Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E221 Black Mesa: Hostiles by JoAcoNS (Apr 2026)
Transcript
- Phil Rice 01:00 welcome to a now for something completely machinima, the podcast about machinima, virtual production and related technologies. My name is Phil rice, and I'm here with my co hosts, Damien Valentine, hello and Tracy Harwood, hello. So this week, we are looking at a pick that was a recommendation and from one of our listeners, and Tracy has decided to make it her pick for this week. So Tracy, why don't you tell us about it? Tracy Harwood 01:29 Absolutely, yeah. Okay, so hostiles are half life short SFM is what it says. And actually, this is a pick we owe to Logan Campbell, Logan, thanks for sharing this with us. It's so good I could not resist sharing it with you guys. So let me go through what I thought about it, and then let's let's hear what you guys think. Okay, so at first glance, hostiles is basically a short, tense, Half Life type vignette built around the arrival of the heku soldiers. Do you call them that heku during, during what appears to be the black Misa incident? The pacing of it is really tight. The action is kind of staged with cinematic intent, and the lighting and animation suggests the sort of Polish we've come to associate with really high end Source Filmmaker work. Frankly, the camera language, especially, I think stands out you've got these kind of really measured tracking shots, a sort of sense of spatial awareness and most moments of kind of stillness that really build tension before this kind of burst of gunfire. It's really atmospheric and really, really brilliantly well done in terms of the the build up of it. However, this was not actually made in source, filmmaker, in fact, in the Creator, a guy called JOA cons created hostiles, primarily in Gary's mod, a tool that in machinima circles often carries a reputation for being really rough and ready animation or meme driven comedy, rather than this kind of cinematic storytelling we see in this in this short, the creator even intentionally labeled the project as Source Filmmaker when promoting it, precisely because that stigma can make audiences dismiss Gmod work before even giving it a chance, and which, in this case, would certainly be a real pity. If you didn't see this, you would definitely miss out. So this is a film, really, that doubles as a kind of small experiment in perception, and it works, you know, it's, it's brilliant. I think my perspective watching hostiles without that content context, you would really assume it was made in source. I mean, the lighting, the animation, the posing, the camera, just, I mean, it just demonstrates how much craft can be achieved with the with the tool, which clearly is so often underestimated, and it it really becomes much less about the software and much more about the technique, you know, with the composition, the editing, the timing, the understanding, and what have you, and what makes it, I think Even more interesting is that this guy has actually also produced a bunch of tutorials alongside the film, which he's published to demonstrate just how he achieved the effects in this particular short. And I think that moves this short hostiles from being just a piece of machinima to being rude. Quite a learning resource as well, which contributes back to the community, rather than just showcasing his his very evident individual skill. I think it's, I think it's a really fascinating approach to doing this, and it embodies everything that we have known about machinima, and have grown up loving about machinima, which is the strength of community angle as well. I think narratively, it's really, I mean, it's a beautifully told sort of story. It's deliberately quite simple, this sort of squad of soldiers going through this really tense environment, and that tension just builds as the sort of situation escalates. It, you know, it kind of, you know, it plays into that half life chapter that we've we've kind of got got hostiles, and it ends up as a disastrous kind of shootout for for the soldiers that we're we're observing here, it's, it's not a complex plot. It's entirely built on atmosphere. You know, you can hear the footsteps echoing through these kind of corridors, these, you know, you can see these soldiers with their weapons ready in in position, and, you know, something quite awful is going to going to happen to them just around the next corner. It's really quite a disturbing battle scene in many ways. I mean, last month we showed some really, quite horrific battles, battle type scenes this, this is nonetheless horrific in many ways. And actually it turns out, though, in this, the winner is not quite the person you don't expect them to be, which is a slightly I call that a lighter moment, I suppose, really. But I think what I liked was the the editing style, the way it's it conveys what's going on here that, you know, you hear heavy breathing. You hear this soldiers talking to one another. But you know, even things like water dripping become quite intense in this, in this, in this short, there's some really interesting cuts and edits. I think I'm quite impressed with the use of perspective, and I think the sound design of it is absolutely stellar. It's outstanding. It's, yeah, it's a fascinating example of what it is really I think the most interesting part for me is that it is not actually paid in Source Filmmaker, yeah. I think it raises lots of interesting questions about, you know, given, given that it's made in G mod, I mean, the question, the obvious question is, why position it as something else? And I think you know we, we obviously know the answer to that. But then it does raise a lot of questions about, you know, the these sort of internal hierarchies that we see play out across the Machinima community about which games should be used and which shouldn't be used, and, you know, questions about authenticity and and and disclosure in terms of, you know, how stuff is made and how it's presented to an audience. And I think this very cleverly transcends a lot of the challenges that we've come across over the years. So yeah, I think I think it's a great pick Logan. I really enjoyed taking a look at it and thinking about the implications of it, really. But before I sort of say any more, I think I'll hand over to to you guys and be fascinating to hear what you think about it. Damien Valentine 09:05 Well, I was going to open with a question, but you've kind of answered it already. Oh, and that was how, like, how was this made? But obviously I know that it's labeled as Source Filmmaker, and I read the description where he says, Actually, know I pull the prank on you. It's Gary's mod. But the question was still how, because this looks absolutely stunning, way beyond what I would expect anything from either of those tools to be able to produce from the smoothness of the animation, like the way those soldiers are moving. They're not just walking down with guns. They're twitchy, and they're looking around, and the guns are moving slightly in different positions the heads. They've got very subtle movements that you'd expect soldiers to have in a tense combat situation, that the animations that would have come with the game wouldn't have had because at the time. Time the game was made, they didn't need to put that kind of detail in. I mean, obviously, though you have soldiers running around with guns, but they're not going around like this, and that's a really poor imitation of what they're doing in the in the film, but you get the idea of what I'm talking about, but also just the way it's rendered out as well. This looks something like you'd expect with an unreal video. It does not a source video from a game that's 20 years old. So I imagine there must be some very extensive mods here to boost the visual quality. But when you kind of answered it by saying that there's tutorials, yes, and guides, so imagine what links to, yeah, so if I watch those, I'll probably get the answer to that, how question, Tracy Harwood 10:50 and I can't answer those questions because I didn't watch the tutorial videos. But okay, they're definitely there. Yeah. Damien Valentine 10:56 Well, we've talked before that the source filmmake. I know it's not a used but the Source Filmmaker is incredibly difficult tool to use. I don't know anything about Gary's mod. I've never played it, so I have no idea how difficult it is to make anything with that other than I would not expect this to be made with it from some of the other Gary's mods, films he looked at, or for the show, or just in general. So this is a very impressive thing. You've got that tension. The person who kills them all is not what I expected the reveal. So I'm not going to say, well, that is, because that completely caught me by surprise. And I just kind of, Oh, that makes a lot of sense, and it kind of gives you a different perspective on the game. Yeah, but that's all I'm going to say about that, because it's worth having that surprise as you watch it. Yeah, it's very intense. And yeah, again, I just don't know how long it would have taken to make something this good with Gary's mod, because just Gary's mod usually produces comedy videos, not something as quite as dark and intense as this. So, yeah, very impressed. Yeah. Phil Rice 12:17 So Gary's mod is, it's reliant a lot on, well, it gives the the Creator very easy access to ragdoll physics for the characters. First of all, which just lends itself to comedy uses. And then, you know, kind of still poses, you know, using a tool we actually saw the wolf ram a few weeks back, and she used a Gary's mod tool in that to kind of distort the body model to make the RAM character. To answer Damien's question is, you know, we know SFM is notoriously difficult to use and get good results out of I don't think Gary's mod is any easier. It's hard in a different kind of way. And arguably, there's more community support and documentation and maybe a little bit more, I don't know, wiggle room to with Gary's mod than there is with Source Filmmaker. But they're both, they're both tough and to do something that doesn't look janky and, you know, comedy very, very challenging. So to clear the air a little bit on some of the mystery of, how does this look so good. It is important to remember that Gary's mod is a Source Engine environment, so really the only so they have access to the same lighting and textures and characters and cameras and all of those things as you would in Source Filmmaker. It's just the access to them is a different method, but they're all still there. It's all the same. So the render and everything would this is all this has always been possible with Gary's mod. It's just it because of its almost Roblox type reputation that it came up with of just get in there and just fool around people making Rube Goldberg machines and things like that. It just never really attracted serious filmmakers, whereas Source Filmmaker, I think people coming at that are people that maybe their introduction to those tools was something like Paul Marino's still seeing Breen, where he used face poser and different things like that to to make something that's kind of austere and very professional looking and serious and stuff. And yeah, that's not been Gary's mods bread and butter at all. It's not who it attracted. So this is it's interesting. And it gives a very It must have been a very interesting conundrum for the filmmaker to try to decide how to position this, because that's really what it was about, is he's wanting to get it in front of an audience. This is a this is a film made for an SF for a Source Filmmaker, fan audience, but made with Gary's mod tools. So if he just made it a Gary's mod film, he wouldn't get the eyes on it that he wanted to. So it's like, he calls it a prank, but no, I think it was a very smart strategy, understanding the audience that he was really going for it. Part of me wonders was was part of the decision that the filmmaker pondered whether or not to leave off any reference to how it was made in the title, and just now, then, then it's a matter of it's even harder to find an audience when you're just going straight for the world. But this is so good that part of me wonders if it isn't one of those that you'd want to put out there, and then have people ask, how did you do this? Yeah, how did you make because they can't tell it kind of looks source filmicry. But then there's these certain the way he walked up the steps this one point, it's like, doesn't look like the normal key framed animation. What's going on. But ultimately, his goal was he or he or she. Their goal was to get this film in front of eyes that are going to appreciate it. This was probably the best, best call to do that, because this does fit right in with the good quality Source Filmmaker stuff that's out there in terms of tempo, in terms of content, in terms of taking itself seriously. You know, it was a good call. So anyway, that's, that's what I had to say about the making of it. It's astonishingly good. We've talked about the animation on racer. I won't spend too much time on that, but just pulling this off in Gary's mod, like even having played with Gary's mod a little bit, I don't, I can't even imagine how much work this took to get things looking so good. And by that, I'm referring specifically to the animation, because that's really that's the unique factor of Gary's mod versus Source Filmmaker is how the animation happens, that everything else is they've got a level playing field so remarkable constructed as a film, it's just astoundingly Good. Point of View, like you mentioned, Tracy, is just, that's just right on the money. That's really what this is about. It's, it's, it's, it's a very strategic and deliberate attempt to get us in the head of at least one of these soldiers, to get us empathizing with them. And then there's this punch at the end the punch line, so to speak, although I didn't find any humor in it at all. I'll explain why in a minute, but, yeah, very, very effective. There's he used some cinematic tropes to get there, and I don't resent it at all. Like there's one point where the character, the character we've been following is kind of having a panic attack and breathing really heavy. His heart's rushing. And you hear, you know, when blood rushes into your head, into your ears, and your hearing gets muffled, muffled. Thank you. High frequencies get get sloped and they that's the that's just we were already, I think, on the precipice of fully empathizing with this character. And that is just a way to just grab us by the lapels and pull us right into that character's body, because we know what that sensation sounds like, and we're just there with him, and it was at just the right moment in the narrative too, because not too long after that is the reveal. Yeah, we won't spoil the reveal, although it's probably not terribly difficult to guess, but I will say this if you are not familiar with the if the half life and half life two general narrative, then this won't make any the ending won't make any sense to you, like if you haven't, if you know nothing about half life, the ending will make no sense to you. If you've ever played half life, or are at all familiar with the narrative, it will make tremendous sense to you, and it is just brilliant, and it's it's shocking, and Damien said it best, I think it kind of turns your whole perspective on its head of how. You've been looking at things, it's helpful to reflect on whether or not you've played the game. It's helpful to know that these soldiers that we're seeing when we're first introduced to those soldiers, it's in a first person shooter in half life, the original Half Life game, when you're first introduced to him. It's quite a dramatic scene, because it's the first time you've encountered anything like that. You're you're on your way escaping out of this, this scientific facility that where this, this incident has happened, and it's your first the first encounter you get with these soldiers is the sound of them talking on their communicators that that distorted vocal sound. And then you catch them running here and there and and then they are the most fierce combatants that you've that you have ever faced in the game. Like, it's a really big deal, and it's a really hard thing to get by the first time you play it. And then throughout Half Life, these, these come back, but these are commandos. They are portrayed, you get the feeling that they're human, but they're portrayed as these automatons. They're just relentless killing machines. They are out to take you down. They're relatively fearless, they're brutal, and they seem to just keep coming and coming. And they're, they're truly, it's the the first really, truly fearful thing that you encounter in the half life universe is these guys. So keep that in mind as you watch this and you see how this narrative unfolds and what this film maker succeeds in doing in terms of your attitude towards these characters, it is nothing short of remarkable. It's, it's really, truly this, this, this is a these characters have been understood in one way for over 20 years, and he changed everything here. Phil Rice 22:04 We've seen someone do that with the combine, but they've done it through comedy. Zach Scott lit fuse films did some comedy stuff where the characters were combine, and one of them had a bucket on his head the whole time. Do you remember that? And kind of talked like Kenny from South Park, you know. And in a weird way, they Tracy Harwood 22:28 used igneous solace. Wasn't Phil Rice 22:32 Ignis Solis was made with Team Fortress too. I believe. Okay, I'm getting Yeah, this other one was called, I can't remember what the title of it was, but it was a short series, a brief series. They did a couple episodes of it, and it was like a situation comedy of, if you were you familiar with the the US television show cops from the 90s. It basically was a reality TV show that a camera crew would ride along with police officers on night patrol and see them encounter real situations, pulling people over for being drunk or, you know, disorderly or whatever. And it was just, it just caught the whole country by storm when it was out. It was popular on TV for a decade, and they were kind of, if I remember the series right, the lit fuse thing was kind of, kind of spoofing that. So these cops, you know, the combine, that's kind of their role in that, that authoritarian society, and they're having these red versus blue type conversations, you know, about things that aren't related to their work and stuff like that. So that kind of humanized the combine that those types of things, and that became a popular thing to do after that, but I've never seen it done in a serious fashion for these commandos who aren't ever thought to be alien or under some kind of compulsion other than being in the military, they are just an elite military squad who is portrayed as soulless and brutal and oh, it's just, it's amazing what he pulls off in the short to that it totally, totally turns that around. Totally changes that idea that they can be vulnerable, that they can be scared. These are things we've never seen these characters do in the games. They're never scared. They're and they're never off mission. They don't stop and have panic attacks. You know, they don't care about each other in the game, like they don't have military band of brothers type camaraderie, like real soul. Soldiers would have that they're just, it's like it's been bred out of them. They just, they don't. So this just opens up. It For Me, it when I suspended disbelief and just really dove into the film, I just thought, how many, how much of what I thought I knew about these soldiers were just assumptions. And are they really just, you know, this is some mother's son, you know, like these humanizing moments, I think that probably happened in real warfare from time to time too. You see the other side as just the enemy, and they're just trying to kill me, so I got to kill them. And then sometimes you'll hear these stories where it's like the veil is lifted, and you realize, oh, they're just like me, you know, they missed their their girl back home. They, you know, they, they lost their brother, they, they just want to go home. They're hungry, you know. So this was, this was kind of a way of shedding light on the humanity of these characters that were thought to have none I just, I can't tell you how much I love that. And the ending was a surprise to me. Total shock. Production values, off the charts. Good sound design, mostly off the charts good. The one thing, the only criticism I have of this film is the footstep sound for the what turns out to be the bad guy character. It sounds like he's running around in boots made of steel. And it's the same sound, repeated and repeated and repeated. And it it really, that's the only thing. I think the reason that it upsets me is because it it pulled me out of the narrative that I really wanted to stay immersed in. But it just, it's just too repetitive. It didn't sound like real footsteps. It ended up being employed cleverly as a device to associate that specific sound with the specific character in the movie. In that regard, it worked well. It made it different from the other footsteps, but it just, it just wasn't executed. Great. That one sound, that's the only one. Everything else in this was just fantastic. It's wonderfully mixed. And then visually, yeah, the edit is just insanely good. So I loved this film. So who, what? Logan, thank you, Logan, Logan, for sending this our way. It is great. It is one that I've bookmarked permanently, and we'll return to again and again. It's just great stuff. All right. Well, no one else, anything else that is our film for this week. Those in the audience, we'd love to hear what you think of this one. Go watch it and then come back and comment here or drop us an email at talk at completely machinima.com my name is Phil rice, and on behalf of my co hosts, Tracy and Damian, we will see you next time, right bye, bye. You.