Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E009: More Bullish Than Ever with Dylan LeClair
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about the stuff, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of Doubtless. 1970.
- 0:14419-8790, 297-2000, and whatever we want to call this.
- 0:19It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 0:27when we sell. Michael, that background is
- 0:31really depressing right now. I know I've heard I was you
- 0:36know, we started this pod, I was on the on the road in the East
- 0:38Coast with the Inlaws family and so I was moving around, got got
- 0:42back to Texas and you know I'm not a professional influencer
- 0:46like our like our buddies here on the on the pod.
- 0:48So my background is not up to snuff, but well, well we're
- 0:52working on it. It's a progress.
- 0:54I mean, I'm throwing rocks in a glass house right now.
- 0:57I'm on a back deck with a. Fiat Plastic Deck Divider behind
- 1:01me, so at least I got some trees right up here.
- 1:05You. Have a nice mix of background
- 1:07and you listen to like since you've been out like on RHR and
- 1:11you hear like seagulls, we hear sirens, cars, people honking
- 1:16neighbors, moans, very diverse and.
- 1:20We're going to look out today. It's a rainy day here at the
- 1:23Jersey Shore and so there will be no advertising single prop.
- 1:28Planes flying over the beach, they're not going to waste those
- 1:30ad dollars. But as you may be able to hear,
- 1:34somebody decided to mow their lawn as soon as we hit record
- 1:36and the weed whacker is out. But I'm not here to talk about
- 1:40backgrounds in the Jersey Shore. We're here to talk about Bitcoin
- 1:43and we are joined again by Dylan Leclair.
- 1:47Dylan, welcome back to the show, Sir.
- 1:49Happy to be back guys. I've been been a fan of what you
- 1:53guys have been doing in the in the in the meantime.
- 1:55I think that's after episode one.
- 1:58What is this episode? What what?
- 1:59What number is this one? 9.
- 2:02Nice. You're almost in the double
- 2:04digits, guys. Coming a little bit.
- 2:08But yeah, we got a lot of feedback from our first episode.
- 2:12Came out of the the the gate guns blazing.
- 2:15We were a little excited about launching the new show, and
- 2:19myself, Michael and Jesse sort of hogged the bike and people
- 2:22were like, hey, let Dylan talk more and so.
- 2:26Taking that feedback into mind, I think we start today by
- 2:30jumping into a piece that you wrote within the last week on
- 2:34disinflation in the current state of the economy.
- 2:39What's going on? Yeah, sure.
- 2:42I guess so. I mean, I would preface it by
- 2:44saying that there's somewhat of like kind of a fear mongering
- 2:49section of a Fintwit that's like.
- 2:53You know disinflation, deflation, you know bust like
- 2:56this is the the end state of things like well like just to
- 3:00you know for anyone that's not familiar with statistics like
- 3:02there still is inflation right there still is the level of
- 3:06prices is obviously still rising.
- 3:07It's just rising less frequently at a slower rate of change.
- 3:12But I think people you know with with the CPI coming in and we
- 3:16can debate whether like CPI is like a good gauge of inflation,
- 3:21but it's what we're working with.
- 3:23You know came in at 3% right, 12 months in a row of of lower
- 3:26inflation. And I the key thing that that
- 3:29stuck with me was from that was like while you know the stock
- 3:33market was celebrating you know S&P, NASDAQ melt into new highs.
- 3:37You know we're basically in a second tech bubble that's you
- 3:41know if you look at the top seven stocks in the stock market
- 3:45like they're almost surpassing their 2021 bubble highs like $12
- 3:48trillion market cap. So you know the stock market's
- 3:52back disinflation. Inflation was transitory after
- 3:54all. But I think it misses the the
- 3:56point a bit at least temporarily an interim.
- 4:00I still think a decade of of of higher inflation and financial
- 4:03repression is ahead. But in the short to medium term,
- 4:05I think that the disinflation is is the main thing to to focus on
- 4:10and here's why. It's because you know we went
- 4:13through the fastest rate hike cycle ever right, like 500 bits
- 4:17of of of rate hikes in the span of.
- 4:20You know 912 months something along those lines in 2022, but
- 4:24it was, it was masked by the the high rate of inflation, right.
- 4:27So so that tightening of monetary policy if you just
- 4:29think of like of of a real yield, right.
- 4:32And like you know technically the the bond market guys would
- 4:35say real rates are looking ahead, not looking behind, but
- 4:38if you just look at the Fed funds rate right now it's like
- 4:395% inflation's 3%, right. So in the past ten years post
- 4:44great financial crisis rates were zero, inflation was 22
- 4:47something percent. Post COVID rates were zero for a
- 4:50long time. Massive QE in 2021.
- 4:54Inflation start starts to fly right?
- 4:56And everyone's saying it's not transitory.
- 4:57Obviously this is here to stay. Inflation gets up to 9 percent,
- 5:0110% plus in the EU. You know, the energy crisis of
- 5:05the Ukraine war kind of soaked the flames, but those rate,
- 5:09those rate hikes weren't really felt because inflation was still
- 5:11so high, right? So, so like there really wasn't.
- 5:14Tight monetary policy, right, Real yields, you could still
- 5:17borrow at a lower rate than inflation.
- 5:19That dynamic has flipped. And so I think what if you just
- 5:22look at previous cycles, right, like the economic downturns, the
- 5:26kind of the the bust phase of these short term debt cycles we
- 5:29see of these asset bubbles, they don't really happen until the
- 5:32Fed starts cutting rates. And why does the Fed cut rates,
- 5:35right, because the economic, you know, the economic cycle,
- 5:38economic activity that the economy is deteriorating really
- 5:40fast. And so they start to cut rates
- 5:42and then you look at what happens to the SP, you look at
- 5:44what happens to the labor market, the real economy.
- 5:47It doesn't actually bottom for a while and it really, it's almost
- 5:50looks like it's sparked by that first cut.
- 5:52So everybody's kind of like disinflation is here, soft
- 5:56landing, everything's great and the pessimistic side of me.
- 6:01Is I think there's a bit more nuance and it's the fact that
- 6:04you know we're seeing the labor market just start to turn.
- 6:07There's you know a lot of research from you know the
- 6:10banking sector says that default rates for retail and like you
- 6:14know the real estate side of things is ticking up
- 6:16delinquencies across the board for all all kinds of credit and
- 6:19financing. And you know with this this
- 6:21inflation rates are now positive for the first time since like
- 6:23before the great financial crisis on a real on a real basis
- 6:26real yields also you know backwards looking in forwards
- 6:29looking. Are higher than they've been for
- 6:31most for many investors entire lifetime.
- 6:34Also if you look at Bitcoin for all of Bitcoin's existence.
- 6:37So that's not like necessarily an absolute bearish thing.
- 6:41It's just the reality that we still have a whole lot of debt
- 6:43out there that the GDP is still very high, still you know 120%
- 6:47at the federal level and real rates are actually positive at
- 6:50least forecasted to be and you know on a trailing basis.
- 6:53So I just think that that's a temporary, that's a transitory
- 6:57outcome cuz real yields can't remain positive for long without
- 7:00things without the wheels falling off.
- 7:03So it'll be really interesting. I think the soft landing calls
- 7:05are premature and we're gonna, we're still not out of the woods
- 7:09yet. I think people think that we did
- 7:11it. We engineered a soft landing.
- 7:13You know Powell and the inflation, inflation is
- 7:15transitory. Camp was right.
- 7:17We we're so back and I think that's you know we this thing is
- 7:22far from over. So that was a long form version
- 7:24of of kind of the state of things.
- 7:25And you know what I was trying to get out with the disinflation
- 7:29post I put out, but yeah, yeah. Yeah, but.
- 7:34And it's so interesting because like you know, at this point
- 7:37I've spent a fair bit of time studying the 70s, a little bit
- 7:41the 40s to see what happened, but.
- 7:43In the 70s there were three waves of inflation, which meant
- 7:46there were three waves of disinflation along the way and
- 7:51obviously they kept coming back. It was not a problem that that
- 7:55was solved as soon as it started to ebb away.
- 8:00And yeah, like even thinking about 2008, We Bear Stearns went
- 8:05under in March and then it took until the fall for the other
- 8:10shoe to shoes to drop. It takes time for the for the
- 8:14bodies to show up. You know, as the tide is going
- 8:17out and right now we're seeing record bankruptcies, like
- 8:22there's your indicator that things are not all well.
- 8:26And I keep biasing back to what Stan Druckenmiller has said of,
- 8:30you know that this is, this is a terrible environment to predict.
- 8:34First of all, the hardest he's ever seen.
- 8:37He's in the hard landing camp still because.
- 8:42The damage is done, you know the the damage is done is yet to
- 8:45show up fully. Yeah, I think the labor market
- 8:49is key. You know if you look at the 70s,
- 8:52a lot of that at least like the first initial waiver was an
- 8:54energy crisis. And we saw somewhat to a similar
- 8:57extent in, you know, 2021 or 2022, you know the Ukraine war.
- 9:01Oil went to like 130 bucks a barrel.
- 9:03Natural gas was was spiraling out of control.
- 9:05There was there was an energy crisis.
- 9:07And that faded away and you know, actually, you know, on a
- 9:09year over year basis, part of the reason why the CPI is so low
- 9:12is because you know, the energy inflation is actually like
- 9:15deeply negative, at least in the trailing 12 months.
- 9:17So. So why is inflation so high And
- 9:20and it's the core basket, right, Which, you know, I will say
- 9:23there is merit to saying like well core inflation, what does
- 9:26that, oh exclude food and energy costs and like you know, some
- 9:30some from the Bitcoin camp including like a little bit
- 9:32myself will be like that's the stupidest thing I've ever heard.
- 9:34Why would you exclude? Food and energy from an
- 9:37inflation gauge and and well the reason is at least at least from
- 9:42an economist standpoint is that those baskets are very volatile
- 9:44and if core inflation is just like services, wages, right.
- 9:48So, So all that it's differentiating is core
- 9:50inflation is higher than the CPI which means what?
- 9:52Well this is a wage driven thing.
- 9:54So like if you think back to like I think six months ago,
- 9:57right late, late 2022 Powell is saying.
- 10:01Yeah, we in a Fed speak way, right, Kind of all jargon.
- 10:05He's saying we need unemployment to get to like 4 1/2%, which
- 10:09employment at that time was like the unemployment rate was like 3
- 10:121/2%. So he's saying we need Americans
- 10:15out of the workforce. Well, why is he saying that?
- 10:18Saying that so that the labor market cools down and wage
- 10:20pressure goes away, right. So this is like, you know, the
- 10:23kind of like messed up dial and and kind of like Rube Goldberg
- 10:28machine economy that we live in where you know, central bank
- 10:31bosses are trying to, you know play God with the economy.
- 10:34But this is, this is a state of things, right.
- 10:36So I think they're going to be effective.
- 10:38I think they keep things tight until we start to see inflation
- 10:41cool down because of it's already cooled down.
- 10:43But the labor market I think cracks a bit.
- 10:47And I if you just look at like excess savings, right, they
- 10:49pumped everybody's with money in COVID.
- 10:52You know the the bottom 2 quintiles and this is part of
- 10:54the post I share the bottom 2 quintiles of of the US economy
- 10:57from a savings perspective has already ran out of money.
- 11:00And then soon that third, you know that 40 to 60% quintile is
- 11:04also going to be out of money. It's really just the richest 20%
- 11:07of Americans that have all the excess cash and the rest are now
- 11:10starting to rely on credit, right.
- 11:11So, So this is where, especially with unemployment taking up,
- 11:14this is where it gets a bit ugly.
- 11:16And you know people have been kind of coaxed to be to think
- 11:19that you know recessions don't occur anymore.
- 11:22This like post QE era is, is you know everything is is fine and
- 11:26golden and we don't see downturns anymore and I think
- 11:29that's a naive perspective. So it'll be really interesting
- 11:32partially I think it'll be interesting because we might see
- 11:35this this downturn whether it's you know equity market related
- 11:38or just the real economy and or both occurs somewhat at the same
- 11:42time as you know. Bitcoin halves and the response
- 11:45to these downturns to these, you know, deteriorations and
- 11:48economic data, you know also asset crashes whether it's
- 11:52commercial real estate or equities or whatever it is the
- 11:55bonds is, is 1 and the same. It's always they're going to,
- 11:58you know pump this thing back full of money.
- 12:00And I think that's where like the timeline gets really,
- 12:03really, really interesting is like we might see, you know Fed
- 12:06cuts and or you know some form of stimulative effect from
- 12:09Congress fiscal spending, maybe not with the presidential
- 12:12elections but after that. Right, right.
- 12:15Somewhat in line with the Bitcoin having and that's like a
- 12:17a pretty exciting timeline for me.
- 12:20And I wonder if we even have that much time.
- 12:23Logan, you can pull up the picture.
- 12:25I just put in our Slack channel. We discussed this yesterday on
- 12:28Rabbit Hole recap of Peter St. Onge wrote a really good piece
- 12:31on his sub stack about the commercial real estate market.
- 12:33And I'm becoming more convinced that outside the labor market
- 12:37this is going to be one of the bigger shoes to drop and if you
- 12:40just look at these numbers. They're pretty startling.
- 12:44So for anybody listening at home and not seeing what's up on the
- 12:47screen, here's a section of one of Peter St.
- 12:51Onge's recent sub stacks at the Money dries up, commercial real
- 12:54estate prices are not plunging with institutional quality
- 12:57offices losing 27% in the past year, apartment buildings down
- 13:0121% and malls down 18%. And this is the most startling
- 13:05stat in this piece. And it makes sense if you
- 13:08consider the the state of San Francisco.
- 13:11And the squalor that is found itself in San Francisco's office
- 13:15vacancy rate is now 32.7%. Pre pandemic was 4%.
- 13:20A recent study from Berkeley found cell phone traffic is
- 13:23actually down 70% in city compared to pre pandemic.
- 13:26And so in the context of commercial real estate,
- 13:29obviously it will likely affect some cities more than others,
- 13:34but San Francisco being one of the most popular commercial real
- 13:38estate cities in the world pre pandemic.
- 13:42It seems like there's going to be massive losses in that market
- 13:45coming, coming to bear soon. Got any CL O's?
- 13:54Yeah, the I mean, it's a human story for me because I lived in
- 13:58San Francisco until 2018 and you know, had a bunch of friends up
- 14:03there after school and. They're all gone now, like
- 14:07there's one or two people in the Bay Area still.
- 14:11Everybody else has left. It's been a general exodus from
- 14:15the city in general. But you know, like we all used
- 14:19to go downtown to work every day, like my whole cohort, and
- 14:23none of us are there anymore. Yeah, the the commercial real
- 14:31estate thing, but I I think particularly like not even just
- 14:34just that but just like what what COVID did to the the like
- 14:39perception of like office work. And and you know the kind of
- 14:43like the information economy I think is is a one way shift.
- 14:46And you're seeing like you know a lot of these these guys that
- 14:48are like you know coincidentally like you know commercial
- 14:52commercial real estate holders or you know have some stake in
- 14:54like investment firms or private equity firms and they're like.
- 14:57Like, yeah, you know, remote work I think is going to
- 15:00transition back to going into the office.
- 15:02And it's like they're talking their own book, obviously.
- 15:05But yeah, yeah, this is this that COVID was like, I think a
- 15:08massive accelerator to a lot of this stuff.
- 15:11And everybody kind of realizes, like, no, I don't need to
- 15:14commute an hour and a half to to go sit in a desk when I can just
- 15:17do this from my house. Like, obviously not.
- 15:20And to paint a little bit more of a picture about why this is a
- 15:23kind of a ticking time bomb. A lot of these assets, these
- 15:28office buildings basically like 90% of them I believe this is
- 15:32stat at this point are on interest only loans.
- 15:36So these are these are mortgages effectively where the owner is
- 15:41only paying interest, they're not paying down their mortgage
- 15:45which is just a riskier form of of loan and means that any
- 15:50drawdown in in valuations you know?
- 15:55Exposes them more quickly and more and more dramatically and
- 15:59so, so that's happening at the same time that nobody's, you
- 16:02know, there's huge drop in demand for these spaces.
- 16:06So at what point in time does that shoe drop and then who does
- 16:10that impact because for most of these assets these live on the
- 16:15books of regional banks that they're actually the the leading
- 16:19lenders for commercial real estate because it's.
- 16:22Historically been kind of a niche.
- 16:23They can have some expertise and they know the area.
- 16:26This is their region and so they've served these markets in,
- 16:29in that way. So what happens then?
- 16:32Do we have it, you know, the the next wave of the banking crisis
- 16:36because suddenly commercial real estate investors are going
- 16:42bankrupt and that hits the books of the regional banks that
- 16:46provided those loans and suddenly they're underwater and
- 16:50and a lot of them. And now you're you're the Fed,
- 16:53What do you do? Do you just let them go out of
- 16:55business because it's capitalism and that's what should happen?
- 16:58Well, that's not what happened in the spring when we had the
- 17:01banking crisis and they stepped in to create the BTFP and calm
- 17:06the panic and you know, backstop these underwater assets.
- 17:10So when does that shoe drop is really, I think the question at
- 17:14this point for me rather than is there a problem?
- 17:17I think it's when does that manifest?
- 17:20You know what I think, I think that the BTFP like you
- 17:24mentioned, I think that is going to be an indefinite program.
- 17:28If you just look at the mechanics of it, it's like okay
- 17:31treasury bonds went the risk free asset treasury bonds, long
- 17:34dated treasuries. You know that everybody just
- 17:36said was cash equivalent essentially and you know, they
- 17:39just locked in for 30 years because interest rates were zero
- 17:42and that was the only yield they could get.
- 17:44Well, yeah, actually they saw a twenty 2530% drawdown.
- 17:48And so BTFP comes in, says, oh, just for one year, a special
- 17:51program, you can take this collateral and you can mark it
- 17:54at par. And it's not just treasuries,
- 17:55it's actually it's agency debt and mortgage-backed securities
- 17:58too. So I think they come in, they're
- 18:00going to have some more word salad, maybe it's the same, you
- 18:03know, acronym facility, maybe it's a different one.
- 18:05But if there is any crisis, maybe even if there's not a
- 18:07crisis, it's just, you know, they wait the full year BTFP
- 18:10continues and they just say, oh, no, we're going to continue on
- 18:13with this program indefinitely. And some like, you know, kind of
- 18:16press release that they don't even really project publicly
- 18:18that like that loudly. They're going to be like, yeah,
- 18:21you know, we'll continue this thing.
- 18:22And any losses that are incurred in the commercial real estate,
- 18:24like obviously if you default, you know, you don't own the
- 18:26asset anymore. But who's what's the, you know,
- 18:29the chain effect, what's the the kind of the counterparty risk
- 18:31well. It's just the Fed's balance
- 18:33sheet and they don't care because they're not a real
- 18:35actually asset allocator. They just print money.
- 18:37Any losses they just mark down. Like Jesse, you had a really
- 18:41good post about that picture of the feds.
- 18:45Basically P&L right, they hold all these long dated bonds that
- 18:48are giving them 1233 percent. Meanwhile they're paying 5% fed
- 18:52funds, 5% on the reverse repo. So they have losses every
- 18:55single, every single day. And they're not even, they're
- 18:59not recording those losses. It's just like a deferred asset
- 19:01or deferred liability or whatever they call it.
- 19:03So I think that's the same thing they're gonna do with commercial
- 19:06real estate mortgage-backed securities.
- 19:08They're just all this pile of crap assets are gonna be,
- 19:13they're gonna be securitized, the Fed's gonna buy them.
- 19:17And they're just never going to actually mark down the losses.
- 19:19Or maybe, you know, marginally, but it's just gonna that the
- 19:21feds just gonna eat it and that, you know, they're just gonna
- 19:23socialize the losses once again. No investment bank or no, like,
- 19:27you know, maybe a few of them isolated, but there's not going
- 19:29to be some like. Mass banking crisis where all of
- 19:33these, you know, the whole bank system fails or like they they
- 19:35sustain massive losses because they made bad investments.
- 19:37The Fed's just going to make them whole, right?
- 19:39Like that's essentially what the BTFP already is.
- 19:41It's like, oh, it's only one year, don't worry about it.
- 19:44But here's your, you know, here's here's this asset that's,
- 19:47you know, 70 cents, $0.65 on the dollar you get to post as
- 19:50collateral at par, right. And oh, also any, any
- 19:53institution using this domestic international, we're not going
- 19:57to reveal your name, right, like.
- 19:59Like what is this? And no one even understands the
- 20:01mechanics of this, but it was a bailout, right?
- 20:03Like like can I pledge my Bitcoin as collateral at $69,000
- 20:06value? No, duh, right.
- 20:09Like that's that doesn't that doesn't compute.
- 20:11But you know, they they play at a different set of rules,
- 20:13obviously. Yeah, if you could pull up
- 20:18Jesse's tweet, really visualizing the amount of losses
- 20:24that, yeah, the Fed is holding on their balance sheet right
- 20:27now, it's pretty. Pretty astonishing to see this
- 20:29chart. Yeah I I came across this chart
- 20:32on on Twitter. It's for people not watching
- 20:35it's it's kind of a straight line at like basically 0 but in
- 20:39the positive this is their profit the Feds profits and
- 20:45remittance. Remittance is due to the
- 20:47treasury is is the the term that they use.
- 20:49But it when you dig into it what that means is actually profits
- 20:52for the Fed is generating but then in the last six months.
- 20:57In really nine months it has fallen off a Cliff like
- 21:00dramatically. It looks like a AD peg of a
- 21:04stable coin and the accounting on this is comical.
- 21:08Dylan nailed it that, you know, this remittance is due to the
- 21:13Treasury is Fed profits that they feed back to the US
- 21:17Treasury for use in in general spending.
- 21:20So that's you know that's the the agreement for the Fed and
- 21:24and their operating mandate they any profits get used for you
- 21:28know general spending elsewhere but if they have losses those
- 21:33losses just sit on the on the Fed's balance sheet which is
- 21:37central bank balance sheet expansion which is this cardinal
- 21:41sin that we're all shouting from the rooftops about like you know
- 21:46this is a problem we we got to watch out for this.
- 21:49This is Japanification. So when you hear that term, you
- 21:52know, that means the central bank stepping in to buy all that
- 21:56distressed assets because there's no other buyer and okay.
- 22:00Great, That's, that's fine. But what does that mean?
- 22:04Well, it, it means inflation. It means that you're growing the
- 22:07monetary base because the Fed is writing blank checks and that
- 22:13manifests somewhere as inflation.
- 22:15So you're paying for it in this indirect tax of inflation.
- 22:18Ultimately and that process has now has now begun and I think
- 22:22Dylan's right that you know these underwater securities,
- 22:26these U.S. Treasuries that were, you know,
- 22:281% yield, we're not going to go back to that.
- 22:32So they're going to be underwater indefinitely.
- 22:36And in that scenario, they're just going to have to roll this
- 22:39program and keep expanding this program as other shoes drop like
- 22:42commercial real estate and they have to step in and create a new
- 22:45acronym facility. For regional banks that have
- 22:49commercial real estate exposure and that Japanification process
- 22:53just will snowball and continue. These are these are layers that
- 22:57will be added over time and then the net of it is balance sheet
- 23:00expansion creating inflation and the overall deterioration of our
- 23:06fiscal system. As we walk through this, it's
- 23:11like. The stuff we're talking about,
- 23:13it's been talked about, you know, all year we knew real
- 23:15estate, COVID, it was going to change the trajectory and we're
- 23:18breaking down like how after the tits up, everything goes.
- 23:21But it made me realize This is why there's so much moral hazard
- 23:24baked into. There's more hazard baked in the
- 23:27products because we know real estate, we know what happens to
- 23:30commercial estate, but we're not necessarily concerned because we
- 23:32know some form of BTFP pensions also have large exposure to
- 23:36commercial real estate. They owe, you know, capital to
- 23:39people retired. So that's going to have to be
- 23:41made whole by somebody. But I think this is what makes
- 23:44it so hard to explain Bitcoin, especially when it comes to the
- 23:48financial products and how you actually secure.
- 23:51Because most people inherently have in their their mind like
- 23:55when they go and secure assets. Like, yeah, I know there's maybe
- 23:58something that might happen, but it'll be figured out we'll we'll
- 24:01get it done with like they would never let me start like we're in
- 24:03the United States. There's all these like things
- 24:05that the moral hazards baked into financial products in the
- 24:08US. And so like, what we talk about,
- 24:10we all know and I think intuitively more and more people
- 24:12are raking up. But it's similar to like what
- 24:14happened with COVID in the sense that most people are like, like
- 24:17they could never really put us in a box.
- 24:18They could really never shut us down.
- 24:20And then it happened and I think some people woke up, but we
- 24:23still have so many people a slave that like, people
- 24:25inherently know there's a lot wrong.
- 24:27But at the same time, I think just bailout after bailout.
- 24:33Record after decade, it's just baked into the site that it
- 24:37can't really actually spin out of control.
- 24:40And I think that ties up to just why it's so hard with this new
- 24:44asset, like in how you secure it and how you deal with it.
- 24:46Because it's like, I'm not worried about it.
- 24:48It'll be figured out. But every year and then every
- 24:51decade in the Bitcoin space, we just realized that's actually
- 24:53not how it works. And a bunch of people end up
- 24:55with holding zeros where they thought they were holding, you
- 24:59know, Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 25:01And Jesse and Dillon both reference Fed speak, the Fed
- 25:05trying to posture a particular way to exude a confidence on the
- 25:09markets. And Jesse, you just fell for
- 25:12some Fed speak, you said regional banks they'll have to
- 25:14bail out and that's one thing I think we do need to make clear
- 25:18with what happened earlier this year with signature, First
- 25:21Republic, Silvergate and those free banks predominantly that
- 25:28was. Marketed as a regional banking
- 25:30crisis. But we cannot forget that those
- 25:32are three of the five largest banking failures in U.S.
- 25:35history. Like they're trying to say, Oh
- 25:37no, it's just the regional banks.
- 25:39Yes, it's not the JP Morgan's, the Wells, Wells Fargo's of the
- 25:43world quite yet, But labeling those banks as regional banks to
- 25:49exude a sort of contained crisis in a smaller segment of the
- 25:55banking sector is. Some Fed speak that that people
- 25:59have fallen for. Yeah, I'd go even as far as
- 26:01saying inflation, there's no inflation or it's reduced to 3%
- 26:04is another component of Fed speed.
- 26:06It feels like there's a tale of two worlds like of uh just in
- 26:11the US when you think about coastal kind of like you turn on
- 26:13CNN and what's actually happening in the world and
- 26:15there's a tale of two economies. When you hear of like the Wall
- 26:18Street top 10 to 20% and would actually people are feeling and
- 26:21there's completely two different things like Marty posted or I
- 26:24don't know if you posted but it or you posted on Twitter.
- 26:26I don't think we showed it on the show.
- 26:28Where the the haircut the Barber been like the in upstate New
- 26:34York basically had been trying to hold off as long as possible
- 26:37to increase prices. And like anecdotally where where
- 26:40I live there's a lady that like delivers food as part of one of
- 26:43these services. And she was just sharing how
- 26:46she's seen like every quarter in the past two years.
- 26:49How her number of like clients just start to reduce in the
- 26:52amount of groceries they're buying.
- 26:54Where she used to have a whole like ultimately like a book of
- 26:56business that's just been like. Cut down 75% because people
- 26:59don't have the disposable income to either buy more groceries or
- 27:02have to use those services. And so this is like across the
- 27:04whole economy where people are getting like kneecapped.
- 27:07And you know we talked about credit and in debt and credit
- 27:09cards and all the things associated, but it's just it's
- 27:13not as cut and dry. I think and I think Dylan, you
- 27:16talked about it where there's like core and CPI but in the
- 27:18reality they're both like tied in together.
- 27:20It's kind of like the Fed and the economists that decide to
- 27:23like start to pull out and the different levers they want to
- 27:25describe. How they are separate, but in
- 27:28reality, like, they both feed directly into, you know,
- 27:30disposable income and how dollars are used.
- 27:33Yeah, and this. Next.
- 27:35Well, to tie back to Dillon, I want to get your thoughts on
- 27:39this, like talking about the Fed trying to induce a soft landing,
- 27:43really targeting the labor market and unemployment.
- 27:46Logan, if you pull up the participation rate chart, the
- 27:49screenshot I shared and slacks, one thing I'm very interested to
- 27:53see is. Does the participation rate like
- 27:55obviously we're coming off the back end of the economic
- 27:58lockdowns. We've had a lot of layoffs in
- 28:00the tech sector and there are a lot of jobs available, but
- 28:03they're typically in the service sector.
- 28:05And so this is one thing I wonder the participation rate
- 28:09specifically, does it throw a wrench in the Fed's ability to
- 28:12create a soft landing because as people remain unemployed for
- 28:17longer and fall out of the unemployment calculation?
- 28:22And fall into the falling participation rate, like does
- 28:25that really prevent the Fed from actually reaching that target
- 28:29because so many people are falling out the denominator.
- 28:31If you see on the right side of this chart, the participation
- 28:34rate after increasing pretty significantly after the COVID
- 28:39lockdowns, never reached the point where it was right before
- 28:43the lockdowns. But it seems to be flatlining
- 28:45and could be going lower moving forward.
- 28:49Yeah, I have a lot of interesting thoughts about the
- 28:51participation rate and like some of them aren't, aren't too
- 28:54nuanced, but I think there's like a huge bifurcation in the
- 28:58labor market that just like you know, unemployment rate or like
- 29:00even labor participation rate doesn't capture.
- 29:03And like some of this is anecdotal, but like you know,
- 29:06especially especially in 2022 when you know all these tech
- 29:09stocks got decimated and you know the VC bubble somewhat
- 29:12burst like. AI seems to be reinvigorating
- 29:15that kind of like micro bubble in a way, but I can just tell I
- 29:20wouldn't have graduated college a couple months ago talking to
- 29:23all my friends. A lot of these people are
- 29:26applying, close friends are applying to good jobs.
- 29:30They have great degrees, got good resumes.
- 29:34And none of them can get like you know, basic entry level jobs
- 29:37and you know into like the remote workforce, right.
- 29:39Where as two years ago these people would have been making
- 29:42six figures off the bat at a tech firm in San Francisco, like
- 29:45no problem with stock options right.
- 29:48And and you know meanwhile like if you look at just like the
- 29:51blue collar sector like you know, my dad is is he has, he's
- 29:55a small family business like does some electrical work.
- 29:57The median age for those blue collar guys is like. 5657 years
- 30:02old and there's no one coming down the pipe, right?
- 30:04So like, and at the same time you have like AI that's like
- 30:08apps and the AI memes are kind of outrageous.
- 30:11Like AI is going to bring our utopia or it's going to like
- 30:15displace 100 billion jobs. It's like, OK, let's settle down
- 30:18a bit. But it is definitely going to
- 30:20displace a lot of entry level like e-mail type jobs, right?
- 30:24Like you just see it like Microsoft record profit, they
- 30:27laid off like 1000 workers or a couple thousand.
- 30:29I don't remember the exact number.
- 30:31And I think this is a trend that will continue, right.
- 30:33And so, yeah, is the unemployment rate gonna go up a
- 30:36bit while we're in this tightening cycle?
- 30:39Probably. I don't really know the
- 30:41direction of the labor force participation rate, but I do
- 30:43know there's a massive mismatch. In, you know, the type of jobs
- 30:46that especially like for America, the world reserve
- 30:49currency, we kind of have this artificially strong dollar,
- 30:52right? Like the coastal elites for the
- 30:54past 40 years, 20 years in particular have have really
- 30:57benefited. You know, Silicon Valley, Wall
- 30:59Street, DC have done great. Meanwhile, like, you know, the
- 31:03Rust Belt, American manufacturing gets absolutely
- 31:06hollowed out. And I think maybe that's not
- 31:08reversing, but you know, the whole COVID thing.
- 31:11Working remote and also like AI has kind of opened up this.
- 31:17You know, it kind of was like the the genies not maybe fully
- 31:20out of the bottle yet, but I think people are figuring out
- 31:22that you know work work is available globally, anybody can
- 31:26do it and even AI can do it. A lot of these like kind of
- 31:29really high paying like entry starter level jobs.
- 31:31And so I think there's a mismatch in terms of like
- 31:34especially in the American labor market where it's going to take
- 31:36a while to figure out and also like from a demographic
- 31:39perspective the boomers, a lot of these people that are
- 31:41working. These like blue collar jobs are
- 31:43all retiring, right? So like, I think that's
- 31:46something that can, you know, take a while to to shake out and
- 31:49also can kind of throw a wrench through a lot of these like, you
- 31:52know, employment models per se, right.
- 31:54Because like there's a lot of people looking for jobs.
- 31:56But like, you know, there's not a lot of people that are like
- 31:59looking to be a plumber, right? There's there's a lot of people
- 32:01that are looking to be a consultant at Deloitte.
- 32:04And that's like, you know, those aren't the same, Those aren't
- 32:08the, you know, one and the same in in the labor, in the labor
- 32:10market, but they are in the data.
- 32:12Yeah, That's something I think about a lot like there's gonna
- 32:15be, you hit the nail on the head like that's gonna be the next
- 32:18decade. We talk about like hard assets,
- 32:20hard skills are gonna be like, you know, hot commodities and
- 32:24being able to actually produce value in like meat space.
- 32:28And yeah, like we talk about like opportunity costs or cost
- 32:32of capital. And you think about like I was
- 32:34at Google and we work and I just always remember, you know, there
- 32:36was a. You know, two I was, I never
- 32:38spent more than three years at any of the firms and part of it
- 32:41was like going there and it was fun.
- 32:42But then you realize like these people aren't working.
- 32:44Like what are they doing? And it was just there was this
- 32:48baking in of the models of like growth and hiring.
- 32:51And we saw this at Twitter when Musk came in and basically cut
- 32:55you know 50% and nothing stopped working.
- 32:57You know where I think because we had been in the bull market
- 33:01for 10 plus years that it hadn't really been understood or felt
- 33:05one that. You can have a more efficient
- 33:08way to grow a company. But two, that the market could
- 33:10churn like this and the fact that it's happened and now it's
- 33:14in the psyche whenever it does and interest rates start to
- 33:16lower, it's still not going to come back fully where people
- 33:19just say, Oh yeah, let's just hire all these people and have
- 33:20them do nothing. And so there's going to be a lot
- 33:23of basically stock in people that to your point went to
- 33:27school to get out and be you know, whether it's consulting or
- 33:30work at Google that. Are going to have to go into the
- 33:32real world and and work. And I think a lot of those
- 33:35people have been sitting on the sidelines even have historically
- 33:37been sitting on the sidelines. But I think they also are now
- 33:40waiting for a market to come back or to your friends kind of
- 33:42like trying to see what's out there versus just getting in.
- 33:45So it's going to be a very crazy decade I think for folks that
- 33:49went to school because they were told to and they're in $100,000
- 33:52in debt and now have to figure out how to like produce value in
- 33:54the real world. And that's the only like value
- 33:57right now that's like looking for it to pay.
- 34:01Yeah. And to tie a couple of these
- 34:03themes together, I mean, interesting anecdote.
- 34:08I ran into an old, like middle school buddy from my hometown.
- 34:12He's down the shore, ran into him on the beach and we got the
- 34:15conversation start. And he's actually one of the
- 34:17few, you know, smart individuals in our generation and went and
- 34:21started his own plumbing business.
- 34:22But to tie this into. Like the real estate thing, like
- 34:27he's his business is crushing it.
- 34:28But he was telling me he's noticed in the last few months
- 34:31he's going to make small repairs to people's houses and he's he's
- 34:35showing them like his cost and what their bills are.
- 34:39And they're like looking at it in shock and they're actually a
- 34:41bit panicked because a number of his clients have told him, like,
- 34:44yeah, during COVID I took out a he lock on my house.
- 34:49And since interest rates have gone up like my my monthly
- 34:52mortgage rate, my monthly mortgage payments have gone up
- 34:55significantly, like I I don't think I can afford to actually
- 34:58make this repair. And so just another anecdote out
- 35:02there tying it back to the real estate market particularly I
- 35:05think and we're from like a small, humble blue collar town
- 35:09and there's a lot of people who made those decisions during the
- 35:12COVID lockdowns to take out. Equity loans from their houses
- 35:18that are sitting in precarious situations right now.
- 35:24Yep, the the amortization schedule and like the the
- 35:28calculation with interest rates from 2 and some change percent
- 35:31to like 6 1/2, seven, seven half percent is absolutely mind
- 35:35blowing. I saw some posts on Twitter, it
- 35:37was like people on Reddit being like like they didn't, you know,
- 35:40they didn't actually look into the math and they bought, they
- 35:42bought a house and they were like.
- 35:44Why is 90% of my payment in the first year going to interest?
- 35:48And it's like, it's like, well, that's how the math works, man.
- 35:51You know, you're paying 1,000,000 bucks for a $400,000
- 35:53house. That's, you know, that's the
- 35:55reality of a 7% interest rate. So, you know, it's not an
- 35:58immediate thing. But like, you know, no, no
- 36:01millennial can afford that. The median, the average net
- 36:03worth is negative, right. Never mind the Zoomers, like,
- 36:07you know, like there's there's just no way.
- 36:09That you know they have unsecured unsecured student loan
- 36:11debt and six figures. You know you're not buying a
- 36:13house that costs, you know X amount of your your average
- 36:17income. It's just it's just not
- 36:18realistic. So I think there has to be some
- 36:20equilibrium felt there. I think a lot of the boomers,
- 36:23maybe not this year, but a lot of the boomers over the next you
- 36:26know maybe 5-10 years are going to go to liquidate their home
- 36:29and realize that you know the the, the listing price that they
- 36:32thought that they would have. You know that clearing that
- 36:35clearing exchange rates actually a lot lower because no one can
- 36:38afford it, right like. Oh, you want to sell that second
- 36:40home you have? Well, you know, that market for
- 36:42buyers really doesn't have any money or not enough of it.
- 36:46So maybe houses continue to go up in nominal terms, but like,
- 36:49in real terms that the housing market was fueled by interest
- 36:53rates going lower for 40 years straight, Right.
- 36:55Like a lot of people thought they were genius for just
- 36:57levering up and, you know, house hacking or real estate hacking,
- 37:00and it was really just a leverage game with cost of
- 37:02capital going lower forever and that reversed.
- 37:05And it's almost like that kind of like Wiley Coyote meme where
- 37:07they run off the Cliff but gravity hasn't been felt yet.
- 37:11Not like saying like a great financial crisis.
- 37:14Wait, it's gonna happen again? The real estate market's doomed,
- 37:16but the valuation's out there. It's not really.
- 37:22Yeah, it's not really supportive for new buyers.
- 37:24Let's just say that. Yeah, this one makes it sort of
- 37:28makes it so precarious and the gradual and suddenly.
- 37:31Meme is like is generally real. Because I was on a conversation
- 37:34earlier and anecdotally one of the largest REITs in the Middle
- 37:38East for real estate was talking about the guy had been like the
- 37:42family office fear between London and like Dubai.
- 37:45And he was saying that his friends is kind of like the
- 37:47proxy for sharing the sentiment in the market and had reached
- 37:50out saying looking at the space, looking at Bitcoin, waiting for
- 37:53BlackRock to step in. And we're joking around, and
- 37:56we've talked about this before, but it's just like, you think
- 37:58about it like real estate is just a shitty form of Bitcoin,
- 38:00right? It's like a liquid.
- 38:01It's scarce, but you know, has a similar profile.
- 38:05And you know why? It's had some monetization
- 38:07around it. But as people wake up, it's like
- 38:10the first people through the door are going to probably make
- 38:12out okay, but then the door is only so wide until you have
- 38:16everybody trying to get out of these liquid assets.
- 38:18And we're right now in the context of real estate.
- 38:22And so I think that's how it ends up where like all you
- 38:25mentioned leverage like all the you know whether it's big short
- 38:28and it's the strippers with the multiple houses or it was you
- 38:31know basically the last trade the past two years and all the
- 38:34Airbnb leverage and the 10 to 30 houses.
- 38:38That everybody's going to be left holding this bag at some
- 38:41point. When that happens, there's only
- 38:44so many people like to be able to to move out of it in the
- 38:46Bitcoin before kind of the mismatch in like what the price
- 38:49of the house is versus like where they where they can
- 38:51purchase a Bitcoin at. Yeah.
- 38:53And I I mean, I do think we have to pay homage to the forgotten
- 38:57generation, Gen. XI.
- 38:58Mean we're talking about millennials not having enough
- 39:01money to buy these houses. But right after the boomers
- 39:04finish retiring, we're going to get this generation, Generation
- 39:07X. Setting up to retire and those
- 39:09born in 67, which I think is the front end of Generation XI, mean
- 39:14they'll be retiring 10 years from now.
- 39:16And if you look at this chart was shared in Zero Hedge earlier
- 39:20this week. Like the median Gen.
- 39:22Xer doesn't have more than $40,000 saved up for for
- 39:26retirement, which is insane. And they've got 10 years to
- 39:31build that nest egg if they hope to.
- 39:35Be able to retire in any sense. And so this isn't a problem.
- 39:39I think it's a more immediate problem than just defining it as
- 39:42a Millennium millennial problem. The Gen.
- 39:45Xers obviously not as large as the Boomers from a demographics
- 39:49perspective, but they're in a terrible position as well.
- 39:54Insane. That's an insane Just graphic.
- 39:57Second, median, median, median savings.
- 40:01Logan, can you throw out the the one I just put in the chat?
- 40:04Yeah. So this is a trend that's been
- 40:06happening basically like this chart for people who can't see
- 40:10it. It shows the the wealth, the
- 40:12percentage of the wealth owned by each generation as they age
- 40:17at that point in time. So the baby boomers is kind of
- 40:20up and to the right. They were accumulating wealth as
- 40:23they got older. Generation X has has had half
- 40:28the slope that the baby boomers had, which is to say they are
- 40:32accumulating. Half the percentage of the
- 40:35wealth as time goes on as they progress through their lives and
- 40:39the millennials are half of that.
- 40:41So you know even though we haven't gotten as far into life
- 40:43as Gen. X or the baby boomers, we are on
- 40:47track to achieve much less wealth than either Gen.
- 40:50X and you know like four times less than than the baby boomers.
- 40:55So and and if you were to put the, you know the next
- 40:58generation on this chart, it would probably be the same story
- 41:01again at a diminishing. Portion of the world's wealth
- 41:06accumulation over time because the circumstances are just so
- 41:10much harder for younger people. And like Dylan, I wanted to ask
- 41:14earlier, what's the sentiment for, like, your friend group
- 41:18about, you know, like the prospect of how you as a
- 41:22generation are are likely to do in terms of accumulating wealth?
- 41:25Or like being able to buy a house?
- 41:27Like, what's that like in your friend group?
- 41:31I mean there's a probably a small small part of that friend
- 41:34group that's very much orange pilled, but that's obviously not
- 41:37the the average perception or thinking, you know, so.
- 41:41So a small number of them have, you know, been buying and
- 41:43holding some Bitcoin. But I think for the most, for
- 41:46the most part the average or maybe median Gen.
- 41:49Z Zoomer doesn't actually think about any of this at all.
- 41:54You know, it's kind of just like live, live life in your 20s and
- 41:57then you know, like kind of a cold hard dose of reality.
- 42:01As you get older and still have that student debt and you know
- 42:04like there's there's no one really is looking to you know
- 42:07accumulate wealth build a family like the the kind of like
- 42:10American like you know nuclear family traditions that many like
- 42:14think of in terms of like the ideal maybe maybe it's not
- 42:18thought of as ideal anymore but like I think that's that's not
- 42:22the reality for the average for the average American Gen.
- 42:26Z it's it's you know it's just like kind of live it up we'll
- 42:29we'll figure it out like. Ethic we ball and you know,
- 42:33there's not much, not much longterm thinking there,
- 42:36unfortunately. For our generation, we had the,
- 42:40you know, the Yolo era of of cringy, you know, nihilism in
- 42:44the moment. And I feel like at some point
- 42:47that has to Crest and recede, but and I think that Bitcoin is
- 42:52the reason why that happens because without hope for
- 42:56building a better financial future by saving.
- 42:59And accumulating wealth then you're going to live in the
- 43:02moment because there's no incentive to save.
- 43:05And so Bitcoin brings back that incentive and I think is I I see
- 43:09it as the most likely thing to turn the tide ultimately in
- 43:13terms of shifting our country and and the world back to the
- 43:19incentives of building a a life and saving for the future on an
- 43:23individual basis and you know an institutional basis as well.
- 43:27And I think. I was going to say I think Gen.
- 43:30Z's at a disadvantage to really wrap their heads around this
- 43:33too. I mean as millennials, I'm 32, I
- 43:36was a senior in high school when 08 happened and that was the
- 43:40obviously the largest financial crisis in my life up to that
- 43:44point. And we watched at a very young
- 43:47age the banks get bailed out, TARP get past and then QE happen
- 43:54and as a young 18 year old that radicalized me and.
- 43:58I think this time around for Gen.
- 44:00ZI Guess, their baby financial crisis was COVID and the
- 44:03lockdowns and they saw markets tank.
- 44:05But on the back end of that, it was a different type of
- 44:08stimulus, which was direct deposits in the bank accounts.
- 44:12And so they probably have this false sense of security that the
- 44:16financial crises happen in the future.
- 44:19The government's going to be there, they're going to bail out
- 44:22the banks, but they're also going to bail out individual
- 44:24Americans will start air dropping.
- 44:26Money into our bank accounts like they did post COVID, not
- 44:29internalizing the destructive nature that has on the value of
- 44:33your of your currency and your pursing power over time.
- 44:35And so there there may be a false sense of security sitting
- 44:39within the generation of zoomers that just went to the COVID
- 44:43crisis. Yeah, you know, Well, I'll take
- 44:46my $2000 check. Meanwhile, you know, businesses
- 44:49get, you know. Loans that are granted away for
- 44:52hundreds of thousands of dollars.
- 44:53Like there is really no understanding of that.
- 44:56It's pretty sad. One thing I I will say when you
- 44:58were showing the graphic of Gen. X median and and mean net worth,
- 45:03something really struck me and it was that and I'm not sure
- 45:05exactly how that was calculated but I would, I would bet and I
- 45:07could be totally wrong here but I would bet that in the those
- 45:10statistics it you know accounts for like 401 k's and pensions or
- 45:13whatever else And The funny thing or maybe not funny but
- 45:16kind of sad thing is that. It's, you know, that is not
- 45:20savings, right? It's it's just passive
- 45:22indexation into a broad basket of, you know, equities and bond
- 45:26securities and like, oh, so you know, you're just passively
- 45:29buying tech at 30X multiples, right?
- 45:33Like after after they've gone up, you know, 20X over the past
- 45:37two decades, right? Like Apple's gone up 30% a year
- 45:39for the last 20 years, right. And so now you're just like DC
- 45:42ING into like a mega Corp that, you know, BlackRock and Vanguard
- 45:46are going to have like. You know that are going to own
- 45:48the shares and you'll get your ETF and and that's savings now
- 45:52like that's you know that's equivalent to savings is just
- 45:55like Oh yeah you know we'll have some financial advisor DCAU into
- 46:00into equity indices no matter the price and that's just like
- 46:03considered normal that's actually considered a prudent
- 46:05decision because the money's bad the money doesn't work and and
- 46:09you know now like you know for the past 20 years bonds haven't
- 46:12even been a valuable form of of investment with no yield.
- 46:16That's changing, at least temporarily.
- 46:17But like, savings isn't actually a concept that's understood at
- 46:22all, because there's been no incentive to understand it.
- 46:24In the 80s it was like different, right?
- 46:26Or like there was an interest rate.
- 46:28Now it's like, who's gonna sit no one saves in a checking or
- 46:31savings account? You know anybody that does
- 46:33understand like savings like oh you know I'll I'll trade futures
- 46:36on the on Robin Hood it's like no like that there's the whole
- 46:40perception of like wealth accumulation has been distorted
- 46:43and particularly like post COVID for anybody that's kind of like
- 46:46new to the game but you know that's not savings like that
- 46:49that's just like you know we're just going along for the ride
- 46:51and people have been rewarded for it.
- 46:53Right. It's been it's been right
- 46:54because that's been the direction has been up because of
- 46:56the stimulus because everybody's passively indexing into these
- 46:59things. Like, stocks don't go up
- 47:02forever, right? Like this is people, like
- 47:04Americans especially, think that this is a reality.
- 47:06It's like all you have to do is look to Europe, You have to look
- 47:08to any really emerging market to know that actually, no, stocks
- 47:11don't only go up forever. And at some point there's going
- 47:14to be, you know, a point of reckoning and not saying it
- 47:16happens a cycle or whatever, right.
- 47:18But like, you know, the real estate market, the stock market,
- 47:21you know, we, the bond market kind of already had this moment
- 47:24and topping in 2020. And then it went down 30% and
- 47:26everybody was like, whoa, what is happening?
- 47:29But like this is what you get. You know, people aren't
- 47:30investing based on like the quality of a company or it's
- 47:33balance sheet or it's, you know, it's discounted cash flows.
- 47:36People are passively just chucking money at a basket of
- 47:40companies at any price. And it's leading to these like
- 47:43you know, gross distortions that nobody really knows the long
- 47:45term impacts of until, you know, we run into a, you know, crisis
- 47:50and then things are like, you know, panic mode.
- 47:52And so I, you know, that's just like something like I think a
- 47:54lot of people see like can't see the forest for the trees.
- 47:57It's like. You know, this is, this is a
- 47:59warped, grotesque kind of monstrosity of an economy that,
- 48:03you know, Fiat has built over the last, you know, I mean a
- 48:08long time but last 50 years, 40 years in particular.
- 48:11And and we're just kind of like on this train that's headed off
- 48:14the tracks on a long on a long time frame and everybody's just
- 48:17kind of docile and okay with it. And like without Bitcoin, like
- 48:20we wouldn't have, you know, any, we wouldn't have anything to
- 48:23like protest that we wouldn't have anything to like opt out
- 48:26of. That system other than like, you
- 48:28know, vote harder, which is like what?
- 48:30What does that, what does that lead to?
- 48:32So, like, you know, it's a pessimistic world if you don't
- 48:34have an optionality or you don't have a choice.
- 48:37But like, thankfully we have a choice and we're all voting with
- 48:39our capital to, to opt into that world.
- 48:42But a lot of people get like, you know, they think of the
- 48:44Bitcoin thing as just like, you know, some mancaps and some
- 48:47weirdos and some laser ad guys on Twitter.
- 48:49It's like, no, like actually we see the world for what it is.
- 48:52It's actually not. Not how it should be.
- 48:55If you just kind of peel back the onion and it doesn't
- 48:58logically makes no sense that you save in a basket of
- 49:01equities. But like, Oh yeah, they only go
- 49:03up and they go up 10% a year. Like you ever see like, like all
- 49:06all over, like TikTok, which is like Gen.
- 49:08Z Financial advice. People are like, Oh yeah, just,
- 49:11you know, if you just passively invest for 50 years, you'll have
- 49:151,000,000 bucks by retirement. And it's like, and people
- 49:18believe that people are like, Oh yeah, like that's how I get
- 49:20rich. It's just like, you know, punt
- 49:22money into stocks. And it only goes up and it's
- 49:25just like these preconceived notions are totally wrong.
- 49:28And at some point it's gonna lead to a lot of people getting
- 49:31hurt. And at some point, I mean,
- 49:33that's gonna be the case for people that have been doing this
- 49:35for a long time, The pensioners, right?
- 49:37Like the people that think they have money that's not there,
- 49:40Marty, you just tweeted about it.
- 49:42It's a sad, sad reality. And without Bitcoin, there
- 49:45wouldn't be much hope. Yeah, you you didn't know.
- 49:47It really is sad. And what's crazy is everything
- 49:50you just described is really so like obvious and conservative.
- 49:53If you think about we go back 50 or 100 years, if we switch
- 49:56Bitcoin for gold or savings or getting married and start
- 50:00producing value at the age of 18, like these are all just like
- 50:02concepts that existed for thousands of years in between
- 50:05like propaganda, societal change and all the things that go along
- 50:09with it, what you just described.
- 50:12To the majority of individuals that say you're insane, you're
- 50:14nuts. Like I even have like you know
- 50:16family members are like, Oh yeah, like you know, they still
- 50:18find out like wife has a 401K that's hanging.
- 50:20I'm like converted to bitcoins. Like, no, we gotta like just be
- 50:22careful just because in her head it's like it's a 401K, it's like
- 50:24my old account. It has to be safe like just in
- 50:27case that Bitcoin thing doesn't work out and it's just it's just
- 50:31sad like that. It's the like the narrative and
- 50:34the things that society like everybody, whether it's because
- 50:37it's work that's required or just going against a narrative
- 50:40that like. They just accept all it takes is
- 50:42looking just right behind the curtains to see everything you
- 50:45just described on. And it really is sad because
- 50:48it's just like right there. All you have to do is just like
- 50:51peek behind it and realize that everything that's been explained
- 50:55or told or all the debt and all the things that you've learned
- 50:58are not actually what they seem to be.
- 51:00And then you're just ready to like.
- 51:02Understand what's happening here and you can take that different
- 51:04position of understanding, Okay. Well, I can accumulate, I can
- 51:06have a plan to raise a family, have a child, retire, start the
- 51:10business. But instead it's just like going
- 51:13further and further out the risk curve.
- 51:15I was at the store a couple weeks back and I don't know how
- 51:17Bitcoin came up with the checker.
- 51:19But then the bagger, I was like, hey, I'm curious like, what is
- 51:22your thought about Bitcoin? He's like, oh man, this shit's
- 51:24crazy. He's like, you know, crypto.
- 51:26Like, I know you can make some money, which you can lose it
- 51:28all. And that's like the perception
- 51:29of the of the markets. Just like, oh, well, I'll play
- 51:31with crypto. But I know I can lose it all,
- 51:33but maybe I can make it all back as similar as a lottery ticket.
- 51:36So there's still so much education and just, yeah,
- 51:40education on this part and within society to get that
- 51:43intolerant minority to the place where it's like, okay, this is
- 51:46the thing that I can actually hold my value in, to increase
- 51:49purchase and power and actually have a better life for myself
- 51:51and family. Yeah.
- 51:53And. I listened to a podcast earlier
- 51:55this week. I highly recommend anybody
- 51:57listening you'll listen to this episode of Invest like the best.
- 52:02Patrick O'Shaughnessy had David Einhorn on recently and he
- 52:05basically went on an hour long diatribe of how value investing
- 52:09is completely dead right now just because of the role of
- 52:12passive investing and people just DC ING in the stocks the
- 52:16way Dylan described like it is somebody.
- 52:20Who made their whole career around value investing
- 52:22essentially tapped out and saying, like, yeah, I don't.
- 52:23I don't think there's room for value investors right now
- 52:26because the market is so insane. Yeah, I mean, you're fighting a
- 52:30£10,000 gorilla, right? Like, like, oh, this, this thing
- 52:33is undervalued or overvalued, right?
- 52:35Like, oh, I don't think NVIDIA should be worth, you know, 400
- 52:38times revenue or, you know, that.
- 52:40I just made that up off the top of my head.
- 52:41But like, you know, it logically doesn't really make much sense,
- 52:44right? But like, no, you're fighting
- 52:46billions and billions and billions of dollars
- 52:47indiscriminate flows and actually the bigger they.
- 52:50Get the more index weight they have right?
- 52:52Like, oh, Tesla, you know, worth, you know, 2X more than
- 52:54every single automotive company in the world combined.
- 52:58Like that doesn't make sense like at the peak of the, you
- 53:01know, 2021 bubble, right. But like you know, just like
- 53:04throw some call option gamblers and throw some ETF index flows
- 53:08and throw a couple leverage ETF's and you know you Tesla can
- 53:11be whatever you want it to be, right?
- 53:13Like that's the the state of things and it's it's really, you
- 53:16know, just it's. It is what it is.
- 53:19But that's not like that. People think of that as like
- 53:22investing. It's not right.
- 53:25It's not investing. It's somewhat of a casino.
- 53:29And this is a little bit of like a tangential point.
- 53:32But growing up where I grew up, where I went to school, very,
- 53:37very leftist progressive state. And once I kind of got my
- 53:40political bearings, I was like. Almost like repulsed by it.
- 53:43I'm like, how could they think this?
- 53:45And then as I matured a bit in my understanding of how it all
- 53:49works, I sympathize with them. I was like, no, I get it.
- 53:52Actually, I get why these people are protesting and saying eat
- 53:56the rich. Not that I disagree with it, and
- 53:59I think that they lack an understanding and a bit of a
- 54:02nuance of how this all occurred. But like, yeah, like, why should
- 54:06that person that literally did nothing except just leverage up
- 54:10his real estate holdings for 40 years, be, you know, be on his
- 54:13third yacht and have 4 vacation homes?
- 54:15Like, what did they work harder than me, right.
- 54:18And like that's that's where we are.
- 54:20That's why the boomer wealth disparities is is so, is is, you
- 54:23know, so disproportionate. Like, it's not their fault.
- 54:27I'm not, you know, I don't hate, like hate someone for being
- 54:30rich. And I don't think anybody
- 54:31should. They played the game.
- 54:32They played it right. But like.
- 54:34You know, the fact that there is a game to play into almost like,
- 54:38you know, a rigged game, right. And the fact that, like, you
- 54:40know, 90% of people, 95% of people don't even understand
- 54:43that there's a game being played is the problem.
- 54:47But yeah, it's led to these gross distortions.
- 54:49It's led to the greatest wealth disparity ever.
- 54:51And we can see that these things lead to, you know, oftentimes
- 54:55like very, very polarized, polarized, populist, polarized
- 55:01political discourse. So like does it make sense that
- 55:03you know that there's a, you know, Bernie has supporters and
- 55:06AOC and those type of politicians have supporters on
- 55:10the left? Yeah, of course that makes a
- 55:12total sense. And I think, you know,
- 55:13unfortunately the the reality is that you know as we go into the,
- 55:17you know, late twenty 20s, early twenty 30s and there is this
- 55:20massive wealth disparity still and you know the the
- 55:23consequences of Fiat monetary policy continue to.
- 55:28To take course, there's going to be a lot of people that are
- 55:30very, very angry and there's going to be a lot, you know, the
- 55:322nd and 3rd order effects of that from a political standpoint
- 55:35are going to be scary for people that actually understand where
- 55:38it like where it leads and what it can lead to.
- 55:40So I mean I don't really have like a political solution to it
- 55:43other than like, you know, opt out and and vote with my capital
- 55:46for a better world. But like, you know, the people
- 55:49that think that we're just going to vote harder to get out of
- 55:51this is it's naive and you know, lacks a bit of understanding to
- 55:55how we got here. Yeah.
- 55:59Yeah, vote harder with your value.
- 56:03That's the only real thing that you can do, I think.
- 56:06I mean that's the only real vote you have right at the end of the
- 56:09day particularly in America in 2023 if you understand the
- 56:15political landscape and the way the, I mean RFK has a lot of
- 56:20support right now, it's likely that the.
- 56:24DNC is going to box him out of being able to actually run in
- 56:29this election because they're they have their guy and they're
- 56:32just going to push him forward whether or not he can speak a
- 56:35full sentence or not. Like they they want to hold the
- 56:38power they have and they're going to use everything at their
- 56:41disposal to ensure that they keep that power and there's
- 56:44nothing you can do. I know this is controversial and
- 56:47people really don't like to hear it, but your vote in that system
- 56:51does not matter. Your your vote.
- 56:54With your capital has much more leverage than any vote that you
- 56:57can put in the ballot box for the President of the United
- 56:59States. Yeah, the change is going to be
- 57:01emergent, just like money emerges in a free market.
- 57:04Like when Dylan, like what you said, really resonated because
- 57:06I've had this thought from like an investment opportunity.
- 57:08I don't have the time, but I think somebody should do this
- 57:11and it will happen is and they do this.
- 57:13Landry's is a good example. I think he's a partial owner in
- 57:17the Houston Rockets. Marty, if you remember his name,
- 57:20because I know he's like, I think he's a bitcoiner.
- 57:22But what he did was he was like in restaurants for a while and
- 57:25he he found this like part of the market that was inefficient
- 57:29in the sense that he understood like people that run restaurants
- 57:32are generally, you know, they really.
- 57:33Like food and they like the hospitality, but they don't run
- 57:36a company in the most like efficient way.
- 57:38And so Long story short he basically aggregated, he was
- 57:41buying up restaurants and then he centralized the point of like
- 57:45operations back office into a central point I think it was in
- 57:49Houston to really just like increase margin and operational
- 57:52fitness and he runs like one of the largest Landry's food.
- 57:57Kind of like conglomerates or whatever.
- 57:59Or if he's a billionaire. The point being is like I think
- 58:01there's something interesting to be done just in like helping
- 58:04blue collar work. Whether it's electricians,
- 58:05plumbers in certain like localities or markets to be able
- 58:09to aggregate and then help them get like on a Bitcoin standard
- 58:12or like at least start to accept Bitcoin, understand Bitcoin.
- 58:14Because at the end of the day like when we go to the most
- 58:17micro level, the individual. Just the single plumber or the
- 58:22restaurant individual that accepts a unit of currency that
- 58:25increases and purchasing power is going to have an unfair
- 58:27advantage by definition, than the person that doesn't.
- 58:29That's holding the dollar. And when that person increases
- 58:33its purchasing power, it can increase its marketability, the
- 58:36products and services it can offer, And ultimately, like the
- 58:39good or the societal impact, it can give back to its close
- 58:44network. Its.
- 58:45Town of the people around it and that starts to build up into and
- 58:49I know Marty talk a lot about the strong towns.
- 58:51I've ever read it. But I would imagine this is
- 58:53talks a lot about like you have to start there before change can
- 58:55really happen and that's where we we talk about this.
- 58:58And I think it's so important from like a business perspective
- 59:00for folks to like at least start to hold a little bit because you
- 59:03start to see that and it really is the the ultimate unfair
- 59:06advantage because year over year if you're able to withstand the
- 59:09withstand the volatility size it correctly.
- 59:12Over time you get this like freedom to do the things that
- 59:15you need to do, whether it's personally or for your business
- 59:17to expand versus be on this hamster wheel where you're going
- 59:20backwards. Like the guy that took the, you
- 59:22know home equity line of credit and now he can't even pay for
- 59:25the the, the, the repair versus having a formal currency that he
- 59:30can take care of that and also expand whatever he's doing.
- 59:34So yeah, I think the, yeah, I think most people on this, on
- 59:37this pod, but like I've never voted in my life.
- 59:39I've never thought any. Anything I could ever do
- 59:43personally would ever change, even from a, you know, like
- 59:48equities and stuff. I had Google stock.
- 59:50I sold it the second it would vest.
- 59:51I never have held an equity outside of that.
- 59:54It's just like it never. It was, it was never trust that
- 59:57I was going to give my money to somebody else and then they were
- 59:59going to give me some more back. And I think that's felt more and
- 1:00:03more over time. I agreed on the voting
- 1:00:06standpoint. I mean, I haven't registered to
- 1:00:09vote either, only been through one election cycle where I have
- 1:00:12been able to, but I'm not gonna register again.
- 1:00:16I am a supporter of Rfk's potential ability to shift the
- 1:00:21Overton window. You know, I like people I think
- 1:00:25are missing the forest for the trees again.
- 1:00:26They're like, no, he's never gonna win or no.
- 1:00:29You know, imagine if he did buy Bitcoin.
- 1:00:31It would crash and then and it would crash the dollar and all
- 1:00:34these but blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 1:00:35And it's like guys like the, you know, he has plus 1400 odds.
- 1:00:39And I would say, you know, I think maybe they're a bit
- 1:00:41higher, maybe not. And you know, Joe Biden can't
- 1:00:44speak a word, He's over there in Congress, you know, on both the
- 1:00:48right and the left, getting an applause for his ability to just
- 1:00:50have a compassionate conversation.
- 1:00:52And he's saying. Hey, you know, I think we should
- 1:00:55lift capital gains on Bitcoin to, you know give some privacy
- 1:00:58back to, you know Americans with their transactions and to
- 1:01:01attract foreign and intellectual capital the US shores and Oh
- 1:01:04yeah, let's you know, passively just back, you know, maybe 1%,
- 1:01:08less than 1% of of new debt issuance with, you know, hard
- 1:01:12currencies will say, you know, Bitcoin, gold, silver, platinum,
- 1:01:15whatever, you know, a piece of boomers with the the metals, you
- 1:01:19know. But like, how is that a bad
- 1:01:21thing? I don't think.
- 1:01:22I think from a Bitcoin standpoint, when you understand
- 1:01:24what he's doing, he's obviously gunning for the for the Bitcoin
- 1:01:26crypto vote, duh. But like is that a bad thing
- 1:01:30whatsoever from a Bitcoin standpoint?
- 1:01:32No, it's not. It's actually a really great
- 1:01:34thing and I think maybe it's not front and center this
- 1:01:37presidential election. Next one it will be 100% and I'm
- 1:01:40I'm really curious to see if it'll be a, you know, right or
- 1:01:43left that embraces it. Like imagine if RFK and Trump.
- 1:01:46Had a debate. I mean, I I doubt RFK makes it
- 1:01:49out of the DNC. But imagine and Trump's like,
- 1:01:51you know, the the nationalist dollar supporter and RFK is
- 1:01:55saying no Bitcoin. This is you know imagine they
- 1:01:57had a debate on monetary policy like imagine that.
- 1:02:01Like that's what shifting the Overton window does, right.
- 1:02:03Like I think that's that's where it's a bit exciting right.
- 1:02:06However unrealistic it may be. Like people are again missing
- 1:02:09the point here we have a presidential candidate third in
- 1:02:12the polls polling better than Biden whether he gets a shot or
- 1:02:15not. Saying let's put Bitcoin on the
- 1:02:17treasury balance sheet and people are up there on spaces
- 1:02:20like debating the legal framework and stuff.
- 1:02:22It's like guys, you're totally missing.
- 1:02:25Like it's it's like it doesn't even why?
- 1:02:28What do you like? You totally missed the point of
- 1:02:30what? Of what this means.
- 1:02:33I completely agree. I think the shifting of the
- 1:02:37Overton window, even if it's done by presidential actually,
- 1:02:40especially if it's done by presidential candidate, is
- 1:02:43massive. For Bitcoin forces people to
- 1:02:45talk about it, to think about it.
- 1:02:47And I'm all for pushing that window closer and closer to our
- 1:02:51worldview. Yeah.
- 1:02:53And and I think it it forces every would be presidential
- 1:02:56candidate to watch how this is going and see like, oh wow, he's
- 1:03:01getting a lot of traction, a lot of attention, a lot of support
- 1:03:05just because he's pandering to the bitcoiners.
- 1:03:08So it gives him this incentive four years on the road or.
- 1:03:12Or two or six or eight for, you know whatever elections for
- 1:03:18other politicians to try to adopt A similar strategy and
- 1:03:21then it's part of the mainstream.
- 1:03:22So Marty, you talked about, you wrote about how Bitcoin wins
- 1:03:26from the margins and this is how that process goes.
- 1:03:30You you start with a more extreme political candidate and
- 1:03:34then the the success of that gambit induces the more
- 1:03:38mainstream candidates to adopt that strategy in the future.
- 1:03:45Yeah. And you're already see, I mean
- 1:03:47at the Bitcoin conference, I'm pretty sure like Vivek
- 1:03:52Ramaswami, who's been rising in the polls in the Republican
- 1:03:55side, he was very supportive of Bitcoin and I think that forced
- 1:03:59DeSantis to come out and support.
- 1:04:02Obviously he was very against, very vocally against central
- 1:04:06bank digital currencies, but he's had to at least pay some
- 1:04:09lip service to Bitcoin. Whether or not he would allow it
- 1:04:13to flourish if he becomes president.
- 1:04:15So yeah, I completely agree, like.
- 1:04:18Just. Forcing people to talk about
- 1:04:20this and it will be very interesting.
- 1:04:22In the heat of the 2024 election, we're going to have a
- 1:04:25having. There's going to be another
- 1:04:27Bitcoin conference right in the lead up to November a few months
- 1:04:32before people actually go to vote.
- 1:04:34And I think the conversation around Bitcoin if we think it's.
- 1:04:42Pretty substantial. Now I don't, I don't even think
- 1:04:45we can imagine how, how front and center it will be,
- 1:04:49especially if there's some economic turmoil that's going on
- 1:04:53at the same time as well. I think the the conditions from
- 1:04:58a narrative perspective are lining up very much in Bitcoin's
- 1:05:01favor over the next year and a half.
- 1:05:06The narrative of like you know FOMC press conferences and like
- 1:05:10it's it's always it's always fun on on days where like you know
- 1:05:14they it's not like 100% locked in what they're gonna do like
- 1:05:17some days you know the market essentially or Powell through
- 1:05:19their you know signaling and Fed speak kind of say what they're
- 1:05:22gonna do before but sometimes it's like oh is the Fed gonna
- 1:05:25cut? Is the Fed gonna hold?
- 1:05:27Is the Fed gonna pause and it's like you know who knows or like
- 1:05:30you know it's like a Sunday night press release for some
- 1:05:32intervention or some like emergency rate.
- 1:05:35Rate cut or whatever versus like Bitcoin programmatic next block
- 1:05:39next block next block having right.
- 1:05:41And it's like, it's like, oh you know it's gonna be like
- 1:05:43mid-april. And as it gets closer and closer
- 1:05:46and closer and we see what the difficulty is and what hash rate
- 1:05:49does, that time gets more and more and more precise.
- 1:05:51And then all of a sudden inevitable no matter what you
- 1:05:53say, no matter what you do, it halves.
- 1:05:55And like, we obviously all understand that function like
- 1:05:58for Bitcoiners, but for like the majority of people like just
- 1:06:02like I wasn't COVID, they're printing a bunch of money and
- 1:06:04then it's like, wait. This thing, what do you mean
- 1:06:07have like the supply have. Oh no, the the inflation rate
- 1:06:09have the issuance. Oh like that's interesting.
- 1:06:12And you know it was more just like kind of the people
- 1:06:14interested in finance and economics that paid attention.
- 1:06:17But like, yeah, imagine if it's RFK or Vivek or whatever who's
- 1:06:21like rising and probably outpaces to Santis at some
- 1:06:23point. He's a pretty reasonable
- 1:06:24candidate talking about Bitcoin and its merits and sound money
- 1:06:27while boom halves, while, you know Jerome Powell and the Fed
- 1:06:31cut rates and you know, say that BTFP.
- 1:06:35Is going to because look at BTFP the one year, right that was
- 1:06:38that was late March when late March 2023, right.
- 1:06:41So if they're going to renew that or they're going to let you
- 1:06:44know 100 plus billion worth of bonds you know marked at a you
- 1:06:48know par value collateral roll off or are they going to extend
- 1:06:51that right at the time of the Bitcoin having right.
- 1:06:53So like yeah, I I think like the having is you know people
- 1:06:57including Jesse at your post and maybe we shift to this after
- 1:07:01this the stock to flow thing like.
- 1:07:04The supply side of it is is the main topic of discussion.
- 1:07:07But often times, and maybe this is a bit contrary to like the
- 1:07:12the typical view is that I think that the having is also a demand
- 1:07:16driver because it it like reinforces people's
- 1:07:20understanding or maybe lack thereof changes that
- 1:07:23understanding of like what it actually is like the
- 1:07:25programmatic monetary policy. Not everybody understands that
- 1:07:28people don't know what a Bitcoin block is or you know. 210,000
- 1:07:33blocks until having, like, nobody really knows what that
- 1:07:35is. They don't really Bitcoin, just
- 1:07:37kind of this, you know, thing that trades and has a price, but
- 1:07:40it's like, oh wait, it halved. What?
- 1:07:43What is, what is that? What are the implications there?
- 1:07:46Meanwhile, you know the Fed balance sheet is off to all time
- 1:07:48highs or whatever. And like even if it's just the
- 1:07:50Wall Street types that understand it or some, you know,
- 1:07:54some chunk of the political discourse that that gets orange
- 1:07:57pilled because of it, with each having more and more people
- 1:07:59understand it and it becomes more and more of a global event.
- 1:08:02And you know, the bitcoiners are partying, but like.
- 1:08:05That's gonna be it's gonna dominate the headlines that day.
- 1:08:07Bitcoin having nobody can stop it.
- 1:08:09Nobody can change it. Next one 2028, it's like whoa,
- 1:08:12that's powerful. So I think that from a demand
- 1:08:16driver the having will also be pretty, pretty damn significant.
- 1:08:20Guys, I haven't been this bullish for for about Bitcoin in
- 1:08:23a very long time. It's kind of crazy to think
- 1:08:26about like you guys just jogging all the like the lexicon and
- 1:08:29the. They're just like a stat
- 1:08:31establishment talking about bitcoins kind of crazy would
- 1:08:33make me think maybe you talk about the margins is like
- 1:08:35Senator Lummis was like patient zero in there and everybody's
- 1:08:38trying to they see like you know the response and they're all
- 1:08:41trying to pander to that crowd And then you know they're having
- 1:08:452020 seems like, you know so long ago that were so long and
- 1:08:48then also short that we're going to be right up four years again.
- 1:08:51And the stage is like set and the awareness is orders of
- 1:08:55magnitude larger and against the backdrop Dylan just shared.
- 1:08:58So it's. I can't imagine we're exciting
- 1:09:00time and then we're all building in this space and contributing
- 1:09:03that we get. So we're just front run it a
- 1:09:06little bit ahead of what's what's happening along with
- 1:09:08BlackRock, I think Black Rocks trying to frontrun it as well.
- 1:09:11Like think about what happens. It's the last having though
- 1:09:13right? We had we had micro strategy
- 1:09:14come out and say we're adopting a Bitcoin standard.
- 1:09:16We're going to we're going to sell shares by Bitcoin.
- 1:09:18We're going to issue debt by Bitcoin.
- 1:09:20This is our reserve ass that we're not selling it.
- 1:09:22We're going to post it as collateral borrow more money by
- 1:09:24Bitcoin. Yet 20 public miners that are
- 1:09:26trading with Bitcoin on their balance sheet that access credit
- 1:09:28lines and and whatever else. Yeah El Salvador come out oh
- 1:09:31it's only a small nation okay. That is established.
- 1:09:34You know bitcoin's legal tender lightning network, Bitcoin.
- 1:09:37We're going to DCA. You know a Bitcoin, one Bitcoin.
- 1:09:41Day right. It's a nation that's small.
- 1:09:42Whatever. But it's a precedent right.
- 1:09:44It's a it's a nation saying you know what, IMF we don't need
- 1:09:47your financing. Giving them the middle finger
- 1:09:49and saying we're gonna buy a Bitcoin.
- 1:09:50Now we have you know only the 3rd.
- 1:09:52The third leading presidential candidate say I'm gonna
- 1:09:55eliminate cap gains taxes and put Bitcoin in the balance sheet
- 1:09:58and people are like Oh no, you know he has no chance and it's
- 1:10:01like do you see what's happening directionally?
- 1:10:03Like only BlackRock said the ETF is you know they Bitcoin ETF
- 1:10:08like. Wake up, this is this is the
- 1:10:10trend and you know Bitcoin on a log scale is going up only and
- 1:10:14people are still just missing the whole point of this like
- 1:10:17haha, it's down 56% from all time highs and it's like you
- 1:10:21know man, I I can't really help you because you can't help
- 1:10:24yourself. It's only black Rockdale and I
- 1:10:28don't know what there is to be so excited about.
- 1:10:30It's only the largest capital allocator in the world.
- 1:10:34And then? I mean, we talked about it last
- 1:10:37week, but I've never been more bullish on the technical side of
- 1:10:42Bitcoin, like how strong the protocol is, all of the upgrades
- 1:10:46that have happened since the last having with Taproot and
- 1:10:49particularly in the maturation of the Lightning Network.
- 1:10:53Like I recorded an episode of TFTC with Cody Lowe, who's the
- 1:10:57head of developer Relations at Fetty.
- 1:10:59And I mean AI, to an extent it is a meme, but to another extent
- 1:11:04there is. A lot of fundamental value there
- 1:11:08and it is becoming abundantly clear that for a I to be, I mean
- 1:11:14we described this last week, but for a I to be as capital
- 1:11:18efficient as possible, they are going to have to integrate
- 1:11:21Lightning gated API access. And again the tooling around the
- 1:11:27lightning network with the different implementations and
- 1:11:29the different wallet development kits that are out there like it
- 1:11:33has reached a point of maturation.
- 1:11:35Over the last four years, where it can actually begin to be
- 1:11:39implemented broadly in different sectors of the economy, I happen
- 1:11:43to think that the AI industry will be a massive first mover,
- 1:11:47but we're going to have that quit that arrow in our quiver as
- 1:11:51well around the next having. It's like, yeah, you can
- 1:11:53actually implement the payments layer of Bitcoin rather easily
- 1:11:57now too. Yeah.
- 1:11:59That's a great point. Like the programmatic
- 1:12:01programmatic money, whether it's for AI or just the Internet.
- 1:12:05While the price appreciates and awareness grows from a
- 1:12:07technological perspective and engineers and some of the best
- 1:12:09talent looking at this and then it being able to be engineered
- 1:12:13via you know. The Internet and a I and just
- 1:12:17like we are like some of the investments like or companies
- 1:12:20like Wavelake or different firms that have a native unit embedded
- 1:12:24in their tech stack that is going to be an insane demand
- 1:12:27driver from 2024 to 2028. I think are there A's had the
- 1:12:31piece about A I, but I think there's just like 1 component
- 1:12:34once people wake up to it and the price is a function of the
- 1:12:37awareness, that's something that we don't even talk about enough
- 1:12:41of the like the amount of demand that's just on the supply.
- 1:12:44As it gets embedded into the text stack of the Internet.
- 1:12:48Exactly. And it's funny how, like Jack
- 1:12:51Dorsey nailed this where you said this is the native currency
- 1:12:55of the Internet and you think you understand all that.
- 1:13:00That means on the surface, like, oh OK, there's a now there's a
- 1:13:03currency that you can use on the Internet.
- 1:13:05But it's a really deep meme because it really talks about
- 1:13:11how all of these systems. Whether that's AI or or
- 1:13:15businesses or whatever, you can create this functionality and
- 1:13:18transactional ability that you can't with conventional
- 1:13:22currencies using this currency. So adoption starts to shift
- 1:13:26towards this thing where you can do something that you can you
- 1:13:29can't do with any other currency and that that that's a tailwind,
- 1:13:33that's a tailwind over time, over over decades, we think of
- 1:13:36the Internet as as being fully built out already like the
- 1:13:39Internet has happened, it's it's reached its.
- 1:13:43Final state that's not true. We're still in really in the
- 1:13:47middle of the Internet revolution and you know Bitcoin
- 1:13:52becoming the value unit that the the Internet can build on is
- 1:14:00kind of the the second-half of this Internet revolution
- 1:14:04overall. So that that's just one of the
- 1:14:06tailwinds you know as is the. The mainstreamification of the
- 1:14:13Overton window and in Bitcoin, at the same time that we're
- 1:14:16going to have, I think, massive stimulus to get us out of
- 1:14:20whatever financial crisis happens over the next 12 months
- 1:14:23because of interest rates getting jacked up and being and
- 1:14:27held there and the body showing up over the coming months.
- 1:14:31And all of those things converge at the same time, such that
- 1:14:34there's tailwinds that we've never had with Bitcoin before
- 1:14:38going into a having. So I think there's a case for,
- 1:14:42and I've written about this, that next cycle could be bigger.
- 1:14:46It may not be, but I think there's a better case for this
- 1:14:49next cycle being bigger than for any previous cycle.
- 1:14:52So are you saying that on the other side of the next having
- 1:14:57the debate over stock to flow is that it was too bearish?
- 1:15:03Yeah, I in terms of stock to flow, who knows?
- 1:15:09I think that that's that's the reality with stock to flow, who
- 1:15:11knows. I guess that's my cue to get
- 1:15:15into that stuff. So all right, let's talk about
- 1:15:18stock to flow because we. Call.
- 1:15:22Natural, yeah. Made a bit of a flash by
- 1:15:25standing up for the the idea. So just to describe my thoughts
- 1:15:32on this and I'll try to pack it in to start stock to flow.
- 1:15:37So the stock to flow model is specifically wrong and
- 1:15:41directionally correct. And what does that mean?
- 1:15:46Well, okay, well, we're actually talking about we have to
- 1:15:49disentangle it a bit stock to flow.
- 1:15:51The stock to flow model is has become three things.
- 1:15:55It's that we think of us together.
- 1:15:58It's the man, it's Plan B, the person who created it.
- 1:16:01It's the stock to flow model, uppercase letters.
- 1:16:05The specific price model with with specific price targets and
- 1:16:09then there's the idea, the idea of stock to flow, lower case
- 1:16:14stock to flow that a commodity that has a higher stock to flow
- 1:16:21ratio meaning lower annual issuance relative to the
- 1:16:24existing stock and ends up becoming more valuable because
- 1:16:31it's a better store value. Those are three different
- 1:16:34things. And we jumble them all together
- 1:16:37and we throw out the baby with the bathwater.
- 1:16:39I think because people take issue with the man Plan B's
- 1:16:44behavior over the last few years, how he's handled critics
- 1:16:48hasn't. The optics haven't been great
- 1:16:51and so people are salty about that.
- 1:16:54The the model has flaws and it's a it's an attempt to.
- 1:17:01Take a data set and and explain what's what.
- 1:17:04A trend that appears to be happening.
- 1:17:07That's what a model is. And that and and that has pissed
- 1:17:15pissed people off. And especially pissed off
- 1:17:17statisticians, mathematicians who take issue with the
- 1:17:22specifics about the model that aren't statistically valid from
- 1:17:26their point of view. And and I actually totally will
- 1:17:28concede that, you know, like we, I think we.
- 1:17:32Have to be prepared to toss out the model, the specific price
- 1:17:35model. I do think that there's some
- 1:17:39valid one of the major complaints about it is that you
- 1:17:44can't have a time based correlation.
- 1:17:47You can't just track with time. Value appreciation can't be
- 1:17:52linked to time because how is that statistically valid?
- 1:17:56But Bitcoin is time. The havings are time.
- 1:18:01The increasing scarcity that comes from the havings, that's
- 1:18:05time based. And so I think there's some
- 1:18:08issues there in terms of statisticians not really seeing
- 1:18:11how stock to flow as a concept kind of sits outside of the
- 1:18:16normal correlations that they're looking at between 2 variables.
- 1:18:21But okay, fine, we'll toss out the model.
- 1:18:25You know we should. There shouldn't have been
- 1:18:26specific numbers about it. Because those numbers got got
- 1:18:30turned into promises and those promises were broken and people
- 1:18:35are angry about it. There should never have been
- 1:18:37specific numbers in in my book. So fine, the the the man has
- 1:18:43made his missteps. The the model has its flaws and
- 1:18:48we should discount it as a as a valid model.
- 1:18:52Yep, But what about the idea? So the idea of stock to flow is
- 1:18:57just this observation that when you line up, when you on a on a
- 1:19:03plot graph the amount different commodities with their stock to
- 1:19:08flow against their total valuation of the existing
- 1:19:11supply. There is an upward and to the
- 1:19:14right trend and it's there's some noise in there sure, but
- 1:19:19there's a trend of of the the less stock less annual issuance
- 1:19:24there is. The more value is stored in that
- 1:19:27asset. So gold has a high stock to flow
- 1:19:30and this is what Safidine includes in the Bitcoin standard
- 1:19:33kind of the whole first third of the book is about how gold won
- 1:19:37as a commodity money because it had the highest stock to flow
- 1:19:41compared to any of the other options.
- 1:19:43So it became the best, most reliable store value.
- 1:19:45That's why it won. That's stock to flow as a
- 1:19:48concept, as an idea and so. That's what I'm trying to
- 1:19:54advocate for in my writing about this.
- 1:19:56My article about why the stock to flow model is specifically
- 1:20:00wrong but directionally correct. And I think that it's time to
- 1:20:05swing the pendulum back a little bit to appreciate the the
- 1:20:09potential merits and discuss the potential merits of the concept
- 1:20:15as an idea. And we can toss out the model in
- 1:20:19its specificity entirely. I'm fine with that.
- 1:20:24And I think it's time to bring that discussion back into what's
- 1:20:28allowed in Bitcoin. Because this is a taboo topic
- 1:20:32that you're not supposed to talk about for some reason.
- 1:20:34Because the the people who who you know browbeat everyone on
- 1:20:40how this isn't statistically valid seem to be proven right in
- 1:20:43the bear market. And now that the prices kind of
- 1:20:47rebound a little bit, we're sort of going sideways towards the
- 1:20:49next having the same mechanics could play out again.
- 1:20:53This idea, as a the conceptual level seems to be tracking
- 1:20:57decently, so let's talk about it.
- 1:21:00Yeah, I mean I'll go left side of the bell curve here.
- 1:21:06The there's only 21 million Bitcoin.
- 1:21:10Everybody's going to need it. Number will go up stock to flow
- 1:21:13like. Correctly.
- 1:21:18I see like regression theory and all this crazy shit people are
- 1:21:20saying. It's like.
- 1:21:21There's a certain amount of stock and the flow gets cut in
- 1:21:24half every four years. If you have all the monetary
- 1:21:27properties that you can't change that, but you would think it
- 1:21:29would go up. It's like the thesis when
- 1:21:32initially all the Plan B stuff happened.
- 1:21:35I never understood why everybody was so angry at them.
- 1:21:37I understand like getting mad at like Mashinsky or like certain
- 1:21:40people that are like naturally defrauding people.
- 1:21:43But it's fucking model. Like if he made a price quote,
- 1:21:45it's the same as like Michael Saylor taking leverage.
- 1:21:47Is that the prudent thing to do? Who fucking knows?
- 1:21:50But like you get to decide to do it.
- 1:21:52You get to decide if you're going to allocate this on a
- 1:21:54model, not a veteran. It's really insane.
- 1:21:59I know Dylan, you might have to run in a bit.
- 1:22:01So do you want to share some some thoughts on this before you
- 1:22:03do? Yeah, no, I mean, I'm gonna be
- 1:22:06honest, like I I was in high school, stumbled upon Bitcoin,
- 1:22:09my cousin was in the ICO. Boom.
- 1:22:12I didn't participate at all. I mean, I didn't have any money.
- 1:22:14But you know, I'm, I'm looking at finance and kind of trying to
- 1:22:19learn, learn my way around things.
- 1:22:21I know crypto and don't immediately dismiss it because I
- 1:22:24don't know any better. Kind of stumble upon Bitcoin on
- 1:22:27on Twitter, like find the right side of of crypto Twitter, like
- 1:22:30the bitcoiners. And then, you know, my 18th
- 1:22:33birthday comes and boom, like within, I don't know, a couple
- 1:22:38weeks before or after Plan B launches that model.
- 1:22:41And I'm a math guy. Like, I, you know, I'd never, I,
- 1:22:44like, didn't really understand much about Bitcoin at that
- 1:22:46point. But like, made sense to me.
- 1:22:49Like from like, from a math perspective, you know, I was
- 1:22:50like in calculus class ignoring my, you know, my, the work I'm
- 1:22:54supposed to be doing, looking at this thing being like.
- 1:22:56Wait, what causes that? And I just, you know, forced me
- 1:22:58to like go down a rabbit hole of having difficulty adjustment
- 1:23:01understand like the protocol at a deeper level.
- 1:23:03So, like, no, I mean it's just a model.
- 1:23:05People are like, no, it's gospel or like, you know, think it's
- 1:23:07like, you know, heresy. Like, I don't think it's either.
- 1:23:11I just think it's it was a, it was a cool thing to like
- 1:23:14conceptualize bitcoins, scarcity, bitcoins, you know,
- 1:23:18supply issuance, it's monetary policy.
- 1:23:21It. I mean it will fail eventually.
- 1:23:23I mean, if it hasn't already technically failed now but like.
- 1:23:26I mean, it's a great thing to understand.
- 1:23:27Like people oftentimes will just like look at search Bitcoin or
- 1:23:32look at like Robin Hood and it's like a chart and it's just like
- 1:23:36bubble crash and they're like, you know, whatever that thing
- 1:23:38is. But like if you understand math
- 1:23:41like at the not a basic level but a little bit more than the
- 1:23:44most basic level and you look at a log scale Bitcoin chart and
- 1:23:48then when it halves, you're like.
- 1:23:50Well, you know, this is maybe there's something here.
- 1:23:54Yeah. So again like, I don't.
- 1:23:56I think the debate is blown out of proportion.
- 1:23:58People are calling Plan B like names and going back and forth.
- 1:24:02It's, you know, I don't really even care to get into that.
- 1:24:04But I think it's cool. It helped Orange kill me, right
- 1:24:07or wrong. So, you know, I'm a I think it's
- 1:24:10cool. I'm thankful for that.
- 1:24:11You know, him publishing it. Yeah, it's greatly spurred my
- 1:24:15thinking, I think. A lot of my work over the last
- 1:24:17three years has been around trying to trying to like
- 1:24:21pressure test the stock to flow concept that just the idea and
- 1:24:25you know I I write about increasing scarcity and I think
- 1:24:28that is the engine for Bitcoin's growth.
- 1:24:31Dylan you mentioned this earlier that like the Havings, the
- 1:24:34Havings are a supply side event but they also spur demand,
- 1:24:40increase demand and and that's very interesting because.
- 1:24:43From Bitcoin's point of view, like to anthropomorphize
- 1:24:46Bitcoin, how does it induce adoption?
- 1:24:50It it can't control demand, but it can control its own supply
- 1:24:55schedule. So it has this function of okay.
- 1:24:58Well, I'm going to you know you've got your your supply line
- 1:25:02and your demand line and they meet right at the Marshall Cross
- 1:25:07and prices set where they where they meet but.
- 1:25:12You can move the supply line and that's the having.
- 1:25:16The having is this this prime mover to to jokingly refer to
- 1:25:22the religious connotation. The prime mover of of adoption,
- 1:25:27because it creates the supply shock changes the that Marshall
- 1:25:31cross that one line gets bumped in a direction that causes the
- 1:25:35price to to have to rise and that whole.
- 1:25:41Cycle creates you know a speculative bubble that in that
- 1:25:45brings in an incremental slice of the adoption curve.
- 1:25:48Some of them get washed out because they speculate and don't
- 1:25:50understand. Some do their homework and
- 1:25:51become sat stackers. That's what we've lived through
- 1:25:54for 14 years. So increasing scarcity to me is
- 1:25:58the beauty of Bitcoin. It's the adoption engine for
- 1:26:01Bitcoin and that's a fundamentally a stock to flow
- 1:26:05related concept. So I think it it greatly spurred
- 1:26:09my thinking. And you know like if you're
- 1:26:12excited for the having, like who's?
- 1:26:15Who's excited for the having? I'm excited for the having.
- 1:26:17Why are we excited for the having?
- 1:26:19Because there's reduced issuance at that point in time.
- 1:26:21There's increasing scarcity. The stock to flow number is
- 1:26:26going to go up at that point in time.
- 1:26:28That's why we're all excited for the having.
- 1:26:31And so if you're excited for the having, you are in a way a
- 1:26:35believer of the stock to flow idea, not the model, just the
- 1:26:39idea. As.
- 1:26:41A, as a Bitcoin miner, I want to say I'm particularly excited for
- 1:26:44the having, but I I think I'm well positioned to to survive
- 1:26:49the initial. And I do think completely agree
- 1:26:52because I think I do understand what you're trying to say,
- 1:26:55Jesse. But I do think we have to be
- 1:26:56very particular with language like there is not a supply
- 1:26:59shock, there's a supply inflation shock, right, Like
- 1:27:03there will, yes. Like you're not reducing the
- 1:27:05amount of Bitcoin and reducing the amount of issuance and
- 1:27:07that's where I think. Actually, when I think the
- 1:27:11critics of stock to flow and particularly Plan B's model,
- 1:27:16they really, they really lean into like you can't predict
- 1:27:19demand. It's like, yeah, obviously you
- 1:27:20can't predict demand. It's going to be volatile in the
- 1:27:23short to medium term. But over the long run, you'd be
- 1:27:25pretty certain due to the properties that Bitcoin has as
- 1:27:28an asset and then the properties it has as a network like there's
- 1:27:34going to be increasing demand because that's fundamental
- 1:27:36utility. As a store of value asset and
- 1:27:39then as a distributed network that can act as native payments
- 1:27:43layer of the Internet. And so unless you're living
- 1:27:46under a rock and not able to think multi decades into the
- 1:27:49future like the the critics say you can't predict demand are.
- 1:27:54I would I would put forth either stupid or disingenuous where
- 1:27:59it's like yeah obviously you can't predict demand like in a
- 1:28:02particular month day week year even but.
- 1:28:05And if you understand what's going on here, you can
- 1:28:08essentially predict out that, yes, there's gonna be
- 1:28:10significant demand for Bitcoin because of the utility it
- 1:28:13provides in many different ways. You just get the nail on the
- 1:28:16head. I was trying to rational or to
- 1:28:17understand where the the like animosity comes from something
- 1:28:21like this and it's not actually an intellectual thing, it's an
- 1:28:23emotional thing that anybody that actually thought initially
- 1:28:27that stock to flow was the price.
- 1:28:29They show it through the emotions that they're pissed off
- 1:28:32that somebody's looking at it. Because anybody that I know like
- 1:28:34you look at, we talk about safe. And there's other people within
- 1:28:36our friend group that like saw. It's like, oh, that's
- 1:28:39interesting. But they never subscribed or
- 1:28:41like thought, oh, the price is going to hit this number.
- 1:28:43It's like that's something. But you could see how somebody
- 1:28:46would be very annoyed or angry if they initially looked at that
- 1:28:48and even made a like personal economic calculation or tied to
- 1:28:52it. So it's just like, I thought
- 1:28:54that came to my mind when you you reference like, where
- 1:28:57somebody would be upset. But Dylan hit on a key point and
- 1:29:00this is where, like I most appreciative Jesse, like what
- 1:29:02you put out and just some of the content you do.
- 1:29:05It's like part of the show. The realization is we've been in
- 1:29:08this bubble and I was thinking about this the other day like
- 1:29:10we've been looking at Bitcoin 5. But I don't know, you know,
- 1:29:13Marty, eight years, like you just look at this stuff and your
- 1:29:17whole kind of like mine starts to shift on how you look at the
- 1:29:20asset, other assets. You know, we we shit on 4/01, KS
- 1:29:23and bonds and everything else on the show.
- 1:29:26It's just like, so we we forget what traditional finance and
- 1:29:31individuals, how they're approaching the space, the
- 1:29:33frameworks they're using to look at it until like as Dylan
- 1:29:36described, it's just like a framework to look at it and
- 1:29:38there's a certain amount of stock to surround a supply.
- 1:29:40It changes, price may go up. Interesting once you pay more
- 1:29:43attention. That's as simple as it is.
- 1:29:46And like we look at like over time, the new vintages of
- 1:29:49bitcoiners, whether it comes in this year, next year in in
- 1:29:52subsequent years, the content needs to get resurfaced.
- 1:29:56The good content, the right content, the right framework,
- 1:29:58because it's important. Like if it's by definition good,
- 1:30:01then it's Evergreen in this ecosystem and it's gonna be
- 1:30:05important to like bring and I think that's what Jesse was
- 1:30:08attempting to do. And it's actually like in my
- 1:30:10mind, you can share if you want, Jesse, it's like you almost
- 1:30:11like. Everybody like fell into the
- 1:30:13trap. Like you put it out there.
- 1:30:15It's on purpose, like you don't believe in the exact number
- 1:30:17targets, but it's like, hey, we should talk about this.
- 1:30:19And instead of realizing it's like everyone up in arms and
- 1:30:22it's like you fell in the trap and I was sitting here and
- 1:30:24everybody's talking about exactly what he wrote about, so.
- 1:30:31Hey guys, I gotta, I gotta run here.
- 1:30:33But it was a hell of a rip. Excited to see this one
- 1:30:35published. Don't really have anything else
- 1:30:39on my end, but it was fun and let's do it again.
- 1:30:42Yeah, Dylan's always awesome having you on.
- 1:30:45We'll do it again, yeah? Just gotta keep crossing that
- 1:30:47dude. Thanks.
- 1:30:52Jesse, did you said the trap intentionally.
- 1:30:57Not really. I knew that it would trigger
- 1:31:00some people. I knew that it would trigger all
- 1:31:03the stock to flow haters. That's a trap.
- 1:31:06I actually, I actually think that at some point in time.
- 1:31:11This becomes a non taboo topic again and and I think a part of
- 1:31:18that process is disentangling the whatever perceived sins Plan
- 1:31:24B committed from the idea of stock to flow as it is laid out
- 1:31:29in Safe Dean's book. And you know, I I think that how
- 1:31:36this could play out is the having.
- 1:31:40The havings keep happening and price keeps drifting up in the
- 1:31:4412 to 18 months following the havings and establishes a new
- 1:31:47price equilibrium in that four year era.
- 1:31:52And and it happens again and it happens again.
- 1:31:56And at some point that pattern is pretty hard to deny right?
- 1:31:59Like the having seems to move something whether it's whether
- 1:32:04it's purely psychological because the, you know, impact of
- 1:32:06the reducing. Block reward size change, you
- 1:32:13know, that gets smaller but it still triggers some
- 1:32:18psychological behavior in the populace.
- 1:32:22The fine, maybe that's part of it, but I think that, you know,
- 1:32:28I think the mechanics of the having increasing scarcity will
- 1:32:31continue to cause some bull markets post having and then and
- 1:32:36then seeking an equilibrium. For the rest of that having era
- 1:32:40and that is the stock to flow idea.
- 1:32:43So at some point that has to reenter what's what we're
- 1:32:48allowed to talk about by whoever is policing the narrative and I
- 1:32:55decided to you know since stock to flow has been so important in
- 1:32:59my. Education and journey in terms
- 1:33:02of building my conviction and stimulating my thought about
- 1:33:06like what? How do these mechanics work?
- 1:33:09I have a whole thread on what happens with the supply, how the
- 1:33:14supply shock manifests for new supply issuance and how that
- 1:33:18eats through available for sale supply in the 12 months
- 1:33:22following and having and how that those mechanics drive a
- 1:33:28bull market. That came from, you know, me
- 1:33:31trying to understand these this stock to flow mechanics at the
- 1:33:39having and how that plays out. So it was important.
- 1:33:43It's been important for me. I think it's a key part of
- 1:33:46deeply understanding why this thing is the best savings
- 1:33:49technology ever because it has this unique property of an
- 1:33:52increasing scarcity that no other asset out there can match.
- 1:33:56And so we have to appreciate increasing scarcity.
- 1:33:59And and the fact that that delivers value appreciation over
- 1:34:02time. And that means talking about
- 1:34:06stock to flow as an idea, not as a model, Not trying to put the
- 1:34:11man or the model on a pedestal, but bring that idea back into
- 1:34:15the conversation. Yeah, again, I'm going to grab
- 1:34:18my my caveman club and just say number of Bitcoin produced per
- 1:34:23block go down, demand go up, number go up.
- 1:34:27It's pretty goddamn simple. People convention over this
- 1:34:31there are doing. Yeah.
- 1:34:35And and actually that's sort of one of the arguments against
- 1:34:38doctor flows is like don't think about it, just just think about
- 1:34:4221 million and and think about the absolute scarcity at the end
- 1:34:46of this increasing scarcity sequence, which is the easiest
- 1:34:51thing to think about it and a totally valid thing to do, but.
- 1:34:57You know, the reason I think this is the fastest horse is
- 1:34:59because it has this increasing scarcity on the way to that
- 1:35:02terminal absolute scarcity, and that's exciting.
- 1:35:06So let's talk about it. Yeah, Yeah.
- 1:35:11And again, it's just all semantics like you you can never
- 1:35:17predict demand in the short to medium term.
- 1:35:19But again, going back to what I said earlier, like if you
- 1:35:23understand what's going on here. On the asset side and on the
- 1:35:26network side, it's pretty obvious that nothing can do what
- 1:35:31Bitcoin can do in both regards and that is going to drive
- 1:35:35demand over the long run. It's actually it's funny, like
- 1:35:39we talk about the difficulty adjustment being like a
- 1:35:42beautiful feature, right? Or like absolutely necessary,
- 1:35:45but like the thing we don't, we it's in the narrative but we
- 1:35:48don't fully like. Brass and I don't know when we
- 1:35:50will, if we ever it's like the supply shock of every four years
- 1:35:53and why it was programmatically set up and in the 50% reduction
- 1:35:57like in the the the flow of like awareness and the dollar, you
- 1:36:00know appreciation and how it goes back like I think that
- 1:36:03obviously has a like if it didn't exist what what is that
- 1:36:07like demand and awareness look like and does it do we end up as
- 1:36:10success? I don't know but I know we like
- 1:36:12it's been discussed but I don't think there's enough.
- 1:36:15Understanding and I don't know if if you guys like have
- 1:36:18thoughts or if it's even like you know point anybody including
- 1:36:21myself in a direction of like that being discussed of the
- 1:36:23supply shock every four years of 50% and how that just you know
- 1:36:27sends it out into the awareness via price function comes back
- 1:36:31and it does it every four years is how that was necessary versus
- 1:36:34anything, any alternative. Yeah, I I think it's the
- 1:36:39marketing department for Bitcoin is that otherwise if it was a a
- 1:36:43smooth scale, you know smooth issuance schedule, then there's
- 1:36:48no moment in time to talk about it, to think about it to to have
- 1:36:51something jarring happen. So I think that it, I think
- 1:36:55there was, it may be unintentional but genius
- 1:36:59inclusion in the issuance schedule.
- 1:37:02I don't know if it I mean it's it had to be intentional in my
- 1:37:06mind. Yeah, of course.
- 1:37:08And I think she actually touched on it like it was like you start
- 1:37:12a 50 Bitcoin, you cut it in half at 210,000 blocks because you
- 1:37:16need a way to distribute the supply and a lot of it in the
- 1:37:20bootstrapping phase to incentivize people to plug in
- 1:37:23their minors. Right.
- 1:37:25Earlier adopters too, like that's how you that's the
- 1:37:29promise for the very earliest cohort of like get your supply
- 1:37:32now because it gets way more scarce in in four years like.
- 1:37:37That that's the marketing department for Bitcoin and.
- 1:37:41It was his way to dispel or their way to dispel efficient
- 1:37:45market hypothesis. It's like you remember in that.
- 1:37:49Having it's already priced in, it's already.
- 1:37:50Priced people In 2023, it's the same thing.
- 1:37:54It's like 23 priced in. That's part of the hate for, you
- 1:37:59know, it's weird because there's this coalition of of people with
- 1:38:03various reasons for hating the stock to flow model.
- 1:38:07The bulk of them are people who put too much, too much stock in
- 1:38:13that model and bet on it, right? Like they hundred X long, you
- 1:38:17know, because we're going to 100K.
- 1:38:19So they got burned and they're pissed.
- 1:38:22That's a huge portion. Then there's the like
- 1:38:25statisticians who find issue with the specific model okay,
- 1:38:29yeah. They're of a small and very
- 1:38:33vocal group and they've got great receipts, you know,
- 1:38:35because it's hard to argue with that and I don't argue with it.
- 1:38:39Like ultimately the the flaw, the flaws in the model are are
- 1:38:42real. There's the time based thing
- 1:38:44that that I take some issue with and and then there's the EMH
- 1:38:51people, people who are coming from traditional markets who
- 1:38:54think it's not possible for the having to matter because it is
- 1:38:58known information in advance. So therefore it must be priced
- 1:39:01in. That's the efficient market
- 1:39:03hypothesis in Bitcoin's entire 14 year history.
- 1:39:06Flies in the face of the efficient market hypothesis
- 1:39:10because why has it appreciated over time?
- 1:39:12Why didn't it it instantly go to $30,000 per coin?
- 1:39:16Because you saw the issue in schedule ahead, so why didn't
- 1:39:19you price it in? That's that's not how it has
- 1:39:21played out. I mean, it hasn't played out
- 1:39:23like that in any market. But they still teach you the
- 1:39:28market. Like correctly in 2007 that was
- 1:39:32the case. At Stanford Business School they
- 1:39:34teach you the weak form efficient market hypothesis.
- 1:39:38And at the time I was like this doesn't seem right, like how do
- 1:39:41you get an edge in a market, but that's what they teach you.
- 1:39:46This is the insanity of the Fiat world we're coming up on almost
- 1:39:50two hours here. But I do think if you guys are
- 1:39:53open to it, touching on the other controversy that you were
- 1:39:55thrust into yesterday, because I do think it's good.
- 1:39:59Teaching opportunity to really help listeners that are coming
- 1:40:06in and learning about Bitcoin and have the question of why
- 1:40:10Bitcoin not crypto to really show the perverse incentives
- 1:40:14that exist in the crypto market. So Jesse, well, I'll, I'll find
- 1:40:21the tweet, you can explain it, then we'll watch the video.
- 1:40:25I I came across a video of. Meltham or however you say her
- 1:40:31name to her credit, to her credit, she I think was
- 1:40:37explaining why there needs to be regulatory intervention in the
- 1:40:42crypto VC space as it exists. However, she is kind of roughly
- 1:40:50in that world. She's an Angel investor in
- 1:40:52crypto things. She may not directly work for a
- 1:40:54fund, but that's part of her world.
- 1:40:57And she's explaining the game. She does a great job of
- 1:41:02articulating the game that crypto VCs are playing at the
- 1:41:06expense of retail investors. We got the video playing.
- 1:41:19We're. Here, nothing on our end.
- 1:41:30What is an exit event? A lot of the venture capital
- 1:41:33that has come into crypto more broadly as an asset class has
- 1:41:36come because there is liquidity in investing in tokens and we
- 1:41:40can ignore it. We can pretend it doesn't exist.
- 1:41:43But incentives, Dr. behavior, and I think one of the big
- 1:41:46incentives we've seen, we've seen play out in the crypto
- 1:41:49venture space, 35 billion. In LP Capital last year went
- 1:41:53into funds. Why did that capital go into a
- 1:41:55lot of these funds? Because they're able to deliver
- 1:41:59cash back to their Lps by investing in new L ones, L twos.
- 1:42:04Perhaps things that have a token that enable this faster turn on
- 1:42:07getting an exit event to liquidity event, that's where
- 1:42:10the challenge really is for the Bitcoin space.
- 1:42:12So that's why I'm excited that we have ordinals with BRC 20s
- 1:42:17because they actually start to maybe enable us to generate new
- 1:42:20streams of revenue. What is that?
- 1:42:25Yeah, Marty, how does that make me feel?
- 1:42:32I want to be a preface this with like, yeah, I think you
- 1:42:35described it well. Nelson was just describing the
- 1:42:37game. But I do think there are some
- 1:42:40misguided notions that B, RC20 tokens and ordinals coming to
- 1:42:44Bitcoin will be additive to Bitcoin because there's going to
- 1:42:49be these quick liquidity events that are possible in the Bitcoin
- 1:42:52ecosystem. Like I don't think anything in
- 1:42:56the Ethereum ecosystem, Solana. The E RC20 world or the NFT
- 1:43:01world has really proven to have any long staying value.
- 1:43:04It's all, in my opinion a product of late stage Fiat,
- 1:43:09people speculating to make a quick buck.
- 1:43:12And the nefarious thing here is that it's institutional capital.
- 1:43:16Knowing that they're dumping on retail making insane gains, good
- 1:43:22for them. Returning capital to LB's as a
- 1:43:24venture capitalist myself, like that is the goal and they are
- 1:43:27succeeding in that goal. But yeah, this gets into like
- 1:43:30the Gray area of ethics and morality and whether or not this
- 1:43:35is something that should be normalized and we should be
- 1:43:38championing on Bitcoin. And I'll make it clear, like I
- 1:43:41don't think, in my opinion, I don't think ordinals and B RC20
- 1:43:45tokens really have long staying power.
- 1:43:48I think they will pump. I think there will be a lot of
- 1:43:51fervor around them this next cycle.
- 1:43:53But at the end of the day, I think Bitcoin as a monetary
- 1:43:57asset and a payments. Like layered protocol is going
- 1:44:01to be the killer app and we don't need any of that stuff and
- 1:44:06it's really catered towards very niche markets that it is very
- 1:44:12clout Chasy to me all that. Stuff.
- 1:44:16This is what you're describing is what Dylan was describing
- 1:44:18earlier about getting out on the risk curve.
- 1:44:21I I I'm glad you brought this up.
- 1:44:23Not to the sense to say anything bad about anybody, but more to
- 1:44:25drive awareness that. Over these cycles we see
- 1:44:29consistent narratives change and we see like all coins continue.
- 1:44:33We saw the ICO buzz, St. O's defy and when the price kind
- 1:44:38of like we talk of these havings, when the price goes out
- 1:44:40then like all the activity dries up because it's all speculative
- 1:44:43and you pump the bags, you get this additional capital in.
- 1:44:46You don't retail, it's rent and repeat.
- 1:44:49But you have to change the narrative over time to continue
- 1:44:52to let go because over time people catch on.
- 1:44:54And so you see you know part of this is like going and.
- 1:44:57And it's basically affinity scamming.
- 1:44:59We've seen it for the past thirteen years in Bitcoin, where
- 1:45:01it's the BRC 20 and all these other, you know, acronyms.
- 1:45:04And I think it's just important to discuss here to people as
- 1:45:07they go. And it's like, OK, I understand
- 1:45:08the Bitcoin signal, but now there's interesting things
- 1:45:10happening on Bitcoin and I can get a higher, you know,
- 1:45:13appreciation of return on my personal portfolio or whatever
- 1:45:15if I buy this token versus just the underlying.
- 1:45:18But the reality is you just need a native unit.
- 1:45:20They're all competing with money.
- 1:45:21Bitcoin is the best form of money and that's why you just
- 1:45:23want to hold the underline and not engage in any of this like
- 1:45:26crazy stuff. So if we can help anybody in
- 1:45:28doing that, whether it's via the show or reaching out directly,
- 1:45:31that's what our goal is. Not only to get you a whole
- 1:45:34Bitcoin, but not to buy all this other crazy shit.
- 1:45:37Yeah, and to make the other crazy shit a little more
- 1:45:39explicit, Melton on Pomps podcast describes the.
- 1:45:46Shit, coin waterfall. The mechanics of it of you've
- 1:45:49got your when a when a coin is launching you start with your
- 1:45:54pre presale and it's ultra insiders.
- 1:45:57It's all the big money in crypto who have had success backing
- 1:46:01projects and you get them in a room and you say we're going to
- 1:46:04give you portion of the supply at this price and they're like
- 1:46:10okay, we're in and then. They hype it up to the next
- 1:46:15layer of the onion, the the not quite as inside insiders.
- 1:46:21So then you do your presale and you charge them 10X the price.
- 1:46:27So suddenly the the, the ultra insiders have already made a 10X
- 1:46:31profit on you know, unrealized but great, everybody's happy.
- 1:46:36Then you go to the next layer and you do your sale.
- 1:46:41And charge 10X the price there. So the ultra insiders are made
- 1:46:44100X, then 10X, then, then you get these new people coming in
- 1:46:49and then you go to retail and set the price high.
- 1:46:53Everybody who's participated so far as an insider hypes it up,
- 1:46:57talks about how it's the next big thing.
- 1:46:58It's going to change the world. Everyone's going to, you're
- 1:47:01going to kill yourself if you miss out.
- 1:47:04And that's them exiting, that's them selling their cut.
- 1:47:09To retail when it finally hits the market after all this hype
- 1:47:11has built up. And that's a 12 to 18 month
- 1:47:14process. Rinse and repeat.
- 1:47:16Retail gets fleeced. I'm just going to name names
- 1:47:21like Novo during Terra Luna like he has a Terra Luna tattoo which
- 1:47:28he marketed and showed off on Twitter like a couple weeks
- 1:47:31before Terra Luna officially blew up around all time highs.
- 1:47:34It quickly went to zero after reaching all time highs and.
- 1:47:38Apparently weren't on the street is he only gets a tattoo when he
- 1:47:42books a billion dollars on the trade.
- 1:47:43So he's already like booked that trade, pumped it to the markets
- 1:47:49and. Yeah.
- 1:47:51And it's, I appreciate like Marty when you get a little, you
- 1:47:55get a little Marty Jones on like these people or like the
- 1:47:57situation because when you really boil boils down like what
- 1:48:00Jesse just described as we talked about early, like the guy
- 1:48:03that was a bagger, that's like I can't mess with this stuff
- 1:48:05because it's kind of crazy. It's like, imagine if the lens
- 1:48:08was, oh, this is how I can increase like my purchasing
- 1:48:11power or like my life. My life will be better off if I
- 1:48:14just have this. But he, he doesn't understand
- 1:48:16that because of everything that Jesse just described and we're
- 1:48:18talking about and what, you know, all coins and just like
- 1:48:22this kind of like risk curve, we basically turn into the Robin
- 1:48:25Hood of vacation of like, maybe I buy, maybe it ends up 0.
- 1:48:30So there's just so much like noise out there.
- 1:48:32And so it does have to be like called out and there has to be
- 1:48:36like. I don't know.
- 1:48:37There has to be a recognition and continue to like explain it
- 1:48:40because it really like hurts a lot of people damages whether
- 1:48:43you know, think about how many people are holding zeros because
- 1:48:46of FTX block by cell system list goes on and on and will continue
- 1:48:49to go on and on because it's just a information asymmetry and
- 1:48:52this stuff is new and so there's people out there to continue to
- 1:48:55sell basically snake oil. Yeah, and I'm I've reached a
- 1:49:01point in my 10 years. Of being in this market and
- 1:49:05seeing many of these cycles where, and I mean I have
- 1:49:09actually been very ardent and calling the stuff out, calling
- 1:49:12them shit coins, saying that none of this will amount to
- 1:49:16anything. But for like the 1st 8 to 9
- 1:49:19years there was always that that small little doubt in the back
- 1:49:23of my mind. Like maybe these shit corners
- 1:49:24are right, maybe there is something here, but in the last
- 1:49:26two years it's become abundantly clear.
- 1:49:29But no, there will be nothing there you don't need.
- 1:49:33And their tokenomic schemes, You don't need their block chains,
- 1:49:35you don't need their functionalities to achieve the
- 1:49:39goals that Bitcoin has set out to achieve.
- 1:49:43And you can even make the argument that even if a another
- 1:49:46token or project markets that it's not really trying to
- 1:49:49achieve the goals of Bitcoin, it's doing something completely
- 1:49:53different. If you do enough research and
- 1:49:54dig into the fundamentals of the problem they're trying to solve,
- 1:49:58they don't need a blockchain or a token at all.
- 1:50:01They're just trying to. Affinity scam, like Michael
- 1:50:04said, to use the new buzzwords and the new technology to
- 1:50:08bamboozle people into believing that it is the solution to the
- 1:50:12problem they're proclaiming to solve.
- 1:50:16And yeah, I've I've reached a point where I do think a lot of
- 1:50:19the people pushing these scams, particularly those that have
- 1:50:23been through many cycles, are reprehensible humans that should
- 1:50:30know better yet. For some reason or another
- 1:50:35refuse to stop scamming people and they do need to get called
- 1:50:40out. And as a free market capitalist
- 1:50:42who really doesn't want the SEC or the federal government to
- 1:50:45come in and over regulate and throw the baby out with the
- 1:50:49bathwater with Bitcoin and lumping it in to all crypto like
- 1:50:53that is how you regulate as social signaling and self
- 1:50:58policing and within this industry that's something.
- 1:51:01That Bitcoin has been much for is attacking the self police and
- 1:51:05just being called salty individuals who are mad that
- 1:51:09other coins are outperforming Bitcoin within certain time
- 1:51:14frames. But no, it's like for me
- 1:51:17personally, I don't think I'm wrong, Could be wrong.
- 1:51:20My gut is telling me 100% right like these people are scamming
- 1:51:25retail investors. They're getting insane profits
- 1:51:30returning it to Lps, get on you as a venture capitalist.
- 1:51:33But at the end of the day, these people have nothing to show for
- 1:51:36it except their returns and the ravages of the retail investors
- 1:51:41they burnt along the way. And it's something I will not
- 1:51:45support publicly, have never supported publicly, but will be
- 1:51:50more vocal in calling out moving forward.
- 1:51:55Yeah. I think very well said.
- 1:51:58I think at the end of the day this is like we're in the
- 1:52:00financial service business. We think about like what we're
- 1:52:02doing. You mentioned on the venture
- 1:52:04side or you know we're doing it on ramp and it's all built on
- 1:52:07trust and it's something that recognized very early on at
- 1:52:11Unchained. Folks would come in and I felt
- 1:52:13like kind of a little arrogant or less very bold to say it's
- 1:52:16like you found the signal here. If you just decide to say stay
- 1:52:18or not, it's up to you because during the bull market, right,
- 1:52:21people are coming in and they're doing all the sorts of sorts of
- 1:52:23stuff. They're running on block by
- 1:52:24either going to Celsius, it's like.
- 1:52:26We want to help on like the journey because we can help
- 1:52:30along like the years there of like how do we we looked at all
- 1:52:33this stuff and we can tell you like this is the plot hold it's
- 1:52:35almost like a one way hash functions like you hear it and
- 1:52:37you're like oh this actually makes sense in the direction of
- 1:52:39like oh I can I understand it where it was hard if you didn't
- 1:52:42know what you were looking at. And so even to the extent on our
- 1:52:45side like on the on ramp from an institutional family office
- 1:52:48individual if you're looking at this and you're like curious
- 1:52:51like I think there's something these guys are saying.
- 1:52:53But I would like to learn more like you can come book a
- 1:52:55consultation, jump on a call, walk you through it.
- 1:52:58Because over the three years while we did this and a chain
- 1:53:01like from personal anecdotes, there was people that were able
- 1:53:03to say 500 plus BTC off of Genesis Block 5, paying off the
- 1:53:08loans, you know, self custody versus leaving on Celsius like
- 1:53:10there's real, there's real like. Affect if like taking action
- 1:53:15whether it's via the pod, talking to other people, going
- 1:53:17on chain, going on ramp, other other trusted parties, we're not
- 1:53:20doing anything because reality is like all these people are
- 1:53:23using individuals that have less knowledge as exit liquidity and
- 1:53:27it doesn't have to be that and that's part of like this whole
- 1:53:29show is just like education and being able to share with other
- 1:53:32individuals. So those mistakes don't happen
- 1:53:33and overtime once it gets to a certain.
- 1:53:36Like they were afraid to do it because you're going to get
- 1:53:38called out ahead of time. It's like do I really right now
- 1:53:40it's still there. We're like the Intel minority
- 1:53:42because crypto. If you're Bitcoin only, you're
- 1:53:43still I think close minded in most people's view.
- 1:53:47And then the whitewash history and like everybody was Bitcoin
- 1:53:49only, it was so obvious the same way as everybody's gold only
- 1:53:53it's not copper or aluminum. So we're in this weird period
- 1:53:57and we're just going to continue to do the part.
- 1:53:59We're going to win Marty. We're.
- 1:54:05Winning, guys, we're winning. I'm.
- 1:54:07I've never been more bullish in my life.
- 1:54:11Like, it's all there. We just got to keep trucking.
- 1:54:14Keep going. Bitcoin is an idea whose time
- 1:54:17has come. Like even like piggybacking on
- 1:54:22that. People have been shitting on
- 1:54:23lightning for five years and I said this on a rabbit hole recap
- 1:54:27yesterday. But I think it's important to
- 1:54:29reiterate here is a lot. Of what you're seeing in terms
- 1:54:33of people going speculating in shit coins, people shooting on
- 1:54:36Bitcoin for it being relatively slow, low transactions per
- 1:54:41second and scaling in this layered fashion, which hasn't
- 1:54:44had immediate success, is driven by an impatience that has been
- 1:54:49normalized in the Fiat economy. We are building cathedrals here,
- 1:54:53as we said a couple weeks ago with Alex Leishman.
- 1:54:56Like it takes time to build out Bitcoin at the protocol layer.
- 1:55:00It takes time. To build out the Lightning
- 1:55:02Network from a liquidity and no topography perspective and then
- 1:55:06from a tooling perspective, like it literally takes time to build
- 1:55:10out these cathedrals to the point where they have utility in
- 1:55:14the wider economy and people who point at bitcoins volatility and
- 1:55:19say it can't be a store of value, it's like, do you really
- 1:55:21expect the best money? That humans have ever come into
- 1:55:27contact with? That is a foreign concept to
- 1:55:30most. Being a digital currency run on
- 1:55:33a distributed network is going to monetize overnight.
- 1:55:36Like your impatience is blinding you to the fact that this
- 1:55:39volatility should be expected. Similarly with lightning, like,
- 1:55:43oh it was launched in 2018, Why is it not embedded in everything
- 1:55:48in every online company today like #1?
- 1:55:52Space symmetry of information. People simply don't understand
- 1:55:55Bitcoin, let alone the Lightning Network and how it interacts
- 1:55:58with the protocol. Layer #2.
- 1:56:01It literally takes time to build out the tools to enable people
- 1:56:03to build on lightning, and that's what we're saying.
- 1:56:07And that's why I'm so bullish right now because I do think we
- 1:56:10have hit a tipping point in maturation, particularly for the
- 1:56:12Lightning Network, where the tooling is at a place where it's
- 1:56:15going to be a lot easier to implement the stuff into online
- 1:56:19services. Don't be impatient.
- 1:56:25People want, it's the Fiat mindset we want quick, bang,
- 1:56:28bang, bang. It's the the quarterly mindset.
- 1:56:32Lower your time preference. I know it's cliche, but like
- 1:56:36again, we're building cathedrals here.
- 1:56:38It is going to take time and there are scammers out there who
- 1:56:42are going to take advantage of your relative impatience and
- 1:56:45say, hey, you don't like that with Bitcoin.
- 1:56:47You don't have that with Bitcoin.
- 1:56:49Here's this token for you. It can do it, but at the end of
- 1:56:52the day it doesn't have the fundamental base layer
- 1:56:58necessities primitives to actually make it a potential
- 1:57:02long term success. Because for these things to be
- 1:57:04successful in the long term, they need to have sufficient
- 1:57:07distribution of full nosed sufficient distribution of hash
- 1:57:11power. They have to be proof of work
- 1:57:12chains, which people don't realize yet.
- 1:57:16They have to have distribution of private key ownership and
- 1:57:18then. Fractal that up to other layers
- 1:57:21as well. It takes time and people are
- 1:57:23trying to leverage your impatience to stack more Bitcoin
- 1:57:27themselves. We need more Uncle Marty's if
- 1:57:30they're. If they don't they don't take
- 1:57:32advantage of your relative you know patients they'll take care
- 1:57:35of. They'll take advantage of your
- 1:57:36relatives. So you need to send them you
- 1:57:39know for 4:11 send them to listen to the pod.
- 1:57:41Send them to us. We will.
- 1:57:42We will support and helping because it.
- 1:57:47There's a lot of bitcoins that get this stuff, but there's a
- 1:57:48lot of people on the external side that are going to get the
- 1:57:51next way to having comes the price appreciates and the next
- 1:57:54people are going to take advantage of them.
- 1:57:55And if you can, if we can get ahead of that, everybody's going
- 1:57:58to be better off. Yes, I want to apologize for
- 1:58:02looking like a complete slob today.
- 1:58:04I had a bunch of calls this morning.
- 1:58:05I'm not able to spruce up. I'm not able to shave.
- 1:58:08I'm sweating right now. I went from a rainy day to a
- 1:58:10beautiful sunny day here over the course of the last two
- 1:58:13hours, but it's a great rip. Yeah, it was great you brought
- 1:58:17you're fired up, so all we can ask for.
- 1:58:20How can you not be fired up? Baby, we're changing the world.
- 1:58:22Let's go. Yes.
- 1:58:26Weekend at the Shore. Need to go.
- 1:58:28We'll see you next. You're coming back to Texas
- 1:58:29next. Next week.
- 1:58:31I'll be in Texas next week. We'll be recording in person.
- 1:58:34Michael and I will, at least. Nice.
- 1:58:37Hopefully that'll be fun. Yeah.
- 1:58:40Just to be here soon enough. It's nice.
- 1:58:41It was at Cooper's yesterday. Parker having lunch?
- 1:58:44Look back. Your brother walks in.
- 1:58:45How's it going? I mean, Justin's going back in
- 1:58:48town. Bitcoin capital of the world.
- 1:58:51We've been the Austin dream, but they they're passing a housing
- 1:58:55ordinance to allow for smaller lots like San Francisco, based
- 1:58:59on San Francisco. That's I don't think we should
- 1:59:03be tracking what San Francisco is doing so.
- 1:59:05People are celebrating it and it's a little concerning.
- 1:59:09All right, something to be aware of.
- 1:59:10We'll see you guys next week. If you're liking the the show,
- 1:59:16please subscribe. If you're listening on the
- 1:59:18podcast app, subscribe there. If you're listening on Fountain
- 1:59:21Podcasting 2.0 and you're streaming us Bitcoin, leveraging
- 1:59:24the network side of Bitcoin to give us sats over the Lightning
- 1:59:28Network as you listen, thank you.
- 1:59:31If you're on YouTube, hit that subscribe button, hit the
- 1:59:33notifications and share this if you're an institutional
- 1:59:37investor. A high net worth individual or
- 1:59:40just somebody who's looking to educate others about Bitcoin?
- 1:59:45Please share the show with them. Like Michael said, we're really
- 1:59:49trying to help get ahead and prevent people from getting
- 1:59:54confused and bamboozled number #2 #1 to try to get you to
- 2:00:00realize why Bitcoin's important and why it's going to be
- 2:00:02extremely valuable in the future.
- 2:00:06Absolutely. We'll do this every week.
- 2:00:09Yes, with that, I'm gonna hit the beach, have a.
- 2:00:12Great weekend guys.