Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade EMERGENCY POD: ETFs Live! with Alex Thorn
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:09Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:12management platform built on Multi institution custody,
- 0:16leveraging our partnerships with industry veterans, Bit Go and
- 0:19Coin Cover on ramps. Multi Institution Custody is a
- 0:23segregated vault requiring two of three institutions at any
- 0:26point in time to sign once a client's unique permissions have
- 0:30been met. Our industry leading best in
- 0:32class approach to custody helps individuals and institutions
- 0:36secure new and existing Bitcoin positions.
- 0:39All keys are held in deep cold storage and kept 100% offline.
- 0:44Managed with institutional grade security best practices.
- 0:48The custody solution eliminates single points of failure and
- 0:52reduces counterparty risks, ensuring maximum security and
- 0:55Peace of Mind on RAMPS Suite of products includes our custody
- 0:59offering, a spot Bitcoin fund, private wealth services and
- 1:02inheritance planning, and managed wealth for advisors.
- 1:05Whether you're new to Bitcoin or a veteran in the space, we would
- 1:09love to connect with you to understand your needs and how we
- 1:11can serve you. Please visit our website at on
- 1:14rampbitcoin.com where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:17connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:22music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:25the biggest bag of odorous extra ever assembled in the history of
- 1:30darkness, 1974198792972000. And whatever we want to call
- 1:38this. It's all just the same thing
- 1:39over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:43I say. When we sell, hey, I say.
- 1:46When we sell. Well, we're live now.
- 1:53We've got 37 minutes ETF launch day.
- 1:56We're joined by Alex Thorne from Galaxy Digital.
- 2:01Yes, sorry. For being late, I'm having some
- 2:03technical difficulties with this Macintosh computer.
- 2:06Are they called Macintoshes? I think originally they're just
- 2:10called Macs now the nomenclature is.
- 2:12Yep. Yep, Alex is a scarce asset.
- 2:15He's been busy this morning. This is your second or third.
- 2:18Recording ball and I got to head over to Pub Key in a little bit
- 2:21to do another, so God, I know. I love pub key.
- 2:26It looked fun last night. Were you there last night?
- 2:28I was there briefly, yeah. But we were, we were celebrating
- 2:31a little bit you know, right, right around market close.
- 2:34So I it was an early night for me.
- 2:35We'll say that, yeah, if. You haven't been to Pub Key in
- 2:38New York City and you're listening.
- 2:39You got to get there, make the pilgrimage.
- 2:41It's worth, Yeah, big thing. So this summer.
- 2:46How are we feeling today? I I'm feeling great.
- 2:49I think these things are are moving.
- 2:53I'm seeing pretty big volume in the scheme of things here.
- 2:58I mean grayscale with the the highest volume, but I think we
- 3:01know you know most of which direction that's probably going,
- 3:04but a lot of success out of the gate, it looks like seeing tight
- 3:09spreads. The the last number I said was
- 3:131.7 billion in volume in the first hour.
- 3:16So we're two hours in now. Yeah, I have higher than that.
- 3:20I got to update my Bloomberg worksheet here.
- 3:22I'm looking at share count, so I'd have to do some some quick
- 3:25tabulation, but I I think that I think we're probably over 2 now.
- 3:29Well, it's been a, it's been a long run, Alex.
- 3:31I feel like out of the group here you've been around closest
- 3:35to the the hoop when it comes to financial services.
- 3:39Fun fact, me and Alex connected years ago.
- 3:41So it's a long game in this space.
- 3:42I think 2018 or 19. I was at the walk selling into
- 3:46Fidelity when he was there on the enterprise stuff and curious
- 3:49on like what's going on, you know, with your former
- 3:52colleagues at Fidelity right now at a Galaxy, like what's the
- 3:55sentiment, people excited. What's going on?
- 3:58Yeah. I think people are very excited.
- 3:59Obviously, it's been a long time in the making.
- 4:01I think I'm seeing Fidelity's doing quite well as well.
- 4:05Keep in mind, they have their own Giant distribution platform,
- 4:09right? I mean, they have 30 + 1,000,000
- 4:11brokerage accounts. They're the largest 401K
- 4:13provider in the United States. So they they have A and and of
- 4:16course they're self custodying their their Bitcoin, right,
- 4:19because they have Fidelity digital assets, their own
- 4:22regulated spot Bitcoin custodian.
- 4:24So yeah I think they're quite excited.
- 4:27I know we're very excited. I mean Galaxy and Invesco filed
- 4:30in 21 and were rejected along with everyone else.
- 4:33So it's been a long time in the making here.
- 4:35I think you know from when you think about the the sort of the
- 4:40the Bitcoin brokerage and expertise smashing into the
- 4:44traditional finance, there's a couple that stand out.
- 4:48Fidelity's obviously one Invesco's the second largest
- 4:53issuer that has a Bitcoin ETF, right.
- 4:55They're the 4th largest ETF issuer in the world and and of
- 4:58course Galaxy has been a a Bitcoin company for a long time
- 5:02and and I hope it remains 1. So, yeah, and then you, I would
- 5:06say Arkan 21 shares right as another combo of sort of crypto
- 5:09native and and traditional. But I think it matters a lot.
- 5:14I mean there's there's some real, it's tricky to do this
- 5:18actually and you know Galaxy is in a is in a pretty unique
- 5:23position. We actually already operate
- 5:24these in two other countries. So whereas I think only 21
- 5:28shares is the only other firm that actually has experience
- 5:31running a crypto native ETP. So look, we're excited.
- 5:35I think there's fast we can finally move on that you know,
- 5:39I'm not, we're not moving on, but we can move on from the
- 5:41endless months of discussion of you know, tea Reed leaving on on
- 5:46tea leave, reading on the ETF announcement and such.
- 5:51So I think people are just excited to get down into the
- 5:54actual race among the issuers. It's going to be interesting
- 5:57what happens to Bitcoin itself, right?
- 5:59I mean, I think you're going to see significant changes in the
- 6:02Bitcoin brokerage space, right? People buying and selling spot
- 6:05Bitcoin. I'll obviously personally always
- 6:08buy Bitcoin. I use River personally, but
- 6:10there's plenty of of good places to buy Bitcoin and I'll be
- 6:14storing it on my myself and I have a I have a powerful multi
- 6:19sig set up. I don't want to show too hard or
- 6:21give too many details on, but there's good reason to own the
- 6:25ETFs also and I think you'll start to see you know, multi
- 6:28custodial models emerge. I think I'm hoping that the SEC
- 6:33will eventually allow shareholders to take physical
- 6:35delivery of the underlying. Obviously that's a huge, you
- 6:39know, limiting factor. If you're bullish Bitcoin with
- 6:43the vehicles today, it'll be a problem too for four O 1K
- 6:48providers that decide to offer Bitcoin exposure.
- 6:51Because if you're long term right on on this thesis, you
- 6:55don't want to get to the end of the road.
- 6:56You know, I'm 37. If I'm going to retire at 67, I
- 6:58want to put Bitcoin in my 4 O 1K and then take it out at 67.
- 7:02I don't want dollars. If if we're right, you're going
- 7:05to want the Bitcoin, you know, so more to come on on these
- 7:09products. I think they they they will
- 7:10evolve further. But for now I think it's just,
- 7:14you know, it's it's going to be good for Bitcoin spot markets as
- 7:16well will create significantly more liquidity I think over
- 7:19time. So it's going to be interesting.
- 7:21You're going to have a fracture. We already have one between
- 7:23investors and Bitcoin network users, but that gulf is gonna
- 7:28widen. Yeah, it's gonna be exciting to
- 7:31see the custody landscape evolve.
- 7:32I think it's three right now for the ETFs between fidelity bit,
- 7:36go with one and then Coinbase with the rest.
- 7:38And to see, Yeah, definitely. There as well.
- 7:41OK. Yeah.
- 7:42Mm hmm. Yeah.
- 7:46And to your point there about like the physical delivery, I
- 7:49think on that issue, I think it's just gonna be forced at
- 7:51some point. Yeah, for especially 30 years
- 7:54down the line, it's gonna be I'm not taking dollars.
- 7:57Yeah, I'm like, I don't. Demand.
- 7:59If you're right about Bitcoin becoming like global money, you
- 8:01don't wanna end up with like selling into, you know, a hyper
- 8:04inflating Fiat currency. I don't make any sense.
- 8:07No, Ridiculous. No.
- 8:10And I I guess, I mean, we just had a discussion with Larry
- 8:13Leopard and David Foley about this.
- 8:16I mean, we can rehash it today, especially since this episode's
- 8:20gonna go out immediately. Like, do you view this as a
- 8:23pivotal inflection point in Bitcoin's history?
- 8:26Yeah, I absolutely do. This is Bitcoin on every screen,
- 8:30on every and every account, right.
- 8:32I think this is a pivotal moment.
- 8:35Bitcoins had many pivotal moments, right?
- 8:37I mean certainly nation state adopting it was a pivotal
- 8:41moment. You know, we don't have to name
- 8:43them all. Hal receiving the first
- 8:44transactions, probably the second, you know, after the
- 8:47genesis was blocked. There have been many milestones
- 8:49I think in terms of global adoption this this is a major,
- 8:52major one truly and honestly, I don't think Bitcoin or
- 8:57traditional finance will ever be the same after this.
- 9:00How do we reconcile 15 years to the date from Hal running
- 9:04running Bitcoin? The ETF gets approved.
- 9:06Yeah, I know it's, it's really, it's it's it's poetic.
- 9:10I mean luckily anything that happens in early January is
- 9:12always going to line up with one of these big days, whether it's
- 9:15the genesis block or the first transaction or the OR or Hal's
- 9:18tweet or whatever, right. I mean, that's the first tweet
- 9:20about Bitcoin basically ever. And I think it's very poetic.
- 9:26I mean how it also goes back. I mean, I I cannot help but keep
- 9:29reading Hal's post on Bitcoin banks right now.
- 9:32He's talking about something a little different than certainly
- 9:35ETFs. I saw somebody say that Liquid
- 9:37was what Hal was talking about. That's also not true if you read
- 9:39the post, he's really talking about literal banks for in a
- 9:42free banking era, issuing their own paper that's backed by
- 9:45Bitcoin. But the the the question remains
- 9:48right, What is the place for institutions in something that
- 9:52is inherently A peer-to-peer network and and that the answer
- 9:56to that continues to evolve. And I'm of the view that if
- 10:00Bitcoin is wildly successful, it needs to be and will be
- 10:03available everywhere, right. It'll be in every fintech app.
- 10:06It'll be at every bank account. It'll be in every brokerage
- 10:08account. It'll be in yourself custody,
- 10:11it'll be everywhere, right in hot wall, it's cold wall, it's
- 10:14banks like. And so I I don't know what that
- 10:16means long term for Bitcoin the network it's it's going to mean
- 10:20something. I think it only becomes more
- 10:23pivotal that Bitcoin stays secure and and and developers
- 10:28stay supported and I don't know it's going to impact Bitcoin
- 10:31culture and so it's going to be which is always evolving we'll
- 10:35just have to wait and see. But I can't.
- 10:36I can't help but again, I encourage everybody to go into
- 10:39Bitcoin talk or find someone to send you a a screenshot of Hal's
- 10:43famous Bitcoin banks post, which he wrote very early in the
- 10:46history of Bitcoin and and we're we're making progress.
- 10:52December 2010, I believe it was December 30th, 2010, right
- 10:55before the New Year, he wrote. That, Mark, it's.
- 10:57Right on his mind. I love it.
- 10:59And it's extremely prescient, whether it's Liquid, Chummy and
- 11:02Mint or banks, I think it is materializing.
- 11:07And it was crazy how prescient Hal was less than two years into
- 11:13the protocol launching, recognizing that this network
- 11:16specifically at the protocol level would have scaling
- 11:19limitations and you would have to have this proliferation of
- 11:23layers above it and a more private banking enterprise on
- 11:28top of it leveraging Bitcoin as a reserve asset.
- 11:31Yeah, that one. That one hit a little bit.
- 11:34Sorry. I was gonna say the what Alex is
- 11:36referring to. I don't know Logan, if it's if
- 11:37it's up but or if you have it, but it hit a little different
- 11:41because I've read it a few times but when it got posted the other
- 11:43day because what we're describing whether it's chumming
- 11:46mints, I guess Fetty Mints would be that liquid what we're doing
- 11:50it on. It's all effectively the same
- 11:51thing. It's multi sig controlling
- 11:53Bitcoin. You have transparency knowing
- 11:55where the Bitcoin sits. So you always have that audit
- 11:57ability. At the end of the day to the
- 11:59main point which we talk about a lot is this free banking idea of
- 12:02that it's reputation based and you can take delivery of the
- 12:04asset to keep everybody honest just hasn't naturally hasn't
- 12:08happened and that's kind of where gold kind of fell off.
- 12:10And so, yeah, it's it's going to be interesting to see where the
- 12:13next decade plays out, especially as people get
- 12:15educated and that's what they demand from like their custodial
- 12:17relationship. Yeah, absolutely.
- 12:23I I actually, it's crazy. I'm on Bitcoin talk right now on
- 12:26Hal's account and you can he actually talked about banks a
- 12:28lot. It's amazing.
- 12:30I put it in there. Logan.
- 12:34Wow, I got the date exactly right from Emory.
- 12:36That feels good. That's nice, Yeah.
- 12:40Actually, there's a very good reason for Bitcoin backed banks
- 12:42to exist issuing their own digital cash currency redeemable
- 12:45for bitcoins. Bitcoin itself cannot scale to
- 12:47have every single financial transaction in the world to be
- 12:50broadcast to everyone included in the blockchain.
- 12:52There needs to be a secondary level of payment systems which
- 12:55is lighter weight and more efficient.
- 12:56Likewise, the time needed for Bitcoin transactions to finalize
- 13:00will be impractical for medium to large value purchases.
- 13:03Won't read the rest, but that's the first pack graph.
- 13:06Yeah yeah. You know this this goes back to
- 13:08like it's a settlement layer. Bitcoin created a digital
- 13:13settlement layer and that solves that sounds solves the very
- 13:16foundation of finance but you need to have all of your like
- 13:21usable interfaces built on top of that settlement layer.
- 13:25And so how was in my opinion just recognizing reality that
- 13:29finite block space 10 minute block times you you need some
- 13:33solution above that and lightning solves a large part of
- 13:37that. But but having having a free
- 13:41banking sort of model where people are companies are
- 13:44competing to be your home for your Bitcoin financial life of
- 13:52course makes sense. It's it's just the rediscovery
- 13:55of of free market capitalism in banking after you know several
- 14:00centuries of it becoming increasingly less free market.
- 14:05Yeah, I think it's like individuals that have looked at
- 14:07Bitcoin for a while, it's generally thought like we're
- 14:10going to recreate the wheel. And if you look more and more
- 14:12it's just we're just re purposing it.
- 14:14We're looking at the existing market structure and we realized
- 14:16that there were certain flaws or you know holes in the mechanics.
- 14:21And so I think it starts to look a lot more like the existing
- 14:24world with just checks and balances which is effectively
- 14:27like existed for a reason. There just need to be a better
- 14:29unit to measure it all by. Well, not even a better unit,
- 14:32just you change the incentives where there's no lender of last
- 14:34resort. So the banks are forced via
- 14:36economic incentives to actually run a good business and not
- 14:41actually reserved to an extent that their their users can't get
- 14:45their money at the end of the day.
- 14:46I mean the, I mean the unit in the sense of like I joke around
- 14:49and I kind of don't joke around. It's like the difference between
- 14:51gold and Bitcoin is multi sig like that unit and the
- 14:54programmatic ability to like have it segregated within
- 14:57different entities is what will keep us from doing what in my
- 15:01opinion what happened with gold or centralized unit, too many
- 15:03paper claims on the the unit. Yeah, I think, I mean it, it
- 15:08comes down to to what we you you either want Bitcoin to be or
- 15:12think Bitcoin will be. I mean, if if everything ends up
- 15:15in let's say a centralized, a layer of centralized
- 15:19intermediaries like banks, Oregon, like ETFs or or
- 15:21whatever, right, then it, it, it probably does mean Bitcoin is
- 15:25not no longer going to be used for unstoppable payments, right?
- 15:29But even in which I don't like, right, I don't want that to
- 15:31happen, I don't think anyone does.
- 15:32That's why we need also proliferation of truly
- 15:35decentralized layers that we can do Bitcoin with.
- 15:38But I would say that even in that world you could still take
- 15:43on the dollar, right? It can still become the world's
- 15:45reserve asset. It may not be used for payments,
- 15:47but it can like it because Bitcoin is doing multiple
- 15:51things, right? It's simultaneously challenging
- 15:53the never ending, inflating Fiat money supply.
- 15:56That can still work if it's Bitcoin banks that are the
- 15:59primary holders and users of it, right?
- 16:03That can still win. But if you want it to be for
- 16:06unstoppable payments as well, then then we need something
- 16:08more, right? It can't only be that.
- 16:10And luckily there's a lot of people working on that stuff.
- 16:11So it absolutely is unstoppable. Payments and a store of value
- 16:15today that can't be inflated but you know the the the there's the
- 16:19fork forks in the road in the future will will lead us down
- 16:22different directions and I want it all right I want it.
- 16:26I want, I want both. I want everything.
- 16:28So I'm very supportive of people using Bitcoin for payments and
- 16:33for and and in a in a non custodial self custodial way.
- 16:37I think that's the obvious core of how Bitcoin should be used
- 16:40and will be used. I don't think that the ETFs for
- 16:43example challenge that. I just think that they grow the
- 16:47base of users and that's why I say I think it's so important.
- 16:50I hope that eventually these ETFs will allow physical
- 16:53delivery because then then you're, you know, first of all
- 16:55that reduces significantly the, the, you know, the trade off
- 16:59that you're making by owning the ETF and not the physical
- 17:02underlying. I love calling Bitcoin spot
- 17:04physical. I think it's hilarious, right?
- 17:07Because you'd be able to get it out theoretically right and and
- 17:10right now you you can't right. So if you own this ETF, you
- 17:13can't send the shares like the like.
- 17:14It's money over the Bitcoin network So it's not for payment
- 17:17that those vehicles and you can't get the Bitcoin itself
- 17:20out. So all you can do is just rely
- 17:22on, you know the DTCC and your brokerage and the issuer right
- 17:27to to honor its value and and and operate it well.
- 17:30And luckily there are very trustworthy issuers here and you
- 17:34know, I trust personally that stocks that I own and at
- 17:37Fidelity are are actually being held there or whatever, right.
- 17:41But we shouldn't have to trust. So I'd love to see them evolve
- 17:45and and and offer that physical delivery one day.
- 17:47Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 17:50exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 17:53about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 17:56allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 18:00We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 18:04Alex the the mental model I I have right now at least for the
- 18:08for these ETFs is that that classic Trojan horse meme you
- 18:14know of of of bringing, bringing into the citadel of of
- 18:19mainstream America. Wall Street is introducing these
- 18:22wonderful Bitcoin ETFs. And you know, I I can't help but
- 18:26feel that as people you know invest a little bit into these
- 18:30Bitcoin ETFs, they learn a little bit more about Bitcoin.
- 18:33They start to value the properties of actual Bitcoin and
- 18:39and want that as you know maybe in addition to their allocation
- 18:43in in the ETF and then you know what's inside the Trojan horses
- 18:48Bitcoin adoption because people are learning about Bitcoin and
- 18:53and and flipping the the the script entirely where we've had
- 18:5615 years of just kind of baseless FUD floating around in
- 19:00the media and now there's going to be Wall Street singing the
- 19:03praises of Bitcoin as an asset and people coming around to its
- 19:07its properties as as being desirable.
- 19:10And some of those are attained through the ETF.
- 19:12But some of those you know especially if you can't redeem
- 19:15in kind live outside of the ETF. Any thoughts on on your
- 19:21perspective on, is that part of how this plays out or your
- 19:26thoughts around that? Yeah, I think it.
- 19:29I think it's going to play out. It's going to be tricky.
- 19:32I mean, I I I really just want to see the ETFs be.
- 19:39I want to see the education materials that everyone's going
- 19:42to be putting out on this. I mean, we've got a bunch
- 19:44together. You can go somewhere.
- 19:47I forget on Invesco's website, I'm in some fancy videos
- 19:50explaining how Bitcoin works. I hope that it leads to real
- 19:54Bitcoin usage and not just ownership.
- 19:57I can't see how it would decline it.
- 19:59So I I think we'll, we'll see marginal increase understanding
- 20:03in Bitcoin broadly and I think that can only help.
- 20:06And I agree. I mean the Trojan horse meme is
- 20:08perfect here. It's, you know come come by this
- 20:11asset. But actually it's, you know
- 20:14learn about Bitcoin, spread the, spread the Bitcoin story right.
- 20:17We've now deputized the world's largest asset managers to to
- 20:20tell that story. There it is.
- 20:22It's pretty. Unreal.
- 20:24Yeah, there it is. Yeah, we're now I, I I think for
- 20:27me the demarcation point is, yeah, bitcoins gone public
- 20:31today. But really what's different is
- 20:35that now Tradfi is going to sing the praises of Bitcoin And that
- 20:41that creates this pretty strong demarcation in the history of
- 20:45Bitcoin, where the mainstream goes from 15 years of just
- 20:49general Bitcoin is bad to now, you know, now and into the
- 20:53future tradify having an incentive to educate and to
- 20:58praise Bitcoin to to to inform the public about why this is
- 21:04actually a really cool asset that you should consider
- 21:07including in your portfolio. And I think that's the the true
- 21:10demarcation here. You know, the the fact that
- 21:13these things are trading now is is great, but the psychology is
- 21:19going to be night and day from the last 15 years to the future.
- 21:23Yeah, I totally agree. I think that's that's where this
- 21:25goes and I think, look it's getting easier to buy real
- 21:29Bitcoin also, right? I mean I mentioned that I use
- 21:31river personally, but I mean you can buy Bitcoin on fidelity.com
- 21:35as well, right? And and you will be able to get
- 21:37it everywhere soon. I I I'll be shocked if you
- 21:39eventually can't just buy spot everywhere.
- 21:40I don't think the ETF like it might slow down some brokerage
- 21:44that's on the cusp of deciding. But again, like don't tell me
- 21:49that if you have one of the world's most popular best
- 21:52performing assets and it's natively digital that every
- 21:55digital platform is not going to eventually offer it.
- 21:58So I, I, and I think also like you're going to learn, people
- 22:02are going to learn how to use it that don't already know there'll
- 22:05be at least some net new marginal Bitcoin user base
- 22:09growth from the ETF ownership. And we already know.
- 22:12I mean guys, you thought we were all around and like nobody, only
- 22:18the tourists that would buy the ETF anyway, left.
- 22:20We net stacked bitcoiners through all the bear markets.
- 22:24That's exactly right. I think it's just a different
- 22:25segment where we have precedent for this with like, you know,
- 22:28very different segment but like cash app and just making it easy
- 22:31for somebody to buy. But some people just left their
- 22:34Bitcoin there. Maybe they bought a small
- 22:35allocation, but there's a lot of people that learned bought the
- 22:39Bitcoin, took it off into self custody and then also looked at
- 22:42larger allocations post that initial like taste to understand
- 22:45what's happening and then where to go.
- 22:46You know, buy in size. But Alex, your point about
- 22:50everybody's going to offer it that like is an interesting
- 22:54reason, interesting dynamic with the authorized participants in
- 22:56Goldman and JPMC in particular. And is it the SAB 121 rule with
- 23:01the banks not being able to custody like how do you do you
- 23:03have any inkling into like where banks start to play into this
- 23:07and and is it like do we think it's going to happen in the next
- 23:1012 to 24 months or is that still further out where banks being
- 23:13able to custody the asset to participate?
- 23:16It's tricky, yeah. SAB 121 requires actually not
- 23:19just banks, I believe public companies to carry Bitcoin on
- 23:22their, on their balance sheets, which is crazy, right?
- 23:26Because like you know bank like take like State Street which is
- 23:28I think the largest custodial bank in the world, right.
- 23:30But or BNY right, which is also a large one, like they the
- 23:34assets that they hold belong to the clients, right.
- 23:36So you you don't hold, they don't hold, you know, a trillion
- 23:40dollars of assets as if they were theirs, right.
- 23:43In a bankruptcy, those are remote, right?
- 23:45They're, they're held, they're owned by the clients.
- 23:46It's a they're trusts, right. So and that's how custody should
- 23:51work for everything, right. You're not you're not giving it
- 23:54over, you know your your life savings or if you're a company
- 23:57your foreign currency or whatever to a bank and saying
- 24:00yeah, actually you know what like just promise to give it
- 24:01back. It's legally segregated on the
- 24:05balance sheet and and and you know, actually.
- 24:08Right. So SAB 121 makes it impossible
- 24:12for banks to hold it because like let's say you put, OK,
- 24:15maybe if it's $1 million the bank and put, you know, count
- 24:18that as their own asset. Sure.
- 24:19But if if let's say it's 20 to 11 and that one million becomes,
- 24:23you know, 10 billion over the next five years, they've got to
- 24:27segregate capital out to match that.
- 24:29They're not going to do it. And that's why they don't do it.
- 24:31It's why even though BNY Mellon has Bitcoin custody, they have,
- 24:35they just self-described their custody assets there as de
- 24:39minimis because they because they don't, they't, they're not
- 24:41really operating yet. I think that is what that's
- 24:45coming under congressional review.
- 24:47I think, you know with the change of leadership at the SEC
- 24:51and or at the OCC and the banking regulators, you'll see a
- 24:54change there. But capital requirements make it
- 24:56hard for banks today, which is again stupid like right.
- 25:00Wouldn't you want people to be able to store their Bitcoin in
- 25:04the safest quote UN quote place there is like I don't understand
- 25:08the move from a regulatory standpoint.
- 25:10It seems backwards. It's very similar to like not
- 25:13having any regulated products in the US and and effectively
- 25:16pushing people into offshore exchanges which is what happened
- 25:19for so long. I it should change.
- 25:22I don't know if it will change within, you know, this year, but
- 25:26you know, I think we know that banks and others would like it
- 25:28to change and. When you consider the liquidity
- 25:31profile of Bitcoin, it's doesn't make any sense.
- 25:34It's. You can liquidate this
- 25:35immediately if you need to. But with that being said, let's
- 25:41talk about the landscape of these ETFs.
- 25:44Obviously 11 approved, 11 launched today.
- 25:47I actually caught CNBCI caught Novo this morning explaining why
- 25:51you guys have done so good historically in Canada and
- 25:55Germany. It's because the the way you
- 25:58guys track spot is very, very good.
- 26:01I believe you said something like around 1% slippage in the
- 26:05spot price too the underlying shares of your Etps
- 26:09historically. So how do you see this playing
- 26:12out with 11 ETFs? Obviously it's probably gonna be
- 26:15a Pareto distribution where a few take a lion share of the
- 26:19market. How does this play out?
- 26:21How long does it take to play out in your mind?
- 26:23Yeah, I think it's probably if we Fast forward a year, I think
- 26:26you probably have one or two big ones and then theoretically like
- 26:30each one down on the list is half the one above it.
- 26:33So you know obviously there are a real tricky one to think about
- 26:38is grayscale. They are already very large,
- 26:41right. But you'd imagine with their fee
- 26:44and and and whatnot that they'll see outflows.
- 26:48I I think of it primarily as a as a grayscale versus BlackRock,
- 26:52Invesco and Fidelity game at the AT true scale just because you
- 26:57know Blackrock's the largest asset manager but also the
- 27:00largest ETF issuer in the world. Invesco is the 4th largest with
- 27:04and and even when you think about Fidelity, Invesco has 10
- 27:08times the assets under management in ETFs than Fidelity
- 27:11does, right. So Fidelity is like 13 on the
- 27:13list, right. Wisdom Tree and Van Eck are
- 27:15bigger than Fidelity in ETFs but it's going to be a bit longer of
- 27:20a game. I mean there are some that you
- 27:22know even like when we look today what, what, what, wherever
- 27:25we end up having closed in this horse race, like I don't think
- 27:29any of the advisor platforms are turned on yet, right.
- 27:31And there are issuers that have significant advantages there
- 27:35like BlackRock and Invesco, which are deeply connected in
- 27:38the advisor community, right. So I I think I've always viewed
- 27:41the ETF as primarily a product for advisors.
- 27:45Obviously it's for anyone, any retail can buy the ETFs.
- 27:48But you know this is the first asset in history that Retails
- 27:52had access to before institutions, right.
- 27:54We've all, we've all been buying Bitcoin already, right.
- 27:57We have plenty of places to buy spot Bitcoin.
- 28:00So I view the net new like market for the ETFs primarily
- 28:06being wealth management and that's a $48 trillion market in
- 28:09the US alone in terms of their AUM.
- 28:12So and those aren't on today as far as I know none of them have
- 28:15turned it on yet. We're talking about you know the
- 28:16Morgan Stanley's, the Merrill Lynch's etcetera.
- 28:18The we're we're advisors are affiliated with banks and broker
- 28:21dealers those are that's a huge pile of assets that should now
- 28:25gain access. So you know there's a couple
- 28:30games here, right. I mean I think day one flows
- 28:33matter, day seven day flows matter three months, six months
- 28:37a year it's it's it could look different.
- 28:39I don't think you're going to see 11 a year from now with
- 28:41meaningful assets under management but they'll they'll
- 28:44be a couple and I think they'll be a few big ones.
- 28:46I think we just sort of have to wait and see.
- 28:49There is more to it. These are not all created equal,
- 28:52right. I mean I know again I I talk
- 28:54about wanting it to see a multi custodial model.
- 28:58I think it's clear that the the issuers primarily decided that
- 29:01Coinbase was the fastest way to approval probably because
- 29:03they're a public company. I don't know they're also I'm
- 29:06willing to bet are good at Bitcoin custody, right.
- 29:08There's there's never been at least a publicized like theft or
- 29:12anything from Coinbase custody that I'm aware of.
- 29:15But it's not just that, right. It's it's where and how you
- 29:19execute who your authorized participants are, how many
- 29:21liquidity providers you have, right.
- 29:23There's a lot more that goes into managing these vehicles
- 29:27than simply buy Bitcoin and and you know store it somewhere.
- 29:30So I I think that obviously Invesco has advantages here.
- 29:35We're the only ones are are fun, which with which really they're
- 29:39fun. We're a partner of theirs that
- 29:42doesn't use Coinbase Prime as an execution venue, right.
- 29:45So we because Galaxy is the execution agent and of course
- 29:49we're one of the biggest Bitcoin trading firms in the world.
- 29:51So there look there's a variety. Yeah.
- 29:53You got to look at things like liquidity and bid ask bread and
- 29:56and tracking quality right. There's a but we we need some
- 30:00time. I know the horse race has just
- 30:01begun but we need a couple days and a couple weeks to really
- 30:04start to see how these things are performing and and who's
- 30:07doing a good job and who who's doing less of a good job.
- 30:10So just it it's honestly more to come.
- 30:13I know making fun of Eric and James at Bloomberg like they're
- 30:16they're they've got so many demands for like real time.
- 30:19Like, I mean people. I mean, they just need to launch
- 30:21like a cable news show and call it like a sports game at this
- 30:24point. That's what people want.
- 30:26Take a little. It's gonna take a little while,
- 30:28I think, for it to play out. Yeah.
- 30:31And another question I have is, do you think the unit bias comes
- 30:35into play in terms of the way the shares are denominated?
- 30:41Because I believe, I think Black Rock's just dividing the price
- 30:44by 2000. Yeah, it's a good question.
- 30:47It looks to me and I don't have all the, I'm looking at the the
- 30:49sort of slate here. Most of them again are trading
- 30:53at like the 40 or $50 range. So I'm going to make them just I
- 30:57don't have the all the prospectuses up in front of me,
- 30:59but but yeah, I see BlackRock is trading at 2650 right now.
- 31:03So presumably they have smaller units.
- 31:06I I don't know, but I I don't think it's going to make a huge
- 31:09difference between them like but it does matter.
- 31:13The broader point which I'm sure you guys have talked about in
- 31:15the past, the unit bias versus Bitcoin, right.
- 31:18It's that old question between like one BTC or a bit or a SAT
- 31:23like how should these, how should it be quoted right?
- 31:25Because you know at 47 K that looks like a pretty expensive
- 31:29thing to buy, right? But at, you know, $26 which is
- 31:32Black Rocks is trading at or you know BTCO is trading at $46 like
- 31:36that seems a lot more reasonable, right?
- 31:39I'll set. Up a few bitcoins for $26 a
- 31:41piece? Sure.
- 31:42Exactly. That's going to be how people
- 31:44think about it. Yeah, I think it's important.
- 31:47It's a similar reason as to why sometimes you see really
- 31:50valuable equities do a stock split for the same reason.
- 31:52It's it's also maybe the reason that like Berkshire Hathaway it
- 31:56hasn't done one right and it's such an expensive equity quote
- 31:58UN quote, just from your unit price.
- 32:02Maybe they like the sound of that, right.
- 32:04Like who knows? I I don't know, Marty, I I I
- 32:07think, you know I think maybe. I think the main things that
- 32:10people care about are liquidity, spreads fees.
- 32:13That's the main, I think most people know, but look again like
- 32:18Fidelity out of the gate here, pretty strong with a lot of
- 32:20volume probably. Again they've got a giant
- 32:21platform, right. They can advertise on one of the
- 32:24biggest brokerages platforms in the world for free because they
- 32:28own it. Yeah.
- 32:32It's been a crazy week. The SEC Twitter account getting
- 32:37hacked. Truly wild.
- 32:40Jumping on the gun by the CBOE yesterday morning and then the
- 32:44eventual capitulation. Everything's a go.
- 32:47And then Gary writing a letter saying he doesn't advise the
- 32:53people investing. Yeah, he's not a fan.
- 32:54Yeah, he's no, they're asset neutral.
- 32:56But then he proceeded to shit on Bitcoin.
- 32:58Yeah, that's strange. It's just been a strange.
- 33:01That you had. Strange.
- 33:03Then you had Hester Pierce counter signaling them on the
- 33:05SEC website as well. It's been Bitcoin drives people
- 33:09crazy. Yeah.
- 33:12I mean, they couldn't even like do.
- 33:13I mean, I guess, look, I guess it was a pretty unique situation
- 33:16with 11 issuers, a, a new asset class quote UN quote and you're
- 33:19like, OK, all right, it was different.
- 33:21I'll give them that. But like, yeah, it drives people
- 33:24crazy. It drove the process crazy and
- 33:26they had to be sued in order to even do it, which is also crazy.
- 33:31Like, they shouldn't have had to be rebuked by the DC Circuit
- 33:33Court of Appeals to the extent they were, which was
- 33:36significant, a significant rebuttal from that court that
- 33:39shouldn't have had to happen, right?
- 33:41None of this should, shouldn't have had to be this way.
- 33:44You shouldn't have had the you shouldn't have to have had the
- 33:46chair of the SEC approve, you know, voting to approve a bunch
- 33:50of products and simultaneously disparaging their underlying
- 33:55collateral like that's it's just bizarre that shouldn't have to
- 33:58be that way. But when you talk.
- 34:02About it at MIT just a few years ago.
- 34:06Exactly, exactly what what? Well, it does.
- 34:11It does beg the question, what's going on behind the scenes?
- 34:13I mean, I saw a meme this morning of Gary Gensler talking
- 34:17to Elizabeth Warren. She's like, what happened?
- 34:20Gary. He's like, I don't know, there's
- 34:21nothing I could do. We had to.
- 34:23We had the load of shit. Yeah, I want to.
- 34:26I'm not going to describe it, but there was a people, one of
- 34:28his, you know, he does a thing every day.
- 34:30He had a good one yesterday. It's worth checking out.
- 34:34And then all the naysayers, you have better markets come out
- 34:38with a letter. I mean they've been writing
- 34:40suggestion letters to the SEC, don't approve this, don't
- 34:42approve this. Now they're like, oh, you guys
- 34:44are enabling crime. Obviously we have the Alex
- 34:47Deviers of the world who've been opining against Bitcoin mining
- 34:50energy use for the better part of the last half decade.
- 34:55We've got Greenpeace, a lot of the tractors out there that are
- 35:00going to have to eat crow in the the months and years ahead.
- 35:04It just it doesn't seem, I don't.
- 35:06It is strange to me that people that have defined their public
- 35:09personas as being opposed to Bitcoin.
- 35:11There's that guy, the Steven deal, even, like, he's the
- 35:14worst. I don't know, he blocked me a
- 35:16long time ago, 'cause I I asked like, I mean, I genuinely was
- 35:19like, are you OK, dude, 'cause this is on something, he said.
- 35:22It's just again like to imagine defining your your life by being
- 35:27opposed to something especially something that like it doesn't
- 35:30care about you. Bitcoin never replies to your
- 35:32tweet. You know, like I don't know who
- 35:34you're like. It's just a strange thing.
- 35:36You know these people who are so professionally anti Bitcoin, I
- 35:41don't understand why we you know we hear some things they try to
- 35:44come up with reasons the the Bitcoin usage of electricity is
- 35:481 or or it's use in illicit finance.
- 35:50But these are these are small. Even if you believe they're
- 35:53real, they're tiny, right. Like they they have to strut
- 35:56find some real world externality that Bitcoin is causing because
- 36:00otherwise they just look crazy. Why don't let people just use
- 36:03what they want. It's it's not impacting you in
- 36:05any way. Right.
- 36:07And of course we know that we know that it's used in illicit
- 36:10finances paled in comparison by the dollars.
- 36:13We know that it's and even take the thing with Hamas, those
- 36:17first of all it was all tether on Tron primarily that was
- 36:19seized by Israel. But it was seized.
- 36:21It was tracked and found right like that's because it's not
- 36:25good for crime. It's it's the blockchain is
- 36:27forever and we won't do the whole energy usage thing.
- 36:31But Bitcoin is is supportive not not negative to the environment
- 36:37in my opinion. Yeah, great.
- 36:40And and invariably, with all those the tractors, it turns out
- 36:44that they are salty because they had an opportunity to buy it in
- 36:482011 when they reported on it then, and they didn't.
- 36:52And and now they've been forced to watch all these shitty
- 36:56Internet people get rich while they didn't.
- 36:59We used to call that the Nathaniel Popper's Syndrome.
- 37:03Like they couldn't buy. Or was there was an article the
- 37:06other day that in the the IT was a guy snarks?
- 37:09Is that his names? And somebody found tweets from
- 37:12him in 2013 having bought and sold Bitcoin?
- 37:16Yeah. Like, I get it.
- 37:18Like it's just it it you gotta guys, let's, let's just, I don't
- 37:23know focus on positivity in your life.
- 37:26Don't. Unless it's Jim Cramer.
- 37:29Unless it's Jim Cramer, like, continue to hate it.
- 37:31It's cool and just has been all over.
- 37:32He's been up he's been he's been for it.
- 37:34He's been against it and he was like he defined the flip flop on
- 37:37this asset. Jim Cramer.
- 37:38But you know I I like the the folks at CNBC particularly Joe
- 37:43Kiernan, but that's AI think that I think we all like Joe.
- 37:47Nobody is more scoring than the individual bought Bitcoin early
- 37:50and sold. Yeah, it's a bad syndrome, Alex.
- 37:53I know you've got something to do here.
- 37:55In a minute. Thank you for joining us for an
- 37:57emergency rip of the last trade, Big day.
- 38:00Thank you for doing what you do. I know it's been a very long
- 38:04couple years for you and your team at Galaxy.
- 38:08Congrats on you guys getting this across the line and it'll
- 38:11be fun to watch how this plays out over the next year.
- 38:13Yeah, I really appreciate it. Thanks for having me.
- 38:15Marty. Cretius.
- 38:16Michael, thanks so much. Love the love the show.
- 38:18Thanks for having me. Awesome.
- 38:20Thanks. Alex Also, if you guys listen to
- 38:22this, go check out Galaxy Brains, especially if you're in
- 38:24the good rap. Alex opens up your.
- 38:26Show with the good rap. Good one this morning.
- 38:27Go to listen to this one. We have JFK talking about going
- 38:30to the moon on the intro rap. It's pretty good.
- 38:32Go. To the moon in this decade.
- 38:35Yes, and do the other things. Not because they are easy, but
- 38:38because they are hard. That's a great speech.
- 38:41All right, guys. Thank you so much all.
- 38:42Right. Thanks.
- 38:44See you guys later.