Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / When She Tried to Leave
Transcript
- Nicholle: This episode discusses alleged domestic abuse, stalking, threats, sexual coercion, mental health, and suicide. Please take care while listening. Zalle: Imagine your sister shows up at your house because her marriage has become too much to handle. You let her stay. You think she's somewhere safe. Then her husband starts calling. He says he's coming to get her. And during a 9-1-1 call in November 2022, her sister reports something chilling. He's coming over armed and ready. But there's a six year old child in the house, and this is only the beginning. Over the months that follow, allegations of harassment, tracking, and escalating conflict will emerge. Then in april 2024 the woman at the center of this story will be found dead. But to understand how we got there, we need to go back to the relationship and the warning signs people say they saw along the way. Welcome back to Coffee and Crime Mom. I'm Zalle. Nicholle: And I'm Nicholle, aka mom. And today, oof, this case has allegations Zalle: has allegations. Nicholle: of control, harassment, tracking, and a relationship that took a deeply disturbing turn. Zalle: And trust me, the more you learn about what was happening behind closed doors, the more questions you're gonna have. So grab your coffee as you have. Nicholle: So grab your coffee because we have a lot to talk about. Zalle: Don't forget to like, subscribe, and leave us a review. Now let's get into it. We're starting in November 2022, more than a year before the woman's death became a national story. She was married to a pastor at Solid Rock Church in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. By this point, according to accounts from the family and the 9-1-1 records later made public, the relationship was already experiencing serious conflict. the wife went to stay with her sister, Sierra Frances, in Gaffney, South Carolina. This wasn't just a visit where everybody was hanging out and catching up. She was trying to get some distance from the situation at home. And what happened next is important because these weren't stories that only surfaced after her death. Her sister was calling 911 at the time. Nicholle: That distinction matters. People can look at a relationship after a tragedy and interpret everything through what they know happened later. But a call to 911 gives us a record of what someone was reporting while the situation was unfolding. It doesn't automatically prove every allegation, but it means the concerns weren't all invented years afterwards. Zalle: It doesn't automatically prove but it means the But it means the concerns weren't all increased in years On november 16th, 2022, Sierra contacted 911 after receiving messages that caused her to fear her sister's husband, John Paul Miller, JP, the pastor, might come to her home to retrieve her sister, Mica Miller. The situation continued into the early hours of november 17th, when another call was made. In the reported messages, the husband threatened to come to the house and used the words armed and ready. Nicholle: In the recorded messages, the husband threatened to come to the house and the world's arm and ready. Sierra described being worried about what might happen if she showed up. There was a young child in the house, which had another layer of fear. Zalle: Sierra described being worried about what might happen if he showed up. There was a young child in the home, which added another layer of fear. The accounts surrounding those calls describe arguments over Mica staying with her sister, what would happen to Mica's belongings, and whether JP would come to the property despite Sierra's objections. The reported messages included threats to put Mica's belongings outside, take them to Goodwill, leave them at Sierra's property. Other messages were described as threatening consequences if the family didn't cooperate. And according to the count of that night, the family was worried enough to ask police to check on Nicholle: And according to account that the family is worried enough has to do to check. Zalle: the situation. Nicholle: And I want to pause on something. If your adult sister comes to your house because she needs space from her marriage, that should be a moment where you can give her somewhere to breathe. But when the conflict follows her to the place where she's trying to feel safe, now the entire family is being pulled into it. Zalle: Right. And the concern wasn't simply that two married people were arguing, it was the reported escalation. The messages, the possibility of an armed confrontation, and the fear that someone might arrive at the house. We also need to be precise here. The 911 calls document concerns and reports made by the people involved. They do not establish that every threat was carried out and no one should Treat a dispatch recording as a court's final determination of guilt. But they do establish that Mica's family was raising concerns about the conflict in November of 2022. And there's another detail in the broader timeline. On November 28, 2022, police responded To Wacama mental health during a separate incident involving Mica and JP. Accounts of that incident describe concerns about whether Mica was able to speak freely while officers were present and whether she was able to enter the facility without interference. We will come back to that because it becomes part of the larger picture of Mica's attempts to get help and the concerns raised by people around her. Nicholle: And already we're talking about several different things. A family member calling police, a mental health-related incident, and a relationship that people close to Mica later described as controlling. Those are related pieces of a timeline, but we shouldn't smash them together and pretend one proves the other. We have to look at each event and ask what the records actually say. Zalle: Absolutely. And as we go through this, we're gonna keep doing that. We'll tell you what was reported and what was documented and what remains an allegation. Because to understand why this case has continued to raise questions, we have to understand who Mica was before the public knew her name. Mica was 30 years old when she died in April 2024. To people outside her community, she might have been known primarily as the wife of a pastor, but that description doesn't tell us much about her as a person. Mica was involved in the life of Solid Rock Church in Myrtle Beach. She was known as a singer and worship leader, and she had a role in the church community. She also worked as an assistant to JP. People who knew her described someone who was friendly and welcoming. She developed friendships with people in the congregation, and some of those friendships would later become important because they were among the relationships in which Mica reportedly spoke about what was happening in her marriage. Nicholle: And that is something I think gets lost when a story becomes about a marriage, a pastor, and a death. The person at the center becomes a collection of allegations and dates. But Mica had a life. She had relationships with people who knew her outside of being somebody's wife. Zalle: She relationship with Jordan outside of being somebody. Right, exactly. And her singing was a huge part of that life. It was something people associated with her, something she did in front of her church community. The relationship between Mica and JP also had a history that was more complicated than a simple story of two people meeting and getting married. Reporting on their relationship describes Mica. As having known JP through the church when she was younger, about 13 years old. Their relationship later developed amid the breakdown of their previous marriages. Accounts of the timeline say John Paul's first marriage was still in the picture during the period when his relationship with Mica was developing. JP reportedly officiated Mica's first wedding. Later after both had gone through changes in their previous relationships, Mica and JP married in twenty seventeen. Nicholle: a reporting. Zalle: And there's a reported age difference between them, 15 years. And the relationship developed within the church community where JP held the position of religious authority. Now let's be clear, an age gap alone does not establish abuse being a pastor does not establish that someone is abusive. And the beginning of relationship, even when it's complicated, doesn't prove what happened behind closed doors years later. What matters is how the relationship reportedly developed and what Mica's friends and family later said about her experiences within it. Nicholle: Because you can have a relationship that looks one way to people outside of it and feels completely different to the person living in it. And when the relationship is connected to a church, that can add another layer. People may see a couple as a spiritual example. They may trust the person standing at the pulpit. They may feel that questioning what's happening privately is the same as questioning their faith. And that is a tricky situation. And that is why it is important that he was the pastor of a church. Zalle: It is important that he was the pastor of a church. Right. And that she was so young when she first met him. And that doesn't Nicholle: And then she was so young when she first met him. Zalle: mean that everyone at the church knew what was happening or that every person around the couple ignored warning signs. We cannot make that assumption. But Mica's position in that community is important. Her marriage and her faith were intertwined with her daily life, her work, her friendships, and her public identity. When friends later described concerns about the marriage, they weren't describing a relationship that existed in isolation from everything else. They were describing a relationship connected to the community where Mica spent much of her time. And some of those friends began noticing things they found concerning. One of the most revealing parts of this case comes from people who said they became close to Mica and heard about the marriage directly from her. One of those people was Charlotte Korn. Nicholle: Corne described becoming friends with Mica through Saw the Black Church. As their friendship developed, she said she became concerned about the rules and restrictions Mica described in her everyday One example involved something as ordinary as making Korn involved that Mica had told her not to call before 11 in the morning unless Mica contacted her first, according to Zalle: Korn described becoming friends with Mica through Solid Rock Church. As their friendship developed, she said she became concerned about the rules and restrictions Mica described in her everyday life. One example involved something as ordinary as making a phone call. Korn recalled that Mica had told her not to call before 11 in the morning unless Mica contacted her first. According to Korn, Mica explained that JP didn't like it when she got out of bed before him. Think about that for a second. We're not talking about a complicated financial decision or an argument about moving across the country. We're talking about what time a friend could call. Nicholle: And if somebody says, Don't Zalle: And if somebody says though Nicholle: call me before eleven because my husband doesn't like me getting out of bed before him, I'd have questions. Because why does somebody else's preference determine whether you can have a conversation with your friend? Wait, let's not even start there. Why does somebody else's preference determine when you can get out of the bed? Zalle: Why does somebody else's breakfast for when you when you get out of bed? When you can get out of when you can wake rise and shine in the morning. That makes absolutely no sense. Nicholle: That is a great example of why I made it through one episode of that documentary. Because I was so pissed off by the first episode I said, Zalle's gonna have to finish this one because I I'm ready to find him. Yeah. Zalle: Yeah. On its own, one household's morning routine doesn't tell us everything about a relationship, though in this specific situation, is very eye opening. Couples do have different routines, but Korn described this as part of a wider pattern, not an isolated preference. She also described Mica's time away from home being restricted. According to Korn, Mica was not supposed to be gone for longer than about three hours. Insane. Korn described JP calling after Mica had been away for roughly two hours, then calling again after shorter interviews as the time for Mica to return approached. Extremely controlling. Korn said that if Mica wasn't home when he wanted her home, he might show up. That is a much more specific allegation than simply saying someone was jealous. It describes repeated contact, pressure around time, and the possibility that an ordinary outing could turn into a confrontation if Mica didn't return when expected. Yeah, that's controlling as hell. Nicholle: Wow. And I want people to understand why that can become exhausting. I already understand. Imagine you're trying to spend time with a friend, but instead of being present, you're watching the clock. You know Zalle: Yeah. Imagine to spend time on the frame, but instead of being present watching live. You know Nicholle: a call is coming. Then another call comes. You're thinking about how you're going to explain yourself, whether somebody's going to show up and what that and what the consequences will be when you get home. You're technically out of the house, but you're not actually free to enjoy being out of the house. Zalle: thinking about how you're going to explain yourself whether somebody's to show what that and what the consequences can be when you hope. You're technically out of the house. But you're not actually free to enjoy being out of the house. Yeah, that's concerning. That's the concern these accounts raise. People sometimes imagine controlling behavior as one dramatic incident, but it can also be a pattern that takes over ordinary decisions. When you sleep, when you leave, who you see, how long you stay, and whether you can relax without anticipating someone else's reaction. In discussions of domestic abuse, this can fall under the broader concept of coercive control. That term describes a pattern of behavior used to restrict another person's independence, choices, and sense of safety. It isn't a diagnosis of either person, and using the term doesn't establish a legal finding in this case. But it gives us a way to understand why friends might be concerned about a series of behaviors that could otherwise be dismissed one by one. Though I probably would have been like, Hey, is you cool? Like we need Yeah. Do you need us to go talk to him? Nicholle: You alright? You can come to my house. Zalle: 'Cause I will go. Nicholle: In a second. And if you're the friend watching it happen, you might not immediately know what to call it. You might just know that your friend seems stressed, that she can't stay out, that she keeps checking her phone, or that she has to explain every little thing. You might notice that she has less time for you than she used to, and you may wonder whether she's choosing not to see you when there could be pressure behind that decision. Zalle: In a second. And if you're the friend watching it after you, you might not immediately know what's called. You might just know that your friend seems stressed, that she can't stay out, that she keeps checking her phone, or that she has to explain every little thing. You might notice that she has less time for you than she used to. And you may wonder whether she's choosing not to see you, when there could be pressure behind that decision. Yeah, that's a horrible spot for either one to be in. Nicholle: And then Michael's case, friends later described concerns that may be on Zalle: And in Mica's case, friends later described concerns that went beyond phone calls and time away from home. They described allegations involving jealousy, accusation about her friendships, and pressure surrounding her personal life. Korn said JP accused Mica of having an affair with her friend. According to accounts published about the case, this was part of a wider pattern of suspicion and repeated contact when Mica was spending time with other people. Again, these are accounts from people who knew Mica, not a court's final determination about every event. But they help explain why the relationship was being described as increasingly restrictive. And then there are the allegations about sexual pressure, which are among the most disturbing part of this story. Nicholle: Again, these are accounts for people who remain like her, not a for final determination about everything. But they help explain why the relationship is being described as increasingly restrictive. And then there are the allegations about sexual oppression, which are among the most disturbing Zalle: Another friend, Bruna Pabin, described conversations in which Mica reportedly spoke about the sexual expectations in her marriage. Pabin said Mica told her that JP expected sex multiple times a day, reportedly as often as four times daily, first of all. Excuse me. Yeah. She also said that when Mica said no, he would allegedly keep her awake or interfere with her sleep. Yeah, he's a sociopath. He's he's he's a weirdo. Yeah. These are serious allegations. Nicholle: has time. Yeah. She also said that when Michael was allegedly she thought a week or an interfere with her season. Yeah, he thinks he's saying she's a he's crazy. Yeah. These are serious allegations. Zalle: they are not part of the federal indictments two charges, and we should not present them as facts established by a criminal verdict. They are accounts attributed to Mica's friend and reported publicly. But they deserve to be discussed directly because they describe an alleged dynamic involving consent pressure and the ability to say no within a marriage. Which for one, men who are in the world who do not understand that because you get married, your wife does not become your property. So no still means no in case you didn't process that. Let me just throw that out there. Nicholle: And we wanna be really clear right there because being married does not mean you lose the right to say no. It doesn't matter if you've been together for two months or twenty years. It doesn't matter if one person believes sex is an important part of a marriage. Nobody is entitled to another person's body. Period. Zalle: Been together for two months, it doesn't matter if one person believes sex is an important part of the life. Nobody is entitled to another person's concept here. Ever. Ever. Pavin also described Mica telling friends that she had taken testosterone at JP's encouragement in an effort to increase her sex drive. Yes. According to these accounts, Mica was distressed that the treatment affected her singing voice, making it lower or raspier. Because Mica was known for singing. That reported change mattered to her personally. It wasn't simply an abstract side effect. It affected something she valued, something that was part of her identity in the church community. We need to be careful not to make medical claims beyond what the sources establish. We also cannot independently establish every private conversation that was portrayed. Nicholle: not everything in the established every private conversation that report Zalle: r that was reported by a friend. What we can say is that people close to Mica described her as having talked about pressure around sex and about taking testosterone, with concerns about the effect on her voice. And that in itself is insane because women should not be just taking testosterone. Nicholle: that was recorded by a friend. What we can say is that people closely might have described her as having talks about pressure on sex and about taking pest prosperous, with concerns about the sex course, that in itself is mistaken that women should taking that prosperous. And what stands out to me is the difference between choosing something for yourself and feeling like you have to do something to meet another person's demands. If somebody wants to seek medical advice about their own sex drive, that's their decision. But if the reason is that they're being pressured to meet someone else's expectations, that raises a very different concern. That is that is control. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Somebody to speak medical advice about their own sex drive, that's their decision. But if the reason is that they're being pressured to meet someone else's expectations, that raises a very different concern. Mm-hmm. That is that is control. At the highest form. Yeah. Off with his head. Pap Pabin also made allegations about sexual situations involving unhoused men. Excuse me? According to her account, Mica said JP had paid men experiencing homelessness to engage in sexual acts involving Mica against her will, including unwanted touching and other degrading acts. If you hire a homeless person to come and give me bum bumps. Sis, sis, let's go. What do you have to think about as a to hire homeless people to come and touch on me. Nicholle: Sis, sis, let's start here. What do you have to think of me as a person to hire a homeless man? Multiple homeless men. What kind of okay. Zalle: Those are exceptionally serious claims and we are not gonna dress them up as proven facts. They are allegations relayed by a friend who said Mica disclosed them to her. They have not been established by a criminal conviction in the case we're discussing, but we also aren't gonna skip over them simply because they're disturbing. If a person is being pressured or coerced into sexual activity, that is not made acceptable by marriage or religious beliefs or a partner's expectations and there is no reason for it to be acceptable for nobody to pay homeless people to come touch you and do things that you don't want them to do to you. All of that is a big fuck no. Nicholle: Absolutely. And the fact that these allegations are uncomfortable doesn't mean we should pretend they weren't reported. It means we should be careful about how we talk about them. There is a difference between telling listeners what a friend said, Mica disclosed, and announcing that we personally know every detail happened exactly that way. We're doing the first, not the second. Zalle: difference between telling listeners what a friend said might have disclosed and announcing that we personally know every detail happened exactly that way. We're doing the first, not the second. That's exactly the line we need to hold. Reporting about the case has also described public sermons in which JP spoke about sexual expectations within a marriage in stark religious terms. And I if you have seen the documentary he does it so all it is sickening. Nicholle: He does it so much. Zalle: And the fact that these people are just sitting in the church like, hmm, yeah, yeah. Nicholle: I mean it's so I get that pastors might talk about that kind of stuff, but it's like it's right. And it's like he is so in Zalle: No, what he was saying it happens over and over and over Nicholle: it happens over and over and these are this is not one or two sermons where he's doing this. He was. Zalle: He was extremely degrading and disrespectful when he spoke about the women, period. Friends say they believe those views were used to pressure Mica, which I am sure that they were, especially with the age difference and the fact that she met him in the church. A person right. A person's religious beliefs by themselves don't prove abuse. Nicholle: Right. And he's the pastor. Right. A person's religious beliefs by themselves don't be Zalle: But when a person allegedly uses religious authority or ideas about what a godly wife must do to pressure a partner into sex, it's one Nicholle: is one Zalle: sickening. Nicholle: second, but it also raises serious questions about the second power or sex. And this is where the religious setting matters. Not because faith itself is the problem, but because beliefs can be used to support a person or they can be used to pressure someone into surrendering their own values. That is exactly what they Zalle: But it also raises serious questions about consent and power because what is happening here? And this is where the religious setting matters, not because faith itself is the problem, but because beliefs can be used to support a person or they can be used to pressure someone into surrendering their own boundaries. And that is exactly what he was doing. Nicholle: and for someone who is deeply connected to their faith, That pressure can be especially complicated. If they're being told that disagreeing with their spouse means they're failing spiritually, it can become much harder to separate what they believe from what another person is demanding of them. And this is a very specific case, but that happens all the time in a church. People will follow that man, usually a man, it could be a woman, that is standing up there telling them things because they warp and use the scripture to turn it into things that Zalle: is demanding. And this is a very specific case, but they have to all the time. Yeah. In a church. People will follow that man, usually a man, it could be a woman, that is standing up there telling them things because they work and use the scripture to turn it into things that give them power or give them access to something. Mm. And this is more disturbing because it is her husband. Nicholle: give them power or give them access to something. And this is more disturbing because it is her husband. Zalle: Yeah. They're just doing what works for them so they could get what they want. Abuse of power at its highest. But the point is not that we can look at someone else's marriage from the outside and know everything about it because obviously you cannot. The point is that multiple people who knew Mica described troubling behavior and those descriptions are part of the public record of how this relationship was understood by people close to her. And as Mica's marriage began to unravel, the conflict wasn't limited to what friends say happened privately. There were also police contacts, reports about her vehicle, and attempts to separate. So Very toxic. By 2023, Mica and JP's relationship was breaking down. Mica filed for divorce in October of 2023. The legal process and separation did not immediately end the conflict, and the timeline shows that the relationship continued to involve disputes and contact. Divorce filings can be complicated. People can file, reconsider, amend their plans, or continue living with uncertainty. while they work out the next steps. So we should not reduce this to a simple story where one filing tells us everything about what Mica wanted at every point. What we can say is that she had taken a formal step toward ending the marriage and the conflict continued into 2024. Nicholle: Right, because leaving a relationship isn't always one clean moment. People may leave and return. They may have financial concerns, emotional ties, fear, religious pressure, family pressure are practical issues that make the process more complicated. From the outside, people sometimes ask, why didn't she just leave? But that question assumes leaving is always straightforward and safe. Zalle: Family pressure or parts of the question that they can process. From the outside, I would sometimes ask, Why didn't she just leave? But that question assumes leaving is always straightforward and safe. And it is not. We can't know every reason Mica made each decision. But the timeline makes clear that she was dealing with a complicated separation. Nicholle: Separation and people around her for reporting concerns about the collection. In February 2024, Michael was involuntarily hospitalized, following a police related decision. According accounts of the period described by her being L for evaluation and labels raising concerns about the circumstances. When she was released, there were also questions about her view in the office. Zalle: And people around her were reporting concerns about the relationship. In February 2024, Mica was involuntarily hospitalized following a police-related incident. accounts of the period describe her being held for evaluation and later raising concerns about the circumstances. When she was released, there were also questions about her vehicle and belongings. Publicly reported records say she later told police that she believed JP had arranged for her hospitalization improperly and that her car had been taken while she was hospitalized. Those were her reported concerns. They are not proved by themselves that every suspected action occurred as she believed it had, but they are important because they show that Mica was raising concerns about her circumstances and trying to have them addressed. And I'm not at all trying to say that I don't believe anything that she's saying because clearly Nicholle: They're not proved by themselves that every suspected action occurs and didn't. But they are improved because they show that Michael is raising concerns about certain things and trying to have them addressed. And I'm not at all trying to say that I don't believe anything that she's saying, that's cool. Mm-hmm. Zalle: I mean Nicholle: Yeah, yeah, definitely. And mental health crises can make a situation even harder to understand from the outside. someone may genuinely need support and they can also have legitimate concerns about how other people are treating them. Those things are not mutually exclusive. A mental health diagnosis or hospitalization doesn't automatically mean someone is wrong about everything they report. Zalle: Right. And it would be irresponsible to use Mica's mental health history to dismiss what she said or what her family reported just because she has stuff going on does not mean that she she she's invalid or untrustworthy. Nicholle: That's right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: The record also needs to be treated carefully in the other direction though. We cannot infer that every concern she had was verified simply because she was in distress. We have to examine each event separately. Then in March 2024, another incident involving her vehicle brought her into contact with police. Mica reported damage to a tire and expressed concern about what had happened. She also raised suspicions about being tracked. Nicholle: Every concern she had was verified simply because she wasn't distressed. We had the examining each company separately. Then in March 2024, another incident involved brought her into contact with police. Michael reported damage to a type and expressed concern about what happened. She also raised suspicions about being tracked. these concerns became especially significant nature from federal prosecutors which I think of price detection based on her deal and that her tires had been damaged as part of the course of conduct directly after what? Then his punishment Zalle: these concerns became especially significant later when federal prosecutors alleged that tracking devices had been placed on her vehicle and that her tires had been damaged as part of a course of conduct directed at her. What? The man his punishment. was I'm slashing your Nicholle: was sweaty. Zalle: tires. The the later indictment gives the allegations a formal legal context, but the indictment is still an accusation, not a verdict. Nicholle: Right. The the later indictment gives the allegations a formal legal practice, but the indictment is still an accusation out of that. And that distinction matters because when we know what prosecutors eventually alleged, it's tempting to go back and say every earlier fear was automatically confirmed. We shouldn't do that. We can say the earlier reports are consistent with the concerns that later became part of the federal case, Zalle: Because because when we know what prosecutors eventually allege, it's tempting to go back and say every earlier fear was automatically compared. We shouldn't do that. We can say the earlier reports are consistent with the concerns that later became part of the federal case, Nicholle: but the legal case has to establish the charged conduct through evidence. Zalle: But the legal case has to establish the charged conduct through Right. By this point the story had moved far beyond a marriage that was simply ending. Mica was trying to separate. Friends had described alleged control and sexual pressure. Police contacts had occurred. There were reports concerning her vehicle and concerns about tracking. But we still haven't reached the event that brought Mica's name to national attention. That happened in April 2024 Mica was still estranged from JP and the divorce process was ongoing. On april 25th JP was served with separation related legal papers, according to the timeline reported in the case. Two days later, on april 27th Mica died at Lumber River State Park in Robeson County, North Carolina. Nicholle: two thousand twenty-four, Michael was still estranged from Day P the divorce process was on. On April twenty fifth, Jacob was searched with separation related legal to the timeline for the fortune case. Two days later, on April twenty second, Michael died at Lumber River State Park in Rhodeson County, New York. Zalle: She was 30 years old. Authorities ruled her death a suicide. That official finding is important. Mica's death has been the subject of public speculation, questions, and intense debate, The federal indictment concerns alleged cyber stalking and false statements to investigators. Nicholle: That official findings is important. My goodness has been the subject of public speculation, questions, and instantly, but we are not going The federal indictment concerns alleged stopping and false statements and investigators. If it's Zalle: It does not charge JP Miller with causing Mica's death. Nicholle: not charged, JP Lower probably not be there. Zalle: She the concern she and the Nicholle: And I think we need to make room for two things at once. We can respect the official ruling about how Mica died and still take seriously the concerns she and people around her have reported before her death. Those aren't contradictory positions. Zalle: No, they're not. And the timeline of Mica's final day has been pieced together using surveillance footage, records, and her own 911 call. On the morning of April 27th, she was seen leaving and returning to her residence. Later at approximately 11:38 AM, she left again. At about 12:12 p.m., Mica entered Dick's pawn shop in Myrtle Beach. She purchased a firearm and ammunition and left around 12:34 PM. She then traveled north away from Myrtle Beach, surveillance and other records, placed her vehicle along Highway 501 and later near a convenience store in Mullins, North Carolina. She left that store at approximately 1:35. Those details help establish the route and timeline. They do not on their own. Tell us everything Mica was thinking or feeling at each moment. We should not pretend we can reconstruct her internal experience from a series of timestamps. Nicholle: And that's important. When we look at a timeline after a death, every stop can start to feel like a clue that explains everything. But we don't actually know what a person was thinking just because we know where they were or where they went. We can describe what the records show without claiming to know what was going through her mind. Zalle: describe director show without needing to know what At approximately 2:54 p.m., Mica called 911 from the area of Lumber River State Park. During the call, she asked whether Dispatch could determine her location through her phone. She then told the dispatcher that she was about to kill herself and wanted her family to know where to find her. That's extremely heartbreaking. The dispatcher attempted to obtain information and determine her location, and the call ended. Nicholle: The dispatcher attempted to obtain information to determine her location in the parking lot. Authorities were sent to the area to locate Michael was later found dead at the park. Her death was officially ruled a suicide. the situation. The call is submitted because it documents her own words emergency response. Zalle: Authorities were sent to the area to locate her. Mica was later found dead at the park. Her death was officially ruled a suicide. The call is significant because it documents her own words and the emergency response that followed. Nicholle: And when we talk about suicide, we need to remember that a person is more than the circumstances of their death. Mica had a life before that call. She had relationships, interests, a voice, and people who loved her. Her final day is part of her story, but it is not the entirety of who she was. Acting like a dev for an Zalle: Interest of a voice in people who loved her. Her final day is part of her story, but it is not the entirety of who she was. Exactly. After Mica's death, her family and friends continued raising questions about what she had experienced in the relationship. The public attention grew and people began examining earlier incidents, the separation, her reports to police, and the circumstances surrounding her death. But even as public speculation grew, the distinction remained. Officials ruled her death a suicide and JP was not charged with causing it. The question of whether alleged harassment occurred before her death became a separate legal matter, and that case would eventually lead to a federal indictment. Before we get there though, we need to talk about what happened in the immediate aftermath of Mica's death. The day after Mica died, He announced her death near the end of a sermon and described it as self inflicted. The announcement and the circumstances around it drew strong reactions from people who had followed the case. Some questioned the way the news was delivered. Others focused on statements JP made publicly and how those statements compared with what Mica's family and friends were saying. But public reaction was Even when it's intense is not proof of criminal conduct. Nicholle: And we have to be careful with the way we discuss somebody's behavior after a death. People Zalle: What we can examine are specific statements in Nicholle: react to grief differently. A public statement might strike one person as cold, another person as inappropriate, and another is simply unfamiliar. What we can examine are specific statements and documented actions. We shouldn't treat somebody's demeanor as proof that they caused a death. Yeah. Zalle: fact that we shouldn't treat somebody demeanor as to do that they cause defense. Yeah, because we have learned the hard way. That it's very hard to determine how people should act. But we're not gonna diagnose JP or claim we know what he felt 'cause we don't. We can describe what he said publicly and explain why people challenged his account or raised questions. At the same time, Mica's family and friends were trying to process a death that came after a difficult separation and a period of reported conflict. For them, the official ruling Did not erase the concerns they had about the relationship. And as the public learned more about the earlier police contacts and allegations from friends, the story became about more than the initial announcement. It became a question on whether Mica's reported experiences before her death had been adequately investigated and whether the con the conduct alleged by her family and friends would ever be addressed through the legal system. That brings us to the federal case. And I'm dropping shit. Mind your business. On December eighteenth, two thousand twenty-five, a federal grand jury indicted John Paul Miller on two charges. Cyberstalking and making false statements to federal investigators. This is a significant development because it moves some of the allegations into a formal criminal case. But it is equally important to understand what the indictment does and does not say. The indictment alleges that beginning in november 2022 and continuing until Mica's death in April 2024, JP engaged in unwanted and harassing conduct toward his estranged wife. According to the Justice Department, the alleged conduct included repeated unwanted communications, contact with Mica more than fifty times in a single day, the posting of a nude photograph of her online without her consent. Tracking devices placed on her vehicle, interference with her finances and daily activities, and damage to her vehicle's tires. These are allegations made by federal prosecutors. They are not all separate criminal counts in the indictment, And they have not all been proven in court. I just want to let you know. This is giving it gives into the statement that we be talking about how dangerous there's nothing more dangerous than a man who wants X, Y, and Z because the lens that you go through. Nicholle: Yeah. Yeah, definitely. So let's unpack that because cyber stalking can sound like a vague internet term. The indictment is alleging a course of conduct, not just one unpleasant text message. It's alleging repeated unwanted contact and other actions that prosecutors say were part of a pattern directed at Mica. Zalle: Insane. Nicholle: The poor woman. Zalle: The alleged volume of contact is one example, fifty times in a day. The Justice Department says the indictment describes an instance in which JP contacted Mica more than fifty times in a single day. Obviously that number is striking, but the legal issue isn't simply whether a person sent all of the messages. The case must establish the conduct alleged in the indictment and prove the elements of the charged offense. The indictment also alleges that a nude photograph of Mica was posted online without her consent. that is an extremely serious allegation because intimate images can be used to humiliate, threaten, or control someone. We should not reproduce image, describe it in unnecessary detail, or treat it as sensational material. Nicholle: that is an extremely serious allegation because intimate images can be used to humiliate, threaten, or control something. We should not reproduce image, described it in unnecessary detail or treated as sensational and fear. The relevant allegation is that prosecutors say he was posted without her consent as part of the alleged course process. And consent law are lawsuit. Zalle: The relevant allegation is that prosecutors say it was posted without her consent as part of the alleged course of conduct. Sounds like a mo a monster, just a little boy. Nicholle: He does. He seems like just a evil little boy. And consent matters here too. Being married to someone does not mean you give them permission to share Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: private images of you with other people. You are still your own person in every way. Zalle: And it does not. are sealed up. Yes. Another allegation concerns tracking devices on Mica's vehicle. That is some crazy shit. Okay. This is particularly relevant Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: because Mica had raised concerns about being tracked before her death. But let's be precise. The fact that Mica reported a concern at an earlier point and the fact that prosecutors later alleged tracking are two separate pieces of information, though they Nicholle: Then Michael reported concerns earlier and effective prosecutors later alleged tracking deputy Zalle: do, you know. Nicholle: speaking, so they do the prosecution still has to prove the case as well. The indictment also alleges interference with Michael's finances and daily activities. That connects to the broader concerns friends have described about restrictions on the time, contact and independence. Zalle: Go together. The prosecution still has to prove its case, as always. The indictment also alleges interference with Mica's finances and daily activities. That connects to the broader concerns friends had described about restrictions on her time, contact, and independence, although the federal charges must be evaluated according to the evidence and legal elements specific to those charges. And then there's the allegation involving her tires. According to the Justice Department, prosecutors allege that JP purchased a tire deflation device online, and sent messages to others concerning Mica's vehicle. That definitely looks suspicious to me. The indictment alleges that he damaged her tires and later made false statements to federal investigators about that conduct. That brings us to the second charge. Nicholle: The indictment alleges that he damaged his items and later made false statements to the federal investigators about that class. That brings us to the second. So the false statements charge is not simply about whether he was a difficult husband or whether his marriage was unhealthy. It's about what investigators say he told them during the investigation and whether those statements were false in a way that violates federal law. Zalle: Right, exactly. The Justice Department alleges that JP told investigators he had not damaged Mica's tires. While investigators uncovered evidence prosecutors say showed he had purchased the tire deflation device and sent messages about the vehicle. JP pleaded not guilty to both federal charges at his first january twelfth, two thousand twenty-six arraignment. He is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty, no matter what we think. And we need to make another distinction very clearly. The indictment does not charge JP with murdering Mica or causing her death. The charges concern alleged cyber stalking. and false statements to investigators. As of now that's it. Nicholle: Yeah, and that doesn't mean the allegations are unimportant. It means we have to be honest about what the legal case is actually about. We can discuss the seriousness of the alleged conduct without saying a jury has already decided what happened. And we are discussing it. It was very serious. And if all of those things are true, he is a disgusting human being. He's a bully. Zalle: It means we honest and publicly the case is actually about we can assess the seriousness of the alleged concept without saying the jury has already decided actually we are discussing the case very seriously and if all of those things are true we have discussed disgusting. Yeah. The indictment also doesn't resolve every allegation friends and family have made about the marriage. The sexual pressure allegations, the claims about coercive control and the accounts of what Mica reportedly discussed to friends are not automatically Proven by existence of a federal indictment. Each claim needs to be attributed to its source and assessed according to the evidence available. But the indictment does establish that federal prosecutors brought formal charges concerning alleged conduct directed at Mica before her death, and the case remains pending. As of October 2026, the federal case against JP Miller remains unresolved. He has pleaded not guilty. The trial has been delayed multiple times, and the latest reporting available to us indicates that jury selection has been pushed to January two thousand twenty seven. delay isn't proof of guilt. Just as a not guilty plea isn't proof that the allegation. Nicholle: And the delay isn't proof of guilt. Just as a not guilty plea isn't proof that the allegations are false. The legal process Zalle: The case will need to address the evidence supporting the cyber stalking charge and the alleged false statements. They may involve communications, records, device-related evidence, and testimony. We're not going to predict what court will find before obviously evidence is tested. But meanwhile, Mica's family and friends continue to live with the loss of someone they love. And the public conversation around her case continues. It is understandable that people want answers, but online theories can quickly become more confident than the evidence allows. A responsible account of this case has to hold on to what is known, identify what has been alleged, and admit what remains unsolved. I want to talk about the broader pattern here because it is easy to focus only on the most shocking allegation or the final day. The accounts from Mica's friends described concerns that touched everyday life. Phone calls, time away from home, friendships, sleep, sex, and the fear of what might happen if she didn't follow expectations. Those are not all the same behavior and they have not all been Nicholle: Adjudicate. Yeah. I have not already adjudicated for taken together the accounts describe what people around Michael were concerned about right now. Zalle: Adjudicated. Yeah. Have not all been adjudicated in court. But taken together, the accounts describe why people around Mica were concerned about her independence and safety. Coercive Nicholle: Force of control is often discussed as a pattern rather than one isolated. It can involve repeated pressure, intimidation, monitoring, isolation, a rope that reduces another doesn't make choices for. Zalle: control is often discussed as a pattern rather than one isolated incident. It can involve repeated pressure, intimidation, monitoring, isolation, or rules that reduce another person's ability to make choices freely. Nicholle: That doesn't mean every relationship conflict is forceful. It means we should pay attention. When a person repeatedly fails, they must manage another person's reaction or a tropical. Zalle: That doesn't mean every relationship conflict is coercive control. It means we should pay attention. When a person repeatedly fails, they must manage another person's reaction in order to avoid consequences. Nicholle: And I think the everyday details matter because people sometimes wait for one dramatic moment before they believe something is wrong. They think, well, he hasn't hit her or they're married, so maybe that's just how they are. But emotional intimidation, sexual pressure, and monitoring can be serious even when there's no visible injury. And someone doesn't have to prove their relationship is the worst relationship imaginable before they deserve refore they deserve support. Zalle: Seriously, even when there's no visible relationship. And someone doesn't have to believe their relationship is the worst relationship imaginable before they deserve love. Before they deserve support. Another part of this case is the role of friends and family. Mica went to her sister's home. Friends described conversations where she reportedly told them what was happening. Police were contacted on more than one occasion. Those actions matter because they show that people were trying to respond to concerns as they arose. They also remind us that people outside a relationship may notice warning signs before they know the full story, but supporting someone in a difficult relationship is complicated. People may not be ready to leave, they may return, they may defend their partner, they may be afraid, financially dependent, isolated, or unsure what will happen if they make a change. We should never assume that someone who stays or returns has given permission for mistreatment. Nicholle: And if somebody comes to you because they need somewhere safe, the first response should not be to interrogate them about why they didn't leave sooner. You can listen, you can tell them you care, you can ask what they need right now. You can help them think through practical options without forcing them to make every decision on your timeline. And if you're worried about somebody, it's important to Zalle: And if somebody comes to you because they need somewhere safe, the first response should not be tempt to interrogate them about why they didn't leave soon. You can listen, you can tell them you care, you can ask what they need right now. You can help them think through practical options without forcing them to make every decision on your time. And if you're worried about somebody's safety, it's important to seek Help from qualified local services rather than trying to manage a dangerous situation alone. For people who are experiencing domestic violence, a safety plan may include identifying trusted people, planning where to go, protecting important documents, considering digital privacy, and getting advice about safe ways to leave. The safest approach depends on the circumstances, so it can help to speak with a trained advocate. And one more thing. We need to talk responsibly about Mica's death. Her death was officially ruled a suicide. We cannot say that any one person, incident, or alleged behavior definitively caused her death. Suicide is complex, and we should not reduce a person's death to a simplistic explanation. At the same time, discussing suicide responsibly does not mean ignoring the relationship concerns reported before Mica died. Those concerns can be examined without claiming to know the precise cause of her final decision. Nicholle: And Mica should not be remembered only as the woman who died. She was a whole person. She had a voice, friendships, a life in her community, and people who loved her. We can talk about the allegations and the investigation while still remembering that the person at the center of this story was more than a case file. Zalle: The legal case may answer questions about the specific federal charges. It may establish which allegations the government can prove and which it cannot. But a court case cannot give us every private conversation, every feeling, or every moment in a person's life. What we can do is tell the story carefully, treat the evidence honestly, and avoid turning uncertainty into a theory Just because the uncertainty is uncomfortable. Nicholle: and avoid bringing uncertainty into a period Just because the uncertainty after Zalle: Mom, after going through this whole timeline, what stands out to you the most? Nicholle: going through this four times, what stands out to you? The accumulation of the little things people describe. The phone calls, the time restrictions, the reports about sexual pressure, and the concerns that came up when Mica was trying to get away from that relationship. One allegation by itself doesn't tell us the whole story, but when several people describe similar concerns, I think it deserves serious attention. And I keep coming back to the fact that Mica's family was contacting police in 2022. Zalle: doesn't tell us the whole story. But when several people describe similar concerns, I think it deserves serious attention. And I keep coming back to the fact that Mica's family was contacting police in 2022. These weren't all conversations that started after she died. Yeah, that's Nicholle: These weren't all conversations that started after she died. Yes. Zalle: what stood out to me too. The November 2022 calls make the timeline fail very different from a story that begins only when Mica's death becomes public. At the same time, I don't want us to look backward and pretend we can know exactly how every event was going to unfold. We know the ending and that can make every early moment seem like it had only one possible meaning. Nicholle: Right, that's true. We need to avoid that. We can say the reports were concerning without claiming everyone knew what would happen later. Zalle: Another thing that stands out is the way faith and personal identity were connected to the relationship. Mica was part of a church community and JP was the pastor. Friends described concerns about the way religious ideas were allegedly used in the marriage. he literally got up and did sermons about the things he wanted in his relationship on Sundays. Nicholle: Yes. So obviously I think it's worth discussing because persons' position in the community affects how others understand things. But we should also make clear that this isn't a story about all pastors or all religious activists. It's about the specific allegations and events connected to these people and those crazy shit. Zalle: So obviously I think it's worth discussing because a person's position in a community can affect how others understand them. But we should also make clear that this isn't a story about all pastors or all religious marriages. It's about the specific allegations and events connected to these people and it was some crazy shit happening between them. Yes, can be absourcing secrets. Nicholle: Yes, faith can be a source of support for people. The concern is when someone allegedly uses their position or religious beliefs to pressure another person into doing something they don't want to do. And when someone says they're struggling, the question should be how to support them, not how to force them to fit somebody else's idea of what a good spouse should be. Yeah, and then they're I think it's important that Zalle: uses their position or do they just use to pressure another person to do something they don't someone says they're struggling the question should be how to support them, not how to force them to fit somebody else's idea of what a good spouse should be. Yeah, and then there's the legal case. I think it's important that people understand the indictment is significant, but it isn't a verdict. Though a lot of us are like, Yeah, it seems kind of fishy, like maybe JP had a little bit more to do with her death and it just being Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: a suicide. It definitely Nicholle: Mm-hmm. It gives that feeling. but the government has made specific allegations. JP has pleaded not guilty. The court has to consider the evidence. We shouldn't skip ahead and announce the outcome because we don't know. We've seen that with recent court cases. We don't know what will come out of that. Zalle: Yeah, I do think that it's crazy that her death was ruled a suicide. If you watch the documentary about it, it doesn't seem like that was the case. But we don't know and apparently the police or the prosecution didn't feel like they could prove it, so there was no charge on that. And we shouldn't use the fact that he hasn't been charged with causing Mica's death to dismiss every other concern either though. Because those are separate questions. The death was officially ruled a suicide. The federal case concerns Nicholle: The death was officially ruled a suicide, federal case concerns, alleged cyber talking and false statements, and the accounts from friends and family provide additional context. But they don't have all of the same evidentiary status. That's why we keep separating the timeline or allegations and Zalle: The alleged cyber stalking and false statements, and the accounts from friends and family provide additional context, but they don't have all of the same evidentiary status. That's why we keep separating the timeline, the allegations, and the legal charges. Nicholle: and I hope listeners take away that you don't need to wait for a tragedy before you take someone's concerns seriously. If a friend tells you they feel monitored, pressured, frightened, or unable to make ordinary decisions without consequences, you can listen without pretending to know everything about their relationship. You don't have to solve everything for them. Sometimes being someone they can safely talk to matters a lot. Zalle: solve everything for you. Sometimes being someone they can safely talk to matters lot. Absolutely. Mica's story raises difficult questions about control, consent, faith, separation, and how concerns are documented and investigated. Some questions will be addressed through the federal case. Others may never have a complete public answer, but we can talk about what is known without inventing what isn't. And most importantly, we can remember Mica as a person, not just the controversy surrounding her death. That's where we're gonna leave this one for today. If you listened all the way through, thank you for spending this time with us and letting us walk through a complicated and difficult case with you. Nicholle: And if you have thoughts about this case, we want to hear them. Just please keep the conversation respectful and remember that real people and families are involved and distinguish the allegations from facts that have been established. Zalle: And once again, make sure you like, subscribe, follow us on social media, and leave us a review. It really does help coughing and crime with mom reach more people. And if this episode brought up something personal for you, you don't have to handle it alone. In the US, you can call or text 988 for suicide and crisis support. If you're experiencing domestic abuse or trying to help someone who is, The National Domestic Violence Hotline is available at 800-799-7233 or you can just text start to 88788 If someone is in immediate danger, call 911. Nicholle: Take care of yourselves, check on your people, and remember that you can support someone without judging them for how complicated their situation is. Zalle: We'll see you next time, Ingestigators. Until then, keep your coffee close and your eyes open. Bye. Nicholle: Ayah.