Latest / The Legal Field: Legal Perspectives in the Agriculture Industry / Seeds of Ownership - Intellectual Property in Agriculture: A Conversation with David Gerasimow
Transcript
- 0:22Amanda Perry Carl: Well, we just got legal and regulatory topics that are critical importance to the agricultural industry.
- 0:27Amanda Perry Carl: My name is the mandatory call, and I'm an agricultural lawyer whose family has been farming in Florida since 1823.
- 0:34Amanda Perry Carl: Before Florida even became a state.
- 0:37Amanda Perry Carl: I have spent almost 20 years in my country in the agricultural industry.
- 0:41Amanda Perry Carl: So we've seen Florida, America, and the world.
- 0:52Amanda Perry Carl: So if you're a farmer, rancher, or grower, if you are involved in raising cattle, beef, poultry, goats, hogs, horses, or other livestock.
- 1:01Amanda Perry Carl: If you grow fruits, vegetables, or sod, if you are involved with the aquaculture, turf grass, or horticulture industry, if you are fighting the good fight to help our citrus industry survive, or if you just like to eat and you appreciate our ag producers, this podcast is for you.
- 1:18Amanda Perry Carl: If you are interested in protecting and preserving our agricultural heritage, lands, and way of life, then come join us in the legal field and see what's growing on.
- 1:28Amanda Perry Carl: Welcome to another episode of the Legal Field Podcast.
- 1:34Amanda Perry Carl: My name is Amanda Perry Carl, and I'm the host of the podcast.
- 1:37Amanda Perry Carl: And I am so excited today to welcome our guest, David Girosimo.
- 1:42Amanda Perry Carl: Welcome, David.
- 1:43David Gerasimow: Hi, how are you?
- 1:45Amanda Perry Carl: I am great on this Monday morning as we're recording.
- 1:48Amanda Perry Carl: Um, David is a fantastic intellectual property attorney, um, and he has really sophisticated IP experience.
- 1:55Amanda Perry Carl: And his law law firm, Jurassimo Law Firm, really strives to make this sophisticated IP litigation accessible to everyone.
- 2:04Amanda Perry Carl: And I've had the pleasure of working very closely with David, including when he was serving as outside intellectual property counsel for an agricultural company where I was working as in-house counsel.
- 2:16Amanda Perry Carl: So let me tell you, he's amazing and he knows the stuff.
- 2:19Amanda Perry Carl: So I'm really excited to have him on today.
- 2:21Amanda Perry Carl: Yes, I'm I'm so glad that you could join us and get and impart some of your IP wisdom on our listeners.
- 2:30Amanda Perry Carl: I think this is such an important topic.
- 2:32Amanda Perry Carl: So, can you give us a little background about your professional history, your expertise, and how you got where you are today, David?
- 2:40David Gerasimow: Yeah, sure.
- 2:41David Gerasimow: And I think um, you know, telling you how I got here uh tells you a lot about what I do.
- 2:46David Gerasimow: So I uh, you know, growing up, I was always interested in computers, video games, that type of thing.
- 2:51David Gerasimow: And so immediately uh decided to study computer science when I got to college and was also interested in math.
- 2:58David Gerasimow: And so went through college thinking, um, you know, maybe I'll be a computer programmer and do that after college.
- 3:03David Gerasimow: But you know, also had other interests like reading and writing.
- 3:06David Gerasimow: And um, as we might get to a little bit later in the podcast, my father was uh an intellectual property attorney.
- 3:12David Gerasimow: So I had known about the field and kind of decided, well, maybe I'll go to law school and uh, you know, build on things like engineering and science that I like, but also incorporate the reading and writing that I think you know you did in law school, and um decided then to become an intellectual property attorney.
- 3:28David Gerasimow: And so I think of that as being an attorney who specializes in science and technology and the legal issues that that relate to that, and in particular, um, those types of intellectual property.
- 3:39David Gerasimow: Uh so I got out of law school about 18, 18 years ago, and have really been in a field of intellectual property since and mostly focusing on patents.
- 3:50David Gerasimow: Uh, I do other work as well, and the firm uh does a variety of intellectual property fields, but most of my experience has been in patents and in patent disputes.
- 4:00David Gerasimow: So I think we're we're you know here today to share some of that uh knowledge about patents.
- 4:07Amanda Perry Carl: Yes, and you mentioned you've you've mentioned their patents and patent litigation, and this is something that we've certainly worked together on for clients and for our listeners who may have a very basic understanding of patents or maybe no understanding of patents.
- 4:22Amanda Perry Carl: Can you give them a little bit of a patent 101 education, the what, the why of patent protection?
- 4:28Amanda Perry Carl: Um, I think it's really important if someone is considering patent protection in their business.
- 4:33David Gerasimow: Yeah, yeah.
- 4:34David Gerasimow: So I what is a patent?
- 4:36David Gerasimow: Um, it's a government right, something the government gives you.
- 4:39David Gerasimow: You don't just get it on your own.
- 4:41David Gerasimow: And it is the right to exclude others from making, using, selling, offering uh your invention.
- 4:47David Gerasimow: Notably, it's it's not an affirmative right.
- 4:50David Gerasimow: Sometimes people think, oh, I have a patent, so I have the right to do something, it makes something.
- 4:54David Gerasimow: It's it's actually the opposite.
- 4:56David Gerasimow: It's the right to prevent others.
- 4:58David Gerasimow: And so when you um come up with an invention, you uh apply to the government uh for a patent.
- 5:05David Gerasimow: And if you meet the requirements and they determine you really have invented something, they'll uh award you uh with a patent.
- 5:12David Gerasimow: And uh that is not the right to make those things, but to prevent others.
- 5:17David Gerasimow: And you could then, for instance, license that right or sue someone who was refusing to pay you uh a license fee.
- 5:26David Gerasimow: And so that right to exclude is where the the patent is and where its its value really really derives.
- 5:34Amanda Perry Carl: And I think that's a very important distinction that probably a lot of people and probably a lot of attorneys who don't work in the patent world don't even have that understanding.
- 5:44Amanda Perry Carl: So I think that's a really important distinction there, that it's the right to prevent others.
- 5:49Amanda Perry Carl: Um and I we know that there are there are multiple different types of patents, and I think this is probably also a really important distinction for our listeners.
- 5:59Amanda Perry Carl: Can you go through the different types of patents and and what they're used for in that process for those different types of patents?
- 6:09David Gerasimow: Uh sure.
- 6:10David Gerasimow: Uh I I think of there being three types of patents, uh utility, design, and plant.
- 6:17David Gerasimow: Uh utility is probably what people think of most when they think of a patent.
- 6:22David Gerasimow: It's it's that kind we were just describing at the beginning.
- 6:25David Gerasimow: Um uh it's a patent on maybe a machine or a novel uh process, uh something a way of doing things.
- 6:32David Gerasimow: Uh a design patent doesn't cover that that fundamental idea so much, but as the ornamental design of an invention, say, or of a machine.
- 6:41David Gerasimow: So say a styling of a tractor doesn't have anything to do with uh its function as a tractor, but it adds to its ornamentation and and can be patentable.
- 6:51David Gerasimow: And then finally, there's there's the plant patent, and that covers um plant varieties um that are engineered that are asexually uh reproduced.
- 7:00David Gerasimow: And so that certainly could be relevant uh to your listeners.
- 7:03David Gerasimow: There's there is the distinction though that the plant patents are pretty limited to plants.
- 7:09David Gerasimow: You could see a variety of utility patents, though, relating to plants, um, you know, things like fertilizers or or any number of things that relate to agricultural fields.
- 7:19David Gerasimow: So those are the three types of patents uh in my mind.
- 7:23Amanda Perry Carl: And if someone was considering, you know, say someone was considering a a patent application, would there be some um considerations that that they should go through, maybe um, you know, the the what that they should go through in a process if they are looking to file a patent application, maybe some things they should be doing along the way if they have an invention.
- 7:50David Gerasimow: Uh sure.
- 7:51David Gerasimow: If first if you if you think you have an invention, um one thing to know is that you're time limited in in filing a patent application uh thereafter, particularly if you use that invention publicly.
- 8:03David Gerasimow: So the U.S.
- 8:04David Gerasimow: patent law grants inventors a one-year grace period after the first public disclosure of their invention to file a patent application.
- 8:10David Gerasimow: So if you think you come up with something, um, don't think you can wait forever.
- 8:15David Gerasimow: Um second, I would think um, you know, people often ask, is this the type of thing you can get a patent on?
- 8:21David Gerasimow: I think the answer to that question is almost always yes.
- 8:24David Gerasimow: Um, I think the only uh drawback is if someone has a vague idea, sometimes inventors don't haven't fully uh conceived of their idea.
- 8:33David Gerasimow: That can be hard to patent.
- 8:34David Gerasimow: But otherwise, most natural things that um that a person would come up with or that we naturally think of of being uh patentable are.
- 8:43David Gerasimow: And after that, it's really just a question of, well, it has to be an invention, you know, it has to be new.
- 8:49David Gerasimow: Uh, absolutely.
- 8:50David Gerasimow: If someone's come up with it before, it's not uh it's not going to be patentable.
- 8:54David Gerasimow: And there's a a variation to be thinking of called obviousness, where even if your invention is new, if if someone skilled uh would have been motivated to come up with the same invention, you might not be able to get a patent either.
- 9:08David Gerasimow: So I think it's I think it's those issues where you need to be um, you know, cognizant that time is of the essence in getting a patent application.
- 9:16David Gerasimow: Thinking that probably your idea is patentable in some way, and that you know, you you need to be uh cognizant of the novelty and obviousness requirements.
- 9:26David Gerasimow: With that in mind, I I think you know, uh obtaining patent protection, applying for it is is uh is accessible to folks.
- 9:35Amanda Perry Carl: Awesome.
- 9:36Amanda Perry Carl: And you know, we we've we've talked a little bit about patents here, and there's a whole world of intellectual property tools um that businesses, individuals can have in their toolkit.
- 9:48Amanda Perry Carl: Um and we we've talked a little bit about patents.
- 9:51Amanda Perry Carl: Let's take a step back for a minute and go to somewhat of the basics of intellectual property.
- 9:58Amanda Perry Carl: There are a few other IP tools beyond patents.
- 10:00Amanda Perry Carl: And I think so often people tend to confuse some of these tools, trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets, and sometimes even confuse them with patents.
- 10:10Amanda Perry Carl: And I think it can be a lot to wrap your head around if you're not well versed in the intellectual property world.
- 10:16Amanda Perry Carl: Um, I think sometimes, especially trademarks and copyrights, people tend to really confuse those two concepts.
- 10:23Amanda Perry Carl: Can you kind of break these down for our listeners and provide them an understanding of how some of these tools are different, what these different tools are and how they're used in the intellectual property world?
- 10:34David Gerasimow: Yeah, yeah, it's a great point.
- 10:35David Gerasimow: So patents, which just discussed, you know, tend to cover invention systems and processes, that type of thing.
- 10:42David Gerasimow: When we think of trademarks as an entirely uh distinct set of intellectual property rights, um, I had mentioned that you you had to plot apply to the government to get a patent.
- 10:52David Gerasimow: That's not always the case with a trademark.
- 10:54David Gerasimow: You can sometimes have these rights uh just by uh being a business owner.
- 10:59David Gerasimow: Uh they can be embellished and augmented by applying to the government.
- 11:03David Gerasimow: Um, but but you know, a trademark in its essence is is a distinctive word, uh symbol.
- 11:12David Gerasimow: It can sometimes be a phrase that identifies and distinguishes the source of goods or services from from someone else's goods or services.
- 11:24David Gerasimow: And so it's it's very much this idea of a brand that in the consumer's mind is associated with a particular source of good or services, and they know that that's where it's coming from, that it's not just um you know any particular uh good, it's from that source.
- 11:41David Gerasimow: They don't need to know the name of the source, they don't necessarily need to know the corporate structure of the source, but they know it's different from the same product or very similar product from someone else.
- 11:51David Gerasimow: It's if it's peanut butter, I know it's that peanut butter that I very much like, and I will always get it because of that brand.
- 11:59David Gerasimow: Um, so that's a trademark, and you can register those with the government, and like I said, that can have a lot of benefits.
- 12:05David Gerasimow: It's really distinguished from a copyright.
- 12:08David Gerasimow: These terms are uh often confused uh and misused.
- 12:12David Gerasimow: A copyright, um, you you again don't necessarily have to apply to the government to obtain, but it it has to do with the expression of an idea, right?
- 12:23David Gerasimow: I was talking about patents might be on an idea itself.
- 12:26David Gerasimow: Copyrights, no, they're on expressions.
- 12:29David Gerasimow: And how do we express ideas?
- 12:31David Gerasimow: Well, it can be, you know, paintings, it can be in the written word, it can be in song, danced video.
- 12:36David Gerasimow: Uh, we we there's a lot of media through which ideas are expressed.
- 12:41David Gerasimow: When when an idea um could be really anything, is fixed, once it's put into a medium, say you you finish that painting, you you tape that film, you tape a podcast, it it is becomes embodied in a particular tangible form and is copyrightable.
- 13:01David Gerasimow: And what it means is that people can't make copies of that expression uh without the owner's permission.
- 13:07David Gerasimow: So people couldn't, for instance, make copies of a podcast without without the owner's permission.
- 13:12David Gerasimow: Um, you you have to register those copyrights with the with the government if you want to do certain things, say sue someone over it.
- 13:20David Gerasimow: But that copyright exists the moment you that expression is fixed.
- 13:25David Gerasimow: And so, you know, it's to to really distinguish uh copyright from trademark.
- 13:31David Gerasimow: Copyright is is an expression, a fixed expression of an idea.
- 13:35David Gerasimow: A trademark is really quite different.
- 13:37David Gerasimow: It's a brand or a logo or uh uh uh a word that signifies a source of goods or services, very commercial ideal uh to be distinguished from copyright, which sounds a little bit more an artist uh artistic ideas, uh, but obviously has commercial value uh as well.
- 13:54David Gerasimow: So I I hope that that uh you know distinguishes trademarks and copyrights um uh for your for you and your listeners.
- 14:03Amanda Perry Carl: Absolutely.
- 14:03Amanda Perry Carl: I think that's a really great distinction there.
- 14:06Amanda Perry Carl: And like you said, I think that those are two for for some reason that really are confused sometimes.
- 14:11Amanda Perry Carl: And I think the way you explain that provides a way for people to kind of visualize the differences and understand those differences.
- 14:19Amanda Perry Carl: Now then trade secrets introduce a whole other element as well into the IP toolkit.
- 14:26Amanda Perry Carl: Can you talk a little bit about that um for our listeners?
- 14:30David Gerasimow: Yeah.
- 14:31David Gerasimow: Trade secrets uh are another body of intellectual property law or type uh of intellectual property.
- 14:37David Gerasimow: They're they're a creature of statute, right?
- 14:39David Gerasimow: States uh have trade secret laws, the federal government uh now has a trade secret law.
- 14:44David Gerasimow: And it's this um it's this notion that you have some uh information, some process, something.
- 14:52David Gerasimow: It can be quite broad, but it has to be secret.
- 14:54David Gerasimow: And the a business, wherever's using that secret, derives value from its secrecy and that they take measures to protect that secrecy.
- 15:06David Gerasimow: So um, you know, a good example would be we have a trade secret barbecue sauce recipe, right?
- 15:12David Gerasimow: It's nobody knows, except a limited set of people, what that recipe is.
- 15:16David Gerasimow: Um, it the fact that you know that barbecue sauce only tastes like that barbecue sauce uh is is gives commercial value.
- 15:24David Gerasimow: And of course, at the barbecue sauce company, only you know, one person knows the complete recipe, something like that.
- 15:30David Gerasimow: So that would be an example of a trade secret.
- 15:32David Gerasimow: And then what we have are acts against trade secrets like misappropriation, an employee who who takes that recipe and and goes to a competitor might uh be uh guilty of trade secret misappropriation under state or federal law.
- 15:47David Gerasimow: And there's uh, you know, recourse that rights owners can take there.
- 15:51David Gerasimow: So it's a it's another body.
- 15:53David Gerasimow: Uh, and and and I really think of trade secrets as the opposite of patents.
- 15:57David Gerasimow: When we apply for a patent, think about the word, it's to be uh clear and transparent.
- 16:02David Gerasimow: We tell the public how our invention works.
- 16:05David Gerasimow: In return, they give us that exclusive monopoly we mention.
- 16:08David Gerasimow: Trade secrets, we don't tell anybody.
- 16:10David Gerasimow: It's the exact opposite.
- 16:11David Gerasimow: We keep it secret, but the law protects it anyway.
- 16:14David Gerasimow: And so I think for someone with a novel invention, they can very much say, I can protect this by getting a patent, or I can try to keep it secret and protect it that way.
- 16:22David Gerasimow: The law uh offers both options.
- 16:25Amanda Perry Carl: And that's a good opportunity there, where if people are trying to decide whether they want to patent it or whether they want to keep that trade secret, where it's good to consult with an intellectual property attorney like yourself to figure out what the best path there is and what the best option there is.
- 16:43Amanda Perry Carl: Um, we like to joke in our family that my granny keeps her recipes as trade secrets.
- 16:48Amanda Perry Carl: Is when she hands you a recipe, it's always missing one ingredient.
- 16:52Amanda Perry Carl: And it's always a key ingredient too, but you don't know about it, but it never turns out right.
- 16:57Amanda Perry Carl: She's 97 and she still doesn't give you her full recipes.
- 17:00Amanda Perry Carl: We like to joke about that in our family.
- 17:04David Gerasimow: Yeah, I think that qualifies.
- 17:07Amanda Perry Carl: Um, you know, in the IP world, just like many areas of the law, we have contractual tools as well.
- 17:13Amanda Perry Carl: Um, and can you talk to us a little bit about some of those contractual tools, NDAs, licensing agreements, you know, other contractual tools that you have in the IP world?
- 17:23David Gerasimow: Yeah, yeah.
- 17:24David Gerasimow: And to tie it with patents, we could say, well, if I own the patent on a particular um invention, you know, you can't use that invention without my permission.
- 17:32David Gerasimow: You know, that that's a government granted right.
- 17:34David Gerasimow: With contracts, those are usually reports between two private parties, and they can create things like confidential um bodies of information, know-how.
- 17:43David Gerasimow: So if we we think of a a non-disclosure agreement, you know, sometimes you might think of that as keeping things uh hush hush.
- 17:49David Gerasimow: You can also say, well, it's between an employer and an employee when they're developing things, the research, the development that's confidential, it eventually becomes know-how, right?
- 17:59David Gerasimow: A company's ability to do business and to do certain technological things uh can be protected with contract.
- 18:06David Gerasimow: Uh at the same time, then it can be transferred by contract, it could be sold, it could be licensed.
- 18:11David Gerasimow: Uh these are valuable things.
- 18:12David Gerasimow: People want access to know-how.
- 18:13David Gerasimow: They don't know how to do things.
- 18:15David Gerasimow: Um, and that's really doesn't have a whole lot to do uh directly with the government.
- 18:19David Gerasimow: You know, they don't they don't grant these rights like they do with patents, trademarks, or copyrights.
- 18:24David Gerasimow: Uh, in some instances, it's it's just it's just uh uh private parties.
- 18:28David Gerasimow: And so certainly to to any listener, you know, always always good to read contracts beforehand because you don't know uh what intellectual property rights you might be gaining or giving up in those in those documents.
- 18:40Amanda Perry Carl: Absolutely.
- 18:40Amanda Perry Carl: I think so often, and and we probably both see it in our practices, um people just assume, well, this is boilerplate language, I'll sign this contract, but it's so important to review every bit of your contract to make sure, like you said, you're not giving up any rights in what someone might think is boilerplate language, but you know, is not and it needs to be read through completely.
- 19:03David Gerasimow: Absolutely.
- 19:04Amanda Perry Carl: So you've given our listeners a really great background um on IP tools, how to use them, some really great information on um why to use them, how to distinguish different tools.
- 19:16Amanda Perry Carl: So let's talk about some hot IP topics in agriculture because there are a lot of them, especially right now.
- 19:24Amanda Perry Carl: One of these issues that I feel like has a lot of attention in the news, um, in politics, in the court system right now, and for good reason in our industry is the right to repair.
- 19:36Amanda Perry Carl: So can you, I know you've been involved in this, can you talk to our listeners about what's going on, kind of basics of what the issues are with tractor software, DIY maintenance, all of that with right to repair and where we are on that and what the legal issues are there?
- 19:52David Gerasimow: Sure.
- 19:52David Gerasimow: And and maybe, you know, start out with just a touch of history.
- 19:56David Gerasimow: Um I think we all know that that tractors and farm machinery in general gener in general, excuse me, has has gotten more complex over time from from you know the invention of cotton gin uh to 200 years ago to now uh that technology has gotten amazingly complex.
- 20:13David Gerasimow: And I think you know, in the last 20, maybe 30 years of farming, we've seen the introduction of smart farming is what we might call it, you know, the use of GPS, uh software um to improve uh you know agricultural output.
- 20:30David Gerasimow: Um at the same time, in tractors, we see and another machinery we see is it's it's not just uh a collection of of you know bits and pieces, it's it's largely a computer.
- 20:40David Gerasimow: You know, it has a computer chip, at least one, and has software running on those computer chips.
- 20:46David Gerasimow: And so, you know, you think of buying a tractor, certainly in the uh in the old days, if you let's say you did not buy it uh on finance, you just bought it out on cash, you you you purchased it, you you owned it outright, and you know, it was yours.
- 21:00David Gerasimow: And and and the law very much supported that with notions of things called the first sale doctrine.
- 21:04David Gerasimow: You know, if someone has a patent on it, that's that's great.
- 21:07David Gerasimow: And uh maybe they're selling something at a profit because of that that um right to exclude competition.
- 21:14David Gerasimow: But once they've sold it, and once that farmer has that tractor, it's his.
- 21:18David Gerasimow: At least it is under the first sale doctrine, and he can do with it what he wants and you can resell it, repair it, whatever.
- 21:23David Gerasimow: And certainly with you know, the um, you know, the with the way the technology was at that time, largely being mechanical, uh uh an individual could do that.
- 21:34David Gerasimow: You know, with with the introduction of software technologies into a tractor, we don't we we don't see uh a full sale of that tractor to to the owner, setting aside issues of like finance and and things like that.
- 21:48David Gerasimow: Just in terms of ownership, is the software in that tractor transferred to the farmer upon sale?
- 21:54David Gerasimow: And the answer is really no.
- 21:56David Gerasimow: What the farmer is doing is taking a license to that.
- 21:59David Gerasimow: that software.
- 22:01David Gerasimow: And of course, then it becomes contractual.
- 22:03David Gerasimow: We were just talking about that.
- 22:05David Gerasimow: And it becomes, well, what are these private parties agreeing to in that contract?
- 22:11David Gerasimow: And you know, it's it's a individuals buying uh farm equipment and people and and the farm equipment manufacturers.
- 22:19David Gerasimow: And so that's that contract uh process isn't exactly a no sheet negotiation.
- 22:24David Gerasimow: It is what it is and will condition um you know how that software can be used in the tractor and how it can be repaired and all sorts of things like that.
- 22:37David Gerasimow: Combined with like the technological complexity of this stuff, it's difficult for individuals to even repair uh current tractors um and you know prevents uh things like third party uh independent repair shops from working on these types of machines as well if if that intellectual property in that software is owned and retained by the the manufacturers, it can really prevent that type of third party competition and and impact farmers that way.
- 23:07Amanda Perry Carl: So that's where I think of the the the right of repair issue it's it's kind of legal basis um and I think why it's important certainly in uh the agultural agronomic field I I think like I said earlier you know we we see a lot about this in the news and I think that's a really good breakdown of what the issues are and how we got to this point, the historical background and then what the intellectual property and the legal issues are there and why there is this struggle and there's that contractual contractual issue there.
- 23:41Amanda Perry Carl: We also have a lot of emerging technology and agriculture and precision farming and data ownership and and um artificial intelligence.
- 23:51Amanda Perry Carl: And I know my kids throw around AI all the time.
- 23:55David Gerasimow: They just throw out the letters AI all the time and think everything is AI but let's talk about real AI here in emerging technology and in agriculture can you talk about some of the issues that you see there um from your perspective yeah I'll I'll I'll stick to the legal issues on on on that um you know we I'm I'm I'm sure AI is is you know providing all sorts of new and novel benefits to to folks in in in agriculture legally I I don't know if if they're facing unique issues uh compared to everybody else and in that regard I would say we have things like data ownership and I I'd mentioned smart uh smart farming out earlier there's a lot of data that can come from from farm operations that data can be useful and it's useful of course for the farmer but it's useful to to others as well and so when I think of you know issues facing uh people today it's well you know if you're using software if you're using AI tools uh in in in your farming practices that's great bear in mind you know what the licensing and contract terms that were associated with those and in particular data ownership I think of if if you're uh a smaller operation or a midsite operation I I think as we enter this AI era you know data ownership is going to be key and retaining data ownership and retaining that intelligence over your own operations is important.
- 25:26David Gerasimow: So I think it was emergency excuse me emerging issue I think of you know making sure that you don't just because you want to use a tool give up all your data uh to to do so.
- 25:36David Gerasimow: And so I think in how to actually avoid that, you know, if if we're thinking of of free tools or low-cost tools that you're using typically then you're giving up rights uh marketing of your data uh in order to do that so be mindful of the tools you employ think about inquire about um you know issues like data uh ownership whether you know what privacy provisions that predates AI um that type of issue is you you employ those tools um however uh great and novel they are uh they can have that that legal drawback that comes with them and I want to caution everybody uh against that and like we talked about earlier always make sure you know what's in your contracts and you read everything that's in your contracts and you know to your point earlier sometimes there really isn't any negotiation on the terms of those contracts when you're negotiating when the the agreement is with a large company and it's their standard agreement it's not like you're going to be able to negotiate some of those terms out but know what's in there and understand what you're agreeing to and decide is this something I really want to use because I'd have to give up these these rights.
- 26:48David Gerasimow: Yeah I think that's I think that's right.
- 26:50David Gerasimow: And you know it's whether it's for farm machine makers or for uh software providers I mean they they put these limitations on for reasons that they think uh are valid and you know believe that protects their investments in in these things.
- 27:07David Gerasimow: And so you know that's uh what they're offering they have their reasons for it and and I I agree uh it's just a a decision informed decision of do you want to use it or not and are those terms acceptable to you now for our listeners out there who may be new to this whole um intellectual property topic and um who might be starting up a business, whether that's agricultural or otherwise, which might involve or need to involve IP protection um as we wrap up here before we get to our final questions can you talk to our listeners a little bit about the strategic value of having an IP portfolio uh sure um yeah you know when I think of people uh starting out I actually think of I don't think of patents first I think of trademarks I think if people are doing any business that's consumer-facing they should think about that brand identity and specifically that legal requirement at least for distinctiveness uh and I I you know I'm not I don't I I try not to tell marketing folks what to do or business folks what to do but I always think of uh a distinctive name one that uh people will remember and will not confuse with others is is at least in my uh sense a good business idea a good marketing idea and the law uh protects that so pick a good name first don't don't wait to too too long and then I would say if you have more than one person in your venture you should probably have pretty good contracts specifying you know rights and responsibilities of everybody there.
- 28:46David Gerasimow: You know if it's a partnership you know partnerships often turn sour.
- 28:51David Gerasimow: And so um just uh an understanding of what what people are putting in and what they can expect out.
- 28:56David Gerasimow: I think those are the like if if you did those two things I think you'd be pretty far along the way uh to to a great start and then you know in terms of portfolio well look people always ask um you know how many patents do you have how many trademarks these these types of of questions and so if you're looking to build any sort of value this is this is the thing type of thing people ask and it's not just a a numbers question there is real substance there.
- 29:24David Gerasimow: We say you know if it's an idea and it's not protected by a patent well in America then someone can take that idea and do it better and and they don't owe you anything.
- 29:33David Gerasimow: And so the patent is the way to to protect against um that type of outflow of of intellectual property.
- 29:40David Gerasimow: And so if anyone's going to invest in a company or or take it seriously usually a portfolio of of protection uh is is is a must and and shows a commitment to to protecting like all that investment that people put into building their businesses and building great products and services um you know Lenture property exists to to protect that so um you know take advantage of it and and you know help it uh uh help you grow your business I think that's great advice um for anybody that's out there listening now before we move on to our final questions do you have any um anything else that you would like to discuss or tell our listeners um about what you do intellectual property in general any um anything else before we move on oh uh sure um you know I I you know I think it's you're a lawyer right Amanda so you know you there's the legal system I think some of your listeners you know can can question you know uh the legal system are they happy with results in any given case are they happy with it overall I think the same thing can be true with the intellectual property system you know I think it is an area uh that on the one hand um provides um incredible incentive to invest in research and development that protects that I think really contributes to a lot of the great things uh that we have access to um you know in today's culture um you know and on the other hand I think it's it's nonetheless an area at least as a body of law that could be you know reformed I think there's areas of improvement but I wouldn't um and maybe I'll I'll add one I I think software protection is an area where I don't think the law's caught up very well with the reality of what software is and what it takes to develop.
- 31:27David Gerasimow: So personally I might like to see some reform uh in that area.
- 31:32David Gerasimow: Um but I guess in in terms of what to communicate then, you know, there's there's uh while there may be small uh areas that could be reformed and improved, I think overall intellectual property is a a really great body of law that that that contributes I think to uh Americans uh competitive advantage and it's a good thing.
- 31:53Amanda Perry Carl: Thank you so much for sharing that and I always like to end my podcast with some fun personal questions because I think it's really cool for our listeners to get to know our guests on a personal basis as well.
- 32:04Amanda Perry Carl: So first of all what do you like to do for fun outside of work?
- 32:10David Gerasimow: Uh I enjoy playing the piano very much.
- 32:16David Gerasimow: Uh I was a classically trained pianist growing up 13 years of training and I find that when I get uh any free time I uh often find myself playing piano.
- 32:28Amanda Perry Carl: That is awesome.
- 32:28Amanda Perry Carl: My 13 year old plays multiple instruments and I always tell him piano is where he needs to focus because you can use that skill your whole life so that's really awesome.
- 32:38David Gerasimow: I agree with MIA I had taken up the trumpet uh later on and I I uh I I'll say I found it a simpler instrument it really only produces one note at a time and so uh I think of the the piano as a more versatile if if not the most versatile instrument and and love it for that reason.
- 32:58Amanda Perry Carl: Well that is awesome.
- 32:59Amanda Perry Carl: Now what is one place that your family loves to visit in your local area that our listeners might not know about I like to ask this especially when I have guests that are from around the country not just here in Florida I think it exposes our listeners to some local spots around the country.
- 33:16David Gerasimow: Uh sure so I uh I I grew up in I grew up in Wisconsin uh and uh spend my weekends there if you look if you so so I don't know your viewers probably don't know much about Wisconsin geography I'd say look at look at your the back of your left hand put your four fingers together and extend the thumb out so it's kind of out on its own that thumb is Door County Wisconsin it's completely surrounded by water.
- 33:40David Gerasimow: It's some people call it the Cape Cod of the Midwest I would say it's uh a lot less crowded and you know more Midwest um but it's a really great place you know it's got a lot of family stuff but a lot of nature uh a lot of good restaurants uh and we go up every year and so do a lot of folks from the area it's a very Midwest center but I I I bet people in Florida don't know it as well.
- 34:02David Gerasimow: I think it's a great area um and we certainly don't go on there.
- 34:05Amanda Perry Carl: I'd be willing to bet most people in Florida don't know about that.
- 34:08Amanda Perry Carl: So that is a really good share we might have to bring our kids up there.
- 34:12Amanda Perry Carl: Sounds like their kind of place in our kind of place.
- 34:15Amanda Perry Carl: Yeah it's great and one last question you kind of shared a fun fact with the piano because I did not know that about you what is another random little known fun fact about you I uh I I like to collect maps.
- 34:36David Gerasimow: I have hundreds of maps you know the kind of that fold atlases um I don't I don't necessarily know why uh and I I just have a terrible time throwing any of them away you know you get them every time you go to a park or something uh I have many of them and so uh I have some displayed in the office even here uh some of the older ones that I I like always always appreciated maybe it's the computer science and map and they very uh analytical like that but maybe that does maybe that counts.
- 35:04Amanda Perry Carl: I really like that we uh my husband and I always search for old maps when we travel anywhere in antique stores because we're always on a mission to find an old one of our area here in Florida.
- 35:15Amanda Perry Carl: So that money because we're always we have not found one yet.
- 35:19Amanda Perry Carl: We find ones of other parts of Florida other places in the South but have not found one of the St.
- 35:24David Gerasimow: John's River here where we live well good luck good luck on that uh particular quest I I I find that they're usually pretty accessible price wise from you know the 1800 1900 it's not you just not that much interest in it so you can usually find some pretty pretty interesting stuff at least to me uh uh good collectible price bond.
- 35:44Amanda Perry Carl: Well I'll I'll stay on the mission for it then I'll look out too well I want to thank you so much for your time today and for our listeners I'm also going to include a link to David's firm's website in the text on the podcast posting and also on our social media posts.
- 36:02Amanda Perry Carl: That way if you ever have a need for an intellectual property attorney um you have his contact information.
- 36:08Amanda Perry Carl: And David thank you so much for coming on today.
- 36:10Amanda Perry Carl: I think this is such great information for people.
- 36:12Amanda Perry Carl: Yeah thanks for having me it was a great time thanks thank you for listening to the Legal Field Podcast for more content please visit the Facebook page of FloridaAdLaw or go to FloridaAdLaw.com and join us next time on a LegalField podcast