Latest / The Academic Boardroom Podcast / Moving Beyond Empathy Fatigue with Dr. Courtney Cogburn
Transcript
- Welcome back to The Academic Boardroom where we sit down with power brokers shaping the future of education. I'm your host, Doctor Eli Joseph. And joining me is my colleague and partner in crime, Dr. Janice Gassam Asare. Today we are pleased to welcome Dr. Courtney Cogburn, an associate professor of social work at Columbia University, through grade school. In addition to being a professor at Columbia, Dr. Cogburn serves as the board chair of the International Center for Advocacy Against Discrimination. Dr. Cogburn directs a research group that uses innovative means to characterize and measure racism and evaluate its effects on mental and physical health. Prior to Columbia, Dr. Cogburn was a research scholar in the Harvard School of Public Health and the Harvard Center for Population and Development Studies. Dr. Cogburn. Welcome to the boardroom. Happy to be here. Hi. Dr. Cogburn, so I just want to give the listeners a little bit of background on how you and I met. I think I saw your LinkedIn. I think I saw your LinkedIn post or someone shared your LinkedIn posts in maybe January or February of 2020, right? As Covid was revving up and I was like, oh my gosh, her research is so cool. She has this like VR system that lets you experience what it's like to be a black person. So I was super fascinated. So I think I reached out to you at some point in February of 2020. We did this interview in March of 2020, so it's been over six years since we chatted, since we interviewed, and in the show notes, I'll link the interview that we did from six years ago if anyone is interested in reading. But how has your journey been with the VR system so far? I'm really curious to hear it's, you know, in the last six years, when we started at George Floyd, had the murder of George Floyd hadn't happened and all of this anti-de stuff hadn't happened. So what's been the impact of that VR system? Can you talk to us a little bit more about that? Yeah, and just a point of clarification about it, because people frame it this way all the time and it's really important. It's not about being black. Like if I wanted to create a virtual reality experience about being black, we would make something else altogether and it would be a lot of fun and everybody would be jealous that they weren't black. But for this, it was about observing racism from the perspective of a black person. So it really is about how people who are putting on the headset are seeing the experience of racism from this point of view. It has been quite a ride since we, we first launched that because it premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival. It kind of put us on this very big stage very quickly, and people started as can we use it in our training, our training and this and we didn't really design it with that purpose in mind. We actually didn't have an in goal in mind. We was sort of an exploratory, experimental thing. And so from there we were just all over the world, honestly trying to integrate the VR into various kinds of experiences and events that people were hosting. I was giving a lot of talks and sort of contextualizing the experience. University started using it, people use it in their classrooms, and that has continued to this day. All these years later, my brother was who's also a professor, was at a conference in Hawaii, and someone was talking to him about a VR experience. And he's like, that's my sister. You know, like it was like it still has this lingering effect. We actually recently published our first empirical paper using the experience, which took a long time to to get out, but it was really trying to help us demonstrate, in addition to all the anecdotal information we were getting about the impact it was having on people, the things we observed with our own eyes, how it was impacting people, and the way that they showed up in relation to these conversations. The empirical piece was a nice compliment to sort of standardize empirically what is going on with white liberals in particular, because that was the target audience. When they go through an experience like this, and we observed that people who went through the VR became less colorblind, so more willing to name race and racism. And this is already a liberal sample, right? So we're moving them even more, demonstrated a greater awareness of structural inequities and society, just generally recognizing that where people end up in life is not just their individual effort and will, that there are structural and social barriers that get in their way. So we notice that even in this ten minute experience, we could see quite a difference in people who went through the experience compared to those who did. So yeah. back when we did the article, I think that is how I framed it. But that's a really important point of clarification. So thank you. And I would love to read. And I'm sure the listeners would love to read that empirical research. Yeah, I'll send it. Yeah. I have a question. It's an introspective question to note. I, we normally use discrimination as a term, and some people think discrimination is always about just race or gender. But it can be race, gender, religion, ethnicity, the way you do things as well. But I have a question for you. Yeah. When was the first time you've ever experienced discrimination? Yeah. So, you know, growing up as black child in Oklahoma, you would expect that I had a lot of experiences with discrimination, but I actually grew up in this sort of black bubble. So a lot of people don't know that Oklahoma had more all black towns than any other state in the country. My family lived in a town that was predominantly black. My high school was predominantly black. So most of my life was actually pretty protected. But I do remember this moment in middle school, in particular, when some kids were doing a class project and one of them started imitating buckwheat, the character. I'm forgetting, The Little Rascals, the show from The Little Rascals, and the way he started, like twisting his face and his mouth and in person voice. I was just deeply, deeply offended. And I don't know, you know, it could have easily at my age, it could have easily been taken as a joke. It was meant to be silly, but I remember calling him out on that right then and there. I don't remember exactly what I said, and I remember him being so apologetic. That's not what he meant to do, but it was the first moment where I felt like, like, oh, we're like a character to you. We're not real people. And this is how is this what you hear? And I know he was imitating a specific character, but it felt deeply offensive to me. So that's my earliest memory. I think that was like fifth, fifth grade. I didn't know that you were actually. That's new information. I didn't know you were from Oklahoma. And Oklahoma is a really interesting place because I'm sure the Tulsa Race riots, I think now they call it the Tulsa, there's a different yeah, massacre. But I'm sure that that being a vocal part of the history, when I think of Oklahoma, that's what I think of was probably a really interesting like framed your understanding of racism and discrimination and just maybe hearing, I don't know if you had any family members that have like vivid memories of the Tulsa massacre that also kind of shaped your perception? No. And this is what's wild. I didn't even know about it until I was an adult and lived outside of Oklahoma and, you know, had my whole Oklahoma history class and no one ever talked about or mentioned this. And so it was really buried for a long time. So people who were directly, even people who were like ancestors were impacted about it. Their families didn't always talk about it, and they're now learning things about. So this is this is actually pretty new information in terms of public engagement around it. But I will say it was very strange for Oklahoma in black Oklahoma life. It's not something most people are familiar with. They're usually surprised that there's black people in Oklahoma. But to see it pushed into the popular discourse through shows like Lovecraft and Watchmen, it was so strange for people to be talking about Oklahoma and Black life. And most people still don't know that. Tulsa was one of 100 black towns in in Oklahoma, and that it was this strategic movement from Mississippi and Tennessee, like they were recruiting black people who were moving to come to Oklahoma and Kansas to create these black enclaves, something I also didn't understand early on. And I recently just learned that they were actually aiming for Oklahoma to be an all black state. It wasn't just the black towns, which is, you know, pretty radical. Yeah, that's I had no idea about them having so many all black towns. That's new information. So I'm so curious and I'm sure the listeners are curious. You know, doctor, I read your you have such an impressive bio, such an impressive background. Even when we spoke six years ago. I think the work that you're doing is amazing. How did you what was your academic journey like? How did you end up at the place where you're at now? And for anyone who's like, I want to do what she's doing. So amazing. Black girls in Stem. Like, what was your academic, excuse me, your academic journey, like, because I know that one term that you used in our interview was a trans scholar. So I'm curious about, you know, for the listeners that don't know what that means, what that means, and what your academic journey was like. Yeah. You know, part of my I think it's important that we talked about Oklahoma and black life in Oklahoma. There's something about growing up that way that just gave me moxie and audacity to do what I want to do. I truly believe I can do anything I want to do, and that has carried with me and has carried with me through my academic career. I knew my junior year of high school, I decided I wanted a PhD in psychology, so I knew that that's what I wanted to do, and I locked in on that goal. And then by my second year of college, I decided I wanted to go to University of Michigan, also for psychology, but then sort of veered a bit and did an MSW first, the Masters of Social work before doing the PhD. That was really important for me because I had done all this experimental, laboratory based work as a psychologist, which is really important research. But it's pretty sterile, like you're trying to remove noise and mess and isolate variables to figure out the relationships between between things. And that's just not how the world works. And so social work gave me a background that allowed me to messy the picture a little bit more, to say what's really going on, what are the factors that are actually contributing to the well-being and success of black folks, which my work is always focused on. So my MSW was a really important part of my training and trajectory. But the PhD was the the goal. And it's important for me to tell this story as well, because it's very easy to see my career or people like me and think that it's always been this straight, linear trajectory. You've always done well. Bop bop bop. Not true. Right? So almost failed calculus and undergrad that tanked my GPA. It really compromised whether I was going to be competitive for PhD programs. I did this MSW. I did research the whole time I was in the master's program, and I worked with this one woman who I will not name. But we didn't have a great relationship. And but I had worked a lot with her, so I asked her to write one of my letters of recommendation. I'm not the first PhD in my family. I know what questions to ask. Can you write me a strong, positive letter of recommendation? She's like absolutely blah blah blah. I'm like, okay, all good. I fast forward, it comes to me that I'm not I'm not getting into the PhD program, the one I've dreamed of, the University of Michigan. I'm not going to get in. And she didn't write me a strong letter and heartbroken. And it was like, you know, Invisible Man, where they give them a letter like, you know, keep running. And that's exactly what that felt like. But I didn't let it derail me. I took a year off. I kept doing research with some of the same faculty in the program that I wanted to go to, and then reapplied the next year and got in, but that could have, like, completely derailed my whole life and trajectory. Right? But for me, I wanted to be at the University of Michigan. I wanted to work with those faculty because I was interested in racial identity. I wanted to really understand how black people survive whiteness, how do they get through not just sort of what the negative impacts are, but what do they have? What do they possess collectively and individually that help them get through some of these systems and experiences? And that's always been a driving force in my in my work. I then move to, in my postdoc trying to understand racism, not as, as you said, Dr. E, not only as discrimination or direct things that happen to people, but as as it exists in the air that we breathe. Right? It's all around us. And especially in a media rich society, we're always on news feeds. We're always getting alerts. We're always, always, always being exposed to this continent. And so I started to become interested in what is that doing to our bodies. If direct experiences with discrimination are harmful, which are well documented and we know what is this constant barrage of information, negative imagery, someone imitating buckwheat times, you know, a million. Like, what does that do to the body? And so in my post, like I started doing these experiments where I would expose people to different types of media content and monitor their physiological responses to see how it was affecting them. And that moved me even deeper into trying to measure racism in more comprehensive ways, and then ultimately getting to the point of the virtual reality. This is the short version, getting to the point of virtual reality, where the empirical work does some heavy lifting and is really important, but it wasn't translating or having the impact that I wanted it to have. And so I moved into VR because I was interested in people basically walking in the data. What does it feel like this really? It's one thing to read a chart. It's one thing for me to try to summarize research we've been doing for 20, 30 years. It's another for me to put you in it. And that was the point of the virtual reality, basically saying, you know, I wanted it to be a gut punch, like walk away from it now, explained it away. Now that you've been treated this way and seeing and experience these things firsthand, and that's just like a little sliver, right, of what we experience on a day to day basis. But it became a tool for me to translate the empirical work in a visceral way, and again, specifically targeting white liberals, where where my target audience. Yeah. I'm so curious about what your thoughts are. I know, especially after 2020, a lot of people were using those Harvard unconscious bias of tests, you know, so I'm curious about your thoughts or whether you had maybe you utilize them in your research as a like a pre and a post test to see if people's unconscious bias after going through your VR system was impacted. What are your thoughts on those tests? Because I've taken them and I find them to be super interesting and super fascinating. Like I took one on wait, wait discrimination. And I showed a bias toward thinner individuals, which was surprising to me because I think I'm pretty. As somebody who's fluctuated weight, I thought I was pretty open minded, but I guess I have some fat phobia buried deep inside me. So I'm curious about your thoughts about those Harvard Implicit Association tests. Yeah, I think and I use those did some studies related to that in my undergraduate research. I think the unconscious bias work has been a really foundational and important, and I think people have misused it. And I'll explain what I mean. So that work has helped to establish for people who weren't burning flags and marching down the street in hoods to realize that they also possess bias. Right? That it's hard to breathe the air we breathe and not walk away with some assumptions about different racial groups who's good, who's bad, who's dangerous, who's not. And so that work really established that, yes, you do have this bias, right. And that bias likely seeps out in your behavior in various ways. Even though when I ask you to tell me how you feel, you wouldn't say that you believe those things. So it becomes really foundational, important. For that reason, I think where people have misused the research is believing that they could undo their bias in meaningful and lasting ways. And so a lot of people started to invest in these trainings around undoing bias. I don't think you undue bias until you correct the pollution that created the bias in the in the first place. It's also, in my opinion, in the original researchers would would agree with this, that they weren't suggesting that you could reduce bias in any lasting way, or that that was the place to focus. Our intervention. I described trying to undo bias is like a Sisyphean task. You're rolling a boulder up a hill, and it's going to roll back down on you, and you'll keep that going over and over again. So what's important about that work is realizing that bias is so pervasive that we need to create systems that anticipate the bias, so put structures in place that anticipate that. When I see a certain name. I may even unconsciously start to devalue their work. So take the names off the resume, right? Don't try to make me be a different person. I'm not waiting for that outcome. Right. I'm going to anticipate that you have this bias a lot of people do. How does the system then need to adjust to what we understand about how pervasive that is? And that's where most people get it wrong, in my opinion, that investing in reducing bias is not really the best use of time or resources. Yeah, that's really powerful because the I mean, even if you do things to help people recognize and address their individual biases, like you said, the systems that allow those biases to persist are still in place. So like in the workplace, even if I maybe did something to address my own unconscious biases, if I'm on a hiring committee and we're looking at a name and I'm like, that sounds black, you know, and my unconscious bias, the system is still in place. So I think that's such, such an important point. And after 2020. You know, I saw we all saw a lot of those implicit bias and unconscious bias trainings and workshops being requested. And those are like my least favorite. I would people were asking me to do those, and I just was like, I don't I it's just it doesn't sit well with me because we have to be addressing the system. But again, I think it's nice to put it on an individual because then the onus of the change is on them and it's like, well, they did this and not the environment that allowed that, that bias to persist. Yeah, 100%. look at your work, especially with the VR work, the immersive experiment as a walk in in an extension to Jane Elliot's experiment. Right. The blue I brown I experiment. It's just that now you're actually, you know, it's more modernized in a way I and I also love and I want you to get into this as well. The subconscious by a thousand cuts, you know, making sure that you immerse the users with, you know, how it feels like to be you know, someone else. I want you to talk more about, you know, the thousand cuts and also what made you think about that particular title? Yeah. So, you know, like I said, I'm a person that kind of does what I want to do. And I jumped in the deep end. I had never used VR. I say this all the time, like had no idea what I was doing. It just sounded cool. And I wanted to try it. And finding my collaborator Jeremy Beilinson at Stanford, who I just wouldn't have been able to pull this off without his expertise and insight. So having that right collaborator was really, really critical. So on that end, because the process was a really important part of this. So it was transdisciplinary, meaning that we defined the problem and built the work together from the very beginning. It wasn't that I had an idea, and then I handed it off to the tech people to make the VR. Like every piece was created together from the very beginning, and there's equal respect for the social worker, psychologists and the computer scientist programmer. Like everyone has equal footing. It's not possible to pull off what we did without all of those people involved. And I think that was a really important part of what we achieved and where we landed. We also allowed ourselves to play for about six months. Right? We had a year to do the project. We took about half that time to shoot stuff on the street, play around with stuff on the trains. This type of story, that type of story, willing to like, throw something out the window that we had spent a lot of time on because it just wasn't working. And so that freedom to mess around, was, as they say in jazz, play outside like it was the freedom we needed, I think, to discover a sweet spot and what we were able to to create, which I'm still really, really proud of. A thousand cuts came up because I knew, though we were very clear, that we wanted to capture multiple representations of racism. It's not just childhood, it's not just the workplace. It's not just police. We wanted it to be layered and build in all these pieces. I knew we were still scratching the surface of what this was. And so I think the title really came from a place of conveying how significant these hits are. Every day you death by a thousand cuts, right? The torture method of slowly depleting the life force of someone as a torture mechanism is, is what I was referencing in in this experience, sometimes when we use words like microaggressions, for instance, it makes it sound small. It's not. It's a cut and it's and a lot of those things happening all day, every day. There's a social media post. I'm always regret not saving it or finding it, but it was a black man talking, sort of going through his day, leaving his apartment, going to get a coffee and coming back. And he basically verbalized everything that happened to him from the time he left to his apartment, from the time he came back. And it was a reference for me as well, is that's every day. That's today. Out of all the years since you've been born, right? The racism you've inherited while you were in utero to walking through to every day, going to get a coffee, going to school, going to work, etc.. And so I knew the VR wasn't going to do that, but I wanted the title to do it to to try and capture the significance of all those hits from birth to death. I greatly, of course, admire the work that you do, but I'm curious, as somebody who also engages with this work, we see what's happening, you know, from the point where we spoke, where maybe there was there was a different it was different in March of 2020 when we last spoke to now, where, you know, there was a spike, I'm sure, an interest in your work. And now there's maybe backlash. Where do you see day? I'm sure it won't be called die, but whatever it'll be called. Where do you see this work in ten years from now? And how do you envision it changing over the next ten years? And also, one question I personally would love to know is what keeps you hopeful? Because it's easy when you do this work to get discouraged. So where do you see this work in ten years? And also what what keeps you hopeful? Yeah, yeah. You know, I think DEI did some really important work historically in terms of improving access and mobility for different groups of people, primarily white women, but also did some work for for black folks and other groups as well. And I think it had been the silver lining in this, right, is I think it had also become stagnant and performative, right, that people were making all these symbolic gestures. They would do their Black History Month program, they would bring me and you and they would bring us in to give these talks and whatever, and then weren't making any substantive changes. They had gotten sort of stuck in like, well, we started going to Howard to recruit black students. Right. And so I found that people really had started to not invest in the way that I would like them to. As you pointed out, in their own environment, their own work. This is not necessarily an employee level problem. It's a social problem. It's a systems problem. And I think people were really hesitant to make the kinds of changes that were required at that level. They had a really hard time questioning whether the LSAT was doing what it thought, what they thought it was doing. Is that school really telling you what it needs to tell you? Or maybe you need to be considering some other factors when you're recruiting people to your firm? That was a much harder question, right, for people to ask. But yes, come from Black History Month, right. And so I think the civil lining of the dismantling is it has forced people who do have a true commitment to it to reimagine what that looks like in their day to day work. And the way that I've been talking about this is really trying to get people to think in the affirmative. What do you want? What do you want your environment to look like? And it's related to my response about what keeps me hopeful. So, you know, I've spent 20 years talking, thinking and studying racism. And it's talk about a thousand cuts, right? So in addition to my lived experience, my professional life is steeped in this as as is many of us. But recently, I shifted to think about the health benefits of imagination and thinking. So I'm working on a book in specifically imagination that doesn't begin with crisis or threat or oppression, but imagination that starts with possibility. And I think this is this is important for the dye space, and I think it's important for all of us. But I think it's uniquely important for for black people. Right. Because what I'm asking in the, in the book is for black people to not only filter their dreams and imaginations through surviving racism or whiteness, which so much of our work is centered on fixing problems we did not create. I'm asking us to remember that we're more than fighters, and that our imaginations are more expansive than our oppression. There's a book that was been really influential, influential for me. It's called Black Aliveness or The Poetics of Being by Kevin Clichy, who's an English professor at Brown, I believe. And he says, you know, blackness has been index to death. When do we get to start somewhere else? And then I pick that up and think about specifically as it relates to imagination. There's an inherent hope in that, that something else is possible, but I think it's more expansive than only fixing problems. When you begin with problems, you're you're limited to the scope of that problem. Your response is automatically tethered to something that's already been designed and created. So if we only respond to racism and oppression, which we should continue to do, to be clear, but that's not the only space we should occupy. I think we create space where we can dream and imagine and create and build and not just fix problems. I think that's important for all of us, distinctly important for black folks. And I think it's related to the question of DEI. DEI started with fixing a problem. We have a problem. What do we do? What do we put in its place? And it's a very different question to ask what type of work do I want to do? Where do I want my company or organization to feel like? What contributions do I want to make to the world? What do I want this to look like and feel like? What do I think we find when we have people who are here from very different walks of life and points of view, it's definitely not going to be the same old stuff that comes up, because you have people who have the exact same backgrounds and ideas, which we know that from. DEI work in research, we already know that more diverse groups create more interesting ideas, but it's a repositioning and it's a reframe. And to be clear, I think we're taking a huge step back, right? Right. With the ending of DEI. I'm not I'm not trying to be Pollyanna about about that that, you know, black women are in particular being fired and laid off and let go at rates that are exorbitant and it's going to cycle us back. But I think I also call on us to be dreamers and see opportunity and see ourselves working outside of existing systems and using our imaginations to to build and grow and not just white. it reminds me what you were saying, just reminds me a little bit of a book that I read by Ruha Benjamin called Imagination Manifesto. Yeah, yeah, it was so good. But as you were talking, I was thinking of what Toni Morrison talks about around the white gaze and how everything that we do as writers, or whatever it is that we're doing, we're thinking about it from the context of a white man, you know, and writing for this white audience. And what does it look like to create and to do without sort of like using the our imaginations? Because I think a lot of us, especially those who do this work, are so focused on the problems and it can be very deflating. You know, using our imagination is not something. So I know when your book comes out, it's going to be really fascinating because I haven't really heard that perspective a lot before. But it's it's so needed. And, you know, I know a lot of people who were doing die who said, you know, I can't I'm not dying for this work. I can't do this anymore. And it's just not fulfilling me. And, you know, thinking about it from that perspective or that reframe of like, what do we want to see? Versus this is the problem and how do we fix it is a really powerful, to me reframe that I actually haven't thought about is like, what do I want to see? Versus what can I do to fix this problem? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I, you know, the, the and the, the distinction I think is, is an important one. So one, one line of imagination we might think about is radical imagination, which is mostly the category who who I adore. And her work is so important. There's another book called Freedom Dreams which is also really important. But but still, so much of that work is radical, right? It starts with the transformation of what is. And so it is responding to that problem, which again, really important. I would put the all black towns of Oklahoma in that bucket. That is radical. You're going to make an all black state. Wow. Right. Like like that's radical. But what I reframe is the life I got to live in. The black town I grew up in was untethered. I wasn't thinking about white people. I wasn't responding to white people. I didn't have to. I didn't have to fight because this container got built for me. That made it save for me to just be a kid. And I was still a black kid. It was still a black family. It was still black culture. And it was not entertaining whiteness in the way that so much of our lives have to on oppression and racism, etc.. So both of those things are really, really important. Radical in the fight, fixing policies, fighting for voting rights, etc. and creating a space for ourselves where we don't have to do that at all, is a really different feeling in your body to think of the lightness and freedom of imagining and dreaming from a place that is not trying to survive something I want to jump in and ask you this question. You did mention that, you know, the recent backlash or the recent you know, the recent backlash against DEI has made us take a step back. But I was wondering, do you think AI also exacerbated the way that we should feel about AI, about DEI? Or do you think AI can help us progress further on to, you know, being diverse and equitable? Yeah, I think I think it's a both and right. So I think there's a lot to be worried about related to to AI. There's certainly like just the climate impacts alone. But even that right. Like is that the way data centers have to be structured. Do they have to use so much water? Is there another way to build data centers that don't damage the planet in quite the same way? Or were y'all rushing and didn't consider other ways of structure? So even there, we should be asking some some questions, and the ways in which AI and the way capitalist societies work, or people are rushing to make as much money as possible, they're rushing to leverage as much control as possible. They're rushing to say, this is inevitable. You have to use this. This is a part of our lives now, I think is really dangerous. And I think there are some things about these technologies that can create a lot of opportunity and equity and access to resources and understanding that you normally need capital, social or financial in order to access how to write a business contract, how to read a business contract, how to hire an agent. Pretend to be my agent, right? Help me design an app. I've had this idea for years. I have no idea how to code. Make it for me, right? Help me launch this business idea. Help me find. I think there's so many ways it's access to knowledge and information, and then the translation into product that is becoming more equitable because of some of these technologies that I think can improve our ability to make some contributions. I think we have to be very careful about it. I think we should be cautious, and I think we should also be considering how do we leverage this for our collective benefit and advantage. And again, I think that's a question of imagination. And there's the imagination that would protect us from it. What do we build in response to it? And then there's the imagination that would say we can almost do anything. What would we do? Right. Not just protect ourselves, not just hold off harm. So I think we need to I think we should be thinking about it. I think collectively, we should all be thinking about how might these technologies help me in in some way, while also being cautious and also being concerned. Yeah. Because I think about from like a health disparities perspective, you know, I know there's a lot of research on how, how many people are using AI and ChatGPT and these large language models to diagnose them or to get mental health support and or get just health support if you don't have insurance. And I don't necessarily think it's a good idea, but I do think that for some people, maybe there's somebody who was able to get an accurate diagnosis, somebody, a black person or a person from a historically marginalized group who maybe wouldn't be able to maybe there's a language barrier, maybe there's, you know, all of these factors where I think that there is good that AI can provide people with democratizing information. But I also think that, you know, like you said, there's that dark side where it's like the, the, the, you know, amount of water that's used and how a lot of these data centers, all of them are in black neighborhoods, poor neighborhoods. And so all of the implications with that. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. And I you know, I've worked with some, some tech companies who, you know, for better or worse, or they have their pros and their cons, but who do have units who are thinking carefully about this, right. In the case for health is one of them. It can be very, very good at some, some health cases. So for instance, I've used it, my aunt had a series of tests and we didn't know what. We didn't know what high meant on this thing versus a low on that other thing. And I asked it and it was able to give me a clear profile, and I ran it by some of my physician friends. They were like, yeah, that's accurate. That it suggests this. Here are questions she should ask in her follow up visit. Be sure to ask for blah, blah, blah, right. And just kind of late this out in a way that we wouldn't have been able to do on our on our own. And I have a physician friend of mine, she's a CEO of City Block Health. Her name is Tony and a G. And she talks a lot about the possibilities of AI as it relates to health equity. Right. If we if we do it right, if we model it correctly, it can give us really accurate information. It can let us know when we haven't been given the information that we need to have. It can help help us pull the right kinds of information out from physicians. So yeah, it can help a diagnosis. It can help with getting the right test, get help with interpreting the test and and and right all these these other other issues. What I do hope for us is that we don't put our heads in the singer, that we don't operate out of fear, that we don't just ignore it and hope that it goes away, that we think that because we're refusing to use it in a given moment, that that is sufficient enough to prevent it from being integrated into society. It's not. The train left the station. They dump this onto society without any consultation, without any heads up, nobody without regulation. Nobody had time to plan. It's here. It's powerful. I don't think it's inevitable in the way that it intersects with every part of society. But I think it's inevitable that that we it's not inevitable in that we have to think about what this is and what it means for us in our societies. And just saying I don't like it and just sort of checking out, that's not that's that's not realistic and it's not an option. You don't have to use it. I'm not telling people to use it. You do need to understand it. There's no way you're going to advocate against it if you don't understand what it is and how it's being used, and putting your head in the sand is not going to help you understand what this is and what it means for how it's going to potentially fundamentally reshape society. So I think we need to pay attention and we need to engage. Now, I know we don't have much time left. I do have a question that I always ask my guests here. You're in academia and you have done tremendous work. If there was one thing, one skill, one quote, one lesson that you wished you you were able to be exposed to when you were studying, what would it be? What skill would you want to learn, or what skill would you want to advise someone who is an aspiring, you know, sociologist or psychologist who wants to get into the field and also is listening to this? What is one thing that you would one lesson or one skill you think would be helpful for aspiring listeners here? Yeah, I think it's it's a wonderful question. There's there's a couple of things that come to mind. I think the first is what I, what I referenced in the beginning about what I think I took away from my childhood in terms of boldness and audacity. I think somehow I believed in my own power, and I did not rely a lot on what other people thought about me to determine which way I went next. I would often take big things that people would make a big deal about, and I was like, oh, I can I can do that, right? And I don't think there's anything particularly special about me. Other than that orientation, I wish people relied more on their authenticity and knowing what that means, truly, and paint with that brush instead of trying to be like someone else they saw. Do something. The most powerful thing we can be is ourselves. And too many of us have been trained to pretend to be people in order to be successful, etc. and I think the more that we deeply connect with who we are individually and what we think we might contribute to society as a result, the better off will will be. The second is somewhat related, but is a quote that I'm not able to attribute to anyone because I can't remember the name of the person who said it to me. They just said it to me in passing at a reception, and they said, there are people who saw the problems of their disciplines and people who solve problems of the world, and people who are trying to solve problems of the world can't go it alone. You have to collaborate, use your superpower superpower combined with someone else's superpower, and work together to build something and discover something amazing. But I think it's it's boldness. It's not just breaking stuff, but figuring out who you are and how you can help build something meaningful in the world. And that's very different that people may think they're doing that. That's not your degree, that's not your salary, that's not your accolades, that's not your individual award. That's not somebody patting you on the back and telling you that you've done a good job. It's actually existing beyond all of that and not relying on those things to determine where your North Star, your North Star is. It's nice to get those things, but that's really not what it's about. I love that, thank you so much, Dr. Cogburn. We were so. Honored to have you on the podcast, sharing all of your knowledge with us. It's great to reconnect. And yeah, I'm just so glad that we had to. And this is my favorite chat, you know, because this is the work that I do as well. So it's been great to connect with you. Thank you so much for having me I appreciate it. Thank you so much. This is The Academic Boardroom and we're signing out right now.