Blood on the Family Tree

A Sip Of Redrum · Feb 19, 2026 · 1h 11m

CASE FILE

[S3E3] | [Blood on the Family Tree]

THE SPIRIT OF THE EPISODE

> The Pour: [Shirley Temple Black]

> The Ingredients:

2 ounces dark rum

1 ounce grenadine

4 ounces lemon-lime soda (such as Sprite or 7UP)

Maraschino cherries for garnish

>The vibe: "It’s dark, it’s sweet, and it’s a reminder of the innocence that this show seeks to protect."

THE SUBJECT

>Name: Jarrell Cuyler

>Date of Incident: July 9th, 1998

>Location: Windsor, Connecticut

>Status: Solved

THE REDRUM TRAIL

>1989: Tammie falls pregnant with first child (Jarrell Cuyler)

>1992: Tammi returns to work hiring Chasity West as…