Latest / Film And Whiskey / Million Dollar Baby (2004) / Monkey Shoulder Blended Scotch
Transcript
- 0:01In 2004, director Clint Eastwood and star Hilary Swank gave the
- 0:05world a poignant picture of a man broken by the weight of his
- 0:08love. In 2023, we try a whiskey that
- 0:12tries to carry that weight on its shoulder.
- 0:15The film is $1,000,000 Baby. The whiskey is monkey Shoulder.
- 0:19And we'll review them both. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:23podcast. Welcome to the Film in Whiskey
- 0:43podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:47glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:49I'm Brad. G.
- 0:50And this week we are revisiting Clint Eastwood's 2004 Best
- 0:54Picture winner, $1,000,000 Baby. $1,000,000 Baby.
- 0:59Brad, this was the fifth ever movie that we reviewed on the
- 1:03Film and Whiskey podcast. Holy.
- 1:05Cow. I went back and listened to our
- 1:07season 1 episode on this movie and I have to say before I go,
- 1:12before I go any further, what we're doing this season is we
- 1:15are going back and re reviewing all of our season 1 movies
- 1:18because we were just babies. We didn't know what we were
- 1:21doing. We didn't know how to podcast
- 1:23and we. Definitely were not worth
- 1:25$1,000,000. No, not at all.
- 1:27I have to say, man, of all of the Season 1 crappy audio
- 1:30adventures I've had, this was unlistenable.
- 1:34I don't know what happened, but like, you know, I do this thing
- 1:37sometimes where like when I make my s s, I kind of whistle a
- 1:40little bit and I have to try to edit that out and post.
- 1:43And in Season 1, I was like, let's do the opposite of that,
- 1:46let's turn that bad. But I sounded like freaking
- 1:49Jiminy Cricket given a little whistle.
- 1:51It was like I had to turn it off after 10 minutes.
- 1:54I don't even know what we said about this movie.
- 1:56Or like the Gopher and Winnie the Pooh.
- 1:58Oh my gosh, it was worse than that.
- 2:00It like, truly, I'm so glad that we are redoing this just so I
- 2:04can eliminate that audio from existence.
- 2:07Yeah. If anything we should just take
- 2:09a transcript from that and just re re say all the same things.
- 2:14It probably was OK content but just the worst audio you've ever
- 2:19heard. Hideous to listen to.
- 2:23All right, so we're revisiting $1,000,000 baby.
- 2:26And I have to say in the 10 minutes that I listened to that
- 2:29episode, Brad, I have very different thoughts on this movie
- 2:32than I did in Season 1. And so I'm, I'm really, really
- 2:35glad we're getting the chance to redo this, man.
- 2:38Bobby Book coming in with a hot take.
- 2:41He likes this movie now. I do I this.
- 2:43Is a good movie. Oh my gosh, Bob, I am here to
- 2:47tell you that this movie is dope.
- 2:51It's really good, man. It's.
- 2:53Really freaking good dude. I have so many more observations
- 2:57than I did back in Season 1. Before we go any further, I on
- 3:02Hilary Swank and I don't know what I was thinking because she
- 3:06is like, I get you can debate whether the character is well
- 3:09written. She freaking knocks it out of
- 3:12the park. Man.
- 3:13She is so good at this movie. Yeah.
- 3:16And I I was reading that they almost chose Sandra Bullock for
- 3:20this. Nope.
- 3:21But the Yeah, it. We'll get to that point in a
- 3:25second. Her production schedule for Miss
- 3:27Congeniality 2 got in the way. I just needed everybody to.
- 3:35Know hate when that happens. I just needed everybody to know
- 3:39that fact about this movie. You should have saved that for
- 3:44two facts and a falsehood because I would have been like,
- 3:46there's no way that's true. That's ridiculous.
- 3:52But yeah, so that's why she didn't make it.
- 3:54And let's just talk for a second about how terrible she would
- 3:59have been in this. Role Listen, I like Sandra
- 4:02Bullock. This this role required.
- 4:05In order to keep this role from being a complete caricature, you
- 4:08have to get perhaps the best actress of her generation to
- 4:12play it. And Hilary Swank just nails it,
- 4:16man. I mean, we've we've talked, you
- 4:17know, we talked back in Season 1 about this, but the obvious
- 4:20talking point here was the physical transformation, the
- 4:23fact that she did the like, Robert De Niro, Raging Bull,
- 4:26gaining 30 lbs of muscle thing. And yeah, I mean, you can see
- 4:29it. She looks incredible.
- 4:31But it's so much more than that. Yeah, you, you can tell that she
- 4:37lived in this character. Like it, it is such a, this is
- 4:41my favorite word to describe my favorite performances.
- 4:45It's such a sincere performance, Bob.
- 4:48Like the authenticity is oozing out of her that she understands
- 4:54this character and and and this character's psyche on an
- 4:58incredibly deep level. Brad, I think we have a lot of
- 5:01good things to say about this movie, but before we get into
- 5:03any of them, we need to hit pause so that we can introduce
- 5:06our first segment of the day, America's favorite segment,
- 5:10which we call Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 5:13movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 5:17ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 5:20Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 5:23podcast where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he
- 5:26has just seen, often for the first time.
- 5:30Which is not true at all this season.
- 5:33That's no, not at all. Like, not even one time.
- 5:35I don't even know why I'm saying the whole thing.
- 5:37Yeah, I think you did. A Brad explains on this.
- 5:41In Season 1, we had already, like, even by season or by
- 5:44episode 5, we had said, like, all right, go ahead and explain
- 5:47the movie. I can tell you with certainty it
- 5:49was not 60 seconds long. I was going to say, can we just
- 5:53talk about how long the Gone with the Wind explanation was?
- 5:58It was a solid 9 minutes. Of me talking and I remember it
- 6:02ended with me being like, and that's intermission.
- 6:05Like we got to the halfway mark and then we were like, you know
- 6:08what, if you just want to know about Gone With the Wind?
- 6:10Just go watch it. Yep.
- 6:14I'm so glad that we implemented the 62nd timer here.
- 6:17That might have kept the podcast alive.
- 6:21All right, Brad, we are. So listen, if you have not seen
- 6:24$1,000,000 Baby, it has been over 20 years at this point
- 6:27since it came out. I'm sure that someone in your
- 6:30life has spoiled it for you, but if you have somehow managed to
- 6:34not have this movie spoiled, you need to keep it that way.
- 6:37Yeah, it's a great boxing film. Go watching and nothing else.
- 6:41Right. And nothing, nothing else.
- 6:43Brad is going to spoil this movie in his breakdown of the
- 6:47plot, so if you have not seen it, go watch it and then come
- 6:50back. Brad, you have 60 seconds on the
- 6:52clock. Spoil this movie and go.
- 6:56Hilary Swank sucks, Clint Eastwood helps her not suck, and
- 7:00then she falls and breaks her neck and he pulls the plug on
- 7:02her. Wow.
- 7:05Boom. I like how you said Hilary Swank
- 7:07sucks, not in like her character like Hilary Swank.
- 7:10The human being sucks. Yeah, she's terrible.
- 7:15All I could ever think about whenever Hilary Swank comes up
- 7:20is that often episode. You know what, man, I got to be
- 7:24honest with you and like I, I don't mean to be the wet blanket
- 7:27here, but it, it really bums me out that Hilary Swank, you know,
- 7:33I'm watching her like do TV shows and stuff now.
- 7:36And I think the fact that she is not necessarily, like, the most
- 7:38conventionally attractive actress, even though, like, you
- 7:43know, that episode of The Office where people are talking about
- 7:45her, like, as if she's actually ugly, I have never thought that
- 7:48she is an unattractive person. Like, you don't get to be in
- 7:51movies if your face isn't a little bit symmetrical, you know
- 7:54what I'm saying? Like, yeah, I, I, I really do
- 7:57think that not just that Office episode, but that kind of rumor,
- 8:03whatever you want to call it, really chased her for a long
- 8:06time. And I think it kept her from
- 8:07having the kind of career that she deserved to have.
- 8:09She wins two Oscars in a five year span and then just kind of
- 8:13goes away and like, yeah, it's not fair to her.
- 8:17She's such a good actress. Yeah, I know she she is a great
- 8:20actress. I feel like there are certain TV
- 8:24actresses or actors that like, make their way to Hollywood for
- 8:29a few films and then eight years later you see them back, like
- 8:33headlining ATV show. You know, that makes sense for
- 8:36them. Doesn't make sense for Hilary
- 8:38Swank man. No, I'd like.
- 8:40I think everybody thought that she was going to be the Meryl
- 8:44Streep of her generation, and those opportunities just never
- 8:47really ended up presenting themselves to her, and it really
- 8:50sucks. Meryl Streep of her generation.
- 8:52That's a That's a bold claim, Bob.
- 8:54Two Oscars in five years, man. She wins an Oscar.
- 8:58Oscar. In in 1999, going into 2000, it
- 9:02was the movie Boys Don't Cry. That was her first, her first
- 9:05Oscar. And then, you know, like she
- 9:08wins an Oscar before Cate Blanchett ever does.
- 9:10She wins an Oscar before Kate Winslet ever does.
- 9:12I feel like these people that we look at as like, oh, they are
- 9:15the actresses of their generation.
- 9:17It was Hilary Swank before it was either one of them.
- 9:20And I think that, like, you know, just to reiterate, it
- 9:23really sucks that we don't laud her as much as she deserves.
- 9:28Yeah, well, I'll tell you this right now.
- 9:30I've never heard of that movie. I I can't even remember the name
- 9:34of it right now. And you just said it 10 seconds
- 9:36ago. It's called.
- 9:36Boys don't cry. Go look at those Don't cry this
- 9:39episode. But we have an episode to
- 9:41discuss right now, Brad. We're talking about $1,000,000
- 9:43baby. I think the obvious point of
- 9:45comparison, and I don't know if you want to do it here or do it
- 9:47after the break. We're going to have to talk
- 9:50about how this is Clint Eastwood's Unforgiven Part 2
- 9:53Electric Boogaloo. Like it it kind of, you know,
- 9:57Unforgiven is Clint making his grand statement where he he
- 10:00first really starts to dig his heels in on the effects of
- 10:04violence and the the effects of violence in his own story and
- 10:09legacy. And I think it's it's following
- 10:12him through all the way to this point.
- 10:13You know, we've done a few Clint Eastwood movies on this podcast
- 10:16now, and even just from Mystic River, a movie we watched for
- 10:20this show coming out the year before this, to this movie, I
- 10:25got to be honest with you, man. Like this movie just feels like
- 10:27it. It goes so much deeper and
- 10:31achieves heights that he really hadn't hit since Unforgiven.
- 10:35Yeah, 100%. He has an ability in this film
- 10:40to tap into the depths of these characters that are written on
- 10:45the screen. And you're not distracted by bad
- 10:49soundtrack the way you are in Mystic River.
- 10:53And you, you don't have, I don't know, you don't have the
- 10:57spectre, you know, not to get too dark or anything, but you
- 11:01don't have the spectre of like childhood sexual abuse hanging
- 11:05over the whole movie. They're like, it's a it is such
- 11:10a uplifting film for the first half.
- 11:12And then, you know, you get to the back half and you understand
- 11:17the pain of what Clint's character goes through because
- 11:22of how uplifting the first half was.
- 11:25Like, you see what an incredible guy he is in the way that he
- 11:28takes care of Big Willy, you know, the first boxer.
- 11:32And you see the way he takes care of Hilary Swank and and you
- 11:35understand the love that he has for this, this girl, this dot,
- 11:40you know, faux daughter that he has.
- 11:43And it's all because Clint is willing to give his characters
- 11:47heart and depth and and allow the camera to sit with them.
- 11:52So after I watch this movie, there was one thing that really
- 11:55blew me away, and it was the way Clint uses the camera in this
- 11:58movie. I think that if there's one
- 12:00thing we've really talked about across all of our Clint Eastwood
- 12:04movies, it's at the cinematography is often quite
- 12:06beautiful, but that he doesn't really use the camera in
- 12:09inventive ways. It's pretty static.
- 12:11It's. Because he only uses 1 take.
- 12:13The first hour and a half of this movie is a very uplifting,
- 12:17albeit conventional rise to stardom sports movie.
- 12:23And yet like it has some of the best in the ring choreography
- 12:28and camera movement that I've ever seen in a boxing movie.
- 12:32And like, we've watched Raging Bull for this for this podcast,
- 12:34we've watched Cinderella Man. I was shocked at how like Clint
- 12:38went handheld with a ton of this camera work in this movie.
- 12:41And you really, it really feels like you are in the ring in a
- 12:45real fight. And I got to give it up to Clint
- 12:48for the ability to have a movie that has so much energy in it.
- 12:53Yeah, well, and you, you feel the power that Hilary Swank
- 12:57brings into the ring. I, I I keep calling her Hilary
- 13:00Swank. What's, what's her character's
- 13:02name? Her.
- 13:02Name's Maggie. Maggie.
- 13:04Fitzgerald yeah. So Maggie, like, fights with
- 13:08such passion and power, and he uses the camera to illustrate
- 13:14that. I I I'm with you, man.
- 13:16I think the other part of the the cinematography that I really
- 13:19loved and I remember talking about in Season 1 was the
- 13:22lighting. Like the way he uses light in
- 13:26this film, for me is reminiscent of like a Citizen Kane, where
- 13:31there's really strong contrast. Yeah, yeah, contrast, but not
- 13:36just like a gradient, like it's like a sharp line between the
- 13:40shadow and the light. And it's a brilliant choice with
- 13:44a movie that ends with such a Gray moral area, to use so many
- 13:52sharp lines, because that's how, you know, Clint's character
- 13:55looks at the world and these sharp lines of black and white,
- 13:58right and wrong. And so you see that through the
- 14:01use of light. But by the end of the film,
- 14:04there's nothing black and white about the decision he has to
- 14:07make. I'm going to pull us out of that
- 14:10moral quandary for a minute to talk more about Clint Eastwood
- 14:13on a on a very superficial level, you know?
- 14:17Brad, he's still, he's still pretty good looking.
- 14:18That's listen, here's what I'm going to say.
- 14:21We don't usually talk about like people's looks and especially
- 14:24their physique on this show because we just don't typically
- 14:28say things like, you know, I really like her body.
- 14:31Like it just makes us sound dumb.
- 14:32However, I have been really impressed watching these Clint
- 14:37Eastwood movies where the man is like, but somewhere between 70
- 14:39and 80 years old and most of the movies we're watching and he
- 14:43doesn't have an old man physique at all.
- 14:45Like the dude's chest is so like he's like washboard like he
- 14:50doesn't have, you can't see like defined pecs, but he doesn't.
- 14:53He also doesn't have saggy old man boobs.
- 14:55And it's it's kind of insane how good of shape he's in in this
- 14:59movie. Yeah, I, I mean, when I think
- 15:02about what Clint Eastwood eats, I feel like he just eats like a
- 15:07can of baked beans and a salad every night.
- 15:11I I don't know, He, he doesn't strike me as a dude to just get
- 15:14fat because he's eating junk all the time.
- 15:17He looks incredible. And you said that he's between
- 15:2070 and 80. I think he might be between 70
- 15:23and 180. I'm not quite sure what age he's
- 15:26at at this point. Oh man.
- 15:29But yeah, the dude looks incredible.
- 15:31I, I am with you 100%. I, you know, I'm over here
- 15:34trying to talk about his skills as a director.
- 15:36But sure, Bob, we we can talk about his looks.
- 15:39Let it be known that one of the first people I've ever fond over
- 15:42on film and whiskey is 76 year old Clint Eastwood or however
- 15:46old he was in the making of this movie.
- 15:49I'm just saying, man, if either of us look half that good at
- 15:52that age, like we have done something right.
- 15:55Yeah, no, 100%. I mean you, you have the height
- 15:59to to to look like him. I'm not.
- 16:02But not the physique. Not, not quite.
- 16:05The physique I I might have the physique.
- 16:06Well, between the two of us. We will look as good.
- 16:10Clint Eastwood. Yep.
- 16:13All right, man, I do want to talk about these performances a
- 16:15little bit. We've already talked about
- 16:16Hilary Swank. This might be the best Clint
- 16:19Eastwood performance. And I said that with Unforgiven,
- 16:22and I said it with Gran Torino. And I think it's crazy how you
- 16:26get various shades of the Clint Eastwood persona, but that he is
- 16:34he's really camping out within those silos in each of those
- 16:38movies, like the Unforgiven. Will money in Unforgiven is not
- 16:42the same character as this character.
- 16:44And his character in Grant Torino is very different than
- 16:46this character. And, and honestly, I think what
- 16:49I really love about this character is that he's the most
- 16:51openly loving person in this movie that he is in in any of
- 16:56these three films. Like once, once she cracks
- 16:59through his kind of, you know, hard exterior, he is like he's
- 17:03head over heels for her. And that's what leads to the
- 17:06tragedy of the movie. But to see that kind of warmth
- 17:09coming from Clint Eastwood is something that you don't
- 17:12typically see. And it was a really welcome
- 17:14departure for me here. Yeah, 100%.
- 17:17And you kind of see it early in the film when you know he's
- 17:20talking to Big Willy and you know, he, he pays to have the
- 17:24guy's car taken care of. And, and the brokenness that you
- 17:28see him feel when Willy leaves him as his trainer is so deep
- 17:35and heartfelt. And it sets the stage for the
- 17:38rest of the film. And I, I think that maybe the
- 17:42first time I watched this, I felt like they spent a little
- 17:44bit too much time leading up to Clint's training.
- 17:47Maggie. I thought it was just the right
- 17:50amount of time on this watch through.
- 17:53Yeah. I mean, I think we are going to
- 17:54get into talking about the script and the issues that I
- 17:56still have with this script. That might be a good
- 17:59conversation to have on the back end of this episode because I do
- 18:02want to emphasize, like overall this movie is wildly successful.
- 18:07And I think that I let the deficiencies in the script
- 18:10really weigh my score down. In Season 1 I think I only gave
- 18:13this like a 7 1/2. You give it a 7A.
- 18:17Seven. Wow.
- 18:18Yeah, that was dumb. However, I will say, I mean,
- 18:21even at this point, I will say this.
- 18:22If we're comparing this kind of directly to Unforgiven and as
- 18:26kind of like, you know, spiritual cousins or whatever, I
- 18:30think that Unforgiven is still more successful at identifying
- 18:35the point that it's trying to make and then like directly
- 18:39targeting everything it does in the movie to address that point.
- 18:43Like, I think there's still, I'm still kind of muddied on exactly
- 18:47what the point of this movie is. Like what is the underlying not
- 18:51just the theme, but like, is there a lesson to be learned
- 18:55here or is the lesson that there isn't a lesson to be learned?
- 18:57And I I just I think that Paul Haggis is trying to do a lot of
- 19:01things at once with this script. And so, you know, the the actors
- 19:05are doing everything they can and they're doing an incredible
- 19:08job. But there are certain things to
- 19:11get back to your point about the lead up to even training Maggie,
- 19:16the Catholic priest in this movie is only in this movie
- 19:20essentially to fulfill the role that he fills in the final scene
- 19:23he has in the movie. Like, and I don't know that we
- 19:26need 8 scenes of Clint kind of fucking with him just for, you
- 19:29know, kicks and giggles to establish that character because
- 19:32the character really doesn't add that much to the overall movie
- 19:36except for like, he's representative of the church's
- 19:41ethical code and Clint disagrees with it.
- 19:43And like, you kind of could have gotten that if you introduce the
- 19:47priest for the very first time in that last scene.
- 19:49And so like, I do think they're just things about the way this
- 19:51movie is structured and set up that that keep it from being,
- 19:56for me, as perfectly tuned as Unforgiven was.
- 20:03Yeah, I mean, you could have established early in the film
- 20:06that he goes to mass by having Maggie, like bebop her way on up
- 20:11and ask him to train her again as he's like walking out of
- 20:14mass. Like, like and.
- 20:16And boom, he's Catholic, he goes to Mass and then at the end of
- 20:19the film you show him with the priest and that's it.
- 20:23So no, I'm, I'm with you 100%. I, I think that there are parts
- 20:26of this film that feel a little bit extraneous.
- 20:30I I think that our big critique of the film the first time
- 20:35through still stands like the, the, the white trash of it all,
- 20:41if you will. You know, Maggie's family is
- 20:45white trash. And, and I'm not calling them
- 20:48that because I'm reductionistic. I'm calling them that because
- 20:51Clint Eastwood, like if there is a flaw for him as a director,
- 20:56now that I've watched a decent amount of his movies, the man is
- 20:59not a subtle person, doesn't have a lot of nuance, right?
- 21:05And you see that very obviously with Hilary Swank's family in
- 21:09this film. And I I just feel like like he
- 21:13could have gotten it across that they were white trash but also
- 21:17real people in a in such a better way than he does.
- 21:21Yeah. I feel like we're already kind
- 21:23of tipping into what we want to talk about in the second-half.
- 21:25So if, if I may, let's press pause on that conversation so
- 21:29that we can talk briefly about the third lead of this movie,
- 21:33Morgan Freeman. And I kind of, I kind of started
- 21:36to broach the topic of the script because you can't really
- 21:38talk about Morgan Freeman's character without talking about
- 21:41the script because most of his role is done in voice over.
- 21:44He is the narrator of this movie.
- 21:46And you find out at the end of the film that the reason he's
- 21:48been narrating it is that he's writing a letter to Clint
- 21:51Eastwood's estranged daughter. I think that part of why I
- 21:55don't, I still don't love this script, Brad, is that it tries
- 21:58to be too cute sometimes and it tries to leverage how much we
- 22:03liked Morgan Freeman as a narrator in Shawshank and then
- 22:07say, like, what if he did that, but like twice as much?
- 22:11And I will say Morgan Freeman, Morgan Freeman's fantastic in
- 22:15this movie. And I I even noticed, you know,
- 22:17like he's doing a different voice than he normally does.
- 22:19And I think it works really well for him here too.
- 22:23But the thing that I'm saying about Shawshank is, you know, in
- 22:26that movie, there's a few scenes where he will have a clever
- 22:30little cute punchline that he delivers at the end of a scene
- 22:33and then it like helps you move to the next little episode in
- 22:36Shawshank. And in this movie, Paul Haggis
- 22:39tries to make Morgan Freeman's character do that in every
- 22:42single scene for the 1st 2/3 of the movie.
- 22:44Like he'll, he'll make a comment at the that the start of the
- 22:47scene and he'll say something like Maggie always did, like
- 22:51knocking him out in the first round and then the scene will
- 22:54play out and she will do something.
- 22:56You know, that's the scene where Morgan Freeman's character tries
- 22:58to introduce her to a new manager and she shuts him down
- 23:01and walks out and then he comes back on and says Maggie always
- 23:05did like knocking him out in the first round.
- 23:07And you're like, OK, I get it. Like that's cute.
- 23:10And it works really well the first like 4 times.
- 23:12But after the 11th scene where he structures it exactly the
- 23:16same way, I it really got on my nerves.
- 23:19And it sucks because they don't use Morgan Freeman on screen as
- 23:24much as they should and the narration gets a little
- 23:27overbearing for me. And so I, I struggle to like,
- 23:30give him the props that he deserves because he's really
- 23:32good when he's on screen, but the narration really takes away
- 23:34from it for me. I I think the other part of the
- 23:37script that took away from Morgan Freeman's performance was
- 23:42he's like the perfect character. Like, there's nothing wrong with
- 23:46him, but I can't stay away from those ponies, you know what I
- 23:51mean? Like, it feels just a little bit
- 23:54forced in there where he's like, Clint, you have to keep my money
- 23:59from me and give me just enough to live on so that I don't waste
- 24:03all my money on gambling. And it just feels a little bit
- 24:08forced. I, I, I don't know how did how
- 24:11did that interact with you? Yeah, I mean, they try to give
- 24:14him some flaws and he talks about like how he was too
- 24:16stubborn of fighter and then he lost his eye and he should have
- 24:19listened to Clint. And you know, and again, I don't
- 24:21mean to get like racial about it or anything, but he's like the
- 24:24only black person in this movie aside from the person who
- 24:26paralyzes Hilary Swank. And like his job is basically to
- 24:31like be of service to everyone in the movie.
- 24:34Like he's literally the janitor. But then he's also there to like
- 24:37pick up all of Clint's emotional baggage.
- 24:39And he's there to be the emotional support for Hilary
- 24:41Swank. And he's there to let Clint vent
- 24:44to him and, and tell him that it was his fault.
- 24:46And you know, like, it just, it doesn't seem like he's a real
- 24:49person. I totally agree with you on
- 24:51that. And even within that, I think
- 24:53Morgan Freeman freaking kills it from an acting standpoint.
- 24:58Yeah. And, and I think part of that
- 24:59reason, and I will, I will say I, I will give Clint credit
- 25:03here. Morgan actually originally
- 25:06auditioned for the role of Frankie Dunn.
- 25:08But. After reading the script, he
- 25:11asked if he could play Daddy the the janitor.
- 25:17Yes. And so I I will say like Morgan
- 25:20chose this role. This is who he wanted to play in
- 25:23this film and when he is on screen, he's incredible.
- 25:29The interactions between him and Clint are pitch perfect.
- 25:34Oh, and like significantly better than they were in
- 25:37Unforgiven. Morgan Freeman wins the Oscar
- 25:39for this movie and he totally deserves it here.
- 25:41You know, and, and we had issues with his character in Unforgiven
- 25:45and I think they're definitely remedied here.
- 25:48Yeah. And if I can talk super quickly
- 25:50about one other character, I don't know if we mentioned him
- 25:53at all the first time we recorded this, you know, on this
- 25:56movie. Jay Baruchel as danger in this
- 26:00film ripped my heart out. This time through I like.
- 26:05So here's the thing though, is he good?
- 26:07And and like, I like Jay Baruchel, I've seen him in a ton
- 26:11of things. You know, he's the voice of
- 26:12Hiccup in How to Train Your Dragon, but like, the character
- 26:17sucks. And also, I don't believe that
- 26:20Jay Berryshell is a developmentally disabled and B
- 26:23Southern. And so like none, none of that
- 26:27performance. And I think I also am being
- 26:29unfair to him in some ways because, and I was going to
- 26:32bring this up in the second-half, what is the purpose
- 26:35of his character? Is he is he a parallel to
- 26:39Maggie? Is he, is he a carbon copy of
- 26:42Maggie? Because it seems like the point
- 26:44this movie is trying to make is that the world is a really cruel
- 26:47place to innocent things. And he is like the most innocent
- 26:50thing, right? But the way that the their their
- 26:53two paths diverge, Maggie and him is like he's able to come
- 26:57back from what the world did to him and Maggie is not.
- 27:01But I don't understand, like, what's the point of that?
- 27:05Like, what's the point of having a second character just like
- 27:08Maggie? Is it to give us a little bit of
- 27:11hope at the end of the movie? Like, I don't know.
- 27:12I just don't understand what he's there for.
- 27:14Have you ever read the book of Ecclesiastes?
- 27:17I I have Brad, yeah. Wow.
- 27:19Wow. Yeah, I, for me, I think he kind
- 27:22of represents the capriciousness and randomness of the world that
- 27:27like, he and Hilary Swank are both innocent, earnest, eager
- 27:32people who are seeking to become better boxers.
- 27:35He has been disadvantaged and isn't able to do what Hilary
- 27:39Swank can do, and the world punishes him for that.
- 27:43And yet even Hilary Swank, who can rise to the the peak of her
- 27:47profession, is still punished by the world.
- 27:52And I, I think that there's a reality that a, a large portion
- 27:57of the meaning of this film can be found in biblical text.
- 28:01The rain shine, the rain pours on the rich and the poor alike,
- 28:06on the, on the Sinner and the righteous alike.
- 28:09And, and I think that that's why I really enjoyed dangerous role
- 28:13in this film, because it kind of illustrated that point.
- 28:16Like, man, there's, there's times in your life where
- 28:19everything's going great and there's other times where
- 28:21everything's going poorly and we're not always sure if we're
- 28:24the ones making it great or poor.
- 28:28I like that. Well, thank you for enlightening
- 28:30me, Brad. And now let me enlighten you
- 28:34because we are going to drink a whiskey that I am still quite
- 28:37fond of that I hadn't tried all the way since season 1.
- 28:41And that is Monkey Shoulder. So what do you say if we get
- 28:44into drinking that? Yeah, let's just pull the stool
- 28:47out, sit down and have a drink. Ouch.
- 28:58All right, everybody, today we are drinking Monkey Shoulder, a
- 29:02blended Scotch that we really were impressed with back in the
- 29:07day as like a starter Scotch. And I'm, I'm curious to see
- 29:10where we're at today, Bob. Yeah, Brad, I can't really
- 29:12remember much of my Scotch drinking journey way back then,
- 29:16but I have to imagine this is one of the very first Scotch
- 29:18whiskies I'd ever tried. And so I think, honestly, we
- 29:22were very blessed that this was kind of our gateway into Scotch.
- 29:25Because I think to this day, it's still one of the ones I
- 29:28recommend to people who are looking to get into the world of
- 29:31Scotch. It's not super expensive because
- 29:33it's not a single malt. It's a blended Scotch and it's,
- 29:36you know, it's low enough of a proof that you can use it as a
- 29:39mixer, but it stands up pretty well.
- 29:41Neat. I will say, though, I have not
- 29:44revisited it since Season 1. So like, I'm really, really
- 29:48excited to see a like, has my palate changed in the last X
- 29:52number of years? But also, like, does this hold
- 29:55up as well? Like, would I still recommend
- 29:57this as a starter Scotch for people?
- 30:00And yeah, let's see what we come out to.
- 30:03Yeah, so getting right into it on the nose for me, it has a
- 30:08really nice citrusy touch to it and almost like an orange zest,
- 30:12orange peel kind of feel. There's some honey going on and
- 30:17then I get a nice vanilla Y cream soda freshness kind of pop
- 30:22at the end that I I really liked Bob.
- 30:25I'm sitting at a 7 out of 10 on the nose.
- 30:28Yeah, Brad, I'm at a 7 1/2 and I was really impressed that this
- 30:32had as much going on as it does on the nose.
- 30:35Like I kind of let it mellow out in my glass a little bit, and
- 30:37every time I went to nose it, I was getting new things on it.
- 30:41It started off with just kind of that nice honeyed note that we
- 30:44get on a lot of blended scotches and some Irish whiskeys as well.
- 30:48But then it got into like the melon territory.
- 30:51And for me, it really reminded me of like when you're eating a
- 30:54honeydew and you get like right down to the rind.
- 30:58Like it's not quite the really sweet flesh of a melon as much
- 31:03as it is like cantaloupe rind, honeydew rind.
- 31:06There was some mint going on in here, which is a note I usually
- 31:10only get on like rye whiskey's, some nice maltiness.
- 31:13And then like you said, there was citrus here.
- 31:15I wrote down lemon zest, but there was that kind of like nice
- 31:18tartness to go along with all of it.
- 31:20Super complex for a $35 blended Scotch so it gets a 7 1/2 for
- 31:25me. Yeah, when I got into the flavor
- 31:28of this, the the actual palette, it turned really spicy for me.
- 31:33There's some like baking spices, clove, almost like a Christmassy
- 31:37kind of spice mix. The vanilla turned from a cream
- 31:41soda into almost like a really rich vanilla cake.
- 31:45And then the orangeness turned tart for me and almost moved
- 31:51into like a black cherry territory.
- 31:54I'm I was like genuinely kind of blown away by this.
- 31:58I give it an 8 out of 10 on the flavor.
- 32:00Yeah, I'm pretty close to you. I'm at a 7 1/2 again.
- 32:03For me, the first things that really manifested, I wrote down
- 32:06ash and char. And it's really hard to talk
- 32:09about something tasting ashy or really charred because with
- 32:13Scotch, we kind of expect some of that bitterness from the malt
- 32:16and we expect some smokiness to it as well.
- 32:19But honestly, for me, it kind of reminded me of when we drink
- 32:22Woodford Double Oaked bourbon, there is a very particular like
- 32:27double oaked flavor. It's not just like barrel char,
- 32:31it's double char. And this, this really reminded
- 32:34me of that. There was a really like deep
- 32:37char note to this, and I think you were kind of talking about
- 32:40vanilla cake a little bit ago. I think cakey is a really good
- 32:44term for this because there's a sweetness underlying it, but it
- 32:48never tasted sugary. It almost reminded me of like a
- 32:51shortbread or like a pound cake. Like just sweet enough that it
- 32:55kind of adds that layer of like fat to your mouth that
- 32:58everything else can kind of dance on top of.
- 33:01Brad I like is this a really great whiskey that we just I
- 33:05have been sleeping on. I think it is Bob like it's I I
- 33:09I will say the the finish is a little bit short.
- 33:12It's very sweet. The spices I got on the palate
- 33:16lingers for just a few seconds. The vanilla really sits for a
- 33:20long time, which I I'm totally fine with.
- 33:24I gave it a 7 out of 10 on the finish.
- 33:27Yeah, I came down to a 6 1/2 on the finish.
- 33:28This was the low point for me as well, but I'm at a completely
- 33:31opposite camp as you. I wrote down that this kind of
- 33:34sits a little heavier than I would like it to.
- 33:36Not that it like camps out in my chest or anything, but that note
- 33:40of char I think really tips bitter towards the end and I'm
- 33:44left with that as kind of my final note.
- 33:46It gets a little bit char heavy for me.
- 33:49So yeah, I'm just in a 6 1/2. However, when I think about the
- 33:53balance of this at a $35 price point and at a fairly low proof
- 33:58blended Scotch, this is a pretty phenomenally balanced whiskey.
- 34:03There was nothing that really stood out in a super negative
- 34:06way about this. I think I'm going to give us an
- 34:088 out of 10 on balance, Brad. Yeah, I, I'm close to you a
- 34:12little lower. I I think that for this to
- 34:15really stand out, the finish would have to come up a little
- 34:18bit, but it's a really solid, well balanced whiskey.
- 34:22I, I don't know if we said it, this is sitting at 86 proof.
- 34:25So at a, at a nice low proof, you're getting a lot of
- 34:28complexity. I give it a 7 out of 10 on
- 34:30balance. All right, so let's talk price
- 34:33because at this point the price has been raised.
- 34:36I don't know whatever the percentage is on this now, but I
- 34:38think when we first tried it, it was around $30 and it's up to at
- 34:42least 35 now in the state of Ohio.
- 34:45Yes, $35. I still think this is a pretty
- 34:48good value at 35 Brad. I think this is a great value at
- 34:5235. You can get a lot of blended
- 34:55scotches cheaper than this. There's not a lot that I would
- 34:58think would be as complex as this and stand up as well meat
- 35:03as this one. You know, when I when I thought
- 35:06about the price originally I was like I can get some cheaper, but
- 35:09now that I'm looking at it, I actually think I'm going to give
- 35:11this an 8 out of 10 on value. I'm I'm right there with you, 8
- 35:15out of 10. This is a incredible value in
- 35:19the world of Scotch especially. I'm going to come back to where
- 35:22we started, you know, 17 seasons ago.
- 35:27Bob, this is the best starter Scotch.
- 35:30I agree. Like I I can't think of another
- 35:33one for the price point and the flavor that I would recommend to
- 35:37somebody. I will say the price is starting
- 35:40to approach the level where part of the benefit of it before was
- 35:44like you're not sending someone out to buy a single malt and so
- 35:47they won't have to feel bad if they don't like it.
- 35:49Because I think when you're like, when you're talking about,
- 35:52oh, it's a single malt Scotch, there's a level of like people
- 35:55think that it's. Pretentiousness.
- 35:57Not even pretentiousness, but like, like intimidation.
- 36:00Do you know what I mean? Like, oh, I have to like this
- 36:02because it's like a really fancy whiskey.
- 36:04And so then when they don't like it, there's there's still like
- 36:07the the shame factor built into it.
- 36:09This one is kind of just like it's.
- 36:11Not just a bottle you have to get rid of, but also a box that
- 36:14it comes in. Right.
- 36:15Well, and this one was like, hey, it's 30 bucks and if you
- 36:18don't like it, you can mix it into stuff.
- 36:20But it's approaching the price point now where it's kind of
- 36:22like you can't just dump it into stuff and call it good.
- 36:26You're still going to be like, if that if you don't like it,
- 36:29you dropped $35 on it. That's not a cheap whiskey
- 36:32anymore. So I think it's still definitely
- 36:34worth the price, but with the caveat that like, we're
- 36:39recommending it as a starter Scotch because we think you will
- 36:42like it, but you can no longer feel 100% guilt free about
- 36:47dumping it if you don't. Unless you're fantastically
- 36:51wealthy. That's that's very true.
- 36:54Then you could just buy it and pour it straight in the drain.
- 36:57Well, on that note, Brad, I recommend not doing that.
- 37:01And you know what's funny is we usually say, do you recommend
- 37:04buying, do you recommend trying? And for most whiskeys in this
- 37:09price point, I would say, sure, go ahead and buy it because it's
- 37:1135 bucks. Don't waste your money trying
- 37:13it. The funny thing is, I needed to
- 37:17drink this whiskey for the podcast today.
- 37:19I only had a limited amount of time and I wasn't going to go
- 37:21tried it. I wasn't going to go buy a
- 37:23bottle. So yeah, I went to a local bar,
- 37:25they had $5 pours and it was one of the best 5 bucks I've spent
- 37:28in a long time. Man, it was absolutely worth a
- 37:31$5 pour. Yeah, no, I, I'm with you.
- 37:33I would say try it. I would say buy it.
- 37:36And yeah, this I'm, I'm very glad that we revisited Monkey
- 37:40Shoulder Bob. I'm coming out to a 37.5 out of
- 37:4450. If I'm being honest, Brad, I
- 37:46think I actually feel more positive about it than even that
- 37:48score would indicate. Yeah, I came out to a 37 out of
- 37:5250, so I'm right there with you. Cool.
- 37:54So we're at a 37.25 out of 50 or 74 1/2 out of 100.
- 37:59This is well above average. I think it's like a genuine
- 38:03crowd pleaser and it kind of goes along with the $1,000,000
- 38:07baby, you know, the the rousing crowd pleaser of 2004.
- 38:13Yeah, yeah, 100%. There's nothing absolutely sad
- 38:17about this movie. But Bob, I think it's about time
- 38:20to pull the plug on this segment and move on to the rest of the
- 38:25episode. What do you say?
- 38:26Oh man, let's get to it, Brad. All right, everybody, that was
- 38:34Monkey Shoulder, a whiskey that I would gladly have on my
- 38:38shoulder any day of the week, Bob.
- 38:41Don't need to get that monkey off my back, Brad.
- 38:44Hey, there it is. You know what?
- 38:47Monkey, we need to get off of your back.
- 38:48Bob, the losing streak that you're on and two facts and a
- 38:51falsehood, Brad. Is going to try to stump your
- 38:55ball. 2 are right and what is wrong?
- 39:012 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 39:04the podcast where Brad presents three items to me as fact, one
- 39:09of which is a complete fabrication, and I have to
- 39:12figure out which one is the lie. Brad, I love how you just assume
- 39:15I'm on a losing streak. Yeah, no, we we actually haven't
- 39:18at this moment recorded the other movies yet.
- 39:21I'm just, I'm just speaking into existence here that on a losing
- 39:25streak, so. Hey man, Oprah told me that I
- 39:28could imagine it and it would be true.
- 39:29So, well, let's here we are. She's wrong.
- 39:31Brad, I assume you have three good supposed quote UN quote
- 39:36facts in front of you about the making of this movie.
- 39:38So hit me with your two facts and a falsehood.
- 39:42Fact number one, This is one of two times when the presenter
- 39:45handing Clint Eastwood an Oscar was Barbra Streisand.
- 39:49Yep, she previously handed him the Best Director Oscar for
- 39:52Unforgiven before giving him the second movie award.
- 39:55She said. I would be very happy to do this
- 39:58again for you, Clint. Fact #2 The This is the first
- 40:02Best Picture Oscar winner to be released on both HDDVD and
- 40:08Blu-ray. Fact #3 Mike Coulter, the actor
- 40:12who plays Big Willy, actually boxed throughout his teenage
- 40:16years and nearly became the state boxing champion in his
- 40:19home state of South Carolina. These are good ones.
- 40:23Number one is true because I remember watching the Oscars and
- 40:28they let Barbra Streisand come out and do best picture.
- 40:30And Brad, I've never talked about this before and.
- 40:32Bob I I believe it's Streisand. Streisand.
- 40:36No Streisand. Haven't you seen Licorice Pizza
- 40:40Bob? That movie is so good.
- 40:42All right, so she comes out to do Best Picture.
- 40:45I don't know if I've ever talked about this before, Brad, but I
- 40:47have like an irrational dislike of Barbra Streisand.
- 40:52I just don't get it with Barbra Streisand.
- 40:54She sucks, dude. I never got it either.
- 40:56I've never gotten it. It doesn't make sense to me.
- 40:58And I get like physically upset when I see her doing things.
- 41:02So anyway, she comes out to give best picture out and, you know,
- 41:06they do. And the Oscar goes to and they
- 41:07open the envelope and instead of just saying the name of the
- 41:11Oscar, she does the thing. Like she steals Clint Eastwood's
- 41:14moment and says, like, Clint, I'm so glad to be giving this to
- 41:19you again. And then everyone has to just
- 41:22infer, oh, OK, it's $1,000,000 baby, you know?
- 41:24And then she says, Million Dollar Baby.
- 41:26But it's like, you know what, Barbra Streisand read the name
- 41:29of the movie. And then when he comes on stage,
- 41:31tell him, I'm so glad that's a moment for you and Clint.
- 41:34Like, don't ruin it for the rest of the world.
- 41:36Babs got me so angry. Dude, I don't even care that you
- 41:41know that that's a fact. I'm so happy to hear that story.
- 41:45Dude, like nothing gets me more upset than people doing stuff
- 41:47like that anyway. Yeah, no, it's true.
- 41:50It's definitely the that moment of like she is making it about.
- 41:55Her. And and that like, it's Kanye
- 41:59getting up on stage and dissing Taylor Swift.
- 42:01It's like stuff like that where you're like, you are already a
- 42:05wildly famous person. Stop trying to get the spotlight
- 42:09on you, Barbara. Barbra Streisand Colon, the
- 42:12Kanye West of the 1960s. All right, number one's true #2
- 42:18sounds like it could be true #3 sounds like it could be true #3
- 42:22was the one about boxing, right. And #2 yeah, you said #2 was
- 42:26HDDVD and Blu-ray at the same time.
- 42:29Yeah, the first Best Picture winner.
- 42:32Do you remember HDDV DS Brad? I remember DV DS, I don't know
- 42:38if I remember like HDDV DS being a thing.
- 42:42So yes, they were a thing for just a little while and they had
- 42:45like a like Blu rays had the blue cases.
- 42:48HDDV DS had similar sized cases but they were like a dark red,
- 42:51like a maroon color. I do kind of remember that.
- 42:54And I remember reading an article about them at the time
- 42:57that like Blu-ray looks like it's going to be the winner.
- 43:00HDDV DS are actually better. And it was kind of like the old
- 43:04VHS versus Betamax thing. So anyway, I remember seeing
- 43:09like, I think the Departed got an HDDVD release, but that came
- 43:14out after this. So I have no idea if that's true
- 43:16or not. I'm going to say 3 is the
- 43:22falsehood, but I wouldn't be surprised if it was 2.
- 43:26That, see, here's the thing, I could tell you whatever I want
- 43:29then, because that like I have the power here and I could just
- 43:32lie to you. It's true, but I'm not going to
- 43:36and you are correct Bob #3 is the false.
- 43:38Right. The only reason I ended up
- 43:40guessing 3 is because I just asked you have you ever seen an
- 43:43HDDVD and you said no. So I was like well clearly he
- 43:46didn't make up that fact. Like I didn't even know what
- 43:49they were until just now. Dang it, I shot myself in the
- 43:53foot. Lawyered for real though, man
- 43:58that was sneaky. Let's talk about $1,000,000,
- 44:01baby Brad. And I think it's finally time
- 44:02for us to talk about the things that don't work for us.
- 44:06We could get really nitpicky about it, but we did that in
- 44:09season 1. Like I talked about the white
- 44:11trash thing. I talked about Paul Haggis being
- 44:13the most obvious screenwriter. You know, even in the first half
- 44:15of this episode, I talked about how I don't like that he
- 44:18continually puts a button on every single scene at the end.
- 44:23And yet, like, it's, it's still just a really well made movie.
- 44:27Like I can't argue with too much of it.
- 44:30And I, I sat down and I started to realize, Brad, I think the
- 44:33thing with this movie that I have always pushed back against
- 44:36is that it is making a very complicated and complex moral,
- 44:41not even complex. It's making a moral argument in
- 44:44a time where like there was very little support for this right?
- 44:47Like euthanasia. I grew up Catholic dude.
- 44:49Like it was starting to become a thing when I was like right
- 44:53around this age. Like the the church debates
- 44:55about euthanasia. Well, wasn't it a like Terry
- 44:58Shivo? Yeah, Shivo.
- 45:00Yeah, that like that was a huge, huge story, right?
- 45:04So I mean, this is a hot button issue.
- 45:06And so again, like I grew up Catholic.
- 45:09This was not something that I was taught was like an OK thing
- 45:11to do, right? And, and I think when a movie
- 45:15challenges your worldview, it's a good thing.
- 45:18It's a good thing to have your world view stretch.
- 45:20It's a good thing to learn about experiences from other parts of
- 45:22the world or from other walks of life than your own.
- 45:26But I think in a lot of ways, when you're watching a movie
- 45:29like that, for the movie to really be effective at what it's
- 45:32trying to do, it needs to present a clear argument.
- 45:35And Quint was making an argument against the majority of the
- 45:38American public at this time. And I, you know, it seems unfair
- 45:43in retrospect to say, like, why didn't you convince me better,
- 45:46Clint Eastwood? Because it's not his job.
- 45:49But I do think that ultimately, the point of this movie is not
- 45:52entirely clear. Frankie's actions are kind of
- 45:55clear. Frankie obviously thinks this is
- 45:56the right thing to do, and he's clearly struggling with it
- 45:59beforehand. He has this great scene with the
- 46:01priest. And the priest says, like, you
- 46:03know, if you do this thing, you'll be lost, and you'll be
- 46:06lost so deep in a place that you'll never be able to come
- 46:09back from it. And real quietly, under his
- 46:12breath, Clint Eastwood just says, I think I already did it.
- 46:16And you don't know if he means, like, I'm already lost or even
- 46:19in my mind, I've already killed her.
- 46:21And I'm looking for permission to do it, you know, so that I
- 46:23don't feel so guilty about it. It's nice that there's some
- 46:28ambiguity to it, But I also just think that Paul Haggis is trying
- 46:32to do too many things at once with all these characters, like
- 46:34Danger and Scrap, and it kind of loses the overall point of these
- 46:40two characters and their tragic love story in the mix of all
- 46:45these other peripheral things he's trying to do.
- 46:48Yeah, well, and and also he's trying to like, really prove and
- 46:52hammer home a point that, like the priest is wrong because, you
- 46:56know, Clint Eastwood terminates her life and then just ends up
- 47:02hanging out at A at a pie bar. He's like, you know what I need
- 47:05right now? Need a good slice of pie?
- 47:08God. Bless it, I just killed
- 47:10somebody. Boy, could I go for a slice of
- 47:12lemon meringue pie right now? Yeah, that will take care of all
- 47:16of life's issues in this. Moment that just felt like a
- 47:19really weird ending. I don't know, like it just I, I
- 47:25don't want to say it felt unearned because there there is
- 47:29a certain sense of resignation to it.
- 47:31Like, you know, he he's like, oh, I'll never quit boxing, but
- 47:34if I did, I'd go buy myself a little diner.
- 47:37And so it's kind of this this like, all right, this was his
- 47:39final act. This is all he had left to get.
- 47:42So I get it kind of works, but it also just felt a little
- 47:46insensitive. Well, and one of my favorite
- 47:49things about this movie is they keep repeating, always protect
- 47:54yourself. That's the rule, right?
- 47:55And the the entire point of this movie is that both Maggie and
- 47:58Frankie failed to do that. And scrap has this really great
- 48:02line in his narration where he talks about like, oh God, let me
- 48:04just read it. Hold on.
- 48:06Before you say that line, Bob, can I just say I don't think I
- 48:09ever once caught that Morgan Freeman's name was scrap.
- 48:14Like coming out of the movie. I don't.
- 48:15I couldn't. You could put a gun to my head,
- 48:19you could threaten to pull out my life support and I would not
- 48:22be able to tell you what his name was in that movie.
- 48:26Hey, Brad. Yeah, his name was Scrap.
- 48:29Oh wow, thanks man, I appreciate that.
- 48:32Welcome dude, he says. All all fighters are pigheaded
- 48:35some way or another. Some part of them always thinks
- 48:37they know better than you about something.
- 48:39The truth is, even if they're wrong, even if that one thing is
- 48:43going to be the ruin of them, if you can beat that last bit out
- 48:46of them, they aren't fighters at all.
- 48:49And so it's this, it's this thesis statement about like,
- 48:51their stubbornness is what makes them fighters, right?
- 48:53And they they want to, they know that they should protect
- 48:56themselves and they still don't. And that's what makes them
- 48:59fighters. And yet I still kind of feel
- 49:01like, is that the ultimate point that this movie's making?
- 49:06Like, I don't know, man. It just gets it gets a little
- 49:09too muddied for me at the end. And I wish that it had a clearer
- 49:13resolution. We, you know, we knocked Mystic
- 49:15River last week for going overboard with the like very
- 49:18obvious resolution. But for all the places that this
- 49:23movie is too obvious, I think that's probably why I'm
- 49:26reluctant to say that it's like, oh, it's really smart that it's
- 49:28ambiguous because it's like, well, it's very obvious in other
- 49:32parts. So I don't want to just assume
- 49:35that you're like a genius screenwriter, Paul Haggis,
- 49:38because there's other areas of the script you could have
- 49:40really, you know, toned it down on.
- 49:43Oh well. Also, like, I'm just going to
- 49:46give Eastwood props where they're due.
- 49:48The fact that he could pull off ambiguity at all is very
- 49:52impressive because that that's not exactly his strong suit as a
- 49:55director. Brad I don't know.
- 49:58I I feel like I've said what I need to say about this movie.
- 50:00I think my issues with it are a little bit more systemic than
- 50:03they are. Like, oh, I don't like this
- 50:05thing. I don't like this thing and.
- 50:08The cinema studio system is at fault for this.
- 50:11Exactly. That's right.
- 50:13Warner Brothers Pictures is at fault.
- 50:16Do you have anything in particular that you want to get
- 50:18at before we get into our last segment of the day?
- 50:23Honestly, I don't think so. Like overall, I, I believe I
- 50:27gave this a nine out of 10 in the first season.
- 50:30And not like I think I was right.
- 50:33I think I did a good job last time, summit it up.
- 50:35So yeah, I'm pretty awesome four years later.
- 50:40All right, man. Well, let's see if you're
- 50:41equally as awesome at picking a double feature for this movie
- 50:44with our last segment of the day.
- 50:46Let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 50:49episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 50:53Let's have another film with this one, even if it's struggle.
- 50:55It's the final segment of the day.
- 50:57Now let's make it a double. That's right, Let's Make It a
- 50:59Double is the part of the podcast where Brad and I pick a
- 51:03movie to pair with this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 51:07Brad, I will let you go first. Mr. Awesome, Mr. Purveyor of
- 51:11everything. That is awesome.
- 51:14I might have the best pairing in the The History of the Film of
- 51:18Whiskey podcast Bob. So $1,000,000 Baby is about a
- 51:23lovable underdog and how you know she proves herself to
- 51:28somebody who doesn't believe in her and and fights her way to
- 51:32the top right. I am going to pair it with
- 51:35another movie that literally is the exact same story.
- 51:39I'm going to pair this movie with Major League.
- 51:45I feel like you're conveniently leaving out like half the story
- 51:48here, Brad. You're just kind of stopping at
- 51:49the the championship, but not the, you know, neck breaking.
- 51:53Major League is the perfect movie to follow up $1,000,000
- 51:57Baby with 'cause you need something to enjoy.
- 52:02And also, if you just look at the history of Cleveland sports,
- 52:05it tracks really perfectly with Maggie's decline, too.
- 52:08We are. We are the broken neck.
- 52:12Of American sports, Yeah. I mean, I don't think mine's
- 52:18going to be nearly as entertaining as yours.
- 52:19I think the obvious choice here is Unforgiven.
- 52:21We've been talking about it all podcast long.
- 52:24Unforgiven's the better movie, and it communicates the point
- 52:27more clearly, but I also think like, it's just these are Clint
- 52:31Eastwood's two best directed movies, as I recall.
- 52:34You know, maybe if I watch Letters from Iwo Jima again,
- 52:36that'll be up there. But what he's able to do here is
- 52:40really, really impressive, even if I have some issues with some
- 52:44of the underlying things here. So yeah, I'm going to pair it
- 52:46with Unforgiven. Brad's going to pair it with
- 52:49Major League. You're welcome.
- 52:51And we're going to move on from that into our final scores.
- 52:56Bob I think that this is a 9 out of 10.
- 53:01I I think that this is a really incredible movie that has a ton
- 53:05going for it. But there's enough little issues
- 53:09here and there that keep it from being a transcendent 9 and a
- 53:13half, 10 out of 10. But this is a movie I'll come
- 53:16back to again at some point in my life.
- 53:18I think I'm at a nine as well. I was actually at a nine and a
- 53:21half until those last few scenes and I'm like, man, I wish that
- 53:24they just like brought it home a little bit better.
- 53:27Like it's just like I struggle to find the words.
- 53:31And part of it is because, Brad, we watched this movie like a
- 53:33couple weeks ago and and we've watched many other movies in
- 53:37between. And I'm really struggling to
- 53:39remember exactly. You know, I take notes during
- 53:42the movie, but I take notes thinking we're going to record
- 53:44this tomorrow. I'll remember this.
- 53:45Wait. You can take notes during a
- 53:47movie. I didn't know how I was allowed.
- 53:49To do that, yeah, What I usually do is I go to the movie theater
- 53:52and I put my phone on full brightness and then.
- 53:56Nice. And I just like I hold the phone
- 53:58over my head so everyone behind me can see what I'm doing.
- 54:01Yeah, well I I so I do the same thing, but I usually just watch
- 54:05YouTube. Videos.
- 54:06I'm thinking about starting to do voice notes during the movie.
- 54:10That's an incredible idea. Clint Eastwood's really good at
- 54:12this. In the middle you can use it.
- 54:15As an opportunity to take notes and practice your voices.
- 54:19Yeah, exactly, which would see. This is a 9 out of 10.
- 54:23I'm with you. We are coming out to an average
- 54:26of a nine out of 10. What do you guys think of
- 54:30$1,000,000 Baby? Great math dude.
- 54:31I'm trying my best man. I had to do the quick
- 54:34calculations. What do you think of $1,000,000
- 54:38Baby, Film and Whiskey Nation? Is it a classic in your mind?
- 54:41Is it as good as Unforgiven? I'd love to hear what you think
- 54:43about it. You can find us on Facebook,
- 54:45Twitter, Instagram and TikTok at Film Whiskey.
- 54:50Or jump onto our Discord. We are on there every single day
- 54:53talking to you, the fans of the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 54:57Find the link to the Discord at the end of every single one of
- 55:00our show notes. All right, Brad, well, we are
- 55:02going to come out of our malaise here and take a very hard turn
- 55:06into much lighter fare for next week.
- 55:08We're going to be looking at Billy Wilder's 1959 masterwork,
- 55:12Some Like It Hot. I can't wait for that one.
- 55:15I'm. I am so pumped for that dude.
- 55:17All right, so join us for that next week.
- 55:18But until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 55:21And we'll see you next time.