Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / The Earthquake of Abandonment Terror: How Preoccupied People Experience This (and How to Overcome It)
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:20love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is Thursday, September 18th, 2025 at 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight
- 0:28Time. And last week I talked about the
- 0:31earthquake of abandonment terror as dismissing people experience
- 0:36it and maybe overcome it. And I thought tonight that I
- 0:41would follow that up with the earthquake of abandonment
- 0:47terror, how preoccupied people experience it and and how you
- 0:51might overcome it. So.
- 1:00Abandonment care is the activation of the attachment
- 1:06system. So really what we're talking
- 1:08about is abandonment fear, abandonment terror.
- 1:12I'd like to use the word terror because for small children and
- 1:18for well even into middle childhood, the experience of
- 1:23being lost or abandoned by your caregiver produces that.
- 1:29Response that is experienced by the child is life threatening
- 1:34really. I think it when it comes from,
- 1:38if you look at it evolutionarily, for instance,
- 1:42the life expectancy of a great ape, a baby separated from its
- 1:46caregivers about an hour and a half, very short.
- 1:51And human babies, obviously it's not so far off from that if they
- 1:57were completely abandoned. And grade ape babies are much
- 2:03better at responding to the environment than human babies
- 2:08are. If you look at the response that
- 2:12children have to abandonment, of course the first thing that they
- 2:18do is look as cute as they can to attract attention.
- 2:22And actually around 42 minutes is the first time a a newborn
- 2:29infant responds with that first request for attachment.
- 2:36Babies don't see so much. Infants don't see so much, but
- 2:40they do track movement. And then there's a reflexive
- 2:44smile that they adopt in response to that to draw
- 2:49attention. If that doesn't work, then
- 2:52there's a kind of whimpering that happens.
- 2:54Very distinct. You'll notice I always marvelled
- 2:58on my God, kids were would have these big birthday parties, you
- 3:04know, 3-4 year olds running around, a sea of three and four
- 3:09year olds running around and the parents standing in circles
- 3:12talking. But all of a sudden, you could
- 3:14see the the in that cacophony of child Glee, a parent hearing the
- 3:22distress call of her kid and rushing off to go find them to
- 3:26see what's going on. So very distinctive in that way.
- 3:31If nobody comes with the whimper, then there's an
- 3:34intermittent cry, and then the intermittent cry turns into a
- 3:38continuous cry, and that continuous cry turns into a
- 3:43tantrum. But if nobody comes in response
- 3:48to the tantrum, the child goes into aneclitic depression where
- 3:52everything shuts down and they preserve energy to preserve
- 3:57life. So it's so built into us, you
- 4:03might say. Freud thought that the thing
- 4:06that drove everything was the death instinct that we're, we're
- 4:10very sensitive to it, even if we don't have a, a cognitive
- 4:14understanding of it. So the earthquake of abandonment
- 4:18here, of course, is followed by what I call the terrible
- 4:22sadness, the tsunami of terrible sadness.
- 4:27There's your metaphor, earthquake and tsunami, and that
- 4:35combination manifests differently depending on what
- 4:38your attachment strategy is. The, the, the terrible sadness
- 4:45for dismissing people, as I was talking about last week, is the,
- 4:53the sense of abandonment that they experience, the sense of
- 4:58rejection that they experience, that there's nothing really that
- 5:01they can do to beckon the caregiver to be responsive to
- 5:05them. They they have to be responsive
- 5:09to the caregiver. So it's a kind of reversal
- 5:12there. But in in preoccupation, what
- 5:17really is going on is the caregiver is so distracted and
- 5:24so lacking in monitoring that the child experiences A chaotic
- 5:34caregiver. And so they can't really predict
- 5:39how to elicit a response from the caregiver predictably,
- 5:45predictably, which is a really a sense of helplessness or
- 5:52powerlessness in relating to their caregiver.
- 5:58In a secure dynamic, the caregiver provides consistent
- 6:02care. They're sensitively attuned,
- 6:05they empathetically connect. They're interested in
- 6:08understanding what the the needs of the child are and how those
- 6:12needs are presented so that they can understand that and then
- 6:16they can provide the care that the child needs.
- 6:20What that does on the child side, of course, is you begin to
- 6:24learn how to express your needs in such a way that the caregiver
- 6:31can respond with them by meeting those needs.
- 6:34So the child in monitoring the back and forth with the
- 6:38caregiver understands that they do a certain gesture, it's
- 6:42likely to elicit a certain kind of care.
- 6:46And so they learn to communicate in that pre verbal, pre self
- 6:54manner. And when you are around
- 6:59caregiver an infant to have developed this dialogue, the
- 7:03communication is quite fast and and developed in the the
- 7:09caregiver can be quite responsive to the needs of a
- 7:12child if they really understand what they are.
- 7:15But this doesn't happen for insecure kids and for
- 7:19disorganized kids. The dismissing child, of course,
- 7:23the dismissing infant, they are neglected and the the caregiver
- 7:28is present but absent to that attunement that would let them
- 7:36understand and they provide for the child what they think the
- 7:38child would have should have, rather than taking the cue from
- 7:45the child themselves. But in preoccupation, the care
- 7:51is is chaotic and the experience of the caregiver is really are
- 7:57caught up and scattered and caught up and scattered.
- 8:01And they respond to the child in the way that they think that the
- 8:07child needs to be taken care of, but are also oblivious really to
- 8:15the signs that the child is expressing.
- 8:22This is different in a way from the way an avoidant child
- 8:28experiences it, and in in the childhood of anxious avoidant
- 8:36childhood becomes a dismissing adult.
- 8:38Of course that misatunement is consistent and unchanging, and
- 8:47it is the care that the parent thinks the child should receive
- 8:52and not what the child indicates in the preoccupied experience.
- 9:02There isn't really a plan for the care in the way that there
- 9:05is in dismissing family system. It's scattered and gathered,
- 9:13scattering thoughts that are then in a moment grabbed.
- 9:17And so there's no continuity between previous moments of
- 9:22care, no continuity in the overall picture of care that
- 9:27they think that the child should receive.
- 9:30It's really spontaneous, whereas in the dismissing side, it's
- 9:37planned and the plan is not varied depending on what
- 9:44happens. The child, of course, thinks
- 9:49that if they can just get it right, if they can just.
- 9:52Present in a way that the caregiver wants that the that
- 9:57the caregiver will take care of them.
- 9:59And every now and then when the care that the caregiver provides
- 10:04lines up with the, the care that the child needs, the child
- 10:08thinks that they've got it right and that if they could just
- 10:14figure out how to get it right again, they, they could more
- 10:18reliably get the cure that they need.
- 10:21And that causes the child to a mesh with the mind state of the
- 10:26caregiver. Of course, the caregiver in a,
- 10:29in an anxious, ambivalent child that grows up to be a
- 10:33preoccupied adult, the caregiver is actually eliciting the
- 10:38child's attention to a mesh in their mind state because they
- 10:42use the child to regulate with that.
- 10:48All making sense so far. In some sense, both an avoidant
- 10:59and a preoccupied or dismissing A preoccupied person abandoned
- 11:05themselves in order to interact with the caregiver in the
- 11:13childhood of neglect that produces A dismissing adult.
- 11:20What you have is somebody who doesn't learn.
- 11:25Interaction particularly well with another person 'cause they
- 11:30don't, they're not taught that with their caregivers.
- 11:35They if you look at that progression of development, we
- 11:42all start out as auto regulating.
- 11:47That is to say, we regulate ourselves.
- 11:50And then if somebody comes along reliably enough that we can
- 11:53reorient and get help from them to regulate, we reorient it that
- 11:58way. And if they come reliably enough
- 12:02that we can learn from them how to regulate ourselves, we move
- 12:05into a collaborative system of regulating where we become
- 12:11really expert at regulating our own emotions and then recognize
- 12:17when we can't regulate ourselves that we have somebody available
- 12:20to us who can help us regulate. So it's in the secure dynamic,
- 12:25it's always this movement between exploration and self
- 12:29regulation to coming back to the caregiver for Co regulation.
- 12:34And that's really the the secure dynamic, Co regulation moving
- 12:39away and coming back. And both pieces are in that in
- 12:44the preoccupied formulation, the caregiver comes reliably enough
- 12:49that you move out of the auto regulation orientation into
- 12:53being regulated by the caregiver, but they don't come
- 12:57reliably enough where you learn to do it for yourself.
- 13:01So you remain dependent on the emotional regulation capacity of
- 13:06the other person. And because they're capacity to
- 13:10regulate you is so unreliable, you are often in a state of
- 13:16dysregulation. And so in some sense what you do
- 13:20is you learn to manage operating in life with a high level of
- 13:25emotional dysregulation. The way that dismissing people
- 13:33manage that is they suppress the sympathetic nervous system, they
- 13:38suppress the attachment system, and they hyperactivate the
- 13:49parasympathetic nervous system, which shuts down the emotions.
- 13:54So they don't, they don't react to the attachment system and
- 13:57they don't feel much. They're they're cognitive
- 14:02preoccupied people. It's the opposite of that.
- 14:04They're very spontaneous, but they don't monitor where the
- 14:08dismissing person really needs to pay attention to how to
- 14:12present to their caregivers what the caregivers want.
- 14:20And they can learn that well enough to be very good at
- 14:25predicting what to do and then doing it so that they get care
- 14:28and it's more reliable. But it is all cognitive.
- 14:34It's not feeling, whereas with the preoccupied, because there's
- 14:44no pattern in producing the the result, they don't put energy
- 14:49into learning to monitor. They're very spontaneous.
- 14:53They learn to ask over and over and over and over again for the
- 14:57thing that they want in somewhat modified ways because that's
- 15:03more predictive of getting the care that they need.
- 15:07You've seen small children with their caregivers, I would bet,
- 15:12out in public who just keep asking for the thing that they
- 15:15want from the caregiver because they never believed the no that
- 15:20the caregiver is giving them. They asked, the caregiver says
- 15:24no, they asked, the caregiver says no, They asked.
- 15:26The caregiver says no, They asked, the caregiver says no,
- 15:28they asked. And then the caregiver gets worn
- 15:31down from having to say no and says yes, which produces the
- 15:35narrative that I just have to keep asking or to get the thing
- 15:42and there's no continuity or plan.
- 15:45And in the giving in that way, do you really want a child
- 15:52understanding and directing the care that they receive?
- 15:56It doesn't really make sense, would it?
- 16:01George. I.
- 16:04So the first question is the preoccupation.
- 16:08Is it true to say that one of the skills that they have to
- 16:11learn is auto regulation is in some sense bringing the tension
- 16:17back? In the preoccupied person, the
- 16:23preoccupied person is looking for regulation in the other
- 16:30person. What they they usually do is
- 16:34enmesh with the mind state and also with the their empathetic
- 16:40experience of the emotion of the other person.
- 16:43And then they identify with the mind state of the other person
- 16:47and they identify with the empathetic experience of the
- 16:51other person's emotion. And then they regulate the other
- 16:56person and then regulating the other person, they feel
- 16:59regulated. So in some sense it's still an
- 17:02outward direction which we wouldn't necessarily call auto
- 17:06regulating. I'm sorry, I meant the skill
- 17:08that they need to learn when. The auto regulation.
- 17:13Right. They need yeah, we make a
- 17:15distinction between auto regulating and mastery of, of
- 17:19self regulation. The reason for that is that the
- 17:25mastery of self regulation is you get very good at regulating
- 17:29yourself, but you understand as soon as you can't regulate
- 17:31yourself, you turn to somebody who can help you.
- 17:35And it's one piece. It's not a back and forth.
- 17:37Whereas auto regulating, you just learn to regulate yourself
- 17:42and there's never the the this thought that you should turn
- 17:47towards somebody else to help you regulate.
- 17:52And why would there be nobody came reliably, never learned to
- 17:56regulate with someone else. You've always been an island to
- 18:00yourself. There's there was never a time
- 18:03when there was an experience of that happening.
- 18:07Most of the time when somebody who grows up to be dismissing in
- 18:11childhood would express themselves authentically, they
- 18:15would be rejected and the caregiver would insist that they
- 18:21present the point of view that the caregiver wanted.
- 18:25And so they also learn to protect their authentic
- 18:28experience and never reveal it to anyone because the pain of
- 18:33that continuous rejection in childhood is so deep.
- 18:38That's their terrible sadness that they they construct these
- 18:43elaborate defense mechanisms, which are highly inflated in
- 18:48order to protect themselves from that deep sadness around having
- 18:53been unwanted. Who they are authentically
- 18:58unwanted and instead who they're not is what was want.
- 19:06But there's but there's none of that long vision in preoccupied
- 19:13experience. It's all just short disconnected
- 19:17flashes of direction. There's no point in monitoring
- 19:22any. But it doesn't make sense.
- 19:23It actually it would be more distressing to attempt to make
- 19:27sense out of it. Instead, you've identified your
- 19:35own failing and and being able to predict what what response
- 19:41you need to make and you just keep making them.
- 19:45I call it hectoring and then eventually.
- 19:50It. Lines up as they like to say you
- 19:53put a monkey in front of a typewriter and at a certain
- 19:57point he'll he'll he'll type for who the bell tolls right just
- 20:02because it randomly falling into place that makes.
- 20:07Yeah. And then you use a measurement
- 20:09that that means what? That means that you can
- 20:14differentiate your own emotion from another emotion.
- 20:17Yeah, you don't. There's no distinguishing
- 20:20between self and other. There.
- 20:24There been a lot of cases no distinguishing between.
- 20:27Inside and outside. That this is my opinion and it's
- 20:32your opinion. This is where I end.
- 20:34And this is where you start. Nope.
- 20:38It's so funny, I know. I thought I was like wait a
- 20:40second, these are like advanced practices also.
- 20:44Right. The practice.
- 20:46Is deliberation. Yeah.
- 20:48The practice is see where you end and see and you can't find
- 20:52the boundary. So is it?
- 20:54Is that the same? But you're not losing the
- 20:57boundary in someone else and identifying yourself and them as
- 21:04one. So you can't identify the
- 21:08boundary in a mesh minute, it's just including two people in
- 21:13dissolving that boundary and just being energy in space.
- 21:18Exactly that. There's neither here, or neither
- 21:20there, neither third so. That's the right.
- 21:25In this case you're saying and pre occupation is we both are
- 21:29one. Right, 1 + 1 = 1 is the
- 21:34formulation. And then lastly, I've seen this
- 21:38preoccupation you use in adults where this is it the same, I
- 21:44don't know the example that the person would speak again and
- 21:48again and again. And I'm not sure you what do you
- 21:55mean by like eventually clicks with somebody, What's the
- 21:58eventually you know? The bell tolls.
- 22:05If you have a small child, say I want this doll.
- 22:08No, can't have the doll. I want this doll with the blue
- 22:11dress. Don't, can't have the doll.
- 22:13I want this doll with the red curls.
- 22:15Don't, can't have the doll. I want this doll that has the
- 22:18black shoes. Can't have the doll on and on
- 22:22and on and on. And the child keeps going.
- 22:24They never stop. And then the the parent finally
- 22:28says, oh, all right, you could have it.
- 22:31And then the child gets the doll and what the child understands
- 22:36is the no isn't real and that they just asked wrong.
- 22:44And so they just ask again. I just ask again, again, again,
- 22:48again, again. And then they become
- 22:51inconsolable if you if you don't acquiesce because they.
- 22:58Saying please again and again. The kids do if they want
- 23:00something. Yeah.
- 23:01Please, please, please, how does this appear in adults?
- 23:06Because there was somebody that I met recently, I was kind of
- 23:10getting triggered because this person would tend to speak her
- 23:13personal experience and one stop and I wasn't sure.
- 23:20Well, the the asking and the. Sometimes what they ask is, is
- 23:30proximity seeking, right? So all they need is to be
- 23:33proximate to they they enmesh almost immediately they begin to
- 23:39emotionally regulate you. And the thing that makes them
- 23:42feel safe, which keeps the abandonment here at Bay, is
- 23:47actual physical proximity to you.
- 23:51And there are certain things that cue to them that the
- 23:56proximity is going to be lost. And one of them is that you stop
- 24:00paying attention to them. And So what they learn to do is
- 24:06to begin to engage with you in such a way that you'll pay
- 24:10attention to them. So they're asking you about
- 24:14things, where they're telling you a story.
- 24:16And what you notice in the way that they do that is that they
- 24:20don't leave a gap between the sentences or the words that they
- 24:25say. That's the first indication
- 24:27because in a normal conversation, you present an
- 24:30idea and leave a gap so the other person can respond.
- 24:34And then they make their contribution and then they leave
- 24:38a gap so you can respond. If you look at it in terms of
- 24:42the structure of a conversation, that means each of you are are
- 24:46holding up your side of the conversation.
- 24:49But in somebody who violates the the maxim crisis maxim, the
- 24:56maximum of quantity, they don't leave the space because they
- 25:00want all the attention on themselves, because that's the
- 25:05thing that makes them safe. It relieves the abandonment
- 25:08anxiety. So in order to get your side of
- 25:12the conversation in, you have to interrupt them.
- 25:14And a lot of the times they're counting on your politeness that
- 25:21you won't do that right, which is a manipulation.
- 25:26Or walk away. I I couldn't do that.
- 25:28It was just. Yeah, or walk away.
- 25:31And actually that's the thing that happens most often is they
- 25:34everybody walks away. It breaks up the conversation
- 25:37when somebody does that and that they find confusing because they
- 25:41had finally gotten the attention sort of go ahead.
- 25:45Is this a typical disorganized? No, this is a.
- 25:52Typical. Preoccupied strategy, I mean,
- 25:54I'm sorry, I'm sorry, preoccupied is that is this a
- 25:57typical trait? Yeah, it's a typical.
- 26:00It's not because they it, it's because they don't have a pause
- 26:04because they're so trained not to be able to get what they want
- 26:13that they're at. Well, it's not.
- 26:16It's that getting the attention is unpredictable and they have
- 26:19no way of knowing how they would get it back if they lose it, so
- 26:22they hold on to. It.
- 26:25If they understood that they they leave a gap and the other
- 26:28person responds and then leaves a gap and then you just get the
- 26:31attention right back, they would be able to enter into a more
- 26:36secure dynamic. But because they find getting
- 26:39the attention back so unpredictable, they feel.
- 26:45Unsafe and getting it. Does that make sense?
- 26:52Yes, disorganized people talk in riddles, which is different.
- 27:02Disorganized people will say something that they want to
- 27:05communicate to you, but they'll wrap it up in a baroque cover so
- 27:10that if it doesn't land in the way that they anticipated it
- 27:14would land, they can make it into something else and that way
- 27:18protect their vulnerability that their authenticity.
- 27:25But a preoccupied person doesn't do that because they don't
- 27:27monitor in the same way. Now the other thing that
- 27:32preoccupied people do is they they'll join a conversation and
- 27:36then in two sentences they'll switch the topic without
- 27:39consent. And then if the conversation
- 27:42gets going again and they lose attention when they get it back,
- 27:46they'll switch the topic of the conversation again without
- 27:51consent. You can license the change of a
- 27:55topic in a conversation where everyone will go along, but
- 27:59preoccupied people don't tend to license it.
- 28:01They just tend to switch it. And what they're really
- 28:04attempting to do is switch the conversation to a topic that
- 28:08only they can can talk about because nobody else has
- 28:13knowledge of it. And the reason that they do that
- 28:16is because it relieves the pressure of people wanting to
- 28:19chime in because nobody has anything to say.
- 28:24And that's the thing that typically leads to the end of
- 28:28the conversation because nobody has any interest in the topic
- 28:32that has been arrived at. And this is confusing for the
- 28:38preoccupied person because they finally land at a topic where
- 28:42only they can talk about it, and then the conversation breaks up.
- 28:47We did. So I'm realizing something is
- 28:50that that's it's not just physical proximity like a quiet
- 28:55preoccupied one be happy because he has or she has physical
- 29:00proximity, but. The attention also needs to be
- 29:02on the the. Proximity and attention.
- 29:07Both. That's the reason that they're
- 29:10famous. I mean, they're we, we, you
- 29:13know, we see them as the people who talk too much.
- 29:15Or is that the the reason? Well, they talk too much if if
- 29:21they have if they if that's the strategy that they're using.
- 29:25Another strategy, of course, is to elicit from you.
- 29:30So they present you a fake problem, then you offer them
- 29:33solutions to the problem. It doesn't matter to them
- 29:36whether you can solve the problem or not because you're
- 29:39paying attention to them. So it's not always that they're
- 29:44doing all the talking. They could be just provoking you
- 29:47to talk to them, and that would be also satisfying.
- 29:52But what really is happening is all of the attention is focused
- 29:55on now, your attention is really on trying to solve their
- 29:59problem, but it's a fake problem and it doesn't need a solution.
- 30:02So they don't really care about that.
- 30:06And if you solve the problem, this is what I call the helpless
- 30:09loop. They present a problem to you
- 30:14and you offer them a genuine solution and they reject the
- 30:18solution and re present the problem.
- 30:21That's the hectoring again. That's the asking.
- 30:24Again, that process of asking. And then you offer them a
- 30:28different solution and they reject that and represent the
- 30:31problem. And then you offer them another
- 30:33solution and they reject that and represent the problem.
- 30:37And all of a sudden you're beginning to have these feelings
- 30:40of helplessness because it doesn't matter what solution you
- 30:46offer, they're always going to reject it because they associate
- 30:51an actual solution to a real problem as the end of the need
- 30:54for proximity, which they don't want.
- 30:57And then it even goes into into sex.
- 31:01They'll have problems in sex either delaying their own orgasm
- 31:05or delaying delaying your orgasm.
- 31:09Because if they associate your orgasm with the end of sex,
- 31:13which is the end of proximity, since they're not actually there
- 31:17for sexual gratification, but they're there for proximity,
- 31:25it's never satisfactory. You never come to a great climax
- 31:30because that would be the end. So there's always problems
- 31:34there. Or that's one of the the main
- 31:37ways that it's relatable. There's a sense of coming to an
- 31:41end. It's almost like they have this,
- 31:45I don't know, loss or, or the sense that this will come in to
- 31:48an end. So they are not in the moment.
- 31:52And that causes the earthquake of abandonment tear to go go off
- 31:59and then the strategies to entangle you preoccupied People
- 32:08use pretend problems, but there's always an implicit ask
- 32:16associated with them. I'll do this for you if you do
- 32:20that for me. But the you do that for me is
- 32:23never expressed. It's only, oh, I'm going to be
- 32:26generous and do this. And then if you don't pick up on
- 32:31that, that implicit aspect of the contract, and you don't
- 32:36fulfill it, even though it's never been presented and you've
- 32:39never agreed to do it, they become enraged at you.
- 32:49Preoccupied people presented three different ways.
- 32:52One is fearfully preoccupied. So it's all about fear and the
- 32:58reassurance around fear. Angrily preoccupied is this sort
- 33:03of badgering expression of anger that you haven't fulfilled your
- 33:10promises even if you didn't make them.
- 33:12And then passively preoccupied really looks on the outside like
- 33:18somebody who's dismissing. The difference between a
- 33:22passively preoccupied person and a dismissing person is that when
- 33:26the dismissing person shuts down, it's quiet in there, not
- 33:31much going on. And in a passively preoccupied
- 33:35person, it's a it's just, you know, this churning upset on the
- 33:42inside with no outwardly expression quite different.
- 33:50It's not making sense. So the way out of preoccupation
- 34:02is to come out of pretend mode mainly, and move in the
- 34:11direction of authenticity in order to.
- 34:16You, you, you sometimes talk about how we deal with people
- 34:21that are preoccupied. And then there's if you are
- 34:28because I am preoccupied. And so when you say that, are
- 34:31you talking about, is it a, a preoccupied person can come out
- 34:35of it or the person that the preoccupied person is dealing
- 34:39with can come out of it with what you're about to say?
- 34:43I was going to talk about how a preoccupied person can come out
- 34:46of preoccupation. OK.
- 34:50Thank you. The main shift is coming out of
- 34:58pretend mode and the way that that really looks is you move
- 35:02from an inauthentic presentation to an authentic presentation.
- 35:10Another way to put that is you move from the the artificial
- 35:15presentation of what you're doing with the implicit
- 35:18understanding of what you want back from it to an explicit
- 35:23expression of what what it is that you're doing.
- 35:29So that you have to say explicitly what you're willing
- 35:32to do and what you expect in return for it, rather than
- 35:36offered to do something for somebody and leave the the
- 35:41return out of it. You then have to train your
- 35:49attention to disengage from the empathetic experience of other
- 35:54people and from the mind state of other people, and turn your
- 35:58attention to your own emotional state and your own mind state.
- 36:03And then you need to begin to learn to regulate your own
- 36:06emotions so that you're not dependent on other people to
- 36:10regulate your emotions. We have different meditation
- 36:16strategies for that, so that you learn, you have developed
- 36:21clarity on your own emotions and you develop strategies for
- 36:24regulating your own emotions. Coming out of pretend mode where
- 36:30you're actually expressing yourself authentically is hard.
- 36:36And part of it is a cognitive decision that you need to make.
- 36:39But you you haven't developed your cognitive mind very much.
- 36:44You have to develop your cognitive mind to understand why
- 36:47you would want to do that. You have to begin to monitor in
- 36:52order to be able to do that. And so the training is to learn
- 36:56to monitor your thoughts and your mind states, learn to
- 37:01monitor your own emotions and learn to regulate your own
- 37:03emotions. This.
- 37:04There's a lot more to do in in correcting this for a
- 37:09preoccupied person than for what a dismissing person needs to do.
- 37:15Once you've been able to increase your mentalizing
- 37:20capacity or cognition enough that you can begin to discern
- 37:30what you like to do, what you find meaningful to do from what
- 37:34you don't, then you can begin the process of developing
- 37:39exploration, your own primary exploration, so that you can
- 37:46derive meaning from the life that you have.
- 37:50One of the things about preoccupied people is they don't
- 37:56tend to explore, not because there's a defect in the capacity
- 38:01to explore, but because it was so interfered with by your
- 38:05caregivers demands on you in childhood that you didn't really
- 38:09learn to do it. Once you begin to explore, then
- 38:17you have the prerequisites for entering into a secure,
- 38:21functioning relationship because exploration is one of the vital
- 38:25pieces. The exchange of discoveries, the
- 38:30exchange of information about your explorations really causes
- 38:36those relationships to sail along for decades.
- 38:42And a lot of cases, because they're so meaningful, most of
- 38:52the time you're going to have to renegotiate relationships with
- 38:54other people because. But this one of the the usual
- 38:58strategies for preoccupied people is to take on the care of
- 39:03the other person, not as a generosity for providing care,
- 39:10but attempting to. Elicit their dependency on you
- 39:16taking care of them. It's one of the ways, yeah, you
- 39:22elicit, you take care of them. You take care of them for
- 39:26things. You take care of things that
- 39:31they should really do for themselves so that they'll
- 39:34become dependent on you and won't be able to leave you
- 39:37because of it. That that's how you're
- 39:40assuaging? The earthquake of abandonment
- 39:43here you figure that you do all these things for them.
- 39:46They would never leave you because they would then have to
- 39:49again do them for themselves. You need to stop doing that
- 39:56because all of that is consuming the energy that you need for
- 39:59your own exploration, and it doesn't actually relieve the
- 40:04anxiety enough to be worthwhile. The abandonment terror is that
- 40:09constant, unrelenting, ongoing anxiety that they're about to
- 40:14leave you. One of the things that
- 40:18preoccupied people tend to do is throw down ultimatums, which are
- 40:24some form of if you don't do this, I'm leaving because
- 40:29they're they're so insecure about the stability of the
- 40:35relationship. But it doesn't seem like a big
- 40:38risk, would it? I'm sorry, why would the
- 40:43preoccupy do that? If he or she will face the the
- 40:49consequences of abandonment, if they say is that I will leave
- 40:53you or why would they say that? Because they're burning out and
- 41:00they're dissatisfied with the relationship and.
- 41:06It the all of the stuff that they do for the other person
- 41:11that provides the care for them is why they think the other
- 41:14person is wanting them. And if they threatened to
- 41:18withdraw it, but they're hoping to elicit from the other person
- 41:22is reassurance that they don't want them to leave.
- 41:28Is that making sense? I I do all the care for you.
- 41:31If I leave, you're not taken care of so I can threaten to
- 41:35withdraw that care from you and that will force you to fold
- 41:39because you can't really do it for yourself.
- 41:43It's not true, but it appears to be true.
- 41:52The but also understand that on the other side, dismissing
- 41:57people tend to seduce, seduce, seduce until they really think
- 42:00that you're hooked on their seduction and then they begin to
- 42:04withdraw. So the the preoccupied person is
- 42:07always in this perception of pursuing the other person, and
- 42:11when they get fed up, they stomp their feet and threaten to turn
- 42:16away and go. But what they're hoping is that
- 42:18then the person will flip and the seduction will start again.
- 42:25So it's a way of maintaining distance.
- 42:30The the preoccupied person withdraws, withdraws, they don't
- 42:34believe, they don't believe and then they're seduced.
- 42:37And then the dismissing person withdraws and then they pursue
- 42:40the dismissing person. But when the preoccupied person
- 42:44burns out, they're not going to follow.
- 42:48And then they make the grand gesture of walking away, hoping
- 42:53that in three steps they'll be spun around and reunion will
- 42:58happen. And a lot of the time that that
- 43:03is what happens. But some of the time it it
- 43:05doesn't. And then you'll notice the
- 43:09dismissing person in that dynamic has replaced you in a
- 43:13few days. And it's absolutely madding.
- 43:17That's when you go into that sort of total collapse, which is
- 43:24the plunge into the the terrible sadness.
- 43:30One of the other things that happens to preoccupied people is
- 43:32you present this pretend, pretend, pretend.
- 43:36And then as you begin to move out of that into an authentic
- 43:40expression, what do you discover is that the authentic expression
- 43:44is as successful in getting your needs met as the pretend mode
- 43:48was. And that really is
- 43:50heartbreaking, really plunges you into the terrible sad, and
- 43:55that all the way along or a long distance of the way along, you
- 44:00could have been asking for the things that you wanted, you
- 44:03could have been presenting your authentic needs, and that would
- 44:06have been met just as well as to pretend was that that projection
- 44:11of the caregivers who you have to pretend and everybody else
- 44:16was wrong. That's what happens in some
- 44:21sense. If you can't present
- 44:23authentically, you self exclude from secure functioning
- 44:26relationships because they don't do that, they don't accept it.
- 44:35But I don't think also part of the terrible sadness for
- 44:39preoccupied people is that we learn to lie in order to be
- 44:43preoccupied. Not only do we learn to lie, we
- 44:45get really good at it 'cause we have to sell these pretend
- 44:50notions to other people. And so we're we get really good
- 44:53at it. But it wasn't easy to learn
- 44:56that. It was excruciatingly painful
- 44:59and it caused the loss of ourselves.
- 45:06So that's another thing. You're coming out of this
- 45:08pretend self into your authentic self, and your pretend self is
- 45:14really accomplished, really developed.
- 45:17And your authentic self is a clutz and not stumbling around.
- 45:21It doesn't have any of the finesse that your pretend self
- 45:26has. And sometimes the skills are
- 45:29transferable, but sometimes they're not.
- 45:31And so you have this slow period of developing the inauthentic
- 45:36self to be as accomplished as the false self.
- 45:43Was that that I find painful a lot of the time.
- 45:55One of the because preoccupied people don't monitor
- 46:03particularly well, they never really understood consent very
- 46:07well. Dismissing people understand
- 46:11consent. They understand they have to
- 46:14license these things, and they do, but they mainly do it
- 46:18through seduction. And seduction the way that
- 46:26dismissing people do it is really about telling the other
- 46:29person what that person wants to hear, which is different from
- 46:35pretending to be somebody else in order to get care.
- 46:39The dismissing person is really first they elicit from you what
- 46:44you want them to tell you, and then they spin it into this
- 46:47amazing version. And it's so intoxicating when
- 46:51they do it well. But they never intend to follow
- 46:56through on anything because it's the delivery of this, the spin
- 47:00job, which is what they're trading, not the actual doing of
- 47:04it. So the reason why that works so
- 47:10well with preoccupied people is they're pretending it's a
- 47:12problem, it's not a real problem, so it doesn't need a
- 47:14real solution. So there's no deficit in that.
- 47:19Whereas with a with somebody who was actually expecting a real
- 47:24solution, the the idealized response against the dismissing
- 47:32person into trouble because they don't deliver.
- 47:35That makes sense. So the terrible sadness of the
- 47:46preoccupied person is the recognition that all this way
- 47:51along where they've been pretending to be somebody else
- 47:55who they really were was good enough and that they could have
- 48:00made a life where people were actually responsive to them, to
- 48:05their authentic expression. And there's a process of pushing
- 48:12through that the the negative reaction, the negative
- 48:18anticipation to what will happen if you present your authentic
- 48:22self so that you can would it. What are the most?
- 48:29Common things with in in my life, what I've been or seeing
- 48:36with people my. Age would be.
- 48:39Introversion versus extroversion How we idolize extroversion as
- 48:46being so you should be. Right.
- 48:49Is that also considered inauthentic or is that?
- 48:53Just a skill. That people say, oh, you can.
- 48:55You can be an extrovert, you just have to learn that skill.
- 48:58I'm never sure of that. So I think we need a little
- 49:03definition here. When you say introversion and
- 49:06extroversion, to me, what I hear is an introvert is working with
- 49:16goals and achievements that are internal to them and don't
- 49:21necessarily reflect the societal values.
- 49:27And an extrovert is somebody who's organized around gathering
- 49:31the external tokens of success and an orientation like that.
- 49:39But it can also mean that you're, you're not not
- 49:45expressive particularly or lively and engaging with people.
- 49:52If you attach that to the original meaning you're, you
- 49:58don't really have much of A need to express what you're working
- 50:03on achieving because it's personal to you and whether you
- 50:08get it or not matters to you and you're not expecting much in the
- 50:12way of external approbation. But the extrovert of course, is
- 50:21going for the trophy. They want that adulation that
- 50:26comes from that or they want the house or the the car or whatever
- 50:29it is the social position because that's the thing that
- 50:34makes them feel satisfied achieving.
- 50:39So it really does. Then what was your family?
- 50:48What was your family's orientation toward introversion
- 50:52or extroversion? And how well did you have the
- 50:57skills that made skills that were necessary to pursue the
- 51:01family's choice of what was meaningful?
- 51:06So that if you feel pressure to achieve in a very conventional
- 51:10way, you might find the extroversion preferable as a
- 51:16means of getting it if there was a more internal more in the
- 51:24family system. This is where you learn it,
- 51:26obviously in the family system and what you're rewarded for.
- 51:34And then you have of course, what what is, what is it that
- 51:38you're good at? What is it that you find
- 51:41meaningful? And how well does that line up
- 51:45with the family system and the demands that they have for you
- 51:49in the system? Do you have secure parents who
- 51:55were interested in what mattered to you what what were interested
- 51:59in what you were good at and encouraged and supported you to
- 52:03to do that and then supported you gathering the skills that
- 52:07you needed to do it? Or did they have an idea of what
- 52:10the family needed of you and push you in the direction of
- 52:15achieving that, whether it was meaningful to you or not or
- 52:19whether you were good at it or not?
- 52:23And that comes from the same misattunement that causes
- 52:27insecure and disorganized attachment or security with
- 52:32features where they just don't really.
- 52:34They're not paying attention to you and supporting you.
- 52:37They're paying attention to themselves and what matters to
- 52:42them. You know, if you look at my
- 52:46family system, my brother, my older brother was pushed toward
- 52:55the Ivy League because my parents were Ivy.
- 52:59My younger brother and my younger system were pushed
- 53:02toward ordinary level of college achievement because the older
- 53:09brother was taking care of that piece and they weren't.
- 53:13They wouldn't pay for my education because they didn't
- 53:17think I needed to an education because they decided that I was
- 53:21going to be the child that stayed home and took care of
- 53:25them when they got older. So all of us had the experience
- 53:32of really disinterest in who we were and what mattered to us and
- 53:40really were set into the roles of an, an upwardly mobile, you
- 53:49know, immigrant family really be like, you know, 2 generations
- 53:55out. We were poor Irish, poor German.
- 54:02So that's the thing. And then how do you, you know,
- 54:08whenever you're put in a position as a child to develop a
- 54:12skill set that is external to you, you do your very best to
- 54:18develop, but there aren't children that refuse.
- 54:20It's that isn't really what happens.
- 54:24But then you get to a place later in your life where
- 54:27actually you have some agency in choosing what you want to do.
- 54:32And then you see what it is. And then when we begin to look
- 54:40at the, you know, the misogyny. Extraversion is masculine.
- 54:47Introversion is a feminine. What happens if you're a male
- 54:51and you're you're introverted? You there's enormous societal
- 54:54pressure to change that because it's otherwise you're
- 54:58acquiescing to being feminine. Or if you're a female and you're
- 55:06ex and you're extroverted, there's pressure on you to tone
- 55:10it down because it's too masculine.
- 55:16But it feels like my. That's my it's not my family
- 55:20system, but it's mine. Right.
- 55:23Feels like that. Where did it come from, though?
- 55:28The you know, we start off as a family.
- 55:29By the time we're three, we're pretty much locked into what
- 55:32they want. And then we take that off to the
- 55:35playground. That's the second part.
- 55:38And then we try to fit into the social hierarchy of the.
- 55:42Of the the elementary school, which is, you know, a vicious
- 55:46place. But it can't happen in college.
- 55:54Well, certainly, but in college it's the conflict resolution
- 55:57themes, which is the third set of attachment experiences.
- 56:03And it's also aided by the fact that your cognitive mind is so
- 56:08much more capable in in college than it was in elementary school
- 56:15or middle school. And also there's for most people
- 56:23sex drive for some kind of sexual interest that arises that
- 56:29wants to be satisfied. And that, you know, the
- 56:34hierarchy of sexual desirability is it's better to be on the top
- 56:39of that than on the bottom. Because people are so cruel
- 56:46about it. And then of course, it's, you
- 56:50know, homophobic beyond belief even now.
- 56:53I mean, with this administration, I mean, you
- 56:58know, well, they're probably already building camps to load
- 57:02all the trans people into. I mean, it's so ridiculous.
- 57:06And then who's right after the trans people?
- 57:08You know, it's not like they're stopping there.
- 57:13So what happens when you know you're not a monogamous sispair
- 57:25of heteros? What happens to you, right?
- 57:29You're slaughtered basically in in the way our our culture
- 57:34teaches sexual expression and, and you see it everywhere, the
- 57:39casualties of people that don't fit into that.
- 57:46And it's completely unnecessarily, you know, I mean,
- 57:50even Freud in the in the 1890s wrote a paper that said that he
- 57:57could find nothing about homosexuality, that that was
- 58:02wrong. It was just an ordinary
- 58:03variation and, and human sexuality.
- 58:06I mean the basis of of that prejudice is, is not about the
- 58:13ordinariness of it or the, the appropriateness of it.
- 58:18So well, we have a few minutes left.
- 58:28Do you want to do a little bit of meditation?
- 58:31Yes. May may I make a request?
- 58:37Sure. This was a very boy you, you hit
- 58:41a lot of spots on this that brought back a lot of very
- 58:46painful memories of my childhood.
- 58:48So anything with this healing in it would be appreciated from my
- 58:51point of view. Let's do some loving kindness
- 58:54practice then. All right, If that's OK with
- 58:57Moody. Yeah.
- 59:00So go ahead and settle in, closing the eyes, scanning
- 59:03through the body. OK, Let go of the meditation.
- 59:19How's that? Good.
- 59:26Very good. Good.
- 59:29Thank you. When I do this practice the the
- 59:33mind state is different, but the sense that if I send it to the
- 59:37whole of me then there is these unpleasant feelings and thoughts
- 59:43that come up. It's almost like I'm blocking
- 59:46it, but as soon as I do, my teller is like we're going to
- 59:49accept the whole thing. But then there are these random
- 59:52unpleasant thoughts. Can you view the thoughts
- 59:57through the through the mind state?
- 1:00:02It's view the thoughts or view myself when I was in the scene.
- 1:00:08Before, well you have a thought and you you have the filter of
- 1:00:16love and kindness and you look through the filter at the
- 1:00:19thought so that it changes the the intensity of the thought.
- 1:00:26For me, it's considering the surrounding air to be the view.
- 1:00:34I can all love you because I'm the one in the, you know, So
- 1:00:38it's almost like the air is the the view and the air is sending
- 1:00:44it back to me, if that makes sense.
- 1:00:46Great. Thank you.
- 1:00:53So Saturday is the second day of the meditation and attachment
- 1:01:04level one class. The following Saturday, the
- 1:01:0627th, is the third day, if you want to jump on that.
- 1:01:11We have a kaleidoscope coming up on the 26th, which is the the
- 1:01:15monthly gathering of the Sangha. Let's see here what else is
- 1:01:23happening in September, Sorry, in January.
- 1:01:38October is what I read. On the 11th is the intermediate
- 1:01:44mentalizing a class, and on the 18th is the advanced mentalizing
- 1:01:53class. This is really about exploration
- 1:01:56and how to explore what the additional mentalizing skills
- 1:02:00you'll need beyond the basics. And then on October 21st, we're
- 1:02:09starting a level two class. So that's what's coming up.
- 1:02:17We sent out a inquiry as to whether people would want to do
- 1:02:22a virtual retreat, and we got a really good response to that.
- 1:02:29So we're going to schedule a retreat from December 29th until
- 1:02:37January 2nd, which is going to be virtual so that you might be
- 1:02:42able to do it. So if you want to.
- 1:02:47So that's everything that's coming up.
- 1:02:51George, have you ever considered using what your curriculum is to
- 1:02:59do a course on forgiveness? I could do with, in the,
- 1:03:08sometimes in the level 1 addiction class, we do a
- 1:03:11forgiveness, but I, I could actually do a day on a day, 1/2
- 1:03:16day on forgiveness. If that works, maybe it's
- 1:03:20something I'd be very, I, it's something I have the most
- 1:03:26challenging relationship with is forgiving.
- 1:03:29You know, all the part, part of this attachment stuff that we're
- 1:03:33doing is I have to be able to forgive the caregivers and
- 1:03:37forgive myself to move as part of my path.
- 1:03:41And I just hold on to what I'm upset with and use it as an
- 1:03:48excuse more often than I'd like. And if you had one every month,
- 1:03:53I would take that one every single month until I get it
- 1:03:56right because it's I, I don't, I think it's part of my path of
- 1:03:59becoming secure. I agree.
- 1:04:02And another place you might look to do it is in IPF, because we
- 1:04:08ideal parent figure protocol. Ah, OK.
- 1:04:11We do a lot. There's a lot of focus on seeing
- 1:04:14the caregivers the way that they were and understanding what
- 1:04:17happened. OK, so it's not actually part of
- 1:04:22that process. Good to see you.
- 1:04:26Ioffer the teaching freely. But I do hope if you're
- 1:04:28resourced and you can make a donation, you will.
- 1:04:31There's a link on the website to do that.
- 1:04:33I hope to see you soon somewhere.
- 1:04:34Along the path. Thank you, George.
- 1:04:38Right, I know.