Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Michael Burry Catches The Lululemon Knife
Transcript
- 0:00So Michael Bury, the the legendary value nester famous
- 0:03for calling the 2008 financial crisis, recently bought 100,000
- 0:07shares of Lululemon, and right now he is down roughly 50% on
- 0:13that bet. Yeah.
- 0:13That is a brutal drop. Right so today we are looking at
- 0:17why one of the greatest investors in the world is, you
- 0:19know, trying to catch a falling knife.
- 0:22Welcome to today's deep drive. It is Thursday, June 11th, 2026
- 0:26and our mission today is to unpack this massive
- 0:29comprehensive 10 year financial research report on Lululemon
- 0:32Athletica. Ticker symbol is Lulu.
- 0:35It's a brand everyone definitely knows.
- 0:37Oh for sure, yeah. But their stock has recently
- 0:40experienced just an absolute shockwave.
- 0:42Yeah, we are witnessing the painful real time friction of a
- 0:45high flying momentum stock just slamming head first into a
- 0:48structural wall. And you know, the blood in the
- 0:51water is exactly what is drawing in deep value investors who
- 0:53think the market has severely overreacted.
- 0:55Exactly. But before we get into the exact
- 0:57mechanics of that structural wall, we have a quick message to
- 1:00share that perfectly aligns with our focus on value investing
- 1:02today. Go for it to access more
- 1:04advanced researches application and our latest published
- 1:07personal intelligent multi agent deep value intelligence.
- 1:10Welcome to explore and join deep values dot AI community to track
- 1:15total market temperature. Welcome to Search and download
- 1:17iOS App Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.
- 1:21Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 1:25and may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 1:28All contents from this channel is for information and research
- 1:30purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 1:34Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 1:37decisions. And we are definitely going to
- 1:38need that due diligence today because our goal is to figure
- 1:42out how a premium high growth yoga brand suddenly became a
- 1:46prime target for a big short style deep value play.
- 1:49Right. It's wild to even think about.
- 1:51It is so to understand the opportunity we have to look at
- 1:53the immediate carnage from their latest earnings release on June
- 1:564th. On the surface, if you just
- 1:58glance at the headlines, top line revenue actually grew.
- 2:01Barely though. It was a modest 4% bump up to
- 2:04$2.47 billion. But looking under the hood, the
- 2:08engine is basically tearing itself apart.
- 2:09We were seeing severe margin compression.
- 2:12Yeah. And top line growth is
- 2:13essentially a mirage if it, you know, costs you significantly
- 2:16more to make those sales. When we talk about margin
- 2:19compression, we were talking about the core profitability of
- 2:22the underlying business just evaporating completely.
- 2:25Their gross margins dropped by 400, 10 basis points down to
- 2:2854.2%. And operating margins, which
- 2:31factor in the everyday costs of running the business, they
- 2:34plummeted an incredible 720 basis points to just 11.2.
- 2:39Percent. Wow.
- 2:40Let's translate those basis points into plain English for a
- 2:42second, because a 720 basis point drop means that for every
- 2:45single dollar Lululemon brings in, they're keeping 7.2 cents
- 2:49less and operating profit compared to last.
- 2:51Year. Exactly.
- 2:52Across billions of dollars in revenue.
- 2:53I mean, that's a catastrophic leak.
- 2:55And that leak translated into diluted earnings per share
- 2:57collapsing 35%, down to $1.69. Yeah, and for a company that
- 3:02historically priced itself for hyper growth, dropping your
- 3:05earnings by over 1/3 is an earthquake.
- 3:08Oh, absolutely. But diving into the research,
- 3:10what really stands out to me is that this pain isn't happening
- 3:13everywhere at once. There's this massive geographic
- 3:16divergent. The split is staggering,
- 3:18honestly. Let's look at the America
- 3:20segment. This is their mature core
- 3:23market. It accounts for the vast
- 3:25majority of their historical success, right?
- 3:27That segment contracted by 3% with comparable sales, meaning
- 3:31sales at stores that have been open for at least a year down
- 3:345%. The North American consumer is
- 3:36demonstrably fatigued. But then you flip over to the
- 3:39international segment and it is booming.
- 3:41It's up 22% and that is anchored by an incredible 30% revenue
- 3:45expansion in China mainland. 30% is huge.
- 3:48Right. It's like an elite marathoner
- 3:50who suddenly hit a wall and is walking at mile 18 in their
- 3:53hometown race, but it's somehow sprinting uphill and setting
- 3:56record paces overseas. Like what explains that
- 3:59disconnect? It really comes down to where
- 4:02the brand sits in the adoption life cycle.
- 4:04Like in North America, the market is saturated.
- 4:07Lululemon is ubiquitous. Yeah, everyone has it.
- 4:10Right. Combine that saturation with
- 4:12elevated interest rates and, you know, persistent inflation
- 4:15weighing heavily on consumer discretionary spending and
- 4:18growth stalls. But in China, they're still in
- 4:21that early adoption, rapid expansion phase.
- 4:24So it's. Still fresh there?
- 4:25Exactly. The brand still carries an
- 4:27aspirational novelty. The structural problem for the
- 4:30company, however, is that you cannot simply outrun a North
- 4:32American collapse with international growth.
- 4:35The sheer volume of the US market is too large.
- 4:37The profit drag just pulls the whole ship down.
- 4:40Which forces us to look critically at their famous
- 4:42business model because for years investors were told Lululemon
- 4:46had an impenetrable economic Moat.
- 4:48Right, the DTC model. Yeah, they don't sell wholesale.
- 4:51You won't find their gear in a traditional department store.
- 4:54They use a 100% direct to consumer architecture.
- 4:57And that architecture has historically been their
- 5:00superpower. By selling exclusively through
- 5:03their 816 company operated stores and their proprietary
- 5:07digital apps, they just cut out the middleman entirely.
- 5:10So they keep all the profit. They capture the full retail
- 5:13markup, yeah. And they maintain total control
- 5:16over the product ecosystem too, like they partner with technical
- 5:20mills to create proprietary highly guarded fabrics.
- 5:23We're talking about Lulong for the four way stretch and Nulu
- 5:26for that signature buttery soft. Feel the classic Lulu feel.
- 5:29Exactly. And they also build a genius
- 5:32marketing mode. Instead of paying hundreds of
- 5:34millions of dollars for, you know, traditional celebrity
- 5:36endorsements or massive billboard campaigns, they
- 5:39created the Sweat Collective. Right, the Ambassador program.
- 5:42Yeah, they partnered directly with local yoga teachers,
- 5:44personal trainers and fitness coaches, giving them steep
- 5:46product discounts. It turns community leaders into
- 5:49walking talking billboards, generating massive grassroots
- 5:52hype for a fraction of the cost of a traditional ad campaign.
- 5:55It is a brilliant, highly defensive setup on paper, but in
- 5:59reality, that Moat is currently being breached by a combination
- 6:03of cyclical and structural headwinds.
- 6:05Yeah, let's look at the cyclical side first.
- 6:08Because of their specific supply chain relying heavily on 3rd
- 6:11party manufacturing in Asia and importing finished goods
- 6:14directly to their network, they are highly exposed to US import
- 6:18tariffs. Oh, wow.
- 6:19Yeah, and changes in customs exemptions.
- 6:21Those tariffs alone accounted for over 500 basis points.
- 6:24Of that gross margin compression.
- 6:26We are looking at an estimated $210 million hit to operating
- 6:30income in fiscal 2025 just from import penalties.
- 6:33OK, let's unpack this. If their DTC model is designed
- 6:36specifically to give them ultimate pricing control and
- 6:38avoid department store markdowns, why are their margins
- 6:41still collapsing so violently? Aren't markdowns the exact thing
- 6:44DTC is supposed to prevent? That is the ultimate double
- 6:47edged sword of direct to consumer retail.
- 6:49You are completely right that DTC protects you from a
- 6:51desperate department store slashing your prices just to
- 6:54clear shelf space. The problem is when you are the
- 6:57sole owner of your entire global inventory and consumer taste
- 7:01suddenly shift against you, there is no overflow valve, you
- 7:04are the one left holding the bag.
- 7:06Oh I see, think of the DTC model like a massive dam.
- 7:09When demand is flowing you capture every drop of profit.
- 7:12But when inventory floods, you don't have a wholesale partner
- 7:16to act as a spillway. So the water just backs up.
- 7:18The dam breaks and you have to aggressively discount the
- 7:21product yourself just to survive.
- 7:23Jeez. And that leads perfectly into
- 7:25the structural head when the great fashion shift.
- 7:27Precisely. Lululemon built a multibillion
- 7:30dollar empire on the aesthetic of tight form fitting yoga pants
- 7:35that was the uniform of the last decade.
- 7:36Oh. Completely.
- 7:37But the current cultural and activewear trend has
- 7:40aggressively, almost violently, shifted toward loose, oversized,
- 7:44relaxed fit St. wear. Right.
- 7:46And while Lululemon's massive corporate supply chain is, you
- 7:49know, trying to pivot its design pipeline to make baggier
- 7:52clothes, these well funded, agile upstarts are moving in and
- 7:56stealing their younger demographic.
- 7:57Yeah, totally. The research sources
- 7:59specifically highlight brands like Alo Yoga and Vori.
- 8:04They are capturing the cultural zeitgeist by perfectly aligning
- 8:07with this new relaxed lifestyle aesthetic from day one.
- 8:11Yeah, they didn't have to pivot. Exactly.
- 8:13So Lululemon's physical stores in the US suddenly saw foot
- 8:16traffic slow down. Inventory started piling up.
- 8:19I mean, it rose 2% to $1.7 billion.
- 8:22That's a lot of unsold leggings. It really is.
- 8:25So to clear out those tight leggings that nobody wanted
- 8:27anymore, Lululemon was forced to initiate the very markdowns
- 8:31their business model was supposed to prevent.
- 8:32And they did successfully clear the slow moving units.
- 8:35Actually, total unit inventory was down 4%, but the cost was
- 8:39devastating. The margin hit.
- 8:41Right. They sacrificed their premium
- 8:43gross margins to flush the system.
- 8:45When you combine the self-inflicted markdowns with
- 8:47persistent labor inflation across their 39,000 global
- 8:50employees, you get that catastrophic 720 basis point
- 8:54drop in operating margin. The engine didn't just sputter,
- 8:57it choked. Yeah, and when an engine chokes
- 8:59that badly and a premium brand starts losing its cultural heat,
- 9:03the pressure cooker usually blows in the boardroom.
- 9:06And Lululemon has been dealing with intense, highly publicized
- 9:10drama at the very top of the corporate ladder.
- 9:13It has been a severe distraction at the absolute worst possible
- 9:16time. The former CEO Calvin McDonald
- 9:19exited in January 2026. Right.
- 9:21That left the company in the hands of interim Co CEO's, the
- 9:24CFO and the Chief Commercial Officer.
- 9:27A leadership vacuum is dangerous for any company, but for a brand
- 9:30trying to navigate a massive aesthetic pivot, it is
- 9:34paralyzing. Oh, for sure.
- 9:35And into that vacuum step the founder.
- 9:37Chip Wilson. Yep, he founded the company way
- 9:39back in 1998. He formally stepped down from
- 9:41the board in 2015, but he never really walked away.
- 9:45He is still the largest individual shareholder, holding
- 9:47a massive 8.7% stake. That's.
- 9:49A lot of leverage. It is, and seeing the stock
- 9:52drop, he launched a highly aggressive proxy fight.
- 9:55He publicly attacked the board, claiming the brand had lost its
- 9:57technical focus, grew and distracted by irrelevant product
- 10:00lines and basically just forgotten its core identity.
- 10:03And that proxy fight forced the board into a defensive posture,
- 10:06burning time and resources they really needed for the turn
- 10:09around. Finally, in May 2026, they
- 10:12reached a settlement to resolve the contest and get back to
- 10:15business. And the details of this
- 10:16settlement are just wild. Wilson agreed to an 18 month
- 10:20standstill and a non disparagement agreement,
- 10:23basically promising to stop attacking the company publicly.
- 10:26In exchange, the board agreed to add two of his preferred
- 10:29candidates to the board. We're talking Mark Maher, a
- 10:32former Co CEO of the rapidly growing running shoe brand ON,
- 10:36and Laura Gentile, a former chief marketing officer at ESPN.
- 10:40Two very solid additions on a. Oh, absolutely.
- 10:43But here's my favorite detail. Instead of reimbursing Wilson's
- 10:46proxy costs, Lululemon agreed to make a sizable donation to
- 10:50support community athletics at Kit Solano Beach in Vancouver,
- 10:53which happens to be the exact neighborhood where the brand was
- 10:56founded. Unbelievable feels.
- 10:57Like a TV drama, the estranged founder is throwing rocks at the
- 11:00corporate windows from the outside until the board finally
- 11:03gives him the keys to the guest house and a donation to his
- 11:05favorite beach just to quiet him down.
- 11:07It is incredibly cinematic, but if we pull back and look at the
- 11:10governance implications, the board made a highly strategic
- 11:14trade. How so?
- 11:15They traded a few board seats and a charitable donation for 18
- 11:18month of peace. They desperately needed to clear
- 11:21the air because executing a turn around requires total focus, and
- 11:25that turn around relies entirely on their new incoming CEO, Heidi
- 11:29O'Neill. Right, she officially takes over
- 11:32on September 8th 2026 and looking at her background I mean
- 11:36she seems custom built for this exact crisis.
- 11:38Absolutely. He is a 30 year Nike veteran.
- 11:42During her tenure, she helped scale Nike's revenue from $9
- 11:45billion all the way up to $45 billion.
- 11:48That is no joke. She brings heavy hitting global
- 11:51operational muscle. Lululemon doesn't need a
- 11:53visionary founder right now. They need a ruthless operator
- 11:56who knows how to manage international supply chains, fix
- 11:58a broken product pipeline and scale globally without losing
- 12:01margin. Exactly, and the board
- 12:03structured her compensation to guarantee she is aligned with
- 12:06the shareholders too. 60% of her $10 million annual equity awards
- 12:11are tied directly to performance vesting restricted stock units.
- 12:15If the stock doesn't recover, she doesn't get paid.
- 12:17Well, Speaking of the stock recovering, the board isn't just
- 12:20waiting around for O'Neill to fix the clothes.
- 12:22They are aggressively deploying capital to force the math in
- 12:25their favor. The buybacks.
- 12:27Right, they refuse to pay a traditional dividend.
- 12:30Instead they are buying back their own stock on the open
- 12:32market. They just utilized A newly
- 12:34authorized $1.0 billion increase, leaving them with $1.6
- 12:39billion in remaining buyback capacity over the trailing 12
- 12:43months. That represents an 8 point O
- 12:46percent buyback yield. That buyback yield is a massive
- 12:49signal to the market. When a board authorizes $1.6
- 12:52billion to buy their own shares, they are looking at the same
- 12:55plunging stock price we are, and they are essentially saying Wall
- 12:58Street is wrong. The market has priced our cash
- 13:01flows too low, so we're going to bet on ourselves.
- 13:04By reducing the total number of shares available, they
- 13:07artificially boost the earnings per share for the remaining
- 13:09investors. Which transitions are deep dive
- 13:11into the most fascinating question of the day really.
- 13:14With the stock batter down to around $118.93 from historical
- 13:19highs well over $400, is this falling stock actually a hidden
- 13:23gem for value investors? Well, the Super investors
- 13:25certainly believe it is. Institutional value legends are
- 13:28actively buying the dip. Philtown, who runs the Rule One
- 13:32Fund, initiated a position with 50,000 shares.
- 13:35And as we mentioned at the very top of the show, Michael Bury of
- 13:37Sign Asset Management holds 100,000 shares.
- 13:40But the detail that blows my mind is his entry point.
- 13:43The research estimates Bury's average purchase price was
- 13:45$238.01. Here's where it gets really
- 13:49interesting. Michael Bury is down roughly 50%
- 13:53on his position right now. If the legendary guy who called
- 13:56the 2008 financial crisis is currently deep in the red on
- 13:59this stock, should everyday investors really be trying to
- 14:01catch to this falling knife? It's a great question, and it
- 14:04highlights the brutal psychological reality of deep
- 14:07value investing. You can be entirely correct
- 14:10about the underlying intrinsic value of a business, but still
- 14:13be punishingly early on the timing.
- 14:15Yeah, being early often feels exactly like being wrong.
- 14:18Exactly. To understand why Bury and Town
- 14:21are willing to absorb that kind of short term pain, the research
- 14:24report ran Lululemon's financials through a strict
- 14:27Buffett style deep value checklist.
- 14:30We aren't looking at brand heat anymore.
- 14:31We are looking purely at the financial machinery.
- 14:33OK, let's. Grade that report card, then
- 14:35what passed the deep value test and what failed?
- 14:38The most glaring positive is the multiple contraction.
- 14:41The price to earnings or PE ratio is currently sitting at a
- 14:44historically low 9.5 X. We really need to unpack what a
- 14:489.5 X PE actually means for brand like this because it
- 14:51represents a total identity crisis.
- 14:53Oh absolutely. For the last 10 years,
- 14:55Lululemon's average PE was 42.1. Investors were willing to pay
- 14:59$42.00 for every $1.00 of earnings because they assumed
- 15:02those earnings would double and triple indefinitely.
- 15:05Dropping to 9.5 X means Wall Street has entirely stripped
- 15:09away the growth premium. They are currently pricing
- 15:12Lululemon the exact same way they price a stagnant 0 growth
- 15:16legacy retailer. And the data suggests that
- 15:18penalty is way too harsh. When you look at the balance
- 15:20sheet, it is fortified. They pass the debt checks with
- 15:23line colors because they have 0 long term bank debt.
- 15:26None, none. They have $1.51 billion in cash
- 15:30just sitting there. Furthermore, they easily pass
- 15:33the cash flow test. Even amidst this crisis.
- 15:36They have generated positive free cash flow for 10 straight
- 15:39years. That's incredible consistency.
- 15:41It is. They're trailing free cash flow
- 15:42margin is 11.4%, which comfortably beats the strict 5%
- 15:47value investing benchmark. And they also maintain a 10 year
- 15:49average return on equity of over 30%.
- 15:52That metric is crucial because it proves that when the product
- 15:55is right, the underlying direct consumer business model is still
- 15:58highly efficient at compounding capital.
- 16:00However, a true deep value analysis requires acknowledging
- 16:04the failures to they did fail a few strict old school value
- 16:09metrics. The price to book ratio is 2.84,
- 16:12which fails the classic Gramm limit of 1.5.
- 16:15Although looking at the context of the sources, failing the
- 16:18price to book metric is incredibly common for an asset
- 16:22light modern apparel brand. Yeah, that's fair because
- 16:24Lululemon doesn't own massive heavy manufacturing factories
- 16:27that sit on their books. They lease retail space and use
- 16:31third party manufacturers. Their value is in their brand
- 16:34and their data, not heavy machinery.
- 16:36Right. But they also failed the EPS
- 16:38consistency test. Value investors want to see
- 16:41earnings rise sequentially every single year.
- 16:43And Lululemon's earnings dropped in 2022 due to the disastrous
- 16:47Mirror acquisition write down and they obviously dropped
- 16:49heavily again this year. Right, the inconsistencies are
- 16:52definitely real, but the. Cornerstone of the value
- 16:54argument comes down to a discounted cash flow valuation
- 16:56or DCFADCF model projects how much actual cash the business
- 17:00will generate over the next decade and discounts it back to
- 17:03in today's dollars. So what were the results?
- 17:05The report ran a highly conservative scenario assuming a
- 17:08slow growth recovery that is significantly lower than their
- 17:12historical averages. Even in that pessimistic
- 17:15scenario, the intrinsic value of Lululemon is estimated at
- 17:18$173.79 per share. Wow.
- 17:21So with the stock currently trading at $118.93, that
- 17:25conservative model offers investors a massive 31.6% margin
- 17:29of safety. That margin of safety is the
- 17:32entire thesis. It means the stock is heavily
- 17:34discounted relative to the actual mathematical cash the
- 17:37business is projected to throw off.
- 17:39The market is pricing in a permanent collapse, while the
- 17:41math suggests a temporary, albeit painful, stumble.
- 17:45So if the map looks that good and you have this massive margin
- 17:47of safety, is there any reason to wait?
- 17:49It is a valor warning to wait, and the answer depends entirely
- 17:52on your time horizon. Buying a turn around story
- 17:55requires immense, often uncomfortable patience.
- 17:57Because the market can stay irrational.
- 17:59Exactly. The stock market is a highly
- 18:02emotional voting machine in the short term.
- 18:05Lululemon is still going to face active pain in the coming
- 18:08quarters. They still have to clear out the
- 18:10wrong inventory, pivot the design team and deal with the
- 18:13ongoing drag of import tariffs. Yeah, that won't happen
- 18:16overnight. But from a strict mathematical
- 18:19deep value perspective, you have to look at the foundation.
- 18:22You are buying a company with 0 long term bank debt.
- 18:25You are buying a highly loyal top tier customer base that
- 18:29boasts a 90% repeat purchase rate.
- 18:31Which is huge. And you are buying an
- 18:33international segment that is active, growing at 22%.
- 18:37You aren't catching a bankrupt company, you are catching an
- 18:39incredibly profitable cash generating machine that simply
- 18:42lost its momentum. So if Heidi O'Neill can use her
- 18:46Nike playbook to fix the product pipeline, the long term upside
- 18:50is substantial. Very substantial.
- 18:52So to synthesize this massive deep dive, wait, let me just
- 18:56recap. Lululemon is caught in a highly
- 18:59visible painful structural transition.
- 19:02The entire narrative of the company is shifting.
- 19:04They are morphing from a high growth momentum darling into a
- 19:07classic deep value turn around play.
- 19:10That's the perfect summary. The balance sheet is totally
- 19:12safe, the cash flow generation is real, and the geographic
- 19:15expansion in China proves the brand still has global
- 19:18resonance. But to unlock that $173
- 19:21intrinsic value and stop the bleeding in North America, the
- 19:25brand desperately needs to pivot its aesthetic and win back the
- 19:27youth demographic from agile competitors like Ello and Vori.
- 19:31Yeah, the financial architecture is resilient enough to survive
- 19:34the storm without going into debt.
- 19:36The $1.6 billion buyback provides a solid floor, but
- 19:39ultimately the creative and operational teams have to
- 19:41actually build the products the modern consumer wants to wear.
- 19:44Math buys you time, but product buys you growth.
- 19:47It is a fascinating collision of hard financial math and
- 19:50subjective cultural trends, which leaves us with a final
- 19:53thought for you to Mull over as you conduct your own research.
- 19:56We've seen today that Lululemon's financial foundation
- 19:59is rock solid, but fashion is notoriously fickle.
- 20:03Oh yeah. Can an apparel brand that loses
- 20:06its cool factor ever truly engineer it back through heavy
- 20:10hitting new management? Or is a $1.6 billion share
- 20:14buyback just a sophisticated financial Band-Aid on a
- 20:17permanently fading trend? That is the multi billion dollar
- 20:20question and the answer will likely dictate the future of
- 20:23retail apparel. It really will.
- 20:24If you like to access wider topics, including life and
- 20:27investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel,
- 20:29Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 20:31Much appreciated. Keep digging, keep learning, and
- 20:33we'll see you in the next deep dive.
- 21:05None.