Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Marketplaces Use Geographic Expansion to Raise Take Rate
Transcript
- Lucas: If you run a two-sided marketplace, your take rate — the percentage you keep from each transaction — is the single most important lever for profitability. But raising it is notoriously tricky. Push too hard, and suppliers or buyers defect. Push too gently, and you leave money on the table. Luna: Right, and we've covered a lot of tactics — reviews, insurance, algorithmic matching. But one lever we haven't really dug into is geography. How does expanding into new cities or regions change what you can charge? Lucas: Exactly. Geographic expansion isn't just about adding users. It fundamentally alters supply-demand dynamics, which directly affects how much you can take. Uber is a great case. In its early years, Uber charged a flat 20 percent commission in most cities. But as it expanded into smaller, less competitive markets, it started experimenting with higher rates. Luna: I remember reports that in some mid-sized U.S. cities, Uber's take rate crept up to 25 or even 30 percent. Was that a direct result of lower competition? Lucas: Partly. In a city like San Francisco, Uber faced Lyft, Wingz, and other ride-share apps. Drivers could switch platforms easily. So if Uber raised its take rate, drivers would just drive for Lyft instead. But in a city like, say, Boise, Idaho, Uber might be the only game in town for ride-hailing. Drivers have fewer alternatives, so they're more willing to accept a higher commission. Luna: So the local competitive landscape is a huge factor. But what about the demand side? If there are fewer riders, doesn't that limit how much you can charge? Lucas: It's a balancing act. In a smaller market, you have thinner liquidity — fewer riders and drivers. That actually cuts both ways. On one hand, drivers need every trip they can get, so they're less likely to churn over a take-rate increase. On the other hand, riders are price-sensitive because the service is less essential — it's not a daily commute for most people in Boise. Uber found that in smaller cities, drivers were the binding constraint. So they increased take rate from drivers while keeping rider prices low. Luna: Fascinating. So the same marketplace can charge different take rates in different geographies. That feels like a recipe for complexity — how do you operationalize that? Lucas: Uber built a dynamic commission model that varied by city, sometimes even by time of day or demand level. But the key insight is that expansion into less competitive geographies gave them pricing power on the supply side. Airbnb does something similar, but in a different way. Luna: How so? Airbnb's take rate is typically around 3 percent from hosts and 14 percent from guests, for a total of about 17 percent. Does that vary by location? Lucas: It does, but less explicitly. Airbnb doesn't publicly disclose city-level take rates, but studies have shown that in rural or less popular destinations, the guest service fee can be higher — sometimes up to 20 percent. Why? Because in those areas, the inventory is more unique and less price-elastic. If you're booking a cabin in the Smoky Mountains, you're not comparing dozens of identical listings. The host has more pricing power, and Airbnb can take a bigger slice without scaring off guests. Luna: So less competition on the supply side means higher take rates. That's a consistent principle. But does that mean marketplaces should always expand into less competitive geographies? Lucas: Not necessarily. You need enough demand to sustain the marketplace. Expanding into a very remote area with no travelers won't work. But the playbook is: first, establish liquidity in a few dense, competitive hubs — that's your proof of concept and your brand builder. Then, expand into adjacent geographies where you can be the dominant player and command higher take rates. Luna: That's exactly what Uber did. They launched in San Francisco, then New York, then London — all hyper-competitive. Only later did they push into smaller markets. Lucas: Right. And by then, they had brand recognition and operational playbooks. They could enter a mid-sized city and quickly capture market share before local competitors even got started. Once they had density, they could gradually raise take rates without losing drivers. Luna: Let's talk numbers. What's a realistic take-rate uplift from geographic expansion? Can a marketplace go from 20 to 25 percent just by entering new cities? Lucas: In Uber's case, the average take rate in the U.S. went from about 20 percent in 2014 to around 25 percent by 2019, and a lot of that came from smaller cities. But it's not automatic. You have to be careful about price sensitivity on the demand side. If riders start using the service less, drivers earn less, and the marketplace loses liquidity. The sweet spot is where you have just enough demand to keep drivers busy, but not enough competition to give drivers alternatives. Luna: So it's about creating a local monopoly or near-monopoly. That's easier said than done. Lucas: Absolutely. And it's not just about geography — it's also about category. A marketplace like Thumbtack operates across many service categories, and each one has different competitive dynamics. Expanding into a new category can be like expanding into a new geography. The same principle applies: find a niche where you can be dominant, then charge more. Luna: Before we wrap up, I want to touch on something real. Lucas, you and I have done over a hundred episodes of this show, and we keep it ad-free because we want to give honest, unvarnished advice. A small number of listeners support us monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's what keeps this going. If you find these strategies useful for what you're building, that's the way to keep us independent. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small group, but they make a huge difference. We're not asking for much — just that if the show adds value, you consider chipping in. It really does let us keep the focus on operator-level insights without any sponsor influence. Luna: So back to geography. We've seen how Uber and Airbnb used expansion to raise take rates. What's the key takeaway for someone building a marketplace today? Lucas: Don't think of your take rate as a single number. Think of it as a portfolio of rates across geographies and segments. Start in competitive, dense markets to build brand and liquidity. Then expand into less competitive areas where you can capture more value. Test dynamically, measure churn on both sides, and adjust. Geographic expansion isn't just about growth — it's a pricing strategy. Luna: And the best part? It's a lever that compounds. As you add more geographies, you gather data on what works, and you can refine your model for the next expansion. Lucas: Exactly. The marketplace that masters geographic pricing can sustainably raise its take rate without alienating users. That's the kind of edge that separates good marketplaces from great ones.