Columbia School, and this originated with the
- 8:25work of the University of Michigan's Angus Campbell and Robert Kahn.
- 8:30And at at the time, they weren't really trying to follow-up on what Columbia was studying
- 8:37necessarily.
- 8:38They were surveying foreign policy attitudes in 1948 for the university's survey research
- 8:44center, and they compared these attitudes with whether they plan to vote in the nineteen forty
- 8:51eight election.
- 8:52Again, Harry Truman versus Thomas Dewey and which party they were voting for.
- 8:55So not only which candidate they were voting for, but whether they were voting at all.
- 9:01And then so they would reinterview these voters after the election too, and this is the, way
- 9:07that the University of Michigan has described it.
- 9:11I I I think this is their exact wording at the time, but three basic reasons that they were
- 9:18doing this.
- 9:19It was to analyze the crystallization of the vote, record personal, attitudinal, and
- 9:25demographic characteristics of voters and nonvoters, Republicans and Democrats, and
- 9:30three, assess the influence of various psychological, sociological, and political
- 9:35factors on the determination of the vote.
- 9:39And this 1948 study would spawn the Michigan election studies, which still go on every
- 9:47presidential and midterm elections, but now they're called the American National Election
- 9:51Studies or ANES for short.
- 9:55And these have been very, very influential and informative about why people think the way to
- 10:04do when it comes to their vote choice.
- 10:05So we still see those conducted even today.
- 10:09And they were there there were successive studies built on top of each other to compare
- 10:13cross sections of the past and the future.
- 10:17So not only seeing or not just how how is a vote changing over time for a specific campaign
- 10:26like the Columbia University studies were doing, but the Michigan school was sort of
- 10:33forward thinking.
- 10:34So every two years when we have a federal election or at least a regularly scheduled
- 10:39federal election, How are people's opinions on these various questions that get asked time and
- 10:47time again in successive elections?
- 10:49How are people's opinions changing on that?
- 10:52And so as the Michigan studies kept going on for federal elections throughout the nineteen
- 10:56fifties, Angus Campbell brought on several figures that would become vital figures in the
- 11:02development of the Michigan model of voter behavior.
- 11:06That included predominantly Syracuse University grad student Warren Miller.
- 11:10He would later found the Inter University Consortium for Political and Social Research in
- 11:151962, and that's there are the ICPSR for short.
- 11:20And there's a lot of political data that we get from them in terms of voter behavior,
- 11:27elections, and so on.
- 11:28Yale grad student Donald Stokes, who would later become a dean at Michigan and then at
- 11:33Princeton University, and then Michigan's very own Philip Converse from the school's social
- 11:39social psychology program.
- 11:42And he would later go on to write the seminal work, the nature of belief systems and mass
- 11:47publics, which was a comparison of how the ideological views work together for elites
- 11:58compared to regular people and basically said that regular people don't have a lot of
- 12:02stability in their political views, whereas elites, elites being people who are involved
- 12:09heavily in politics, who are actually elected, their political views tend to stay pretty
- 12:16rigid.
- 12:17So Angus Campbell brought on Miller, Stokes, and Converse.
- 12:23And using data from the Michigan election studies for the nineteen fifty two and nineteen
- 12:28fifty six presidential elections, which were both won by Eisenhower, Dwight Eisenhower, they
- 12:34wrote the landmark book, the American Voter, which is regarded by some people as the most
- 12:39important book in the history of electoral research.
- 12:43And they distinguished between long term and short term vote forces, and they really
- 12:51emphasize the importance of attachment to a political party with a caveat.
- 12:56Party loyalties and social characteristics are relatively stable but don't account for short
- 13:02term shifts in partisan division of the vote.
- 13:04So what before, we weren't really accounting for, well, what happens or why would a
- 13:10Republican vote for the Democratic candidate or why would a Democrat vote for the Republican
- 13:13candidate?
- 13:15Previous studies didn't really get into that.
- 13:18And so this attachment to the political party, basically, how strongly do you identify as a
- 13:25democrat or as a republican?
- 13:28It was used to explain how Eisenhower won landslide victories as a republican for
- 13:32president, but a plurality of voters were still democrats.
- 13:36And if you look at congress and how that, how the partisan divide for congress was, it was
- 13:46very routinely a democratic majority, oftentimes pretty sizable democratic
- 13:52majorities.
- 13:52There were a few times that republicans would break the majority in either the house or the
- 13:57senate.
- 13:58But at that time, congress very much routinely broke democratic.
- 14:05And then sometime in the nineteen fifties began a forty year streak where democrats had the
- 14:10majority in the US house.
- 14:14And much of this party loyalty of Eisenhower's time was traceable to the new deal by FDR,
- 14:22which was that system of political pro and economic programs that FDR and his
- 14:29administration pushed for and mostly succeeded in getting implemented back during the Great
- 14:36Depression.
- 14:37And this stud so this study by Michigan the Michigan University researchers, it also
- 14:45weighed attitudinal forces toward Eisenhower, toward his his opponent, Adlai Stevenson,
- 14:51relevant social groups, parties as managers of government, and how how people perceive the
- 14:56parties as stewards of government, domestic issues, and foreign policy issues along with
- 15:02Eisenhower's popularity because you gotta remember also Eisenhower was a war hero.
- 15:08He was he had served in World War two and had been one of the leading commanders during d
- 15:17day.
- 15:17And so with the Columbia University or the Columbia School, as it's called, solely focused
- 15:24on the sociological aspects, the Michigan School built upon that and blended both
- 15:28sociology and psychology, so socio psychological factors.
- 15:34Most relevantly for this podcast episode, though, the American voter by Campbell, Miller,
- 15:40Stokes, and Congress used the metaphor of the funnel of causality.
- 15:44So the funnel of causality was not invented by the Columbia School.
- 15:48It became later on a thing from the Michigan School.
- 15:53So there's that little bit of a history lesson for you.
- 15:57So now more to the actual funnel of causality.
- 16:02What exactly goes into it?
- 16:04So the basic premise is picture a funnel on the large open end, the wide end, you have these
- 16:11long term overarching or overarching forces shaping who you are.
- 16:16They affect how you perceive the short term choices or short term forces, excuse me, later
- 16:22on down the funnel.
- 16:23So then as you go to the narrow end of the funnel, you get to the short term forces.
- 16:29So these are more specifically related to the issues and the candidates.
- 16:34The funnel is also a representation of time.
- 16:38That large, wide end of the funnel is your baseline, sort of your the start of the
- 16:45timeline, those forces that begin shaping your general political views.
- 16:49And then the narrow end is as the campaign goes on, it starts to ultimately shape your vote
- 16:58choice as the campaign keeps going on, and then you have your vote choice.
- 17:05So voting behavior research has refined the study of vote choice over time building on the
- 17:11work of the Columbia and Michigan teams.
- 17:15And, ultimately, the funnel causality is a model of voting behavior, and there are plenty
- 17:20of those that exist today that have built upon earlier work.
- 17:23Sometimes they are represented as a funnel as well, not not always.
- 17:27You don't necessarily need to represent voting behavior as a funnel, but it's a common way to
- 17:32do it.
- 17:33And so there are some often used often used internal and external forces thrown in there in
- 17:40many conceptions of the funnel.
- 17:41Usually, the way you see it and I say usually, I'll get to it in a minute why there's not
- 17:47necessarily a specific way to envision the funnel of causality.
- 17:52But usually, when you depict the funnel, the traits that are focused on the group
- 17:57characteristics, the the external forces are thrown into the wide end, and then the
- 18:04individual focus, the internal traits are in the narrow end.
- 18:08So those group traits include things like your economic structure.
- 18:11So how far how well off is your economic outlook where you live and where people you
- 18:21know are.
- 18:23Obviously, that can fluctuate sometimes, but there are some places that are generally more
- 18:27well off and then some places that are generally worse off.
- 18:31Your social division.
- 18:32So predominantly race and religion.
- 18:35You white, black, Asian, Hispanic, multiracial in terms of religion, Christian, Muslim,
- 18:44Jewish, Hindu, Buddhist, atheist, whatever the case may be, historical patterns.
- 18:50So both of your own and of where you live.
- 18:54So are you in a place that is generally divided, republican and democrat?
- 19:00Do you live in a very democratic place?
- 19:02Do you live in a very republican place?
- 19:04How have you voted in the past?
- 19:06Have you routinely voted democrat?
- 19:08Have you routinely voted republican?
- 19:10Have you gone back and forth forth?
- 19:12Have you thrown in third parties and independents?
- 19:17Group loyalty, so you can think of that as your social identity.
- 19:20So how you identify with any of these groups.
- 19:24Is your race a strong part of your social identity?
- 19:27Your religion, your party, the value orientation.
- 19:33So the values that you share about about family or how exactly the government should be
- 19:43involved in people's lives or how little it or if you think that it should be less involved in
- 19:48people's lives and then your party attachment.
- 19:51So how strongly do you identify as a democrat or a republican, or do you identify with either
- 19:56one of them at all?
- 19:58The way we sometimes describe that is as what we call a weak Democrat or Republican and
- 20:05strong Republican or Democrat.
- 20:07It's not a value judgment.
- 20:09It's just a way to describe how closely you identify with that party.
- 20:15And these group traits are sometimes referred to as political cleavages, which are social or
- 20:21cultural dividing lines that break societies into different groups with different political
- 20:26views.
- 20:26So those are very influential a lot of times on what people vote as, especially, like, if
- 20:33you're for example, if you are a if you're from a black neighborhood, black voters typically
- 20:39vote Democratic.
- 20:41If you're a white male that goes to church, a lot of times, you you you tend to vote
- 20:48Republican.
- 20:50So those are examples of political cleavages.
- 20:54Individual traits include where you get your political news from.
- 20:59Do you watch Fox News, CNN, MSNBC?
- 21:03Do you get it from a another a different source?
- 21:09Issue opinions and those those sources, I mean, there's a myriad of of sources that you can get
- 21:15your news from, and plenty of them have a very heavy bias one way or another.
- 21:22Your issue opinions.
- 21:23So what do you think of abortion, guns, LGBT issues, foreign policy, all sorts of different
- 21:36issues, obviously.
- 21:37Perception of the candidate's image.
- 21:39So how do you see Donald Trump, Kamala Harris, Joe Biden, Barack Obama, George Bush?
- 21:46That's starting to get a little little way back there at this point.
- 21:50Wow.
- 21:50It's kind of amazing to think about some of those some of those political figures are an
- 21:56eternity ago in in political years.
- 21:59But what do you think of all of those candidates or political figures of yesteryear
- 22:05or today?
- 22:06So Chuck Schumer, Bernie Sanders, Mitch McConnell, your interaction with your family
- 22:11and your friends.
- 22:13So kinda going back to what the Columbia and the Michigan schools, but especially the
- 22:18Columbia school use those interactions with your family and friends and how they shape your
- 22:23political opinions.
- 22:24Now you're not necessarily gonna agree with them, but they still can often impact what you
- 22:30think because when you have a group that leans one way, it it's you know, not don't
- 22:37necessarily automatically take the same exact stances, but they will impact what you think to
- 22:44some degree.
- 22:46Your actual interactions with the campaign, whether it's president, US senate, US house,
- 22:52state legislature, your local officials, whoever the case may be, your personal economic
- 22:59class.
- 22:59So are are you specifically well off, or are you poor, or are you middle class?
- 23:05You're working class?
- 23:07So just to reiterate, group characteristics, which tend to look at more external characters
- 23:13characteristics like your race and your social social divisions of where you where you are and
- 23:20your historical patterns of how the place you live votes.
- 23:26And then down to the more at the narrow end of the funnel, more internal individual focus
- 23:32characteristics like your specific views on issues, domestic and foreign, or your
- 23:42perceptions of a candidate's image.
- 23:44So that's the basic way that the can the funnel is typically visualized as.
- 23:51But I said earlier that there's not really a true there's no one correct visualization of a
- 24:00funnel of causality.
- 24:02There isn't a true, this is exactly what the funnel looks like diagram.
- 24:06Why can't there be one true funnel of causality?
- 24:10And that's just because everybody feels the pull of different factors or the same factors,
- 24:16but in different ways.
- 24:18A couple of the more common designs, but, there's there are a couple of more common
- 24:23designs, but none that are 100% correct in every single situation or for every voter.
- 24:29There might be some overlap, and they aren't mutually exclusive, but there you do see some
- 24:36key differences.
- 24:37And I'm going to put up this common example of a funnel on the screen here.
- 24:42But you see at the wide end of the funnel, you see economic structure, social divisions,
- 24:49historical patterns, and then those start to feed into your group loyalty.
- 24:55Not necessarily not not specifically every party, but your your racial or religious groups
- 25:01or or gender groups or or whatever the case may be.
- 25:05Your value orientations, what values you specifically hold dear, and in group loyalty,
- 25:12again, being affected by those things.
- 25:14And then that starts to distill into your party attachment.
- 25:17And then coming from the outside is the government actions and the influence of
- 25:22friends.
- 25:23And then those start to feed into campaign activity, media influence, your specific issue
- 25:29opinions, which are and all those are once again affected by your party attachment, your
- 25:35group loyalty, your value orientations, economic structure, social divisions,
- 25:40historical patterns, issue.
- 25:43So it goes into issue opinions then to candidate image, and then those can then be
- 25:48affected by the economic conditions and the political conditions.
- 25:51So not necessarily your specific economic status typically, but what about other outside
- 25:58forces?
- 25:58Maybe you lose your job.
- 26:00Maybe tariffs come in because, obviously, tariffs have now become a big talking point
- 26:07with the Trump administration and then other political conditions coming in.
- 26:13Whether there's a, you know, from maybe where you live, maybe it's not very politically
- 26:19competitive.
- 26:19Maybe it is politically competitive.
- 26:21And then all those things come into your vote.
- 26:26So if you're able to see that on the screen, if if you don't see it on the screen or or you're
- 26:31you're only listening to this, hopefully, that was a reasonably explanatory look at it just to
- 26:41really quick reiterate it to hopefully make that make more sense.
- 26:46Just in this specific example of funnel, this is one of the common examples of a of a funnel
- 26:52of causality you see.
- 26:54At the wide end, economic structure, social divisions, historical patterns, those feed into
- 27:00group loyalty and value orientations, which then feed into your party attachment.
- 27:05And then your party attachment along with government actions and influence of friends
- 27:09then start to feed in and affect the campaign activity and how you perceive the campaign
- 27:15activity, how you perceive the candidates, your issue opinions, the media influence as well,
- 27:21then those suddenly bring in not suddenly, but those then you bring in the political
- 27:27conditions and the economic conditions, and then boom.
- 27:31You've got your vote choice.
- 27:33But once again, that's just one example of a funnel.
- 27:38That's not the only version of the funnel.
- 27:41And it's because as the funnel of causality is a what's ultimately a model of voter behavior,
- 27:47we have a bunch of other models that we can compare as well.
- 27:50These may not necessarily be represented as a funnel, but the funnel is a really good
- 27:55visualization for trying to describe a vote choice.
- 28:00So you have some other examples of voter behavior models as you got the rational choice
- 28:07theory, which assumes that people are all rational actors and analyze costs and benefits
- 28:12of a vote choice, and then they vote accordingly.
- 28:15Retrospective voting, which is quite simply, are you or your group doing well?
- 28:21Usually, Then you if if you are doing well or your group's doing well, then you vote for the
- 28:27current party in power.
- 28:29And if they're not doing well, if you're not doing well, then you vote against the current
- 28:33party in power.
- 28:34So it's this system of rewards and punishments.
- 28:37And then you've got party line voting, which is simply people based or voting based on the
- 28:42level of attachment that they feel to their party.
- 28:44Are they very strongly Republican?
- 28:47Probably gonna vote Republican up and down the ticket.
- 28:49If feel strongly Democratic, they're probably gonna vote Democrat up and down the ticket.
- 28:54In any case, though, whatever model you use, whatever funnel of causality or if you don't
- 28:59use a funnel at all, whatever model you use to explain voter behavior is going to have some
- 29:04sort of shortcoming, and you can't explain 100 of all voting behavior for all people.
- 29:10If we take rational choice, not everyone is rational.
- 29:13Some people don't have great research skills.
- 29:17Campaigns can obfuscate obfuscate their and their opponent's intentions and say, oh, then,
- 29:23you know, my opponent's gonna be trying to kill people or or whatever they try to say to make
- 29:30you not vote for them.
- 29:31See how terrible and evil my campaign opponent is?
- 29:35And then the opponent will say, no.
- 29:36Actually, it's the other guy that's terrible and evil.
- 29:40Retrospective voting.
- 29:42You don't necessarily assume that the party in power is responsible for your your trying to
- 29:50think of the way, not dire state, but your your state of if you're not doing well, you might
- 29:56not necessarily assume that's the majority party in power.
- 30:00You may find that the minority party is what a lot of people, across the political spectrum
- 30:05love to say about the opposition is that they're obstructionist, and the real reason for
- 30:13the group not doing well.
- 30:15Lots of people and lots of people still vote the same way every year even if their economic
- 30:21or social state is not doing well.
- 30:24They still just vote the same way every year.
- 30:28Party line voting does not account for those times when a longtime voter finally, what some
- 30:34might say, quote, unquote, gains a conscience and then votes against their party's nominee or
- 30:39nominees.
- 30:40And it's it's not common, but you do see it every once in a while or, you know, not explain
- 30:45why people decide to sit on the sidelines on a in a given election where they just don't vote
- 30:52at all.
- 30:53And then for the overall funnel of causality, just funnels funnels of causality in general,
- 30:58it doesn't necessarily account for the intensity of how any of these factors impact
- 31:04voting behavior.
- 31:06Maybe your loyalty to your group doesn't really affect your your vote choice, or maybe your
- 31:14economic class doesn't really have as much of an impact as it does for another voter.
- 31:19But you must remember, though, that these are all models, and they are not necessarily meant
- 31:25to describe how every nook and cranny works.
- 31:29They're not necessarily trying to say, oh, this is exactly how it works a % of the time.
- 31:34They're just models for you to try to better visualize why people think and choose the way
- 31:42they do.
- 31:44Now just mentioned them just a moment ago.
- 31:46What about people that don't vote?
- 31:49Now you can have all these factors that are attempting to influence you, what groups you
- 31:54belong to, your social divisions, your economic structure, your even if you have a party or
- 32:01don't have a party, these attempts by these campaigns to try to influence you so that you
- 32:07vote for them or try to get you to sort of activate your biases, so to speak, to make you
- 32:16get up and vote for that candidate.
- 32:20You can have all these things attempting to influence you, but sometimes you might not
- 32:25decide to vote.
- 32:26You might decide to not vote at all, or somebody else might decide not to vote at all.
- 32:32To the best of my knowledge, there is no funnel of causality for nonvoters.
- 32:38But we can look at some of the specific factors in the funnel for some ideas of how nonvoters
- 32:43would distill all those traits into their vote choice or rather lack thereof.
- 32:50So first of all, let's think about some of the reasons people give for why they don't vote.
- 32:56Some people feel they're not informed enough to make a decision, whether they just haven't had
- 33:00the time to research things or they just don't know where to look or just haven't put the
- 33:07effort in.
- 33:08Sometimes they're disgusted with all their vote choices.
- 33:11Now that doesn't necessarily stop people from voting.
- 33:13Some people will vote for, quote, unquote, the lesser of two evils.
- 33:18They might not know an election is happening.
- 33:21Now for those of you who are regularly tuned into politics or at least more than the average
- 33:27person, you might think, how can they not know an election is happening?
- 33:31You'd be surprised.
- 33:32Some people don't know that there's anything other than a presidential election going on, or
- 33:36they think that all elections for offices are happening during a presidential election.
- 33:42Some people don't know that, elections and odd numbered years happen sometimes.
- 33:47Not necessarily.
- 33:49It's not always the case.
- 33:50Some place a lot of places where people live, there are no, elections in odd numbered years.
- 33:55I live in a place that does not have elections in odd numbered years.
- 34:00They're preoccupied with other things in life.
- 34:04You know, it's easy for those of us who are involved in politics for a living, like myself,
- 34:09to say, well, how can they how can they not, you know, get involved in this stuff or or try
- 34:14to research anything?
- 34:16There there's there's some this all this is so important, but a lot of people got a lot of
- 34:21other stuff stuff going on right now.
- 34:23And it it may just take up a lot of their time, and they don't really get invested in politics
- 34:32or they don't know where to look or they just they don't wanna have anything to do with
- 34:36politics because of how dirty and divisive it gets.
- 34:41They don't think their vote will matter whether from a philosophical standpoint or a numerical
- 34:46standpoint.
- 34:47They say, oh, I'm just one in millions of people, or they they think philosophically that
- 34:52just hey.
- 34:52It doesn't matter how many people are are voting.
- 34:54My vote is not gonna matter because people are in office are just gonna do whatever they wanna
- 34:58do, or they just simply don't care about politics.
- 35:03Those are just some some reasons that people would decide not to vote.
- 35:09But now let's take some of those factors and apply them to the funnel of causality.
- 35:13Let's apply them to these let these reasons for nonvoting.
- 35:17So if we look at historical patterns, for example, on that wide end of the funnel, a
- 35:24nonvoter probably rarely or just never votes when they have had the opportunity to in the
- 35:30past.
- 35:31And if that's the case, they probably won't vote this time.
- 35:34If they've had, let's just say, six elections that they could have voted in previously, they
- 35:41didn't vote in any one of them, probably not going to vote this time.
- 35:44Now oh, Barack Obama and Donald Trump have gotten some of those kinds of voters to
- 35:51actually turn out to vote for them in the past, but it's not a common thing.
- 35:56Party attachment.
- 35:57Nonvoters usually don't have a strong party attachment.
- 36:01Those with strong party attachments vote at higher rates than those who do not have strong
- 36:06party attachments.
- 36:08So independents, for example, third parties, but there are still registered Democrats and
- 36:15Republicans, a lot of them that don't turn out to vote.
- 36:18Maybe not necessarily every election, but they will they will maybe only vote every other
- 36:25election or only in certain elections.
- 36:28Media influence.
- 36:29These are people who probably consume little to no political media whatsoever.
- 36:34Campaign activity.
- 36:36They probably have little to no interaction with campaigns.
- 36:39Maybe they're not actually being effectively reaped by campaigns because you have all these
- 36:44campaigns that could spend all these millions and millions of dollars to try to reach people,
- 36:50but they might not have actually there might be a segment of the population that's just not
- 36:55being reached effectively.
- 36:57You can have all this money and spend it spend it all to try to win an election, but it
- 37:02doesn't mean you're spending it effectively.
- 37:04So it may not be on the voters.
- 37:06It may be on the campaigns themselves.
- 37:08Issue opinions.
- 37:09Maybe they these nonvoters have a lot of ambivalence on issues, or they just don't think
- 37:15about them too much because they don't personally they're not personally affected by
- 37:21some of these issues.
- 37:22Maybe it's a foreign policy issue.
- 37:24What if something's going on, like, with the Russian invasion of Ukraine or, Israel and and
- 37:32and Gaza, some voters might say, well, I I don't really care about this because it doesn't
- 37:38personally affect me.
- 37:39That's that's how some voters see it.
- 37:43Influence of family and friends.
- 37:45Many of their family and friends might not be politically involved either, so they see that.
- 37:50They're like, okay.
- 37:50I I don't care either.
- 37:53All sorts of different reasons.
- 37:54And I'm I'm not trying to say that any of them are necessarily wrong or that they're bad or
- 37:59anything like that.
- 38:01It's just some of the reasons that people have for not voting now.
- 38:06Personally, do I think that people should vote?
- 38:08Yeah.
- 38:08But I I used to be one of these people who was more like, if you don't vote, you don't have a
- 38:15right to complain.
- 38:17Not really like that anymore.
- 38:19There's a lot of reasons why people don't vote.
- 38:21A lot of complexity.
- 38:22And, I they may care a lot about these things going on, but they don't feel like they're
- 38:27qualified to make a decision, for example, or they just have a lot of other stuff going on in
- 38:33life, and they really haven't had the time to research what's going on in politics.
- 38:37And especially today with with everything that goes on, not just with with AI, but, campaigns
- 38:46in general trying to obfuscate what's what's really going on or what their candidates think.
- 38:54Sometimes it's it's just really hard for these people to really sift through these nonvoters
- 38:59to sift through all the crap and say, okay.
- 39:02This is what's actually happening.
- 39:06So there's all sorts of reasons why people have or that's all sorts of reasons that people have
- 39:11for not voting that, you know, you we should be a little bit more empathetic to.
- 39:19Not not not for everybody, but for some people, that is the case.
- 39:24But in any case, why should you care about the funnel of causality?
- 39:29Why is it important for you to know?
- 39:32It's because too often, we don't try to understand where people who think and choose
- 39:37differently than us, where they're coming from.
- 39:41You hear it all the time.
- 39:42People are these kinds of people are stupid.
- 39:44They're misguided.
- 39:45They're selfish.
- 39:46They're evil.
- 39:47All these negative characteristics that we assign to them, people that we don't even know.
- 39:53And it happens to all of us.
- 39:54A lot of us are like that.
- 39:56So conceptualizing the this funnel of causality may help us to understand why others think the
- 40:02way they think, and we might become more empathetic because we, quite frankly, could use
- 40:07a lot more empathy in politics these days.
- 40:10And Republican, Democrat, independent, third party, we we all could deal with a little bit
- 40:16more understanding of each other because we all have our own biases to contend with that
- 40:21impacts how we think.
- 40:22None of us are 100% completely independent in our thinking.
- 40:27We we should strive to be.
- 40:28We should push as hard as we can to be as independent in our thinking we possibly can be
- 40:35regardless of whether we're we're a Democrat, Republican, independent, third party, no party,
- 40:42whatever the case may be.
- 40:45We should strive to be completely independent in our thinking.
- 40:48But even when we don't realize it, we have mitigating factors, some of those general group
- 40:57characteristics that impact how we think, and then some of the more individual based factors
- 41:04that affect how we think.
- 41:07So really each one of us has our own funnel of causality.
- 41:12Even when we might have similar characteristics like our economic background, our typical
- 41:19voting patterns, how we perceive those things through our personal lens can differ.
- 41:24Maybe you have two different people that are from a middle class neighborhood, and they both
- 41:34have voted the same party each time.
- 41:37Maybe they're both democrats or maybe they're both republicans.
- 41:41But in one election, they actually vote differently.
- 41:47One continues to vote democratic when they voted democratic before.
- 41:51Maybe the other democrat decided, for whatever reason, they're gonna vote republican this
- 41:55time.
- 41:55Same thing if you've got two republicans from a middle class neighborhood, and they both voted
- 42:01Republican the whole time, but then one of them decides in this election, actually, I'm gonna
- 42:05vote Democrat this time.
- 42:07There's all sorts of reasons reasons they might do that.
- 42:10There's we all have different capabilities in researching candidates and issues, which can
- 42:16impact how any of these funnel factors impact us.
- 42:20The campaign activity might have a lot more impact on somebody who is not as well versed in
- 42:28how to research things.
- 42:29They just hear what the campaign tells them, and they just take it at face value.
- 42:33Some funnel factors will have less impact on some people than others.
- 42:38Example, your party attachment.
- 42:40If you don't have a party at all, well, although you do have some of those independents
- 42:46who lean Republican or lean Democrat that are more Democratic or Republican than they might
- 42:51think they are, but then you also have Democrats and Republicans who are registered as
- 42:56such, but they don't really feel that strongly attached to their party.
- 43:01Your the influence of your family and friends, maybe you don't find them as influential.
- 43:07If if your family, you know, some some some children, they'll just follow what their
- 43:13parents told them because they that's what their parents told them.
- 43:16Some kids will be very rebellious and go the opposite way just to rebel against their
- 43:23parents.
- 43:25All sorts of different things.
- 43:28So all these the the funnel of causality may look a lot different for each one of us.
- 43:34So just remember, there is no one true funnel of causality because there's gonna be different
- 43:40funnels and models of voting behavior that can help explain different people.
- 43:45So just something to keep in mind.
- 43:47In short, it's it's not necessarily important.
- 43:52You don't need to know specifically the ex even if there was a true funnel, regardless of
- 43:59whether there was a true funnel, you don't need to necessarily know exactly how it works.
- 44:03You just need to have a general sense of how all these factors, both group oriented and
- 44:09individual oriented, come in and affect somebody's vote choice because it's once again,
- 44:17it's about empathy and understanding where people are coming from.
- 44:20And and all of us can fall short in that regard, but just try to be a little bit more
- 44:27understanding of why people think the way they do.
- 44:30Doesn't mean you can't debate with them or or say that they're they're wrong or you can't
- 44:34can't call out people or anything like that.
- 44:37But it's just something to keep in mind because none of us have all the answers.
- 44:42All of us are are contending with our own biases.
- 44:47And some people don't really try to look past those biases, but some of us do.
- 44:52In any case, we all should try to understand people a little bit more.
- 44:56But in any case, that is today's episode on the funnel of causality.
- 45:03So once again, as always, to all of you, thank you so much for listening, watching.
- 45:11Please like, comment, subscribe, share the podcast with all the people you know.
- 45:17Help this channel grow, help this this whole thing I'm trying to do with striving to be as
- 45:24nonpartisan as possible and try to be as informed as as possible.
- 45:29Help that help spread that message, help spread the word about the podcast and all my other
- 45:34work.
- 45:35Speaking of which, in the show notes, Facebook, LinkedIn, my educational email course.
- 45:42It's about a series of six emails about mistakes we make when trying to depolarize
- 45:51politics, why we make those mistakes, and how we can go about correcting those mistakes.
- 45:58Because sometimes when we try to depolarize politics, we actually make it worse.
- 46:02And I talk about some of those reasons.
- 46:04My book, why independents rarely win elections and how they become more competitive.
- 46:11And I'll also link my original article about the funnel of causality on medium down below as
- 46:17well.
- 46:18But that's gonna do it for today's episode.
- 46:20So as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 46:23And until next time, take care.