Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Three Biggest Questions, Used Car Week, NAVIcon with Steve Greenfield
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is November 3rd, Friday, rolling in hot. Um, we're kind of gearing up for next week. Kyle and I's first visit to Used Car Week. So we're gonna have- Yeah...
- 0:11Steve Greenfield on the show today to talk about it. Everywhere I go. 'Cause he is a Used Car Week veteran. Who I is and who I was. Professional. Profession- I've been staying late.
- 0:19This is, this is actually, this is just a completely selfish, like, what are we getting ourselves into? [laughs] Yeah, right. We're like, let's, let's try not to- It's the whole reason why we're here...
- 0:27how do we not embarrass ourselves? Actually, I don't know if anyone could advise us well on that, because it's bound to happen. We're gonna embarrass ourselves at some point. You're rolling in embarrassing ourselves.
- 0:35But, but Used Car Week is an event that we've been hearing about, and every year we're like, "Hey, we have to go to Used Car Week next, n- next year." Yep. And this- Yeah... is the year it finally happened.
- 0:43Basically, we said that last year about SEMA too, and we didn't make it this year. Didn't make it. And, and now that- We've still got time for CES potentially, so. That's true. Yeah. That, when is that? Wait, no.
- 0:54Wait, did we just miss CES or SEMA? Oh. Now I'm getting them mixed up. No, we met, S- wait, SEMA's going on right now. No. We're missing SEMA. Yeah. There we go. It's over.
- 1:01CES is in January, so we got option, we got options. Man. We got options. I don't know. I don't know. But either way, uh, we're getting ready to be wheels up next week. But we have Steve Greenfield on the show.
- 1:11Nathan, bring Steve in. I don't know where he's gonna be. Where in the world- There he is... where in the world is Steve Greenfield? Yeah. Steve, I saw him- I'm-... down there. He was in the green room side.
- 1:19He was like, "These guys." [laughs] "They don't even know what's going on." He's like, "I'm reconsidering my decision." [laughs] He's like, "If they read my weekly email, I tell you what." We do. We do, actually. Yeah.
- 1:28Yeah. We do. We do. Well, I'm in, I'm in a rental car in a, a Hertz rental car at Midway Airport, in the parking garage. Here I am. In Midway. You have really good- Okay, wait. In Midway. Start with that.
- 1:40You, 'cause you're all over the, you're all over the country, sometimes in a rental car, sometimes in an Uber. Like, what's the anecdotal evidence- [laughs]... on the rental industry right now?
- 1:49[laughs] Especially in Chicago. Um, yeah, lo- lot- lots of EVs. Lots of EVs. Although, although I don't know if you saw the news this week, earlier this week. Right.
- 1:57Hertz has said that they're gonna no- the commitment of 100,000 Teslas, they're, they're gonna, uh, pull back on that now. One, because prices are so volatile.
- 2:06I mean, they're sitting with a lot of cars that are worth a lot less because of these price dis- discounts. Sure. Yeah. But al- al- al- also just repair costs apparently.
- 2:13So- When they, when they do have repairs, it takes a long time to get Tesla repairs. Because initially, when, I remember this story, like, six months ago, Kyle and I were talking about it.
- 2:21They were like, "Hey, our, our maintenance costs are way down because of the EVs." Yep. "This is gonna be great. Stock goes up," right? But now it's like, oh, but if there's a repair- Ah...
- 2:31it kind of flips the- Different, yes... 'cause we were, we were trying to figure that out. We're like, wait, didn't they just say that it was cheaper? But, you know, repairs, I guess. That's the thing.
- 2:39I mean, yeah, yeah, regular maintenance, what, what do you have to do? You change tires once in a while. There's no oil changes or anything. Wiper blades.
- 2:44But yeah, I mean, if, if you do get in a, you know, a bumper crash or something, these things take a long time apparently to fix. Yep. Well, there you go. Yeah. Well, they know they have one renter. Imagine that.
- 2:53They have one renter in you. Steve, you are definitely a Used Car Week veteran. Why do you like the event? Like, what's the unique proposition of Used Car Week versus some of the other events out there?
- 3:03Ah, so you have to go back in history actually, 'cause, you know, I, I, I spent 10 years at Manheim, so I was in the remarketing world very, very deep.
- 3:10And we used to have, like, two weeks in a row where we were basically parked in Las Vegas with three different conferences. So- [laughs]...
- 3:17the history is Used Car Week is actually an amalgamation of, like, three conferences that converged, like, a decade ago or something. No way. So- Ah...
- 3:25instead of being in Vegas now three, two weeks in a row, uh, you're actually, you know, very efficiently in and out in, like, three days. In Phoenix. In Phoenix. Yeah.
- 3:34Okay, so what were the original- They were, they were big around... what were the original three- Oh, does it?... two or three things that happened? Oh, now, now you're gonna make me remember events. Yeah.
- 3:40[laughs] Well, w- w- w- one was remarketing. One was, like, um, a finance-related conference. And I think one might have been, like, a, a repossession. Infla- Someone's gonna call me out on this for sure.
- 3:49Inflatable gorilla suit maintenance- I should have known... conference. [laughs] Exactly. Exactly.
- 3:53But they were, they were, they were, they were all roughly, like, used car related, but they, they realized they were greatly inconveniencing all these people and, uh, stretching the audience over two weeks. So they...
- 4:02I mean, I, I think it's worked well. You'll, you'll find when you guys are there, you know, next week, there's a lot of people that show up for this conference. Great.
- 4:08Yeah, no, I think, like, looking at the attendee list, which is something that they post, which is a little bit different than a lot of other conferences- For sure...
- 4:14like, yes, you see some dealers, but there's actually a high level of interest across, like, financing and remarketing and, and used car operators that are more, like, n- national level used car operators or shippers or, or things like that.
- 4:31It w- it's like a much more broad industry partner look. Most of these events, outside of maybe NADA, you, you really are narrow in the type of industry partners, but this is way more broad.
- 4:43And I'm guessing that's- Yeah, it's, it's-... 'cause of the content. And it's awesome, dude. I can tell you this.
- 4:47Like, as you get closer to transportation conferences, and then at the far end, uh, repo conferences, the number of piercings and tattoos- [laughs]... per square inch of body- I knew that was coming... goes up great.
- 4:58So, I mean, depending on which room you're in there and who you're meeting with, I mean, it's, there's some wild and crazy characters at these conferences. You know what I, I hear, I hear- Amazing...
- 5:06a SoTo audience expansion is what I hear. There you go. Yes. You guys fit right in. I, I think you guys are right. We're actually gonna be at a conference- I think you're gonna be exactly where you guys need...
- 5:13with flat bills, where everybody's gonna be like, "That's normal." No, they're not even gonna think about it. We're gonna be like, "Dude, we need some tattoos quick." [laughs] Right?
- 5:20You guys will need tattoos to fit in here. Yeah, exactly. Easy, easy. So, um, we're going into the week.
- 5:24What are the, what are the one, two topics that you think are gonna be top of mind, uh, or the top of the conversation? What are we gonna walk away from, you know, hearing throughout the halls?
- 5:36Well, I, I think, I mean, it's, it's, you know, it's almost passe now, but, you know, E- EVs are a, a big thing. A- a- in this world that you guys are going into next week, it's more about these residual values, right?
- 5:46So Hertz is, is a good example. But there's a lot of fleets out there that have EVs, and with all the price cuts that Tesla's done, it's really disrupted.
- 5:55I mean, if, if you're sitting on 100,000 EVs right now and prices drop by 5,000 or 10,000 retail- Oh, man... I mean, no, it's, it's a real, real problem. Man.
- 6:04And then, you know, the flip side of that is, like, if you, if you, if you're, like, you know, uh, basically originating, you know, vehicles into a fleetAnd you're trying to forecast what an EV's gonna be worth in three years.
- 6:15Well, good luck- Yeah... right now. Yeah. Uh, because of the volatility. And, and, and without the, have some certainty around what that residual value's gonna be in, in three years, I mean, you, you can't...
- 6:25So, so a lot, a lot of these guys are like, "We don't wanna put EVs into fleet."
- 6:29You're, you're, you're hearing a lot of dealers in the used car departments won't even take EVs on trade-in because they don't wanna take the ri- Well, one is, how do you appraise them?
- 6:38And then the flip side is, like- Yeah. Yeah, you appraise it- You don't want-... and then you hold it for 15 days. All of a sudden, the price changed $7,000, and now you're holding the bag. Yeah.
- 6:46This is a bi- a, a big issue, a b- a big issue.
- 6:49And, and you need a really stable and healthy ecosystem of used vehicles in order for, like, new cars e- go either into fleets like Hertz or even for a consumer to say, "Look, I don't wanna buy a Tesla right now because it, it could be worth a lot less tomorrow, the day after I buy it."
- 7:03So i- that, that, that's a big challenge right now. And, like, a- all the stuff we talked about, repair as well, handling these things, and, you know, getting them charged is definitely a, a challenge.
- 7:13But I think the biggest thing could be just, like, residual values, used car prices on EVs. Okay. So EVs, definitely. It's, it, you know, maybe it seems passe, but look, everyone's talking about it. What's another topic?
- 7:26I think the other, the other thing is, like, look, a, a lot of the auction participants are gonna be here, right? All the big auctions, all the, the, the, the, the online-only auctions.
- 7:35And they're sweating a little bit because, you know, we, we had this three, these three years where there was a depression in new car sales.
- 7:42And, you know, two or three years down the road, all those new cars become used cars. Yep.
- 7:46And so if I, if I'm a dealer, if I, you know, if I'm a v- very big retailer, if I'm a Carvana or, or CarMax, I'm sitting here saying, "Huh.
- 7:53My forecasting models mean that, you know, a couple of years from now, there's gonna be a shortage of good, low-mile, good quality, lightly used vehicles." Mm-hmm.
- 8:02And the auctions aren't sort of, aren't gonna have the volume to sell. So we're gonna see this, this interesting dynamic. Again, back to, to residual values.
- 8:10How do you forecast what a used vehicle's gonna be worth when we know there's gonna be a shortage, there's gonna be more demand than supply, which will support used car prices.
- 8:19But if you look at, you know, Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index, which gives you an idea of, like, what used values are selling for, used ve- cars are selling for, it's in very, very high.
- 8:28How long is that gonna last, and how volatile is that gonna be?
- 8:31So if I'm an auction company- Well, because we haven't even seen, we haven't even seen, you know, we, we've been, the used car market has been high because there's not new car inventory, but we, we still have yet to see the part, the, the part of the play where the used car value remains high because there's no used cars- Right...
- 8:49in inventory. That's right. And then as it swings- That's right... right, new car glut after that, and then it goes round and round.
- 8:55It's, it's this massive, yeah, it's a massive thing, and I, I didn't even think about the impact to the auctions. Like, the impacts of, of just their revenue, because less, less going through it.
- 9:05And then these large r- retailers rely on the auctions still. Like, we hear a lot of deal- de- dealers saying, "I wanna get out of auction. I wanna go, you know, direct to consumer."
- 9:14And it's a lot different proposition buying 50, 60 used cars off the street- Yeah... than it is hundreds of thousands of used cars to go across the country, um, obviously.
- 9:26And, and, and, and then, then, then we get to topic three. So to get afr- ahead of Paul's question. So top- topic three, topic three is related to that. So think about this.
- 9:35So yes, Ca- CarMax, for example, wants to be independent of auctions and be able to get all their cars through trades. Right. Well, or, or buying cars off the street.
- 9:44But w- what we know just happened is everyone who bought a car for the last three years paid more than MSRP. Mm-hmm. And when those consumers come back in to trade in their car, they're gonna be shocked.
- 9:54They'll be like, "What do you mean it's now worth, like, 15 grand less than I thought it was worth?" Mm-hmm. Because we're gonna get back to regular depreciation on these cars. Mm-hmm.
- 10:01These cars are gonna be so far underwater, meaning that consumers are gonna owe so much more than the car's actually worth, that there's no way you can, like, roll all that negative equity into a, a, a, a vehicle purchase.
- 10:13Right. No one's buying that. So they're gonna be stuck. They're gonna be stuck.
- 10:16They're gonna be like, "I'm gonna have to own this car a lot longer and just burn off all that negative equity by just holding onto it," which means I think we're gonna see m- many fewer c- in an environment where dealers are gonna be craving these, like, three-year-old vehicles, consumers just aren't gonna be able to bring them back into the market because there's gonna be so much negative equity.
- 10:33I had a situation- Is, is- Go ahead. Well, is that the, I, I, and m- like, the devil's advocate on that, and I haven't seen the reports on, like, the watered loan, right?
- 10:42Like, how much water is in consumer loans right now. I, I, that's a big question that I have because you still saw, you know, 50% to 60% of new retails getting trade-ins.
- 10:53And so those trade-ins would've been high in that timeline, too. Like, are we, are we actually gonna experience the high water on loans where consumers aren't gonna get out of them, or is the gap much closer?
- 11:04Um, I, I, I don't, I haven't seen any concrete evidence to that, and maybe you have. That's why I'm asking the question. I, I, I have it. But you guys are gonna be, like, the feet on the street next week.
- 11:13I, I, I would try to, like, burrow into that question. If you can find some people- Right... to comment on that, th- that, that's a big potential problem in the industry, and it needs to get exposed one way or the other.
- 11:23I- Yeah. I have an, anec- anecdotally, um, I had an executive from New York City called me. Uh, we were actually filming the, the fourth episode of More Than Cars. We were at Mohawk Chevrolet.
- 11:34And I got a phone call, and he was saying, "Hey," 'cause all of a sudden, I'm, I'm his car guy. I know about cars, right? So- [laughs]... he's like, "Here's what I have. I wanna get into a Bronco."
- 11:42I was like, "Perfect timing. I'm at a dealership. Let me see what your car is worth." And hi- and he was in an Equinox. So gave, you know, went back and forth, found out what he owed on it. And he had the means, right?
- 11:54But still, he was probably five grand backwards. He owned the car for two years. And even he was like, "Ah, you know, I, I think I'll just stay in it for now." Wow. Right? And that, that was somebody- Yep...
- 12:05who had the means to do it. Just sideline him immediately. Immedia- no, he was out of the conversation as soon as he found the value, and I explained why it was like that, 'cause he was also confused, right?
- 12:14Oh, I know things were high, but I don't think people realize what that actually means.... is that, oh, things were high. Well- You paid this and the residual value's changed. It's, it's a major difference.
- 12:25I mean, we're talking about- Well, yeah, and-... like a 20, a 28 or a $30,000 Equinox, and he was $5,000 apart from where he thought he was. Yeah.
- 12:33And, and when you see these studies that show, like, you know, half of Americans have less than $500 cash in their bank account. Right.
- 12:38They, they just have no, no, no, no means to, like, buy their way out of the, the hole. Yeah. And, and there are... We didn't cover the story, but there's definitely, like, the savings.
- 12:47The headline was something like, "All of that savings we, we gathered during the pandemic is now gone," basically was the headline. They burned it off. It- They burned it off. Yeah, yeah. [laughs] It is no longer...
- 12:59I think- Bought all our NFTs... the consumer just keeps, keeps spending, keeps spending. Yeah. You know, credit card rates are going up and we're, we're just like, the, the US consumer is continuing to spend.
- 13:07It is a thing. Wow. [laughs] It is a thing. Hey, real quick, before we go, give us the, give us a little insight into what Navicon- Yes... looks like. Uh, because you got a whole day- Yeah, yeah...
- 13:16where you kind of are moderating a little portion of this event. Like, what, what can people look forward to, uh, through the day that day? Besides Kyle trying to make them cry. Yes. Right. That, that little portion too.
- 13:26I know, exactly, yeah. [laughs] We're gonna get Kyle up on stage as a judge, Shark Tank style. [laughs] So that'll be pretty awesome. So, um, no, Th- Th- Thursday, all day, you'll see me up on stage.
- 13:35You know, I've got the CEO of, of CarGurus kicking us off, Jason Trevisan, followed by then Car, Car Dealership Guy.
- 13:43Um, although, you know, I've tried to convince him to get up on stage with some kinda, like, mask on, but, uh, he's gonna be Zooming in. But, uh, the, uh, we're gonna take open questions from the audience.
- 13:52So if you've been wanting to ask Car Dealership Guy questions, we will be taking questions live- [laughs] How fun... and putting him on, on the spot to ask question, which is super cool.
- 14:00And then, you know, um, we've got, we've got a few of our portfolio companies up on stage getting interviewed from, uh, by Chase Fraser at Fraser McCombs Capital, and he is, uh, he's interviewing them.
- 14:10Um, and then, uh, we're gonna get Kyle up on stage and put him in a seat and have fi- five five-minute pitches. He's used to this. He's been through this a few times before. And- Love it...
- 14:19Kyle can pepper, pepper them with questions, and then ultimately score these guys at the end. And they'll take away the Navicon Cup, and we'll award that right after lunch. Which is so cool.
- 14:29Uh, how, who makes the Navicon Cup every year? There's a guy up in Detroit, um, who welds these things for me. Perfect. And we, we've gotten him a lot of business. So you gotta see this.
- 14:40Hopefully we can, you know, uh, put, put that image up on- Yes... on the screen here for everyone to see. But yeah, I mean, you gotta see this guy. He's truly talented. He's a welder. He does the work himself.
- 14:50And as a result, we've got him a lot of extra work. But, um, I, I can definitely, if anybody wants, you, you can, you can, uh, message me, happy to put you in contact with this guy. Great guy, and, uh- So cool...
- 15:00he does great work. It's a work of art. Every year I'm like, "Who makes these things?" And now we know. Now we know. Yep. Awesome. All right. Well, there you go. There's the episode for your Friday.
- 15:08Thank you, Steve, so much for joining us. We can't wait to hang out with you next week and cause a little trouble. Maybe in the meantime we'll get some earrings, some tattoos, and, uh- [laughs]...
- 15:15try to hang out with the repo guys. Talk to you next week. June 4th here, guys. See you there. [upbeat music]