Latest / The Marketing Meeting with Itir Eraslan / 46. Can Marketing Still Save the World? with Massimo Giunco
Transcript
- 0:00Massimo Giunco: I still see the potential of marketing to opt for the
- 0:04common good instead of the common bad.
- 0:07But then I also understand that everyday life, when you have
- 0:12clients or you work for a brand and you do your job, that's not easy.
- 0:17How can people working there change when all the financial system, the
- 0:22political system care less than they say?
- 0:25Itir Eraslan: Hi, this is the Marketing Meeting and I'm your host, Itir Eraslan.
- 0:29Every two weeks I meet with experts and we talk about topics related to
- 0:33brands, marketing and businesses.
- 0:36And we sometimes add random lifestyle topics too.
- 0:39I hope you enjoy the show.
- 0:49Welcome to the marketing meeting podcast today.
- 0:51Massimo Giunco is joining me again.
- 0:54He is a brand strategist.
- 0:56He worked 25 years at Nike at various communication leadership
- 1:00roles, including marketing brands.
- 1:03And he is the person who, uh, got me into marketing.
- 1:07He was my first marketing boss.
- 1:10So we are here today to discuss a bit about what happened in 20 to 24 and.
- 1:17his predictions takes on 2025.
- 1:20Welcome Massimo.
- 1:22Massimo Giunco: Thank you.
- 1:23And thank you for the opportunity is always a pleasure.
- 1:26And you know, I cannot say no to you.
- 1:28So that's why I'm here.
- 1:29Itir Eraslan: And I'm, I'm using it almost every year because last year you were in
- 1:33my podcast and this year, just before the year ends, try to squeeze in some time,
- 1:39uh, trying to convince you with like, it's going to be a very short podcast.
- 1:42Yes,
- 1:42Massimo Giunco: it
- 1:44Itir Eraslan: is.
- 1:44So Massimo, I want to ask you about, first of all, what went wrong in
- 1:502024 for brands and marketing?
- 1:53Massimo Giunco: Okay.
- 1:54I don't want to sound negative.
- 1:57Also, I have a reputation to be, uh, a bit pessimistic about the state of marketing.
- 2:02Actually in 2024, nothing went really wrong in the sense that
- 2:10I haven't seen positive or negative changes versus the past.
- 2:15The key point is that the digital marketing domination is still there.
- 2:20Digital marketing is too big to fail and too big to be changed.
- 2:26And, uh, even in my humble consultancy job, I talk to several brands, several
- 2:33clients, and It's there, it's given for granted and uh, they have a very weird
- 2:41interpretation of what a brand can do and uh, what a company can do for the
- 2:47brand and so that's why then we are always talking about the same stuff.
- 2:51A bit of social media, a bit of digital marketing, a bit of CEO, a bit of e
- 2:57commerce and that's marketing for them.
- 3:00If they're happy about that.
- 3:04As long as they don't complain because they don't grow anymore,
- 3:07you know, or they have some poor return in terms of business.
- 3:13That's one thing.
- 3:14The second thing, which is very connected to that, Is the data tragedy, you know,
- 3:22in the sense that the data extraction from people is more and more inclusive.
- 3:30And I was thinking about that when four weeks ago Google announced
- 3:35the new version of their Google Nest product for home security.
- 3:42Then I was thinking, why the hell they are so interested in protecting
- 3:47us and our homes and storing all these cameras and sensors.
- 3:53And then there's a new frontier of data extraction for them.
- 3:59So they've done it on everything.
- 4:02They've done it on the web, tracking everything that we do.
- 4:06And then the Google Maps.
- 4:08Tracking every street of our planet and tracking where we go, where we
- 4:15stop, how many hours we are in the car.
- 4:19And now they want to do it in our home.
- 4:21They want to enter our home to see how many people we see, how we
- 4:27live, what time we eat, what time we go to sleep, our furniture.
- 4:32And, uh, and one stopping this thing is, uh, is the real
- 4:37issue that is beyond marketing.
- 4:41They are using all of it for marketing at the end, because then they are
- 4:45transforming all of this in data, so they can sell more keywords, more
- 4:52programmatic advertisements with a platform to grow their revenue.
- 4:56Okay, if we have to say what went wrong, this has been wrong.
- 5:00And it has to change, but it will not change because, again, there are the
- 5:05data industry is too big, it's too powerful, it's too rich, and it's quite
- 5:11difficult to imagine something else.
- 5:15Stop tracking is, uh, something that is very easy to achieve,
- 5:19but it's impossible to
- 5:20Itir Eraslan: implement.
- 5:21Massimo Giunco: And then the last thing that I, that I see that make me,
- 5:26Smile because of the fact that there is a kind of general misunderstanding
- 5:34of the marketing fundamental is that too many, especially in the world of
- 5:38fashion, are playing with the price
- 5:43in a suicidal way, you know?
- 5:46Itir Eraslan: Can you repeat that again?
- 5:48Uh, you mean the playing with the price?
- 5:51Massimo Giunco: Yeah, you know, the price.
- 5:52Product, place, price, uh, placement, you know, one of the four P's.
- 5:58And the price thing is, in the world of fashion, is managed
- 6:04in a very weird way, you know.
- 6:05On the luxury side, right now, they have increased price three times, almost four
- 6:11times, over the last five years, you know.
- 6:15But then they complain because the business is not going so well,
- 6:18you know, thank you very much.
- 6:22It's mathematic, you know, and on the other side of the spectrum,
- 6:26when you're going to the mass market, the fast fashion, they
- 6:31are doing just the opposite game.
- 6:33Then they take every opportunity, the Black Friday, the sales, and
- 6:39uh, we're to squeeze the price.
- 6:43You know, and then they complain because they have a problem
- 6:46with profitability and margin.
- 6:47Yeah.
- 6:48Okay.
- 6:50And, uh, in both cases, the business model doesn't let them manage inventory, the
- 6:59production level, and this and so forth.
- 7:02So things are getting worse.
- 7:04And this is something that struck me all the time, you know, on that side.
- 7:10Itir Eraslan: And thinking about 2025 trend, you have been mentioning,
- 7:15uh, what are the expectations from not the expectations?
- 7:19What, what do you think will continue to happen, uh, in the next year?
- 7:24Although I'm in one year is It's actually a short period of time.
- 7:29It doesn't change massive things most of the time.
- 7:33Uh, but what do you see the trend shifting towards?
- 7:38Massimo Giunco: Honestly, although I'm an old guy, not a boomer, but very close
- 7:43to be a boomer, I don't think anything will change what we were talking about.
- 7:51I think generative AI, that's there.
- 7:55where we will see, because we are already watching it.
- 7:59I'm personally watching the progress that he's making,
- 8:02especially on the visual side.
- 8:05I was in Finland four weeks ago and I met a couple of startups.
- 8:11Finland is one of the European country with the most developed software
- 8:16business was introduced to two platforms, AI platforms, uh, one from, from a
- 8:26visual perspective that is by far more advanced of what we can see and
- 8:33find on the web right now, and it's impressive the ability of this platform
- 8:39to develop and to create Thank you.
- 8:44And to combine inputs from, uh, what is in the stock, what you give to
- 8:51them in order to, at the end, execute assets of several formats in a very
- 8:59easy way, but also very, very close.
- 9:04to a professional form
- 9:07and this is something that made me think a lot around the potential of transformation
- 9:13because this is not 10 years, this is today, it's red, it's there.
- 9:20And also the input that you can give to the platform.
- 9:23are very serious, you know, in terms of positioning, in terms of quality,
- 9:30filters, and at the end, when you consider that 95 percent of the assets
- 9:37that you produce for any brand, digital ecosystem between social, own channel.
- 9:44is basic stuff that doesn't need to be a revolutionary or of drive, but it's just
- 9:51done because you need to fill the space.
- 9:54These kind of tools are able to do it at one tenth of the cost.
- 10:01And without using all the professional services you usually recruit to
- 10:07organize and produce all these assets.
- 10:11And that's something that may change a lot, the way of working of marketing
- 10:17team and the marketing industry overall.
- 10:21That's quite impressive, honestly.
- 10:23Itir Eraslan: I would like to ask you one thing over there because I have
- 10:25a conflicting idea for generative AI.
- 10:29I'm also watching, so we don't know what's going to happen, but 20 years ago
- 10:33when we were doing marketing, we were producing, for example, five different
- 10:38formats of assets for one campaign.
- 10:40Now we have Increased to like almost 50, 100 types of assets across all platforms.
- 10:48Like every two days, we're going to have a new creative targeting
- 10:51to a new audience and so on.
- 10:53So there has been a very big shift from how we produce content.
- 10:57So lately we have seen so many content creators and creative directors
- 11:02working on creating new assets.
- 11:05However.
- 11:06I'm just questioning if humanity needs that much of assets,
- 11:11uh, because generative AI will be producing them overall.
- 11:15And do we need more?
- 11:16And I'm just, is it the time for less is more?
- 11:20Because yeah,
- 11:22Massimo Giunco: yeah, yeah.
- 11:23I totally agree.
- 11:24So I would divide the answer.
- 11:27On one side, today, every brand, every company has, right or wrong, a digital
- 11:34ecosystem that is very complex and fragmented and they need to feed it, okay?
- 11:40And this is why they spend a fortune in production for all the assets that
- 11:46they need to feed this monster, okay?
- 11:50And on this side, generative AI can be a solution.
- 11:55To produce faster, cheaper, even better in many cases, and to meet
- 12:01the expectation of this ecosystem.
- 12:05Okay, on the other side, we know exactly that this is wrong, doesn't
- 12:09bring anywhere, and doesn't help you to grow your brand or, I mean, As I
- 12:14said, 95% of these assets are commodity.
- 12:17Then you need, because you need to have a picture, you need to have a post.
- 12:22So I totally agree, align with you.
- 12:24Less is more, but if you don't want to have less and you don't want to spend
- 12:31half of your budget in producing assets that are useless and eroding more and
- 12:37more, the budget to buy media and increase your reach, that can be a solution.
- 12:43Itir Eraslan: Because I, the more and more I hear from the founders and all
- 12:48the other marketers is like, they want to focus and they want to declutter instead
- 12:52of having a hundred assets per campaign.
- 12:55Why do we go back to not five?
- 12:57Like we did before, maybe like meet at the front at a 10 and then maybe
- 13:02make them quality because human eye.
- 13:05And also ear can easily identify an AI produced assets and everything
- 13:11will start looking very nice and very beautiful and everything will start
- 13:16to look so similar and we would.
- 13:19recognize that it's AI created.
- 13:21So I'm just in the mindset that it's time for creativity to come back again.
- 13:28Massimo Giunco: I totally agree for the, but those are two different problems.
- 13:33You know, when you have these billions of contents posted every day, you know,
- 13:39it's not the human eyes can recognize AI.
- 13:43Human eyes will not watch them anymore.
- 13:46In any case, you know, but they need to produce them because they
- 13:51have their own platform and their own universe of digital marketing.
- 13:58Okay, that's their problem.
- 14:00If they don't want to adjust it, it's fine.
- 14:04Then, totally agree, there is still a massive need for creativity, genius,
- 14:13and, uh, distinctivity, and to create something spectacular, able to, you know,
- 14:20catch your attention, generate memories, and, uh, raise the memory in your brain.
- 14:26Okay.
- 14:26I mean, this is not a dilemma, it's the problem of marketing over the
- 14:31last 15 years and why the performance of marketing is declining and
- 14:37why brands are not doing well and that's too long of a conversation.
- 14:43And the second thing, and this is not a prediction, but it's also based
- 14:49on, you know, when we think about chatGPT and I like to use chatGPT.
- 14:57More and more often, not for business reason, but for my very, very obvious
- 15:03day by day things or At the beginning I was making comparison and then I see
- 15:10that it's much better than Google search.
- 15:14And then I was talking to a few friends and some more intelligent
- 15:18people than me and I understand that the problem of open AI is that they
- 15:25still don't have a business model.
- 15:27You know, so they're collecting billions of dollars to improve their products, but
- 15:34they still don't have a business model.
- 15:35The subscription model of uh, Chatshupati generates only a
- 15:39marginal fraction of what they need.
- 15:43I would not be surprised if they will enter the world of digital advertising
- 15:50and become a competitor of Google.
- 15:51And that is why, honestly, I think it's important.
- 15:54They are now on the iPhone, and they are entering the consumer mass market
- 16:00to drive a bit of attention and also confidence and familiarity with this.
- 16:05And if they enter, there can be probably a little bit of an earthquake
- 16:11in the world of digital advertising.
- 16:13Because You know, the status quo may change quite dramatically.
- 16:20And that's the only, it's not even a prediction, it's just an observation
- 16:24as a boomer that he's using JGPT to find the best restaurant in
- 16:29the place where I visit, you know.
- 16:31Itir Eraslan: Even for the best restaurant here, I assume.
- 16:34Massimo Giunco: And it's fine.
- 16:36It's fine.
- 16:36You
- 16:37Itir Eraslan: know.
- 16:38Well, I'm like, I'm already surprised that they haven't entered.
- 16:41I mean, like a year ago, I was already thinking.
- 16:44That we're going to soon seen ads and then how brands going to adjust to that.
- 16:49You have to make sure that our website is, you know, readable and the open
- 16:54AI, uh, bots can crawl it and so on.
- 16:56You know, those type of things were in my mind, but probably they are still
- 17:01collecting the dollars and trying to make a business model out of it.
- 17:04Yesterday I was reading an article about SEO and how.
- 17:08Google's AI search, you know, also when you go to Google, there's an AI search
- 17:13that's presented to you, how it's, uh, reduced the amount of website business.
- 17:19Because since you search it and you're just like having a summary, you don't need
- 17:23to go to the websites to get the data.
- 17:26So it's also changing a lot of things.
- 17:29I think we're going to watch a lot.
- 17:31Okay.
- 17:31So what else for 2025?
- 17:36Massimo Giunco: I don't know.
- 17:37I want to take it, uh, with calm and peace and I've been too
- 17:45committed to, to change the world.
- 17:48And, uh, honestly, I don't think I'm, I will be able to do that.
- 17:53You know, I totally understand, uh, that we live in a, in a world
- 17:57that is falling apart and that marketing has played a role in that.
- 18:05We want or we don't want.
- 18:08And there's a certain moment of my life over the last year, as I was thinking
- 18:13that marketing has the possibility to, to do the opposite, to reverse this,
- 18:18you know, as we were able to change the behavior of millions of people.
- 18:22to buy chocolate even when we don't want, maybe we can do the same to buy renewable
- 18:29energy, even if we don't want, you know, every time I come close to a conclusion,
- 18:35then I discover something else.
- 18:36Okay.
- 18:37I need to start the game.
- 18:38And I think I will never find the real solution, but I still see the
- 18:42potential of the ability of marketing of the aggregate community of
- 18:48marketeers to opt for the common good.
- 18:53Instead of the common bad, you know, that's, but then I also understand
- 18:57that, that everyday life, when you have clients or you work for
- 19:05a brand and you need to, you know, you do your job, that's not easy.
- 19:11And so, It's a, I struggled to find the real solution to that.
- 19:18Uh, there are many, more and more books right now around sustainable marketing,
- 19:25but all of them implying that the company we work with or we work for.
- 19:33They are changing, you know, from profit to profit people on the planet.
- 19:38But we see the reality is that 95 percent of the companies are still
- 19:44profit driven and they don't want to hear from the planet at all.
- 19:49And so, How can people working there change, you know, when all
- 19:56the financial system, the political system, they care less than they say.
- 20:02And that's the biggest dilemma, you know.
- 20:05It is true that Marketing cannot transform the goal of the company
- 20:11into something that is more sustainable, more open to justice.
- 20:16But it's also true that marketing is crucial to help people to change behavior.
- 20:24And right now, you know, we don't know.
- 20:28for which behavior they should go and choose.
- 20:32So that's the dilemma of 2025 and 2076 and over the next 30 years.
- 20:40In the meantime, we have to observe things that are not pleasant and
- 20:47they're not giving hope and optimism.
- 20:52Itir Eraslan: As much as I, you know, spend time on social media
- 20:55or watching news and so on, uh, I recognize that people like you
- 21:00who has extensive knowledge and who can teach new generations
- 21:04More about how to do marketing.
- 21:07What are the things that, uh, the marketer should stand behind and so on.
- 21:12Uh, the people like you are staying away from social media.
- 21:17Uh, whereas you should step in, uh, to talk more.
- 21:22Well, I mean, we know that when you talk and step in and talk
- 21:25more, it creates a ripple effect.
- 21:28That's what happened in 2024 with one of your posts and probably that's the
- 21:32The one and only post that you had.
- 21:34Um, but intellectually we feel, uh, that we went, we just want
- 21:39to don't deal with it, which I feel is not the right approach.
- 21:44Uh, that's why I wanted to have you at this episode, because I think
- 21:48people need to hear from people like you that has extensive knowledge
- 21:52and that can really help and guide a new young marketer who cannot.
- 21:58Stand up and think differently.
- 22:01Uh, that's why I think I know that predictions are not like, we don't need
- 22:06to talk about technical predictions because I already have like so many
- 22:10technical predictions, like short form content will not be so popular or so on.
- 22:14And so on.
- 22:15Uh, but I think the prediction is that marketing changed the
- 22:20world, but does the marketers know and behave with that in mind?
- 22:28Massimo Giunco: Yeah, it's, uh, it's very true.
- 22:32I'm thinking about what can be the best platform, not for me to talk about
- 22:38it, but there are many people that are much more prepared and stronger than me
- 22:46that can definitely help, you know, to create a new generation of marketeers.
- 22:54And the new generation of marketeers will clash against the wall.
- 22:59of the corporate world if this world doesn't change and if this
- 23:04world doesn't want to change.
- 23:07I'm already talking to some universities
- 23:12to understand what can be done at least to expand the marketing program
- 23:17of those universities and to include, you know, a few hours discussing about
- 23:26that or integrate what you already teach around behavioral marketing
- 23:30or around strategies or even the sustainable marketing operation itself.
- 23:37Okay, definitely we can start also from the students because
- 23:41they are the one that will be in charge very soon to play marketing.
- 23:49I haven't found yet the way to do it, but don't expect me to write anything else
- 23:58On social media, but
- 24:00Itir Eraslan: that's that's the issue.
- 24:01I think with marketing Massimo you are the expert in marketing, which I would
- 24:05love to hear your thoughts on but you and people like you are staying away
- 24:10from social media because You Of some certain reasons, but then it means
- 24:16that some of the thought leadership is definitely not on digital marketing.
- 24:21Uh, there should be another, maybe it's not on the universities or courses
- 24:25or whatever, but probably people will start to seek to get the thoughts of
- 24:30people like Massimo through some other channels, some digital channels, uh,
- 24:36because digital will start to get.
- 24:39mediocre mass, all the same average content, whereas getting
- 24:44to really expert content will get harder and harder to reach.
- 24:49Like you living, not doing any polls and not sharing anything.
- 24:53How can people learn from you, right?
- 24:56That's, I think, an insight for the coming years ahead.
- 24:59Where do we find expertise?
- 25:01And that expertise may not be living in the, you know, walls, in
- 25:06the gardens of, uh, uh, worldwide.
- 25:10So, yeah, with that, uh, thanks so much for joining me.
- 25:15I know that it's a short one, uh, but I think for listeners who would understand
- 25:20that there are some really important parts that, uh, can be taken from.
- 25:25Thanks so much, Massimo.
- 25:27Massimo Giunco: No, thank you, Itir, for the trust and
- 25:30thank you for your nice words.
- 25:31I'm still nobody, so that's why I don't think my voice is relevant.
- 25:36I, I thank you for your really important, at least to me, comments and words
- 25:43and thank you for everything you do.
- 25:45Ciao.