Latest / Brett Keane and Eve Show / Why People Dislike Neil deGrasse Tyson By Brett Keane

Transcript

Why People Dislike Neil deGrasse Tyson By Brett Keane · Brett Keane and Eve Show

• 0:08
  The more of you that I inspect, the more of you I see reflect.
• 0:16
  The more I tried with your lips, the more the mask you wear.
• 0:21
  It rents the greatest. Seek out your boys.
• 0:25
  My ears soak off with noise. You show and tell me the
• 0:31
  greatest sees. Well, hello ladies and
• 0:52
  gentlemen. My name is Brett Keen and you
• 0:54
  are watching listening to the Brett Keen Show.
• 0:56
  When you get an opportunity, check out my international radio
• 0:59
  station. Don't forget to rate, comment,
• 1:02
  subscribe, all that good stuff. And also, if you could, if you
• 1:05
  could be a gent or a gently share my videos around.
• 1:11
  Let people know what's up. Today we're going to talk about
• 1:15
  what an idiot Neil deGrasse Tyson is, and I know there's
• 1:19
  some people out there where they think he's just one of the most
• 1:21
  fantastic folks in the world, and some people even call him a
• 1:25
  scientist. What a lot of people don't know
• 1:28
  is he's never actually contributed anything to science.
• 1:31
  Neither has Bill Nye. Neither has a lot of these
• 1:35
  atheist spokesmen or these scripted people who get out on
• 1:39
  shows like The Cosmos and Talk. They really are not that
• 1:44
  intelligent. They just know how to read off a
• 1:46
  teleprompter, which even Joe Biden on his good days can
• 1:51
  manage to do that. So.
• 1:54
  That doesn't make you intelligent, it doesn't make you
• 1:56
  a fucking genius in any way. And I'm going to give you an
• 1:59
  example of Neil deGrasse Tyson looking like a complete and
• 2:02
  utter fucking dum dum for the whole world to see.
• 2:07
  And I don't know why it is more people aren't talking about
• 2:10
  this, but here's an example of Neil deGrasse Tyson jumping the
• 2:14
  shark, showing us that politics are more important to him than
• 2:18
  actual facts and reality and the truth.
• 2:21
  Which he claims to worship science.
• 2:24
  Here we go. One of your functions overtime
• 2:29
  has been to communicate scientific knowledge to the
• 2:33
  public. Yeah.
• 2:33
  And that's why I was quite surprised to hear you talk about
• 2:37
  the idea that we all exist on a spectrum where you wake up one
• 2:41
  day and you feel like you're more female and more male.
• 2:45
  The XXXY chromosomes are insufficient.
• 2:51
  Because when we wake up in the morning, we exaggerate whatever
• 2:57
  feature we want to portray. The gender of.
• 3:02
  Our choice suppose. No matter my chromosomes, today
• 3:05
  I feel 80% female, 20% male. I'm going to, I'm going to put
• 3:10
  on makeup. I'm going to do that.
• 3:12
  Tomorrow I might feel 80%. Male I'll remove.
• 3:15
  The makeup and I'll wear a muscle shirt.
• 3:18
  Why do you care? What?
• 3:21
  What? What?
• 3:21
  What business it? Is it of yours to require?
• 3:27
  That I fulfill your inability to think of gender on A.
• 3:32
  Spectrum my only point. Was that?
• 3:36
  If who you decide as. Male and female in the street is
• 3:42
  a construct. Of.
• 3:45
  Of of. So he's going to Babble on for
• 3:52
  another 5 minutes, as Neil deGrasse Tyson tends to do, but
• 3:56
  he says, what is it to you if someone feels like they're a man
• 4:01
  one day and a woman the other day, then what's the problem?
• 4:04
  Well, the problem is, is that you are representing science.
• 4:08
  You are claiming to be a part of the science community and you're
• 4:12
  telling people that there's a spectrum on males and females
• 4:15
  when there's not for the last. I would say since the existence
• 4:21
  of man and woman, it is always been known.
• 4:24
  It has always been a a fact that if you want to be able to bring
• 4:30
  children or have offspring in the world, you have to have a
• 4:34
  partner. You have to have someone who has
• 4:37
  different parts than you in order to be able to process and
• 4:42
  create life. Now there are some organisms out
• 4:45
  there, and there are. A rare amount of animals out
• 4:48
  there that have the ability to impregnate themselves.
• 4:52
  But just because something else can do that, that doesn't
• 4:55
  suddenly mean that that's a binary or a woman or a man or
• 4:59
  anything like that. It's just that that creature
• 5:02
  within its nature does that. That just doesn't happen to be
• 5:05
  the same nature as a man and woman who is a part of the human
• 5:09
  species. So he's talking.
• 5:11
  Basically. His argument is what if someone
• 5:14
  feels like doing something? What if someone feels like doing
• 5:17
  something? Well, how does that coordinate
• 5:20
  with science though? If I say I don't feel like I
• 5:24
  evolved from a monkey, if I don't feel like I evolved from
• 5:27
  that, that's not really an argument, is it?
• 5:30
  If I give you actual scientific reasons why it is that I don't
• 5:35
  think that science has established something or they
• 5:37
  have established something. Then that's what everybody would
• 5:41
  be looking for. That's if you're a true seeker,
• 5:43
  if you're an actual skeptic or an actual person who is
• 5:47
  intellectually honest with yourself, but he's literally
• 5:50
  doing a guilt trip, who are you to do this?
• 5:53
  Well, I could turn that around, right?
• 5:55
  I could turn this whole conversation around and said,
• 5:58
  well, who is it to you to tell me how I should feel about this
• 6:02
  shit? If I don't feel like what you're
• 6:05
  saying is fucking truthful or factual, and I feel that Neil
• 6:09
  deGrasse Tyson is full of shit, then so be it, right?
• 6:13
  I mean, since it's all about feeling, why should I even be
• 6:17
  obligated to explain to you, Neil deGrasse Tyson, why the
• 6:21
  fuck I feel the way I do about your stupidity, right?
• 6:25
  You see how I turn that shit around?
• 6:28
  Let's listen to some more of this fucking nonsense.
• 6:33
  And trends and what the beauty industrial?
• 6:39
  Complex wants you to see. If that's how we establish
• 6:44
  gender. Then maybe some people want to
• 6:48
  be fluid within that. Gender identified so.
• 6:52
  They'll they'll wear a skirt but maybe have a beard, or they'll
• 6:56
  mix and match that in whatever way you want.
• 6:58
  Hold on, I'm. Not wait, wait.
• 7:00
  I'm almost done. I'm almost done.
• 7:02
  So okay. If a person using the tools of
• 7:06
  the beauty. Industrial Complex wants.
• 7:08
  To mix and match this. Yeah.
• 7:11
  And they are expressing their freedom in a free country to do
• 7:17
  so. You see what I mean, ladies and
• 7:24
  gentlemen? Now, if I were to walk up to
• 7:26
  Neil deGrasse Tyson right now and say it's a free country, and
• 7:30
  today I feel like I'm a scientist, today I feel like I
• 7:34
  should be running fucking NASA. He would be the first one to
• 7:38
  tell me, well, just because you feel like you are the
• 7:41
  administrator of NASA, just because you feel like you're
• 7:44
  more intelligent than me, you know, there's.
• 7:48
  He would expect her to be a process.
• 7:50
  He would expect me to back that up with some kind of evidence
• 7:53
  and information. But now he's literally telling
• 7:57
  the public that whatever someone feels or whatever, you know,
• 8:01
  yadda yadda yadda. The problem is, is that this
• 8:04
  conversation is about what is actually factual.
• 8:08
  What is there evidence for, as opposed to what people just have
• 8:12
  some kind of strange wild hair up their ass that they and
• 8:15
  decide they want to feel some way?
• 8:18
  You know, ladies and gentlemen, besides this whole trans debate,
• 8:21
  there's plenty of people in the world who wake up sometimes and
• 8:24
  they imagine that they're reincarnated from some kind of
• 8:28
  alien species. There's some people who think
• 8:31
  they're hanging out with the ghost of Elvis.
• 8:33
  There's people out there who are thinking they're sitting by a
• 8:35
  campfire with fucking Bigfoot and Neil deGrasse Tyson would be
• 8:40
  the first time to snicker, mock and laugh at them.
• 8:43
  But suddenly, for whatever reason, because politics is
• 8:46
  popular nowadays and what is trending, he's going to go along
• 8:50
  with absolute horse shit. There's no hate here ladies and
• 8:54
  gentlemen. I'm just saying if you're going
• 8:57
  to claim to be a part of the science community, then do what
• 9:01
  the hell you guys been claiming that you're all about in the 1st
• 9:04
  place. The facts and the evidence, not
• 9:06
  based upon feeling? Here we go.
• 9:09
  Here's some more bullshit. Why is?
• 9:15
  Your job to. Tell them not to okay.
• 9:19
  That's my only. And so I'm Speaking of gender
• 9:23
  expression and the freedom to do so and and if you want.
• 9:28
  If you want to. Restrict that then what country?
• 9:32
  Are you we living in? Hold on.
• 9:34
  So first of all, I don't know a single person and I've talked.
• 9:38
  We've talked to trans people on the show.
• 9:39
  We have trans employees at trigonometry.
• 9:43
  We we've spoken to all sorts of people about this issue.
• 9:45
  I do not know a single person who wants to prevent people from
• 9:49
  dressing how they want or behaving how they want or
• 9:52
  choosing any name that they want.
• 9:54
  However, the problem. Is so you don't.
• 9:57
  But you know such people. Are out there.
• 9:59
  I'm sure such people exist in the same way that there are
• 10:01
  people who believe. That the earth is flat and so
• 10:04
  on, but they're a tiny minority. They exist, I don't know how.
• 10:07
  Tiny they are given. The dialogue fairpoint.
• 10:11
  However, what I would say is that the conversation in the
• 10:15
  public consciousness has become prominent not between people who
• 10:19
  want to defend the right of anyone to dress how they want
• 10:22
  and the people who want to prevent that.
• 10:23
  The reason the conversations become an issue is that we
• 10:27
  assign and allow certain privileges to people based on
• 10:30
  their sex. If you are female, you get to go
• 10:34
  to places the only other females are in, like changing rooms and
• 10:38
  toilets and so on. If you are female, you get to
• 10:42
  compete only with people of your sex, because females are at a
• 10:47
  disadvantage in physical competition to males in almost
• 10:50
  every sport. In other words, we carve out
• 10:53
  certain areas where your sex matters tremendously.
• 10:58
  Even though we may respect your right everywhere else to believe
• 11:02
  that you are whatever you are to dress however you are, etc.
• 11:05
  So your claim that today you woke up and put lipstick on and
• 11:11
  grew your hair out long and tweezed out your mustache and
• 11:13
  whatever, and therefore you are female, has an impact on other
• 11:17
  people in certain contexts in which that is a problem and gave
• 11:21
  only two. Contexts.
• 11:22
  Do you have others? Sorry.
• 11:23
  I wasn't finished and in those contexts it is essential.
• 11:28
  People would argue to protect women from unfair competition
• 11:31
  and from various risks for which female only spaces already
• 11:36
  exist. That's why people are having
• 11:38
  this conversation. It's not out of bigotry you
• 11:40
  have. Yeah, it's not out of bigotry.
• 11:45
  Anybody out there you could take a moment and just simply do a
• 11:48
  Google search and you're going to find that repeatedly crimes
• 11:52
  have been done against little girls and women with this whole
• 11:56
  bathroom thing? Now I don't have a problem.
• 11:59
  If people want to build a third bathroom, fine.
• 12:04
  But you have to understand that if you take away the roles of
• 12:06
  females and males, then it's going to get to a point where
• 12:10
  people are going to argue. Well then why should there even
• 12:12
  be woman or man bathrooms in the 1st place?
• 12:17
  And do women really want that, I mean?
• 12:20
  A lot of women use the bathroom not just so you can, you know,
• 12:24
  do your thing, but you also, a lot of women spend time in
• 12:27
  there. They use it for their place to
• 12:29
  be able to do makeup, They do it for their privacy, and so on.
• 12:34
  Now, what are you going to do if guys decide that they just want
• 12:37
  to walk in on you and do all this kind of thing?
• 12:40
  I mean, there's a lot of major inconveniences for this, and
• 12:44
  this is ridiculous. But besides that, there's been a
• 12:48
  number of crimes that keep on happening, ladies and gentlemen,
• 12:51
  A consistent amount. There's a pattern here.
• 12:55
  Lot of women are getting hurt. Women are getting screwed up.
• 12:59
  Even in professional sports, they're getting messed up.
• 13:02
  So, I mean, is there any kind of care or concern about this?
• 13:08
  And why is it so important for us to only care about the
• 13:11
  feelings of one group? Why is it that if you feel that
• 13:14
  this is wrong or you feel like you don't agree with it, then
• 13:18
  suddenly you're a bad person? I thought this was all about
• 13:21
  whatever you feel you know, who are you to basically tell us
• 13:26
  that we're not allowed to be bothered by this shit?
• 13:29
  I don't get the logic here, ladies and gentlemen.
• 13:32
  Let's continue to listen. Then those two examples, and
• 13:37
  I'll address each of those in turn, but you have more than
• 13:39
  those two. Probably not.
• 13:41
  OK, so. So let me address.
• 13:43
  Those two examples directly, I'll address that.
• 13:45
  Sports is very important. You said that female, I
• 13:48
  remembered so, so, but you don't seem to have a third example.
• 13:54
  So and even if you do, we presume that would be very
• 13:57
  distant third compared to those two cases.
• 14:00
  No, there's a third one I can give you very easily in this
• 14:02
  country for politics, we have female only shortlists for
• 14:06
  positions in in Parliament. Therefore, I didn't know about
• 14:09
  claims that's. Well, that's another example I
• 14:12
  can give you more. So female only shortlists.
• 14:15
  There are certain targets within corporations for diversity
• 14:19
  targets to have a certain number of women on the board.
• 14:23
  Therefore, when you make a claim that you are female, you are
• 14:26
  attempting, whether intentionally or not, to insert
• 14:30
  yourself into categories that are deliberately designed to
• 14:33
  protect women's interests. That is the concern that people
• 14:36
  have. So there's four examples for you
• 14:37
  there. Please address.
• 14:38
  Them. So interesting about the
• 14:40
  parliament. I have to look into that to find
• 14:41
  out what the is it. Is it try to ensure the
• 14:44
  representation of women. Is that the goal?
• 14:46
  Okay. Fine.
• 14:47
  So that's perfectly noble cause there.
• 14:49
  So about personal changing spaces, okay, that's a solvable
• 14:58
  problem of course. And we basically have
• 15:01
  accomplished that here in Manhattan, where I live,
• 15:04
  practically all bathrooms are either.
• 15:08
  Multi gender or it's solo bathroom, so only one person at
• 15:12
  a time. Or you walk into a space and
• 15:15
  there's stalls that are closed off but then you exit the stall
• 15:18
  and you come to a communal sink. Okay.
• 15:25
  So we could sit here and listen to this whole dribble.
• 15:28
  We could. But it's not really going to go
• 15:30
  nowhere. There's nowhere in this entire
• 15:33
  video where Neil deGrasse Tyson points out any kind of facts and
• 15:36
  evidence He does what he normally does.
• 15:39
  Whenever he's getting his ass whipped in a debate or
• 15:41
  discussion or whenever he's looking stupid, he has this
• 15:45
  consistent pattern where he'll just Babble on and on and on and
• 15:48
  hoping that if he babbles on long enough, people will just
• 15:52
  forget what the entire conversation was.
• 15:54
  Basically put you to sleep tactic.
• 15:57
  And that's what he does. He's a he's a professional
• 16:01
  mumbler, you know, And we see a lot of that kind of stuff
• 16:06
  whenever it comes to these arguments.
• 16:08
  I've seen it happen with many scientists out there where they
• 16:12
  get to a point where they don't have an answer for something,
• 16:15
  but they don't want to sound stupid and they can't
• 16:17
  acknowledge that they don't know any better or that they're
• 16:20
  ignorant. And they just continue to rail
• 16:24
  on and on and on until people are like, yeah, yeah, yeah,
• 16:27
  whatever. I think Neil deGrasse Tyson, not
• 16:32
  only is he an idiot, but he's rude.
• 16:36
  You can watch the Bill Maher show with him as well as him on
• 16:40
  other shows, and anytime he's in a conversation with people, this
• 16:44
  is how he does them. He cuts them off.
• 16:47
  He interrupts. Just watch any damn video with
• 16:49
  him where he's interacting with people and he doesn't play well
• 16:53
  with other atheists and agnostics either.
• 16:56
  He cuts them off too. And.
• 16:58
  He is very narcissistic. It's really, really hard to look
• 17:03
  at him and see this bloated bullshit that comes off of this
• 17:07
  guy. And besides that, I just don't
• 17:11
  see any, I don't see any kind of redeemable qualities about Neil
• 17:16
  deGrasse Tyson whatsoever, and there's a lot of people out
• 17:20
  there like him. Who they got to be on TV for a
• 17:24
  little bit, or they got popular because they read off a script
• 17:27
  and sounded really dramatic when they did it, and then suddenly
• 17:30
  they become like some kind of household item and people just
• 17:34
  think that suddenly this is somebody that you listen to or
• 17:37
  whatever. But it's pretty clear.
• 17:40
  It's pretty clear There's something else I should point
• 17:43
  out too. And this is kind of hitting
• 17:45
  below the belt, I admit that. But Neil deGrasse Tyson has.
• 17:50
  A record for sexual assault. I don't know if many of you knew
• 17:54
  that. There's quite a few different
• 17:56
  records out there were women have come out and said that he
• 17:59
  inappropriately touches them and does the kind of things that he
• 18:03
  does. He treats them like sex objects.
• 18:06
  Now, being in a conversation like this would be pretty wacky
• 18:11
  for him because he already has shown from his history that he
• 18:16
  has no respect for women or their space.
• 18:19
  Right, so why the fuck is he going to defend the woman's
• 18:23
  space in the 1st place when he himself can't keep his dirty
• 18:27
  mitts off of women in the 1st place who do not wish to be
• 18:31
  messed with or fondled by him? Do you see what I mean?
• 18:35
  He's the wrong guy to be arguing with over the space and privacy
• 18:40
  of women and women's roles in society because he doesn't have
• 18:44
  any fucking respect for him in the first place.
• 18:47
  Well, ladies and gentlemen, that's all I got to say.
• 18:50
  God bless. And if you don't believe what
• 18:52
  I'm telling you, a simple Google search would clear it all up for
• 18:55
  you.