Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Unveiling the Design-Build Revolution
Transcript
- 0:07Hello, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the Engineering Influence
- 0:10podcast by the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:13My name is Shreya, and I'm very happy today to be joined by Keith Molinar.
- 0:17I'm representing the ACAC Research Institute, and we're going to be talking
- 0:20about design, build, delivery methods of engineering today.
- 0:23Keith, thank you so much for being on the podcast. It's lovely to have you here.
- 0:26So happy. Thank you for the opportunity.
- 0:28So let's just dive right in. What exactly is the design, build method?
- 0:32The design-build method is a project delivery method, and that's where one project
- 0:38team for both design and construction has a single contract with the owner.
- 0:41It does vary quite a bit by procurement method and payment methods.
- 0:46So, for example, with the procurement method, you can have a best value procurement
- 0:51method or you can have a qualifications-based procurement method.
- 0:55It also varies with a contracting method, for example, a lump sum payment method
- 1:01or cost reimbursable payment method.
- 1:04So really the essence is one contract for both design and construction between
- 1:10the owner and the design builder.
- 1:13Okay, great. So how has the design build method evolved over the years and what
- 1:17factors contribute to its growing adoption in the engineering industry? Sure.
- 1:21Well, you know, design build is really one of the oldest contracting or project delivery methods.
- 1:27The first time in history it was used was back with the Code of Hammurabi,
- 1:31where absolute accountability was fixed on the master builder.
- 1:35Here in the U.S., it's really grown in both volume and use since the 1990s.
- 1:44When the public sector and some of the private sector started using it,
- 1:49it looked a lot like the design bid-build method, where it was very competitive in pricing.
- 1:54Sometimes used a lump sum procurement method and contracting method.
- 1:59But since then, it's really evolved to where it uses all types of procurement
- 2:05methods. We're starting to see a lot more qualifications based and a lot more
- 2:10contract, sorry, cost reimbursable contracting.
- 2:14That's great. I think its evolution is honestly very interesting.
- 2:17Yes, it really is. And it continues to evolve.
- 2:22Perfect. As anything should, right? Exactly. So, based on your research,
- 2:26how does design-build compare to traditional delivery methods in terms of cost
- 2:30efficiency, schedule adherence, and overall project performance? Yeah.
- 2:34So, you know, I've been lucky enough to be doing research in design build since
- 2:38the early 90s and seen different studies across a variety of sectors from vertical
- 2:44buildings through horizontal construction, water, wastewater.
- 2:48Water pretty consistently from the owner's perspective,
- 2:52it really does deliver a project much faster than traditional design bid build
- 2:58because we can overlap design and construction and get construction going before
- 3:03the actual design is finished in many cases.
- 3:07You know, what's interesting in some recent work we've done for ACEC is looking
- 3:13at it from the designer's perspective.
- 3:15And although the owner's getting things faster, there can be some challenges
- 3:20for some of the team members with risk allocation and other elements.
- 3:24But overall, the popularity has grown so much because of the efficiency and
- 3:29the effectiveness of the delivery method.
- 3:31So essentially, when those two teams design and construction communicate,
- 3:35things happen more efficiently and quicker. Yeah, absolutely.
- 3:38You know, you don't even necessarily need to start design.
- 3:42I'm sorry, start construction before design to get something done faster.
- 3:46It's just the collaborative nature of the team.
- 3:48For example, coming up with solutions that can be built faster through better
- 3:53constructability, having the contracting and construction team integrated into
- 3:58the early design methods.
- 4:00Yeah, cross-communication leading to more efficiency always.
- 4:04Absolutely, yeah. So the study highlights some concerns about risk allocation
- 4:07in design-build projects. How do you think stakeholders can ensure a more balanced approach?
- 4:12Yeah, that's a great question. You know, it really begins with the owner and
- 4:16their understanding of risk allocation and the implications that can have on
- 4:21project success and project cost overall.
- 4:23There is an attractiveness for owners because you have a sole point of responsibility
- 4:28to shift a lot of risk onto the
- 4:31design-build team. And frequently design builders will take on that risk.
- 4:35But if an owner doesn't look in detail at those risks,
- 4:40they can end up really paying more and actually can even create disputes between
- 4:46team members because they haven't equitably allocated the risks.
- 4:51So I think what we're seeing with the owners who really...
- 4:55Thoughtfully look at risk, but more so get the design build teams involved in
- 5:00a discussion of risk is really where we're seeing better results and more effective projects.
- 5:08And so how do you think, like, we talked a little bit about integrated collaboration.
- 5:11How do you think doing that early and often among owners, designers,
- 5:15contractors, how does all of that influence the success of these projects, design build projects?
- 5:20Well, you know, when you look at engineering and construction projects,
- 5:23they're incredibly complex, right, with, you know, hundreds if not thousands
- 5:28of people working on them from all various trades.
- 5:32The earlier we can get construction knowledge, the earlier we can get operations
- 5:37knowledge, the earlier we can start to think about the complexity of the project,
- 5:42the better chance we have at a successful project.
- 5:45So having those integrated teams come together to work on solutions that don't
- 5:51shift risk too much to one party, but really equitably put the risk across the team,
- 5:56really does support a more effective project delivery.
- 6:02Yeah. And like you said, I mean, earlier, it causes less dispute between teams
- 6:05because then one team is not taking on all the risk and super stressed, right?
- 6:08Yeah, that's generally true, but it does take.
- 6:12You know, the owner assigning risks to the team members that can best manage them.
- 6:18And it also takes the team members being willing to be on those projects or
- 6:23walk away when they get risks that they can't take on.
- 6:26Because that's where we're really seeing disputes arise from that early misalignment
- 6:31of risk or early acceptance of risk. Yeah.
- 6:35And, you know, with recent infrastructure investments, how do you foresee the
- 6:39role of design-build evolving in large-scale public projects?
- 6:43You know, as I said, I've been lucky to be looking at this delivery method for almost 30 years now.
- 6:49And I keep seeing the industry shift away from a traditional design-build to
- 6:55design-build where it's near almost half of the market.
- 7:00For infrastructure, it's incredibly effective.
- 7:04And that's because the time to delivery is so much less.
- 7:09So when you think about large infrastructure projects, they can take years, even up to 10 years.
- 7:14And so the earlier we can get the teams together, the faster we can get to construction,
- 7:20the more effective that is.
- 7:21And when you think about the benefits to the taxpayer or the traveling public,
- 7:26you know, getting that project open and in use is really one of the key success factors.
- 7:33Yeah, I mean, overall, it sounds like design build really is the future of project
- 7:36management and project delivery.
- 7:38Yeah, you know, we keep seeing it grow. I think, you know, it's not the only
- 7:42project delivery method out there, so we do need to be cautious to see it as a panacea or as,
- 7:48you know, we'll solve all of our problems because there's still really opportunities
- 7:52to use design, bid, build in the right situations on the right projects when
- 7:57it's the best to allocate risk.
- 7:59But for projects that need to be delivered quickly and where you get benefits
- 8:04from innovation coming from early construction knowledge and design,
- 8:08it really is working quite well for the industry. That's so interesting.
- 8:13Genuinely. And is there anything else from the study you would like to cover or highlight?
- 8:17I think, you know, we're just wrapping up phase one of our look into progressive design build.
- 8:23And what progressive design build is, is a form of design build where the team,
- 8:31both designer and constructor, are hired through qualifications based.
- 8:36So in the beginning, not on price.
- 8:38And then they work with the owner together during the first phase to validate
- 8:43a scope and to come up with a scope that fits within a budget and create a design-build budget.
- 8:50You know, I've just been astounded at the response that we've gotten on this
- 8:55first phase of the study.
- 8:57We had more than 500 responses to our initial questionnaire to look at interest.
- 9:03A couple things really stick out there.
- 9:05First, 76% of the participants that we saw are satisfied with the progressive design build method.
- 9:12That's higher than our traditional and our phase one study that we did for ACEC,
- 9:17where it was really a little bit less than a third were really satisfied.
- 9:22So, just that high level of satisfaction is really surprising.
- 9:27Also, the use across all markets from water, wastewater, through vertical buildings,
- 9:33through aviation and infrastructure, highways, rail, it's been much more pervasive than I thought.
- 9:40So, that's really exciting. You know, we still really want to look at,
- 9:44you know, where on those few projects that aren't successful,
- 9:48that people aren't satisfied, we really want to learn why.
- 9:51And it does seem to be coming down to misalignment of risk allocation at the
- 9:56beginning of the project.
- 9:58And, you know, I think the more we can learn about that and develop tools,
- 10:02the even more successful the delivery method will be.
- 10:05Yeah, definitely keeping the communication lines clear will probably help prevent
- 10:09that misalignment, right? Yeah, yeah.
- 10:11And it all is, you know, I think what's really sets progressive design build
- 10:16up for success is just what you said, that ability,
- 10:19the ability before you come to a price to have a very open dialogue,
- 10:23what solutions will cost and what time frame they can be done and really scope
- 10:30a project within the budget that you have available to meet the project objectives.
- 10:35Okay, that is about all the time we have for today.
- 10:38Thank you so much for tuning in to the Engineering Influence podcast,
- 10:41live to you from the ACEC 2025 Annual Convention and Legislative Summit.
- 10:46Thank you so much for joining me on today's episode.