Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 306. Trust the Process: How to Design Teams That Actually Work
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: Swift trust can help your communication and
- 0:06your teams be more effective.
- 0:08My name's Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:11Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:13Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:17Today, I look forward to speaking with Melissa Valentine.
- 0:19Melissa is an associate professor in the Management Science and Engineering
- 0:22Department at Stanford and a senior fellow at the Stanford Institute for
- 0:26Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence.
- 0:28Her research focuses on how emerging technologies, including artificial
- 0:32intelligence and algorithms, are fundamentally transforming work,
- 0:36organizational design, and team dynamics.
- 0:39Melissa, along with her co-author Michael Bernstein, wrote the fascinating
- 0:42book Flash Teams: Leading the Future of AI-Enhanced, On-Demand Work.
- 0:48Well, welcome, Melissa.
- 0:48I'm really excited to have you join us.
- 0:50Thank you.
- 0:51Melissa Valentine: This show is so fun, and I love the guests you
- 0:53have, so I'm delighted to be here.
- 0:54Matt Abrahams: Well, thank you, and thanks for being one of them.
- 0:56Shall we get started?
- 0:56Melissa Valentine: Let's do it.
- 0:57Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:58I have to say, I really enjoyed your book, Flash Teams, very much.
- 1:01Really, really interesting.
- 1:03Can you define for all of us what a flash team is and explain what people,
- 1:07processes, and infrastructure enable flash teams to get aligned and execute quickly?
- 1:12Melissa Valentine: Yeah.
- 1:12So my PhD is in organization science, basically.
- 1:15So I got my PhD at a business school, and then my collaborator is a computer
- 1:19science professor, and he was doing a lot of work on crowdsourcing.
- 1:22So what's cool about crowdsourcing is the crowd is, like, millions of people
- 1:26online, and you can get things done quickly 'cause you just put a task out,
- 1:30and then there's millions of people who are available to come work on the task.
- 1:34But what he was seeing at the time that he and I started working together
- 1:37was crowdsourcing was stuck because they were doing, like, really,
- 1:39they called them micro tasks, but just really, like, small tasks.
- 1:42And then I had this toolkit, organization science, and my dissertation had been
- 1:46about how you can use team scaffolds or lightweight team structures, and then you
- 1:52populate the team structure with experts.
- 1:54And the team structure and the role structure helps them
- 1:56know how to work together.
- 1:57So we sort of were able to combine the logic of both of these.
- 2:00So you have these, like, lightweight structures that allow people who are,
- 2:04like, relative strangers to come together and work together on really complex stuff.
- 2:08So this system that we built with a great team of a PhD student, Daniela
- 2:11Ratelny, she organized this great lab at the time we first did our flash teams.
- 2:15So we built a platform that basically took all the logic of organization
- 2:19science and team science, and then the speed and scale of crowdsourcing,
- 2:22and then put them together.
- 2:23So the way the system works, you have this platform where I'm somebody who
- 2:27wants to get something done, so I go to the platform, I design the team,
- 2:31and then the platform integrates with something like, we used Upwork.
- 2:35So there's like 10 million freelancers who are on Upwork.
- 2:37And then, so I'll say, "Here's the task that I need done. Here's the role I
- 2:41need filled." And then the platform can integrate with Upwork, and then it's
- 2:44open call to the 10 million freelancers.
- 2:46Who's got the right expertise?
- 2:47They join the team.
- 2:48So you can just convene teams really fast.
- 2:51And what we showed with this research is that you can get
- 2:53things done really quickly.
- 2:55You can pull teams together.
- 2:56They build really complex stuff.
- 2:57And it was really inspiring.
- 2:58I mean, it's even faster now with GenAI.
- 3:01Matt Abrahams: So you set a framework and expectations and then leverage a
- 3:04tool that pulls people in, and then the flash team is really the focused,
- 3:07concerted effort that it's all about.
- 3:09One of the essential elements of any teaming or groups
- 3:12coming together is trust.
- 3:13What are some of the communication skills or other skills that people
- 3:17can deploy to establish trust quickly?
- 3:19I'm assuming part of what flash teams do, besides accomplish their work,
- 3:22is they're able to coordinate action, perhaps through building trust.
- 3:26Melissa Valentine: Yeah, trust in flash teams is essential and complex, right?
- 3:30'Cause it is relative strangers.
- 3:32You get together and you work together really intensely,
- 3:35and then you disassemble.
- 3:36So I think that there's this idea in the literature called swift trust, and there's
- 3:41an assumption that you just assume trust.
- 3:44You just meet somebody for the first time, you assume they're competent, you
- 3:47assume that they know how to do their role, you assume you're both there for the
- 3:50same reason, to work hard, get it done.
- 3:51So that, yeah, the assumption of swift trust is really useful.
- 3:55It doesn't always work out, but the sort of like offering
- 3:57of swift trust is part of it.
- 3:58And then paying attention to when it's not going right and being willing and
- 4:02able to repair quickly is also important.
- 4:04Matt Abrahams: I love this idea of swift trust.
- 4:06So you approach from a place of trust, assuming that you are trustworthy,
- 4:10and I will trust you, and you will do the same, can expedite things.
- 4:13Because there's a lot of this testing that goes into trust and time, and if you start
- 4:16from that place, and obviously it might fail or people could take advantage of it.
- 4:21But the second part, what you said, I think really is the helpful part,
- 4:23is to have that meta-awareness and watching for it, and then being willing
- 4:27to speak up and try to repair it.
- 4:29So I think it's not only swift trust, being open to trust, but being
- 4:33open to repair when it's not there.
- 4:35I really like that idea of swift trust.
- 4:38So much in my life I think would be better if we just approached
- 4:41everything with this notion of like,
- 4:43Melissa Valentine: Oh, swift trust.
- 4:43Yeah.
- 4:43Yeah.
- 4:44I mean, there is a real difference 'cause I think of the person I wrote
- 4:46the book with, Michael, he and I have worked together for 15 years
- 4:49now, and that is a different kind of trust than like swift trust.
- 4:52But swift trust is a tool that's useful.
- 4:54Matt Abrahams: Right.
- 4:54It's, and it's a way to at least initiate and then you can build
- 4:57deeper, the trust and relationship.
- 4:58That can only happen, I think, after repeated exposure and time.
- 5:02You talk about discursive diversity, and I had to practice saying
- 5:06that multiple times, by the way.
- 5:08Can you share what you mean by discursive diversity, and how can
- 5:11teams recognize when they need to shift their communication style from a more
- 5:15open-ended brainstorming, ideating to a very highly coordinated approach?
- 5:20Melissa Valentine: Yeah.
- 5:20So that is from the dissertation of one of my really brilliant PhD students.
- 5:25So her name is Katharina Lix, and she invented that measure.
- 5:29So what she was able to do, she had all of the Slack transcripts of
- 5:32different flash teams, and she was able to, she did this NLP processing.
- 5:37Matt Abrahams: And NLP is natural language processing, I assume.
- 5:38Melissa Valentine: Yeah, yeah.
- 5:39Before it was cool, she learned how to do it, and she was able to
- 5:42create this measure where she was looking at the similarity of the
- 5:45language that people were using.
- 5:47So you have all of the Slack interactions, and you can basically
- 5:50compare people talking on the team and how similar are the words that they're
- 5:55using, the sentence structure, right?
- 5:57Are they using the same adverbs, like adjectives?
- 5:59Sense of urgency gets encoded in all of that.
- 6:01And what she was able to show is that the similarity of the language that people
- 6:05are using or the difference, so this is where, let's see, discursive diversity.
- 6:08Matt Abrahams: Discursive diversity.
- 6:09Yeah.
- 6:09Melissa Valentine: Yes.
- 6:10Matt Abrahams: Different types of words and language.
- 6:11Melissa Valentine: Exactly.
- 6:12Yeah.
- 6:12So that sort of would predict the team meeting a milestone in different ways.
- 6:16So there were times when you really want the language to diverge.
- 6:20So this is a moment of brainstorming, ideation, right?
- 6:23You want a lot of creativity, you want a lot of divergence.
- 6:26But then as you get closer to the deadline, you really, for the
- 6:28team to meet the deadline, then the language needs to converge.
- 6:31Like, people need to start sounding more like each other to hit the deadline.
- 6:35Matt Abrahams: So one, it's a measure really.
- 6:37So you can look at, you know, if I'm a manager or somebody looking back at doing
- 6:42a postmortem or after the project is done, and I can look at the communication, be
- 6:45it Slack, Jira, whatever the tool is, and I can actually see the, the language
- 6:50might be a hint as to where we are.
- 6:52And as you're trying to get closer to the decision, more similar language is a sign.
- 6:57What I'd be curious, and I don't know if there's any research on this, is can you
- 7:00actually use language to influence that?
- 7:03So can I, as a manager, encourage more diverse language through
- 7:08ideation, but want us to start moving towards a decision, encourage people
- 7:11to start using similar language?
- 7:13I wonder if you, if it's causal in that way.
- 7:15Melissa Valentine: I think that's a great research question.
- 7:17Matt Abrahams: Yeah.
- 7:17I think that's really interesting.
- 7:18So I encourage everybody listening to think about the language you're using
- 7:21for the different tasks you have and start to notice what that looks like.
- 7:24And maybe you can run your own experiment and play with that.
- 7:27I want to keep on flash teams, and then I want to make a, have a broader question.
- 7:30But when flash teams hit a snag, for example, like a miscommunication, what
- 7:35is the most effective way to fix that so they don't fraction and deal with
- 7:39too much friction in those situations?
- 7:41Melissa Valentine: So I'm so glad you asked this question.
- 7:43I have an unpublished paper.
- 7:46So we ran three really complex flash teams one summer, and we had all of the DMs.
- 7:52So we had all the Slack front stage and then all of the Slack DMs, the backstage.
- 7:57And the thing that was really interesting in analyzing all of that data is a
- 8:00lot of repairs happened backstage.
- 8:02So something would happen in the public Slack channel, and then a dyad
- 8:05would go to the back channel, and they'd be like, "What is this bug?"
- 8:07And they would sort it out and then come front stage with the solution.
- 8:11So it created a lot of smooth operations.
- 8:14Like the flash teams, they all accomplished their goal.
- 8:17There didn't seem to be a ton of conflict.
- 8:19So this pattern of backstage repair was really interesting to discover.
- 8:23I think any human behavior, it's got different sides to it.
- 8:27So I think it did support smooth operation.
- 8:30But what I saw in the analysis that I have not yet published is that the people
- 8:34who are more involved in backstage repair ended up with more influence over time.
- 8:38So these are the workers and the managers who were, like, really
- 8:41helping make the decisions.
- 8:43So it's something about access to where the real problems get solved was, like,
- 8:46creating a lot of influence for people.
- 8:48Now, I don't totally know what to do with that.
- 8:50As someone who is interested in flash teams going well, I would maybe say you
- 8:53need like a postmortem on a flash team.
- 8:56What were the problems?
- 8:57Who helped solve them?
- 8:58What do we learn about this together?
- 9:00Matt Abrahams: It's really intriguing that the people involved in that
- 9:03repair or that dealing with those problems end up being more influential.
- 9:07Melissa Valentine: Yeah.
- 9:08'Cause it's like they had the realer story of what was going on.
- 9:11And sometimes it was in the backstage repair that decisions were made
- 9:14and then presented as if they were quite done, if that makes sense.
- 9:18Matt Abrahams: That's really intriguing.
- 9:19I'm putting on my manager hat and thinking if I were in the midst of any team, be
- 9:23it a flash team or a regular team, how I could be aware that the folks who are
- 9:28involved in helping fix, repair, dive deep into problems, what that means
- 9:32for them in terms of their currency and how we interact on the public stage.
- 9:36And I just think it's interesting that we now have these two channels and ways
- 9:39of communicating that can be measured.
- 9:41I know you think about storytelling and change.
- 9:45How can everyday employees in an organization use storytelling to drive
- 9:50broader systemic change and build coalitions to help achieve whatever
- 9:54it is they're trying to achieve?
- 9:55Melissa Valentine: Yeah.
- 9:55So one of the studies that I did when I first got to Stanford was
- 10:00actually of an academic cancer center.
- 10:02I saw stories be really influential in this study.
- 10:06So it feels a little different than what we've been talking about with AI and
- 10:09algorithms and so forth, but it still to me is a study of organizational design,
- 10:13which is what I'm really interested in.
- 10:15What happened in this study, so I was studying as this cancer center
- 10:18was trying to do a transformation.
- 10:20They were trying to decrease the coordination burden on
- 10:22patients and their families.
- 10:25And during the study, there was a group of patient advocates or activists who really
- 10:29wanted the cancer center to understand how much coordination they were having to do.
- 10:33So the way that they made their case, this is why I'm thinking of it, is they had an
- 10:37initiative they called Patient Stories.
- 10:39And so they went to great effort to collect a lot of patient stories where
- 10:42patients just talked about, like a family member had to quit their job to become
- 10:46the full-time coordinator for the patient.
- 10:48So they came up with dozens of patient stories.
- 10:51And then in this paper that I have, I analyze how they basically use
- 10:54the stories to make the case and to spread the movement, spread the
- 10:58message across the cancer center.
- 11:00And at the end of the study, they had convinced the cancer center to take
- 11:03on some of the coordination work.
- 11:05So it ends up being this end-to-end story of patient stories, patient
- 11:09narratives actually changing the organizational design, which
- 11:12is why I'm thinking about it.
- 11:14It was like a very powerful thing that these patient activists did.
- 11:17Matt Abrahams: Stories can really resonate and motivate people.
- 11:19Was there anything specific to the stories that you think were really important?
- 11:23Was it the fact that the stories accounted for all the specific coordination events,
- 11:27or was it the emotionality, or was it the fact that these people just collected a
- 11:32bunch of stories and the cancer center's like, "Wow, there are all these stories.
- 11:35We should probably do something"?
- 11:36Melissa Valentine: I think a lot of us interface with the healthcare system,
- 11:39and we could just see ourselves.
- 11:40So the patient stories were just like, "This is us. This is you
- 11:43and me." And then it illustrated the problem really specifically.
- 11:46So somebody's sitting in a wheelchair in a hallway 'cause they had been
- 11:49dropped or something like that.
- 11:50And so it's like, wait, like, I think the cancer center is so full of people
- 11:54who care, and then hearing like the specific instance in a really relatable
- 11:58story, they were just like, "Oh, that's a problem that I can help with."
- 12:01Matt Abrahams: I think you hit on it.
- 12:02It's relatable and real, and we can connect.
- 12:04Thank you.
- 12:05Can you take what you've learned about flash teams and give us any insight
- 12:10that we can just apply to a normal team?
- 12:12So I've got a team that's been around for a while, and we meet regularly.
- 12:15Is there any insight from your work on flash teams that could perhaps
- 12:18help my team be more efficient, feel more connected, ideate better?
- 12:22Melissa Valentine: One thing that Michael and I used to say when we were writing the
- 12:24book, we were trying to think of what's the mindset here that any manager would
- 12:28find empowering, and the phrase we came up with is experts everywhere all the time.
- 12:33So you've got your trusted team.
- 12:35Great.
- 12:36Keep working together, taking good care of each other, working hard,
- 12:38but really recognize that your organization, the world, the internet,
- 12:44the world is just full of experts who can help, and people like helping and
- 12:48bringing their expertise to something.
- 12:50So it's just having a mindset of recognizing how much collaboration
- 12:53is available, how much expertise is available, and maybe it,
- 12:56like, invites you to think of the boundaries of the team a little more.
- 12:59Matt Abrahams: That's funny you said that 'cause that was exactly the word I
- 13:01was thinking is porous, is that it can be very easy to insulate a team and say,
- 13:05"This is the team," but being a little more open and pulling in expertise.
- 13:09When I was managing a team, I ran a learning and development
- 13:12group, and we had this very tricky thing we had to train people on.
- 13:16And it turned out that somebody in the company who was an admin was using our
- 13:20tool, and they actually knew how to do things that we were trying to figure
- 13:24out how to train people on better.
- 13:26That person was an expert, and by just dumb luck, we figured that out
- 13:30and incorporated them into the team.
- 13:31And I like that idea.
- 13:33Melissa Valentine: I think that there are a lot of tools that can
- 13:35be very helpful to managers in terms of how the team works together,
- 13:39coordinates, and stuff like that.
- 13:40The other thing we said in the book is AI-driven team design, so just making
- 13:44use of the tools to be very thoughtful in how you're structuring your team.
- 13:47Matt Abrahams: So AI can help us structure the team and maybe even
- 13:50identify who some of the experts are that, that we might know.
- 13:53I love that.
- 13:54Melissa, this has been great.
- 13:55Before we end, you know I like to ask three questions one I make up just for
- 13:58you and two I've been asking everybody.
- 14:00Are you up for that?
- 14:00Melissa Valentine: Yeah, let's do it.
- 14:01Matt Abrahams: Beyond the academic research you do, you're also a creator,
- 14:05and you study the algorithms that serve up information on social media.
- 14:09What advice do you have for others who are creators?
- 14:12Melissa Valentine: Okay, so I love Instagram and TikTok.
- 14:16I don't, like, I have, I think it's people have complicated
- 14:19relationships with social media.
- 14:20So the attention stuff is real.
- 14:21My attention span is shot, but I have learned so much from content creators.
- 14:27I am such a fan.
- 14:28My advice is keep going.
- 14:30If you're an expert, put it out in the world, like, people will find it.
- 14:33Different life transitions I've gone through, different, like, health
- 14:35stuff, different fitness stuff, different hobbies, like, I have
- 14:37learned so much from the internet.
- 14:39So thank you, content creators.
- 14:41Matt Abrahams: You know, as a creator myself, and it took me a while to
- 14:43identify as a creator, but I think many of us are motivated to help
- 14:48people, and it's that motivation that actually helps us get through.
- 14:52It's hard to put out the content, and the algorithm can sometimes
- 14:56help you and sometimes not.
- 14:57So it's that passion, desire to learn and to help, I think, that really motivate.
- 15:01And I can hear that in your voice, and I see it in the
- 15:03things that you post and create.
- 15:04Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 15:08Melissa Valentine: So I'm at a moment where I'm thinking a lot about
- 15:11communication, where we really take each other in in a really deep way.
- 15:16So I have a friend who is a therapist and a Buddhist.
- 15:20She has a quality of listening and expression that it, that allows
- 15:23for, like, true communication.
- 15:25So I would say I'm gonna, I'm gonna nominate her.
- 15:27It's, like, a fascinating thing about being very aware of yourself that
- 15:30allows you to be very aware of others and just, yeah, like, it is a lot of
- 15:33presence, as you're saying, like, a lot of kind of presence and connection.
- 15:37Matt Abrahams: Yeah, I like that, self-awareness and other awareness.
- 15:39Thank you.
- 15:40And final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into
- 15:43a successful communication recipe?
- 15:46Melissa Valentine: Something that I've come to appreciate is how useful, like, a
- 15:49deep awareness of your own experience is, 'cause then you're even more able to take
- 15:53in another's in all of its complexity.
- 15:56So yeah, self-awareness, other awareness, and then working from there, I think
- 16:01what's possible between you is, like, new.
- 16:03It's like something that neither of you would have done
- 16:04without that kind of connection.
- 16:07Matt Abrahams: I sort of bristle at the word synergy, but in this case
- 16:09that's exactly what you're talking about, is it's the power of the two
- 16:13is greater than either individually.
- 16:14But that comes, as you said, from a self-awareness and then other awareness.
- 16:19Thank you for the three ingredients, and thank you for the conversation.
- 16:22Your work to me is really intriguing because it focuses both on technology,
- 16:26but the human aspect of people coming together, and the fact that there are
- 16:30structures that we can rely on to help expedite and make things more efficient.
- 16:34Melissa, this has been fantastic.
- 16:35Thank you, and thank you for the work you do.
- 16:37Melissa Valentine: Totally.
- 16:37Really fun for me too.
- 16:38Thank you.
- 16:41Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 16:43Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 16:45To learn more about groups, listen in to our episode 241 with Colin Fisher.
- 16:49And to learn more about social media algorithms, please check out
- 16:52episode 268 with Angèle Christin.
- 16:55This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 17:00Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 17:04Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 17:08Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 17:10Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 17:14And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 17:18learning content, and our newsletter.
- 17:20Please join us for our Think Fast, Talk Smart Learning Community
- 17:23at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 17:26You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards, an AI
- 17:30coach, and book club opportunities.
- 17:32Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of our Think Fast,
- 17:37Talk Smart Learning Community