Latest / Adventures Through The Mind / Linking Individual Stress To Societal Dysfunction | Dr. David Katz ~ ATTMind 204
Transcript
- 0:00(upbeat music)
- 0:33Hello, this is your first time.
- 0:35Welcome to Adventures Through The Mind.
- 0:38This is a podcast that explores topics relevant and related to psychedelic culture, medicine,
- 0:43spirituality, and research, and always with the underlying question of, "What is the
- 0:47How can we work with and through our psychedelic experiences to become better people, not just
- 0:51for ourselves, but for all those with whom we are nested in relationship, presently and
- 0:56across time, human and non-human alike?
- 0:59I'm your host, as always, James W. Jesso.
- 1:02And again, if it's your first time, welcome.
- 1:04If it is not your first time, welcome back.
- 1:07This episode was actually recorded quite a long time ago.
- 1:11I recorded the interview that is probably about a year ago, sometime in March of 2025.
- 1:18And I'm releasing it as the first episode of 2026 because, well, first off in the curation scheme of things,
- 1:25it didn't entirely fit just yet.
- 1:28And it is fitting now because it feels like it speaks to something that is important at the time in these times,
- 1:36which is how much
- 1:39biological
- 1:40process might be
- 1:42impacting and being impacted by
- 1:45larger socioeconomic political
- 1:48conditions.
- 1:49What does that mean? Well, you've read the title, I assume, but what it means is that
- 1:54we're going to talk today about how stress and inflammation, the dynamics they have with
- 2:00each other, how they compromise perception and behavior, and how they can actually be
- 2:05spread between people through perception and behavior, as well as how it spreading between
- 2:11people can impact a population kind of a...
- 2:15like a contagion that infects the social political body as a whole, compromising even the very leadership, the controllers that would normally keep that social or political body from entering into a disease state.
- 2:31I probably sounds like a lot, but I promise you it is progressive and clear to understand
- 2:37as we go through the interview.
- 2:39Part of what is going to make this interview comprehensible, despite being very large
- 2:43and complex topics, has to do with our guest and his ability to speak in ways that are
- 2:49understandable and accessible for a wide audience.
- 2:53That guest is none other than Dr. David Katz.
- 2:56Now I'm going to read Dr. Katz bio here.
- 3:00Dr. David Katz is the founding director of Yale University's Yale Griffin Prevention
- 3:06Research Center, past president of the American College of Lifestyle Medicine, founder president
- 3:13of the True Health Initiative, and founder-CEO of True Health ID Incorporated.
- 3:19Dr. Katz earned his bachelor's degree from Dartmouth College in 1984, his medical degree
- 3:25from the Albert Einstein College of Medicine in 1988, and his master's in public health
- 3:31from the Yale University School of Public Health in 1993.
- 3:36Katz is a board-certified specialist in preventative medicine and public health,
- 3:41He's the recipient of many awards for his contributions to public health and has received three honorary doctorates.
- 3:48He holds five U.S. patents with others pending.
- 3:52He invented the research methods known as evidence mapping and evidence threshold pathway mapping.
- 3:58He's the principal inventor of the overall nutritional quality index algorithm and invented
- 4:04the first fundamentally new dietary intake assessment method in decades called diet quality
- 4:10photo navigation.
- 4:10He has authored roughly 200 peer reviewed publications, many hundreds of health columns
- 4:16both online and in print, and 17 books to date including leading textbooks in both nutrition
- 4:22and preventative medicine.
- 4:24He has served as one of the expert judges for the annual rankings of diets by US News and World Report for much of the last decade,
- 4:32and he was a 2019 finalist for a James Beard Foundation Award in the category of health journalism together with Mark Bitman.
- 4:40And he's on the show today to talk about the contents of a paper he was co-author on titled
- 4:46A Multiscale Inflammatory Map Linking Individual Stress to Societal Dysfunction.
- 4:52With that said, what are we going to talk about today? We're going to talk about
- 4:55what is stress, what is inflammation, what are the dynamics between them,
- 4:59how they influence individual health, how
- 5:02The systems of stress and inflammation and the resolution processes can get distorted and we can end up in
- 5:11states of chronic inflammation. We talk about inflammation's relationship to the brain as well as
- 5:17the brain's relationship to inflammation. That
- 5:20two-way path is going to be talked about.
- 5:21We talk about how inflammation influences compromises at times, our perception and behavior, and how it can then spread like a contagion through a population
- 5:33that's spreading over time, degrading not only the...
- 5:37social dynamics of a particular population, but going as far as to degrading the institutions,
- 5:44the social institutions, political institutions, and even political leadership of a given country
- 5:49as well as international affairs between countries.
- 5:52Do-do.
- 5:54Inflammation in a bottom-up, inflamed people to inflamed system, and top-down, inflamed
- 6:00dysfunctional system into greater inflammation in individuals.
- 6:03And we're going to do so in a way that's progressive and
- 6:06features quite a lot of information, not only on what's happening and why,
- 6:11but what we can do about it.
- 6:12Each of us right here, right now,
- 6:15in ourselves in ways that contribute to our own health,
- 6:18and the health of, at the very least,
- 6:21our small communities, perhaps even the world at large.
- 6:25That's all for the intro.
- 6:26Please enjoy this interview with Dr. David Katz
- 6:28here on Adventures Through the Mind, episode 204.
- 6:31Dr. David Katz, thank you for coming on Adventures to the Mind and welcome.
- 6:37Thanks very much, James. Good to be with you.
- 6:41So I'm not sure how it came about, but somehow I got exposed to your paper, the name of which I did not write down, so I'll get you to repeat in a second.
- 6:53And it explores the sort of link between inflammation, stress, mental states, behaviors,
- 7:02and then the links between how those unfold in the individual with how they unfold interpersonally,
- 7:09and then upwards into society in ways that impact human health, human society, and even
- 7:15planetary health. And I was--
- 7:18Well, very impressed.
- 7:20And also, like, impressed is like good work, but also impressed in the sense of like, "Wow,
- 7:28I'm so happy to see this explored and explained in such a coherent way in a time that it feels
- 7:36so relevant."
- 7:39So first up, I'll thank you for that and for your work.
- 7:42That's very kind James thank you so yeah I don't know how you found the paper either I'm glad you did I suppose it is about altered states of mind and so that there's there's clearly some overlap.
- 7:55But not exactly in your wheelhouse so thanks for reaching out I appreciate it just a shout out so the papers called a multi scale inflammatory map linking individual stress to societal dysfunction.
- 8:07And we publish this with a great deal of excellent editorial support, by the way, from Frontiers in Science.
- 8:13So, really nice journal.
- 8:15We did a symposium based on the paper that they hosted and we had people attend from all over the world.
- 8:21So, it's had quite a lot of traction.
- 8:22And a shout out to my co-authors, in particular, Yoram Bodevots, who's in the immunology and
- 8:29surgery department at the University of Pittsburgh.
- 8:31Yoram was our captain.
- 8:32I was a member of the crew as we worked on this paper, but Yoram as an immunologist led
- 8:38the charge.
- 8:39And then we had a mathematician, Julia Arciero, and a neuroscientist, Paul Vershure.
- 8:44So really interesting team.
- 8:45I'm a lifestyle medicine specialist myself.
- 8:48So in some ways, I'm the right person to talk to about the translation from individual factors
- 8:55to society.
- 8:57But the contributions everybody made were extremely illuminating.
- 9:01So it was a great learning experience for all of us as the best of academic papers are,
- 9:06because as your colleagues are working on the paper,
- 9:08they're taking you on a deeper dive into aspects of it that aren't quite your area of expertise.
- 9:14So we all learned a lot from one another.
- 9:16It was a good project.
- 9:17And this kind of multidisciplinary approach to an issue, a hypothesis, a concern, I think is
- 9:25something that I think there's a lot of value in high specificity and narrow focus on a particular
- 9:33aspect of something that is being researched.
- 9:36But when it comes to the kind of things that we will eventually be getting into talking to today,
- 9:40the kind of interdisciplinary approach seems to integrate things in a way that our society a
- 9:47lot of the times these days anyway seems to be lacking in this kind of like integration of what's
- 9:52all happening and then try to make it work.
- 9:54choices and observations that are based on a lot of different factors rather than the particular silos
- 10:01that a person or organization is specializing in. So that's really great to hear.
- 10:06That's an interesting observation. And I think our society is lacking in three things right now, fundamentally important.
- 10:15One is basic civility, the idea that we could agree to disagree and still respect one another.
- 10:21The other is nuance. Everybody seems to be shopping for answers that are yes or no, right
- 10:26or wrong, left or right, as opposed to, well, it depends. It's context-dependent, it's
- 10:31circumstance-dependent, and most things in the real world actually are. It depends, is
- 10:37almost always, a valid answer. And the third is just as you suggest, the failure to see
- 10:42the big picture, the forest through the trees, a singular issue in my field, the biomedicine,
- 10:49Where we have more and more ultra specialization you can see the world's leading authority in the treatment of some particular injury of your left knee
- 10:57The only problem being that if there's anything else wrong with you as a person in the world
- 11:02It's apt to go over look for many years. You'll be interested to know I started many of my public talks
- 11:09reciting the blind man and the elephant that parable is owned by John Godfrey Sax.
- 11:15It was six men of indistinct to learning much inclined who went to see the elephant though all of them were blind that each by
- 11:21observation might satisfy his mind that goes on from there. Each of the six takes part,
- 11:26takes hold of a different part of the elephant, reaches a completely different conclusion. No one
- 11:30obviously gets their arms around the whole elephant and understands the big picture.
- 11:34So I do think that's a fundamental challenge these days and and to be clear
- 11:40science has advanced tremendously on the power of reductionism
- 11:46scrutinizing up close the smallest parts of the smallest parts of something
- 11:51But you're not going to understand an ecosystem that way.
- 11:55You're not going to understand the connections
- 11:59among many levels of influence that way.
- 12:01The influence of stress on inflammation in the immune system,
- 12:05the influence of the immune system on other organ systems,
- 12:08the influence of the organ systems on the behavior of the organism the influence of that behavior by that individual on a community you can't get that with reductionism you need a different approach so i appreciate the observation and we agree.
- 12:24Yeah, the, what was the three there? You said civility, nuance, and then the ability to...
- 12:30Yeah, basically the ability to see the whole, which is often greater than the sum of its
- 12:36parts. So if you just scrutinize the parts, you'll have a distorted perspective on the
- 12:42whole. So there's a case to make for both. There are times when up-close scrutiny of
- 12:46small parts is the way to go.
- 12:49but not to the exclusion of seeing the big picture.
- 12:52And in fact, that adage about missing the forest for the trees
- 12:56is a fundamental liability in academia
- 13:00and certainly in academic biomedicine.
- 13:04- And perhaps is a...
- 13:06heart and parcel to what we'll talk about today with respect to stress, perception, behavior,
- 13:12and the sort of lack of nuance, the grasping for certainties and hard lines of definitions
- 13:19and stuff and not being able to relax into looking at the whole picture and not become
- 13:23adversarial with those that you disagree with.
- 13:27But let's leave that for now.
- 13:30First point I'll say with respect to your other colleagues on the paper throughout the course of the interview. I'll refer to it as your paper.
- 13:38I mean that in the larger sense of it yours as a part of a larger team.
- 13:45And so getting into the basics, you know, the value of reductionism to some extent, I want to look
- 13:51specifically at the most kind of foundational part in this, which would be the basically
- 13:59inflammation stress in the individual. So my question here to start is, you know, what is,
- 14:06I guess, kind of a multilayered question, but like, what is inflammation?
- 14:10[BLANK_AUDIO]
- 14:10what is stress, what is linked between them, and where do these stress inflammation processes go
- 14:18right? Like where are they to the value of the individual? And then where do they go wrong?
- 14:25And keeping this at the scope of the individual for now.
- 14:29Yeah, that's put together very nicely.
- 14:32So I think most people have a basic understanding of inflammation.
- 14:38If you are stung by a mosquito, for example, and it gets hot and red, you have an inflammatory
- 14:45response right there.
- 14:46If you're stung by a bee, you have a larger inflammatory response.
- 14:50If you get a cut as it starts to heal, there's a tension in that tissue, and that's an inflammatory
- 14:56response.
- 14:57And the idea that you can have an inflammatory response to pollen or a bee sting or wound
- 15:04healing already starts to tell us, "Well, wait a minute, that doesn't sound all bad.
- 15:09Maybe the body should react to bee venom and certainly the body should react to a wound
- 15:14and do what it needs to do to heal it."
- 15:17And that's the point.
- 15:17So, inflammation is a key core function of the immune system, generating a response to
- 15:25a provocation.
- 15:27And so when we talk about inflammation, we're not making a value judgment.
- 15:32And most things with regard to human physiology are a question of appropriate equilibria and
- 15:38homeostasis.
- 15:40There is a healthy degree of inflammatory response that allows us to do a couple of critical
- 15:46things.
- 15:47First, to fend off foreign invaders.
- 15:49That would be viruses, bacteria, parasites.
- 15:52That's how we fight them with an inflammatory response.
- 15:55And so it's mediated by the immune system, although the immune system is part of a greater
- 16:01whole, that in turn is regulated by other systems in the body and we'll talk about that.
- 16:06But think of this primarily as a core function of the immune system to levy a defensive
- 16:12response.
- 16:13And then it does the same thing engaging in surveillance within.
- 16:18So not all the threats to the human body come from without.
- 16:21We can have rogue cells.
- 16:22That's what mutations cause.
- 16:24And of course, some mutations are potentially carcinogenic.
- 16:27So not all mutations have the potential to lead to cancer.
- 16:31Some do.
- 16:32For the scope of this discussion, we won't get into the exact genetic mechanisms of that, but let's just accept that some mutations can
- 16:40give a cell cancerous potential.
- 16:43Not every
- 16:45precancerous or potentially carcinogenic mutation in our body does us harm, and that too is because of inflammation.
- 16:51The immune system levies an inflammatory response and dispatches cells
- 16:56that don't look like they should and don't act like they should. So more often than not,
- 17:00If you have a healthy immune system, it's cleaning how so it's defense against what assaults us from without.
- 17:06It's surveillance within all of that is inflammation.
- 17:11It's mediated by white blood cells to be distinguished from red blood cells which carry oxygen in particular.
- 17:18And there are many different families of white blood cells.
- 17:22There are chemical compounds that serve as messengers.
- 17:25So there's crosstalk among the different families
- 17:27of white blood cells.
- 17:28That too is all part of the immune system.
- 17:30And on and on it goes, these cells are generated
- 17:33in the bone marrow.
- 17:34And I say these things only to start to give
- 17:36a very basic sense of the elaborate choreography involved
- 17:41in even talking about just one organ system in the body.
- 17:44Just one simple thing, inflammation.
- 17:47We tend often these days to talk about inflammation as a bad thing because we're over inflamed.
- 17:54And the best way for people to think about this, I think all too often, as I mentioned,
- 17:59we have a problem with nuance, so we tend to render judgments about things as if they're
- 18:04always good or always bad.
- 18:05You can't think about inflammation that way.
- 18:07If you had no inflammatory response, you wouldn't live very long.
- 18:12It's essential.
- 18:13On the other hand, if you're too inflamed all the time,
- 18:16that will degrade your body's healthy systems,
- 18:20accelerate aging, and do you all sorts of harm.
- 18:23You can think of the immune system in some ways
- 18:27as an army within, and you can think of damage
- 18:29to healthy cells as that army engages with an enemy
- 18:33as collateral damage.
- 18:35So too much aggression, you get an awful lot
- 18:37of collateral damage, you damage your healthy cells.
- 18:40and all sorts of mayhem and sews.
- 18:43So inflammation is neither good nor bad.
- 18:45Balance in this system is good.
- 18:48Inbalance is bad.
- 18:49Too little, you're vulnerable to foreign invaders
- 18:52and to rogue cells.
- 18:54Too much, and you degrade your healthy cells and tissues
- 18:57and accelerate the aging process.
- 18:59So you're looking for the sweet spot.
- 19:01You want a primed immune system that can defend you
- 19:04with inflammation when you need it, but isn't turned on and overactivated all the time. A lot of people,
- 19:11given that the ambient stresses were having this conversation,
- 19:15I would include myself among them are subject to too much unhealthy
- 19:20inflammation and we'll talk more about that.
- 19:23Then you asked about stress and then i'll talk about the interaction between the two so stress is in some ways a little bit more abstruse and harder to define is the kind of thing where you know it when you feel it.
- 19:35But basically for scientific purposes we talk about stress as any sort of provocation.
- 19:43that is a harsh stimulus on the system,
- 19:48the system being our bodies, our minds, our perception.
- 19:53And not all stress is bad either.
- 19:54We actually differentiate between you stress
- 19:58where you're stressing something in a way
- 20:00that actually makes it stronger.
- 20:01The most obvious example there would be lifting weights
- 20:03to build muscle.
- 20:04you're actually degrading muscle tissue when you stress it with heavy weights,
- 20:10but then it rebuilds in the aftermath of that stress and comes back better, stronger, faster.
- 20:15So stress can be a good thing, and of course the same can be true for mental stress.
- 20:20You can stress yourself and habituate to it so you have a greater tolerance
- 20:24so that you can work through distraction.
- 20:26There are all sorts of potential advantages of overcoming stress.
- 20:31And when you use stress to build,
- 20:33It's largely you stress when stress is deconstructive rather than constructive. It's distress
- 20:40So what really talking about here is distress as a problem
- 20:44So not all inflammation is bad not all inflammation is good. Not all stress is bad not all stress is good stress
- 20:52Evokes primitive responses in our body
- 20:55because basically those provocations I'm talking about if you transplant them to a primitive world and we talk about this in the paper.
- 21:03They would look like a predator coming at you or the threat of starvation so we can play out over span of perhaps days or it can play out over the span of seconds.
- 21:15In a primitive world where we're living naturally.
- 21:18There are probably no stresses that play out over years.
- 21:22It's all compressed.
- 21:23We live in a very different world today, and of course we get into that in the paper too,
- 21:27and it's a big part of this conversation.
- 21:30So what should happen if you are motivated to find food or water and are struggling to
- 21:37do it?
- 21:38what should happen if...
- 21:40In your peripheral vision you catch the fast movement of a predator coming at you
- 21:45Well, you need a a brisk response in the case of finding food and water or shelter
- 21:51You need stamina. You need to be focused. You need to be strong. You need to be
- 21:56persistent you need to have endurance you need to keep going because your life is on the line it's playing out over hours and days.
- 22:03So that stress basically should contribute to all of those factors enhancing cardiovascular strength and stamina by increasing blood flow.
- 22:15directing critical nutrients to muscles, enhancing your ability to access oxygen, and all the more so.
- 22:22So think of that as sort of the slow twitch response to stress, which is stimulating your adrenal glands and other organ systems.
- 22:30And then there's the fast twitch response, where a predator is coming at you and you need to fight or you need to flee and you need to do it pretty much instantaneously.
- 22:39That's really what stress is for.
- 22:41And James, I know in your work,
- 22:43you're very focused on psychedelics.
- 22:45And it's interesting just to digress for a minute
- 22:47and note when we think about drugs
- 22:50and the effects they have,
- 22:51obviously the human body did not build pathways
- 22:55to respond to specific compounds it had never seen.
- 22:59It's just that in certain instances,
- 23:00those compounds interact with systems and pathways
- 23:04in the body that serve some fundamental purpose.
- 23:07And so the same is true with factors that stress us.
- 23:12We basically have aspects of our nervous system that support survival.
- 23:17If someone gets away from a predator and someone else doesn't,
- 23:21it's the person who gets away from the predator who lives.
- 23:24to pass on their genes so essentially genes reward the ability to get away from the predator if someone
- 23:30persists long enough to find essential food and water and shelter and someone else doesn't it's the
- 23:35person who does who makes the much better ancestor there's people who don't live long enough to make
- 23:40babies make very poor ancestors so we're really talking about survival traits and so things that
- 23:47stress us trigger these pathways.
- 23:50that were laid down by evolutionary biology to favor our survival.
- 23:55So stronger, faster, brisk responses.
- 24:00But they obviously have implications for the immune system,
- 24:04which is triggered by this and affected by blood flow and
- 24:07affected by circulation and affected by hormonal stimuli and
- 24:11all these different pathways interrelate.
- 24:13So,
- 24:14In a nutshell stress is provocation. It can be use stress. It can be dress distress
- 24:21Inflammation is the immune system reacting to a provocation
- 24:24It can be constructive or it can be destructive and then the two interrelate because chronic stress
- 24:31stimulates the immune system producing chronic inflammation
- 24:35Which is much less constructive than the immediate primitive
- 24:40Response to a provocation for which the immune system is really designed. I'm not going anywhere
- 24:46But I am getting up for a second because I have a pesky dog at the door. Okay
- 24:49[BLANK_AUDIO]
- 24:56And there's apt to be another soon. Definitely they're part of my de-stress mechanism. I
- 25:03tend to spend as much time as possible with dogs and horses.
- 25:08Yes, animals. Our relationship with the non-human world as an essential, I think, as in we
- 25:15needed and without it we suffer is an important aspect of our health that I don't think is
- 25:21regularly talked about. Although you could comment on that, but we could also move on.
- 25:25You know, it's interesting. We didn't really get into that in the paper, but it is relevant because we had those relationships in
- 25:31primitive times. I mean, certainly our relationship with dogs and before them wolves goes back a very long time and
- 25:39And
- 25:40we probably need it more now than ever our ancestors did they needed that relationship for hunting and survival but i doubt it was a big factor in their mental health because the world.
- 25:51Was fairly simple and in tune with our native adaptations we live in a world that's totally out of sync with our native adaptations.
- 26:00And the purity of emotion in those relationships with other species, the way it grounds you
- 26:08and takes you into the realm of honesty and pure devotion and faithfulness.
- 26:16Yeah, I find it extremely therapeutic.
- 26:18So again, as much time as I can with my dogs and my horses.
- 26:24So, going back to what you're saying about this interaction between the neither positive
- 26:32nor negative necessarily between inflammation and stress, what I read in your paper is that
- 26:39the way that we have our...
- 26:40And I don't want to spend too much more time on this, but I think it's important for people
- 26:43is that
- 26:44One of the things that is interesting about our inflammatory response is that we are very quick to launch an inflammatory response, but there's a long tail for resolving it.
- 26:55And so if, for example, stressors can stimulate distress in a system in a way that doesn't resolve the stressors,
- 27:05external or internal. Don't resolve, then there isn't an opportunity for the inflammation to
- 27:10resolve. Is this what you mean by things can become, we could be in chronic inflammation? Because
- 27:16there's no break from the stressor and thus the stress response that would allow inflammation to
- 27:22finish its process and come back to a non-inflammatory homeostasis?
- 27:28those are all very astute observations change but i would say it's not so much
- 27:34a long tail as the failure of the provocation to abate so example think
- 27:41about those times you're driving you get that sudden flash of red and blue
- 27:47in your rearview mirror
- 27:49you feel your adrenal gland respond to that.
- 27:51That's a response.
- 27:53It's just, you know, and there are other things that do it.
- 27:55Anytime you're severely startled,
- 27:58you feel that tingle in your adrenal glands.
- 28:00You can almost locate them anatomically.
- 28:02You feel it begin in your flanks.
- 28:03And the adrenals sit on top of the kidney.
- 28:06So it's actually in your, the lower back out to the side.
- 28:12And you feel it there.
- 28:14And then it radiates through your body.
- 28:16And it's almost like an electrical charge.
- 28:18But if it's a siren or if it's a sudden startle, the tail isn't all that long.
- 28:25There was a provocation, you feel instantaneously that your body is supercharged.
- 28:32And it's not necessarily a good feeling, because there's often nothing to do with it.
- 28:38And you have to contain it and that that's frustrating
- 28:40But if you had to fight or if you had to flee it would be just the thing. It's just what you need
- 28:46So it's it's it's the right response for the wrong circumstance
- 28:49But then if it was a sudden startle sudden provocation that goes away
- 28:54You actually feel that adrenal stimulus mediated by catacolamines epinephrine nor epinephrine
- 29:02the fight or flight hormones and then others cortisol that they get into the act but principally that immediate surge is
- 29:10it's adrenaline, it's epinephrine.
- 29:12But you feel it dissipate.
- 29:13You actually, you know, it's almost like going up to a peak, you know, where there's a sudden neurological discharge.
- 29:19You feel that peak.
- 29:21You're supercharged and then you come down and yeah, you know the descent is slow relative to the ascent
- 29:27The ascent is instantaneous that you feel it release and it's like throwing a light switch
- 29:33But then it dissipates pretty quickly. We're talking about minutes
- 29:36Assuming the provocation goes away the problem with chronic inflammation
- 29:41And and this of course is the reason we wrote the paper is that we think chronic inflammation abounds
- 29:47is that the provocation is
- 29:51abstruse, that the the provocation is
- 29:55lives in your mind and
- 29:57doesn't go away. So you think about
- 30:01stresses of finance, for example, or politics or
- 30:06what we all went through during the pandemic and you know just sort of you
- 30:09know worrying about the future and all the things all of us worry about all the
- 30:13time. You ruminate on those things. They take root in your mind it's not a
- 30:20sudden provocation so periodically something will happen that that's a
- 30:26trigger.
- 30:27the stock market will tank and all of a sudden you're more concerned about your finances for instance.
- 30:32Very germane at the time we're having this conversation.
- 30:36So, but you know on any given day it's any given thing but then if that thing.
- 30:41Doesn't go away completely it's not like the siren that came or went it's not like the startle that came or went it's real.
- 30:48In your mind that it's there is there's something to be concerned about that doesn't fully subside.
- 30:55Well, then neither does the inflammatory response.
- 30:58So, essentially, you don't get that sudden release of norepinephrine and then an abatement.
- 31:04You get a constant lower-level push on your adrenal gland.
- 31:11Still stressed, still stressed, still stressed.
- 31:14That's not normal in the sense of our native adaptations.
- 31:19And it leads to dysregulation in all the other organ systems.
- 31:24It affects the cardiovascular system.
- 31:26It potentially affects the microbiome, which is best thought of as an organ system in its own right, a critical part of who and what we are.
- 31:34most indelibly it affects the nervous system, the immune system,
- 31:39and those two interact very extensively.
- 31:42Some of the very same hormones that influence inflammatory responses function as neurotransmitters in the brain,
- 31:50even catecholamine hormones.
- 31:51So that sudden response to a stress,
- 31:55That actually is part of what regulates brain activity, nor epinephrine is not just a hormone and it's not just about fight or flight.
- 32:03It's a neurotransmitter as well.
- 32:05And again, I know these things along the way just because this is, you know, if you will, mini med school, right?
- 32:10It took us years to learn how all these things fit together.
- 32:13It's extraordinary.
- 32:15The more you understand about the human body's choreography,
- 32:19How everything fits together with everything else it's a wonder that any of us ever makes it through a day fully intact how many things need to go right how much cross talk there needs to be and how much understanding of one organ system by another organ system.
- 32:34It's really quite extraordinary but that.
- 32:37chronic provocation that never fully subsides because it just takes root in the back of your mind and periodically moves to the front of your mind but it never goes away completely that predator that chased you.
- 32:50If you got away and predators off another Aaron hunting something else now you know there's still a predator out there.
- 32:56There are the predators out there.
- 32:57So, I suspect we were always subject to some level of low-level worry, low-level anxiety,
- 33:04and perhaps low-level inflammation in response to it.
- 33:07It's unlikely that our Stone Age ancestors had completely worry-free days even when they
- 33:12weren't running from something because they knew they might find themselves running from
- 33:16something.
- 33:17But on the other hand it was much more a matter of acute provocation relief of that provocation and return to a baseline for which we are adapted.
- 33:27I don't think in a world of stock markets and taxes and geopolitics and climate change and everything else we could throw onto the heat.
- 33:36I don't think we ever get to a healthy baseline or at least we have to really struggle to get there and consequently
- 33:43we have chronic inflammation in response to all of that.
- 33:45Hmm. And...
- 33:48And we're gonna explore that a little bit more because you had... you did say, well two things.
- 33:52You talked about the brain. I'm gonna ask you about that in a second.
- 33:54And you said that the stressors are... they're in our mind.
- 33:57And then you said take root in our mind because they are in our mind and what we'll get to in the interview here,
- 34:02what you talk about in our papers, it's...
- 34:03It's also not just in our mind, although the stock market might be an invention of the human mind
- 34:11that kind of in some respect other than literal physical buildings exists entirely through
- 34:18constructs in our mind and in our relational dynamics is a very real thing external to us that
- 34:23has an effect that can be
- 34:25a stressor and often is. But before we get there, I want to go a little bit more into
- 34:31the brain because I want to use that as a stepping point to talk about how stress and
- 34:36inflammation is going to spread out beyond the individual, but still staying with the individual
- 34:43other than the response of catecholamine, dopamine, norepinephrine, etc.
- 34:51Where does the brain fit into all this? And I mean this with respect both to the brain's role
- 34:57in inflammation regulation, but also with respect to inflammation's effect on our thought and
- 35:05behavior through its effect on our brain.
- 35:10So, two separate questions really and two separate answers.
- 35:17So first, what is it the brain should do to regulate the system, this response?
- 35:23So let's think of the brain first as the master regulator of our responses.
- 35:31That's really what the paper is about.
- 35:33So that's where we needed a mathematician and you could think about being trained and
- 35:39coached and schooled in ways to manage and mitigate stress so that the provocations are
- 35:46out there in the world but the way you respond to them is cultivated and honed and productive.
- 35:53So essentially you would be training your brain or mind to be a better regulator and
- 36:02to dampen down, to filter stress and determine what is constructive, what is destructive
- 36:07responses.
- 36:09And with that filter operating at a high level, you would literally filter out some of the
- 36:16provocation and prevent it from triggering the immune system.
- 36:21So the psychological response to stress.
- 36:25Is a direct factor in the immune system response distress and psychological response comes first
- 36:32So if the very same thing happens to you and me and I get wildly upset about it and you stay calm
- 36:39Even though we both experienced the exact same provocation. I'm going to have more inflammation than you are
- 36:45because my brain didn't filter it as effectively, right?
- 36:48So we can train the mind to be the master regulator.
- 36:51And that's where our colleague,
- 36:53Julie Arcearo came in helping us to build
- 36:55this mathematical model.
- 36:57Okay, so let's think about all the stresses in the world
- 37:01that we routinely encounter.
- 37:03They're not gonna go away anytime soon.
- 37:05What can we do about this?
- 37:07Well, let's think about if we had better suppression.
- 37:11Of the response to those dresses and then what stress does to the brain looking at it from the other direction.
- 37:22Is essentially it invites a reaction right so if we go back to the primal origins of all this.
- 37:28And we go back to the primitive role of catecholamine hormones and other hormones and neurotransmitters
- 37:36that are all configured into the stress response in a primal world where the particular concern
- 37:42was predators and starvation and such.
- 37:45You're supposed to do something when you're provoked.
- 37:48You're supposed to climb the hill to find the plant or find the animal that you need to eat.
- 37:55You're supposed to soldier on to get to water when your weary muscles are saying stop.
- 38:00You're supposed to fight, you're supposed to flee.
- 38:03So essentially the provocations, whatever they are,
- 38:08are urging our brain to do something fairly urgently and sometimes dramatically.
- 38:19Fighting, for example, I would consider a dramatic expression of a stress response,
- 38:23but it's a totally logical one in primitive context.
- 38:27But what if that's not the right response? What do you do with that?
- 38:31You contain it and so you see it, you cultivate resentment.
- 38:37Let's just for a moment reflect on you feel an intense urge to react and there's no obvious productive reaction.
- 38:46To the thing that just provoked you to the argument you had to the unpleasant interaction you had at work to difficult situation with a member of your family to the person who cut you off on the highway right.
- 39:04What is road rage? It's a primitive response. It's this person threatened me.
- 39:12It's the absence of that cognitive filter that says, you know, may have been intentional, may not have been intentional,
- 39:19whether intentional or unintentional, escalating this is not going to be good for anybody.
- 39:24I'm not going there. Well, every day, hundreds of times, probably thousands of times across the country, people do go there.
- 39:31Why? Primitive stress response.
- 39:35So essentially what stress does to the brain is invite it to go primitive.
- 39:39And push the response. And there's even talk in neuroscience about the different
- 39:43layers of the brain, the reptilian brain. As you move closer to the brainstem
- 39:47you're actually getting to the more ancient parts of the brain.
- 39:50You go further back in evolutionary biology all the parts of the brain that we have in particular the prefrontal cortex which helps us understand
- 39:59consequences and implications and
- 40:02Anticipate where our behaviors will take us into the future that didn't exist
- 40:07So stress pushes you back toward the reptilian primitive brain where it's all about fight or flight
- 40:14And that's highly problematic.
- 40:16So one of the issues we wrestle with in the paper is,
- 40:20how do we tip that balance?
- 40:21How do we protect the brain
- 40:24from the provocation that undoes it?
- 40:27So we engage in dysfunctional responses.
- 40:29And sadly, the answer is currently,
- 40:32"We all too often fail to do that."
- 40:34And so there is an escalating dysfunction
- 40:37and we'll talk about that.
- 40:38And how do we empower the brain, train the brain and mind to be a better filter so that we don't let stress take us back into our most primitive cells?
- 40:52Being a primitive person in a primitive world is perfectly reasonable.
- 40:56You've got saber-toothed cats to worry about, you know, fight or flight is just right
- 41:02But when you're on a highway
- 41:04It's almost never right when you have an unpleasant exchange with a co-worker. It's almost never right. So I
- 41:11Think we should be fully conscious of and this James takes us back to your earlier observation about
- 41:18The big picture and holism if we understand ourselves in context, what kind of animal are we?
- 41:25Where did we come from? What are we adapted for? Well, we're social animals. We need one another
- 41:31We need to understand one another
- 41:34there has to be some level of trust and and and
- 41:37Respect and civility for social animals to function. We need common cause on common ground
- 41:45But then we are adapted to defend ourselves against
- 41:48Provocations many of which in a primitive primitive world are potentially life-threatening
- 41:54How do we deal with all of that in a modern world of our own devising that is far removed from everything we're adapted to?
- 42:03It's a real challenge for sure.
- 42:05Yeah, definitely.
- 42:06I want to see if I can just summarize what you just said somewhat, you know, simply so we can move on to like how this spreads between people is that
- 42:15The effect that the brain can have on stress is kind of psychological. It's how we navigate,
- 42:21filter the stressor such that we can appropriately respond to that stressor to calm the nervous
- 42:28system down either by being like, "That's actually not relevant, so we can calm down,"
- 42:34or, "That is relevant. I need to take action towards it so that I can resolve it," and thus
- 42:38calm the stressor response down.
- 42:40And then there's the other way, which is the stress.
- 42:43Does something to the brain that triggers the need
- 42:46for response in some way.
- 42:49In the acute situation you're talking about,
- 42:51okay, Cybertooth cat, okay, I need to respond
- 42:54to this situation or I saw something, analyze, okay,
- 42:58actually I'm recognizing, I just thought it was a thing,
- 43:01but it's not there, I'm calming myself down.
- 43:03So I don't unnecessarily respond.
- 43:05So this is the both sort of like sides of this.
- 43:08So what you're saying is that stress source can cause changes, they can manipulate the
- 43:17way, like manipulate our thought and behavior through its activation of the brain's inflammatory
- 43:23and stress response.
- 43:25And in a acute situation, it can help us mobilize towards resolving the stressor.
- 43:32But in a chronic situation, it can just cause low-level perpetual distortion of our thought
- 43:40and behavior in ways that can be used to help us.
- 43:43not do well for us in a modern society, in their modern civilization, because they're
- 43:50sort of perpetually somewhat or increasingly more or less primitive responses rather than
- 43:57[BLANK_AUDIO]
- 43:58may lack a better terminology, like evolved responses to the situation. So in this way,
- 44:04stress and inflammation can manipulate thoughts and behaviors in ways that can actually have
- 44:10detrimental effects on ourselves and on our world rather than having the sort of positive
- 44:17effects of helping us resolve or regulate to whatever that stressor is. Is that about right?
- 44:24Yes, all reasonable, all well said.
- 44:27The only thing I throw into the mix, you're talking about the brain, the mind, and so
- 44:34am I, and we should not convey to those listening that it is a monolithic thing.
- 44:40So yes, these responses are intrinsic.
- 44:43But as noted, you and I may...
- 44:46react to the same provocation very differently. So inter-individual variation in that response was always important.
- 44:54Is all the more important today? Even if we go back to primitive context, right? If there's a saber-toothed cat and you and I are both reacting to it,
- 45:03and you are provoked, but in a constructive way, and I completely panic.
- 45:10You know i'm the one more likely to run into something and trip over it and become lunch right so even then the mind acting as a filter so there's an interpretive lens says what is the provocation how do i most constructively.
- 45:26address this provocation that was always important that much more so now when the nature of the stress.
- 45:33Is less clearly linked to an obvious response right we have to deal with subtleties like conflict resolution and you know we have to essentially do judo.
- 45:44with our native inclinations.
- 45:46If our native inclinations are fight or flee
- 45:48and neither of those is the right thing to do,
- 45:51say, okay, how do I translate the fight or flight response
- 45:54into something that is constructive here?
- 45:57For instance, a dialogue where we actually try
- 46:00to understand one another and come
- 46:03to some comfortable resolution
- 46:05'cause we're starting out in conflict
- 46:07and we don't wanna stay there.
- 46:09And I neither want to react in a dysfunctional way
- 46:11nor just see the,
- 46:12So what can I do with the response to this provocation that's constructive?
- 46:18So, so it's not just the brain. It's the individual. The individuals
- 46:25preconditioning is a huge part of this equation as well.
- 46:29And I don't want to I want to move on from the brain here pretty pretty much right away
- 46:34But there's one thing I want to just like get clarification on or have you you know quickly give us the breakdown on which is that?
- 46:41the brain itself, from what I understand, can become a driver of inflammation as a consequence of the brain being damaged or made dysfunctional through chronic inflammation or through some sort of
- 46:59something that managed it. For example, I have previously had a head injury and I experienced
- 47:06lots of what I assumed to be the damage on or the dysfunction of my thought and behavior as a
- 47:14consequence, not of an external stressor per se, but as a consequence of inflammatory responses in
- 47:20my brain. My brain is being on fire all the time as it responded to this event.
- 47:25And so it is also possible that the brain itself can become a driver of inflammation.
- 47:30Is that correct?
- 47:31It is.
- 47:32There's actually just a few quick remarks and then we can pivot.
- 47:34But a recent study actually looking at the mechanisms of sleep linked to brain health,
- 47:42showing that there's a lymphatic system in the brain, particularly active during sleep,
- 47:48that clears toxins from the brain.
- 47:50So even just as simple as impaired sleep.
- 47:53greater accumulation of toxic metabolites in the brain, the failure to clear those out, brain dysfunction associated with increased inflammation, just there.
- 48:03But then, as you say, injury to the brain, and that can be...
- 48:10something purely psychological, it could be organic.
- 48:15They're really, we're talking about brain and mind.
- 48:17I think we should probably just say, you know, they're essentially the same thing.
- 48:21One is a manifestation of the other.
- 48:23But think of something like PTSD, right?
- 48:25So there was a trauma, post-traumatic stress disorder.
- 48:30And the trauma could be any one of a number of things.
- 48:33Probably most widely known would be exposure to war among combat veterans.
- 48:39And then post-traumatic stress disorder is a brain disorder and a mind disorder.
- 48:46And it does all sorts of terrible things to all of the organ systems in the body and leads to physical ailments because the brain is the source of the inflammation, the bad inflammation, the excessive inflammation.
- 49:00The constant stress reverberating throughout the entire endocrine system, the system of hormones in the body.
- 49:05all of that equilibrium is thrown off because of a malady that if you will originates in the brain so absolutely the brain is
- 49:16the critical filter regulator we need but it can be the primary source of the problem.
- 49:22And in those kinds of scenarios, we get stuck in a particular sort of response loop,
- 49:28which can instead of moving us towards the restful sleep that resolves,
- 49:32you know, that activates the glum fatic system, and we can sort of like squeeze and release
- 49:36our little brain vesicles and get that fluid in and out of there. And that doesn't happen.
- 49:41And what happens is just like progressive,
- 49:44compromising of the systems that would otherwise regulate or control our inflammatory response.
- 49:50Exactly.
- 49:50And it can progress over time.
- 49:52You know, thinking, I'm giving a webinar later this week on sleep and nutrition and
- 49:59the interactions there.
- 50:01And in that talk, I'll be showing slides that look at the cascade.
- 50:06So essentially the ways that stress
- 50:08can compromise sleep, poor sleep can reduce our tolerance for stress, stress and poor sleep.
- 50:15Gang up on the brain and the nervous system, increase the inflammatory response,
- 50:20the inflammation leads to increased risk for chronic disease, disrupts appetite-regulating
- 50:25hormones, makes us more likely to eat bad food, which further compromises neurotransmitter levels.
- 50:30you get the idea to degenerating spiral right it's the classic case of going down the drain.
- 50:35The good news and it's important to append the good news quickly here.
- 50:40Is that you can reverse engineer that and think of it in just the opposite way so if I become a bit better at at mitigating and managing
- 50:47stressful provocations in my life.
- 50:50I can sleep more restfully I can better detoxify my brain making me even better at handling stress the next day.
- 50:57which will increase my energy, allow me to be more physically active,
- 51:03shield my healthy cells and organ systems from the onslaught of inflammation,
- 51:09make me a bit more robust,
- 51:11maybe making it easier for me to make healthy food choices
- 51:15because my appetite hormones are not out of balance.
- 51:18which will improve the quality of my sleep, which will further improve the quality of my stress
- 51:22tolerance and round and round we go. So one direction this cascade leads is down the drain.
- 51:27The other direction the very same cascade can lead is up a spiral staircase to the best version of
- 51:32your vitality at the top. And obviously as a specialist in internal medicine, lifestyle medicine,
- 51:39and preventive medicine, that's what I've been trying to do my whole career is help people climb
- 51:43that spiral stair.
- 51:45I want to ask you specifically about intervention for the individual a little bit later on.
- 51:52I imagine for listeners, you know, they've probably already got a sense of what the
- 51:58general answer to this next question is.
- 52:00We've been talking about, you know, behavior and how stress and inflammation influences
- 52:04behavior.
- 52:05And we've also been using examples of, like,
- 52:07the behaviors of other people as a potential stressor that would activate an internal stress inflammation response.
- 52:17But I'd like you to talk a little bit more about how it is
- 52:22that
- 52:23inflammation can spread between people because this is one of the sort of central
- 52:27arguments you're making in the paper is that this stress inflammation process is not contained
- 52:33into the individual and because of that it's not an individual issue. It is something that
- 52:39can spread between people. How does it spread between people?
- 52:44Yeah, actually how does it spread between people? Yeah, so so there's a lot there and and I'll state the case pretty succinctly
- 52:53We've recently discovered there there've been
- 52:56Many papers published on this topic that what we used to think of as non
- 53:00Communicable diseases like for example obesity and diabetes are indeed communicable
- 53:04They run in social networks because behaviors do
- 53:07people behave the way the people around them behave,
- 53:11we all influence one another.
- 53:13And we influence one another with our reactions
- 53:15to provocations.
- 53:16So we take the simple example of road rage.
- 53:19Let's say that you're a very reasonable person
- 53:22and you have pretty reasonable stress tolerance.
- 53:25And let's just say somebody else is having a particularly
- 53:28bad day and they're in a rush and they're being rude
- 53:32and they cut you off.
- 53:34They do something unpleasant on the highway.
- 53:39And you're provoked.
- 53:41And maybe it doesn't quite rise to the threshold where you do something dysfunctional.
- 53:47But what if you are a reasonable person who's also having a bad day?
- 53:52You're subject to chronic stress and you're worried about friends and family and job and
- 53:57money and all the stuff that stresses everybody out all the time.
- 54:01And so you're tolerant and maybe you slept poorly the night before and we can talk about all the reasons you ate poorly
- 54:09You didn't exercise you're not that that vortex you're talking about exactly you're caught up
- 54:14And maybe not in a way where anything bad would have happened absent a provocation, but but your threshold for tolerating
- 54:23A stressful provocation is lower than it ought to be.
- 54:28Fight with your spouse, a bad night's sleep, the usual stuff.
- 54:32You're just a human.
- 54:34A perfectly reasonable human, but not at your best and most tolerant.
- 54:40And then somebody does something.
- 54:42that is a fairly significant provocation.
- 54:46In fact, you get that response
- 54:47where you feel your adrenals tingle
- 54:50because something happens while you're driving your car
- 54:52that you know could have been lethal,
- 54:54but for your quick response.
- 54:55And then suddenly you're seething
- 54:57with fight or flight hormones.
- 54:59Now your brain, if it were in a good state,
- 55:02if it were well rested and detoxified,
- 55:04would step in here and down regulate this response.
- 55:07But what if it's not?
- 55:08Well essentially you just had the transmission of somebody else's.
- 55:14Badly handled stress response so that person's in a rush and they're stressed out that's why they're behaving badly behind the wheel in the first place.
- 55:22It just was transmitted to you and now everything comes down to your stress response which may be impaired.
- 55:29Now, if the two of you engage, and now we've got a road rage incident going on, others may
- 55:35get involved because the way you're driving irresponsibly is going to start to affect
- 55:40any other vehicles in the mix.
- 55:42And we all know what kind of mayhem can result from this.
- 55:45And that's just one example.
- 55:47Well, another example might be that, you know, say I'm that person who got all stressed
- 55:52out because somebody cut me off or whatever.
- 55:55I might not realize it, but then on my way home, I have to stop at the store or something,
- 56:01and I don't realize that I'm just acting kind of shitty, so that impacts the person who
- 56:05checked me out at the till, or maybe I get home, and I argue with my partner and I don't
- 56:10our child is there, so now they're being impacted by the buffeted of the stress between my partner
- 56:11know what to do.
- 56:16and arguing, and it actually was me just being triggered by something because I'm stressed by
- 56:21something else. I completely agree and absolutely, and I was going to take it up a notch. We live
- 56:27in the age of interconnectivity.
- 56:29So you take it to the internet. So, you know, all these negative feelings
- 56:35We have a massive megaphone all of us do and and so, you know, there's been a lot of talk about the effects of
- 56:41Social media on mental health. This is a huge part of it. So we can we can inflame
- 56:46Multitudes with our own inflammation. So this is highly transmissible. So, you know, essentially we take this
- 56:55This tendency to see then we express it on social media platforms and we're less tolerant of what others may say we spout things that are
- 57:05emanating from frustration from resentment from
- 57:10Anger and you know all of these emotions that if you think about it have something to do
- 57:16With handling acute provocations in the world, but that's not what's going on here. We can't
- 57:20react to these acute provocations.
- 57:22We don't know how to react to these acute provocations.
- 57:25There is no good response.
- 57:26It's not like running away from a predator
- 57:28and saying, yes, I made it.
- 57:29I live to fight another day.
- 57:32There's none of that.
- 57:32There's a lack of clarity.
- 57:34So it just festers and ferments.
- 57:36So we look for ways to express it.
- 57:39And we all have ways of expressing it to large numbers.
- 57:44And you can, I think without too much difficulty,
- 57:49translate this all the way up to the level of geopolitics.
- 57:54Let's pause for a second here. I want to make a quick comment, and I think this is a really important factor in what you're saying with,
- 58:00"We go on to the internet, and that's a way that we could respond."
- 58:06Like, "I'm angry. Here's my whatever."
- 58:09The complication in that is that the places that we do that are platforms that are profit-driven,
- 58:18and we're, in some respect, we are the product in these profit-driven networks.
- 58:23And part of what those networks do to profit is to keep people on the platform as much as possible,
- 58:30and they've designed algorithms to see what content has people most engaged on the platform.
- 58:35one of the styles of those content is angry outrage because if you're triggered, you engage.
- 58:43It's driving engagement. So these types of things end up getting pushed to the front of
- 58:48people's feeds and then people are being validated and reinforced.
- 58:52good job for being angry and shitty and then somebody else gets validated because they responded and we get this loop where it's not only spreading now and being pushed by algorithms to more people were also getting rewarded for the spreading of this stress contagion.
- 59:09Yeah, I just want to react by saying how easy it is to engage in that.
- 59:14that particular cascade and why it happens.
- 59:17So think about the difficulty we all have
- 59:19in looking away from a car wreck.
- 59:22- Oh yeah.
- 59:23- What's going on?
- 59:24I mean, why does traffic get backed up
- 59:26on the side of the highway where there isn't the crash
- 59:28because of rubbernecking?
- 59:29You know, you could be stuck for hours
- 59:32only to learn that the problem was on the other side
- 59:34of a divided highway.
- 59:36Why do humans behave that way?
- 59:37Well, again, adaptation, evolutionary biology,
- 59:40primitive impulses.
- 59:42it's that sudden disruption in your normal environment that most requires your attention.
- 59:50And this, by the way, is trans species. There are many other species that have the same tendency.
- 59:54If something has changed in their environment, that's where their attention is drawn.
- 1:00:01So it's a native tendency to have our attention directed there.
- 1:00:06And it's easily exploited.
- 1:00:09And obviously the people who control social media platforms
- 1:00:15have a great deal of expertise in capturing our attention and commandeering it.
- 1:00:21But we shouldn't be too harsh with ourselves as we think about our vulnerability to this.
- 1:00:25It's hardwired into us.
- 1:00:27It all does make sense.
- 1:00:28But absolutely, the more extreme position is going to be more captivating than a, well,
- 1:00:36I think it might be, and I think it might not be.
- 1:00:39It's interesting just for a second to digress.
- 1:00:41Bertrand Russell famously said that the whole thing wrong with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so sure and
- 1:00:49Wiser people so full of doubts if you're wise and if you're knowledgeable
- 1:00:53You know what you don't know and you're almost never a hundred percent certain of anything
- 1:00:57Good scientists are rarely a hundred percent certain of anything, but that's why the public flock to
- 1:01:03con artists who are absolutely sure and make them all sorts of promises.
- 1:01:09So in every domain, the extreme provocation, the titillating thing,
- 1:01:16effectively captures our attention.
- 1:01:17And then we engage, and then there's all sorts of psychological research
- 1:01:21showing how we push one another to more extreme.
- 1:01:24So this is part of it too. There's a good book.
- 1:01:26by Thaler and Sunstein going to extremes, looking at religious radicalization and political radicalization,
- 1:01:34but it extends to our daily lives.
- 1:01:37So, you know, I'm kind of angry about a particular thing and I opine about it on social media.
- 1:01:42Who's going to react to that?
- 1:01:44Well, maybe somebody who thinks I'm getting carried away, but most likely somebody who agrees with me,
- 1:01:49is going to give me a cyberspatial pat on the back.
- 1:01:54And now i feel vindicated and validated and so whatever ambivalence i had about my own reaction you know maybe i'm getting carried away but i really feel that blank.
- 1:02:04As my fists clench and now somebody tells me yeah you're so right and it happened to me and i was so pissed and well now you know i feel it more strongly some of that ambivalence is shaved away.
- 1:02:15So now I express it more strongly and now somebody who even has a more radical view of the same issue than the two of us chimes in
- 1:02:22We radicalize one another
- 1:02:25Well, this this is contagious inflammation. This is social
- 1:02:29inflammation and if we are members of a group or a tribe or a clan all moving in one particular direction with our
- 1:02:37Emotion feeding off of one another
- 1:02:39there is apt to be a countervailing clan
- 1:02:42that's expressing just the opposite point of view
- 1:02:44and doing exactly the same.
- 1:02:46So whatever hope we had of meeting in the middle
- 1:02:49is rapidly dissipating as we gravitate
- 1:02:52in one direction becoming ever more extreme
- 1:02:54in our shared view and the other group gravitates
- 1:02:57in the opposite direction becoming ever more extreme
- 1:02:59in their shared view.
- 1:03:00And the next thing you know,
- 1:03:02We're at war with one another and I mean that either literally or figuratively
- 1:03:07It can be among individuals. It can be arguments in cyberspace where it can be the real deal
- 1:03:13But it's the same basic process every time
- 1:03:15Let's take a little break here from the interview as we do and I want to give a big thanks to my patrons on
- 1:03:22Patreon especially the people whose names are listed on the screen here on YouTube
- 1:03:26These individuals, the people on the screen, as well as my patrons as a whole, you listening, maybe one of them, you make this podcast possible.
- 1:03:35Not only do you make this podcast possible, but actually this is my full-time job.
- 1:03:41This is what I spent the last 10 years plus of my life investing into my ability to do so.
- 1:03:48on the very basis that I believed in a kind of
- 1:03:53non-extractive
- 1:03:55reciprocal generosity carrying an appreciation
- 1:03:59dynamic for funding my life, for funding my
- 1:04:05well-being, for
- 1:04:06basically earning an income and building a career around.
- 1:04:11And you patrons on Patreon, you make that possible.
- 1:04:14You make that dream come alive every single day.
- 1:04:17And I really, really appreciate that.
- 1:04:19Thank you very much.
- 1:04:21If you're listening, find value in this show.
- 1:04:22I'm sure you've heard me talk about it before.
- 1:04:24If you've been here before or you've heard it elsewhere on different podcasts,
- 1:04:28If you're finding value in the show, please do consider contributing financially to the costs, the expenses that go into producing the show hard and soft, time, literal financial resources, equipment hard and soft, all the rest.
- 1:04:43Of course, if it's not in you, if you don't got that,
- 1:04:46Don't worry about it. Just enjoy the podcast. Many of us are struggling right now in the larger economic field of the world
- 1:04:52So just enjoy the podcast if you do got something you're willing to offer
- 1:04:56Send me a tip even just one time tip of the hat
- 1:04:59tip of the coin
- 1:05:02Would appreciate it. You can do so via links in the description patreon if you want to
- 1:05:07Be more regular or just follow me for free on there sort of try to cut away from the algorithm
- 1:05:13or PayPal, cryptocurrency, Co-Fi,
- 1:05:16if you wanna leave a one-time donation.
- 1:05:18Again, all of that goes a long way,
- 1:05:20even if it's just a small amount,
- 1:05:21and I really do appreciate it.
- 1:05:25And we'll call that the little thank you
- 1:05:29and request, hat out for this episode
- 1:05:34and we'll get back to our interview
- 1:05:35with Dr. David Katz right now.
- 1:05:38So, with respect to the constraint time, I'm going to try to change some of the things
- 1:05:47I'm going to ask and then invite you to be as somewhat, without feeling rushed, concise
- 1:05:52as possible on the question so I could try to fit the sort of most and what I think are
- 1:05:56the most important ones.
- 1:06:00Yeah, so talking about, you know, first off, this not being too hard on ourselves,
- 1:06:06one of the things I've heard a sort of a thinker on this, Tristan Harris say is that it doesn't
- 1:06:12make sense to think about it in the sense that these algorithms or these platforms are trying to
- 1:06:16defeat the best of us, but they're designed to sort of hijack
- 1:06:20hijack our weaknesses rather than fight our strengths. And I once made a video where I talked
- 1:06:26about being addicted to social media, and I used the metaphor of being upset with myself that I
- 1:06:34lost a fight to Mike Tyson. And yeah.
- 1:06:36the whole Mike Tyson and Jake Paul thing aside. But like, it's not reasonable to think like,
- 1:06:42oh, I really failed because I got lost in this thing or caught up in this thing. Like, no,
- 1:06:46they're designed to make sure that we get caught up in them. They're literally designed based off
- 1:06:52of gambling technology to keep us engaged and stuck. And I also want to talk about, you know,
- 1:07:00the you spoke of this like the the
- 1:07:04The impact of these stressors all collectively pushing certain behaviors we get on social media
- 1:07:10and it spreads in this way and it spreads at a rate and an expansiveness as far as modern,
- 1:07:18as far as the history we know of, the narratives we have for the history of humanity, at a speed
- 1:07:24and a reach.
- 1:07:27that we've never known before absolutely like almost literally the speed of light in some
- 1:07:34instances, you know with fiber optic cables and these kinds of things, right? Absolutely. And
- 1:07:43again, I feel like it's quite logical for people to take what we're talking about here.
- 1:07:47and we can see how that would then spread because whereas we have this sort of polarization
- 1:07:53that's happening and the sort of ongoing stressors would influence the way we engage socially
- 1:08:00and culturally and what kinds of social or cultural sort of
- 1:08:07Factors we would then be inclined or disinclined towards, which on a larger scale would influence
- 1:08:13what sort of rises to the top of our society or our culture rather than and what sort of
- 1:08:19like fades into the background.
- 1:08:21For example, reading fading into the background as social media rises to the top or short
- 1:08:27form videos rise to the top or just television in general.
- 1:08:31And then that would also influence our political views, what we would celebrate or reject politically,
- 1:08:40or in response to say there's the fight for it, vote for who I vote for, but then there's also
- 1:08:46the flight from it. It's just too much. I don't want to engage at all. Either way,
- 1:08:51we can now see how this
- 1:08:53this sort of stress contagion you're talking about can influence politically,
- 1:08:58which would then change the shape of our society on multiple levels.
- 1:09:04And then...
- 1:09:10Okay, so where's the link here?
- 1:09:12So I feel like that's logical for people, so feel free to comment on that or expand.
- 1:09:17Let me step in.
- 1:09:18So all good reflections and important.
- 1:09:22One of the things we failed to say, and let's go with the simple example again, because
- 1:09:26it makes everything clear to have a picture in your mind.
- 1:09:29So let's do the road rage thing.
- 1:09:32So, you know, it's you who had the difficult day and the difficult night and you are obligated to react to somebody being very
- 1:09:40Irresponsible in another car on your way to work kind of thing. What we didn't talk about is what set that person off
- 1:09:48Maybe there's they've got all the same good reasons, right? They had a
- 1:09:52their child is using drugs, some terrible thing happened.
- 1:09:56The reason that they're out of control is because some provocation got the better of their tolerance mechanisms.
- 1:10:04But then they're effectively paying it forward to you.
- 1:10:07So, you know, you were doing okay.
- 1:10:09You were basically keeping it under control, but your stress tolerance is down.
- 1:10:14and maybe they make you snap.
- 1:10:16Now, if you snap, you're going to affect somebody else
- 1:10:19and they're potentially going to affect someone else.
- 1:10:21This is very much like the model
- 1:10:23of infectious disease contagion.
- 1:10:25And by the way, all the things we're talking about
- 1:10:27are highly relevant to the COVID pandemic,
- 1:10:29the way the internet affected our response to the pandemic,
- 1:10:33the way we polarized.
- 1:10:34But we could have a whole separate conversation
- 1:10:36for a couple of hours about the pandemic,
- 1:10:39which we're obviously not going to have.
- 1:10:41But one of the interesting things to do is simply think about the spread of stress and inflammation person to person, the way we think about the spread of virus.
- 1:10:50Effectively, it goes viral. Every person who has it and is carrying it potentially can transmit it to someone else.
- 1:10:58What determines whether or not that other person succumbs are the same three factors that we always talk about in epidemiology host
- 1:11:06Agent environment right so the environment is that highway where you're driving and if there are all sorts of engineered safeguards against
- 1:11:14Calamity results on that highway engineered safety features in the cars
- 1:11:19Bells and alarms that go off when you're driving irresponsibly the environment actually may constrain the interaction
- 1:11:26between host and agent so mayhem doesn't ensue that would be a good thing so we can engineer solutions into the environment.
- 1:11:33The agent in this case is the provocation but the host is you and if you've been trained to be meditative or reflexive if you've learned to you know count to ten take a few deep breath before you react to something if you just have a little bit.
- 1:11:50of that constructive ability built into your stress tolerance.
- 1:11:54You, as the host, can cut it off at the pass.
- 1:11:58It's a lot like being immunized.
- 1:12:00So you can imagine you've got stress and reactive inflammation being propagated through social media or on the highway or anywhere you like.
- 1:12:10But in any given individual who is not overcome and undone.
- 1:12:17It hits a wall because that person now isn't affected, isn't drawn in to the inflamed response and consequently can't become a vector to pass it on to others.
- 1:12:30you can essentially think of this in terms of stress, herd immunity, or inflammation, herd immunity,
- 1:12:38where every one of us who acts as a barrier prevents others from ever being exposed.
- 1:12:44Because if I'm not undone, I behave much better than if I am undone.
- 1:12:49And if I behave much better, I'm much less likely to set you off whether your tolerance is higher or low.
- 1:12:53So in other words, you may be immunized too.
- 1:12:56or you may be unimmunized and completely vulnerable,
- 1:12:59but if I never trigger you, it doesn't matter
- 1:13:02because you don't get exposed to the inflammatory provocation
- 1:13:05and we should be thinking of it that way.
- 1:13:07And simple examples could be in real space,
- 1:13:10could be in cyberspace, same basic thinking.
- 1:13:13So that translation from the individual to the collective
- 1:13:18invites thinking about this like the spread
- 1:13:20of a viral contagion.
- 1:13:22There are some really very potent parallels.
- 1:13:27I think a kind of missing piece that isn't entirely spoken to yet and I think is absolutely
- 1:13:33essential before the interview here is over is how this spread of this contagion moves upwards
- 1:13:40into the social political body which changes the body, changes the environment as you talked about.
- 1:13:47because if you're saying, "Oh, this person's stressed," because of all the regular stresses that
- 1:13:51we're all experiencing, well, those stresses are responses to our social, cultural, political
- 1:13:59environment. And as these inflammatory loops and this can change and spread to
- 1:14:06to create dysfunction socially and then politically, it alters the environment. And you speak about this in the paper.
- 1:14:14It's not just a bottom-up process of the inflammatory response spreading between people and out.
- 1:14:20It changes the very environment that they are in, which then has a bottom--or sorry, a top-down effect on the individual,
- 1:14:28creating a
- 1:14:30And more likelihood of stress response.
- 1:14:33So it's not just like a, oh, it gets more and more stressful.
- 1:14:36It's like a back and forth.
- 1:14:38I believe you use a term something like a runaway,
- 1:14:41feed forward process that just increasingly compromises
- 1:14:46human decision making, behavior,
- 1:14:50which I'm trying to push some stuff in here
- 1:14:53that normally we would have regulators
- 1:14:56like in the body, we have the brain.
- 1:14:58Or the mind in society we have political leaders and/or bodies of political leaders that represent
- 1:15:06multinational interests to help sort of regulate the effects things that are happening in society
- 1:15:12so they don't explode into literal war or civil war or collapses of various institutions we rely on.
- 1:15:21But those regulators can get damaged as well. Those functions can degrade. And we can be in a
- 1:15:26situation where our political leadership, our geopolitical leadership, can be compromised
- 1:15:31by the same feed-forward process, which then changes our environment only further advancing
- 1:15:37the inflammatory contagion, the stress contagion that you're talking about until we live in a
- 1:15:42world similar to where we are now, or in the midst of using the
- 1:15:46the paper, Paul The Crisis and the dread and all of that that comes with it, which only
- 1:15:51then further feeds the process. Did I miss anything there?
- 1:15:56That's about it. Sadly, I'm feeling a lot of that these days and you likely are and
- 1:16:02certainly many listening, whatever.
- 1:16:04side of the political spectrum you're on, you recognize that we're very polarized and
- 1:16:10there's a lot of pain that we're all wrestling with.
- 1:16:15In my case, I have real concerns about our lack of civility, our lack of inclusiveness.
- 1:16:21I'm a humanist and I'm deeply concerned about the fate of the planet.
- 1:16:26We have some hope of being healthy, vital people on a healthy, vital planet.
- 1:16:29or we have no hope of being healthy vital people.
- 1:16:32And there is no planet B as the saying goes.
- 1:16:36So yeah, all that's true.
- 1:16:37And we could connect the dots in all sorts of ways,
- 1:16:41but you could think of these primitive responses,
- 1:16:45the dysregulation of the inflammatory response
- 1:16:48by excessive chronic stress.
- 1:16:51By the way, one thing we didn't talk about
- 1:16:53is that chronic inflammation is a critical pathway
- 1:16:56to all major chronic disease.
- 1:16:58So all those other things are going on, but now you're also dealing with the fact that
- 1:17:02you've got type 2 diabetes or coronary artery disease.
- 1:17:05Which puts more stress on the medical institutions which makes healthcare harder to access.
- 1:17:10You're spending time in doctors' offices, it's disrupting your work, you're more stressed.
- 1:17:14That's not helping.
- 1:17:16So another feed forward loop is that chronic stress leads to chronic inflammation leads
- 1:17:21to chronic disease, which leads to more chronic stress.
- 1:17:24So all of that.
- 1:17:25And then sure, the frustration people feel in the modern world having no clear action
- 1:17:32plan to address the sources of stress.
- 1:17:35Have us looking for some way to lash out and that can be what we express in social media
- 1:17:41But it can also be you know
- 1:17:43I just I want somebody to blow up the system that's making me so unhappy and so it can be a vote directed at disruption
- 1:17:51And so we wind up with disruptors in chief and you know a system that isn't operating as that rational regulator of provocations but actually becomes a source of provocations.
- 1:18:07So if we become highly polarized as individuals we radicalize our own views because.
- 1:18:14we never feel fully relaxed or fulfilled or satisfied.
- 1:18:18We're just constantly subject to stress.
- 1:18:21And we have chronic inflammation in response to that stress.
- 1:18:25And we have chronic disease in response to that inflammation.
- 1:18:28And chronic unhappiness and frustration in response to all of that.
- 1:18:32And then we express it in our behavior and we grow a tribe of like-minded people and we talk ourselves
- 1:18:40Into finding those who share those views to represent us out in the world
- 1:18:44So we don't feel quite so helpless
- 1:18:47Somebody is going to do something about that. I want someone in a position of real power who can
- 1:18:53Represent my unhappiness. Well, then you get the representation of this inflammation
- 1:18:57inflammation.
- 1:18:59in the halls of power, which obviously has the potential to interact with other people in other halls of power and inflame them.
- 1:19:07And so we're talking about a massive effect amplifier. So you could think of politics simply as the connection between individual and community level stress feed forward loops.
- 1:19:24and transcontinental stress feed forward loops.
- 1:19:29We're seeing all of this in the world around us today.
- 1:19:34And I think a critical question obviously becomes,
- 1:19:39what on earth can we do about it?
- 1:19:40We can talk about that to bring us over the finish line.
- 1:19:45But it's certainly important that we all recognize
- 1:19:49our vulnerability is not just isolated within us.
- 1:19:53Let's keep in mind one of the other sources of stress
- 1:19:55and we address this very briefly.
- 1:19:58I think some of my particular contributions to the paper
- 1:20:01had to do with studies looking at crowding.
- 1:20:04Crowding is a source of stress.
- 1:20:05Well, there are eight billion homo sapiens.
- 1:20:07That's not the normal state of our species.
- 1:20:10We were foragers in a great big open world.
- 1:20:13We get time to ourselves.
- 1:20:14And the time we spent with other people was people we actually knew.
- 1:20:19We're now immersed in a crowded world where we're obligated to interact very extensively with people we don't know at all or know quite nominally,
- 1:20:29and almost never. Some of us are privileged maybe to be able to get into the woods, but most people just don't ever have a chance to really be entirely off by themselves.
- 1:20:39And that's another effect amplifier. So if you could just find that quiet, restful meditative time in a great big open world with ample elbow room, it would also be brain room and it would let you decompress.
- 1:20:54That would be time alone that doesn't include the content, the consumption of content, right?
- 1:21:03I want to also say crowding, there's also scarcity as well. So crowding is not just people around,
- 1:21:10but it's the sort of decreased access to vital resources. However, the brain,
- 1:21:15however our ancient nervous system perceives that, or however our modern nervous system
- 1:21:20perceives it, including scarcities and things like access to food, or just access to money,
- 1:21:27or employment which is money or
- 1:21:30housing, things that are getting increasingly more difficult to access as we're in this
- 1:21:36inflammatory runaway, feedforward thing in our society bottom up and top down.
- 1:21:42All that, but also just keep in mind, we really are talking about a world and a social dynamic
- 1:21:48where everybody around you is inflamed in all the ways that you are.
- 1:21:52And so when you're interacting with them, you're interacting with their inflammation.
- 1:21:56So A, you needed tranquil time.
- 1:21:59to be alone at peace to decompress within yourself and be
- 1:22:05When you do interact with other people you need them to be reasonably
- 1:22:10under control and at peace in order not to
- 1:22:14re-provoke you and
- 1:22:16increase that inflammation
- 1:22:18And if you can't get either of those, if you can't decompress or you're already operating at a high level of stress and inflammation,
- 1:22:25and everybody else has that same problem so they can't decompress and they provoke you and you provoke them,
- 1:22:31you can see how this situation rapidly gets out of control.
- 1:22:36And you have a problem of global inflammation.
- 1:22:40And we're talking about literal inflammation
- 1:22:42in our bodies affecting organ systems,
- 1:22:44driving the pandemic of chronic cardiometabolic disease,
- 1:22:48driving social unrest,
- 1:22:52and occurring in bodies and in the body politic
- 1:22:58in exactly the same ways for all the same reasons.
- 1:23:03We've got about five minutes left of recording time here.
- 1:23:08There's so many more places we can go, clearly, like so many more avenues to discuss how this
- 1:23:13is playing out.
- 1:23:14But I think what I should hope, I hope there is a good answer to this question I'm about
- 1:23:20to offer you.
- 1:23:21And I also hope that people are, you know, not so distressed now that they're not able
- 1:23:26to hear what you're about to say.
- 1:23:31what can we do about it? And I understand that there's ways that we can engage in politics
- 1:23:37maybe differently or how we engage in society and so on and so forth. And those are relevant
- 1:23:40questions. But I want to take it to zone zero, as I would say, in permaculture. Me, like I'm
- 1:23:48asking literally for myself, but also for people who are listening,
- 1:23:52what can I do for myself to help intervene in this spiral down the drain such that I can have to
- 1:24:05become more of a net positive effect?
- 1:24:07on this cascading event around me in myself and on others.
- 1:24:11What can I do?
- 1:24:13Where can I intervene?
- 1:24:14- Yeah, and I like to start with what's actionable
- 1:24:18by the individual.
- 1:24:19So James, I very much appreciate the invitation
- 1:24:23to have this conversation with you
- 1:24:24because I think we're helping.
- 1:24:26So anybody listening,
- 1:24:27I mean, I hope we're not distressing people too much.
- 1:24:29Sorry, folks.
- 1:24:30I mean, it is what it is, right?
- 1:24:32So we're all in the same boat.
- 1:24:33But if you understand that these reactions are not about being a good or bad person,
- 1:24:39that they're about physiology and the nervous system and hardwiring and evolutionary biology,
- 1:24:46profound forces that shape to and what we are,
- 1:24:49if you understand,
- 1:24:51A native impulse you can control the native impulse far better if it's happening in the background
- 1:24:58Where you're unaware of it you have no opportunity to control it, but if you know
- 1:25:03How you can be triggered and and you know what's going to affect your
- 1:25:07Tolerance threshold for for stressful provocations if you're just just being conscious of that
- 1:25:13puts us in
- 1:25:15I'm reluctant to use the term but the driver seat puts us you know gives us potential control over that
- 1:25:20It also invites you to then ask yourself where do my particular vulnerabilities reside on any given day
- 1:25:28You know if I'm having a hard time
- 1:25:31Paying forward good emotion and I feel like I'm likely to contribute to this chronic inflammation
- 1:25:36What are the primary reasons is it because I'm in pain?
- 1:25:39A lot of people are in chronic pain.
- 1:25:41That's a factor.
- 1:25:41Is it because I'm unhealthy and it's making men happy?
- 1:25:45Is it because I sleep so poorly?
- 1:25:48Is it because they're particular sources of stress
- 1:25:50in my life?
- 1:25:50I actually went through this exercise
- 1:25:52with my patients for years.
- 1:25:54They called it holistic profiling.
- 1:25:56I said, you know, we talked in these literal terms.
- 1:25:58So years before this team came together
- 1:26:00to write this paper,
- 1:26:02I essentially was doing this with my patients.
- 1:26:04Okay, so there are lots of things
- 1:26:05that can make you unhealthy and unhappy.
- 1:26:07Let's line them up and talk about them.
- 1:26:10And then each one we fix has the potential to make it easier to fix the next one.
- 1:26:15So we can go from that circling the drain and downward spiral to a spiral staircase up.
- 1:26:20Our goal is the best vitality, both physical and mental, you can achieve.
- 1:26:25What one thing would you like me as a doctor to help fix?
- 1:26:30That would give you the greatest boost and the greatest inclination to say now i want to fix the next would it be pain because of arthritis would it be disrupted sleep is it is a chronic stress.
- 1:26:41Let's start with your priority some inviting everybody listening do this exercise yourself.
- 1:26:46What stands between you and being the best version of yourself? What what makes it hard to be the kind
- 1:26:54decent caring person you really want to be for everybody you encounter every day because I think we all want that
- 1:26:59We all feel the same things we all know
- 1:27:02You know that kindness feels good both to express and receive so if we're not doing it if we're not receiving it or we're not
- 1:27:08delivering it
- 1:27:10We're not happy about that.
- 1:27:11So what's in the way?
- 1:27:13Each of those things is potentially fixable.
- 1:27:15And then the second question,
- 1:27:17so the first question is what are your priorities?
- 1:27:19Second question, is it something you can address on your own or do you need help?
- 1:27:24Very often we need help.
- 1:27:25That's perfectly okay.
- 1:27:26We all need somebody to lean on.
- 1:27:28Who can help with that particular issue?
- 1:27:32And can you access that?
- 1:27:34Now, if the answer is no,
- 1:27:37we get into a complicated realm where, you know,
- 1:27:40we need to be talking about things like social services
- 1:27:42and, you know, there are social workers
- 1:27:44who can help people get the resources
- 1:27:46they need to access critical help.
- 1:27:47So if your particular source of stress is your health
- 1:27:50and you don't have insurance,
- 1:27:52you don't have the means to address your health,
- 1:27:53and okay, so then we need to step back and say,
- 1:27:55the first problem here is access.
- 1:27:59and social resources, we need a social worker.
- 1:28:02And they're available and hospitals often make
- 1:28:04their services available for free.
- 1:28:06And so there's one whole path to go down.
- 1:28:09But I don't wanna make this too specific.
- 1:28:11I just wanna talk in general
- 1:28:12about recognizing our vulnerability
- 1:28:14to be part of the problem of propagating stress
- 1:28:18and inflammation.
- 1:28:19and each of us has the potential to both feel better individually and be part of the collective solution
- 1:28:26if we get a better handle on it. So ask yourself on any given day if I feel the temptation to be undone and behave in a way I'm not proud of,
- 1:28:36what is the particular driver of that?
- 1:28:39And how do I fix it and whose help do I need?
- 1:28:43Start there.
- 1:28:44And what we then did in my clinical practice is the next visit, say, okay, if we're effectively
- 1:28:51addressing your sleep with better sleep hygiene, for example, and some just simple education
- 1:28:56there.
- 1:28:57And because you're sleeping better, your pain tolerance is higher and you're less burdened
- 1:29:01with pain.
- 1:29:02What's the next thing you want to do?
- 1:29:03Can we now start talking about a little bit of more physical activity?
- 1:29:06Physical activity, you all know how important it is for your physical health, but it's an
- 1:29:10incredible tonic for the brain.
- 1:29:12It relieves stress.
- 1:29:13And just a quick aside here, James, even though you asked for short answers, you're
- 1:29:19I would note that in my particular case,
- 1:29:23I've been advised on the value of meditation
- 1:29:27from no less than Deepak Chopra himself.
- 1:29:29Actually, no Deepak, he's told me personally
- 1:29:31how important it is to meditate.
- 1:29:32I've tried.
- 1:29:33And every time over the years I've tried to meditate,
- 1:29:36I keep coming back to the same basic place,
- 1:29:38which is, hmm, how many emails could I be answering now?
- 1:29:43I just can't get past it.
- 1:29:45But a hike in the woods for me,
- 1:29:48is both physical activity and meditation.
- 1:29:51Riding a horse for me is both physical activity
- 1:29:54and meditation, being outside in nature is meditation.
- 1:29:58So I double dip.
- 1:29:59I no longer worry about it.
- 1:30:00I don't think I need to find time to meditate.
- 1:30:02I think taking my mind to a peaceful tranquil state
- 1:30:07in whatever way works best for me, that is my meditation.
- 1:30:10And it just so happens that I meditate best.
- 1:30:13And I feel best and I'm most creative and most productive
- 1:30:18when I'm physically active.
- 1:30:20Well, I'm actually feeding two birds with one sesame seed
- 1:30:23there because it's important to be physically active
- 1:30:25and it's important to meditate, to unclutter your mind.
- 1:30:28I do them together, that kind of thing.
- 1:30:31So you all need to figure that out for yourself.
- 1:30:34What stands between you and your best vitality,
- 1:30:37mental and physical,
- 1:30:39What do you need to do to improve that one thing and you do it without help and if not who's helped you need and do that one thing.
- 1:30:48Do that as a gift to yourself and as a gift that you'll be able to pay for and then parlay that progress with that one thing into attention to the next and then the next and the next and it's really a very short menu of items.
- 1:31:01Physical activity, eating well, avoiding toxins like tobacco and excess alcohol.
- 1:31:08Sleeping enough, managing stress, you're not going to avoid exposure to stress, but managing it, filtering it effectively,
- 1:31:16and healthy social connections. Feet, forks, fingers, sleep, stress, and love.
- 1:31:22The six-cylinder engine of lifestyle is medicine.
- 1:31:25So let's just think about those six.
- 1:31:27Get it any one of them and improve it and then use that
- 1:31:34Motivation to improve the next and the next it's not long before you're starting to see that the top step of that viral staircase
- 1:31:41leading to your vitality is in reach and all the while
- 1:31:45While you're improving your internal environment, you are improving the external environment because you are now
- 1:31:52projecting a more positive version of yourself. You are no longer as likely as you were yesterday to be somebody else's intolerable
- 1:32:00provocation.
- 1:32:02And eventually, perhaps no longer being a negative impact, but even getting to the point of being
- 1:32:10a positive impact on those around you. Not just a neutral non-negative, but even a positive impact
- 1:32:16on the days because the same kind of upward spiral that can happen within us can also happen between
- 1:32:22us in the same way the downward one is happening now. Is that correct?
- 1:32:25It's absolutely correct. So you are you're both, you know, you're you're a wall that
- 1:32:31contributes to herd immunity because you're not
- 1:32:34provoking other people, but yeah when you really feel good and you're really a source of positive emotion
- 1:32:39You brighten somebody else's day and so they may have been headed toward the point where their tolerance was compromised
- 1:32:46and you may fortify their tolerance because use a fuse their day with some sunlight absolutely so all these things work in both directions we can't say that stress and inflammation travel.
- 1:32:59In social networks without acknowledging that.
- 1:33:03gratification and contentment and equanimity also travel in social networks and you can be a source of any of those you can help.
- 1:33:13Elevate other people's tolerances for stresses they may encounter and then they become an additional blocker.
- 1:33:20And the probability of truly effective herd immunity where we stop propagating stress and inflammation in one another
- 1:33:29gets ever more realistic.
- 1:33:34Dr. David Katz, thank you so much for coming on the show. Thank you for your work.
- 1:33:39I'll be sure to link the paper in the show notes this episode for people who want to check it out.
- 1:33:44But is there anything you'd like to leave the listeners with before we go, be it a final word or your social media?
- 1:33:51Because again, you could be a positive effect on social media.
- 1:33:56So anything you'd like to leave the listeners with in our closing here.
- 1:34:00Sure, James. Thank you. Yeah, and I like to think that I am a positive influence. I certainly try to be and aspire to be I
- 1:34:06We talked about my dogs along the way
- 1:34:09Every day I strive to be the person my dogs believe I
- 1:34:15So yeah, I mean the just just to close out first of all, thank you for finding the paper that there was no high probability
- 1:34:21That was ever gonna happen
- 1:34:23Thank you for the invitation and this conversation. I'd simply
- 1:34:28close by noting i am a lifestyle medicine specialist and if we get the things right that we've been talking about so in particular dealing with stress and and managing inflammation but those other things i put on that list just now so physical activity getting diet right sleeping enough and so forth.
- 1:34:48we could eliminate 80% or more of all the chronic disease in the world around us.
- 1:34:53And just think what a stress relief that would be.
- 1:34:55All the times that somebody we love succumbs to heart disease, cancer, stroke, diabetes, dementia.
- 1:35:01Those are terrible days. Those are tremendous sources of stress.
- 1:35:05We actually know how to prevent that at least 80% of the time.
- 1:35:09So you can reduce your own personal risk by 80% by getting this lifestyle formula right.
- 1:35:15And you then become a source of light for the people around you.
- 1:35:20You inevitably wind up paying it forward,
- 1:35:22because it's easier for other people connected to you
- 1:35:26to be active and eat well when that's what you do.
- 1:35:30So we focus today on mental aspects and brain aspects
- 1:35:34and stress and inflammation.
- 1:35:37But we're really talking about a fundamental formula for advancing the human condition,
- 1:35:43adding years to lives and adding life to years.
- 1:35:46So by all means, start with yourself, focus on yourself, figure out what you need to address
- 1:35:52to achieve your best vitality, but understand how high is up.
- 1:35:56The value proposition is truly incredible and inevitably, if you can become a master of
- 1:36:03this formula in whole or in part.
- 1:36:06you wind up paying it forward to the people you love.
- 1:36:10And maybe that's the greatest gift of all.
- 1:36:13- Beautiful.
- 1:36:14And do you have social media?
- 1:36:16Is there somewhere you want people to go?
- 1:36:18Yeah.
- 1:36:18I mean, I don't want to take away from how beautiful
- 1:36:20what you just said was, but yes.
- 1:36:22- Thanks.
- 1:36:23Sure, so I have a primary website,
- 1:36:26which is kind of a hub to all things I'm involved in.
- 1:36:29That's davidcatsmd.com.
- 1:36:32My principal work is in the area of nutrition actually where I founded a company and you can learn more about that at dietid.com.
- 1:36:42And James maybe you'll make this easier for people and post the links and then the one other thing I tried to do.
- 1:36:48I believe in science.
- 1:36:50I believe in the sensible interpretation of science,
- 1:36:53and I believe it's important to avoid
- 1:36:56the stressful conflict of he said, she said,
- 1:36:59by representing the global consensus of experts
- 1:37:03regarding the sensible interpretation of science.
- 1:37:05So I created many years ago a nonprofit
- 1:37:07called the True Health Initiative.
- 1:37:09It was all about bringing together disparate experts
- 1:37:13from countries all around the world.
- 1:37:14We have about 50 countries represented.
- 1:37:17To say to the public, we agree about the fundamentals of a health promoting lifestyle and diet that it, you know,
- 1:37:24it there isn't nearly as much conflict as you think and you don't have to choose this expert versus that expert.
- 1:37:30This is 500 experts from 50 countries all coming together
- 1:37:34across a spectrum of activity to say we agree and you can learn more about that effort at truehealthinitiative.org.
- 1:37:42Okay, thank you so much for that, Dr. David Katz, and thank you again for your time today.
- 1:37:47I really appreciate it, and I imagine my listeners do too.
- 1:37:50Thank you, James, likewise.
- 1:37:52And cut.
- 1:37:54Okay, that was our interview with Dr. David Katz here on Adventure to the Mind Episode
- 1:37:59204.
- 1:38:00The links that he mentioned there at the end will be included in the show notes of this
- 1:38:04episode at jameswjesso.com, which there will be a link to jump over to.
- 1:38:08Yes, I'm trying to get you to go to my website.
- 1:38:11Honestly, there's not really anything to sell on there or what, but I just put a lot of
- 1:38:16time into making stuff to go on the website.
- 1:38:18So if you go over there, it also, I don't know, it really means something that you took
- 1:38:22a chance to check out the website that I built.
- 1:38:24I'm pretty proud of it.
- 1:38:27And I'll also include links to support the show if you'd like to do that.
- 1:38:32Financial ways are mentioned in the middle there of the episode, and non-financial ways include any kind of social engagement on the internet as well.
- 1:38:42You might know if you're following me, I'm kind of, you know, pretty critical of what the algorithm is doing to us as a species, as individuals,
- 1:38:50and I feel disgusted that I need to participate in it to try to grab and steal to trick your attention into engaging with this content.
- 1:38:59I don't like that. It disgusts me, and I try to avoid it as much as possible.
- 1:39:03And so I get that these podcasts take more than just five seconds and a quick double tap to engage.
- 1:39:12But if you even just want to give it a quick double tap, that does mean something.
- 1:39:16You know, double tap like thumbs up subscriptions, all the rest. It means something.
- 1:39:22And I guess that's it. You can follow me on those
- 1:39:26questionably ethical questionable ethically questionable platforms. You can follow me on my newsletter
- 1:39:32I've got a couple of different options listed below
- 1:39:36Instagram, Blue Sky, LinkedIn
- 1:39:38Twitter, probably, Substack, eventually.
- 1:39:42And it's all linked there, so go check it out in the description.
- 1:39:46And I think that's it.
- 1:39:48I don't talk about this much directly, but if you're ever looking for any integration
- 1:39:52coaching for psychedelic experiences, I offer that as a service.
- 1:39:56Leave a link to that there too.
- 1:39:58I'm actually about to be further upskilling my integration coaching capacity by participating
- 1:40:03the ICIRS integration course.
- 1:40:07this year, which will help me have a better understanding of how to support people in acute crisis after disturbing psychedelic experiences.
- 1:40:16It's got a pretty good handle on it, but hey, it never hurts to get better at supporting people.
- 1:40:23I mean, unless you're...
- 1:40:25codependent and erasing yourself in the process, in which case it would get, it
- 1:40:30would be better to get good at supporting yourself. Anyways, I'm
- 1:40:34rambling because it's the end of the episode and I can just do that I suppose
- 1:40:39and you'll tune out when you tune out which I suppose you already either
- 1:40:43already have or you're about to because I'm ending the episode. At the end of
- 1:40:48this episode, sorry at the end of the interview, this is the last thing I promise.
- 1:40:53It was left with a sense of what we can do about this situation that we export in the interview.
- 1:41:00I don't want that to be lost because I got swept up enjoying rambling at the end of the podcast,
- 1:41:07so I want to double down on that within each of us as a capacity to interrupt
- 1:41:12the spread of stress-induced inflammation as best we can.
- 1:41:17And each of us are capable in some way or another.
- 1:41:19I'm doing my best.
- 1:41:20I bet you you're doing your best.
- 1:41:22And hopefully at the end of this podcast, after this interview,
- 1:41:25you have an even more refined, more granular, more engaged, more aware sense.
- 1:41:31of what our best might look like and why and how.
- 1:41:35And that's it.
- 1:41:36Thank you for tuning in all the way
- 1:41:37to this episode of Adventures Through The Mind.
- 1:41:39I've been your host James W. Jesso.
- 1:41:40And until the next one, take care and stay curious.