Latest / The Film Hobbyist / The Empire Strikes Back (1980): Yoda was Wrong
Transcript
- 0:12in and spend some time with the film hobbyist.
- 0:15My name is Lydia and I love movies. We're here
- 0:32in my backyard. You're sitting on a blue folding
- 0:37patio chair with a black metal frame. I'm in
- 0:42a large gray camp chair. It's a summer evening.
- 0:47The sun has gone down behind the tree line of
- 0:50the neighborhood. Before us is a circular brick
- 0:55fire pit, almost like a short well, and the fire
- 1:00inside licks the darkening air. We have tiki
- 1:05torches around the area, like a ward against
- 1:08mosquitoes. But I have bug spray if you need
- 1:11it. A little over a year ago, we had a conversation
- 1:16about the Star Wars television show Andor, an
- 1:19absolute masterpiece that I couldn't stop thinking
- 1:22about. I shared some about the significance of
- 1:26Star Wars in my life, and I promised you that
- 1:29one day we would have a conversation about a
- 1:32Star Wars movie, probably The Empire Strikes
- 1:35Back. Now, on a sticky summer night in mid -August,
- 1:39before we head into the fall, is just about the
- 1:43right time. I was already obsessed with Star
- 1:48Wars by the time I saw my first footage at age
- 1:51six. My older brother had talked me through a
- 1:54lot of the basics of the story and its world,
- 1:57and I'd already been playing Star Wars games
- 1:59in my backyard for years by the time the special
- 2:03editions had become available to rent. I was
- 2:06waiting with my dad at the video rental store,
- 2:09and on a special display TV, The Empire Strikes
- 2:14Back began to play. I got to watch the first
- 2:17few minutes, mostly. Dad made me turn my back
- 2:21when the monster attacks Luke. I was entranced.
- 2:25I had to be dragged away partway through the
- 2:28Hoth battle and begged my brother to tell me
- 2:31if Luke ended up being okay. At eight, some family
- 2:36friends sold their record player in a yard sale
- 2:39and passed on their leftover vinyls to us before
- 2:43they moved, and in that pile was the original
- 2:46soundtrack for Empire Strikes Back. I took to
- 2:49listening to it when I came home from school,
- 2:52especially as I got older and school became a
- 2:55difficult place. I would self -regulate listening
- 2:58to Yoda's theme, breathing with the legato strings.
- 3:04This film series, and Empire specifically, are
- 3:08kind of essential in my life. I love this world
- 3:13deeply. And like everyone who loves that galaxy
- 3:17far, far away, I have a lot of opinions about
- 3:20it. I try to pick my battles. I am actually fairly
- 3:24chill with people who haven't seen it, so if
- 3:27that's you, don't be embarrassed. I have no problem
- 3:31with anyone who doesn't like the movies or isn't
- 3:34interested, but I will argue that the first Star
- 3:37Wars movie from 1977, now called A New Hope,
- 3:41and its direct sequel, The Empire Strikes Back,
- 3:44are an essential part of general cultural education
- 3:48for how much they impacted all levels of storytelling
- 3:52and culture. There's a before Star Wars world
- 3:56and an after Star Wars world, and it's really
- 3:59important to understand that. Empire specifically
- 4:03is referenced and echoed in film and TV everywhere,
- 4:08so watching it for the first time would be filled
- 4:11with a strong sense of, so that's where that
- 4:13came from. The Empire Strikes Back is the middle
- 4:18chapter in a trilogy, kind of the first movie.
- 4:22to know it was the middle of a trilogy. It begins
- 4:25in the middle of a story, and it ends in a rather
- 4:29unresolved place, just like a good Act 2 of a
- 4:34three -act story structure. Act 1 introduces
- 4:37the characters, the world, and the stakes, and
- 4:40ends with the inciting incident, the event that
- 4:43spurs the story into action. In the case of the
- 4:47original Star Wars trilogy, That would be Luke
- 4:50emerging as a hero to destroy the Death Star,
- 4:53challenge Darth Vader, and give the Rebel Alliance
- 4:56their first real victory. Act 2 deepens the characters'
- 5:02relationships, raises the stakes, changes the
- 5:05dynamics, and ends with our characters in about
- 5:08as bad a spot as they can get. Which is, frankly,
- 5:13how Empire nearly ends. Han frozen and kidnapped,
- 5:17Luke with terrible knowledge, a severed hand
- 5:20and a lost lightsaber, and Leia and crew barely
- 5:24escaping to the Millennium Falcon with their
- 5:27lives. They land in this terrible situation because
- 5:31of Luke and his anger, his hot -headed pride.
- 5:35He hadn't learned enough of the ways of the Force.
- 5:37He needed to let go of his fear for his friends'
- 5:41safety and his attachment to them and train with
- 5:44the great Jedi Master Yoda. Or at least, that's
- 5:49what Yoda thinks. And I think Yoda is wrong.
- 5:57This is a highly controversial statement, I know,
- 6:00both in canon and out. If you call someone Master
- 6:05Yoda, or describe someone as being like Yoda,
- 6:09that means someone who is incredibly wise and
- 6:13all -knowing. Someone you want to sit and learn
- 6:17from for as long as possible. Master Yoda is
- 6:21considered to be the perfect teacher. Maybe a
- 6:24little eccentric, but the person you can trust
- 6:27most of all. In canon, he's the wisest of the
- 6:32wise, so good and humble that he has even given
- 6:35up the appearance of wisdom. Anyone who speaks
- 6:39ill of Yoda is clearly a bad guy. He's the most
- 6:43trustworthy Jedi ever, 900 years of teaching
- 6:47and serving the Force, and yet, I think he got
- 6:52this wrong. I have to acknowledge some fuzziness
- 6:57with so -called canon here. The meta -mythology
- 7:01of Star Wars is that George Lucas wrote out a
- 7:05nine -part series and decided to direct the middle
- 7:09three with the knowledge of the other two parts
- 7:12in his head. That's not actually an accurate
- 7:16picture of how Star Wars came to be. Yes, Lucas
- 7:20had a sketch of things, but we have to acknowledge
- 7:24that a lot changed between films. In A New Hope,
- 7:29George Lucas did not know that Luke and Leia
- 7:33were siblings. Absolutely did not know that.
- 7:36He would have made different choices for sure
- 7:38if that had been at all on his mind. And it's
- 7:42pretty clear that some of the plot of Return
- 7:44of the Jedi wasn't pre -planned. A second Death
- 7:48Star? That's a choice that screams rewrite. Yoda
- 7:53dying randomly in the beginning? Yeah, that also
- 7:57feels anticlimactic when you watch Empire and
- 8:00Jedi back -to -back. So my discussing these two
- 8:04films as if they are a continuing story with
- 8:07pre -planned consequences is definitely a suspension
- 8:11of disbelief kind of thing. In The Empire Strikes
- 8:16Back, Luke arrives on the swamp planet of Dagobah
- 8:20with a confidence edging on impetuosity. He's
- 8:24been through many trials and difficulties already,
- 8:27and has survived because of his connection to
- 8:30the Force, the energy that flows through and
- 8:32around all living things, that binds the universe
- 8:35together. Luke isn't cocky, but he is secure
- 8:40in his courage and skill. He's not afraid, and
- 8:45he's open to following his destiny in weird places.
- 8:48I mean, that's how he's landed on Dagobah in
- 8:51the first place. He saw a vision of his dead
- 8:54mentor while he was passing out from hypothermia
- 8:56and has decided to pursue what it told him. Now,
- 9:01part of Luke's time on Dagobah with Yoda is realizing
- 9:05what he doesn't know. He assumes a great Jedi
- 9:09Master will look outwardly like a powerful warrior.
- 9:13Yoda does not. He assumes learning the Force
- 9:17will be really cool and exciting. He learns that
- 9:20it's much more of a mental and spiritual journey
- 9:23than a physical one, although all the flipping
- 9:27on vines challenges this a little. Luke realizes
- 9:31that he's often distracted by what's coming next
- 9:34rather than what's happening now, and he struggles
- 9:37to get over his materialistic framing of the
- 9:40world for a spiritual understanding. This learning
- 9:44is centered around three big failures in his
- 9:48training. First, there is his vision in the magic
- 9:52cave. Now this scene is really weird and hard
- 9:56to understand, which is why I love it. But here's
- 9:59the best way to understand it. Yoda is giving
- 10:03a lesson on the two sides of the force, the light
- 10:06side being when you are calm and at peace, and
- 10:09the dark side when you are angry and afraid.
- 10:13They come near to the cave, which Yoda says is
- 10:16a place strong in the dark side, and tells Luke
- 10:19that if he goes there, he won't need his weapons.
- 10:23Luke, on edge and used to relying on his weapons
- 10:27in a tight spot, ignores him. Inside, Luke sees
- 10:31Darth Vader. He takes the offense, extending
- 10:35his lightsaber and attacking his enemy. Luke
- 10:38overpowers and beheads him. only to find that
- 10:42Vader's mask reveals his own face inside. This
- 10:47is a failure. Luke approached with aggression
- 10:50and anger and learned that such actions will
- 10:53only hurt himself in the end. He will become
- 10:56the evil he seeks to destroy, which will be his
- 10:59own destruction. Failure two involves Luke's
- 11:04X -Wing starfighter. While Luke is supposed to
- 11:07be focused on moving objects with his mind, His
- 11:11ship sinks deep into the swamp. He's distracted
- 11:14and panics. This is his only way out of here,
- 11:17after all. Yoda tells him to try and lift it
- 11:21with the force, which Luke says is too hard because
- 11:24of the ship's size and weight. He budges it a
- 11:28little, but gives up, declaring the task impossible.
- 11:32Yoda, however, uses the force himself and elegantly
- 11:36raises the ship out of the mire onto dry land.
- 11:40I don't believe it, says Luke, which, Yoda informs
- 11:45him, is why he fails. Okay, so we have a failure
- 11:50of self -control, a failure of belief, and then
- 11:53the final failure of letting go of attachment.
- 11:58While connecting with the Force, Luke sees a
- 12:01vision of his friends Han and Leia experiencing
- 12:04great suffering. Compelled to help them, knowing
- 12:08they may die if he doesn't, Luke prepares to
- 12:11leave his training early. Yoda insists he stay,
- 12:14that by leaving he'd put all their efforts at
- 12:17risk, especially with Luke's lack of control
- 12:20of the Force. For the sake of the galaxy, Luke
- 12:24must put aside his friend's suffering, especially
- 12:27as in this vulnerable time he will be tempted
- 12:30by the dark side. To leave would be to put his
- 12:33attachment to his friends above the greater good
- 12:36of the galaxy. For Yoda, this is taking the easy
- 12:40way out, choosing his fear over what may happen
- 12:44to his friends to rush into a confrontation filled
- 12:47with passion and hate, rather than patiently
- 12:50pursuing the goodness of the light side of the
- 12:52Force, letting what happens to his friend happen,
- 12:55and emerge to fully stop Vader and the Emperor.
- 13:01But I don't think that's what Luke's doing at
- 13:04all. Luke sees that his friends are at risk because
- 13:09of him. And he will knowingly put himself in
- 13:13danger to help them. He's not leaving out of
- 13:17fear. He's leaving out of purpose. He is giving
- 13:22up his own personal spiritual desires in order
- 13:27to serve people he loves. But let's humor Yoda
- 13:32here. What would happen? if Luke hadn't left.
- 13:38Han and Leia would still have been captured by
- 13:41Vader. That happened before Luke was anywhere
- 13:44near Bespin. Vader would still have tortured
- 13:48Han. Would he have frozen him in carbonite if
- 13:51Luke wasn't on his way? Well, that was still
- 13:56part of his plan for Luke, so probably. And Boba
- 14:01Fett would still have stolen Han away. Leia would
- 14:05have been held captive by Darth Vader. Maybe
- 14:09Lando still would have attempted an escape. It
- 14:13would have been more difficult with Vader watching.
- 14:15But even if they had made it to space in the
- 14:18Millennium Falcon, the hyperdrive would have
- 14:21been broken, and R2 -D2 wouldn't have been there
- 14:24to fix it. Leia and Lando could not have escaped
- 14:29without his help, and he was only there because
- 14:32Luke was there. So now we're going to jump into
- 14:37Return of the Jedi, dangerous territory, I know.
- 14:40Would the Emperor have been overthrown by Luke
- 14:44alone? Well, Luke does defeat both Palpatine
- 14:50and Darth Vader. But the Empire would still have
- 14:54had a second Death Star. Luke doesn't destroy
- 14:57that at all. It takes the combined efforts of
- 15:00Leia, Han, Chewie, C -3PO, and Lando to do that.
- 15:04So the Sith may have been stopped, but the galaxy
- 15:08would not have been saved. Now let's look at
- 15:12what does happen. Luke, yes, repeats the mistake
- 15:17of the cave by copying his offensive moves against
- 15:21Darth Vader in Cloud City. He loses control.
- 15:25and is overwhelmed by Vader's use of the Force,
- 15:28and then his hand is cut off as he learns the
- 15:31awful truth of his parentage. And the Luke of
- 15:35Return of the Jedi is a humbler, wiser man. He
- 15:40keeps his promise to return to Yoda, who tells
- 15:44him that he's actually fine and doesn't need
- 15:47any more training. He chooses to confront Vader
- 15:51nonviolently, to reach out to the last vestiges
- 15:54of his humanity with hope. And while he is enticed
- 15:58by Palpatine to embrace his anger, he stops short
- 16:02of killing Vader by realizing that he is doing
- 16:05to his father as his father did to him. I don't
- 16:10think he could have done any of those things
- 16:12if he had not chosen the rescue of his friends
- 16:15over his own spiritual enlightenment. Yoda's
- 16:20assumption in Empire is that general compassion
- 16:23will best lead to calm and peace and goodness,
- 16:27and that attachments will lead to passion and
- 16:30fear and hate and suffering. But what we see
- 16:33here is Luke mixing his attachments with wisdom.
- 16:38Yes, in Return of the Jedi, his desire to protect
- 16:41Leia leads him to give in to Vader's taunting.
- 16:45But it is his attachment to his father that stops
- 16:48him short of delivering the killing blow as he
- 16:52declares, I am a Jedi like my father before me.
- 16:57If any of this thematic stuff sounds familiar,
- 17:00well, it's a big feature of the prequels. Again,
- 17:04acknowledging it's even murkier to interpret
- 17:07Empire by prequels made two decades later, but
- 17:11we are just echoing what was done in the original
- 17:13trilogy first. In the prequels, the Jedi Order
- 17:17is a huge institution. Force -sensitive children
- 17:21are found and taken by the Order at a very young
- 17:24age. Nine -year -old Anakin is deemed too old.
- 17:27This is on purpose because it reduces the attachments
- 17:31they have. General compassion, good. Attachments,
- 17:35bad. The Jedi are meant to be beacons of peace
- 17:39and justice in the galaxy. But if they don't
- 17:43have attachments... How do they pursue peace
- 17:46and justice? Well, they do what the Republic
- 17:50tells them to do. The sometimes corrupt, selfishly
- 17:55motivated Republic. The Jedi have essentially
- 17:58become the Republic's police force. In The Phantom
- 18:03Menace, young Anakin Skywalker is a slave. And
- 18:07do the Jedi care about freeing slaves? No, because
- 18:12they have no attachment to them. They don't actually
- 18:15care about pursuing freedom or justice on Tatooine
- 18:18because the Republic isn't there. So much for
- 18:22general compassion. And because they have limited
- 18:25their sight and power to the Republic, they do
- 18:28not see the phantom menace corrupting that very
- 18:31institution. And Anakin Skywalker falls, not
- 18:35because he has attachments, but because he does
- 18:38not have healthy, wise attachments. He has no
- 18:42examples of such. He is worried, selfishly, that
- 18:46he will lose his relationships, rather than being
- 18:49filled with purpose to save those he loves. And
- 18:53so the Jedi Order falls, even though Yoda leads
- 18:57it. And now, again, Yoda attempts to make the
- 19:02same mistake, assuming that Luke loving Leia
- 19:05and Han is the same thing as Anakin loving Padme,
- 19:08not understanding that Luke is perhaps acting
- 19:12with the most compassion by leaving. So how did
- 19:17we get here? How can we have this overt stated
- 19:21value of the importance of giving up attachments
- 19:24for the sake of general compassion and have a
- 19:27story which tells quite another thing? That's
- 19:31because of a meta -problem. Cultural values.
- 19:37Star Wars is heavily influenced by Asian culture.
- 19:41Yeah, there's the outward influence of Akira
- 19:44Kurosawa's samurai films on the plot, and the
- 19:47costumes and the production design echoing kimonos
- 19:50and samurai armor and their silhouettes and closures,
- 19:53but I'm talking deeper. The Jedi are warrior
- 19:57monks, not unlike Shaolin monks who practiced
- 20:01both Buddhism and Kung Fu. The Force is also
- 20:05heavily Buddhist in its influence, but its duality
- 20:09screams Taoism. The dark and light side are very
- 20:13yin and yang -esque. There isn't any reincarnation
- 20:17here, but both Obi -Wan and Yoda's disappearance
- 20:20as they become one with the Force is very achieving
- 20:24enlightenment here. Buddhism is very big on both
- 20:30the importance of compassion, and on the giving
- 20:34up of personal attachments. Nirvana, or enlightenment,
- 20:38can only be achieved by this nothingness of doing
- 20:42dispassionate good. I don't know how George Lucas
- 20:47first learned about Asian philosophy. It's probably
- 20:51because he came of age in the 60s. There has
- 20:54always been a countercultural interest in the
- 20:57Far East. Orientalism is this fascination with
- 21:02those other people to the east who must be more
- 21:04than human, since they are clearly not the same
- 21:07as Westerners. But after the Cold War, the U
- 21:11.S. embraced the importance of Western institutions,
- 21:15and their kids rebelled by looking for something
- 21:19different. So the Beatles did transcendental
- 21:22meditation and visited ashrams. The counterculture
- 21:26and the embrace of Eastern philosophy was really
- 21:29big in San Francisco especially, which is where
- 21:33George Lucas began his filmmaking journey. The
- 21:36two things are probably related. And so, George
- 21:40Lucas, also influenced by Joseph Campbell's writing
- 21:44on the Ramayana and ancient Sanskrit myths, decided
- 21:48to tell a story with Eastern religious influence
- 21:50and Eastern religious values. Except George Lucas
- 21:56was still a kid from a farming town in California
- 22:00who grew up Methodist. I don't blame him for
- 22:05not being able to shake the hold of the storytelling
- 22:08values of his childhood. That attachments matter
- 22:13rather a lot. If you love a girl, you would do
- 22:17anything for her. If you love your family, you
- 22:21would throw your body on the flames to protect
- 22:23them. If you love your friends and they are in
- 22:26danger, you will drop everything to rescue them.
- 22:30Because in Western storytelling, selflessness
- 22:34means caring about individuals more than yourself
- 22:37or your own wants. Not general individuals, specific
- 22:42ones. Attachments are kind of the most important
- 22:47thing. Because we have connections to people,
- 22:51we serve them. And if we serve with general compassion,
- 22:54it's because we would hope those we are attached
- 22:58to would be cared for the same way if they were
- 23:02in need. So I don't blame him for mucking it
- 23:06up, for trying to tell a story about giving up
- 23:09attachments to save the galaxy and accidentally
- 23:12telling one where the galaxy is saved because
- 23:15a son reached out to the father who wronged him
- 23:17and because a father saw his son in pain. and
- 23:21that attachment woke up his humanity. Yoda was
- 23:26wrong. And we are all better for it. Thanks for
- 23:35coming.